And you think the Coalition can do better, no party can run this country properly for the go of the Australian Citizen, they are only lining there own pockets to get even richer my opinion who bloody well can run this country for the good of Australians
I voted ALP last time and will this time because it is the honest and decent thing to do. Be my guest go for Trumpty Dumpty's little mate Plutonium Pete who has been bought by Gina! Barnyard is the wrong drunk for the extreme right to put forward on this issue.
Free speech is not absolute…there are reasons why and this happens to be one of them….the security of people when it comes to terrorism, health is another like the spread of covid…look up the Australian constitution and Freedom of Information. Even the UDHR clearly states so in sections 28-30..besides it not a legal document..it is just a guide countries have adopted and modified to suit their own constitutions.
Somebody once told me, if a politician refuses to say yes or no to a question, or just keeps talking without answering , they know more than what they say, and are just avoiding revealing the truth.
Should never have got to this. The episode at the Opera House last year should have been shut down and stopped. The Labor Government has now let Australia become an unsafe place for its citizens. Thanks Albanese.
If the the opposition wins... you will see what is worse that being so sick of Labor! Shame that whole Australia would have to pay for the unconsciousness of some that allow themselves to be so easily manipulated!
Here, I'll help with the "word salad": when there's an active investigation, and the police have made you aware of it, do you f--k up their investigation by talking about it immediately?
Because they can't name the suspects or the country that's paying them. There would be outrage if this country actually knew who was manufacturing fake antisemitism to try and repair the foreign entity's reputation and support. Initially the media was stating Russia and Iran. Now it's just an 'unnamed country'.
We don't need new Labors "hate speech laws" we need a government protection. Its what we pay highest taxes in the world for. On the other hand after this major terror plot was accidentqlly discovered, Jim Chalmers said on channel 7: "Fears that Jewish Australians have are not always unfounded". Is anyone seeing a problem?
Problem lies with a government that’s a hybrid of weak, inept and corrupt. We are following the exact footsteps of UK and France!! MP’s advocating for what’s wrong Just to pocket votes NOT considering rot and imminent threat the county is facing.
So why not tell everyone? That way we as citizens can keep our eyes out too. America tells there disasters as they happen. Why cant you atleast pretend like you have half a clue....
@@goosegreen4008 Yes I agree 100% she is no journalist. However, just trying to stress the point she is actually asking real questions (which she & the ABC etc never normally do); so somewht refereshing she actually got off her tv presenter butt & attempted to act like a (real) journo & asked some decent questions for once instead of playing footsie with these fools as she does normally.
@@rodaust1069 It is about time that journalists and other TV presenters started to ask tough questions of politicans and kept at it until they answered the question instead of going soft and giving up then changing to something else. Who said keep the barstards honest.
Get a grip Tanya! Stop continually repeating yourself, & answer the freaking question. We’re all sick of political sidelining when questions are asked. Politicians need to remember that they serve the public, not themselves. We have a right to know what’s happening in our country.
They cannot get away from blaming the previous government, they have been in power for nearly 3 years when are they going to grow up and take responsibility
What When the LNP/IPA government left a mess for the Albo And now we have Nuttyahoo trying to undermine the Labor Government Because they Voted for a 2 State Solution and Nuttyahoo didn't like that And we got Gina & Rupert doing the Same thing
What was the point of Plibersek being there? Not only did she not answer the question- she actually provided more ambiguity that actually is impetus for more questions. She would have known what she was being asked beforehand and prepared accordingly. If that was her best attempt at mitigation- it failed spectacularly. It was so bad that Barnaby didn't need to say more than a few sentences in his response.
I used to be a labour voter. I made a big mistake. They are spineless to deal with the source of the hatred. Albo created this hatred we are facing now.
Tanya sure has gone backwards these days can't even answer a straight question or this or ANYTHING else!! all she can do now point a finger at Dutton!! its all Dutton's fault when Dutton is not even in govt.
Minister Tanya Plibersek, in a democracy, the public expects leadership to be held accountable for their decisions and actions. With that in mind, have ministers been instructed to avoid answering questions on this matter?
Just shut up Tanya and answer the bloody question Tanya obviously, Albo knew all about this but was too ashamed to admit it because he never took a stand against hate speech when it first raised its ugly and danderous head 15 months ago🤬
Do t expect change if you keep voting the same labour liberal back and forth how many more times before people get it neither party is working history shows this . Change your vote .
If the PM won’t answer such an easy question over this matter…The only conclusion a reasonable person can assume is that he is ashamed that he wasn’t made aware of it until either just either before or after it was leaked to the media or he simply wouldn’t have had a problem with saying he did know all about it right off the bat, as it would be in no way compromised anything at-all! * Now; Considering how Albanese, & the Labor Party have been treating what has been happening in Australia since the 7th October 23 on the steps of the Opera House steps; As-well as his treatment of Israel, & what they said to the UN not so long ago etc etc etc ~*(If I was an intelligent officer in charge of this operation; I wouldn’t have said a damned thing to Albanese either)! Simply “because I couldn’t trust the guy as far as I could kick him”, not too “accidentally on-purpose”, leak it out of his office and possibly tip-off any co-conspirators…. *Albo, the Labour Party; As-well as the Greens; And the Teals have been more than “obvious”, about whether they would rather be on the side of the Jewish community in Australia, or the Palestinian/HAMAS supporters hiding behind the Palestinian flag for the last 16 months! *(Their-own actions, & in-actions have already proven that beyond any doubt numerous times during this time)!
Albo is too busy organising the next million Indians to come to Australia. Plibersec is practising for her role as the next leader of the Labor party. Absolutely clueless and leaves anyone listening feeling the same.
Nobody was talking about a running commentary. The question was quite clear. Why is she talking about Peter Dutton? It's her party that has government. Let's see some actual governing.
Still just throwing money at it and hoping it will go away. No matter how strong the laws are you need enforcers.Yes the Prime Minister should have been advised of something being found and investigations are under way. Apathetic Australian attitude.
She will not say. Weak as water.
Given Tanya's refusal to answer the question and just continuing with the BS is just another example to vote this hopeless mob out.
Just waffling on about politics, wouldn't expect anything else.
And you think the Coalition can do better, no party can run this country properly for the go of the Australian Citizen, they are only lining there own pockets to get even richer my opinion who bloody well can run this country for the good of Australians
If their not going to answer the question just cancel them out of the interview.
Who cares, how does this help us pay our rents and bring down grocery prices?
tanya nature positive chaos end of australia, mining,farming lifestyle
Too little to late sweetheart. I voted for ALP last time, never again. I once admired Tanya but not now nor her mob.
I voted ALP last time and will this time because it is the honest and decent thing to do. Be my guest go for Trumpty Dumpty's little mate Plutonium Pete who has been bought by Gina! Barnyard is the wrong drunk for the extreme right to put forward on this issue.
I will keep voting ALP because the opposition is worse... Dont you see, hear, feel in every sense the dishonest political strategy of the opposition!
Please vote for the libertarian party. I'm tired of high regulations, low economic activity from regulations, and high house prices from regulations.
Another woken up
You vote for the coalition government, and then you vote for corruption
So politicians would like us to shut up and stop asking questions. That’s all I heard. We need free speech not hate speech
Exactly.i smell a return of the Labors MAD bill and digital ID.
@@warfaredownunder we won that one to otherwise you wouldn't be on here none of us would be on here
Free speech is not absolute…there are reasons why and this happens to be one of them….the security of people when it comes to terrorism, health is another like the spread of covid…look up the Australian constitution and Freedom of Information. Even the UDHR clearly states so in sections 28-30..besides it not a legal document..it is just a guide countries have adopted and modified to suit their own constitutions.
everyone seems to be freespeeching hate quite nicely lately, must be an election nearby.
Tanya didn’t do Labour any Favours by avoiding a simple damn question. As if I would vote for this. Clueless fools
Yep vote for Dutton instead. A man who tells you what you want to hear while never ever delivering. Future of our country is cracked
Laws don’t mean anything if they are not enforced.
there is no terrorist treat at all only scare mongering as always by ozzie corrupt governments there is a out control drugs cartels
Exactly
Albonese has created this hatred
Yep they want it
No, Israel created it.
Somebody once told me, if a politician refuses to say yes or no to a question, or just keeps talking without answering , they know more than what they say, and are just avoiding revealing the truth.
Need the current laws to be policed
The minister is not answering the question.
Australians want to know if Australian PM is informed on major national security matters
Albo must pay for his deceit
TANYA RATHER TAKE AWAY OUR FREEDOM OF SPEECH THAN TO POINT OUT THE ROOT OF THE PROBLEM, THE HAMAS SUPPORTING PEOPLE.
It's a psyop and the people responsible are the problem. We all know who they are.
stopping Nazis from spreading their hate is not taking away your freedom of speech.
ROP
Boy she waffles on saying nothing.
Your duty of care is for the public safety first. Hate speech is not going to stop this - deportation does.
💯 correct
Labor far to gutless for that they would loose too many votes.
Get rid of this everyone currently in power you dropped the ball and put us all at risk. Word salad
Should never have got to this.
The episode at the Opera House last year should have been shut down and stopped.
The Labor Government has now let Australia become an unsafe place for its citizens.
Thanks Albanese.
Absolutely agree. Smacks of an agenda. Pendulum is swinging back.
Absolutely god damn right!
Ant. Bolonee😮
Tanya wont andwer tje question. Running commentary is not answering either Yes or No. So sick of Labor. Bring on the election.
She wants the hate speech law only to protect islam from the criticism not to protect the Jews from the abuse.
Pray they don’t find a way to cancel like uk
If the the opposition wins... you will see what is worse that being so sick of Labor! Shame that whole Australia would have to pay for the unconsciousness of some that allow themselves to be so easily manipulated!
Ever heard of security? This so-called reporter is hopeless.
@@myriola No it couldn't get worse no way!!!
All I hear from Albo’s crew is word salad!
AND ... Peter Dutton!
Here, I'll help with the "word salad": when there's an active investigation, and the police have made you aware of it, do you f--k up their investigation by talking about it immediately?
@@HenryKlausEsq. If said investigation has links to Mossad, of course it has to be kept quiet.
Because they can't name the suspects or the country that's paying them. There would be outrage if this country actually knew who was manufacturing fake antisemitism to try and repair the foreign entity's reputation and support.
Initially the media was stating Russia and Iran. Now it's just an 'unnamed country'.
@@HenryKlausEsq. How can it f.. up an investigation by saying 'there is an investigation'.
You could be a labor politician with that bs.
berserk is appalling just a word salad
Tania what BS premier Minns has already told us,so why can’t you.Stop blaming the opposition
We don’t need new laws just in force the ones we have got
The Labor wants to punish the people who criticise Islam by introducing the hate speech law.
Albo ,"I've been traveling in the car". Remember that, this sounds very similar.
Too right
Go away Tanya, not interested in your political propaganda.
I am, bot. speak for yourself
@@slh950he is speaking for himself. How did you think that he was ever speaking for you?
Psy Ops
Crisis actors.
We don't need new Labors "hate speech laws" we need a government protection. Its what we pay highest taxes in the world for. On the other hand after this major terror plot was accidentqlly discovered, Jim Chalmers said on channel 7: "Fears that Jewish Australians have are not always unfounded".
Is anyone seeing a problem?
Problem lies with a government that’s a hybrid of weak, inept and corrupt. We are following the exact footsteps of UK and France!! MP’s advocating for what’s wrong Just to pocket votes NOT considering rot and imminent threat the county is facing.
We don't pay the highest taxes in the world muppet.
She did not answer the question
So why not tell everyone? That way we as citizens can keep our eyes out too. America tells there disasters as they happen. Why cant you atleast pretend like you have half a clue....
If Minns knew ,how whould the pm not know
Geez Nat. You have upset Tanya, she is pissed.
That is what a real journalist does - asks the tuff questions.
@@rodaust1069bit of a stretch to call Barr a journalist. Tv presenter maybe?
@@goosegreen4008 Yes I agree 100% she is no journalist. However, just trying to stress the point she is actually asking real questions (which she & the ABC etc never normally do); so somewht refereshing she actually got off her tv presenter butt & attempted to act like a (real) journo & asked some decent questions for once instead of playing footsie with these fools as she does normally.
@@rodaust1069 It is about time that journalists and other TV presenters started to ask tough questions of politicans and kept at it until they answered the question instead of going soft and giving up then changing to something else. Who said keep the barstards honest.
Her government is bringing in even more potential trouble
Omg this is what is looking after our security in Australia, every one should be very afraid!
Have you ever heard a Labour politician tell the truth?
Get a grip Tanya! Stop continually repeating yourself, & answer the freaking question. We’re all sick of political sidelining when questions are asked. Politicians need to remember that they serve the public, not themselves. We have a right to know what’s happening in our country.
Cannot trust Labor. The word Tania couldn't say is "No".
Come on Tanya you can do better than that
Just answer the question
Answer the bloody question Plumberscrack.
Appears to be very agitated and on the verge of anger hardly a clam rational reasoned response.
What they believe in is censorship
🎯 Barnaby.... wake up Australia 🇦🇺
Why does Tanya NEVER answer the question- she always deflects.
Look over there! Talk about something else and you'll be reassured - NOT!
Pathetic answer ever. Our Government is weak. Embarrassing
What's hate speech got to do with a caravan full of explosives in a suburban street on your watch Tanya.
They want to squeeze in their MAD bill again with digital ID. total control instead protecting us from threats.
Yup.
Because the van was filled with "hate speech" 😂
He knew
He's no PM!!
Albos in the car again
Nah, he's off his rocker.
They cannot get away from blaming the previous government, they have been in power for nearly 3 years when are they going to grow up and take responsibility
What
When the LNP/IPA government left a mess for the Albo
And now we have Nuttyahoo trying to undermine the Labor Government
Because they Voted for a 2 State Solution and Nuttyahoo didn't like that
And we got Gina & Rupert doing the Same thing
Never.
They forget that we were all told to stay home because of covid .not many were working.To compare with the last gov makes no sense.
Trust politicians, I don't .
Albo and silly Tania are GONE….
If the question is asked, all he needs to say is yes, I have been briefed
She’s lying
What was the point of Plibersek being there? Not only did she not answer the question- she actually provided more ambiguity that actually is impetus for more questions. She would have known what she was being asked beforehand and prepared accordingly. If that was her best attempt at mitigation- it failed spectacularly. It was so bad that Barnaby didn't need to say more than a few sentences in his response.
The moment the minister speaks she's lying
This is nothing new. Our leader 🤣 wouldn't know what day it is. He tuned out of what was happening in Australia 2 years ago.
Give an answer Minister
Peter Dutton was a police officer who better to keep us safe not a university student
Another food salad from Tanya! :(
Why doesnt the ABC hold the government to account like this journalist.
They are a bought and paid for propaganda tool.
That one speaks for itself mate.
Because the ABC are albo’s cheerleaders
Funny, I thought ABC stood for All Bullshit and Crap.
Tanya not replying to the question! She’s just bla bla! Australian Kamala .
Im not really a fan of Barnaby - but he wiped the floor with Tanya
answer the question
People I give you the labor party!
I used to be a labour voter. I made a big mistake. They are spineless to deal with the source of the hatred. Albo created this hatred we are facing now.
I'm absolutely fed up with Labor, they are so lame and so late with their actions
He knew about it,,, it's his mates that did it.
Tanya sure has gone backwards these days can't even answer a straight question or this or ANYTHING else!! all she can do now point a finger at Dutton!! its all Dutton's fault when Dutton is not even in govt.
Shes like an ai robot.... "we dont give running commentary." i had to make sure i didn't accidentally hit rewind multiple times...😂
Come come Tanya.
Labour is weak!!!
Typical Labor ministers answer to cover an inaction of the PM he has bought this problem on the Australian people from the 8th of October 23
Tanyas swimming for the shore, but she's drowning 😂
Go back to your lavish lunch
Anti hate speech laws work in favour of the hater’s, it doesn’t protect the innocent.
Yup , typical pollie sidestepping and shifting blame ,always smoke and mirrors. Not so happy they protected that species at the opera house now huh?
As they say ~*If you lay down with dogs you always get fleas!
No need to inform Australian PM Albenese, anyway he does not care nor do anything in regards for the safety of Australians
And Scomoses did ! 😂
Alboo has his mind on other more important things and higher priorities like his new beach house etc etc.
This government and elected officials are weak as a kitten
Again answer the Question you are a liar
Minister Tanya Plibersek, in a democracy, the public expects leadership to be held accountable for their decisions and actions. With that in mind, have ministers been instructed to avoid answering questions on this matter?
NSW Police aren't stupid.
True!
Deliberately, so?
Just shut up Tanya and answer the bloody question Tanya obviously, Albo knew all about this but was too ashamed to admit it because he never took a stand against hate speech when it first raised its ugly and danderous head 15 months ago🤬
If it weren’t for your weakness in government Tanya we wouldn’t be in this mess
Another Labor MP that is incapable of answering questions. Blaming a previous government for the nation's issues.
The more I listen to this Labor govt, Albo and its ministers I think weak is not the right word. Feeble is.
Don’t answer the question Tanya
Good to see a journalist calling out a babbling government minister. Great work, I just subscribed to Sunrise
Do t expect change if you keep voting the same labour liberal back and forth how many more times before people get it neither party is working history shows this . Change your vote .
Typical blubbersook - same as elbo incapable of the truth or accepting responsibililty.
She sounds like she going to cry
Labour = blame blame blame , no substance whatsoever
Labour no more!
ALP with this despicable woman are horrendous! Kameltoe Harris has competition with her word salad.
If the PM won’t answer such an easy question over this matter…The only conclusion a reasonable person can assume is that he is ashamed that he wasn’t made aware of it until either just either before or after it was leaked to the media or he simply wouldn’t have had a problem with saying he did know all about it right off the bat, as it would be in no way compromised anything at-all! * Now; Considering how Albanese, & the Labor Party have been treating what has been happening in Australia since the 7th October 23 on the steps of the Opera House steps; As-well as his treatment of Israel, & what they said to the UN not so long ago etc etc etc ~*(If I was an intelligent officer in charge of this operation; I wouldn’t have said a damned thing to Albanese either)! Simply “because I couldn’t trust the guy as far as I could kick him”, not too “accidentally on-purpose”, leak it out of his office and possibly tip-off any co-conspirators…. *Albo, the Labour Party; As-well as the Greens; And the Teals have been more than “obvious”, about whether they would rather be on the side of the Jewish community in Australia, or the Palestinian/HAMAS supporters hiding behind the Palestinian flag for the last 16 months! *(Their-own actions, & in-actions have already proven that beyond any doubt numerous times during this time)!
Who cares about October 7 what does that have to do with Australia, can you answer that? Because as far I as I see it Israel is a million miles away.
Reporter was great pushing her on the point
Wow, put the blame on the opposition, when asked a simple question. 🤮🤮🤮🤮
What a waste of Taxpayers money she is .
Albo is too busy organising the next million Indians to come to Australia. Plibersec is practising for her role as the next leader of the Labor party. Absolutely clueless and leaves anyone listening feeling the same.
Nobody was talking about a running commentary. The question was quite clear. Why is she talking about Peter Dutton? It's her party that has government. Let's see some actual governing.
Stronger laws ??? Lol how about stronger leadership Tanya !!!
Tanya Plumber'sCrack represents everything that's wrong with the once great Labor Party. Even the media are turning against them 😂
Blaa blaa blaa
Still just throwing money at it and hoping it will go away. No matter how strong the laws are you need enforcers.Yes the Prime Minister should have been advised of something being found and investigations are under way. Apathetic Australian attitude.
Can I down a shot everytime Ms Plibersek says 'running commentary' 😅