Are you dependent on UA-cam and social media to gain Islamic knowledge? Download the Thaqlain App today by visiting app.thaqlain.org Also, if you found this content beneficial, please take a moment to donate at thaqlain.org/support.
Are the scholars that ignorant to acknowledge that the hadith refers to the Imams of the Ahlulbayt so they make it vague and complicated so they just drop it/forget about it, 👍🏼
@@Thaqlain Very good read so far! He does a very good job of making the Mahdi’s occupation intelligible to Sunnis. He talks about prophets who had long lives, and other Muslim communities who believed people like Enoch were still alive.
The 12 Imam's: 1 Ali Ibn Abi Talib (as) 2. Hassan Ibn Ali (as) 3. Hussain Ibn Ali (as) 4. Ali Ibn Hussain Al Sajjad (as) 5. Muhammad Ibn Ali Al Baqir (as) 6. Jafar Ibn Muhammad Al Sadiq (as) 7. Musa Ibn Jafar Al Kadhim (as) 8. Ali Ibn Musa Al Rida (as) 9. Muhammad Ibn Ali Al Jawwad (as) 10. Ali Ibn Muhammad Al Hadi (as) 11. Hassan Ibn Ali Al Askari (as) 12. Al Mahdi (as)
@AzharAli-ig6fn Who told me?? Has your teachers never told you? By the way, Allah hears and sees all (Qur'an) & I'm happy with what I've written (names of all Imams). If I'm wrong, it's me who has to deal with it on the day of Qayamat, not you.
We know from Bukhari : 7222, 7223 ; that there were 12 divinely appointed leaders/Imams. In surah Baqarah, verse 124 Allah say no zalim (including unjust) will be an imam. All of the muslim rulers except for the shia Imams were cruel and unjust. Also Abu dawood : 4282-4284 shows that the prophet pbuh said that the mahdi (final of the 12) will be from my line and from the descendents of Lady Fatima a.s. These show that the imams are from the prophets lineage. Bonus : the names of Imams were foretold by the prophet (al kafi : chapter 126; hadith 1391)
There’s no such thing in the Bokhari . I suggest you read the narrations . Only Shias believe in that . For example in one of these narrations it says that the Rafidi believes there are 12 imams . But clerics like that delete the first two words in the narration ( Rafidi believe)
It does make sense that some would combine all types of valid leaders after Prophet Muhammad. If the rope taken up was broken and picked up by two and Ahl Bayt had a father and two sons, if would make more sense that those were the successors.
11:45 - 14:07 The Qur'an affirms answers through The Torah in Surahs 3:119, 10:94, 16:43, 21:7, 34:31. Surahs 2:132-134, 3:84, 4:163, affirm the 12 Imams, and the 13th. This is the nation which passed away, the one which first received Islam via Imam Ali. 14:08 - 17:55 Although the 12 have passed away they continue in the afterlife as judges, as do the 12 of Yeshua ben Miriam who assumedly succeeded the 12 from Jacob. Saying they will not separate is proof in itself of the 13th Imam who comes in the end of days even as the 12 continue as judges.
I keep posting my comment here however when i return to this video it seems to get deleted.. Is it because my comment has a link of another UA-cam video attached?
Is it that Yasir Qadhi, Mufti Menk, Aasim Hakeem, Zakir Naik and the rest have not come across these hadiths or they just lack the wisdom to acknowledge that these 12 refers to the Imams of Ahlulbayt or they’re just hypocrites seeking the worldly fame and gains. It’s just a question. May Allah continue to misguide those who refuse to be guided.
I am Shia myself, and I will tell you that the 12 Imams is a false and have nothing to do with authentic hadiths. The only authentic is the fact that Quran and Ahlulbeit will never separate until the day of judgment. Those interested in finding this truth must search for it.
It is better either first to give a disclaimer (that you are, for example, an Ismaili) or to provide relevant proof before accusing a Mutawatir narration as false. We assumed you to be an Ismaili because you posted a similar comment in a previous video.
Who do we believe Sunni & shia scholars who say the 12 successors is an authentic hadith or a nobody on UA-cam. Who brings no evidence his only claim to fame is he claims to be a shia 🤨 We have hundreds of millions of shi'a who know better than you & disagree with you. Why do you nobody think you will know better than every other shia
Are you dependent on UA-cam and social media to gain Islamic knowledge? Download the Thaqlain App today by visiting app.thaqlain.org
Also, if you found this content beneficial, please take a moment to donate at thaqlain.org/support.
I love the qazwini family!!!❤❤❤❤
Are the scholars that ignorant to acknowledge that the hadith refers to the Imams of the Ahlulbayt so they make it vague and complicated so they just drop it/forget about it, 👍🏼
Catholic here.
Interesting timing, my copy of “Dr. Mahdi Maghrebi
A Historical Research on the Lives of the 12 Shia Imams” just arrived!
Do share your reviews of that book.
@@Thaqlain Very good read so far!
He does a very good job of making the Mahdi’s occupation intelligible to Sunnis.
He talks about prophets who had long lives, and other Muslim communities who believed people like Enoch were still alive.
The 12 Imam's:
1 Ali Ibn Abi Talib (as)
2. Hassan Ibn Ali (as)
3. Hussain Ibn Ali (as)
4. Ali Ibn Hussain Al Sajjad (as)
5. Muhammad Ibn Ali Al Baqir (as)
6. Jafar Ibn Muhammad Al Sadiq (as)
7. Musa Ibn Jafar Al Kadhim (as)
8. Ali Ibn Musa Al Rida (as)
9. Muhammad Ibn Ali Al Jawwad (as)
10. Ali Ibn Muhammad Al Hadi (as)
11. Hassan Ibn Ali Al Askari (as)
12. Al Mahdi (as)
Who told ??
@AzharAli-ig6fn
Who told me??
Has your teachers never told you?
By the way, Allah hears and sees all (Qur'an) &
I'm happy with what I've written (names of all Imams).
If I'm wrong, it's me who has to deal with it on the day of Qayamat, not you.
Sunni dudes lije Adnan and Farid and their likes shiver at the challenge that Thaqlain posed to them to debate any topic .
... & also Shamsi & it's Hyde Park Dawah crew😂
@@DaTruth1017 Absolutely
@@mnoorbhai
I just remembered.
I forgot to mention that arrogant Hijabi 😅
I love prophet muhammed (sawas) and his ahlalbayt (as)!!!❤❤❤❤❤
We know from Bukhari : 7222, 7223 ; that there were 12 divinely appointed leaders/Imams.
In surah Baqarah, verse 124 Allah say no zalim (including unjust) will be an imam. All of the muslim rulers except for the shia Imams were cruel and unjust.
Also Abu dawood : 4282-4284 shows that the prophet pbuh said that the mahdi (final of the 12) will be from my line and from the descendents of Lady Fatima a.s.
These show that the imams are from the prophets lineage.
Bonus : the names of Imams were foretold by the prophet (al kafi : chapter 126; hadith 1391)
There’s no such thing in the Bokhari . I suggest you read the narrations . Only Shias believe in that . For example in one of these narrations it says that the Rafidi believes there are 12 imams . But clerics like that delete the first two words in the narration ( Rafidi believe)
@@Foozool what the hell are you talking about? Go and see the hadith first.
It does make sense that some would combine all types of valid leaders after Prophet Muhammad.
If the rope taken up was broken and picked up by two and Ahl Bayt had a father and two sons, if would make more sense that those were the successors.
Thanks
Jeez what drug did ibn taymiya use, did someone give him hush money?
Many were paid off.
Sectarian wars were innovated by him as sanctioned.
hush money or hashish?
@@thecritiquer9407 habibi probably both
The drug of hatred of Ahlulbayt.
Exactly
11:45 - 14:07 The Qur'an affirms answers through The Torah in Surahs 3:119, 10:94, 16:43, 21:7, 34:31.
Surahs 2:132-134, 3:84, 4:163, affirm the 12 Imams, and the 13th. This is the nation which passed away, the one which first received Islam via Imam Ali.
14:08 - 17:55 Although the 12 have passed away they continue in the afterlife as judges, as do the 12 of Yeshua ben Miriam who assumedly succeeded the 12 from Jacob. Saying they will not separate is proof in itself of the 13th Imam who comes in the end of days even as the 12 continue as judges.
Hazrat Ismail's name is mentioned 12 times in the Holy Quran
Wow. Such delicate is the book of Allah.
I keep posting my comment here however when i return to this video it seems to get deleted..
Is it because my comment has a link of another UA-cam video attached?
Most probably. As UA-cam automatically holds comments with links.
How old is this video?
6 hours old
They were originally recorded in 2018-19
@@Thaqlain Whatttt?! I thought it was just now😂
Sayed is forever young :)
@@Thaqlain Right🧐
Is it that Yasir Qadhi, Mufti Menk, Aasim Hakeem, Zakir Naik and the rest have not come across these hadiths or they just lack the wisdom to acknowledge that these 12 refers to the Imams of Ahlulbayt or they’re just hypocrites seeking the worldly fame and gains. It’s just a question.
May Allah continue to misguide those who refuse to be guided.
It's their nasibiat and munafiqat
I am Shia myself, and I will tell you that the 12 Imams is a false and have nothing to do with authentic hadiths. The only authentic is the fact that Quran and Ahlulbeit will never separate until the day of judgment. Those interested in finding this truth must search for it.
It is better either first to give a disclaimer (that you are, for example, an Ismaili) or to provide relevant proof before accusing a Mutawatir narration as false.
We assumed you to be an Ismaili because you posted a similar comment in a previous video.
Stop spreading nonsense
I am Shi'a blah blah
My friend you don't believe twelve imams you are not Shi'a
Stop the spreading bad news here
@@fs5882 You think you can fool us by saying you are a shia
Ismailis , if you are , need to take a 180dehree turn in your falsified ginads .
Who do we believe Sunni & shia scholars who say the 12 successors is an authentic hadith or a nobody on UA-cam. Who brings no evidence his only claim to fame is he claims to be a shia 🤨
We have hundreds of millions of shi'a who know better than you & disagree with you. Why do you nobody think you will know better than every other shia