Thanks for your kind words. Updated version is here: ua-cam.com/video/4PJKe12mUvs/v-deo.html Let me know whether other topics interest you. You might also find my website helpful: uslawessentials.com
This way the BEST VIDEO of breaking it down. Thank you! Simple and able to get the information. It explains in detail. My professor directed me here. So glad she did.
thank you so much! finally a video that does not waffle and just gets straight to the point. its so easy to understand now that you explained it. idk why these other videos on UA-cam feel the need to waffle so much.
Thanks for stopping by. If you are interested I have more material with videos on the US government and legal system on my website: uslawessentials.com/us-government-us-legal-system/constitution-distribution-power/ uslawessentials.com/us-government-us-legal-system/constitution-distribution-power/the-constitution-and-compromise/
There is an updated version of this video ua-cam.com/video/4PJKe12mUvs/v-deo.html You might like to visit the uslawessentials website, too uslawessentials.com
That's kind of you Max. There's an updated version of the video which I think is a bit more appealing stylistically: ua-cam.com/video/4PJKe12mUvs/v-deo.html. On my website there is additional information on the Consitution and federal and state court systems: goo.gl/lzqMQP ; goo.gl/5DtEPG My blog is here: uslawessentials.com/blog If there are other topics that interest you please let me know.
Madie Leigh Thanks Madie. I think I made a slightly updated version which should be on the channel somewhere. All the best to you. www.uslawessentials.com
awesome job sir thank you sooooooo much you are a great teacher you do not know how much this simple quick and easy to understand video helped me in writing this paper keep up the great work !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
+Precious Johnson Thanks PJ. I hope it was a helpful introduction. You're welcome to stop by my website uslawessentials.com and my FB page. goo.gl/2qxEIy
+Eva De Leon Hi Eva, thank you. No explanation is perfect . . . But I appreciate your kind words. You might find the material I uploaded here helpful: uslawessentials.atavist.com/constitution-distribution-of-power
Trumps rant about having power to open States sent me here. So basically he does have the power but according to federal government the state government has that power
That's actually a very good question. The federal government almost certainly does not have power under the Constitution to compel states to re-open. It does not have the power to do other things (such as immigration policies in response to the pandemic).The federal government also could have taken the lead in coordinating steps to combat the pandemic intelligently. It did not. For some of the reasons that led to this failure, please see this article: www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2020/06/underlying-conditions/610261/
Reed, thanks. This was an early video I worked on and tried to improve some of the sound and visuals here: ua-cam.com/video/fF3EvltwHYk/v-deo.html If you're researching federalism I hope this was a good start and thanks again for your kind comment.
KIM LORI Kim, 1. Thanks for your kind comment on the videos. 2. I cannot give you answers if this is for school because that would not be right. But I'm happy to help you think about your answers. By the way, I just started a message board on my website and you should feel free to register and post ideas and questions:(@forum) To answer your question you need to realize that the question requires you to identify two things to answer it correctly. First, of the four choices you listed, which were Madison's proposals with regard to the US national government? Second, which of these proposals was tied to protecting people's rights and the public good? Start thinking along those lines and let me know your thoughts.
Hi Kim, 1. Unfortunately I can’t tell you whether your answer is right or wrong because that might be considered cheating. 2. But here is a way that you can determine the correct answer. You need two magic words: (i) Why and (ii) Because If you think answer number one is correct, ask yourself why you think that. Can you find a book or article written by a reputable historian which states that Madison supported direct lawmaking by citizens? Better yet, take a look at what Madison himself wrote in Federalist No.10. There is a good article on Federalist No. 10 in Wikipedia actually so you can start with that. By reading these resources you can determine what Madison thought of direct lawmaking. You will also be able to determine the correct answer to the question. 3. Here is something to think about as you do your reading. Let's say 100 people live in a small town. 90 people vote to do "X." Unfortunately, "X" is very bad and unfair to the other 10 people. Did Madison have any ideas on how to address this type of potential problem in the early days of our country?
Both. As with other issues facing the country as a whole and where there is a large-scale disaster, the federal government had the power to take the lead. The federal government could have coordinated a national response by disclosing the danger as opposed to denying its existence, helping to prepare the country with testing kits, ventilators, safely testing people entering the country, etc. The federal government did not fulfill its role in response to the pandemic and the result has been horrifying. States have the power to take important steps within each state such as closing schools and enforcing other rules to reduce the spread of the virus.
+Brandon Igiehon Thanks Brandon. I'll be updating my videos and adding new material so please check back. You can also see material on my website uslawessentials.com If there are topics that interest you let me know.
+BRK Thanks BRK! I have a FB page now where you can can see an updated version. Please come by if you can ( goo.gl/2qxEIy) I'll post notices there about courses and online tutoring. Anyway, thanks for watching.
MNgocMinah No federal government means that the federal has a power where they have laws the counts equally for every states that unifies them that where you have the president congress etc But the state power is where the state has it’s own power which mean that each state is different between how they rule their state fx California state is not the same as you have en fx Florida state I hope you get the picture here
+USLawEssentials Well I actually don't have any idea if ever that there will be a Federelism in the Philippines.but how about the Pres wanted to implement this kind of Federelism in our country does still need to bring to Congress or Senate before they implement this kind of Government? or the Pres can implement right away without the further talks.
+Grace Bravo Trust me, you know much more about this than I do. Perhaps it would be accomplished through changes to the Philippine Constitution or through legislative change? I'd be surprised if the Philippine president could do this on his own authority, but again, I'm just guessing. Sorry I'm not more help.
In your explanation, you are stating that federal government is national power and suggesting that state government is not the same thing as as federal government. However, federalism definition is the authority shared between national & sub-national (i.e. state) level.
This seems a little revisionist to me. The word "federal" as in "the federal government", has nothing to do with sharing power with the states. Federalism is simply having an overarching national government. It is the Constitution that dictated that power would be shared with the states; that was not a feature of federalism originally. It was the price the states exacted for joining the Union - that they be allowed to maintain some autonomy.
Hi, not sure what exactly you mean by "good" but it was a successful compromise. I talk about it a bit here: uslawessentials.com/constitution-distribution-power-part-ii-constitution-compromise/
first 10 seconds taught me everything I spent hours googling. tysm.
Better explained than my teacher at school. Thank you Sir.
Thanks for your kind words. Updated version is here: ua-cam.com/video/4PJKe12mUvs/v-deo.html Let me know whether other topics interest you. You might also find my website helpful: uslawessentials.com
This way the BEST VIDEO of breaking it down. Thank you! Simple and able to get the information. It explains in detail. My professor directed me here. So glad she did.
thank you so much! finally a video that does not waffle and just gets straight to the point. its so easy to understand now that you explained it. idk why these other videos on UA-cam feel the need to waffle so much.
who else got this assigned by teachers?
Me!!!!
me
me\
me
Easy explanation .. Thank You.
+Ashfaquzzaman Chowdhury Thanks AC. If you stop by our Facebook page you can see an updated version. goo.gl/2qxEIy
Great explanation thanks!
Thank you! Much easier to understand than those crazy crash course videos.
Great explanation! This system of government is simply genius!
I am taking a class on American politics and I found this video helpful and easy to understand. Thanks!
I love this explanation. It’s easy to understand.
Thank you for summing it up for me
Thanks for stopping by. If you are interested I have more material with videos on the US government and legal system on my website:
uslawessentials.com/us-government-us-legal-system/constitution-distribution-power/
uslawessentials.com/us-government-us-legal-system/constitution-distribution-power/the-constitution-and-compromise/
sooo boring
+Savaliya Juhi shut up bitch
thank you for explaining it in a nutshell...this is what's happening in the philippines right now..our current president is pushing for federalism
My textbook was just confusing me, this video made it much easier to understand. Thank you.
Cebby Thanks Cebby. I hope it's a helpful introduction and you can tackle your textbook easier now. uslawessentials.com/forum uslawessentials.com/blog
Your video was explained well. It was very informative. My understanding of federalism increased because of you. Thank you so much.
Thanks, updated version is here: ua-cam.com/video/4PJKe12mUvs/v-deo.html You can also visit the uslawessentials website at uslawessentials.com
loud and clear..:)
jigs Thanks!
This was so helpful! Thank you.
There is an updated version of this video ua-cam.com/video/4PJKe12mUvs/v-deo.html You might like to visit the uslawessentials website, too uslawessentials.com
Very easy, short and understandable explanation.. Good job on the video, and thanks for the help
That's kind of you Max. There's an updated version of the video which I think is a bit more appealing stylistically: ua-cam.com/video/4PJKe12mUvs/v-deo.html.
On my website there is additional information on the Consitution and federal and state court systems: goo.gl/lzqMQP ; goo.gl/5DtEPG My blog is here: uslawessentials.com/blog
If there are other topics that interest you please let me know.
Max Taylor it really is
Eo Two?
Thanks for your lectures
Hey im from canada and wondering how you can start a new province or a new "state". Like a new child of nationalism
This video help me so much! I will recommend it!
Madie Leigh Thanks Madie. I think I made a slightly updated version which should be on the channel somewhere. All the best to you. www.uslawessentials.com
now i know why some people want federalsm
Yes, thank You for Your concise explanation with historical context.
This video is nice I could understand everything so once again thanking nice video
Thank you!!!
Thanks. Updated version is here: ua-cam.com/video/4PJKe12mUvs/v-deo.html
thank u federalism is foundation
of world and world should adopt the federalism to make our world ,a world of peace and prosperity
Thankyou for this explanation.
This is so incredibly helpdul
Dude this is awesome! Well done!
thank you for explaining
Oh I get it now!
Very very enthusiastic! Thank you!
WOW I NEED THIS FOR MIDTERMS.. SO EASY AND CLEAR ... EXCELLENT
Good to hear. Thanks. Let me know if there are other topics of interest to you.
USLawEssentials The best video, thank you so much.
awesome job sir thank you sooooooo much you are a great teacher you do not know how much this simple quick and easy to understand video helped me in writing this paper keep up the great work !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
+Precious Johnson Thanks PJ. I hope it was a helpful introduction. You're welcome to stop by my website uslawessentials.com and my FB page. goo.gl/2qxEIy
Perfect explanation! Thank you, sir.
+Eva De Leon Hi Eva, thank you. No explanation is perfect . . . But I appreciate your kind words. You might find the material I uploaded here helpful:
uslawessentials.atavist.com/constitution-distribution-of-power
THANK YOU!!! for this great video
good way of explanation. thankyou!
Thanks! updated video is here: ua-cam.com/video/4PJKe12mUvs/v-deo.html
you are simply great. thousand thumb up
Better explained
Thanks
im happy thnx for xplaining....
with love from india.....
thnx so muxh
Thanks. Updated version is here: ua-cam.com/video/4PJKe12mUvs/v-deo.html
Allrounder rahul q
I watched this because my country is looking at this as the new form of government
good explanation
great explanation!!! very good to understand it easily!!
+Cecilia Mata Thanks Cecilia. You can see a new version of the video on the USLawEssentials Facebook page goo.gl/2qxEIy
Thank you for sharing!
Hi, updated video is here: ua-cam.com/video/4PJKe12mUvs/v-deo.html
More here: uslawessentials.com
Thank u! That was easy to understand 😄
Thanks, updated version is here: ua-cam.com/video/4PJKe12mUvs/v-deo.html
Let me know if other topics interest you.
uslawessentials.com
Thanks amillion
Great summary! Good job!
Thank you very much ! It was very helpful !
Peace out !
Updated version is here: ua-cam.com/video/4PJKe12mUvs/v-deo.html More content is here: uslawessentials.com
nice.Just what I was looking for.
Tajinder Singh Good to hear, thanks!
Thank you
Thanks for watching. Updated video is here: ua-cam.com/video/4PJKe12mUvs/v-deo.html
Incredible
Thanks a ton for this perfect video!!!
Trumps rant about having power to open States sent me here. So basically he does have the power but according to federal government the state government has that power
That's actually a very good question. The federal government almost certainly does not have power under the Constitution to compel states to re-open. It does not have the power to do other things (such as immigration policies in response to the pandemic).The federal government also could have taken the lead in coordinating steps to combat the pandemic intelligently. It did not. For some of the reasons that led to this failure, please see this article: www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2020/06/underlying-conditions/610261/
@@USLawEssentials OMG thank you for your quick response. I will definitely be subscribing to your channel !!
This really helped! Thanks so much
This is so much easier than google!
Reed, thanks. This was an early video I worked on and tried to improve some of the sound and visuals here:
ua-cam.com/video/fF3EvltwHYk/v-deo.html
If you're researching federalism I hope this was a good start and thanks again for your kind comment.
KIM LORI Kim,
1. Thanks for your kind comment on the videos.
2. I cannot give you answers if this is for school because that would not be right. But I'm happy to help you think about your answers. By the way, I just started a message board on my website and you should feel free to register and post ideas and questions:(@forum)
To answer your question you need to realize that the question requires you to identify two things to answer it correctly. First, of the four choices you listed, which were Madison's proposals with regard to the US national government? Second, which of these proposals was tied to protecting people's rights and the public good? Start thinking along those lines and let me know your thoughts.
My answer is 1- direct lawmaking by citizens, is correct ?? Thank you so much.
Hi Kim,
1. Unfortunately I can’t tell you whether your answer is right or wrong because that might be considered cheating.
2. But here is a way that you can determine the correct answer. You need two magic words:
(i) Why and (ii) Because
If you think answer number one is correct, ask yourself why you think that. Can you find a book or article written by a reputable historian which states that Madison supported direct lawmaking by citizens? Better yet, take a look at what Madison himself wrote in Federalist No.10. There is a good article on Federalist No. 10 in Wikipedia actually so you can start with that.
By reading these resources you can determine what Madison thought of direct lawmaking.
You will also be able to determine the correct answer to the question.
3. Here is something to think about as you do your reading. Let's say 100 people live in a small town. 90 people vote to do "X." Unfortunately, "X" is very bad and unfair to the other 10 people. Did Madison have any ideas on how to address this type of potential problem in the early days of our country?
Thank you Sir for your explanation.
In your graphic of New York State, you left off Long Island. It is only a major component of the state.
Interesting
Where does management of covid-19 rest? Which authority ?
Both. As with other issues facing the country as a whole and where there is a large-scale disaster, the federal government had the power to take the lead. The federal government could have coordinated a national response by disclosing the danger as opposed to denying its existence, helping to prepare the country with testing kits, ventilators, safely testing people entering the country, etc. The federal government did not fulfill its role in response to the pandemic and the result has been horrifying. States have the power to take important steps within each state such as closing schools and enforcing other rules to reduce the spread of the virus.
thanks very helpful
+Brandon Igiehon Thanks Brandon. I'll be updating my videos and adding new material so please check back. You can also see material on my website uslawessentials.com If there are topics that interest you let me know.
So this was mainly intended for the states right?
very good !!!!
+BRK Thanks BRK! I have a FB page now where you can can see an updated version. Please come by if you can ( goo.gl/2qxEIy) I'll post notices there about courses and online tutoring. Anyway, thanks for watching.
how can i find it?
I used this video to check on my test
I still can't define the states' right can you tell me about it ?
So this is just American Federalism, not about Federalism in general.
Nice vid
+Ronda Jones Thanks Ronda.
So the states government is just tiny parts of federal goverment?
MNgocMinah
No federal government means that the federal has a power where they have laws the counts equally for every states that unifies them that where you have the president congress etc
But the state power is where the state has it’s own power which mean that each state is different between how they rule their state fx California state is not the same as you have en fx Florida state
I hope you get the picture here
Do you think that Federilsm is good for the country like Philippines?
+Grace Bravo Hi, I'm sorry, I don't have enough knowledge regarding the issue. I assume it's still an ongoing debate? What do you think?
+USLawEssentials
Well I actually don't have any idea if ever that there will be a Federelism in the Philippines.but how about the Pres wanted to implement this kind of Federelism in our country does still need to bring to Congress or Senate before they implement this kind of Government? or the Pres can implement right away without the further talks.
+Grace Bravo Trust me, you know much more about this than I do. Perhaps it would be accomplished through changes to the Philippine Constitution or through legislative change? I'd be surprised if the Philippine president could do this on his own authority, but again, I'm just guessing. Sorry I'm not more help.
In your explanation, you are stating that federal government is national power and suggesting that state government is not the same thing as as federal government. However, federalism definition is the authority shared between national & sub-national (i.e. state) level.
This seems a little revisionist to me. The word "federal" as in "the federal government", has nothing to do with sharing power with the states. Federalism is simply having an overarching national government. It is the Constitution that dictated that power would be shared with the states; that was not a feature of federalism originally. It was the price the states exacted for joining the Union - that they be allowed to maintain some autonomy.
Your dumb
@@ridinngsoloo Says the guy who misspelled half the words of his response...
A
Your voice sounds like jschaltt minecraft
Why was federalism good for America
Hi, not sure what exactly you mean by "good" but it was a successful compromise. I talk about it a bit here: uslawessentials.com/constitution-distribution-power-part-ii-constitution-compromise/
bruh
I understand nothing lol
thank u federalism is foundation
of world and world should adopt the federalism to make our world ,a world of peace and prosperity