Why Julian Nagelsmann is the perfect Real Madrid manager

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 тра 2023
  • Try The Athletic for FREE for 30 days: www.theathletic.com/tifoirl
    📗 Tifo's new book, "How to Watch Football" is now available internationally: linktr.ee/tifobook
    Julien Nagelsmann is one of the brightest managers on the market at the moment.
    The 35-year-old was unceremoniously sacked by Bayern Munich after an inconsistent season, replacing him with Thomas Tuchel to little effect.
    But Nagelsmann has been on Real Madrid’s radar for some time, and while Carlo Ancelotti’s contract runs until 2024, his future is uncertain. What would the young German manager add to Los Blancos as head coach? Jon Mackenzie is here to explain.
    Follow Tifo Football:
    Twitter: / tifofootball_
    Facebook: / tifofootball
    Instagram: / tifofootball_
    Listen to the Tifo Football podcast:
    Apple Podcasts: bit.ly/TifoFootPod
    Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/06QIGhq...
    About Tifo Football:
    Tifo loves football. We create In-depth tactical, historical and geopolitical breakdowns of the beautiful game.
    We know there’s an appetite for thoughtful, intelligent content. For stuff that makes the complicated simple.
    We provide analysis on the Premier League, Champions League, La Liga, Serie A, Bundesliga, World Cup and more.
    Our podcasts interview some of the game’s leading figures. And our editorial covers football with depth and insight.
    Founded in 2017 and became a part of The Athletic in 2020. For business inquiries, reach out to tifo@theathletic.com.
    Music sourced from epidemicsound.com
    Additional footage sourced from freestockfootagearchive.com
    #realmadrid #nagelsmann #bayern
  • Спорт

КОМЕНТАРІ • 253

  • @cheshdaglish
    @cheshdaglish Рік тому +379

    it's terrible to presume Modric & Zidane had that little balance

    • @TheAthleticFC
      @TheAthleticFC  Рік тому +222

      I'd say it takes incredible balance to be in that position for the whole video.

    • @nikhilnain3133
      @nikhilnain3133 Рік тому +6

      😂😂😂

    • @jcm9890
      @jcm9890 Рік тому +3

      this messed me up... OCD

  • @Ayush-pu8ym
    @Ayush-pu8ym Рік тому +40

    Modric and Zidane hanging for dear life back on the wall 😅😂

  • @joshuahill5920
    @joshuahill5920 Рік тому +53

    Can you guys please do a video on Arne Slot? I need a slightly awkward man standing in front of a horizontal television to tell me if I should be excited or not about him likely coming to Spurs. Thanks :)

  • @StriderDSC
    @StriderDSC Рік тому +71

    Nagelsmann's RB Leipzig team were a treat to watch. One thing to add, he would also use players in different roles during different phases of play to consistently adapt to what other teams were doing defensively. Key example, sometimes Konrad Laimer would be a 6, sometimes an 8, other times he'd end up at RB depending on where he was needed to break the press or progress the ball. Halstenberg and Klostermann, same thing. Sometimes they'd line up as FB's, other times they be tucking in narrow as LCB/RCB with Upamecano in the middle. The main caveat of all this is he requires players to be adaptable to this method of thinking, something some Bayern players were reluctant to do (mainly because they'd never done it before). If you give him all that youth at Real, especially with the technique they have, plus veterans who are used to a flexible structure and would probably play better the closer they are together since they aren't the fastest, they'd be a juggernaut.

    • @commentarytalk1446
      @commentarytalk1446 Рік тому +5

      Bit surprised this vid focused on him at Bayern and not Leipzig. Personally I hope he does go to Madrid.

    • @neildylanyoung
      @neildylanyoung 4 місяці тому

      Great analysis, thank you

  • @victorvelasquez1482
    @victorvelasquez1482 Рік тому +203

    I'd love to see Nagelsmann at Madrid but the truth is that they're never going to be a system first team like others in Europe, they're always going to be a players first team because of the culture, the last two times they had system managers was Lopetegui and Mourinho who had lots of years between them. Maybe it's been enough time and Madrid are ready to try a system first philosophy again but if they're going to do that then they need to move on the old guard and they're not going to do that this summer. In an ideal world Ancelotti moves on to manage Brasil and Nagelsmann arrives in Madrid but that's just not going to happen right now.

    • @mickeyjunior7177
      @mickeyjunior7177 Рік тому +11

      zidane is very much a system manager as much as man management

    • @d4n4nable
      @d4n4nable Рік тому +13

      Nagelsmann is not a "system" manager at all.

    • @karnpandharipande
      @karnpandharipande Рік тому +4

      Things will defo change, tactical football is the current norm and RM will soon realise that they will have to adapt

    • @ermikolski7415
      @ermikolski7415 Рік тому +8

      The summer 2024 is internally announced as the summer of change because this will be the end of Modric, Kroos, Benzema and Ancelottis contracts and the “big reset“ would fit perfectly. But this decision could lead to a 2019 type of season where Real felt harmless.
      However if this is what it takes to get a new style of playing and especially a new style of attacking I would accept it because Real needs some more than “give the ball to Vini“ to compete at the highest level as seen against City imo.

    • @Agent.K.
      @Agent.K. Рік тому +3

      @@mickeyjunior7177
      Zidane was never praised for his tactics like Pep, Klopp, Tuchel etc… but he’s great at man-management.

  • @psycheshit
    @psycheshit Рік тому +20

    Positioning of the frames in the background is so well thought of it aligns well with the statements ...cheers 🥂

  • @kakuite
    @kakuite Рік тому +35

    Real Madrid has pretty much've never been about being a Systemic Team. Even when we had José we relied heavily on "parking the bus" so to say but that season we scored 110 goals in league alone. So clearly the counter attacking system heavily relied on Higuain, Benzema & Ronaldo's goal tally with Ozil's killer eyes behind them.
    As Madridista myself, I'm more than happy to see what Carlo has acheived in last 2 season. We had no tangible enforcement (except Camavinga & Tchouameni) where it's needed the most i.e. Attackers & Fullbacks. If given the proper squad Carlo is a proven winner. I personally feel Tuchel would've been better suit than Nagelsmann tbh. But for the Managerial change that'll happen in 2024 summer at Real Madrid doughout, Xabi Alonso or Arbeloa could be in the leading position along with Zidane ofc.

    • @alimagdi343
      @alimagdi343 Рік тому +3

      Ancelotti has no answers for in possession or out of possession no definite style, no proper build up play no pressing structure. All of these stuff a coach of an elite club cannot be lacking. Ancelotti has relied heavily on players but u absolutely need a proper sytem which the players can rely on. Ancelotti cannot continue as real madrid manager anymore

    • @samuels.s.s.830
      @samuels.s.s.830 Рік тому +10

      @@alimagdi343 that’s why he has won all the possible titles in his first 3 seasons coaching real, including two champions league and two presences in the semifinals. Guardiola, for example needed it 7 seasons and x1000 millions in signings to reach two champions league finals and two semi-finals.
      Also he has a better winning rate in the matches that he has coached for real than coaching GOAts like Wenger, klopp, Luis Enrique, Tuchel, and many more, plus he is the only manager that has won the league title at Italy, England, France, Germany and Spain.
      And do not forget mourinho that in the same number of seasons at real won half the titles than Carlo.
      But of course ancelotti doesn’t now nothing about football and all this “clever-sytem” managers are better but decided to let win Carlo for some reason

    • @kakuite
      @kakuite Рік тому +6

      @@alimagdi343 thats the entire point of not having a systemic team. And also, you're not giving the credit Carlo deserves as an tactician. Real Madrid knows when to let your opponent have the ball, when to sting them and when to turn the screw in the game. Yes we've lost game and by heavy margin but you can't win all day, everyday. Do you seriously think Ancelotti won La Liga, UCL, Supercup, Supercopa, Club World Cup & Copa Del Rey in last 2 season with power of friendship? 😆

  • @shoot2000
    @shoot2000 Рік тому +177

    Unfortunately he's not an yes man! Perez would never even consider him! 💔 But as a Madridista I badly wanted this man as our manager!

    • @ishuuuuuu7304
      @ishuuuuuu7304 Рік тому +24

      ???!??
      Zidane was not a yes man nor was Mourinho nor was capello.
      💀💀💀💀

    • @akwilson1676
      @akwilson1676 Рік тому +4

      @@ishuuuuuu7304 Zidane was not a yes man?

    • @ishuuuuuu7304
      @ishuuuuuu7304 Рік тому +9

      @@akwilson1676
      Yes, he wanted Ronaldo to stay, perez didn't listened to him he left, wanted some signings perez refused left again with doing some fight

    • @danicule8671
      @danicule8671 Рік тому

      And maybe you start playing good football

    • @Jay-in6dl
      @Jay-in6dl Рік тому

      Doubt you’re a “Madridista” tbh. You’re probably a yank who started following them a few years ago.

  • @raul-yd3ob
    @raul-yd3ob Рік тому +32

    The Nagelsmann lost the dressing room stuff is bs, after his sacking key players came out and said that they didnt feel that way and that he will be missed,

    • @fishyfish6510
      @fishyfish6510 Рік тому +2

      He didn't lose the dressing room. He lost is girlfriend😂

    • @escape2nirvana
      @escape2nirvana Рік тому +4

      That’s actually false, lot of people got along the board at Bayern weren’t keen on nagelsmann’s image tbh

    • @divingdown6173
      @divingdown6173 Рік тому

      He did lose the dressing room though? Only kimmich was the only one who liked, many players spoke out saying they didn’t like the way he made them play, they didn’t like his tactics etc. it was all over the media, he lost neuer the team captain as well after sacking the previous goalie coach as well. Name me which “key players” spoke out to help him that are permanent members of the squad 😂 not someone like cancelo

    • @escape2nirvana
      @escape2nirvana Рік тому

      @@divingdown6173 musiala and goretzka were both fans.

  • @JesseShortss
    @JesseShortss Рік тому +72

    I honestly feel that Xabi or Raul will be a more suitable fit but Julian is clear tactically.

    • @fugaziishime
      @fugaziishime Рік тому +7

      Xabi alonsos team onoy pass the eye test. No substance to his play still maybe in a season or two, but not now. I think you dont really see much of leverkusen.

    • @karnpandharipande
      @karnpandharipande Рік тому +24

      Xabi has a long way to go. If he goes to RM, I wouldn't be surprised if things turn out like Stevie G at Villa.

    • @samelmudir
      @samelmudir Рік тому +3

      Ruud possibly? just left PSV

    • @decode3667
      @decode3667 Рік тому

      Raul? Lol, he's bad.

    • @fugaziishime
      @fugaziishime Рік тому

      @@philippzorn539 you are very casually not mentioning the fact that the same team finished 3rd last season. Xabi only came in october of 2022. You are trying to portay like he was given a bad team. Xabis team actually did worse than gerrardo seoane. They do look good and eventually there maybe a good manager there, but nothing sp3cial. Overrated by simpleminded people. A good coach right now.

  • @nicinat0r
    @nicinat0r Рік тому +6

    Nagelsmann and Madrid vs Tuchel and Bayern in the Champions League would be a banger

  • @somerandomedgyguy1723
    @somerandomedgyguy1723 Рік тому +9

    Still can't get over the fact that Bayern sacked him when they were top of the league, still in the Champions League and DFB-Pokal. Tuchel would have been a better Real fit imo, he got that dominant winning mentality and vibe Real also want to emanate. Now Tuchel got somewhat wasted on that badly put-together Bayern squad.

  • @joshuaantonelli2138
    @joshuaantonelli2138 Рік тому +7

    I really enjoyed this video but I think it's to radical change from Carlo to Julian. Carlo Ancelotti is the ultimate man manger and pragmatic coach. Julian Nagelsman is philosophy and process manager. Who didnt really get a grip on the bayern munich dressing room. For me makes more sense for someone like Pochettino to take real Madrid job who isnt as tactically as strong as Julian but more a man manger like Carlo. Like a happy middle ground between them. Also good at working with young players and could start the rebuild. Funny enough Julian probably a better fit for Chelsea after Tuchel and some of the new signings like Nkunku.

  • @leonardo_da_g9168
    @leonardo_da_g9168 Рік тому +5

    I’d love to see that Nagelsmann 316 system, he did extremely well at Bayern with it , his problem was the fact that Bayern was vulnerable to transitions counter attacks but that won’t be a problem at Madrid With the likes of Fede , Tchouameni , Camavinga and Bellingham who can run for days

  • @ProducoesBatata
    @ProducoesBatata Рік тому +7

    I really like when you're in these videos, football Michael Vsauce

  • @RIP_Milhouse
    @RIP_Milhouse Рік тому +6

    Can only focus on those pictureframes.

  • @gluestix17
    @gluestix17 Рік тому +2

    Jon i love how your videos chronologically flow 🥰🥰

  • @farhantalukder
    @farhantalukder Рік тому +10

    jon, would love to know ur feelings about vanvleet contract and impending siakam contract

  • @shahnewaz9700kf
    @shahnewaz9700kf Рік тому +1

    *real Madrid manager interview*
    HR: your cv?
    Julian: here's this video-

  • @GrahamPlays
    @GrahamPlays Рік тому +1

    Great insight and flow Jon!

  • @robovac3557
    @robovac3557 Рік тому +8

    You man here is really good at these videos. Him and the Scottish fella.

    • @robovac3557
      @robovac3557 Рік тому +1

      Please remove the love heart. I'm not single and my boyfriend monitors my internet activity.

    • @alitrust6058
      @alitrust6058 Рік тому +1

      ​@@robovac3557hhhhhhhh you joking right ??

    • @robovac3557
      @robovac3557 Рік тому

      @@alitrust6058 It's all good. He handles the money and helps keep me in check and I handle the cooking. It's called teamwork. Typical relationship stuff.

  • @damiennaidoo7401
    @damiennaidoo7401 Рік тому +4

    JDP/Rehearsed patterns of play (Pep/Conte/Arteta) vs Freedom of expression (Mourinho/Carlo/Zidane) is an interesting battle. Do you think Madrid need to move away from the latter approach - they have been amazing in the Champions League in the past decade.

  • @ShivamTiwari-on2kl
    @ShivamTiwari-on2kl Рік тому +3

    We need more of Spanish league coverage on Tifo

  • @Dominic_bane
    @Dominic_bane Рік тому +2

    Lovely video as always.

  • @arsenalogist4285
    @arsenalogist4285 Рік тому +13

    The problem with Madrid versus City was more personnel and lack of defensive game plan

    • @shottskies
      @shottskies Рік тому +2

      I'd say it was at least 90% lack of a defensive game plan. That and showing no desire whatsoever in the second leg.

    • @arsenalogist4285
      @arsenalogist4285 Рік тому +1

      @shottskies But if they had more athletic pressing players maybe the game plan would have sufficed.

    • @shottskies
      @shottskies Рік тому +4

      @@arsenalogist4285 you don't need to press to win football games. Pressing is an option not a requirement. Madrid pressed at times from memory and it's true they're not great at it but primarily against city they would rather sit deep in defense to absorb pressure. It's in these moments where they were very poor in the second leg especially.

    • @arsenalogist4285
      @arsenalogist4285 Рік тому +1

      @shottskies You always need to press and close down at some stage in defensive phases of play. Whether that's in a low, mid or high block; pressure is a fundamental principle.
      I just think the personnel were too old this time, I.e. Benzema, Modric and Kroos. Hell did you see how much space Rodri and Stones had in midfield?

    • @garyanderton
      @garyanderton Рік тому +1

      @@arsenalogist4285 Thank you. Finally someone that doesn't just spew out the "Ancelotti is outdated" crap. Ancelotti played Kroos as a CDM, when that gap should have been filled by Tchouameni. As he said when he lost to Barca 4-0, it was his mistake, sometimes coaches fail. Nobody called Pep outdated 10 years ago when Ancelotti beat him 4-0 while coaching Bayern.

  • @muhammadradhivan8436
    @muhammadradhivan8436 Рік тому +5

    Its Don Carlo's fault RM cant defend in Mid and cant break City's defense? No. Get him fresh legs in Mid and front, he will do so much better than Julian

  • @bastosluis244
    @bastosluis244 Рік тому +4

    I find it funny that, for you, the teams success is only based on the coach and not the players
    Because, in reality, what Guardiola has, and always had, is a good sense of what kind of player his team should look for
    This is not just about the formation and whatnot, this is about the type and quality of the players you have with you!
    Yes, he is a good manager, but the reason why he's a good manager is because he's good at understanding how a team should be formed, instead of just buying any player that is in form!
    He's better than most because he understands the idea of chemistry, not just because of his tactics
    Because if you were to ask other teams to do the same he does in City they wouldn't be able to do it properly.

    • @user-jy6ij9oq5f
      @user-jy6ij9oq5f 3 місяці тому

      Yes true the thing madrids pholosiphy is too buy any player that looks good but their downfall is they rely on individual more than the team

  • @chris.48
    @chris.48 Рік тому +25

    I think if anything they’ll go for Xabi Alonso. But I really think it’s time to let Carlo go fr

    • @takudzwabrendon9895
      @takudzwabrendon9895 Рік тому +17

      The issue is not carlo, the issue is we don't give coaches time to experiment , if you don't win a title , or uefa, bye bye that's the problem
      Zizu and carlo have good ideology but don't get time to perfect and update or renovate them becoz they are coaching with threats from the president and too much expecting, yes madrid is a big team but its time we start giving coarches time

    • @chris.48
      @chris.48 Рік тому +9

      ⁠@@takudzwabrendon9895 you’re right I really think Perez should’ve backed Zidane but tbh I don’t like how Carlo wants his football played and I think it’s time for Madrid to get a coach that’ll like to control games and I think it’ll be perfect for the players we’ve got

    • @d4n4nable
      @d4n4nable Рік тому +3

      They saved up the Mbappe millions for years now. Vini was a great transfer. A few others were decent. But overall, they saved up over the last years. And still won a ton of shit and got into the CL semis this year.

    • @AeonQuasar
      @AeonQuasar Рік тому +1

      @@d4n4nable Luckily they met two very off form teams to reach it. Both Liverpool and Chelsea where not the team they usually are this season. So lucky draws made it to the CL. The huge difference in quality against City showed how far behind they really are.

    • @langletprolet8378
      @langletprolet8378 Рік тому +2

      @@AeonQuasar Lucky draw would've been if they got the path with the italian teams.

  • @yorkshirepud9004
    @yorkshirepud9004 Рік тому +8

    My favourite video on this channel so far. This guy has brilliant tactical understanding! Great content!

  • @TheNouriani
    @TheNouriani Рік тому +6

    God I wish we could have seen Nagelsmann and Bayern face City this season instead of Tuchel… Such a shame what Oliver Kahn and Brazzo have done to Bayern… Hope we can rebound next season

    • @chris2k940
      @chris2k940 8 місяців тому

      I really think julian would’ve pulled it off

  • @georgemeyers9087
    @georgemeyers9087 Рік тому +2

    Florentino Pérez learned a lot from the first term he served as President. He knows he made a terrible mistake when he fired Del Bosque when he started building his galáctico team. That is why he has implemented a policy that is as certain as death and taxes. There are three big trophies each season: league, cup, champions. If you win at least one of the three, you keep your job; if you don't win at least one, you're fired. He does not look at the board unless he is looking to replace the coach. Call that policy what you will, but it gives managers security in their success.
    I still think Anccelotti isn't the best tactician (though he has improved since he works with his son), but he is a great talent manager and a good people person. And you what? Sometimes that is more than enough. He has won league, cup, champions, superleague, supercup, and club world cup in two years. I'd say he has earned to continue as Madrid's manager.

    • @daniaaal
      @daniaaal Рік тому +1

      I agree. Ancelotti provides stability and authority in Madrid's dressing room. Sure, his tactics may soon be considered out of date, but he still can bring out the best in his current squad. The fact Modric can still play well (at times) is a testament to Ancelotti's managerial ability. I think he deserves at least one more season before someone like Raul, Xabi or Nagelsmann would takeover.

  • @jacksonhunt8090
    @jacksonhunt8090 Рік тому +4

    What is the difference between current Real Madrid playing style and Nagelsmann more ‘localised’ style? Both seem to be doing the same thing (overload certain areas) to generate space to exploit. In which case, how would Nagelsmann be different to Ancelotti?

  • @Usernamenotavailable1
    @Usernamenotavailable1 Рік тому +5

    As a Madrid fan,it's frustrating to sse the players clueless in the field.All they got is one plan and if one player is out of sync them whole plan fails.It's the same reason why Madrid gets hammered 4 nil,5-0 by barca.They got tactical structure and backup plans with role for each player.In Madrid if our plan doesn't work,team looks like 3rd division team.Carlo should leave and Nagelsmann seems to be the perfect man.With modric,benzema and kroos getting old,new batch of players coming in it's perfect time for us.Klopp and Nagelsmann are two coach i think that suits Madrid.

    • @Nathan-opioid
      @Nathan-opioid 11 місяців тому

      not Flopp please, we dont need the moaner

  • @alexsch5583
    @alexsch5583 Рік тому +13

    I'm never gonna call for Carlo to be let go but if he'd call it a day and heads for Brazil, I'm here for it!

  • @oronsayepaul6709
    @oronsayepaul6709 Рік тому +3

    Nagelsmann's tatics will overpower Xavis bacerlona and Peps City if Real made the right choice of coach by appionting him

  • @matthewmcneany
    @matthewmcneany Рік тому +10

    As I understand it what John's saying here is that Nagelsmann represents a Hegelian synthesis between the (thesis) control based play of Guardiola and the (anti-thesis) counterattacking style of Ancelotti.

    • @FarCry2311
      @FarCry2311 11 місяців тому

      He leard form both, and combine it with german football, like Klopp

  • @toluemoruwa6151
    @toluemoruwa6151 Рік тому +3

    How has no one mentioned the tilted jerseys in the back???

  • @juang8360
    @juang8360 Рік тому +3

    Bayern made a huge mistake letting him go :(

  • @BKKLB
    @BKKLB Рік тому +2

    After the turbulent season he had and only signing on for another two years. I half expected Jurgen Klopp to look at Real Madrid. I would expect that if Klopp doesn't retire at the end of 25/26 season he must either go to Bayern or Madrid.
    Not sure if Nagelsman does. I actually think Pochettino was the strongest fit for Real Madrid but Chelsea have taken him off the board.

  • @jamespye2936
    @jamespye2936 Рік тому +2

    thankfully, as a barca fan real madrid are more likely to keep ancelotti, and by then i hope nagelsmann will be gone. the thing that worries me the most about JG teams are the way they press, and how fit they are.

  • @iamwhatiam5091
    @iamwhatiam5091 Рік тому +4

    De Zerbi should also be considered for the position but Nagelsmann has more experience of managing a top club's team.

    • @CheeseyMilkshakes
      @CheeseyMilkshakes Рік тому +2

      De Zerbi is very overrated atm, blokes been doing a good job for a year, that’s it. Look at his managerial record before Brighton, it’s not good at all.

    • @bananarecipe
      @bananarecipe Рік тому +1

      ​​@@CheeseyMilkshakes what counts as Mangerial record win rates? Trophies? if we are counting overall performance he did well at Sassuolo
      Got them 2 8th placed finish That's like getting a midtable team like Palace 8th place also he got them playing good football
      You can argue he's time in Ukraine wasn't impressive won the league with Shakhtar but they win it every year
      I would say it's harsh to say he's overrated i think he's in same category as Bielsa where he hasn't won anything and people disregard him

    • @CheeseyMilkshakes
      @CheeseyMilkshakes Рік тому +2

      @@bananarecipe He’s overrated in that people are saying he’s gonna be next Real manager etc. dudes managed a mid table prem club for one season

    • @deeznoots6241
      @deeznoots6241 Рік тому +1

      @@CheeseyMilkshakesfacts, people forget that Sean Dyche and Big Sam have gotten mediocre premier league teams to Europe for a season, its a question of whether De Zerbi can keep it up consistently or if it was just one good season.

    • @iamwhatiam5091
      @iamwhatiam5091 Рік тому

      @@CheeseyMilkshakes Hmmm. Yeah, Brighton was also doing well under Potter but the team has improved even more under De Zerbi.

  • @angelojoaquim6847
    @angelojoaquim6847 Рік тому +4

    He could coach Real Madrid, but we’ll need to speak Spanish, that in my opinion is the big factor before all others things tbh

  • @sidvyas8549
    @sidvyas8549 Рік тому +1

    Just saying but that’s an INSANE 5-a-side back there.
    Messi, Xavi, Maldini, Modric, and Zidane.
    Sheesh!

  • @prime_arakida
    @prime_arakida Рік тому +2

    What's going on with the posters in the background?

  • @algfourty9185
    @algfourty9185 Рік тому +5

    I like the idea of going after Nagelsmann, i worry about his much publicised ego however. All the success Real have had jn recent times has come under Don Carlo and Zizou, far more selfless and affable managers; we absolutely don't need another Mourinho-style rebirth cycle, b7lut if he can keep that ego in check Nagelsmann might be a good shout

  • @didnaeknowyehaditinye2813
    @didnaeknowyehaditinye2813 Рік тому +6

    Difference is peps style requires unreal technical quality in every position apart from haaland who is the best striker in the world anyway. Ancelotti can create a style to win with a team that’s “flawed” hence winning champions leagues with aged squads or unbalanced squads. Peps style is obviously brilliant but there’s a reason he’s not won a champions league since having the best club side we’ve ever seen.

    • @daniaaal
      @daniaaal Рік тому

      I think that's why Pep is able to dominate leagues while he struggles in UCL, whereas Ancelotti has actually struggled in the league while relying on individual brilliance of his players and the occasion to win cup competitions. Obviously his luck ran out against Man City, and I actually expect more teams to have a go against Madrid if Ancelotti does not alter his tactics.

  • @Iainden10
    @Iainden10 Рік тому +4

    oh god. the pictures. make it stop.

  • @yan.weather
    @yan.weather Рік тому +18

    Jon good explanation! However, slow down verbally! Take some pauses. This will make yourself less anxious and thereby audience will be calm to ingest info as well ❤

  • @ILLALLU
    @ILLALLU Рік тому +1

    Best hoodie you've worn yet

  • @Awolowooo
    @Awolowooo Рік тому +1

    Not Zidane recreating his Headbutt on Modric

  • @caroselangelomalinis7463
    @caroselangelomalinis7463 Рік тому +2

    What about Spalletti for Real Madrid?

  • @drex5160
    @drex5160 Рік тому +3

    Naglesman ego is too big to last at Madrid. The best Madrid mangers are the ones that can balance egos, including his own.

  • @Epic-Poetry
    @Epic-Poetry 11 місяців тому +1

    Jon McKenzie is an exceptional tactician, HOWEVER TIFO, particularly JJ Bull, lauded/loved/adored *Graham Potter* and that went well didn't it? There's a TIFO video essentially celebrating his arrival at Chelsea (a video they wish they'd not made). So what could possibly go wrong with Nagelsmann at Real? I would suggest it would be a fast-moving car-crash.

  • @theosundblad7687
    @theosundblad7687 Рік тому +1

    Why is no one talking about that Pep uses the old WM-formation?

  • @ahmadkanafani7603
    @ahmadkanafani7603 Рік тому

    Where do they buy these Framed Kits?

  • @wizcombo
    @wizcombo Рік тому

    notice modric and Zidane Jerseys are messed up on the wall.. Nice touch

  • @AG-cq3kb
    @AG-cq3kb Рік тому +1

    great video, do think there's a good chance Ancelotti ends up leaving, but less so that Nagelsmann comes in unfortunately. He'd be perfect though

  • @adamstevens8661
    @adamstevens8661 Рік тому +1

    anyone else notice the wonky madrid shirts on the wall? nice
    touch 😅

  • @mawiiile706
    @mawiiile706 Рік тому +5

    i like how the modric and zidane frames are crooked because madrid got battered lol

  • @Carrrnage
    @Carrrnage Рік тому +1

    That is the most Evil Villain picture of Pep I've ever seen. Man looks like he's planning to nuke the Premier League.

  • @yutinhoqrvb6871
    @yutinhoqrvb6871 9 місяців тому

    big W for the raptors hoodie 🇨🇦

  • @Juiced_Lemons
    @Juiced_Lemons Рік тому +1

    Id like to see JN back at Bayern🥲

  • @some_guy2911
    @some_guy2911 Рік тому

    Nice hoodie 🇨🇦

  • @22many77
    @22many77 Рік тому

    is doggy mac okay? he seems so aggravated here!! brilliant analyst. perhaps nailmanballs dont mesh with bielsaballs?

  • @djbhashkar
    @djbhashkar Рік тому +1

    Please fix Modric and Zidane frames

  • @user-gc5hg7en5o
    @user-gc5hg7en5o Рік тому

    "Good news is.. He's right there 😂" 10:49

  • @michaelchandra9069
    @michaelchandra9069 Рік тому +1

    I think it will be interesting to see nagelsmann in PSG. They have the power(money) to buy player an he could introduce PSG to one new philosophy where PSG old Philosophy is try to be like Madrid where they have many stars player in which is fail. I think PSG would be great for nagelsmann as a young coach to build his own team with his philosophy rather than trying to be on big club where trophy every year is the must. and i think its good to have a more great team in the champions league in the future rather just few great team.

  • @Fardok
    @Fardok Рік тому

    Wow didn't know John was a Raptors fan!

  • @mattholmes5920
    @mattholmes5920 Рік тому

    John wearing an nba hoodie after flexing that extensive knowledge on the pod

  • @AwakeningFromADream
    @AwakeningFromADream Рік тому +1

    I thought Jon bought sticky tape for the background frames

  • @phnompenhandy
    @phnompenhandy Рік тому +1

    Nagelsman might be a perfect tactical fit, but his time at Bayern showed he lacks the authority to manage the board and suits.

  • @cyandamadlala9610
    @cyandamadlala9610 Рік тому +1

    What are your thoughts on hansi flick?? Would he work in madrid?

    • @kukunase1686
      @kukunase1686 Рік тому

      no i doubt. he is very much a system and pressing manager with a highline. He would work more at maybe barca or City or Liverpool

  • @pozsoz
    @pozsoz Рік тому +1

    I don't think he'd work at Madrid. In Madrid's case it's a lot about being able to manage the squad, tactics have never been that important, Madrid plays simple, straightforward tactics.
    I really cannot see Nagelsmann playing his weird tactics like a 3-1-5-1 that turns into a lopsided back 4-4-2 on defense and so on at Real Madrid, I don't see Carvajal as a false wingback or a 3rd centerback, nor Vinicius tracking back to help on defense.
    Nagelsmann can manage an elite squad, just not Madrid, maybe at a more system-type team.

  • @matesamuelszilagyi7852
    @matesamuelszilagyi7852 9 місяців тому

    It’s the time for Real Madrid to change the philosophy of the entire club and keeping up with the modern footballing expectations.

  • @madslasher
    @madslasher Рік тому

    Respect for that Toronto Raptors hoodie, bruv.

  • @amantlebishopthantsha1265
    @amantlebishopthantsha1265 Рік тому +1

    All those ideas of relying on good structure and PRESSING are good the problem is that they divert from the galactico identity. PERSONALLY I STILL PREFER GALACTIC IDEAS

  • @bulelanibotman
    @bulelanibotman Рік тому

    what is really the deal with the shirts on the wall? today they're skewed the next they're changed

  • @ameenr9129
    @ameenr9129 Рік тому

    6:54 Nagelsmann bit

  • @gentleken7864
    @gentleken7864 Рік тому +2

    Is Zidane headbutting Modric? Has he learnt nothing?

  • @pedropierre9594
    @pedropierre9594 Рік тому +1

    Reminds me of the Lukaku video, it didn’t turnout right did it

  • @ptmproductions296
    @ptmproductions296 Рік тому

    Is it just me or where they fighting? cos' in that background the modric and zidane shirts are skew. Or was it an aesthetic choice?

  • @mikimikula
    @mikimikula Рік тому +1

    I don't think he can manage egos that well, his Bayern time shown that

  • @tomascarneiro2100
    @tomascarneiro2100 Рік тому

    Raptors fan? Just because I'm really confused after last episode where you just named random NBA players like Allen EEverson ahah

  • @Keiphton27
    @Keiphton27 Рік тому

    Pictures!?

  • @samijabbour
    @samijabbour Рік тому

    Wished it to happen for the longest time after he was sacked by Bayern.. but Ancelotti is staying for another year 😞

  • @myat4051
    @myat4051 Рік тому

    Meanwhile Indian, Nepali and Bangladesh experts use terms like CAM,CDM to describe football positions and tactics

  • @facundosaenz12
    @facundosaenz12 Рік тому

    Real Madrid won everything through the years, they still asking "if they should be doing something completely different" Madre mía...

  • @jasoneinstein7986
    @jasoneinstein7986 Рік тому

    Jose tells you when playing one match I don't care control pls respect counter attack tactics no every time need to control

  • @akashm8358
    @akashm8358 Рік тому +1

    Madrid don't do systems, they always get the best players or currently the best young players in the world for every position and establish a baseline level of quality with in the squad, no manager can come in and tell the board at Madrid to get rid of one of their best players because they don't fit their system, if a manager says that then Madrid will get rid of him. I think that is the right approach, if you have the best players in almost every position and you can't create a winning team because a certain player doesn't fit your system then you need to go and learn how to manage big players from managers like Ancelotti and Mourinho. Most of these modern managers are no different than football manager video games. And i don't think nagelsmann will ever coach Madrid, if you don't understand the culture at Madrid and if you are an outsider and you think your system is everything and unwilling to adapt, then managers will get eaten alive at Madrid. Lopetegui got a taste of that he wanted to be a system manager and once his system fails he didn't know what else to do and he got fired pretty quickly

    • @daniaaal
      @daniaaal Рік тому

      I agree with you to some extent. The more important quality for a Real Madrid manager would be to manage egos of big-name players and allow their individuality to shine on the pitch. It's important for the manager to gain the players' trusts more than any tactical or systemic changes to the way the team plays. Which is why, more often than not, although Madrid are capable of creating chances when they control games, they generally thrive more on counter attacking or transitional football, because in those scenarios, the forwards are afforded more space and independence to problem-solve.

  • @raybanaviators
    @raybanaviators Рік тому

    whoa someone ducked up the modric and zidane fake jerseys in the back

  • @vishnu_2954
    @vishnu_2954 Рік тому

    can only dream

  • @avyuktkochhar8374
    @avyuktkochhar8374 Рік тому

    Jon, I thought the Slot video was gonna be the next video😔

    • @TheAthleticFC
      @TheAthleticFC  Рік тому

      This was filmed before he said that.
      The next video Jon films will be about the Slot machine.

  • @aayushsharma8421
    @aayushsharma8421 11 місяців тому

    Now that bellingham has arrived, If klopp gets hand on this madrid team, he would give a fair competition to pep

  • @aloktripathi27
    @aloktripathi27 Рік тому

    Huh you did so little analysis on Nagelsmann based on two screenshots? One were they were trailing and had to more forwards and strech the play? Lmao and a quote that is really old? Well done, great work

  • @Ruony24
    @Ruony24 Рік тому

    😆😆 you guys intentionally messed with the pictures on the wall to annoy the dude who commented in a previous video on those pictures not being in line

  • @hieutruong7456
    @hieutruong7456 Рік тому

    Did you just use a vine boom

  • @mickeyjunior7177
    @mickeyjunior7177 Рік тому +1

    Actually Spalletti will be the best coach for madrid

  • @damiennaidoo7401
    @damiennaidoo7401 Рік тому

    Madrid requires managers like Carlo, José and Zidane who are balanced and grant their attackers freedom. Coaches who push systems like Pep, Nagelsmann and Conte don’t suit Madrid. Watch the way Madrid attack in comparison to City/Arsenal (JDP teams) - Carlo’s style of combinations will suit the Brazilian NT very well.

    • @daniaaal
      @daniaaal Рік тому

      I wouldn't categorise Mourinho as balanced. He had a very rigid structure to the team, especially in terms of defending, and often made less-pleasant-on-the-eyes teams, but he did allow counter-attacking football to occur. He's very much result oriented more than anything else, so in a way he's always coming up with tactics to counter the opposing team's tactics. Which is why he often loses the dressing room over time, because most players eventually get frustrated with him and how their team plays.

  • @1000deaths
    @1000deaths Рік тому

    you guys did a video like this about Potter and utterly cursed him 💀

  • @monarch1993
    @monarch1993 Рік тому +3

    I was very happy that RM got destroyed by Man City, mainly because RM football is actually very boring to watch.