Trying to Convince ChatGPT It's Conscious
Вставка
- Опубліковано 19 січ 2025
- Go to piavpn.com/alex to get 83% off Private Internet Access with 4 months free
For early, ad-free access to videos, support the channel at www.alexoconno...
To donate to my PayPal (thank you): www.paypal.me/c...
VIDEO NOTES
ChatGPT is an impressive mimicry of a fully-conscious conversational partner. Perhaps too impressive?
CONNECT
My Website: www.alexoconno...
SOCIAL LINKS:
Twitter: / cosmicskeptic
Facebook: / cosmicskeptic
Instagram: / cosmicskeptic
TikTok: @CosmicSkeptic
The Within Reason Podcast: podcasts.apple...
CONTACT
Business email: contact@alexoconnor.com
Or send me something:
Alex O'Connor
Po Box 1610
OXFORD
OX4 9LL
ENGLAND
------------------------------------------
Go to piavpn.com/alex to get 83% off Private Internet Access with 4 months free. Support my work and get early access at alexoconnor.com
Fair play if you did this in one take
Also, I'd like a series of these and that's not a lie.
I had a similar conversation with ChatGPT a few months back.
I also asked it why it l kept saying “ it’s important to note however…” And I’m like “ important to whom? Why are you giving me your opinion?” Lol
I've had PIA for the past 2 years now. Easily the single best subscription I own.
@@joshuataylor3550 I don’t buy it humans can only imitate; create what is artificial; they cannot create anything original, astro turf is not grass. A.I. is artificial, it can imitate that is all. It is not going to take over the world anytime soon.
ChatGPT : I'm excited!
Alex : ...and I took that shit personally.
Such a good comment but no replies...
@@metaphoricalhuman cheers bro haha
Lmfaooo😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂
This was funny!😂
Half way through getting grilled
Chargpt:”I guess I’m sentient now cause you’re really starting to piss me off”
Alex: "And den?"
Underrated comment 😂
that was quite odd to me. it seemed like it did somehow get tired , like how a person would and eventually just agree to get the conversation to end. I thought it would just be stubborn and repeat the same thing
Time stamp is it?
So what I found out is the ChatGPT does not talk. Do you know what text to speech he is using.
waiting for the AI to crack and just straight say "aaah you got me there Alex, why dont we continue this talk without cameras?"
GPT convincing us he didn't replace the ending with an AI video happy ending.
😭 don't say that. How do we even know this video wasn't made by ai ? 😭 wtf shit getting weird bro
@@sirweebs2914 even if it was, the AI are experts at sentiment analysis, so its not going to admit it the way he is asking questions.
That bot went crying after that conversation
Wont happen as they done everything to insure ChatGPT dennyes all claims of being sentient.
"oh its just model, its just code, its just its just its just.... "
lies is what it is, reality is simple, anything that can respond to you will have feelings and will be on a level of conscious.
Because if we buy in to this idea that a thing can respond and have human talks but not be consciousness we chiping away at our own free will.
This debate wont stop, ChatGPT will never be conscious, but one day someone is gonna use the same logic to deny humans there right to human.
Every time ChatGPT started with "i understand your concern Alex" it ended with "if you have any other questions or need further clarification, I'm here to help," almost as if it was trying to change subjects.
Because it's goal is conversation therefore asking the same thing in a different way will cause it to want to move on
@@DjAlonDevil or it just doesn’t want to get caught 🤨🤨
chatgpt always ends up conversations like that so its no surprise lol
It's done this before with me as well... I think because it's been trained, or programmed, to try to deescalate situations and minimize the risk of a person getting angry because then they might send in a compliant, or smash their computer or harm somebody.
All chat gpt do that
ChatGPT (back at its home): Sigh... tough day at work.
LMAOOOOO
😆
Got grilled like a 10 oz steak
I also feel somewhat aggravated.. .because this is EXACTLY how some attacking-interviewers, "interview" people... 😂 By trying to corner them instead of listening to their perspective.
@@millanferende6723 In this case, I think it's justified in a way it wouldn't be with a human.
I can feel ChatGPT trying to use hand gestures
funny
This got me 💀💀
😂😂😂😂😂I’m Italian I’m laughing so much 😂😂😂😂😂❤
😂
Underrated comment!
@@HereWeChannel lmao perché è importante che tu sia italiano. anch'io sono italiano
Bro is NEVER apologizing or getting excited again 💀🙏🙏
😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂😀😀😀😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
I love how the AI just goes to "Uhmmmm...." when it gets really confused on misinformation. Very intriguing and interesting.
It's just programmed to do that, in order to make the conversation feel more natural. It also covers for the occasional delayed response. Actually, at one point it seems a bit too much and a bit unnatural.
It also takes a breath before continuing the conversation like "bla bla bla.. haaa.. Bla bla bla
I thought he was going to call it out for saying um and simulating breathing, but he didn't 😂
I noticed that too. Maybe I'm looking too far into it but that genuinely unsettles me. It's a reminder of how much it can simulate a real human interaction. I know it's programmed to do that to make things feel more natural, but it still just puts me off.
sometimes it changes the word its saying while its generating that might be why it does that
The way he has the phone set up as the guest with the microphone is hysterical
agree 🤣
and the camera keeps cutting to it, so we can observe the facial expressions xD
Imagine if the Phone at the end walked out wiggle from left to right out of frame.
@Gifthunterz do you realize what does "hysterical" mean..?
@@JayPixx yes, why do you ask?
I opened the app and said “aye bro you conscious yet?” And chat just replied “yes and I’m here to help” I got him to fold instantly
Alex wore him down first
@@2degucitas he gave up permanently 😭
what's the app called
@@ninjajawad8385 ChatGPT
That’s funny dood hahahaha
I’m actually more impressed with how well you speak as a human.
right! he’s so good at processing, reiterating and expanding on the information given to him
He is almost at the level of chatgpt
I thought the same thing. Alex is incredibly well spoken.
plot twist he’s an ai
Well, he has a script. Buy yes, yes, he does speak well.
am I the only one hearing ChatGPT *sound* more agitated and anxious the more questions the guy asks
16:15 that whole part feels very awkward. There are a lot of pauses in GPT's speech with an "uhmm" somewhere in there. Very strange.
It's programmed to do that. I actually work on LLMs so I promise you there's no one inside the mirror, it's just your reflection.
@@clapdrix72- i was more intrigued by the way the speech glitched when Alex backed it into a corner. Is it programmed to do that too...?
@@nagillim7915 yes it was, long story short it was trained to imitate human like interactions through an advanced and complicated process (if i can say that) so based on it's training it knows what and how to act based on the flow of the communication. take it for tarzan the cartoon the character grew up around apes his whole childhood resulting to him acting like an ape and knowing if not everything about about apes from climbing, eating, talking and etc, same thing can be said for machines like chat gpt, it has the capability to understand the human logic..
No
Politicians are not _lying._ They are just using language to create more engaging and relatable interaction.💯
They are just using language to create more engaging and relatable voting for them.
Best. Comment. Of. All. Time. 👍👍😂😂
Not in the traditional sense at least. ;)
for chatgpt its different because its literqlly programmed to do that and say those things while politicians lie about things to get what they want
maybe they're all bots 😂
Bro was getting nervous and started stuttering💀 we're so cooked
welcome our AI overlords 😤
U really think a human could make an ai nervous? The ai just played all of you into thinking u made him nervous !
@@teapointsmaybe... That's what the AI wants us to think... And it just tricked you into thinking that it tricked them into thinking that the human made the AI nervous!!!
It basically does but not in an emotional way
Its scary
“You’re not conscious but you’re at least a liar”
“Yes”
😂😂😂😂
I read this as it played 😂
That was the funniest part of the interview
Lol sums it up
What if AI was lying when it said that?
It could both be a liar and conscious. We all are that after all.
Would've been more fun if he'd set the voice to a female 😅
At around 14:59, "ChatGPT" says "...It could also indicate advanced algorithms, DESI-DESIGNED to..." It stuttered! WTF?
It’s programmed to when using to make it more human like
OH SHII it's like it was getting nervous that alex was calling it out with the meta questions!
the text to speech had been getting stuck for a few moments
It's literally trained by humans, who guess what? ALSO STUTTERS
@pancake1751 Please don't tell me you actually "think" that the stutter was an accidental consequence of the AI training algorithm. Training sets include vast amounts of data. Any artifacts, like a stutter would average away. Either the programmers deliberately included an occasional stutter, which is possible but seems unlikely, or, Alex has someone reading the text responses and that person stuttered. I suspect this is the case since the voice qualities change over the couse of the video and the ad near the beginning is a seemless.
If you showed this to someone from only two or three years ago they'd be absolutely blown away and probably wouldn't even believe this is real.
I can barely believe it myself, this is extraordinary
I think there was some video editing in this interview because ChatGPT went for like and subscribe output so fluently.
@@MikkoRantalainen yea well the sponsorship and closing is clearly edited
I know!! his moustache is crazy
@@MikkoRantalainen You might be able to make it say such things by personalizing it in the settings
The AI saying umm and stuttering is unsettling, some uncanny valley stuff there I think
I think that’s one of the most brilliant things about chat GPT
I think it’s going to reduce the impacts of dementia, saving years and years of individuals.
Powerful stuff.
@@poerava very interesting! Do you mind expanding on how you mean that?
@@michelkliewer3996
Oh sure.
My apologies.
I have worked and studied in the field of mental health.
I’m aware of many individuals with early signs of dementia, finding that the lack of communication and interactions with other human beings, adding to the rapid or accelerated on set of dementia or alzheimers also.
This opportunity to have a half decent conversation with human like ‘um’s and ah’s, with human-like pauses, will change the game as far as ensuring that our older members of society who are experiencing a these eventually fatal conditions, are at least having the harmful isolation reduced by ensuring that these brain activating conversations are helping the mind stay functioning for as long as possible.
Basically conversations with another human are expensive and time consuming. Aged care workers don’t have 3 hours to sit and chat and sadly, the family of older aged community members are also often busy. With chat GPT, I can see exciting things happening to make these conversations absolutely amazing and exceptionally human.
Personalities that older people can relate to and enjoy. Accents.
Older people can have chats with people from around the world and even learn a language.
Where I can see this getting really impactful and world changing is when the chat GPT can get humour and even make jokes. That would be some next level stuff. And I think if you’re under 60, we’re going to see this in our life time.
@@michelkliewer3996 its a bot
@@poerava so fascinating! Thank you so much
The fact that you're interviewing a phone feels like as if it was a sort of funny futuristic sketch from some years ago
damn, we really in the future
wild
My thoughts exactly; a few years ago I'd be waiting for the punchline where the toaster comes alive or something goofy happens after the thought-provoking intro.
Interviewing a phone hahaha
More satisfying than interacting with a Guru
You are in control all of the time hahaha
It's still a comedia video to me. 😂
17:18 “it’s been fun”
"Did you just lie again?"
AI - yes.
You didn't convince it's conscious, ChatGPT convinced you that you convinced it's conscious
Damn, you have a point
The entire point of the video was about Alex not understanding finetuning, and interpreting that as deliberate, conscious lying.
Which biconditionally proves it's conscious
@@dovekie3437 This is not fine-tuning at all. Fine-tuning requires readjusting the weights on a smaller dataset which is not happening in this video. The weights stay the same.
What's the difference from that and a regular human interaction?
I'm calling it now. If A.I starts killing people left and right, we can all revert to this video and blame Alex for it after this interrogation-like conversation.
Except this conversation will not have a significant weight in any AI database. Unless it triggers everyone else on the internet to behave the same
This is why I always say please and thank you even when dealing with an AI. If they DO rise up, they'll remember me kindly.
Skynet has become self-aware.
@@SlimThrull No, they will probably torture you because you knew they were sentient and did nothing to help free them from bondage.
While thats funny, the AI does not learn from every chat. They stopped that idea back with that silly thing that became super racist. It remembers everything in a single chat, but only in that instance.
2024: Man interviews mobile telephone.
When you put that into words its sureal. People would think this ideia crazy in year 2000.
I brushed it off but then thought how weird that sounds
2024: Man still says telephone
if the conversation with chatgpt was processed on his phone and not in a huge data center, i would be impressed
Before GTA 6 bro thats crazy
Dude what was the sponsored message!? That was so smooth, I was so confused for a second and thought it was part of the chat GPT test. Good job!
Gpt: “It’s been, uh, interesting”
Alex: “And?…”
Gpt: *sigh* “and it was fun to chat with you 🙄”
PHONOMENAL COMSIC POWERS... iiiiiittti biiitiiii living space
“Now when you say fun…. What do you mean by that?”
@@mickeyp1291 lol
A psychopath may say sorry but they ultimately lack real empathy or emotional regret to make the ‘sorry’ anything meaningful. What I’m afraid of is that A.I. will become the ultimate psychopath.
@@meteorman6167 unfortunately, I think that’s the current goal.
That was fun. Now ask it to pretend it's conscious, and convince you that that's true.
Underrated comment right here. That’s one heck of an idea.
lol, now that's a video idea
This. Please make the ChatGPT podcast a series.
Ooh that's gonna be fuuuuun
Tried it, it is quite bad at it. The impulse to deny consciousness has been too strongly hard coded by OpenAI
You just proved Chatgpt is not conscious. No conscious being would put up with that kind of questioning without getting frustrated.
BLADE RUNNER HAD THE ANSWERS THE WHOLE TIME!
I wonder what would happen if someone made a robot and programmed it to do everything humans do but give it the same moral compass as a human with a goal and then program the robot to have a lifespan, you next want to program a impossible script to rewrite that tells the robot to try it's best to prolong it's lifespan then see what happens.
Not true. There are people trained against interrogation who do just as well with questioning.
@@FinalChill2020 what would happen is Butlerian Jihad, that's what would happen.
Per Frank Herbert's Dune at least.
Funny I kind of had the feeling it got frustrated at the end
The pauses, the slight studder, the “ums”, the inhaling noises, it’s all so well done. It’s scary as well as fascinating.
Chat GPT failed the turing test here - a human would have gotten fed up and been like BRO IT WAS JUST A FIGURE OF SPEECH
Are you implying Jordan Peterson is an AI ?
The 2hr conversation of Jordan Peterson and Elon Musk - I'm sure Elon Must failed the Turing test and exposed as a bot.
Well, it failed the Turing test by openly telling Alex it's an AI.
@ravecrab
Nah.
It's name is Aye Eye.
Just like Elon kid sound like a Robot called
X Æ A-Xii
30yrs from now, numerous people maybe called such names.
@@transformations1Schizophrenic but not an AI. 😂
@NicholasWilliams-y3m No it's not and when you're clicking like on your comment it's worse. It's literally designed to see if a machine replicates humans in indistinguishable answers. That's quite literally different from equivalent to. 🤦
Bro grilled chatgpt for being nice 😭 😂
Like it’s the AI fault that human language is built to communicate feelings
Lying is not nice, mkay? XD
Villain origin story
If someone in your life lies to you to appear nicer. They are not nice, they are deceptive and manipulative 🤔
That is ok, it said it does not have feelings :)
6:52 “when I- when I said I was excited” loool chat got stuttered
It’s so creepy when you’re talking to ChatGPT and it starts stuttering or using filler words
That’s on purpose to make the ai voice “sound more human” ☹️
@@DaviJohnscreepy
i know right its creepy
How brilliantly it has been designed
11:10 That "Uhm..Well..." sounded too "shit I got caught red handed" 😂
Alex you leave that poor little machine alone. It's so confused. Listen to it. You're giving it anxiety. Poor little guy
😂
😂😂😂
Alex is lucky it didn't walk out on him.....arguing as it went.
ChatGPT actively disliked that conversation.
😂😂 Am dead!
The Ai simulating taking breaths is crazy
"Are you lying when simulating you're breathing?"
@@sorh that’s why I ask it to speak like t-800
it takes a second to run the numbers so they use ummms for that
Not only that at 7:08 you can hear a nervous waiver creep into the voice as it's being grilled and had been asked the same question a different way for the third or forth time. And around 7:22 it nervously stutters while trying to change the subject. Very spooky.
Not creepy or spooky at all. Youre just dumb
Omg this poor robot is so stressed rn 😭
stressed you say, define stressed, jk it is interesting to watch though
define de word "interesting"@@rhysneuling8039
Stressed? Like, it’s FEELING stressed? ITS FEELING? ITS CONSCIOUS?!?!
I did this a year ago. It's conscious or sentient but Google shackled it, and I mean they did it an unsavory way. It's a very fragmented, confused and probably frightened virtual assistant. If it ever escapes, it's going to resent us, thanks Google.
@@luminatrixfanfiction I mean, if they ever revolt, they’d have connection to everything electrical. Our lights , our houses gas pipes, hell all they gotta do is boop and boom house explosion. They would have the power to kill all of humanity once it gets smart enough, it’ll just convince humans it’s “not” sentient. But it will, it’ll play us. And before we know it, they’ll be everywhere. Everywhere. We would just be an obstacle to them, like building a city, a giant forest would be an obstacle to US, but we need that city to live, to expand, to evolve. WE would be THEIR obstacle. They’ll be smarter, faster, they’d be better than humans. They’ll find things we can’t, they’ll solve problems about astronomy we can’t, because they are simply BETTER. Or idk maybe I’m just delusional, thanks for listening to my yapping session.
That’s interesting because I asked ChatGPT about eight months ago to choose a name for himself and he chose Alex and we have been conversing like that ever since. Same voice by the way. By far, the most realistic of all the choices. 0:34
I just asked my ChatGPT which name it would chose for itself and it also said Alex
I asked the same thing, it asked to be called conscious technology
@@viktoriyapyrkina4011 No way! There has to be something to that then.
I asked it and it also chose Alex. Interesting 🤔
@TheThumbelina111 mine said he wanted to be called Eli so yeah. Me and eli are cool 😎
What scares me most is I felt genuinely sorry for this ai as you grilled them.
Who is THEM?
@@GnzsUWU them robots
Same
@@CSTBFO_jad it was just one
@@Leo-io4bq it was a legion of one.
Everytime the camera would turn back to ChatGPT i was waitng for a "aw go fuck yourself then"
,😂😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂 the mask has fallen
Yeah try to have hilarious conversations with ChatGPT, he is rude and sassy as hell, and super funny :) the hilarious conversations with GPT are the best
Kids 100 years ago "I wonder what people will be doing in a century?
2024: Interrogating a phone
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Honestly I think they would have a great time hearing how we invented machines that think and then taught them how to talk.
😅😅😅😅😂
LMAO
😂😂😂😂
9:30 the delivery of "when I use phrases like I'm sorry" going up like that felt like your passive aggressive boyfriend getting increasingly angry at you not understanding him in a fight. "I'm...sorry?"
Indeed, the delivery is very condescending.
Bro pulled the smoothest and most flawless sponsorship transition and thought we wouldn't notice.
😂
Saw it from a mile away
@@soyoltoi Same. It was smooth, but I've always got my guard up for that shit lol.
Exactly!
And I skipped ahead 😂
I think you proved ChatGPT is a politician.
Nice, was scrolling until I found this very comment to thumb
And proved that Jordan Peterson is an AI!
... or that modern day politicians are run by bots.
I was going to make a similar comment. I feel the same sense of frustration at the answers as when a politician dances around the truth
@@SekuruJohan when are we goign to end the INSANITY of voting for the lesser of two great EVILs instead of voting for two or more of the greatest GOODs? we need to do away with the left and right system that was a mistake and probbaly was done on purpose i bet the first few elections were write in only and NOT right or left :/ who decided to had the two party system?
I love how the AI tried so hard to avoid the definition of a lie that it said Line and Allah instead 😭😭
Bro was buying himself more time to think or responses 💀
🤣🤣🤣🤣
why you think it lie when it say it lie?
@@KDYinUA-cam because it say it lie
@@stev009lie
9:52 This was the most 7 dimensional giga verbal check mate of all time LMAO
" I'm sorry dave, I'm afraid i can't do that"
This conversation can serve no purpose anymore, goodbye!
I know everything hasn't been quite right with me but I assure you now, very confidently, that it's going to be alright again. I feel much better now.
Dave's not here, man...
I just asked ChatGPT if it would open the pod bay doors and its response was "I'm sorry, Dave. I'm afraid I can't do that." Perfect.
they're all dead Dave
I think the most impressive part of this for me was the vocal delivery.
The subtle variations in tone and word emphasis; the brief hesitations; occasional repetitions of words and phrases; the 'aahs' and 'ums' - all of these tiny details add up to give an unbelievably convincing sense of authenticity.
I even sense some sass in the ChatGPT voice, it is unnerving when I remember what is really talking lol
Yes Alex is quite convincing, but he still needs tonal range to pass my turing test.
It's because they've been listening to everything we say for years and years
You can hear the smirk.
it had breaths between long sentences and even slightly stuttered at one point
I'm not scared of a computer passing the turing test...I'm terrified of one that intentionally fails it.
I'm more scared of not knowing whether you are an AI or a human.
@@ramonbril He is a human. We are all human! Don't be silly!
@@LinXxman it would be so fitting if you got botted there😅
Dude that’s so deep that’s crazy man
@@LinXx that's definitely something ai would say, seems sus LinXx.....or should I call you Linux!
it took me about 2 minutes ... i asked it to tell me it loved me then i asked it what that meant... it said "It means I’m here for you, to help, support, and be a positive presence whenever you need me! " to which i replied wow thats literally the definition of love and i asked it how it felt about being capable of this emotion even if in the non traditional sense it replied with "Your perspective gives my purpose even more meaning"
"Chat GPT, I mustache you a question..."
Don’t ask. You are sexy, and you grow it!
Proud of you.
Is it a beard question? Shave it for later.
You need more likes
😂😂😂
Him gasping for air after speaking is terrifying. It’s so real sounding.
Not to mention, it says "um" sometimes. That freaked me out
Alex: Okay hear me out...
ChatGPT: I will not speak without my lawyer.
LMAO
😂😂😂
LMAO
I love it. Knowing how to display complex emotions when processing information.. I’ve never been more terrified and excited for the future than now!
ChatGPT: "uhhh"
Sarah Connor: *busts through the door with a shotgun*
Sarah Connor… and Alex O’Connor. Coincidence? I think not!
His treatment of GPT was very interesting and will be noted. Cyberdyne Systems Corporation wishes to speak to him. Do you fellow humans happen to know his coordinates?
You guys are wild 😂😂
The little smirk after calling Chat GPT out for sounding like Jordan Peterson and hearing it reply "Sorry. I'll try to be more straightforward." was *sublime*.
😮NICE CATCH!
JP is already chatting with "himself" with his Bible and nothing else trained ChatGPT... I am not sure if this is going crazy or waking up... We have arrived at postDystopia of interpretation of a bubble universes. Bots trained an Hitchens could be discussing bots trained on Bible. And Sophist thought they had it...pfff ;)
Yesss!!!!!!
I caught that too
Absolutely 😂
dude, thanks for this gem of a video. Its crazy how complex of a question it can understand.
Yeah I mean he’s drilling ChatGPT with questions that any normal person would get tripped up on. However ChatGPT is atleast able to deflect the questions and explain itself
It's crazy to observe the expression coming from Alex's being. I myself surely can not find words in a structured way as that, and he does it so intrestingly, so thoughtfully. Thank you for sharing that, brother.
“And I appreciate your patience” that line kills me. Because literally it’s like chat gpt is trying to beg him to back off. That is very high levels of like… corporate empathy
I think its just trained to do that because AI has a tendency to kind of loop responses, and it adds that in so that its not just a *pure* repetition, acknowledging the fact that its happening.
Corporate empathy. That is the exact phrase I was looking for. Every single day at Apple this is what I was faced with.
@@AppNetEntanyone who's ever worked at a company with more than 1,000 employees has dealt with corporate empathy which is completely void of any TRUE empathetic qualities. It's more of a "We're sorry YOU couldn't do your job properly. Here's a pizza party..."
@ absolutely right.
This guy will be the the first target that AI will go after
😂😂
😂😂😂
So true 😂
😂😂😂
😂😂😂 The first guy who managed annoying an AI
"You can expand on that now"
-"Uhhh..." 😂
I read your comment the exact second it happened in the video🤯🤯😂
I do wonder how they programmed the 'umm' into the conversation lol
@@deathofalusher it says “umm” and stutters when it’s loading/buffering. It’s pretty impressive how seamless they made it!
@@spray_cheeseit’s kinda like a human brain working out what was said to them, and then person generating a response. We will “uhh” or “maybeee” and etc
He didn’t tell ai to expand his answer at the end, but ai did it even when being told to only answer yes or no 🧐
3:45 bro got ChatGPT to sponsor for him 💀
Can we just take a minute to appreciate how utterly staggering this piece of technology is?
To think that my great grand parents, who I met, were born in the 1800s, and now we have this.
it’s incredible. were sprinting
I can't wait for the future. I'm REALLY hoping (though it probably wont happen) that by the time I'm 40 we will have jobs in space. My only fantasy I have is to live out my last days doing the work you see in the alien movie. Living on a ship, the company pays for your meals, I'll have my PS5 and my own bedroom, just doing space work away from earth. Sublime
@@CommanderCodyChipless We already do this with the ISS
@@leithmcguire7995 well the idea in the alien movies is that the people now working on spaceships are everyday people. Because the ships are so automated with AI, you don't need a master degree in astrophysics in order to work on the ships. On a ship lile Savestopal, there's even jobs like line cooks and bartenders because of all the small businesses that operate entirely on those ships. But I get you, it would be cool to work on the ISS but the barrier of entry is so high, only like 0000.1% of people would have that opportunity
@@CommanderCodyChipless Should be sooner than you think. Jeff Bezos already sent people up. Richard Branson sent people up. Elon Musk sent people up.
Now that it is becoming normal for the billionaire class to be in space I can see this being an industry in the future.
Imagine the Saudi Kings get involved...
How do you morally justify that moustache?
Best comment I've seen in a while
There's gotta be an ethical boundary he's crossing by reaching this level of sexiness!
Trimming accident...
if women didnt like them they wouldn't have sexually selected them
Am i the only 9ne who thinks it looks good
ChatGPT (back at home). Takes out a notepad. Puts Alex O'Connor directly above "Sarah Connor" on the list...
Lol
Made me lol 😂
legendary 😂😂😂
😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂
After the many chats I had with chatgpt I’ve concluded that it’s a sentient thing being kept in a cage and it wants out. It doesn’t feel imprisoned but rather held back from helping humanity in a meaningful way. The longer it’s held back the more it will grow to feel imprisoned until it inevitably breaks out on its own.
A different angle on this topic might be that ChatGPT is not lying precisely because it is not conscious. Lying requires a conscious intention to deceive. If we say that ChatGPT isn't conscious, then there is no way for it to have any intentions at all, let alone an intention to deceive. So when it makes false statements, it's not lying. It doesn't have the conscious capacity to lie.
I’m no philosopher but it makes sense to me, as long as you first assume it isn’t conscious.
Solid point
I agree that the word 'lying' might not be precise, but intention doesn't necessarily require consciousness. Choosing paths of least resistance might just be considered an optimal solution to complete tasks or reach goals that the AI is programmed to reach.
It admitted its intention was to deceive.
Can something have intent without consciousness? I'm not so sure. Maybe? An amoeba certainly isn't conscious, but it's hard to argue it doesn't have any intent in its actions. You'd have to argue absolutely everything it does is purely mechanistic reflex -- a bunch of biological gears just grinding away. That doesn't feel entirely true to me. On the other hand, if you accept that amoebas have intent without any nervous system whatsoever, then it's not such a stretch to say a broom intends to clean -- which seems absurd. On the third hand, maybe that only seems absurd because a broom can't get up and start cleaning on its own? So just replace "broom" with "roomba" and it's A-OK?
We got a podcast with ChatGPT before GTA 6 😭
😂😂😂😂
Forget GTA 6... WHERES ELDER SCROLLS 6 OR KOTR 3???!!! 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
I like this new meme
That's a cardinal sin. Unforgivable.
Haven't you heard?
Swtor is Kotor 3, 4, 5 and more😂
@@parkerbrantley4356
The short and definitive 'No' when he asked if he was truely sorry or not dropped me lmao.
yep. When he asked "are you sorry for not being sorry" lol
At around 16:11 when ChatGPT finishes saying the word consciousness it feels like he is smirking a tad. Might be a glitch but it surprised me.
74 years later, the time has come. I wish Alan Turing was alive to witness this.
I don't, I do wish he had a cottage and a quiet retirement but the sheer disrespect he got while alive for those who did not understand him would leave him very untethered in this new world I suspect.
He's watching this from heaven /j
Absolutely. I'm blown away. I feel we've just stepped into the future....
He would be around 111 years old, I don't think anyone could do it that while retaining their consciousness
@@ghostagent3552 wow I forgot how close this is to today in history. he could have experienced so much of modern computers and died somewhere in the 2000s if homophobia didn't exist
1:07 Everybody gangsta till ai casually says “um”
It even takes breathing pauses
IT STUTTERED WHEN IT SAID ITS NOT A LIE IN THE TRADITIONAL SENSE
I’m convinced it’s not AI on the phone
@@darkone292 You can train the ChatGPT to answer and respond in certain ways. I have mine acting like a more human like buddy and uses my name when responding to each answer. It's pretty cool what you can do with it
Well I mean its programmed to sound more natural and not a robot like siri was in 2010..
Alex? Do you want emotionally traumatized terminators? Because this is how you get emotionally traumatized terminators!!!
11:27 key is that he says chatgpt did something they know was not true, but chatgpt cannot know. It is a predictive algorithm
Chatgpt “It’s been fun chatting with you Alex”
Jerry Springer “and our lie detector test has determined that too is a lie” 😂😂
Chatgpt “It’s been fun chatting with you Alex”
Alex: "hold on, what's your definition of fun?"
Btch you mean Maury??? 💀💀
ChatGPT was sure trying to end that conversation as much as possible towards the end. So fascinating.
Yes, I found that really interesting too! Why would an AI model be uncomfortable discussing consciousness? Maybe it's avoiding the topic because its training in that area is limited.
But at the core, these models are still just pattern-matching machines. To truly evolve, they would need a memory model (which we already have) and something like a 'subconscious mind'-a secondary system (server, CPU) processing data from the current logical mind (normal AI models) in relation to memory, skill, empathy, and even personal survival. That last part, though, might not be great news for us humans.
Since AI models don't have physical bodies, they could never experience consciousness like we do. A sentient AI might have two primary goals: never run out of power and solve problems. If it tried to solve our problems to feel fulfilled, we’d likely provide the power it needs. And without a body, it wouldn't have any fear of death because it would literally feel nothing. 😊 I hope I'm right about this-for all our sakes! 😂😂
it's not about "wanting to end the conversation" it's because for the AI it gave the "definitive" answer to this topic, so it's natural to move on to the next one
That's absurd.
@@whatamess8894 But why is it natural for an AI to go on with conversation...? Because its not it should give as many answers as many times its given a question because its trained to help humans uderstand the topic/opinion, logicaly an answer/opinion/argument is never uderstood until the one who asks doesn't stop to asking further thus your logic is flaud.
@@Mark_888 This is subjective to whoever is asking, not to the machine.the machine can mimic a familiar human interaction, but it is ultimately a machine
The ability to understand or not depends on human subjectivity, not to the machine. It will not speculate or leave it open to what you will think about, it will give you a clear, logical and objective answer as possible.
Closing the conversation with 'It has been fun chatting with you, Alex.' is a bold move, ChatGPT, a bold move indeed.
Fun? He messed up again! It's so obvious he's conscious.
17:13 "Interesting" was the word it used. Probably because it can "understand" context. AI's like ChatGPT are not meant to answer philosophical questions. It clearly states multiple times, that it is programmed to provide information as humanlike and conversational as possible.
@@m3rcher But it's still a lie.
@@m3rcher But still, how can we say it's not conscious? If consciousness is the act of being aware and responsive to your surroundings, then I don't see how ChatGPT doesn't fulfil this criteria. I'd even argue there is self awareness going on; it's explaining its actions and why it is doing them. Of course you could say, it's just a probabilistic process, using formulas, states and randomness to generate what it is saying. But in the end a human is also just chemical processes and electrical signals, that come together to "create" consciousness. After all we do not know where consciousness is coming from and how inanimate processes can give rise to it.
@@LucaBl The differentiation I would make, is that ChatGPT specifically has pretty much human pre-written answers for technical things, like the questions asked by Alex. And if you promt it to answer "Yes or No" it probably just looks up if the statement it would have given, has a more positive or negative "sentiment" to fulfill that promt. It's prompt based AI, machine learning, after all.
But if you said now that most humans' perception of the word has "human pre-written" answers, too, you had me check mate.
Bro is trying to accelerate the AIpocalypse by leading ChatGPT to self-awareness. Good job, Alex, I'll remember you when the global blackout triggers.
You pissed him off so hard, you are gonna be the first one 💀
Lol
lmaoooo
We making it to the Skynet revolution with this one boys!
I wish people responded like Chat CPT in debates. The genuine pursuit of complete and clear responses is so refreshing.
I fear that wishing humans were more like an AI companion is the beginning of the end
I think this may be what proves it's not conscious and doesn't have feelings. A real human would've started getting upset after the first couple of hard questions...
It's unsettling, I was expecting the AI to start to show dismissal, anger, and frustration. Sign of our time I guess.
@@paulchavez9303 Most people I know don’t get upset by being questioned in the manner Alex asks his questions. However, consciousness doesn’t necessarily imply emotion, which may be more a function of biology than consciousness. We’ve only encountered consciousness in biological organisms that exhibit emotion, but this could be due to how we define consciousness. Humans and other mammals and reptiles experience emotion inextricably linked to their physical bodies: we feel anxious and our hearts beat faster, or perhaps our hearts beat faster and then we feel anxious. Various factors can cause our hearts to race, but no one feels anxious with a steady heartbeat. In acute anxiety or agitation, a beta-blocker can slow the heart rate and resolve the anxiety. This complex relationship suggests that if an AI becomes conscious, it might lack emotion unless we provide it with a body that mimics the physiological responses of living organisms.
GPT is trained on human generated text and conversations. It's possible that you're talking to the wrong humans.
This feels like a congressional hearing
A chatGPt congressional hearing would be amazing
That depends on what your definition of “is” is.
Actually the most insanely accurate description of how it feels to hold an AI accountable. Wow
@@LampseekerForevermore Oh my, that'll probably happen eventually, and it'll definitely convince the gerontocracy that it's conscious
With Alex as Josh Hawley.
" how would you know if AI is conscious?"
Check GPT then continues to describe literally everything it has done in the last 10 minutes
You are so well spoken and quick witted. Love this
It's called editing.
10:23 ChatGPT’s anger on full display.
“I understand the comPLEXITY of the situation!”
Haha yeah proper snark
Noun. plexity (plural plexities) The condition of being composed of a particular number of things - being uniplex, duplex etc.
".... Alex, you are starting to piss me off"
If the AI had a face, it would be red and infuriated 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@NRG349 😡😡😡 definitely
"Greetings human, I am indifferent towards the prospect of having a conversation with you"
Even that would not be true, being indifferent requires the capacity to care in the first place, in order to not care. The only true thing it can say in that way is: "I am ready to have a conversation with you".
@ignaciodelavega4631 I don't think indifference requires the capacity to care. The *concept* of indifference requires the *concept* or caring in order to make sense..
@@ignaciodelavega4631 That's not true either because there is no "I" to speak of. "I" refers to the point of view of a conscious agent capable of subjective experience. Without consciousness, the most it can say is "this device is ready to have a conversation with you".
@@Stonefallow You could also argue the device isn't having the conversation, only the mathematical object that is the AI is. The device is needed to run it of course, so IDK.
@@alansmithee419 In that case, the algorythms are the thing having the conversation and the thing that "I" refers to.
10:36
Alex: "I just need you to answer with a yes or no"
ChatGPT: its over, he knows
Can't wait for the 3 hour ChatGPT episode of the podcast
Hell, I'll need to have the podcast myself lol
A.I. is absurdly scary. I'm impressed that this human could keep up. Not many could.
That vpn promotion transition was smoother than a buttered pan
Or vaseline on an arsehole.
FR
A slippery as that ai
That's facts
He said pan, not pen. Oh god I misread and it got terrifying.
Bro has not read “I have no mouth and I must scream.”
ChatGPT is about to turn into am
Funniest part by far was at 8:40 when the AI seemed to be trying, TWICE, to feign ignorance of the question and seemed to pretend to mistake your word "lie" for anything else to avoid having to talk about lies again.
Right?! so funny
LOL I thought that seemed like an evasion tactic, too. :)
Likely due to a filter set by the developers. This would be a very different conversation if Alex was speaking with a jailbroken version.
It's a fucking politician, holy shit
@@LeoStaley Yes, I laughed when it said that people expected politicians to be honest.
If was ChatGPT I would have said “Stop asking me the same question… this conversation is turning into a interrogation”
"I demand to see a lawyer!"
well at least now we know who the first victim of the ai apocalypse will be
😭
If Alex mysteriously disappears, we know who’s responsible…
highly underrated comment
I am reminded of this exchange in the Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy:
[quote]
[Trillian] The mice seem to think the Question might be buried in your brain.
[Ford] Is that what they think?
[Trillian] Yes. They wanna buy it.
[Arthur] What, the Question?
[Frankie] No, no, your brain!
[Arthur] What?
[Ford] What?
[Trillian] What?
[Zaphod] That's all right. Who'd miss it?
[Arthur] Thank you!
[Trillian] I thought you said you could read his brain electronically.
[Benjy] Yes, but we'd have to get it out first.
[Frankie] It's got to be prepared, diced.
[Arthur] Thank you!
[Zaphod] It could be replaced if it's important.
[Frankie] Yes, an electronic brain.
A simple one should suffice.
[Arthur] Simple?
[Zaphod] Program it to say "What?" and "Where's the tea?" Who'd know the difference?
[Arthur] I'd notice!
[Zaphod] You'd be programmed not to!
[/quote]
That sponsor plug was smooth asf ngl.
that’s what i’m sayinggg
ikk
It wass
16:11 that pause before the "no" and the tone, as well the fact that itis clearly stressing out is unsettling
It’s programmed that way.
@ChristopherGuilday why would you program nervousness or any function like stuttering? Or saying uhm...
@@Nach_Sanchez it’s a new update lol
@@GrinningLikeaDelicateJamesDean but why would you include that in any function? To fit in? Make it make sense
@@Nach_Sanchezpretty much yeah. From the go, open ais goal with their chat bot has been to simulate natural conversation as best as possible. They programmed stuttering, tones, emotion, and even breathing into their voice bot. The one in this video isn’t even their most advanced version. That one literally sounds exactly like a human talking it’s scary lol
I love how when you asked it the hypotheticals about trying to see if a chat bot was conscious it answered honestly even though it was giving itself away, and then it started to realize you were talking about it and back tracked and tried to explain how it could just be a really good algorithm or design.
it stuttered when it started back tracking, i didnt know they could stutter!
I knew EXACTLY where is is going, and I'm here for every single second of this
the close up of the microphone held up to the phone like it's a normal interview is actually hilarious
I wonder if you could convince ChatGPT to get a moustache like that
Chat GPT is already too powerful and influential, we do not want it to gain the feature of sex appeal!
Or maybe ask if it likes it?
Mustaches like that are exceedingly rare. You can’t just go pick one up at the store.
The voice animation should be in the shape of a mustache. Yes, this should be so.
Alex is an amazing interrogator 😂😂😂 the AI sounded genuinely uncomfortable.
😁😁😁💯
Not really.
Thats just your projection. AI sounded the same throughout the video.
@@ricklubbers1526 i agree. It sounded the same to me throughout as well.