In the first book, when Claire travels the first time, she was wandering around the stones looking for a scarf she left behind and was absentmindedly thinking of Captain Black Jack Randall who was Frank's ancestor he was just telling her about. I think she accidentally was transported to him because he's the first person she meets when she goes through the stones, not Jaimie.
Oh, that's really interesting. I always thought it must be a loved one in the past or present. I didn't think it could be someone like Black Jack Randall. Thanks for your comment.
Oh wow, Master Raymond? He was such a criminally underused character! In fact, I gladly would have seen an entire season of the France episodes over the Jamaica ones later on!
Die Vergangenheit von einzelnen Menschen hat Claire auf jedenfall verändert. Denn wenn sie jemanden das Leben durch Heilung rettet und er dadurch z.B. eine Familie gründet und Kinder zeugt dann verändert sie die Geschichte.Aber um größere Geschichts- Themen zu verändern braucht man eine sehr grosse Energie von sicherlich vielen Menschen....
Time travelers can definitely change the past, but probably not huge differences like wars. Claire and Bree’s conversation in S5 about her attempting to make penicillin basically confirms that. Plus in the books Lovat’s seer says that people’s actions can change outcomes.
Oops! While you included the video of Roger when he found the standing stones in Upstate New York (if I remember correctly) after briefly escaping from the Mohawk, you didn't mention those stones. So there were 4 portals and now Brianna may have found a 5th portal in Scotland when her co-workers locked her in the tunnel. It was fascinating to see Brianna and Roger discuss it by looking at a map of the area to see there may be a connection to Craigh Na Dun!
More people I think are travelers . #1-2 Clare's parents. #3 the nun in France the hospital .#4 Clare's uncle the Egyptolgest , #5 the Indian woman that was stopped in her tracks after seeing that stone necklace . #6 could be the French chemist lady assistance. #7 And maybe Fiona. Or someone in her family . Other than a love(or ghosts) connection perhaps , political or strong of justice. Could be a reason that one can time traveler. Along with other things you mentioned. You as a time traveler is a calling.
Perhaps Bri and family were able to cross the second time, because they were desperate to see the doctor to help Mandy, so that is where they were meant to be at this time.
I’m really confused. I’ve watched the series through several times. I don’t remember ever hearing about Master Raymond being a time traveler in the series. Is it in the books? I haven’t read the books but I know the series pretty much by heart at this point. How did I kiss this?
It’s been many many years since I’ve read the books but I thought Master Raymond was known to be a traveler. This was a book situation, not a TV series thing.
It’s a bit more obvious in the books, but I believe Raymond also makes a reference to being interested in things “not from this time” in the show. There’s a novella called “the space between” (I haven’t read it myself yet) that gives more background on both Master Raymond and Comte St Germain and their relations to time travel.
He was thinking of his son probably. Now, after watching Season 7 Part 2, it's clear to me that it's about who you're thinking of. It doesn't have to be a conscious thought where the person says I want to see this person etc.
No one really knows why Jamie’s ghost is there, but it’s strongly believed to have to do with the ending of outlander, which hasn’t been written/ published yet
Small detail of correction if I may, when pronouncing “Ocracoke” it sounds more like “Okra- Coke” when you combine the vegetable Okra and the soda Coke. Sorry it sounds like nails on a chalk board the way its pronounced in this video. (Traveled there many times and it’s mostly an Eastern North Carolina thing 😊) Otherwise this was an informative video on what seems hard to keep track of especially with the season 7 episode 5 “visiter” that we experience and I’m hoping it’s Da and no one bad. 🍻 ❤
Ich denke doch, das der Reisende die Zeit ändern kann. Wohlbemerkt, nicht die Geschichte. Claire hat selbst ein Mal ihrer Tochter erzählt, daß sie, wenn sie jemanden heilt, der sonst gestorben wäre, schon was geändert hat. Auf diese Weise denke ich ändert sich etwas. Ausserdem muss man die Steine hören können. Das ist die Stimme der Zeit. Mandy und Jemmy können auch die Steine hören. ( Edelsteine). Jamie reißt in seinen Träumen. Das hat er schon einige Male Claire erzählt. Das 1. Mal, bevor Bree durch die Steine kam. 💯💯💕👍👌💖
In the book, it was alluded to that the blood lets you go further than the 200 years. SPOILER It is also hinted at that Roger and Bree's third child won't be able to travel, and he was born when they still live in the past.
I had a thought., In the episode Singapore , Clare treated a patient . Wouldn't it be cool if that patient be a descendant of Dr. Joe Abernathy ? More fan fiction on my part.
I just hope that when Diana explains all this (if she does), it won't be a modified explanation due to all the theories out there and that she stays true to what inspired her from the very beginning . If I remember correctly, the TV series ''Lost'' and the sequels to ''Star Wars'' had their stories changed because many fans guessed what would happen. Well, the result was not the best move of the creators who saw their basic ideas truncated. I hope she sticks to her guns is what I'm saying. Sure, you're never safe from a new idea. But the worst thing is reacting to what fans say or hope.
Oh another seer or time traveler could be the Chinese man, Mr. Willoughby. Aka Yi Tien Cho. And maybe the lady fortune teller that he loves.🔮 Wasn't there an old Indian medicine woman that got killed? She too could have been a time traveler .
The books do not indicate Willoughby, the shop girl, the seer, or the Indian woman. There is a distinct difference between travelers & those who deal with mystical & spiritual aspects. There really isn't an absolute guideline to time travel, as Claire told Donner. No one that they know of knows for sure. Claire, Roger & Bree, traveled 202 years either way. Speculation as to how Geillis went further & a blood sacrifice, it's just that, speculation. If you want some further insight read The Space Between- it gives more story On Raymond & Compt St. Germain
as someone somewhat (two years at school and I still remember jack shit lol) familiar with mineralogy, the idea of a "gemstone" is so funny to me. like what are the criteria :D it's all just minerals. can you travel with a piece of silica? do the stones know the difference between silica and chalcedony? :D does it have to be a certain hardness? would synthetic work? or does the traveler have to see the gem as something precious. could you use organics? it's not a mineral but it is still classified as gems. it would just be so funny to me if someone traveled through stones and then later discovered graphite from their pencil was gone xD pencil is a girl's best friend :*
They travelled back to warn Claire and Jaime of the fire. Now that they survived that, the Mack’s don’t have any real reason to go back. Their current time is safer for them and their children to exist in. But knowing this show there’s likely going to be another reason for them to return.
Claire introduced penicillin 150 years before it was supposed to be. So, she gave the bugs a 150 year head start. These bugs now would be resistant to most antibiotics. I believe Claire inadvertently caused the death of thousands in the future.
Are there other explanations for time travel? Why couldn’t Wendigo Donner or Bree & Roger couldn’t time travel in certain instances? Tell me below!
In the first book, when Claire travels the first time, she was wandering around the stones looking for a scarf she left behind and was absentmindedly thinking of Captain Black Jack Randall who was Frank's ancestor he was just telling her about. I think she accidentally was transported to him because he's the first person she meets when she goes through the stones, not Jaimie.
Oh, that's really interesting. I always thought it must be a loved one in the past or present. I didn't think it could be someone like Black Jack Randall. Thanks for your comment.
I like to think time travellers can change small things but cant change fixed points in time. Really big historical events
Great explainer video. I hope they have more time travel episodes before the series wraps up.
The stone circle the MacKenzies used in S5 was not Okracoke. It was the one that Roger found when trying to escape the Mohawk in S4.
Oh wow, Master Raymond? He was such a criminally underused character! In fact, I gladly would have seen an entire season of the France episodes over the Jamaica ones later on!
Yes we'd like to hear your explanation on why people can't change the past.
Die Vergangenheit von einzelnen Menschen hat Claire auf jedenfall verändert. Denn wenn sie jemanden das Leben durch Heilung rettet und er dadurch z.B. eine Familie gründet und Kinder zeugt dann verändert sie die Geschichte.Aber um größere Geschichts- Themen zu verändern braucht man eine sehr grosse Energie von sicherlich vielen Menschen....
Time travelers can definitely change the past, but probably not huge differences like wars. Claire and Bree’s conversation in S5 about her attempting to make penicillin basically confirms that. Plus in the books Lovat’s seer says that people’s actions can change outcomes.
Late to the party but, yes please, more details of your theory
Oops! While you included the video of Roger when he found the standing stones in Upstate New York (if I remember correctly) after briefly escaping from the Mohawk, you didn't mention those stones. So there were 4 portals and now Brianna may have found a 5th portal in Scotland when her co-workers locked her in the tunnel. It was fascinating to see Brianna and Roger discuss it by looking at a map of the area to see there may be a connection to Craigh Na Dun!
More people I think are travelers . #1-2 Clare's parents. #3 the nun in France the hospital .#4 Clare's uncle the Egyptolgest , #5 the Indian woman that was stopped in her tracks after seeing that stone necklace . #6 could be the French chemist lady assistance. #7 And maybe Fiona. Or someone in her family . Other than a love(or ghosts) connection perhaps , political or strong of justice. Could be a reason that one can time traveler. Along with other things you mentioned. You as a time traveler is a calling.
I really wonder if we're going to learn more about Claire's parents. They are a mystery to me
Perhaps Bri and family were able to cross the second time, because they were desperate to see the doctor to help Mandy, so that is where they were meant to be at this time.
That and she knew Joe Abernathy, whom her mother told her to seek out to help Mandy.
Oh that makes a lot of sense!
thank u for explaining..I was only focusing on jamie😪😪
You're welcome:):)
I wanna hear about the changing of the past!!!
What is the sodium Context ?
You may be a big fan of the series, but it's high time you learned how to pronounce Diana's last name properly.
I’m really confused. I’ve watched the series through several times. I don’t remember ever hearing about Master Raymond being a time traveler in the series. Is it in the books? I haven’t read the books but I know the series pretty much by heart at this point. How did I kiss this?
It’s been many many years since I’ve read the books but I thought Master Raymond was known to be a traveler. This was a book situation, not a TV series thing.
It’s a bit more obvious in the books, but I believe Raymond also makes a reference to being interested in things “not from this time” in the show. There’s a novella called “the space between” (I haven’t read it myself yet) that gives more background on both Master Raymond and Comte St Germain and their relations to time travel.
Roger's father was a traveller too and we don't know that he had someone he was going to.
He was thinking of his son probably. Now, after watching Season 7 Part 2, it's clear to me that it's about who you're thinking of. It doesn't have to be a conscious thought where the person says I want to see this person etc.
I never understood in the first episode the man standing outside of Clare's window, watching her, then brushing against Frank and disappeared.
No one really knows why Jamie’s ghost is there, but it’s strongly believed to have to do with the ending of outlander, which hasn’t been written/ published yet
Small detail of correction if I may, when pronouncing “Ocracoke” it sounds more like “Okra-
Coke” when you combine the vegetable Okra and the soda Coke. Sorry it sounds like nails on a chalk board the way its pronounced in this video. (Traveled there many times and it’s mostly an Eastern North Carolina thing 😊)
Otherwise this was an informative video on what seems hard to keep track of especially with the season 7 episode 5 “visiter” that we experience and I’m hoping it’s Da and no one bad. 🍻 ❤
There is a portal today in New YOrk city. At the Ave of Americans and Tesla.
This was explained by Nicholas Tesla where time travel
Ich denke doch, das der Reisende die Zeit ändern kann.
Wohlbemerkt, nicht die Geschichte.
Claire hat selbst ein Mal ihrer Tochter erzählt, daß sie, wenn sie jemanden heilt, der sonst gestorben wäre, schon was geändert hat. Auf diese Weise denke ich ändert sich etwas.
Ausserdem muss man die Steine hören können. Das ist die Stimme der Zeit. Mandy und Jemmy können auch die Steine hören. ( Edelsteine).
Jamie reißt in seinen Träumen.
Das hat er schon einige Male Claire erzählt. Das 1. Mal, bevor Bree durch die Steine kam. 💯💯💕👍👌💖
In the book, it was alluded to that the blood lets you go further than the 200 years.
SPOILER
It is also hinted at that Roger and Bree's third child won't be able to travel, and he was born when they still live in the past.
Yes, let’s hear about your theories on why they can’t change the future! (I agree with U btw!)
I had a thought., In the episode Singapore , Clare treated a patient . Wouldn't it be cool if that patient be a descendant of Dr. Joe Abernathy ? More fan fiction on my part.
He would be an Antecedant.
He would not have been a Descendent, someone coming after a person, but, rather, an Ancestor, a blood relation coming before a person.
I wonder what would happen if you tried it without a jewel.
I just hope that when Diana explains all this (if she does), it won't be a modified explanation due to all the theories out there and that she stays true to what inspired her from the very beginning . If I remember correctly, the TV series ''Lost'' and the sequels to ''Star Wars'' had their stories changed because many fans guessed what would happen. Well, the result was not the best move of the creators who saw their basic ideas truncated. I hope she sticks to her guns is what I'm saying. Sure, you're never safe from a new idea. But the worst thing is reacting to what fans say or hope.
Wasn't Fiona waiting for them in the future?
Yes she was.
Oh another seer or time traveler could be the Chinese man, Mr. Willoughby. Aka Yi Tien Cho. And maybe the lady fortune teller that he loves.🔮 Wasn't there an old Indian medicine woman that got killed? She too could have been a time traveler .
The books do not indicate Willoughby, the shop girl, the seer, or the Indian woman. There is a distinct difference between travelers & those who deal with mystical & spiritual aspects. There really isn't an absolute guideline to time travel, as Claire told Donner. No one that they know of knows for sure. Claire, Roger & Bree, traveled 202 years either way. Speculation as to how Geillis went further & a blood sacrifice, it's just that, speculation. If you want some further insight read The Space Between- it gives more story On Raymond & Compt St. Germain
Count, or Compte en Francais.
Forget the exta "e". Typo.
@@kathleenferguson3296 thanks ding dang typos
Are interfering with my train of thought . Choo choo chugga chugga.!🚂.....😁
Conte*@@kathleenferguson3296
Spoiler alert! In season 7 Bre finds an other possible time travel location, in the cave?
New flash: It doesn't. Some things don't have to be explained i.e. the unexplained.
Nts 1:23
as someone somewhat (two years at school and I still remember jack shit lol) familiar with mineralogy, the idea of a "gemstone" is so funny to me. like what are the criteria :D it's all just minerals. can you travel with a piece of silica? do the stones know the difference between silica and chalcedony? :D does it have to be a certain hardness? would synthetic work? or does the traveler have to see the gem as something precious. could you use organics? it's not a mineral but it is still classified as gems.
it would just be so funny to me if someone traveled through stones and then later discovered graphite from their pencil was gone xD pencil is a girl's best friend :*
Why can bre and roger not go back to their family now that the baby’s heart is fixed?
Maybe she is well but still need (modern) checkups and meds.
They travelled back to warn Claire and Jaime of the fire. Now that they survived that, the Mack’s don’t have any real reason to go back. Their current time is safer for them and their children to exist in. But knowing this show there’s likely going to be another reason for them to return.
Orca coke
OkraCoke is the pronunciation ( not the spelling).
A 10 minute video wasted after you watch next weeks episode PLONKER
Claire introduced penicillin 150 years before it was supposed to be. So, she gave the bugs a 150 year head start. These bugs now would be resistant to most antibiotics. I believe Claire inadvertently caused the death of thousands in the future.
Yes indeed 💉
Ohhhh, savage, haha!