Even cooler is hearing the original guitar in the background + lead guitar bends you can slightly hear in the released versions. Hope we hear an early RM containing the first go with the solo, should an RS remix set comes out maybe this year
Never noticed before that Paul and George are not in total unison on the riff - only George is playing the seconds in between the roots and thirds, while Paul is skipping them.
@@rbstems The conventional wisdom, as far as I’m aware, is that it’s McCartney and that Lennon’s only instrumental contribution to the song is tambourine on the basic rhythm track. The fact that the piano and McCartney’s guitar work are overdubbed onto the same track is actually evidence that it’s McCartney, because the song has seemingly been intentionally arranged so that those two parts never coincide, and there’s even a delay getting back into the piano part after the slide solo. They would have been recorded separately onto the track as punch-ins.
@@corailgris the lead guitar and the piano were overdubbed at the same time onto the same track. which means that if Paul was playing lead guitar, John must've played piano
Yes the sleeve does mention Paul on piano, but the recording notes mention otherwise. Paul clearly plays lead guitar, and it was recorded at the same time as the piano : so John on piano seems logical
but it wouldn't make sense to overdub these two parts live together - imagine for each take, Paul would have to wait a minute before for his slide solo, as oppose to just punching him in to that part @@rbstems
It's rare when a bass is a song in itself. ...Drums, too!! Cowbell, just right amount, of course. So, much rocking in less than 2 1/2 minutes.
Rubber soul begins!!!
Good stuff man ! Keep up the great work !
Finally, George's guitar can be heard super clearly
Even cooler is hearing the original guitar in the background + lead guitar bends you can slightly hear in the released versions. Hope we hear an early RM containing the first go with the solo, should an RS remix set comes out maybe this year
Amazing stuff!
Was Ringo tapping the hit-hat when he was playing the drums to this song because I can’t hear over John playing the tambourine.
Yes. Clearly.
@@IsaacWale2004Oh Ok
Never noticed before that Paul and George are not in total unison on the riff - only George is playing the seconds in between the roots and thirds, while Paul is skipping them.
Paul piano or John plays piano?
John plays it according to my notes, as it was recorded on the same track as the lead guitar by Paul.
they were likely bounced down to one track, plus neither of them occur it the same time...but you never know, could be John @@rbstems
@@rbstems The conventional wisdom, as far as I’m aware, is that it’s McCartney and that Lennon’s only instrumental contribution to the song is tambourine on the basic rhythm track. The fact that the piano and McCartney’s guitar work are overdubbed onto the same track is actually evidence that it’s McCartney, because the song has seemingly been intentionally arranged so that those two parts never coincide, and there’s even a delay getting back into the piano part after the slide solo. They would have been recorded separately onto the track as punch-ins.
Is it possible there are two piano tracks…or two players?
Only John on piano.
@@rbstemsI used to own a vinyl copy of Rubber Soul where It was written that Paul played piano on Drive My Car.
@@corailgris the lead guitar and the piano were overdubbed at the same time onto the same track. which means that if Paul was playing lead guitar, John must've played piano
Yes the sleeve does mention Paul on piano, but the recording notes mention otherwise. Paul clearly plays lead guitar, and it was recorded at the same time as the piano : so John on piano seems logical
but it wouldn't make sense to overdub these two parts live together - imagine for each take, Paul would have to wait a minute before for his slide solo, as oppose to just punching him in to that part @@rbstems
Sarebbe bello separare anche le voci