35:00 I think we also have to consider that both groups are managed very differently and because of that the number of produced/written songs can hardly be compared. Stray kids was promoted as a self-producing group since pre-debut, and from what I know JYP + other producers don't interfere much (I'm not a stay so someone can correct me if I'm wrong), but for TXT they have to compete against professional songwriters from across the globe to get their names on their songs. only if what they wrote is the best option out of everything that was submitted, their parts get picked. This is not to discredit 3racha at all though, they have done a lot of great work obviously. But I think it's very different if you pretty much get free range to do your own thing compared to competing against some of the best in the industry (also, TXT have far less songs + albums in general, even though they only debuted 1 year later)
SOOO TRUE.... no any better way to put this into words. SELF PRODUCING Groups often release albums and songs frequently... even SVT being a self produced groups have already had sooo many albums even more than 2nd gen groups. cuz they have the entirety of freedom to do whatever they want with the music.... but TXT being under heavy judgement and competition is way more impressive in my eyes to have contributed sooo much in their songs to be accepted by the best producers (globally) including the very own SLOW RABBIT.... this makes me think how fabulous of an artist BEOMGYU is, to have 3 of the songs he produced (2 being ones from trainee era + 1 being a melody that came to his mind WHILE WASHING HANDS... LOL) to be parts of their EPs.... TXT literally are TOP NOTCH
TXT is very much a group where it's like... Nobody is allowed to make fun of TXT _except_ TXT. If they throw shade at each other and joke about each other? Totally fine; they're all into it. The moment someone who isn't one of them tries it? They're ready to fight.
All groups has that kind of privilege with debut views, not just txt. For example,skz had views because of twice and their predebut survival show,enhypen because of bts,txt(one of the members was super close with txt and he was promoted as “possible 6th member of txt”),seventeen;riize because of nct and exo;babymonster because of blackpink and etc. Bighit’s predebut group trainee a(now disbanded)was popular because of army and moas and of course because of jj’s insane popularity(he is an incredible dancer) or woochan’s smtm(rap competition) background
@RachaDance253 because they are from the same agency and twice was probably the biggest gg domestically...if you want to claim that skz had no privileges whatsoever from being in the same agency as twice and/got7 (not to mention that the agency itself is BIG 3), then you l and all other stays have no rights claiming that txt have the privilege of being in the same agency as bts. For clarification, neither me nor any moa claim that txt didn't actually have such a privileges, because they did and they have also constantly addressed it. It is more so to bring to light the hypocrisy of some stays that skz did not have any privileges, when in reality they debuted in one of the biggest companies and even had pre-deput exposure, because of their survival show.
@@nadyanikolova5719 I wasn't saying that skz had no privileges i was trying to ask why you think so if you thought I was rude I am sorry but I am stay and moa too, most groups had privileges except like 2% of kpop But I don't think that skz had privileges because of twice or got7, it thinks it's just the attention they got from the survival show because if you look at earlier videos there weren't many people supporting them (MY OPINION, EVERYONE DESERVES TO HAVE ONE)
im so glad that u finally got around to watching a guide for txt! its a shame that there were technical difficulties but i cant wait for u to watch the rest of the guide :D * the suchwita ep with txt is another great intro to txt
I think TXT were the without set positions, especially to debut without them (March 2019) (or at least the first more known group). Stray Kids debuted with set positions and it wasn’t until after their Main Vocal left at the end of October 2019 that they changed things.
There's a BIG difference between writing/producing songs and having "credits" which are pulling numbers VS writing and producing for the sake of getting credits.. TXT's B-sides are getting streams and are being praised CONSISTENTLY album after album compared to OTHER GROUPS who are nowhere to be found except for their title tracks and with 10s to 20s b-sides in their albums which are not making any mark in their discography (which is crazy LOL)
subscribed, as a devoted kpop fan for 10 years and someone who ults in hybe groups ESPECIALLY bighit's only two kpop groups, bangtan sonyeondan and tomorrow x together, this was such a well-done video. thank you for pausing to read and respectfully voicing your personal opinions. I've watched tubatu grow up and have grown with them and despite every member being an oppa to me, watching them grow through awkward stages and hardships just helps one develop a sense of protection over them lol. 이 잘 만들어진 비디오에 다시 한 번 감사 드리며 앞으로 더 많은 것을 볼 것입니다!
I geniunely want to hear txt rap ugh, like if they trained as a hiphop group when will they let them rap!! I have seen some snippets here and there and honestly there's so much potential.
1:20:18 yeonjun is a fox but it actually doesn’t specify what kind of fox, so you can think of fennec fox or others kind of fox, but most fan used the red fox to represent yeonjun🦊 I was so sad the internet keep cutting off especially the part i was looking so forward to see you react..😭
52:50 op was talking bout the cover txt did, "boy in luv" where soobin raps.. and the piano is a txt song "our summer" from their debut album. 😅 hope u correct that out.😊
General advice for moas in streams going forward, check and make sure that the information you’re giving the streamers is correct before putting it in chat, and also make sure that the info isn’t going to confuse them because of sending it at a bad time. An example is the pronunciation of member names, you can always google the information before giving it if you’re not sure.
the second you started noticing yeonjun on sugar rush ride mv, i knew you gonna be just like me, getting obsessed hahah. He really is talented. All of them are!
oh my gosh the moas in your comments must be babies, they gave you misinformation so many times😭, yeonjun is pronounced yawn-jun btw, the moa who said yun-joon is incorrect, also that moa's name was typed in hangul so it's weird they don't know that but they probably don't speak korean and just googled the hangul so it's fine.💀
BangChan is an ENFJ and he really looks and listens to his members so it’s really unfair to lump all E’s as people who don’t care about others feelings. We really do. I hate these generalizations.
About the BTS shadow thing, yes yes. But I wanted to say that it must've been soooo much worse bc they are a bg. If they where a gg they'd still get "riding BTS' coattails" shit, but being a bg there can be much more direct comparison. I literally saw someone call Crown (their debut track) a rejected BTS song :v
Yeahhhh, ppl say they (& Enhypen) are trained as both vocal & rap, but tbh I see them as pretty much just a vocal group. Not saying anything about their talent, but rly I can't think of any prominent rap sections in any songs (tt or b-side). I know the guide mentioned it, but for TXT they've been around 4 yrs now. I just don't think rap is an interest for them (nothing wrong w/ that, just idk. It doesn't rly mean much to say they can if they never actually do)
@@SHGogo-df5jr me neither although it would be fun to see them try this concept one day. u can see a little on their show talk x today season Zero or their cover of come back home
25:20 exactly! By that logic, if TXT is only successful bc of the BTS boost then that would apply to literally any artist from the big 3 (JYPE, SM, YG) & as a Stay we know that ain't why Skz smash so hard xD
35:00 I think we also have to consider that both groups are managed very differently and because of that the number of produced/written songs can hardly be compared.
Stray kids was promoted as a self-producing group since pre-debut, and from what I know JYP + other producers don't interfere much (I'm not a stay so someone can correct me if I'm wrong), but for TXT they have to compete against professional songwriters from across the globe to get their names on their songs. only if what they wrote is the best option out of everything that was submitted, their parts get picked.
This is not to discredit 3racha at all though, they have done a lot of great work obviously. But I think it's very different if you pretty much get free range to do your own thing compared to competing against some of the best in the industry
(also, TXT have far less songs + albums in general, even though they only debuted 1 year later)
yess this
thiss
exactly!! u explained this so well
This!
SOOO TRUE.... no any better way to put this into words. SELF PRODUCING Groups often release albums and songs frequently... even SVT being a self produced groups have already had sooo many albums even more than 2nd gen groups. cuz they have the entirety of freedom to do whatever they want with the music.... but TXT being under heavy judgement and competition is way more impressive in my eyes to have contributed sooo much in their songs to be accepted by the best producers (globally) including the very own SLOW RABBIT.... this makes me think how fabulous of an artist BEOMGYU is, to have 3 of the songs he produced (2 being ones from trainee era + 1 being a melody that came to his mind WHILE WASHING HANDS... LOL) to be parts of their EPs.... TXT literally are TOP NOTCH
TXT is very much a group where it's like... Nobody is allowed to make fun of TXT _except_ TXT. If they throw shade at each other and joke about each other? Totally fine; they're all into it. The moment someone who isn't one of them tries it? They're ready to fight.
All groups has that kind of privilege with debut views, not just txt. For example,skz had views because of twice and their predebut survival show,enhypen because of bts,txt(one of the members was super close with txt and he was promoted as “possible 6th member of txt”),seventeen;riize because of nct and exo;babymonster because of blackpink and etc. Bighit’s predebut group trainee a(now disbanded)was popular because of army and moas and of course because of jj’s insane popularity(he is an incredible dancer) or woochan’s smtm(rap competition) background
Because of twice, how?
@RachaDance253 because they are from the same agency and twice was probably the biggest gg domestically...if you want to claim that skz had no privileges whatsoever from being in the same agency as twice and/got7 (not to mention that the agency itself is BIG 3), then you l and all other stays have no rights claiming that txt have the privilege of being in the same agency as bts.
For clarification, neither me nor any moa claim that txt didn't actually have such a privileges, because they did and they have also constantly addressed it. It is more so to bring to light the hypocrisy of some stays that skz did not have any privileges, when in reality they debuted in one of the biggest companies and even had pre-deput exposure, because of their survival show.
@@nadyanikolova5719 I wasn't saying that skz had no privileges i was trying to ask why you think so if you thought I was rude I am sorry but I am stay and moa too, most groups had privileges except like 2% of kpop
But I don't think that skz had privileges because of twice or got7, it thinks it's just the attention they got from the survival show because if you look at earlier videos there weren't many people supporting them (MY OPINION, EVERYONE DESERVES TO HAVE ONE)
seventeen def didn’t
Bro enhypen got bc of I-land. Yes I-land got more known thanks to bts’s visit, but I-land was already very known.
I love TXT so much, they have such a diverse range in music, I hope you can explore that. They are also an incredibly funny group.
It’s sad that u had to end it but it was a fun vibe. Can’t wait until we get the rest
im so glad that u finally got around to watching a guide for txt! its a shame that there were technical difficulties but i cant wait for u to watch the rest of the guide :D
* the suchwita ep with txt is another great intro to txt
52:34 the song it’s not boy in luv by BTS, it’s called our summer and it’s by txt
I think TXT were the without set positions, especially to debut without them (March 2019) (or at least the first more known group). Stray Kids debuted with set positions and it wasn’t until after their Main Vocal left at the end of October 2019 that they changed things.
So happy you are getting into my ult group! You will love them. I look forward to the rest of the reaction!
There's a BIG difference between writing/producing songs and having "credits" which are pulling numbers VS writing and producing for the sake of getting credits..
TXT's B-sides are getting streams and are being praised CONSISTENTLY album after album compared to OTHER GROUPS who are nowhere to be found except for their title tracks and with 10s to 20s b-sides in their albums which are not making any mark in their discography (which is crazy LOL)
subscribed, as a devoted kpop fan for 10 years and someone who ults in hybe groups ESPECIALLY bighit's only two kpop groups, bangtan sonyeondan and tomorrow x together, this was such a well-done video. thank you for pausing to read and respectfully voicing your personal opinions. I've watched tubatu grow up and have grown with them and despite every member being an oppa to me, watching them grow through awkward stages and hardships just helps one develop a sense of protection over them lol. 이 잘 만들어진 비디오에 다시 한 번 감사 드리며 앞으로 더 많은 것을 볼 것입니다!
1:04:15, Not the comments being late and confusing you even more than helping lmao 🤣 The effort was there and appreciated though.
I geniunely want to hear txt rap ugh, like if they trained as a hiphop group when will they let them rap!! I have seen some snippets here and there and honestly there's so much potential.
i hope you can continue the guide and post it ! it was a lot of fun watching with you !
Thank you for the reaction I really enjoyed it, I'm exited for the rest :D
Ohhh looking forward to the rest
yup beomgyu being kind-of unhinged is partly the reason he's my bias lol
If you want to have a good laugh react to TXT's Silence of Idol (Good boy gone bad)
1:20:18 yeonjun is a fox but it actually doesn’t specify what kind of fox, so you can think of fennec fox or others kind of fox, but most fan used the red fox to represent yeonjun🦊
I was so sad the internet keep cutting off especially the part i was looking so forward to see you react..😭
52:50 op was talking bout the cover txt did, "boy in luv" where soobin raps.. and the piano is a txt song "our summer" from their debut album. 😅 hope u correct that out.😊
Btw they’re all super tall. 6’ and 6’1 avarage
He doesn’t class that as super tall because he’s taller than that.
@@melovesawyerI was not comparing to him. Compared to Stray Kids they’re tall. Actually a lot of idols are around 6’ it’s just stray kids are short
Txt is amazing❤
Thank you. So fun watching this with ya. Can’t wait to see the rest!
Yes, thank you for reaction! ❤
really loved this and can't wait for the rest hehe :D
General advice for moas in streams going forward, check and make sure that the information you’re giving the streamers is correct before putting it in chat, and also make sure that the info isn’t going to confuse them because of sending it at a bad time. An example is the pronunciation of member names, you can always google the information before giving it if you’re not sure.
We need part 2!!
Hope you can finish the rest
YESSS MY ULT
You’re actually so funny I laughed so hard 😭👍 thank you for this
😌
33:05 lmaoooo the way you tried to read Kai’s full name, but just gave up😂
the second you started noticing yeonjun on sugar rush ride mv, i knew you gonna be just like me, getting obsessed hahah. He really is talented. All of them are!
You can call 'taehyun' by the name 'terry'. that's his English name
Cannot wait for part 2
it's not complete yet :(
please post the full reaction^^
oh my gosh the moas in your comments must be babies, they gave you misinformation so many times😭, yeonjun is pronounced yawn-jun btw, the moa who said yun-joon is incorrect, also that moa's name was typed in hangul so it's weird they don't know that but they probably don't speak korean and just googled the hangul so it's fine.💀
finally I've waited too long! thanks
When Soobin is rapping that your replayed, it's BTS's song BOY IN LUV
Why I can't find this video on your channel but my watch history??
Btw I loveeee your reaction, plz more of TXT❤ Eagerly waiting 🤍
14:01 they broke it again with Chasing that feeling
It's not complete т.т
Part 2 when? ♡(> ਊ
BangChan is an ENFJ and he really looks and listens to his members so it’s really unfair to lump all E’s as people who don’t care about others feelings. We really do. I hate these generalizations.
Beomgyuables🥰
About the BTS shadow thing, yes yes. But I wanted to say that it must've been soooo much worse bc they are a bg. If they where a gg they'd still get "riding BTS' coattails" shit, but being a bg there can be much more direct comparison. I literally saw someone call Crown (their debut track) a rejected BTS song :v
Please react to seventeen guide.....please...
13:20 I just heard that ateez now become 4th gen most viewed group in 24 hours
They deserve it 😭
really? with how many views?
@@cyj305I think 19m
wait really?? what mv??!
@@hueningpie crazy farm
@@hueningpiecrazy form
Pls watch game caters x hybeeee
Yeahhhh, ppl say they (& Enhypen) are trained as both vocal & rap, but tbh I see them as pretty much just a vocal group. Not saying anything about their talent, but rly I can't think of any prominent rap sections in any songs (tt or b-side). I know the guide mentioned it, but for TXT they've been around 4 yrs now. I just don't think rap is an interest for them (nothing wrong w/ that, just idk. It doesn't rly mean much to say they can if they never actually do)
txt was initially going to be a hiphop group so they trained for it but before their debut bighit changed their concept
Huh interesting... I can't imagine it xD@@beeaxolotl
@@SHGogo-df5jr me neither although it would be fun to see them try this concept one day. u can see a little on their show talk x today season Zero or their cover of come back home
Txt is amazing 🤍
pleeeease react to txt variety shows or meme videos :D
25:20 exactly! By that logic, if TXT is only successful bc of the BTS boost then that would apply to literally any artist from the big 3 (JYPE, SM, YG) & as a Stay we know that ain't why Skz smash so hard xD
FINISH PLESEEE
Hope U finish rest with us PLZ 🫶