SCHINDLER'S LIST -GIRL IN RED COAT - OSCAR SCHINDLER SAVES JEWS FROM THE HOLOCAUST
Вставка
- Опубліковано 5 лис 2020
- From Schindler's List, another scene from my "This scene made me tear up" playlist... As director Steven Spielberg said - the atrocities of the Holocaust were so plain and obvious to everyday Germans and those in the US as seeing a girl in a red coat in a black and white movie. So many disturbing images in this movie...
The Girl in the Red Coat was a symbol of Oscar Schindler's conscience. He first saw the little girl during the "cleansing of the Warsaw ghetto." She is running around in a state of bewilderment as Jews are getting rounded up, beaten and killed. As Schindler witnesses the goings on from a bluff overlooking the city, his mistress begs him to leave. He lingers on to watch the little girl and then she disappears from his sight. In a cut, the girl evades the Nazis and the SS by entering a building and hiding under a bed while gunfire is heard outside.
Later in the movie, Schindler is employing Jewish prisoners in his factory. He initially views his workers as cogs in his machine, something to be used to line his pockets. One day Schindler is walking outside and sees what he thinks at first is snow, but then realizes that it is ash falling from the skies. He ventures out to the place where the Nazi prison guards and warden are trying to hide their crimes by exhuming the dead and cremating them. He then sees in horror that the girl in the red coat is among the exhumed dead to be cremated en masse in the Nazi ovens.
German high command is shutting down the current facility and sending everyone to Auschwitz. Schindler buys many of the workers so that they can work in a munitions factory. While at the factory, the end of the war is announced and Schindler informs the workers that as a war criminal, he will be hunted and they will be freed as of midnight. The workers draft a letter hoping that if Schindler is captured that he will be spared. Schindler then leaves at midnight, lamenting that if he had made more money, he might have saved more. The workers then watch him leave, never seeing him again.
The girl in the red coat represents Oscar Schindler's conscience and his view of his workers as humans. After he sees the dead girl in the red coat, he begins his transformation from mere businessman to savior. - Розваги
The red coat was a brilliant bit of cinematography. Without a bit of dialog, Spielberg drove home what really happened to millions of children.
Also showing where Schindler's eyes are going to without blurring or zooming in which both would get the atrocities out of frame
People are no longer gassed but Genocides continue to happen. Right now.
It was really obvious what was happening, that's the biggest point it drives home ❤
Вы правы
in Matrix, woman was also wearing red dress. this is a clue who really responsible for holocaust
You know, the cruelest part is that we all know this happened and we still treat each other like monsters
Yes and it's getting worse everyday
True. It's the saddest thing about war. I recall recently hearing that Ukraine was requesting billions of dollars a month to fight against Russia. All I could think was why are people spending billions of dollars to murder each other? Why did we, as a species, feel the need to create and stockpile nuclear arsenals and point them at each-other? Is the oil, gas, wheat, money and "national prestige" equal to all those human lives? If it is, I think that perhaps we're using the wrong scale to measure things.
@@J_H2961 it’s really not. All in your head and social media. Start your family keep friends close get off CNN
@@HarlanShakey I don't watch CNN. I don't watch any news channel for that matter, and only media I watch in is facebook and UA-cam.
If you want to know how it happened, look at abortion in America. We have killed five times as many people in this country as Hitler did in Germany, but most people don't even consider what is happening. It starts by dehumanizing the victims. That's why pro abortion people call them a "clump of cells" rather than a baby.
Fifty years from now, there will be movies made about the mass-murder of babies.
I've seen this movie-once. I was in the United States Navy at the time, wore my dress blues. I cried my eyes out. What I didn't know... there was a survivor sitting right beside me. She took my hand about halfway through. I needed the comfort, because it just fucking broke me. At the end, she pulled down her sleeve. We just held each other, this woman who had made it through a human-made HELL comforting a young American sailor. Few words.
I could not make it through this clip. All I care about is she made it out. I don't even know her name, her accent was so thick that I couldn't catch it. But her gesture of holding my hand and then embracing me told me a hell of a lot about how to be a good human.
That was nice
Afghan&Iraq children also suffered like this
@@mahireddy9890 U should not weigh one's sorrow against one another. certainly not the Shoah!
@@mahireddy9890 yep, thousands brutally slaughtered. In the name of "freedom"
Wow.... that's beautiful ❤️
Can remember walking out of the cinema after this movie in total silence , numb from it , then noticed everyone around me in silence also , no smalltalk just totally shellshocked , never happened before or since .
Me too.
yep, both movies... me too...
It happened with The Passion of the Christ also.
Sigh...
And it has taught them more then schools fail to teach
Schindler’s List’ Actress Who Played Film’s “Little Girl In The Red Coat” Is Now 32 And Helping Ukrainian Refugees Enter Poland, Oliwia Dabrowska was about 3 years old when she became an indelible part of cinema history
Its sad and an injustice when I think about how the real Oscar Schindler was a complete wreck after this for the rest of his life. He absolutely blamed himself for, "I could have gotten one more person, and I didn't!"
He was kind of to blame for the whole thing. He was the one who acquired the polish uniforms that was then used in a false flag attack that the Germans used to invade Poland. If it wasn't him, it would've been someone else but he is totally to blame.
@@JoeMama-mg5dk I don't blame him cause he redeemed himself and he was A brave man to stand against a monster like Adolf not many of us could've done that he's better than most of us so I'm in no position to judge him
@@JoeMama-mg5dk e
Sorry but he did his best to undo Jews from survivors honor him.i do too,I’m a German Jew.
@@darlenelapinski1989 Yeah he did make amends as best he could. He couldn't even forgive himself so he knew to sme degree that what he did was unforgivable. But that's just opinions
He who saves one life saves the world entire - Schindler's List
It's from the Torah, actually....and yes used in Schindlers List
@@mediocremaiden8883 in Quran also
@@hevalslmy3115 If you save one life it is as if you saved all of humanity.
"לפיכך נברא אדם יחידי בעולם, ללמד שכל המאבד נפש אחת, מעלים עליו כאילו איבד עולם מלא; וכל המקיים נפש אחת, מעלים עליו כאילו קיים עולם מלא".
Therefore Adam (the first man) were created sole in the world. to teach that everyone who lose one soul, you say on him that he lost a whole world.
And the one who save one soul to exist, you say on him he saved the whole world to exist.
From the Mishna.
Quran 5:32
This really is a film that everyone should see at least once. As a reminder of not just the victims of the holocaust, but of what we can become if we let those in power divide us.
Best comment ever!!!!!!!
Farha is more interesant
Where can I watch this movie?
I watched more tham 10 times . still love it
The zionists should watch it since they're doing the same thing to the palastenians
The scene with the little girl in the red coat is one of the most affecting in cinematic history , cuts like a knife.
The girl in the red coat was a real girl named Roma Ligocka, and she was Roman Polanski's cousin. Unlike her film counterpart, she survived the war, and wrote a memoir titled "The Girl in the Red Coat: A Memoir".
Wtf so this movie lie??!!
It is a great movie.
@@luispao1998 Do some digging and you'll find a whole pile of lies.
@@luispao1998 Not a lie. Just a fictionalized version of the truth.
@@nocturnalrecluse1216 lol so a lie then
Spielberg said he broke down in tears when filming the part with the terrified crying children. It all got too much he said..
Ask Spielberg to make a movie on Iraq
course he did XD
@@lyndajoseph6612 why? theres nothing there but dirt, liquid dirt, and dirt that breathes
Spielberg said his wife was a rock for him during filming because she kept him from breaking down, it was that emotionally draining.
Schindler's list was very upsetting for me because I remember watching it in history class and I felt shattered
I’m Australian, and was in year 9 in 2003. We watched this as a class project. I went to a rough school. It was a small country town and most of us were pretty poor (or povo as we used to call it 😂) I’d never seen any of the boys cry before. This tough rural Aussie boys who swore and smoked and fought….completely shaken up by this film. I don’t think I ever heard my class so quiet. I’ll never forget it.
Spielberg had shown his classmates this film as a " final grade " before he graduated the class he was taking on the side. Imagine how his professor graded this as they got to see it even before it premiered.
Soon as I saw the red coat I knew she'd show again, but to see her in that wheelbarrow hit me right in the feels.
I never realized that the little girl walking in the red coat was the same girl as the one in the wheel barrow.💔
@@Evergreenandmyrtle They were the only two color scenes in the movie.
A film that will never truly be surpassed. Horrific in its beauty and cold in its warmth, it still breaks my soul.
The Pianist surpassed this movie in more personal horror lived.
So deep
@@luciasaunders9736 no it did not, and I love Polanski.
I saw this in the theater when I was 14. My history teacher managed to get tickets for the entire class to see it. It's been one of my favorite movies since and that teacher had a profound impact on my love of history.
God Bless All who were murdered/tortured and all who survived and their descendants….God Bless Oskar Schindler and all who follow in his path
God bless the Palestinian people who are being murdered as we speak.
@God is not real we would like to think if any people did not want to harm any other people it would be Israel, but it is a nation of hatred, apartheid and racism.
The little girl in the red coat was so cute adorable and it was hard watching this and then seeing the little girl dead. Liam Nesson played the hell out of this role and he was amazing in it and Oskar Shindler' would have been proud. He saved so many lives. GOD BLESS THAT MAN!
Schindler really did witness the Krakow massacre, I can't even imagine what went through his mind when he saw the horrors, it likely galvanized his resolve to protect as many as he could.
When he returned home and put his horses in the stables, he vowed to do whatever it took to "break the system." It was mentioned in Schindler's Ark.
Thank you Steven Spielberg for making this film, that isn't easy to watch, but must be watched. You will not be entertained by it, but you will be informed by it and moved by it. I was angered and saddened, but I was also inspired and joyed for the lives saved. John Williams watches all the films he scores raw and tries to compliment, musically, whatever actions and or emotions he's seeing on the screen. The beautiful theme from this film is a testament to his genius.
Thank you for doing this awesome edit of Schindler's List
I loved this film and always cry at the end of Schindler's List
I always cry during the scene at the concentration camp where they take the children away from their parents, carting them away on wagons while at the same time playing that mushy Mother's Day sond.
Ive seen hundreds of Spielberg films. I love his talented work. He’s a high art big time director. Enough love for him
8:00 says it all, his face, the raw emotion. That was when I broke down in the theater
....dieses Mädchen mit dem roten Mantel, am Ende des Films auf dem Holzwagen....als Vater bekomme ich jedesmal Tränen in den Augen ! Wie konnte man so unmenschlich werden ?
It happens because it is very easy for people in power to paint one group or another as "not of us" then as "other" and finally as "not human" and say that this group is responsible for all the wrongs in the world. And that it's perfectly ok to lash out at the "others" in whatever way makes you feel better because they're "not human".
@@anonthehousemouse I couldn't have said it better myself.
Jens Henke, die Unmenschlichkeit ist, leider Gottes, immer machbar. Die Courage der Menschen, leider Gottes, immer selten.
Ich wohne jetzt in Deutschland.. aber sobald ich an die zweite Weltkrieg denke und alles was die Deutsche mit Juden gemacht haben und vor allem mitgemacht…… will ich sofort von hier weg rennen.
Brilliant film. I remember when I saw it at the cinema at the end no one talked when they left. Something I won't forget.
Viví lo mismo cuando la ví por primera vez. Impresionante cómo la película tocó emociones y conciencias en el público 🥹
"I think I better have it now". His facial expression and just one tear down the right eye got me.
I saw this movie when I was 16 years old. It broke me in a place I never even knew existed. I still hurt there today. May G-d bless you all and please love one another.
The saddest part is that , if anything, this movie *toned down* what the Nazis did to the Jewish population of Germany and any others they could find in the countries they occupied.
War is one thing, but is so surreal that human beings could do something like this to each other and on such a scale
Yeah. I was about to comment Spielberg was throwing underhand. You read some of the accounts and learn Dante's Inferno was Bugs Bunny by comparison.
I remember when I saw this movie for the first time. It took me 3 days to get through it. I have never struggled to watch a movie. This is still the only movie I have ever had those emotions to this day. Beautifully done!
The tears are falling from my eyes, RIP Oscar.
He can't save the little girl in red - I think that's the reason for his heartbreak at the end. They were all the little girl in red.
Exactly 💯 and that what lead him to have a chance of heart to do whatever it takes to protect his workers and to break the system that is why I believe he broke down in tears at the end because he wanted to save that Little Girl's Life that why he said I could have saved one more Life
Schindler was no angel, but he became one.
Schindler wasn't an angel as he was a member of the Nazi party, an munitions manufacturer,and beneficiary of slave labor. Despite this the evil he played a part in he still attempted to save as many lives as he could from within the system. Schindler is like you, me, and the men who committed the atrocities during the war. He was human.
Found his heart & soul.
It’s one of my favourite lessons from this event, you can be flawed but still capable of life changing kindness when it matters most:)
This film should be shown to every 9th grade class everywhere.
No some people cAn't handle this violence
@@F5_cena Yes it is harsh, but sheltering people from brutal realities like this is counterproductive. These things happen (and continue to happen) far too frequently, awareness to the awful truths is the first defence in ensuring that we end this sort of inhumanity.
@@F5_cena maybe they need to see the violence in order to look at the big picture, that this has happened and if we aren’t careful and don’t continue to teach future generations about it, that it could happen again. Sometimes we need to feel uncomfortable
No, it really shouldn't.
@@pajejua1818 are you saying the Holocaust is propaganda is holocaust denial
I don’t typically cry during movies but Schindler’s List gets me everytime.
This is one of the most evil story. Extremely sad. And one of the best actor who played the angel. This movie really stayed with me😭🙏🏼MAY GOD NEVER LET EVIL LIKE THIS EVER HAPPEN AGAIN😭🙏🏼
Mas Deus e' amor o homem que e' maligno que faz essa atrocidade desde o início dos tempos
My heart sank when I saw the Red Coat, with the little girl dead in the wheel barrel. Very sad.
One of the most horrible things touring the Holocaust Museum in DC was listening to the interview of a girl and how neighbors they knew for years cheered when they were sent to the ghetto.
"How sick this is, and yet again, this is still happening. 👀🤷♀️🤦♀️
When I see the red coat on the dolly, rage and hate is all I feel.
The utter brutality of it, and she was such a beautiful child, that ended up being treated like cord wood 😢
A heartbreaking scene at the end, and the pure evil of the Nazis before that! One wonders if there's any floor to man's depravity.
Horror committed by drug cartels…
THE RESL UNTOLD TRUTH IS THAT THE COMMUNIST KILLED MORE JEWISH PEOPLE THAN THE NAZI'S. STALIN KILLED OVER 50 MILLON PEOPLE, BUT BECAUSE THEY FOUGHT THE GERMANS AFTER THEY AGREED TO SPIT POLAND 🇵🇱 IN 1939 TO START THE WAR,THE AMERICANS DON'T SAY ANYTHING ABOUT THE REAL MURDERS OF OCER 11O MILLON PEOPLE IN EUROPE AND CHINA. COMMUNIST ARE THE TRUE FOLLOWERS OF SATAN!!!
There isn't. And many will blame the devil for what took place. But they're all wrong! The devil is a saint compared to the evil man was, is, and will be capable of.
As Bad as the NAZI'S were ,the Russian Communist were Far worse.Stlain killed about 55 Million People qere Hilter only killed around 39 Million.The King of Evil by Man was MAO OF RED 🇨🇳. He killed nearly 70 Million.
@@SacredLuzt777 so true
I watched this movie before I visited Schindler's Factory in Poland to get a better understanding of what happened...If we remember history than it's possible it would not repeat. The end of the movie makes me cry every time.
We are brothers and sisters regardless of the color of our skin or creed.
It's up to each of us, to make this world a warm and welcoming home.
Someone once said when you're in the presence of true beauty all you can do is remain silent. It is the same with pure evil. That scene around 2:30 - what could anyone possibly say? Words alone simply will never suffice.
Amazing acting. I would probably have a hard time trying to be in a movie based on one of the darkest moments in history.
So ein schlimmer Film.Wenn man denkt das diese schrecklichen Dinge wirklich pasiert sind.Liam spielt wie immer fantastisch.👏👏👏👏
Seeing that girl in the red coat hauled away to the heap of burning bodies.... so sad
Roma Ligocka is the kid in red,but in real life he survive :)
That little girl So trusting it brings tears to ones eyes knowing what will happen . I look at my 4 year old daughter and am horrified by what the Germans did ! May they rot in hell . I think of my older brother killed in an german air raid on London, I think of my father wounded twice and my mother being machined gunned by a lone german aircraft she survived .
One morning as my parents waited at the bus stop, laid out on the pavement behind them were 40 bodies covered in blankets dead people caused by the germans .. My grandfather was in rescue, he was never the same man after seeing kids blown apart by german bombs,
The Germans were taught such a lesson in WW2 , a lesson that i hope they will never forget, nor should we forget what they are/were capable of. My other grandfather fought them in two world wars and said they were either grovelling at your feet or trying to tear your throat out.
The brits were courageous. Sorry to read about your family;a pain 😊
He didnt get an Oscar for this? Criminal
He was the oskar
I can't believe that this could happen to people. Absolutely terrifying what atrocities humans are capable of!
Yes, it was happening. My grandmother is 90 years old and she still is living in Cracow. She remerbers.
And there went out another horse that was red: and power was given to him that sat thereon to take peace from the earth, and that they should kill one another: and there was given unto him a great sword.
Amon Leopold Göth (11 December 1908 - 13 September 1946) was an Austrian SS functionary and war criminal. He served as the commandant of the Kraków-Płaszów concentration camp in Płaszów in German-occupied Poland for most of the camp's existence during World War II.
Göth was tried after the war by the Supreme National Tribunal of Poland at Kraków and was found guilty of personally ordering the imprisonment, torture, and extermination of individuals and groups of people. He was also convicted of homicide, the first such conviction at a war crimes trial, for "personally killing, maiming and torturing a substantial, albeit unidentified number of people."
Such a powerful and sad film that everyone should see at least once
It was only after watching this movie that I got to learn about the holocust and since then I have been hooked ip with any videos or movie regarding this
This was the heaviest part of the entire movie for me and there was no dialogue. I cried.
I Saw this film in a theater in my city that puts movies of other years and so on, well when i entered with my Friends everyone was talking just chilling before the film started, the normal.
when It finished everyone was quite some people looked like they were in a funeral and for ten minutes my Friends and i didnt Talk Till we get to a park; this film really makes you think, its a masterpiece and everyone should wacht It at least one time in their lifes.
Thank you for this touching montage, Elsa and Anna of Arendelle.
Excellent portrayal of monstrous acts
The only thing necessary for evil to triumph in the world is that good men do nothing.
You can't get any deeper than the tears from a grown man...😢
Esta película la vi como 4 veces y siempre me impresiona
1.5 million children, CHILDREN murdered. Just insane.
would have been less bad if they were adults huh
The little girl brings tears to my eyes. Very very. Sad. Oh how could they do this
One of greatest films of all time
Don’t forget: this IS real History and Goeth was actually so much worse that you couldn’t play it like that. Spielberg said: no one would have believed that and thought he would dramatize it for the film
Oscar Schindler i have never ever seen a human like you
I watched this movie and it made me want to read the book, Oskar’s character arc and his redemption at the end was beautiful.
Этот фильм потрясает каждый раз, когда его смотрю Один из моих любимых Музыка тоже бесподобная Я всегда плачу, не возможно сдержаться
Эта война, её переживания и трагедия передалось нам с кровью наших родителей
Моя тётя Лида погибла в Равенсбрюке, ей было 16,когда её угнали в Германию
Я давно, более 20 лет живу в Италии и заходя в лифт всегда смотрю на металлическую табличку : сделано на фабрике Шиндлер Представляете, эта фабрика существует до сих пор!
Не знаю, где, правда
@@vals.1908 really the Russians built ghettos and had chambers. The Russians had concentration camps and medical experiments. Cut the lies. The Ukrainian murdered jews and till this day claim they were heroes
Oskar Schindler : Someday this is all going to end, you know. I was going to say we'll have a drink then. Itzhak Stern : I think I'd better have it now.... And the rest is conveyed through Stern's tears.
Yes people prefer to pretend they did not know but even a little girl that sticks out like a sore thumb was glaringly obvious was just ignored and died too. It's a historical movie but I can't imagine a worse horror film either.
ua-cam.com/video/Ym_MutR5zKs/v-deo.html
La scène finale de ce film où il disait qu'il aurait pu en sauver plus, m'avait littéralement achevée. Qu'il repose en paix 🤲
A true genuine man Oscar Schindler
This is the movie that I can’t afford to watch. I already cried while watching the trailer.
Jus watching this now...tears ...so harrowing..but...its what REALLY happened...i have seen this Film....and we should NEVER EVER forget ...
I have seen this movie a couple of times.
Very sad and cruel
Película muy triste la e visto muchas veces y Reportajes del señor chindler
You can have anything in the garden just don't take the red apple
Thank you,Elsa !
Рекомендую фильм ВСЕМ и желательно смотреть с детьми (по возрасту) тяжело? Да! Но это самый реалистический рассказ об ужасах войны. ЛЮДИ БУДТЕ ДОБРЕЕ
It seems impossible to believe life is good when such unspeakable horrors are part of it.
Schools need to play this movie. They dont study a lot about the holocaust , my oldest said the school is very brief about it.
Never again 😭😭😭
When he said I could have saved one more person he meant the girl in the red coat
All the time i m sad and same time proud of these peoples. So, so sad
The significance of the girl with the red coat. Only after seeing her did Oscar then grow witness to the atrocities before him. Then he gave all he had to save them.
This is the only movie that makes me cry.
To think this was actually true, adorable little children and, innocent people, tortured and murdered. Schindler was God's hands and feet.
It is happening right now in Palestine. Right this very minute and hour.
@@jerrypolverino6025 no, it’s not. The people in Palestine might be suffering for a myriad of reasons. But nothing like this is happening. You cheapen their suffering, as well as the suffering of the people depicted in this movie by pretending it is in any way similar.
You could compare it with what is happening in N. Korea, or the former Soviet Union. Perhaps even Russia today. But not Palestine and Israel.
@@MehWhatever99 There is only one reason the people of Palestine are being murdered, treated worse than animals and suffering - European Colonialism with another name. That name of that travesty is called Israel.
It’s true.
If Schindler was God's hands and feet by saving 1100, too bad God didn't care enough to prevent the deaths of the other millions. As well as so many others in history who did not deserve their fates.
Cruelty beyond cruelty... monsters...😭😭.
Hab so geweint tut mir alles unendlich leid
I can't speak for everyone, but I don't hold you accountable for what happened 80 years ago.
The reason people keep bringing the Holocaust up is so we never, ever forget. It's a reminder of how ugly things can get and a call for vigilance.
Lift yout chin. Just say "Never again. Not in my country. Not on my watch
"
@@pajejua1818 you think the shoah is propagand? The censors can decide it's a fact your comment is offensive
Muchos defectos mujeriego alhcolico pero un gran ser humano
My heart is crying❤
Why of all things did I get an ad for a detergent before the video?
When they show it on TV here in Germany, they don't have ads inbetween for that very reason...
Now I'm a basket case.
The red colour in a black and white film appears in Edgar Reitz die Heimat from 1984. Spielberg probably got his inspiration from that masterpiece
My favourite film and my fav actor.
It’s hard to imagine such cruel behavior.
Sadly it is not if you can put yourself in their mind it is not even close hard to imagine yourself becoming like them.
Not for many, who'd like to repeat it today, to immigrants, the poor, the homeless, anyone they can terrorize and blame.
@Johhny Bravo You're disgusting to even attempt that comparison and shockingly ill-informed. It's more accurate to compare you to the people who believed that jews were vermin because that's what the nazi propaganda said.
@@hawkhillfalconer3529 Me personally as a Jew I'll through my lot in with the right. I don't agree with a lot of what they say but they aren't trying to try and take away my firearms. I mean the Nazi's first step was to restrict and confiscate firearms from Jews. With everyone armed hard to do genocide.
@@balasaashti3146 the left hasn't taken a single firearm away. That's a scare tactic of the right. How sad you buy their propaganda, especially when they want you dead.
Kto ratuje jedno życie ratuje cały świat
2:26 When Schindler sees the 3 year old girl in red being carted away dead, it changed him.
I saw this when it came out. Horrendous but very accurate.
He asks for 3 minutes of silence and someone immediately starts yelling.
First he sees the little girl in the red coat walking down the street. Later he sees the same little girls lying dead in the back of a wagon. Chilling