3:20 Nope, you are wrong. In RDR2 the body of water follows the arms movements of the character, while in AC:M the water uses a simple standard circular animation/sprite, no matter what the character is doing.
Red dead redemption 2 have a system that the water reacts in real time, while AC Mirage, it's more like animations. But the water in RDR 2 looks like jelly sometimes
Hell no, that's asking for way too much. If every game tried to have visuals and story as perfect as rdr2, we would rarely get good gameplay again. Let it be the greatest in those catagories, until we have the technology to replicate that greatness without sacrificing the rest of the product.
@@senhorveiasMy man. Rockstar is literally the worst example you can give when it comes to “not just thinking about money” It’s a damn miracle we still get singleplayer masterpieces from them considering all the greedy decisions they shove down our throats any other time
@@SilverGeFer No, they just save the scummy MTX for their online only games (GTA online, RD online) which i honestly can appreciate. If them "thinking about only money" leads to them making these incredible singleplayer experiences then im all for it. My problem is with these Ubisoft/EA type companies that dont put any passion or creativity into their games and expect massive payouts, because they dont understand that making great games = more money than the trash games that they produce every other year.
@@Sea-Bird..just because rdr1 is a technical masterpiece doesn't mean it can't be replicated, Rockstar did it 5 years ago and it's just your average AAA video game company, they just needed a great amount of time and recourses
@@DTunezOfficial sharp shaodow always hurst my eyes, wth with this dog shit emgine, i remember ass creed unity has great soft shaodow, much realitics lookin. soft shadow setting in rdr2 so nice and not take fps, this RAGE engine so good. ubishit need put nvidiapcss shadow for their trash.
@@DTunezOfficial The shadow doesn't move with the sun, it only moves when the character moves. If you stand still then cast a shadow it will stand still and not move wtf. i recognize this from ass creed originl to migare.
It always has been mate, like in games like GTA 5. You know the feature where you switch characters (franklin, Trevor or Micheal) in middle of a game with no loading screen? Its getting introduced to Spiderman 2. A game which hasn't even come out yet.
More like Rockstar uses everything that has been achieved in making good videogames while many other companies just cut corners to look good enough but to never really strive for anything better since it would take too long and the price would be too much, even though they more than likely can increase their budget, they just don't want to
Just to point out, the swimming thing, it’s not about the game itself, it’s being more realistic by showing that Arthur isn’t a trained assassin and a 1899 cowboy
As a game developer myself I lost my marbles after seeing the lighting in rdr2, the only other thing that made me react like that since was frozen 2s autumn lighting, ITS JUST SO GOOD! sadly it’s hard to get stuff that looks as good as rdr2 and fr2 because they make their own lighting systems and they are not released to the public.
Did you say mirages water physics look better? The ripples are all hand animated no simulation or additional interactions going on, watch Arthur when he wades through the water and the ripples affect the natural current of the water, and when he’s swimming he’s actually moving the water organically it’s not a canned animation
@@c00lmanableI disagree, but you have your opinion. RDR2 is supposed to reflect reality though, so it’s not always meant to be beautiful. The dirt and scars on the face, the movements of the horse… it’s not stylized, if you see what i mean.
1:38 you can see that in rdr2 the light intesity from the fire changes as the air disturbs the flame the intensity of light changes from time to time bt in acm the intensity remains same as if the light is coming from a light bulb. Very cool details juat goes to show how rdr2 still holds up in terms of designs.
Ass Creed Mirage is nothing compared to RDR2, this video talks just about graphics but in terms of gameplay, characters, story, voice acting and over all aesthetic of the game, RDR2 beats it. Ass creed is just another game which will be forgotten, not Red Dead redemption
@@kinhamid9665I myself do prefer the red dead franchise to assassins creed but the amount of red dead fans who pretty much just bully anyone who dares compliment assassins creed is insane.
This is the same animation as it was in previous games. Even Kassandra hasn't been changed, like she has the balls)😂 So I think they could have personalized this animation to each character.
I didn’t even start the video, but I know this one is going to be amazing. Edit: Knowing Rdr 2 is from 2018 blows my mind that certain aspects included into the game are better then one from this month!
Doesn't matter, rdr2 is at effectively the same price point as Mirage and other ubi games, it should compete with it. Dev time simply isnt an excuse. If they dont want to compete with rdr2 or Elden Ring then they need to lower their price, simple as that.
@@nogeagor971 There's a lot of aspects have to be addressed to compete with rockstar's Titles... (Time, budget, skill, direction, etc..), which in this case (the compression) mirage have a lot missing. Also about the pricing, I bet you (with logic) if RDR2 came out recently, it would be priced as any ordinary game at the current gen.
For those who are defending AC Mirage here's the thing , instead of rushing the games release why not take your time and create a well polished game with compelling storyline ? The thing is Ubisoft lacks vision it tries to create several themes of one genre that has worked and that to unpolished and quick. And as far as budget is concerned why not create a smaller open world game but with compelling storyline and lots of details? Is this too much to ask or impossible to do ? I mean they have done this before with AC1 !
How funny you are. I wonder why, then, with such logic, Rdr on the PC release came out so sucky? Why didn't they finish it? You don't even know what these games are about. Games about the assassin are primarily about the era, its atmosphere, the construction of beautiful worlds of those times. There have never been any cool plots there. By the way, there is no good plot in Ddr 2 either
@@MaxColfieldbut there are several cool plots in Red dead Redemtion 2, I'm in the third chapter. At the beginning the brawl in the saloon was a cool plot that came so suddenly, or when Arthur was kidnapped and you have to free yourself, those were very cool plots in my opinion.
Rockstar never miss. They are one of the few companies who care more about their customers than money. As a video game programmer RD2 water has physics why AC is more animation base. You can tell because when AC walks though the water it’s the same water affects playing(recycling through) same as when he idling in the water there’s no other movement in the water from his hands beside the circle water movement that keep appearing from the center of his body.
@@Ax3line19 at the end of the day more people are playing GTA than RDRO and it’s not a lot you can add to RDRO without breaking the lore. So the best business decision would be to abandon RDRO for more GTAO content. At the end of the day it’s still a business through and through.
3:10 Definitely not. Look at how Arthur’s individual limbs push the water around. Another example of the superior water physics in RDR2 is with boats and how the oar pushes the water around. RDR2 without a doubt has superior water physics.
Yeah, the only downside is it sometimes looks really weird and not like water. But players don't really spend that much time in it anyway. And it looks great while crossing it on a horse so that's good enough for me!
10 years from now RDR2 realistic graphics is still on the top, even games these days releasing still have less realistic graphics than RDR2, I remember playing in 2018 when it first came out I was so stunned by the environment I spend more time roaming than doing missions lol!
It’s so surprising that even 5 straight years, a new game is still compared with a 2018 game. That’s enough to know that rdr2 is actually a great game or in fact one of masterpieces
@@imagi.nation1429 what do you expect in a comparison video. You can't expect a rdr2 player not thinking about the truth that's happening in right front of you. Duh!
mirage is still lowkey impressive to come think about it. it was supposed to be a valhalla dlc but they were allowed to make a new game instead. and the team isnt really big at all so props to ubisoft bordeaux and they only had like what? 2 years to make the game? maybe less??
@@testtestrestrest i have rdr2 and i have played almost all ac games and this was actually the team that made mirage (bordeaux). It was their first game ever because they were supposed to make dlcs for valhalla instead so they had less time to make mirage. and rdr2 had like 8 years when mirage only had 2-3
@@testtestrestrest What do you mean? on par rdr 2 realism is next level. I mean you can talk, greet to almost every npc. Your cloth affects your body or the fact that every interaction somewhat has an affect on the protangonists personality. Quality of food affects you, even animals have more brain than mirages npc and not even kidding. Vultures eat dead people sheeps go for grazing in the morning and comeback in the night. Mirage just uses old animation while rdr 2 is based on new engine with 300000+ animations. Mirages map is smallers than like gta V and its empty. Thats not on par dude
And to think, they haven't remastered RDR2 yet. I would pay $69.99 to play it in full Remastered. (not whatever they did for GTA San Andreas, 3, and vice City)
Okay … guess it’s time for all the other devs to make more expensive games then ? Don’t look for excuses to defend someone as childhood destroying as Ubisoft … they make shitty games … I mean they have very good ideas and the games have a lot potential but I never played a game where Ubisoft really excelled…. And I played a lot of games from those assholes, so they definitely do something wrong
seen the title and actually laughed out loud. In my honest opinion, the only developers that will be able to outmatch the level of details and environment interaction is rockstar.. it's just way too good.
Even though it's a 2018 game, from the old generation, RDR2 continues to be superior to any new generation game, this just shows how far ahead of that time this game is. It's a game that's in a shelf of its own, and probably only Rockstar will be able to make another game to beat it.
Hey, Arthur and Uncle! You both just need to love Rdr2. (joking aside, both of your accounts are Rdr2 fan accounts) Why do you say "nostalgia blinded" in this case?
Wtaf lol. Water physics “BETTER” in AC Mirage? We saw the same video right? It’s arbitrary model interaction. In RDR2, as you move the water reacts differently and dynamically. In ACM, the water ripples in a circle radiating out from you. That’s elementary water physics reacting to arbitrary object interference, not dynamic physics reacting to movement and mass. RDR2 definitely wins water. ACM does exactly what most other modern games are doing. With this method, the character makes the same ripples standing as any other object/model does and they make the same radiating ripples walking or swimming.
Of course it moves with the hand (object interference) and better work has done with RDR2. But did you observe the way ripples work? It's not working like it should work on water. like high density or heavily contaminated. So Mirage has the upper hand here even if it does not have that physical interference. But at the end it's the way we see. Can't disagree totally with you. Good point!
Comparing these two games like this isn't really fair imo. RDR2 had a much bigger team, bigger budget, and more development time than Mirage did, which makes sense because RDR2 is a much bigger game in general as well, being in development for eight whole years while Mirage was under 2 years. That said though, given that RDR2 is 5 years old now, it holds up very well.
Mirage was not even made by ubisoft montreal I'm not sure what part of ubisoft made Mirage but all I know is that part of ubisoft never hade a whole game they just helped
Well I guess Ubisoft have to take more time and money in their hands then … u can’t excuse a worse game … if you wanna do a masterpiece (what imo devs should try doing) then you should be ready to do everything necessary to make it a masterpiece… clearly something Rockstar was ready to do an Ubisoft NEVER did…. and I don’t think they even could even with more time money bigger team etc they just don’t know how to do art anymore they just drop lifeless games who are all the same with little effort to make a bug
People always say stuff like this in any comment section related to games that RDR2 is being compared with. It's such a massive cope lol you're talking as if ubisoft is some kind of beggar that is lacking resources and budget to create a game but as a matter of fact ubisoft is already one of the biggest game companies there, you're lying to yourself by using that bs excuse that ubisoft has less budget/resources.
That's not true. Ubisoft has 20,000 employees while Rockstar doesn't even have a quarter of that. Ubisoft has different teams working on different games at the same time, so it's likely that this one took 3-5 years to develop and not 2 as you say. Rockstar simply puts more effort and resources into making a single game, that's why RDR2 is superior technically to other games released today.
Haven't Been in your Channel Brother Need to catch up hehe Awesome Content Brother Thank you for uploading. IMO Both game is great in their own unique ways. Fire Upload❤🔥👍
Lol i didn't even think people would compare these two. I actually did in my own time, i was watching people roll rugs and lay them down and the rolls were red but the ones she took out and laid down were yellow. Rdr2 doesn't miss things like that
@@vihangabimsara4716 Still extremely bad for a game thats the same price as RDR2, they should either spend more time making a better game or reduce their price, theres no excuse for them.
I think Ubisoft is the only gaming studio that can match or even exceed Rockstar's level of detail and polish. They build great landscapes and architecture but they need to give more time to certain games like the AC series, FarCry, and Watch Dogs. They need to focus more on quality rather than quantity.
Me, can't stand westerns or cowboys, brought RDR2 for the game engine, hoping someone would do a mod to remove the western theme from the game, for true OPEN WORLD, in hindsight it would have made more sense to not buy the game, and wait for a mod...that's never coming. RDR2 is a vast, diverse, and heavy on the details and story, wonderful game engine, beautifully implemented with a massive amount of content and immersion...just not for me. Mirage, a tiny project in comparison, holds its own for what it is, with enough content and story for the AC junkie who needs his AC fix, grand exotic setting with a rich historic culture, im just starting to enjoy it. Both are a welcome addition to their genre, but in terms of scale, complexity and depth RDR2 is the clear winner. PS: Don't UBI have at least 4 Game Engines?.
Their problem isn't even Quality, its a complete lack of passion and creativity, all their games are these corporate clones of each other (just like their employees :) )
@@nogeagor971 this man is completely right, Ubisoft could NEVER reach rockstar not in a million years, they have good ideas wich have so much potential but they screw it up every time (literally the last time I was satisfied with an ubi game I was like 12) bcs like the man said they don’t have passion or creativity they just copy past their games with little effort as possible, rockstar is exactly the other way around those mfs are real artists… and I will always remember rdf2 till I die … I am not gonna remember vallah maybe just bcs it was so bad. ..
Who agrees that RDR2 is the greatest game of all time and that only RDR3 or GTA6 can defeat it's level of realism, charecter depth, story, cinematics, physics and plot.???
If RDR2 after 5 years still looks better than many new games (water in AC looks really good though), I wonder how GTA 6 will look like. I hope changes that happaned to Rockstar won't influence it too much and we will get a movie like game just like RDR 2.
Bruh rdr2 and ac have different character traits, one is a gun slinger and the other is a fucking assassin, you can’t say “unlike” rdr2 player can swim underwater in mirage. By that logic unlike Ac guns are available in rdr2 and unlike rdr2 character can jump and run on buildings
Rdr2 still goated. I loss interest of games that used to be fun for me. Now I'm on a continuous loop of finishing RDR2. On my 16th run now. Not sure how many more times need until I can move on to other games. Hahaha
Red Dead Redemption 2 is the definitive of Purity in the Gaming World And Assassin’s Creed Mirage is at the standards of what a regular game should be like, Graphically.
Only thing i was dissapointed in RDR2 was that there was no “mirage” on top of fire/flames. I was thinking if they could do the sunlight through the ears then they could’ve done with the fire. But RDR2 is still king in all other aspects
In defence of Mirage, Mirage had like a bit over 1 year of production time Rdr2 had over 8 years of production time Mirage had pretty much 10x smaller Budget than rdr2. Mirage had a smaller company make it with a staff size of roughly several hundred people. Rdr2 was made by a massive company with the staff size of around 6000. The fact mirage still (somewhat) can hold its own against rdr2 is mind boggling
Agreed, but that's the point right ? Instead of rushing the games release why not take your time and create a well polished game with compelling storyline ? The thing is Ubisoft lacks vision it tries to create several themes of one genre that has worked and that to unpolished and quick. And as far as budget is concerned why not create a smaller open world game but with compelling storyline and lots of details?
And the point? Mirages map is smaller than 45 km square while rdr 2 is 75-80 Km square. While half of the map feels empty rdr 2 map is filled with animals and towns. Mirage just reuses old animations while rdr2 has 300000+ animations. The realism in rdr2 I mean how your clothes affect your body? Your behaviour towards your horse? Arthers interactions affects the his personality and changing more interactions. While rdr 2 is made like completly new , Mirage is just a overated copy of its past.
Also when u whistle after running Arthur has difficulty. If you ride too fast arthur barely manages to open eye. Like people do when wind is fast I forgot what it is called. Also you can see bullets remaining in revolver barrels. And many mire rdr2 is goat
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Its mind blowing how modern games still getting compared with RDR2 bur few of them can compete with it...truly a goated game
Naughty Dogs is the only studio whose games can stand strong in comparision to Rockstar's Games.
@@rawaacrew
Naughty Dog is also a great studio but yeah it’s a little wrong to compare those games with open world games
Rdr2 isn't a modern game?
2018, it released in 2018. 5 years ago@@plumoo22
@@plumoo22it is 5 years old already
Rdr2 literally has the best lighting seen in any open world games
I like how lighting is reflected in white surfaces, just put together a white horar against a black horse an SEE the difference
RDR2 is the best open world game.
cyberpunk literally has path tracing
personally I think max graphics metro exodus achieves that
@@cheesecheese6459Real
3:20 Nope, you are wrong. In RDR2 the body of water follows the arms movements of the character, while in AC:M the water uses a simple standard circular animation/sprite, no matter what the character is doing.
I don't think he knows how to swim. Rdr2 did it better.
Better in assassins creed
Ikr? That's what I came to type here
Yes RDR2 is better.
Red dead redemption 2 have a system that the water reacts in real time, while AC Mirage, it's more like animations. But the water in RDR 2 looks like jelly sometimes
RDR2 is the benchmark all games need to reach….not just in visual terms but story and character depth…….if that’s at all possible
Hell no, that's asking for way too much. If every game tried to have visuals and story as perfect as rdr2, we would rarely get good gameplay again. Let it be the greatest in those catagories, until we have the technology to replicate that greatness without sacrificing the rest of the product.
@@Sea-Bird..rockstar did it 5 years ago..so it is possible, just make a game with passion and not just thinking about money
@@senhorveiasMy man. Rockstar is literally the worst example you can give when it comes to “not just thinking about money”
It’s a damn miracle we still get singleplayer masterpieces from them considering all the greedy decisions they shove down our throats any other time
@@SilverGeFer No, they just save the scummy MTX for their online only games (GTA online, RD online) which i honestly can appreciate. If them "thinking about only money" leads to them making these incredible singleplayer experiences then im all for it. My problem is with these Ubisoft/EA type companies that dont put any passion or creativity into their games and expect massive payouts, because they dont understand that making great games = more money than the trash games that they produce every other year.
@@Sea-Bird..just because rdr1 is a technical masterpiece doesn't mean it can't be replicated, Rockstar did it 5 years ago and it's just your average AAA video game company, they just needed a great amount of time and recourses
RDR2's shadows are even better because they soften realistically further away from the object its cast from. Mirage's shadows are always sharp
weather, reflection, physics, gore, animations, clouds, face animations, shadow, drawdistance, reflection, night, realtime shadow moving..... everything better in rdr2
@@namgunaucao9771 yes but he showed shadows
@@DTunezOfficial and yeah this is the fucking bad video ever
@@DTunezOfficial sharp shaodow always hurst my eyes, wth with this dog shit emgine, i remember ass creed unity has great soft shaodow, much realitics lookin. soft shadow setting in rdr2 so nice and not take fps, this RAGE engine so good. ubishit need put nvidiapcss shadow for their trash.
@@DTunezOfficial The shadow doesn't move with the sun, it only moves when the character moves. If you stand still then cast a shadow it will stand still and not move wtf. i recognize this from ass creed originl to migare.
Rockstar was way ahead of it's time
It always has been mate, like in games like GTA 5. You know the feature where you switch characters (franklin, Trevor or Micheal) in middle of a game with no loading screen? Its getting introduced to Spiderman 2. A game which hasn't even come out yet.
No, Rockstar clearly used time travel to make a game like this
@@muhammadamaar7936They didn't used time travel,
There games shows to all gaming industry that having love in making the game matters the most
More like Rockstar uses everything that has been achieved in making good videogames while many other companies just cut corners to look good enough but to never really strive for anything better since it would take too long and the price would be too much, even though they more than likely can increase their budget, they just don't want to
@@Butwastakethey also wanted to that in Gta San andreas but the consoles weren't powerful enough lol
Only game that can defeat rdr 2 is gta 6 or rdr 3
Spiderman 2 is almost out. I don't think it will beat rdr2 but it looks fun.
In terms of realism and graphics, maybe. But it’s not the best at everything, like how linear the missions are for example.
Last of Us Part 2, Ghost of Tsushima… everyone rides GTA so hard and it’s trash.
@dathunderman4 true, in terms of realism it is great
GOT feels cartoony@@offthewallsurfer1
6:42 bro really said rowing a boat at the speed of sound with no considerable character exhaustion is better and more realistic
Just to point out, the swimming thing, it’s not about the game itself, it’s being more realistic by showing that Arthur isn’t a trained assassin and a 1899 cowboy
and he is a gunslinger not a trained solider or sum
As a game developer myself I lost my marbles after seeing the lighting in rdr2, the only other thing that made me react like that since was frozen 2s autumn lighting, ITS JUST SO GOOD! sadly it’s hard to get stuff that looks as good as rdr2 and fr2 because they make their own lighting systems and they are not released to the public.
Frozen 2?
@@Bluewater225I’m not weird you’re weird
frozen2? bruh
@@Kilkko tf u mean
We can never allow them to release those lighting systems to the public because you humans are just not ready for the things that are used by Aliens.
Did you say mirages water physics look better? The ripples are all hand animated no simulation or additional interactions going on, watch Arthur when he wades through the water and the ripples affect the natural current of the water, and when he’s swimming he’s actually moving the water organically it’s not a canned animation
Mirage just looks better tho... in every way
@@c00lmanable no it really doesn’t lol but I suppose it’s a matter of opinion.
@@c00lmanableI disagree, but you have your opinion. RDR2 is supposed to reflect reality though, so it’s not always meant to be beautiful. The dirt and scars on the face, the movements of the horse… it’s not stylized, if you see what i mean.
@@c00lmanablemaximum ac fanboy
@@shadowblyat2323 lol I'm just trolling . RDR2 is the most beautiful game even in 2023
Just a reminder RDR2 came out 5 years ago, so the fact these two are even comparable is a testament to how good that game is.
8 years ago?😮💨
Rdr2 released in 2018 bruh
@@fabilix7899 sorry 5 years ago in 2018 I started writing that and just got confused
@@sadtwolvesfan it's cool my brotha I knew you got it confused
Mirage isn't even better than unity and that can't out in like 2014
1:38 you can see that in rdr2 the light intesity from the fire changes as the air disturbs the flame the intensity of light changes from time to time bt in acm the intensity remains same as if the light is coming from a light bulb. Very cool details juat goes to show how rdr2 still holds up in terms of designs.
Ass Creed Mirage is nothing compared to RDR2, this video talks just about graphics but in terms of gameplay, characters, story, voice acting and over all aesthetic of the game, RDR2 beats it. Ass creed is just another game which will be forgotten, not Red Dead redemption
Bro in ACM too the intensity of light changes. Go get some fucking Specs
In the RDR2 fire, the logs also collapse over time like if they were being burned
Really shows how well-made Rockstar games truly are
Red Dead Redemption 2 you can compare with real life only😂
you're right my buddy
@@Crystaloanimation do you play Rdr 2 buddy?
3:58 I like how basim interacts with the grass using his hand. Nice little detail
Yes but it you watch closely he slows down only when exiting the bushes unlike RDR
Bro you're not allowed to say anything good about AC in these
Bayek already did that in AC Origins
@@kinhamid9665I myself do prefer the red dead franchise to assassins creed but the amount of red dead fans who pretty much just bully anyone who dares compliment assassins creed is insane.
This is the same animation as it was in previous games. Even Kassandra hasn't been changed, like she has the balls)😂 So I think they could have personalized this animation to each character.
I didn’t even start the video, but I know this one is going to be amazing.
Edit: Knowing Rdr 2 is from 2018 blows my mind that certain aspects included into the game are better then one from this month!
Thank you! Hope you enjoy! 😊❤❤
It is better in all aspects
Because Mirage runs on a 10 year old engine. I like it but truth be told its a game on 2016 level.
@@mikeo9074yes origins and odyssey lok better than this
6:20 RDR2 has soo realistic face while AC Mirage has baby face
Lol sensitive more bad is rdr only wrost vga👎😑
Nah arthur just needs some skincare 😂
RDR2 is a masterpiece most definitely, but the time involved through developing it is way long then any ordinary game development time span...
Doesn't matter, rdr2 is at effectively the same price point as Mirage and other ubi games, it should compete with it. Dev time simply isnt an excuse. If they dont want to compete with rdr2 or Elden Ring then they need to lower their price, simple as that.
@@nogeagor971
The man said it all
Ubisoft is not small so why they don't use more people for making a masterpiece instead of a normal game ?
@@nogeagor971 There's a lot of aspects have to be addressed to compete with rockstar's Titles... (Time, budget, skill, direction, etc..), which in this case (the compression) mirage have a lot missing. Also about the pricing, I bet you (with logic) if RDR2 came out recently, it would be priced as any ordinary game at the current gen.
@@romanian7382 a good question to ask ubisoft Montreal, Paradox...
Hope gta 6 recieves similar amount of care and attention like RDR2 from rockstar, they make 1 game after many years, and usually worth th wait
Gta6 is gonna make rdr2 look like a demo of rockstars new graphics and physics
Keep your expectations low and u will never be disappointed:: KRATOS
@@monkeyman2918That’s what CDPR said. Just keep ur expectations low and u will never be disappointed.
@@monkeyman2918lmao
For those who are defending AC Mirage here's the thing , instead of rushing the games release why not take your time and create a well polished game with compelling storyline ? The thing is Ubisoft lacks vision it tries to create several themes of one genre that has worked and that to unpolished and quick. And as far as budget is concerned why not create a smaller open world game but with compelling storyline and lots of details? Is this too much to ask or impossible to do ? I mean they have done this before with AC1 !
How funny you are. I wonder why, then, with such logic, Rdr on the PC release came out so sucky? Why didn't they finish it?
You don't even know what these games are about. Games about the assassin are primarily about the era, its atmosphere, the construction of beautiful worlds of those times. There have never been any cool plots there. By the way, there is no good plot in Ddr 2 either
@@MaxColfield sucky lol.. I play it in 2k more than 60 fps.. The game is soo well opistimised.. I think you should get a better pc😂
@@MaxColfieldbut there are several cool plots in Red dead Redemtion 2, I'm in the third chapter. At the beginning the brawl in the saloon was a cool plot that came so suddenly, or when Arthur was kidnapped and you have to free yourself, those were very cool plots in my opinion.
@@MaxColfieldNo fucking way rdr2’s story isn’t a masterpiece
Rockstar never miss.
They are one of the few companies who care more about their customers than money.
As a video game programmer RD2 water has physics why AC is more animation base. You can tell because when AC walks though the water it’s the same water affects playing(recycling through) same as when he idling in the water there’s no other movement in the water from his hands beside the circle water movement that keep appearing from the center of his body.
Fromsoft, capcom
@@doctordeath2551 uhhhh x doubt
They literally left rdr online to give more updates to GTA online
Because rdro didn't gave them enough money
@@Ax3line19 at the end of the day more people are playing GTA than RDRO and it’s not a lot you can add to RDRO without breaking the lore.
So the best business decision would be to abandon RDRO for more GTAO content.
At the end of the day it’s still a business through and through.
3:10 Definitely not. Look at how Arthur’s individual limbs push the water around. Another example of the superior water physics in RDR2 is with boats and how the oar pushes the water around. RDR2 without a doubt has superior water physics.
Yeah, the only downside is it sometimes looks really weird and not like water. But players don't really spend that much time in it anyway. And it looks great while crossing it on a horse so that's good enough for me!
@@Nigaki23333the water in rdr2 is more like gta 4 which has one of best water physics
I love the scenery in both games. The map designers are fantastic. But in texture, RDR2 wins in my opinion. Animation-wise, RDR2 far surpassed ACM.
10 years from now RDR2 realistic graphics is still on the top, even games these days releasing still have less realistic graphics than RDR2, I remember playing in 2018 when it first came out I was so stunned by the environment I spend more time roaming than doing missions lol!
It’s so surprising that even 5 straight years, a new game is still compared with a 2018 game. That’s enough to know that rdr2 is actually a great game or in fact one of masterpieces
you guys are like bots commentimg the exact same thing in every single comparison video💀
@@imagi.nation1429 what do you expect in a comparison video. You can't expect a rdr2 player not thinking about the truth that's happening in right front of you. Duh!
@@rishitshah4338 didnt say i expected something, just pointed out the lack of original thought
What is he supposed to say? RDR2 is ass, even if proved its better than games coming out this year. Like dawg, come on.@@imagi.nation1429
I was expecting Mirage to be absolutly dunked but I'm honestly surprised.
To be honest, red dead has far realistic graphics and deep-core gameplay. But i do love the parkour elements and historical events in every A.C game.
Awesome Blaze92 wonderful video and Details broo
Gotta agree Rockstar makes best masterpieces even though take light years.
Light years? It's not travelling lol
no, id give Valve that makes the best nasterpieces, they make games that last for years and invent new ideas that every other company copies it.
I don’t think a game can top rdr2
GTA6 i hope will be able to
maybe rdr3 at one point :D
This is like comparing an amazing italian pizza from Rome to a New York slice from the bronx.
mirage is still lowkey impressive to come think about it. it was supposed to be a valhalla dlc but they were allowed to make a new game instead. and the team isnt really big at all so props to ubisoft bordeaux and they only had like what? 2 years to make the game? maybe less??
is it because you have mirage? And just mirage only? Also even if the team isnt big, the entirety of ubisoft is almost on par with rockstar
@@testtestrestrest i have rdr2 and i have played almost all ac games and this was actually the team that made mirage (bordeaux). It was their first game ever because they were supposed to make dlcs for valhalla instead so they had less time to make mirage. and rdr2 had like 8 years when mirage only had 2-3
Speaking facts bro
@@testtestrestrest What do you mean? on par rdr 2 realism is next level. I mean you can talk, greet to almost every npc. Your cloth affects your body or the fact that every interaction somewhat has an affect on the protangonists personality. Quality of food affects you, even animals have more brain than mirages npc and not even kidding. Vultures eat dead people sheeps go for grazing in the morning and comeback in the night.
Mirage just uses old animation while rdr 2 is based on new engine with 300000+ animations. Mirages map is smallers than like gta V and its empty. Thats not on par dude
Bro, I’m so glad that you’re the using background music that ENXGMA used it before. Keep it up!
👇
its fascinating that a last game still kicking so many current gen a$$es 😍
Rdr2 was 10 years ahead ❤
Not gonna lie, since Odyssey (or maybe Watch Dogs 2), Ubisoft's water effects are now really good, from minor ripples to massive wave simulations
Ahhh just another day with rdr2 masterpiece !
Every year I understand that the peak of games is 2018
Not only games...
And to think, they haven't remastered RDR2 yet. I would pay $69.99 to play it in full Remastered. (not whatever they did for GTA San Andreas, 3, and vice City)
It doesn’t need a remaster. A 60 FPS update would be nice tho
@@dathunderman4yea like why TF no 60fps or 1440p/4k for consoles
It's going to be real life then, with ray tracing though I bet someone wouldn't be able to guess what is what.
@@30-06LoverXbox series S 😂😂
This is like comparing a pond to an ocean
RDR2 was a revolutionary piece of entertainment software where other games are just video games
No
Yeah keep telling yourself that😊 @@carlossantiagoclaros99
Ubisoft are also trying let give them a like ❤
RDR2 is the most expensive game ever made, its no surprise it beats alot of games in terms of graphics, realism, etc
Okay … guess it’s time for all the other devs to make more expensive games then ? Don’t look for excuses to defend someone as childhood destroying as Ubisoft … they make shitty games … I mean they have very good ideas and the games have a lot potential but I never played a game where Ubisoft really excelled…. And I played a lot of games from those assholes, so they definitely do something wrong
@@thedj6921 Did you play A.C. Black Flag?
@@thedj6921ac origins is best ac game with good story graphics and details and is beautiful 2
man, because of your greatness, you started youtube with already 200K subscribers, keep up the greatness
Rdr2 just aint comparable man its too good the horses still look better than any
LoL that's like comparing Gordon Ramsay to McDonald's.
2023 Best Game RDR2 2025 GTA 6 2030 Bully 2 ❤ All time Rockstar Game's 🔝 number 1 Open world Game's 🔥
Rockstar are way too overrated, I'm sure you don't play any games, and if you did, you'd know that there's nothing good in a game once it's completed
@@MrMojoRisin971 name a game which has a more immersive and interactive world than rdr2 then.. go ahead
Botw,totk,metro exodus
@shinobimsh5687 I ain't good with abbreviations friend, so use words instead of this idubs crap
@@themadtitan728 if you are the least bit literate, you'd know what my comment means.
seen the title and actually laughed out loud. In my honest opinion, the only developers that will be able to outmatch the level of details and environment interaction is rockstar.. it's just way too good.
Even though it's a 2018 game, from the old generation, RDR2 continues to be superior to any new generation game, this just shows how far ahead of that time this game is. It's a game that's in a shelf of its own, and probably only Rockstar will be able to make another game to beat it.
Water physics are clear in rdr2, and ngl it beats ac mirage in every single category lmao.
Rdr2 is just better in everything .there is no game will ever come close to rdr2 , its not a video game . *Its a pure art*
RDR2 fans are nostalgia blinded
@@Reu672dDe5ahuwhUwUindeed
Hey, Arthur and Uncle! You both just need to love Rdr2.
(joking aside, both of your accounts are Rdr2 fan accounts)
Why do you say "nostalgia blinded" in this case?
Let me remind you RDR2 is turning 5 years on Oct 26, 2023. Stunning game!
3:14 are you kidding?
I think we all know the only horse detail that matters here.
RDR 2 Best game of all time 💥❤
And here we are again with the good old theme music and exciting comparison xD
Para que superen a RDR2, pasaran unos 6 años más. Si bien disfruto de ambos juegos. Nada se le compara. Puso la balanza muy alta.
Lo unico capaz de superar a RDR2 es GTA VI de la misma Rockstar
@@HiddenBladesx2 Siendo sincero, solo RDR 3.
@@Daniel218lbni siquiera salió GTA ví , piensa un poco
Wtaf lol. Water physics “BETTER” in AC Mirage? We saw the same video right? It’s arbitrary model interaction. In RDR2, as you move the water reacts differently and dynamically. In ACM, the water ripples in a circle radiating out from you. That’s elementary water physics reacting to arbitrary object interference, not dynamic physics reacting to movement and mass. RDR2 definitely wins water. ACM does exactly what most other modern games are doing. With this method, the character makes the same ripples standing as any other object/model does and they make the same radiating ripples walking or swimming.
Of course it moves with the hand (object interference) and better work has done with RDR2. But did you observe the way ripples work? It's not working like it should work on water. like high density or heavily contaminated. So Mirage has the upper hand here even if it does not have that physical interference. But at the end it's the way we see. Can't disagree totally with you. Good point!
Comparing these two games like this isn't really fair imo. RDR2 had a much bigger team, bigger budget, and more development time than Mirage did, which makes sense because RDR2 is a much bigger game in general as well, being in development for eight whole years while Mirage was under 2 years. That said though, given that RDR2 is 5 years old now, it holds up very well.
Mirage was not even made by ubisoft montreal I'm not sure what part of ubisoft made Mirage but all I know is that part of ubisoft never hade a whole game they just helped
@@EXIOO_1bordeaux
Well I guess Ubisoft have to take more time and money in their hands then … u can’t excuse a worse game … if you wanna do a masterpiece (what imo devs should try doing) then you should be ready to do everything necessary to make it a masterpiece… clearly something Rockstar was ready to do an Ubisoft NEVER did…. and I don’t think they even could even with more time money bigger team etc they just don’t know how to do art anymore they just drop lifeless games who are all the same with little effort to make a bug
People always say stuff like this in any comment section related to games that RDR2 is being compared with. It's such a massive cope lol you're talking as if ubisoft is some kind of beggar that is lacking resources and budget to create a game but as a matter of fact ubisoft is already one of the biggest game companies there, you're lying to yourself by using that bs excuse that ubisoft has less budget/resources.
That's not true. Ubisoft has 20,000 employees while Rockstar doesn't even have a quarter of that. Ubisoft has different teams working on different games at the same time, so it's likely that this one took 3-5 years to develop and not 2 as you say.
Rockstar simply puts more effort and resources into making a single game, that's why RDR2 is superior technically to other games released today.
I like how Arthur has a really rough face but the AC guy has a smooth face even though they obviously both live harsh lifestyles. (good on Rockstar)
We wait for GTA 6 then and only then RDR2 will get the competition that actually has a chance
For those that didn't know, Basim was a champion swimmer at the Baghdad 865AD Olympic games.
I love both games
Haven't Been in your Channel Brother Need to catch up hehe Awesome Content Brother Thank you for uploading. IMO Both game is great in their own unique ways. Fire Upload❤🔥👍
Thank you so much bro! 😊❤️!
@@BlaZe92 Thank you Brother for uploading great content. ❤🔥
ubisoft is and always will be 10 years behind rockstar
Lol i didn't even think people would compare these two.
I actually did in my own time, i was watching people roll rugs and lay them down and the rolls were red but the ones she took out and laid down were yellow.
Rdr2 doesn't miss things like that
rdr2 is one of the best games ever no doubt but mirage is good too
Yes cuz Ubisoft only take 3 years to build it and its a good game unlike starfiled
@@vihangabimsara4716 Still extremely bad for a game thats the same price as RDR2, they should either spend more time making a better game or reduce their price, theres no excuse for them.
It’s nothing compared with rdr2, we talkin about one of the best games ever made … Ubisoft is unable to create such an art
@@thedj6921 Ac Mirage look 2 years to develop and rdr2 7 years
@@kaushikkv8423
well … I guess they should’ve been also doin 7 years then
Ubisoft has nailed water physics exceptionally well since far cry 3
You with engxma sound!!
Great😁
I think Ubisoft is the only gaming studio that can match or even exceed Rockstar's level of detail and polish. They build great landscapes and architecture but they need to give more time to certain games like the AC series, FarCry, and Watch Dogs. They need to focus more on quality rather than quantity.
Exceed really lol you're a half blind ubisoft fan bowii
Me, can't stand westerns or cowboys, brought RDR2 for the game engine, hoping someone would do a mod to remove the western theme from the game, for true OPEN WORLD, in hindsight it would have made more sense to not buy the game, and wait for a mod...that's never coming. RDR2 is a vast, diverse, and heavy on the details and story, wonderful game engine, beautifully implemented with a massive amount of content and immersion...just not for me.
Mirage, a tiny project in comparison, holds its own for what it is, with enough content and story for the AC junkie who needs his AC fix, grand exotic setting with a rich historic culture, im just starting to enjoy it.
Both are a welcome addition to their genre, but in terms of scale, complexity and depth RDR2 is the clear winner.
PS: Don't UBI have at least 4 Game Engines?.
@mihirvd01 Not a chance in the world
Their problem isn't even Quality, its a complete lack of passion and creativity, all their games are these corporate clones of each other (just like their employees :) )
@@nogeagor971
this man is completely right,
Ubisoft could NEVER reach rockstar not in a million years, they have good ideas wich have so much potential but they screw it up every time (literally the last time I was satisfied with an ubi game I was like 12) bcs like the man said they don’t have passion or creativity they just copy past their games with little effort as possible, rockstar is exactly the other way around those mfs are real artists… and I will always remember rdf2 till I die … I am not gonna remember vallah maybe just bcs it was so bad. ..
Who agrees that RDR2 is the greatest game of all time and that only RDR3 or GTA6 can defeat it's level of realism, charecter depth, story, cinematics, physics and plot.???
Enxgma vibes
The way the world also interacts with entities is another reason for red dead being better
Rdr 2 lighting is so awesome even without ray tracing
If RDR2 after 5 years still looks better than many new games (water in AC looks really good though), I wonder how GTA 6 will look like. I hope changes that happaned to Rockstar won't influence it too much and we will get a movie like game just like RDR 2.
Bruh rdr2 and ac have different character traits, one is a gun slinger and the other is a fucking assassin, you can’t say “unlike” rdr2 player can swim underwater in mirage. By that logic unlike Ac guns are available in rdr2 and unlike rdr2 character can jump and run on buildings
you can't compare any video game with red dead 🤦
Basim be riding a motor boat 😂 6:48
His chest looks off like if it's a block
RDR 2 is still graphically comparable with all latest open world games...
RDR2 won every single detail comparations till now
No
6:41 Surpasses? With the AC boat as fast as a motorboat that hardly has any effect on the water? You sure?
18 vs 23
Rdr2 still goated. I loss interest of games that used to be fun for me. Now I'm on a continuous loop of finishing RDR2. On my 16th run now. Not sure how many more times need until I can move on to other games. Hahaha
6:40. Sure, despite the fact that AC looks like is riding a Jet ski. Damn that speed!
after playing this dogshit, my respect for valhalla and odyssey is increased, I enjoy them way more than i ever did.
3:32 In Odyssey, the character touches the grass with his hand, it seems like a small thing, but great!
Every one praising rdr2 for being ahead of its time
*Meanwhile Assassin's creed Unity:...*
Games are starting to catch up, after 5 years
Red Dead Redemption 2 is the definitive of Purity in the Gaming World
And Assassin’s Creed Mirage is at the standards of what a regular game should be like, Graphically.
nice video blaze 2018 game vs 2023 game
Thank you bro! 😊❤️
Only thing i was dissapointed in RDR2 was that there was no “mirage” on top of fire/flames. I was thinking if they could do the sunlight through the ears then they could’ve done with the fire. But RDR2 is still king in all other aspects
Red dead redemption 2 was ahead of its time and remember it was made based on the ps4 if it was the ps5 it would be even more impressive
RDR2 is the definition of pushing the system to its limita
In defence of Mirage,
Mirage had like a bit over 1 year of production time
Rdr2 had over 8 years of production time
Mirage had pretty much 10x smaller Budget than rdr2.
Mirage had a smaller company make it with a staff size of roughly several hundred people.
Rdr2 was made by a massive company with the staff size of around 6000.
The fact mirage still (somewhat) can hold its own against rdr2 is mind boggling
Agreed, but that's the point right ? Instead of rushing the games release why not take your time and create a well polished game with compelling storyline ? The thing is Ubisoft lacks vision it tries to create several themes of one genre that has worked and that to unpolished and quick. And as far as budget is concerned why not create a smaller open world game but with compelling storyline and lots of details?
And the point? Mirages map is smaller than 45 km square while rdr 2 is 75-80 Km square. While half of the map feels empty rdr 2 map is filled with animals and towns. Mirage just reuses old animations while rdr2 has 300000+ animations. The realism in rdr2 I mean how your clothes affect your body? Your behaviour towards your horse? Arthers interactions affects the his personality and changing more interactions. While rdr 2 is made like completly new , Mirage is just a overated copy of its past.
Also when u whistle after running Arthur has difficulty.
If you ride too fast arthur barely manages to open eye. Like people do when wind is fast I forgot what it is called.
Also you can see bullets remaining in revolver barrels.
And many mire rdr2 is goat
1:07 woah, I didn't even know that was possible. How did they achieve that?
6:40, When he rows the boat, the boat is supposed to move slowly but looks like it's a speedboat compared to Arthur's rowing...
At horse you forgot a small detail to check for 🏀 🏀 segment
Kind of mind boggling a little, how Arthur face stands strong side by side with this 2023 next Gen game! 6:00
I don’t think Ubishit can do anything with AC franchise in their entire lifetime to outdo RDR2. They are simply not committed enough.