Vegetarian VS Non-Vegetarian ? एकेन्द्रिय VS पंचेन्द्रिय ? मांसाहार में शाकाहार से अधिक पाप क्यों ?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 2 жов 2024
- मांसाहार (Non Vegetarian) भक्षण करने में शाकाहार (Vegetarian) भक्षण करने से ज्यादा पाप क्यों होता है ? Why Vegetarianism Is Better Than Non Vegetarianism | Logical Reasoning | Jain Food Science |
प्रणाम,
कई लोग शाकाहार का विरोध करते हुए यह कुतर्क करते हैं कि फल सब्जी में भी जीव है और मुर्गे बकरी गाय में भी जीव है, और जीव यानी आत्मा तो सब में समान होती है तो Vegetarian खाने में उतना ही पाप लगेगा जितना Non Veg खाने में लगेगा ! तो इस बड़ी समस्या का समाधान करते हुए हमारे जैन शास्त्रों में एकेन्द्रिय (Veg) यानी जिन जीवों में एक ही इन्द्रिय यानी Sense होता है जैसे भिन्डी, ककड़ी आदि और पंचेन्द्रिय (Non Veg) यानी वो जीव जिनमें पाँचों इन्द्रियाँ होती है जैसे मनुष्य, जानवर आदि में क्या भेद है वह स्पष्ट रूप से बताया गया जिसे उदाहरण यानी Examples आदि द्वारा Logical Reasons के साथ इस प्रस्तुति के माध्यम से समझने का प्रयास करेंगे !
जय जिनशासन
जय महावीर
#jainism #jaindharm #jainreligion #jains #jain #jainstatus #vegetarian #nonvegetarian #confusion #solution #jainfoodscience #ekendriya #panchendriya #logical #facts #reasons #jainismupdates #explorejainism #shakahaar #mansahaar #jinshasan #jainmedia
Vegetarian VS Non Vegetarian
Ekendriya VS Panchendriya
Logical Reasons
Why Non - Vegetarianism Is More Cruel Than Vegetarianism ?
Jain Food Science
Jain Lifestyle
Jain Food Rules
Do Subscribe JAIN MEDIA SHORTS Channel To Watch Short Videos/Reels Of Jain Media : / @jainmediashorts
To Join Jain Media’s WhatsApp Group
Kindly Save +91 7200805050 And Send Us Your Name and City (Via WhatsApp).
Contact Jain Media - jainmediainfo@gmail.com
Join Our Telegram Group For Updates : t.me/joinchat/...
Join Jain Media Membership :
/ @jainmedia
========================================
Subscribe Us On UA-cam - / jainmedia
Like Us On Facebook - / jainmedia
Follow Us On Instagram - / jainmedia
Our Website - jainmedia.in/
i'm sanatani and i'm pure vegetarian from birth.... love to Jain brothers..... Jay Siya Ram...Jay Mahavir
जय जिनेन्द्र , जय सिया राम
To add : हिंसा की दृष्टि से हिंसा करने वाले के भावों में एकेन्द्रिय से पंचेन्द्रिय के प्रति भावों में क्रूरता बढ़ेगी तो ही हिंसा होगी.. एकेन्द्रिय की हिंसा में क्रूरता कम चाहिए.. मच्छर की हिंसा में क्रूरता अधिक चाहिए.. और फिर पंचेन्द्रिय की हिंसा में तो क्रूरता की पराकाष्ठा चाहिए.... इसलिए नॉन वेज भक्षण से स्वयं में क्रूरता के कितने गहरे संस्कार विकसित होते हैं.... अधिकतम लोग खुद पंचेन्द्रिय वध करने योग्य क्रूरता नहीं रखते पर उसका भक्षण करते हैं.. भविष्य में यह क्या ही अनुमोदना का संस्कार किस रूप में परिवर्तित होगा...
I didn't understand
Go Vegan 💚
बहुत ही अच्छा समझाया
1 more resaon is agr non veg walo ko ped podhe bachane unko sabse pegle nonveg chod na hoga kyu ki jab koi animal 15 kg ghas phus khayega tab 1 to 2 kg maas milega very high loss
👏Great explanation!👏
I think non-jain log dekhe toh voh bhi vegetarian ban jayenge🔥💯
I am already half Jain. I don't eat non veg food but I still consume onion garlic potato carrot and other vegetables grown underground
Bahot hi sundar tarike se vakhyan kiya bro🙏
🙏❤️ Jai jinendra ❤️🙏
जय जिनेन्द्र 🙏🙏
Very nice
Wahhh!! What an excellent, analytical logical and mind blowing explanation... each question here is making the listeners think deeply... A very high levels skills are required to present this important debate in a simplified way. The explanation was vwry very good bhaiya... God gifted man buddhi hai aapke...
These kind of skills which everyone should learn to develop their intelligence in the perspective of interview, logical based exams, communication skills and problem solving skills etc..
Jai mahavir swami ❤️✨
Yeh sab Dev guru Krupa se hi mumkin hota hai
Great explanation. Khub khub anumodna. Also Refer dada bhagvan's Ahinsa book. Jai jinendra.
We will support you ❤️
जय जिनशासन जय महावीर 🙏❤️🙏
हमेशा की तरह खूब ही सरल और सारगर्भित तरीके से समझाया खूब खूब अनुमोदन
Excellent explanation ❤
Mehul Bhai pls make videos on navkar mantra ke real life chamatkar of common people, like cancer me chamatkar through navkar, or any impossible situation got in control with this mantra..., Den lifestory of pujya bhadrankar vijayji... Pls pls🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
हमारी दूध और डेयरी प्रॉडक्ट्स की मांग के लिए रोज लाखों गाय और भैंसों की की कत्ल होती है और मांसाहार सस्ते में बाजार में बिकता है
2600 साल पहले भगवान महावीर स्वामी ने तो ओरिजिनल गाय के दूध का भी निषेध क्या था तो यह दूध हम कैसे ले सकते हैं क्यों इसका कोई विरोध नहीं होता कृपया बताने की मेहरबानी करें
आपने काफी सुंदर विश्लेषण किया
even they know the fact more violation involved in cutting panchindraya and that's why they will take their child to place where people cut vegetables but will never prefer to take their child to slaughter house...
Plus the amount of global warming done because of non vegetarian is huge. Non veg is going to be the biggest reason for water shortage in the future.
True..
Plz make video on why we should not go to restuarants which serves vegetarian and non-vegetarian food.
Aapka ye message bahut achha laga. Mein Europe me rehta hoon aur vegetable siraf khanese achhi sahad rehtihay lemon vitamin s supplements Lena padtahai. To India me vo kaise solve karate hain? Dhayavaad😊
Ek baat or, panchandriya ko zinda rehne ke liye ekindriya anaj adi ka bhakshan to karna he padega or fir us panchandriya ka bhakshan agar hum karege to hume ekendriya or panchandriya dono ke bhakshan ka paap lagega.
Well said🙏
Sir please is point pr bhi video layiye ki , Jains Mushroom 🍄 kyu nhi khaate ?
Si mai pure vegetarian hu to kya mai sahi hu ya galt hu
Aapne ye topic pe vedio bnaya thank u...
I am not Jan but I am vejiteriyn.
Great explanation. Khub khub anumodna. Also Refer dada bhagvan's Ahinsa book. Jai jinendra.
Good job 👏🏻 100percent agreed
please stay without eating
Hello sir, what if there is an 'Ahimsa' solution to household cockroaches in say kicthen?
please make logical reasoning on murti also that it has power with scientific reasons🙏💝 @jainmedia
Feedback noted
Thanks
17 Dec ko hone wale GIRNAR AADOLAN ke liye bhi video banaye or sabko jagruk kare.
Its time to show jain unity,
Jai Neminath,Jai Girnar
Thanks
So satisfied ans 😊
Mehul bhaii well explaination this video is amazing ❤❤❤
Kya dogs ko pedigree dena sahi hai ? Usme non veg hota hai..agar gharwale muje force kare dogs ko pedigree dene to kya karna chahiye
Very important topic 💯 .. thank u so much for covering this in so detailed way Mehul bhai. I hope now people will understand why Jainism is not a religion but a way of living a life 💯❤️
What nonsense
I love Beef❤
This is a very good concept. You have tried best to explain but still feeling something is missing in your explanation to support this argument. Please continue to explore more.
I have posted this as a comment and am writing to you as well. I have also heard that "more the senses, more the pain", and so more sins. Lives with only one sense of touch, as seen in Ekendriya, may have only fear when they get touched by something. They are unaware what's going to happen to them. But Lives with more senses, let's consider Panchendriya, will also be able to see, and sense other pain of other lives. In slaughter house, when they are stood in the series, or when kept in the cages, they see what happens to the other ones... it may be their family member, we may never know, so that emotional attachment and pain can also be there... even if its ignored, they hear the screams of the others and they try to leave from the grip to save their lives...so killing them is obviously more sinful. What a poor argument they make.... Look at the life, which doesn't know anything and is not even trying to protect itself... you show mercy for them and make vegetarians to feel guilty? whereas the life which (with the additional senses) knows what's going to happen to them and who want to live, and is screaming... you don't show mercy to them???
Superbly explained
I want to know
Kya Jain dharm ke sutra disease cure kar sakte ?
Yes ofcourse
@@jeevanbhanushivir818 may I know kaun kaun se ?
Very nice explanation bhai 🙏 u explained in very deep nd detailed, . Proud to be a vegeteraian, proud to be jain 🙏 jai Aadinath 🙏
BGM (background music) thoda aur kam kar do.. Throughout the video irritate karta hai.
Ya bgm nikal hi do. 🙏
Bahut achhe example aur deeply samjaya mehul bhai
Dhanya vad aapka 🙏
Excellent explanation and very intelligent analogy. Thank you very much. I hope this video reaches as many people as possible. As now being a vegetarian, we will much more clearly and precisely be able to explain the logic behind why eating one sensed being is less harmful vs. eating higher sensed beings. 👏👏👏🙏🙏
🙏🙏🙏
Very nice very very nice explained
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏👍👌
Very Nicely Explained With the same arguments given by Non vegiterian people❤❤❤❤,🙏🙏🙏🙏❤️
Nice explanation and example 🙏
This is too logical.. I was zoned out.. I am vegan only for the animals.. That they shouldn't feel pain.. Just as i fear pain.. Run away from it. No one wants pain.. No living being..but I loved the analysis 😊..Minute analysis
Plant biologist Simcha Lev-Yadun, from the University of Haifa (Israel), lists for OpenMind the senses that we tend to think of as exclusive to animals, but which also exist in plants: they see, hear, smell and taste, and of course respond to touch.
Well explained
Jay Ho Pujyashree Gurudev pranam and khub khub Anumodana pranam 🙏🙏🙏❤️
Beautifully explained. Jo Hindu dharm ke Guru vegetarian food promote karte hai unko yeh video dekhna chahiye. Woh bina kisi logic ke logo ko vegetarian food khane ko bolte hai par unke pravachan main logic gayab rehta hai sirf emotions se kaam kar rahe hote hain
Good logical explanation!!! I also heard that "more the senses, more the pain", and so more sins. Lives with only one sense of touch, as seen in Ekendriya, may have only fear when they get touched by something. They are unaware what's going to happen to them. But Lives with more senses, let's consider Panchendriya, will also be able to see, and sense other pain of other lives. In slaughter house, when they are stood in the series, or when kept in the cages, they see what happens to the other ones... it may be their family member, we may never know, so that emotional attachment and pain can also be there... even if its ignored, they hear the screams of the others and they try to leave from the grip to save their lives...so killing them is obviously more sinful. What a poor argument they make.... Look at the life, which doesn't know anything and is not even trying to protect itself... you show mercy for them and make vegetarians to feel guilty? whereas the life which (with the additional senses) knows what's going to happen to them and who want to live, and is screaming... you don't show mercy to them???
Truly Said🙌🙏
@@JainMedia 🙏
@@sejjalshahlogical comment.. But non vegetarians just want to numb their guilt and so blame us..
Go Vegan
Jai jinendra🙏🙏🙏🙏
सब कुछ गुणों पर निर्भर है। इसलिए मिथ्यात्व से उठ कर सम्यकत्व की तरफ़ अपना कदम रखना चाहिए।
Proud to be Non Vegetarian
अति उत्तम, किन्तु दूध एवंम पानी कोनसी श्रेणी का पदार्थ माना जावे
जय जिनेन्द्र
Khoob khoob dhanyvad bahut bahut anumodna aapki Mehul bhai Jay Jinendra pranam
Kya aap ek video parents ko Diksha ke liye kese convince Kare isle liye bnaoge
Apke
Diksha bhaav ki khub khub anumodana 🙏🙏🙏
Connect with sadhu bhagwan for solutions,🙏.
Non fertilized Ande chalte nai pr dudh chalta hai aisa kyo?
Non fertilized Anda mansahar hai kya?
Yes non fertile egg is non veg but milk is not non veg
If you can understand Gujarati, then from the following link, you'll get your answer of comparing an egg with milk. In the video its explained: why blood is non-veg and why milk is not considered non-veg. ua-cam.com/video/4XjniPqloAU/v-deo.html
अति उत्तम
Thankyou bhaiya hame bhi veg nonveg ke bare me bohat kuch bolte he hum unlogo ko aache se ab samjha payenge
🙏🙏👌👌👍👍
👌👌
Aise to jain logo ko gadi nahi chalani chahiye pollution se kitanu marte hai
Jo sansar me rehte hain, woh gadi use karte hein, Jain Sadhu Sadhviji nahi. Aur, Jaino ka population bhi itna kitna hai, jo pollution me badhotri karte honge. Jain gadi chalana bandh kar de, to kitna pollution kam hoga?
@@sejjalshah hame koi problem nahi hai aap ko problem hai jivo ki hatya ho raahi hai na
@@maheshagrawal5374 aapke pas Gadi hogi, isliye aap chalate honge. Hamare to koi gadi hi nahi... 11 number bus zindabad. aur kabhi mahine me 1-2 baar public transport :)
Gadi chalane mein ghar ka kam karne mein Vyapar karne mein kheti krishi karya mein jo hinsa hoti hai vah sankalpit hinsa nahin hai
Iska pap nahin lagta hai. Sadhu aur Sadhvi inko nahin karte Hain .
Beautiful explanation
Nice video
❤
Wow❤❤❤❤
Respect #vegan what a lesson 13:59
Here is a link where Mr. Mehul Jain from the same channel, "Jain Media" has explained about - should we go Vegan...? ua-cam.com/video/NmjfS27laaQ/v-deo.html
I, as a Jain, if eat underground vegetables and eat at night
Vs
A person, non jain, from anarya desh, never heard anything about dharma, if he eats underground vegetables and does ratribhojan
To us person ko kam paap lagega or mujhe zyada paap lagega...
Ye logic right hai?
इसमें एकांत नहीं है, इसमें अलग अलग एंगल आएंगे, क्योंकि खाते वक्त आपके भाव और उस व्यक्ति के भाव के ऊपर सब कुछ निर्भर करेगा !
जैसे आप दुखी हो कर खा रहे हैं कि काश मैं रात्रिभोजन त्याग कर पाता आज मज़बूरी है लेकिन जिस दिन अनुकूलता हुई अवश्य त्याग करूँगा, ऐसे भाव हैं तो आपको कम पाप लगेगा, इसलिए कहते हैं कि पाप करना ही पड़े तो कम से कम उस पाप के प्रति पक्षपात नहीं होना चाहिए.. लेकिन अगर आपके भाव ऐसे है कि कौन माने प्रभु की आज्ञा मैं नहीं मानता मैं तो पेट भरकर खाऊंगा मेरी मर्ज़ी हो तब खाऊंगा तब ज़रूर आपको ज्यादा पाप लगेगा क्योंकि इस परिस्थिति में पाप के साथ पाप का पक्षपात भी है, आप पाप तो कर ही रहे हैं लेकिन पाप में भाव भी क्रूर है इसलिए
हम जब छोटे होंगे अनजानेमें यां अपने हाथ लगने से उनकी हलचल बंध होते हुए देख कुतूहलवश, चलती हुई चीटियां मरी होंगी। उसमें और आज जब बड़े हुए, जिनशासन समझने लगे तब वह कुतूहल मनमें रहेगा क्या? फिर भी यदि वह प्रक्रिया करेंगे तो मन के भाव कैसे होंगे? क्या वैसे भाव होने चाहिए? Very much the same reason as... why the amount of punishment to a child is less than to an adult, for the same crime done?
Aapne ye nahi bataya ki jyada vedna kise hogi ekendriya ya panchendriy ko
Obviously panchendriy jeev ko
mujhe ek kutark esa bhi aya tha ki jab sab log vegeterian ban jayenge to earth balance nai kar sakegi na kuch khane ke liye vanaspati hi nahi rahegi to iska javab kya de sakte hai?
ये तो बहुत ही हास्यास्पद तर्क है, भविष्य में ज़रूर लेने का प्रयास करेंगे ! feedback noted
Bahot search ke baad, yeh link mili... aapko jawab mil jayega.Please watch / listen to it. ua-cam.com/video/NVPq_IIjQVE/v-deo.html Recently I also watched a video, where a doctor who himself is a non-vegetarian (reason tongue's taste), suggests eating 80% of Veg food, for a good health. Even Non-vegetarians aren't and can't eat 100% non-veg... So, as per that video, if non-vegetarians start eating 80% Vs us, eating 100%, then too the same difficulty will occur. ua-cam.com/video/pRlpPOj6HnY/v-deo.html To be frank, Hamari Dharti maa, hame ek dane ke 100 dane deti hai... woh bhi kitne kam samay me... uske saamne, study se yeh bhi pata chalta hai animals bahot sara khana khae, tab maans banta hai...
Jaminkand ma kis indiya ka jeev hota hai
अनंतकाय ऐसे तो एकेंद्रिय ही है, यानी कि उन्हें सिर्फ स्पर्श इन्द्रिय होती है लेकिन अनंतकाय यानी ज़मीनकंद में एक शरीर में अनंत आत्माएं होने से उसके भक्षण का जैन धर्म में निषेध है अधिक जानकारी यहाँ देख सकते हैं : ua-cam.com/video/mZIdoNvzgsU/v-deo.html
Yani ekindiya jeev ma atma ka tatav hota hai
No, u hv not visited dairy, if u might hv visited, ur explanation will not be this, Dairy is a curse ,
Actually commercialisation of dairy is a curse