Abul Hassan sab, congratulations for such a wonderful commentry on Josh sab,during my summer vacations for many years in a row I have been going to listen him with my father sab BISMIL SAEEDI a famous poet , (during the year 1959-64) in DELHI , please contact me on this page, if, you feel you are intersted to know more regarding Josh Sab, please contact me , with regards, MAHBOOB SAEEDI (CA)
گرامی قدر جناب عبدالله حسن نغمی صاحب ، اسلام علیکم ! سب سے پہلے تو آپکا شکریہ۔ اپ نے اس قدر خوبصرت انداز میں اردو کے جلیل قدر شاعر و فلسفی حضرت شبیر حسین خان جوش ملیح آبادی کے بارے میں اپنے قیمتی جزبات کا اظہار کیا ۔۔۔ خراج تحسین پیش کیا جو کرنا آپکا فرض اور جوش صاحب مرحوم کا اپ پر حق بھی تھا۔ میں نے بہت توجہ اور دلچسپی سے پورا پروگرام سنا جو بے حد بہترین اور شاندار ریکارڈ ہوا ہے۔ دس سیکنڈ کے لیے سیل فون کی گھنٹی نے اور اُن صاحب کی معذرت نے پروگرام پر بد نظری سے بچنے کے لئے۔۔۔ انتظام کردیا۔ اپ نے جوش صاحب سے اپنی رفاقت کا حق ضرور ادا کیا ہے ۔ لیکن ابھی بہت گنجائش باقی ہے۔ جس کے لئے مزید پروگرام ہونے ضروری ہیں ۔ اگر ہوسکے تو اپ مجھے اپنا فون نمبر ضرور لکھیے۔ میں بھی اپ سے فون پر بات کر سکوں ۔ احقر و دعا گو۔ جیم سین ٹورانٹو
Doubt ka zikkar atay hee, aksar saalo'n ko saanp suungh gaya. Urdu has a great tradition of agnostics (I wouldn't call him an atheist) and he was a shining light of that tradition. What we call in Punjabi "sher da bacha" Thanks for the upload. On UA-cam he's conspicuous by his absence. Should have stayed in India. People like Firaq have better legacy, what a great shame.
Khurmiful There’s nothing glorious about denying the existence of GOD. On one hand, the atheists and agnostics deny the existence of GOD. And on the other hand, they get a huge sense of being intellectually qualified by dint of denying the existence of GOD. It’s ludicrously ironical that they derive a great sense of pride and self worth by denying something they say doesn’t exist in the first place. If they’re true in their claim they’re idiots of the highest order. And so we know that they’re not tight, they’re idiots and bigots at the same time who deny the existence of THE only creator (who is the architect of the very existence of all that exists) with nothing but ridicule at their disposal. What a pity!! It’s like a fridge saying it wasn’t created by an engineer and that it came into existence on its own.
Thanks for providing me a chance to listen pure and beautiful Urdu from a gentleman of U P ,now a rare lot even among the people of muslim UP!!
It's been a long time since I heard a talk this interesting.
Abul Hassan sab, congratulations for such a wonderful commentry on Josh sab,during my summer vacations for many years in a row I have been going to listen him with my father sab BISMIL SAEEDI a famous poet , (during the year 1959-64) in DELHI , please contact me on this page, if, you feel you are intersted to know more regarding Josh Sab, please contact me , with regards, MAHBOOB SAEEDI (CA)
I would love to know more
Bahut dilchasp guftugu Mashaallah
گرامی قدر جناب عبدالله حسن نغمی صاحب ، اسلام علیکم !
سب سے پہلے تو آپکا شکریہ۔ اپ نے اس قدر خوبصرت انداز میں اردو کے جلیل قدر شاعر و فلسفی حضرت شبیر حسین خان جوش ملیح آبادی کے بارے میں اپنے قیمتی جزبات کا اظہار کیا ۔۔۔ خراج تحسین پیش کیا جو کرنا آپکا فرض اور جوش صاحب مرحوم کا اپ پر حق بھی تھا۔
میں نے بہت توجہ اور دلچسپی سے پورا پروگرام سنا جو بے حد بہترین اور شاندار ریکارڈ ہوا ہے۔ دس سیکنڈ کے لیے سیل فون کی گھنٹی نے اور اُن صاحب کی معذرت نے پروگرام پر بد نظری سے بچنے کے لئے۔۔۔ انتظام کردیا۔ اپ نے جوش صاحب سے اپنی رفاقت کا حق ضرور ادا کیا ہے ۔ لیکن ابھی بہت گنجائش باقی ہے۔ جس کے لئے مزید پروگرام ہونے ضروری ہیں ۔
اگر ہوسکے تو اپ مجھے اپنا فون نمبر ضرور لکھیے۔ میں بھی اپ سے فون پر بات کر سکوں ۔
احقر و دعا گو۔ جیم سین ٹورانٹو
Doubt ka zikkar atay hee, aksar saalo'n ko saanp suungh gaya.
Urdu has a great tradition of agnostics (I wouldn't call him an atheist) and he was a shining light of that tradition. What we call in Punjabi "sher da bacha"
Thanks for the upload.
On UA-cam he's conspicuous by his absence. Should have stayed in India. People like Firaq have better legacy, what a great shame.
Do you mean "doubt" like the religion which recommends one ought to doubt every flipping thing?
+Ali Hammad Shah I don't know of any religion that encourages doubt, but if there is one, it will be a great religion.
Khurmiful If you think you should doubt everything why not as well doubt that one ought to doubt everything. It sounds very paradoxical.
+Ali Hammad Shah yes, can't go wrong when your inquiry rests on skepticism.
Khurmiful There’s nothing glorious about denying the existence of GOD. On one hand, the atheists and agnostics deny the existence of GOD. And on the other hand, they get a huge sense of being intellectually qualified by dint of denying the existence of GOD. It’s ludicrously ironical that they derive a great sense of pride and self worth by denying something they say doesn’t exist in the first place. If they’re true in their claim they’re idiots of the highest order. And so we know that they’re not tight, they’re idiots and bigots at the same time who deny the existence of THE only creator (who is the architect of the very existence of all that exists) with nothing but ridicule at their disposal. What a pity!! It’s like a fridge saying it wasn’t created by an engineer and that it came into existence on its own.