FULL VIDEO: Karan Thapar Interviews Ram Guha | Fault Lines of The Republic | Karan Thapar
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 лип 2018
- Veteran journalist and television interviewer Karan Thapar speaks to one of India's leading scholars Ramachandra Guha on "Fault Lines of the Republic" at the first edition of 'The Wire Dialogues' held on July 4, 2018. Click here to support The Wire: yt.orcsnet.com/#the-wire
after many years I am watching this type of interview who can talk so true so bravely and heads off. Thank you, Mr Ram
The Wire is doing a fabulous job in bringing such subjects to the fore.
I was never communal but I supported BJP in 2014 thinking Modi has gone through a "hriday parivartan" and will bring development and take India to double digit growth. I have to say I was naive. I will NEVER vote for BJP for what they have done to the country.
shreyansh singh great brother me too.
me too. I hate anyone who don't respect the constitution of India.
RSS has become a monster like hydra in Marvel Cinematic universe - Judge, Jury & Executioner
(BJP is just a tentacle of RSS, it has no independent existence)
shreyansh singh Not only were u naive but sadly most Indians r when it comes to politics.
Mary Vasaikar nope. People voted BJP because Congress was doing so many blunders and in that time period Modi was better option than Rahul Gandhi.
People didn't expected Modi will turn into a bigger jer...
Same here
The sound of laughter in the audience... honey to my ears. A breeze to my soul. Confirms that not everybody in this country is afraid of the current regime. And they will laugh their heart out at it! Thanks so much.
We are afraid of corrupt politicians like Sonia, Pappu and Priyanka. They looted my country and likes of Karan & Guha tali baja rahe hai
@@rajnishkumarsanghi4495 yep like bjp did anything better by bringing toxic polarity and communal disharmony. Oh any pegasus said hi.
⁰
Finally thapar got someone as witty and stubborn as himself😂😂😂
Arsalan A exactly
Agree
Arsalan A yes indeed
Arsalan A
And as sold as he himself. Now throw bhakt jibe at me.
Damn! This is one of the best Wire interview ever! (As expected from Ram Guha sir!)
Modi even don't give credit to Lord Rama 😂😂😂
Liar.. He credit all old govt. all PMs .. this fellow dont like him for his own personal reasons so he is barking in public
@@puttarajbv5877 can u please show the proof, he critisized the most of the former PM's but he didn't give credit to all the PMs for their contribution to their nation. He may have appreciated sir. A B Vajpayee. Please have a check up ur head is messed with andh bhakthi
This comment on Lord made me in splits 😂😂😂😂
Great to see Karan on the Wire. Amazing feat!
"In my school days, self love meant something else"
Welcome to league the son 🤣
Pleasantly surprised to see there are not many gaalis in the comments. Is there huge attrition in BJP IT cell?
Jaya Bhattacharyya Saffron trolls don’t understand english all that well. The humour in this interview went over their heads!😆😆😆😆
Absolutely to troll someone needs basic intelligence fortunately no one from bjp it cell qualifies that
Election is coming
Actually good observations
They are saving that money to use it just before and during the elections. ;P
Citizens of India unite!!
Alon Seldou to kick out pseudo seculars
@@CD-123 Yes. Kick out all pseudos, be it seculars or nationalists.
And bigots and fundamentalists....and racists and sexists.
That's the power of Guha Sir's genius, he made the satire so subtle and endearingly acceptable that the truth is not that bitter after all. Thanks to The Wire for bringing it to us.
One of the most brilliant interviews I’ve ever seen.
What a show no words awesome
It hurts more when people knowingly stand in support of him and don't even want a realistic discussion .... Their ultimate question is 'what is the option?'
Albert Einstein so you support killings ?
Guys ... Share this to your respective social media platforms, if the thoughts resonate with you !!!
This is important.
Thank you wire
bhakts wont have a bloddy idea of whats going on here too much for their intelligence
Salim Ali Tyagi because tyagi converts whose ancestors were coward Hindus converted by sword r all IIT'ans just like u who think they r repositors
of all the knowledge in universe
Kaso ho....jihadi... N..
Muslim
Islam is a religion of destruction...not a peace
vikram shridharan please dont spread hate...
This is how an interview should be spontaneous questions and straight forward answers.
I was waiting for this video...
Thanks Wire for the interview!
The wire should have a patreon account.
Study in self love. Lol that summed up modi perfectly.
ecozonebiz Nehru presented the Bharat Ratna to Nehru
Indira gave it to Indira Gandhi
Soniya ensured every damned university and national park is named after Rajiv
Modi gave Bharat Ratna to Atal Bihari Vajpayee.
Yet it is modi who is a study in self love, right ?
Chinmay Joshi well all said and done. The psychological studies point Modi in that direction. Don't u feel This government is totally Anti People. Anti farmers. Anti Dalits. Anti OBC. Anti minorities. Anti achee din. Anti poor. Anti opposition. Anti Ambedkar. I can write a book here so I better stop.
ecozonebiz bhai what psychological studies? Any links? First of all , no accurate psychological analysis is possible without talking to the person concerned and secondly I follow every national news and I am sure no credible psychologist has done any such study on Modi's personality. As far as your rhetorical about "anti - this and anti -that" bhai no party can be anti so many groups and keep winning elections!
Chinmay Joshi well we will see in 2019. I wear a 15 lac suit (the media tells the price so u know) then I have written on the suit in bold golden threads NARENDRA DAMODAR MODI. most will say either I am Modi bhakt down to the core or utterly CHEAP. This is psycho analysis. Don't need a doctorate for that. Remember Suit boot ki Sarkar.
@@chinmayjoshi5594 thats what the problem. We'd love to talk wid him but he either gives scripted interviews or leaves out of interview if he feels cornered. He hasnt even given a single press conference.
thankful to wire ..i wish i had treasure to donate ..yet i will share this to as many as i can .. thanks
What an amazing interview. Two of the most brilliant minds in our country
Phillip Gabriel they are often accused of bias. Maybe that is a flip side of being so learned. They are not just haters they re countering on hard facts
Thank you ...@thewire_in for providing this full video on UA-cam ...Was waiting for it!
I think Ram Guha posed a very pertinent question at the start of the conversation
'Who are actually voting for Modi? & Why?'
Karan Sir I love the way you do interviews...
Please see the interview of Karan Thapar with Aarif Mohammad Khan Which epitomised how he tries his best to get guest to concur with him by pushing the same point over and over in so many different ways!
Watched such a great interview on Indian news after a long time. Wire is truly doing an incredible contribution when all the other news channels have lost their journalistic capabilities.
Absolutely right 👌👌
Real Punchline by Guha starts @ 10:06.......😆😆 and then Multiple definitions of Modi..... 😆😆😆😆
Hardeep Singh 9.04 amazing observations.
Now I know why he writes these huge volumes.
When I see Modi and his 1.5 sycophants.. I am reminded of Kiran Desai from The Inheritance of Loss : He knew that the way to coax strength, power and fame was to pretend that it existed.
I am happy to see such good people in my country....two best journalists I respect...
WOW!! How prophetic of Ram!! Listen the end of interview and understand Pulwama + Balakot = Victory.
wutever indira gandhi did...her vision fr India was much different thn tht of modi...she wanted india to be in the league of elite n scientifically developed secular democratic country.She had lov fr her country n its countryment irrespectiv of caste gender religion...n wut modi wants is just absolute power at the expense of the evrything thts bful in the country .he has no hesitation to bring this country to a desastrous end shud he retain his pm ship..
she even wanted to cut any corporate funding to political parties but morarji desai jeopardized the plan, the result is corporate are running the country now.
ravin is there any reference to that.. She was suspicious of his ethics and excellence and got him killed.
@@sootheseeker Was Morarji Desai killed?It would take a lot to kill a Guju.
Shekhar , nonsense. She would have had to come back from heaven or purgatory or wherever the dead go to have him killed! She died in 1984 and Moraji died in 1995. Stop spreading rumours that haven't an iota of truth in them!
I think they should have a talk show with humour involved in it. These are the people whom nation actually wants to hear.
R Guha should debate Subramanian swami .. that would be interesting 😁
An intellectual vs ?
He is not of level to debate Subramanian swamy. Historian known for distorting Indian History.
Ram guha accepting on point he never votes for BJP 😁😀😀😂😀
Because he talks about reality and I met him many time he is very simple ,I know him
His mother says that you are like my child ,so many time his mother came in our house they all are well educated and honest person
One more great person is there who doesn't come in news and social media such a gentleman he was I live with him 5years ,
I would never seen a person like him
His name (Seshadri Ratnam ,)
He was such a super man
I am always impressed by the analysis that Mr. Ram Guha brings forth to all the existing problems. His observations on personalities appear impartial. I am also impressed by Mr. Karan Thapar interviewing style.
In last they said the wire is unbiased news channel.
Well I have watched nearly 30 interviews of karan Thapar and he proved his loyalty to Congress always
where are the bhakts ,or they dont understand english
career guidance some bhakts are here...with fake name like arsalan...
They are not ‘Bhakts’. They are ‘Modi Fools’. They are not aware, they are being fooled in the name of religion.
sheldon pereira Christian fundamentalists r more pissed than mullas
spoken like a true pandya
sasi kumar funddementalists dude how do u invent these words???
57:20 It is so scary that Ramachandra Guha sir accurately predicted the Modi-Shah Duo's tricks that may be applied before the 2019 elections. Exactly what happened just a few months before the elections - the Pulwama attacks and the subsequent air strikes. Really makes you wonder if the whole unfortunate incident was a coincidence after all..
I have read somewhere - "Historians possess the telescope to the future." That certainly seems true in case of this interview.
R. Guha is also very funny😂 Thank you 'the wire' for this interview 👍
'Atleast He is not as Vile as Modi. He may never get my Respect but my Vote'.
MOST INTERESTING QUOTE IN THIS TO THINK.
Modi fans cannot even understand the conversation. Run 1 mile from karan, just like Modi.
Death to Jewmerica & IsraHell! @ i dont like your name.
No, one can be completely opposed to Modi, as I am, and take issue with your blatantly racist name. In fact, we oppose the Modi government primarily because of the anti-Muslim racism being stirred up. We cannot support anti-Jewish racism either.
By the way, I am strongly pro-Palestine and strongly oppose Israeli state policy. But even then, your name is inexcusably racist.
That is the reason Modi ran away from Karan's interview.He was totally flommoxed by the impeccable English and sauve presence of Thapar.It brougjt out Modi's plebian background seriously discforting to the crass Modi.No wonder heumbled something about wanting to drink water!
@Albert Einstein @ well as a person who cares about peoples prosperity, i am. People who voted him again are idiots or anti nationals. May be you can say, terrorists.
His heart bleeds for a forest fire in Portugal 😅😂😂
Well he is bitterly true. Modi lacks one of the best traits of a true leader ie. sharing credits of success with others and taking full charge of failures - something MS Dhoni or APJ Abdul Kalam had.
'a case study in self love' 😁😁😁😁
The most intelligent historian of our era....
Anybody else scared for the future of India ?
Pappu, Mayawati, Mamta DoDo, Akhilesh Yadav, Arvind Khujliwal, Sharad Padav, and a host of Anti-Nationals like Kanhaiya, Khalid, Bhattacharya, and to top it all Lallu Yadav
amazing use of words..basically they are saying rahul gandhi is better than MODI.......HATS OFF
Thank you for putting up the whole video.
Was really looking forward to this.
Simply Awesome!!!
To understand Modi's character one should read The Caravan special issue on Gowalkar, Modi is a great admirer of Gowalkar. Gowalkar was an educated fella, but carried a deep-seated hatred for Gandhiji, and he minced no words in eliminating Gandhi ! No wonder Modi follows guys who called Gauri Lankesh a 'kutia' even after her death ! this can be called a degradation of ones own values of character. See the mysterious death of Judge Loya in conjunction with the death of Dhabolkar, Pansare, Kalburgi,Gauri Lankesh, Ishrat Jahan, Sohrabuddin, Haren Pandaya, and the riots perpetrated at Koregaon ! Imprisonment of Azad, and the atrocities on the Dalits. he is certainly a dishonest PM India has ever had.
History may remember Narendra Modi as the most popular Indian PM but history will not be kind to him
It was a treat to ears. Great analysis
Thanks for bringing up this interview just before elections and people now have made a choice. Kudos to you both.
गुड़ जॉब गुहा sir
A great chat..we need more like these
Please take more interviews.
RamGuha as always 👌👌👌
Incredible
A person who can’t analyse proper English or Hindi notes and governs by gut feelings of understanding and executing powers without grasping the entire complexity of an issue cannot be in a powerful position where his or her judgement effects billions.
Neywin Mongmaw That makes it far worse. I hope people realize it and let some educated and sensible folks out there.
Neywin Mongmaw very well summed up.
the way you put it is superb
True.
Modiji, even after 4 years in PM chair, remains more interested in Power that comes from the office.. He is still to (may not ever) exhibit the responsibility that is due on the Chair.. That's why he is seen as a Powerful PM but not as a Responsible PM.. There is no example of any instance when he has shown being responsible.. be it on his action, or through his words, or his orders, or the debates he unleashes...
The Election campaign for 2019 would be centred around fear, division of society, negativity, etc. The coming campaign would be frightening to common masses.. fabric of society will face the deadliest attack ever in history of the nation. The Hawk is out there looking for its prey...
His desire to be hugged by leaders who do not want him to hug them 😆lol
😂 Karan thapar and modi interview was the best interview ever
Too much intelligence on the dias. Ram Guha one of my favorite author
nither hindutva not Islam is going to decide our fate, religions are for human and humans are not for relegion. in other countries this isn't an issue but we even after 70 years are fighting over this.
I would say all these intellectual rubbish.
humanity prevails
Bro you are correct. Religion is for the people not for the government. Sadly politicians use religion for governances all around the world and gets messed up. No development in any filed but damages the whole struggle for development.
What an interview!👏👏
If any bjp politician made an anti-muslim comment before 2014 there used to be a huge uproar in the media..they were usually reprimanded by their high command and often labelled as fringe elements..but now most of them are actively doing it on a regular basis
This interview was just too good
Witty and informative
Mr.Guha is a narrowly broadminded version who is known as a visionary.
After all the apt criticism, Thapar starts to peddle Rahul as a stalwart after 49-50mins in the show ... LOL...
Sensibly I will say this is all true
Please bring out a publication of this wonderful interview..its the need of the moment.
I want to contribute to your channel. I don't see the links anymore.
What mr guha said about Christian is 200% correct
Think he made some very valid points on Narendra Moron sorry i meant Modi.
Please do comment after a month whether you are still alive or out of jail 😂
aditya burgerfuel LOL 😂
Ankur Mishra The fuck!You ever heard of sarcasm? Why would a person I am threatening reply to me with a lol message.Such q dumbfuck you are
no it was not funny at all. also you bring to shame all the democratic people who have been put in jail or killed while they were doing their duty.
hahah ... Nice one
Awisome थापर जी
Ram sir has a prophetic vision when he says that the duo will come up with something spectacular before 2019 elections n spectacular is something that happened jus before the election which swayed the voters towards bjp
Just amazing,
thanks for sharing The Wire
All the congress men he has spoken to are wise, educated, sensible, speak to the point, and think about the people, great leaders and have good intention. Its shocking that they all think Rahul Gandhi is the best person to represent them and their party.
Is he the Most powerful than Indira Gandhi?
Not possible
Syed Afsar yes he can't be b'coz indira imposed emergency to save her position......modi didn't......modi would be powerful in ending triple and halala
@@naturebeauty5037 yep he is also allowed "one" of the biggest riot to carry on, india has seen.
@sidharth vardhRajan
Best Team and timing of this
Event....
More power to You
Partly agreed with him... Some points are right
I feel sorry for the creatures who have disliked this Wonderful conversation
Absolute savagery.Kept the conversation very interesting.kudos to Thapar too,asking vital issues to both BJP and Congress ministers and now Ram Guha
Superb commentry on the state of India's present and future.
THE GREATS RESPECT AND LOVE
I don't know, how many of you are educate enough to know about the present situation, but it is a request to look into all the matters seriously because present scenario is one of the worst of all time in India.
Yes things like this happened before but not on that large scare, previously some Google developer was not killed in mob this time it does, previously prime minister attended public media conference but this he does not want to face the truth, previously corruption was in thousand crore range this time it is in lakh crore range. But the point is we didn't give vote to prime minister to just compare present figures with past, this thing we can do ourself. He needs to be faithful with his promises for the peoples of India.
It is a request to all to look into the present situation in depth.
This comment is more than relevant now.
Thank you vardhRajan for listening
Just loved this debate.
I wish this interview was available in hindi so that more people understand.
Ram Guha is as witty as Karan Thapar this is lit
I will say it was there overconfidence which has reduced their popularity . Demonetisation will hurt them a lot. However the kind of money power they have you can never predict the future
Shaandar :)
'Acche din' is a tube light that chocked.
Ram guha provided the much needed unbaised view of the present day government. The reality is,regardless of what we say it is going to be tough to beat modi
NIteNdRa pRAtAp SInGh 😂 He's already beaten in Rajasthan both in d elections n the rally 😂
Mary Vasaikar what that has anything to do with this interview?
@@CD-123 that seems mildly ignorant. Read a few books by Guha. He is fairly leftist, but he has great opinions.
Banner in the background??!!