Dr. Vin Gupta: I think Biden is quite high-functioning as an octogenarian
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 лип 2024
- Drs. Ezekiel Emanuel and Vin Gupta discuss President Biden's physical and cognitive abilities.
» Subscribe to MSNBC: / msnbc
Download our new MSNBC app for the latest breaking news and daily headlines at a glance: www.msnbc.com/information/dow...
Follow MSNBC Show Blogs
MaddowBlog: www.msnbc.com/maddowblog
ReidOut Blog: www.msnbc.com/reidoutblog
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and Alex Wagner who brings her breadth of reporting experience to MSNBC primetime. Watch “Alex Wagner Tonight” Tuesday through Friday at 9pm Eastern.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: www.msnbc.com/
Subscribe to the MSNBC Daily Newsletter: link.msnbc.com/join/5ck/msnbc...
Find MSNBC on Facebook: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: / msnbc
#Biden #Politics #Election
I agree with Dr. Gupta. We need more discussion about Trump's mental health. Something is wrong with that man.
This is NOT “the only story of the day.” Put a rest to it. We all know he’s old, but he’s experience, wise, and has a great team.
Finally, an expert doctor, Dr. Gupta, raises the more serious issues with TRUMP 's cognitive abilities. I hate it that people have not focused on Trump's mental state, his decline, and how evident his issues were in that debate. We have such a double standard!
You dont like what trump said. No one could understand what biden was saying
@@kylegrant9980 Yes, he's running against Obama in this election. That's definitely true. Nikki Haley, not being in either House, had a say in policies including the Capitol Police. Yup, that's true.
@@kylegrant9980WE WHO ACTUALLY LISTEN TO THE PRESIDENT KNOW EXACTLY WHAT HES SAYING ..STOP LISTENING ONLY TO FOX EDITED VIDEOS. YOU CAN UNDERSTAND TRUMP..BUT HE LIES AND GOES ON INCOHERENT RANTS!!!
They both are dealing with cognitive issues. There should be a cut off age running for President.
What are u talking about trump is on his game never stops bidens in bed by 5pm and wakes up at 9am believe you have trump derangement syndrome
Dr. Vin Gupta, THANK YOU FOR SCHOOLING CNN and mainstream media ON MENTAL AND PHYSICAL HEALTH AND AGING 101
RN here. Absolutely agree with Dr Vin Gupta!
So there’s no signs of Parkinson’s with his gait, turning, arm swing, and freezing or stared or frozen face.
@@gatvestreet9248I'm definitely not seeing reputable doctors coming out and saying Joe has Parkinson's, but even if he did, that wouldn't disqualify him. FDR was in a wheelchair because he'd had polio, and he was elected President 4 times!
@@greeneyedlady5580 that’s true. He could have Parkinson’s and continue on depending on the level and speed it advances. Parkinson’s is there but no one knows the level except his doctors.
Who said he has Parkinson's?
@@QT-Hush He has all the signs and he meet with a Parkinson's specialist 8 times so you tell me
And all these people howling about Biden don’t seem to remember Jan.6th. and the threat to this country. It isn’t Biden that has memory issues.
Embarrassing.
Donald talked about Nuclear Submarines around Cuba yesterday at speech did he give away Classified Information ?????
@QLHOOQ EXACTLY WHO KNOWS WHICH IS WHICH ??? EITHER WAY SHOULD WE KNOW??? WATCH SPEECH.
Putin put the nuclear subs down there after he warned Biden that if Ukraine used any American military hardware to attack Russia with, that all targets in America are subject to nuclear attack. Zelensky took out two long range early warning nuclear missile radars deep in Russia that weren't even pointed at Ukraine. Zelenskyy and Biden are are walking us very quickly into World War III. China is even doing military exercises on the Polish border at Putin's request. Trump would have never allowed any of the above happen. The MSM wont report it because it would hurt the democrats if they did. I hope the democrats let this important post stay up.
He didn't suddenly become old two weeks ago. If this is such a big issue then why didn't he get a primary challenge? It's too late now. He has all of the delegates.
Watching these folks continuing to double-down on stupid is breathtaking …..
Thanks
~Jim Eagle
It's F'n Glorious. 😆
And you're smart?
@@tonymnQuan Yes. Quite.
@@tonymnQuan compared to a Democrat, he is einstein
@@tonymnQuan if you voted for Biden and voting for Biden again he's smarter than you
Gaslighting
Biden does have a large cabinet who do alot of specific jobs for the administration. Hes not working solo.
Thank you Dr Gupta!!
Thank you Dr. Gupta, I agree with you. I am amazed on the number of people who have turned on Biden knowing what’s at stake, democracy. What do we know about Trumps health? Nothing…. These stories have done more damage to Biden than the bad debate. Morning Joe used to be a daily watch for me but I am losing faith in all the mainstream media. I am voting for Biden. The Supreme Court decision and project 2025 should be out front and center for discussion. Disturbing coverage.
Still better than having a president ranting about electric boats, sharks, and thinks Hannibal Lector being real.
It is unprofessional to make a remote diagnosis.
These doctors should know better.
Do you mean at least he is clearly biased by his love of the President?
Huh, doctors do that all the time. Ever heard of Doc on Demand.
@@rickfraser5756 Actually, the guys with the degrees would be part of societies that would have rules not to do it.
Wait, you’ve never had a phone appointment with your doctor?
@@judgesunday3455 Exactly where did any of them talk to the patient at all to ask any questions? The fact that you think watching someone is the discovery of an appointment is pretty sad. They aren't even consulting at this point because no medical person actually examined Biden in front of them.
Hey, the media told us the same for years prior to the debate despite the evidence showing Biden was in decline. The media does not have our best interests at heart.
Stop watching the news is the best defense against evil
I think there was plenty of reporting by the media but they really didn’t see much more of Biden than we did. Blame the WH and Jill for keeping him out of the public eye. And blame them too for encouraging him to run again!!
Which "media"? LOL
Daily reminder
F J B
And you too
Shut up. He’s the candidate. Get behind him or prepare for Project 2025
Project 2025 is the new Russian collusion. So hot right now. Fire!
What part of Project 2025 scares you the most?
agenda 47*
@@Duude125the part where they say they are going to bring back slavery and include mexicans and asians this time. they also said that they would send everyone who can’t recite the first 12 books of the bible perfectly to prison. and they ALSO said that they would be artificially inseminating every female alive in their “Proer Life” Plan. its just terrible
I would love to see a ply by play of trumps mental accuity as well as other assessments
Oh yeah the Parkinson's Doctor that visited the Whitehouse multiple times was there to treat some other 81 year old with Parkinson's.... not Joe !!!😆
The Parkinson’s expert is literally the White House physician that treats White House staff…
@@Omglawlsusuck
See ? 🤣
Dingle, He was treating all the young soldiers with Parkinson disease!!! 😂😂😂😂
@@Dingleberry777 They were clearly there to see the guy that cleans the toilets at the White House. C'mon, man! No joke!
@@BudFudlacker Sounds legit 🤣
Can we get off the maga talking point and talk about Epstien? Or is MSNBC CEO on the list?
Do we really need a 81 to run the country?
Thank heavens no one is asking you.
If Trump won he would be 83 be the end of his term. Facts
@@engletinaknickerbocker5380 Oh but they are and you as well. Wake up
@@judytalk128 go Kamala!
Do you need a want to be dictator run the country?
Weekend at Bernie’s is coming to a end soon with no sequel in site. 👍
@@rickfraser5756You’re a walking contradiction 😂
@@rickfraser5756 your pain is my reward. I am truth
I'm just fine with that,. Biden has appointed an excellent group of people, and hired competent advisors. Haven't you noticed that with this administration, and the Biden campaign, there haven't been any big scandals, no indictments, no arrests. Then look back on the chaos with the Trump administration and campaigns, and all of the arrests, indictments, guilty pleas, and convictions. I would never vote to go back to that chaos and corruption.
Sheer desperation at this point!
@@rickfraser5756It’s sad you had to write a paragraph about what you Dems do on a daily basis. Take your contradictory comment and shove it.
@@rickfraser5756what are your pronouns baby😂😂😂?
@@rickfraser5756possibly the commenters who saw Biden in the debate noticed similar issues a year ago and want to express the media has half-truthed MANY times, so could this be another?
While some may enquire if anyone was surprised at the debate consider changing your news source.
And others are enjoying themselves as they have dealt with media fabrication, lies for several years.
Gaslighting defined
I never understood Bipolar depression until I watched MSNBC. Years of lying about Biden's health have come back to haunt them!😂😂
💯
Tell me how please
@@danielleaskins7558 Stuck with a turnip.
I think they are the 1s driving the Biden BS about his health ID be more worried about Trump he clearly has mental issues
Brilliant speech at the UN. Imagine trump attempting an actual speech instead of ranting and raving about himself and bullshitting to his gullible cult members.
"The only story of the day" Yeah because the media won't shut up about it. Thank you Dr Gupta. BIDEN/HARRIS 2024
The media does this all the time. They grab the easiest story for them to understand and that's their one big story. They can't handle more than one at a time. And they pick the wrong story and keep hammering at it long after it's dead.
It's so ridiculous. They will never be satisfied by anything Biden does or says that contradicts their story because they have this non-story embedded in their brains.
Robert Hur deserves an apology.
Robert Hur is a partisan hack and LIED like all chump cult members do
Hur's memory was worse than Biden's
Hur's memory was worse than Biden's. Hur is a partisan hack and sealed his fate as such
HUR needs to give an apology. Biden sat with him for many hours and as you may know HUR was a Trump appointee. We have seen what Trump appointees in the Supreme Court have done. One should have asked HUR whether people outside the Justice Department had called him and, if so, .what had they communicated.
@@MusicandMMA He didn't
25th amendment needed
Is that the popes blessing 🙏😊
What kind of Psychotropics are you dropping Dr. Gupta?
Doctor Gupta gave a very reasonable and well thought out analysis based on his many years of training, and all his years of practice. If you don't like it, that's a you problem. Your scepticism didn't trump his expertise. I've heard numerous doctors give a very similar analysis.
Looking to score some more because you've run out?
Thanks, Doc, from an octo!! We can still function in everyway..The stress on President Biden and what he accomplishes is far beyond what some much younger people are capble of!!. Get real Folks!!😊
Emanuel has a smirk on his face as he listens to Vin Gupta.
We have seen the issues over time. It's all there but nothing like the debate. The debate was insane....
Joe is toast. He had a good run ... thank you. Now let Harriw step UP!!!
Trump blurted out more insane lies as ever before.
" Hunter's Laptop is Russian misinformation." MSNBC EXPERTS 😂😂
And everyone in JB's administration. They stuck with that as long as they could.
As a Democrat I still believe this lie!
@@swimminginthoughts if you was a democrat you would know trump and his maga cult lie and create false stories about everyone to get ahead .. you ain’t no democrat 🤣🤣
@@swimminginthoughtsThat’s because you have a room temperature IQ
The sheep are so easily led. They surrender common sense, values, children, their safety, based ion an activist pretending to be a journalist.
Everybody wants a merit badge or an A grade. Shut up and get us through the next critical presidential election
Please, please, please, my American friends, DO NOT FORGET WHO THE REAL ENEMY IS!!! Joe's mental capacity is the least of your problems at the moment! And no, you are not alone in this fight... It is in your hands, but make no mistake, it will have repercussions throughout the entire world. We're all pulling for you!
It's Biden or dictatorship. The time for change was when we picked him, and we picked him. Who else is gonna draw people like Biden does. Lets acknowledge Bidens impressive track record shall we. Trumps trying to pick his opponent again is all this is. He KNOWS he's not beating President Biden. 🇺🇲
GoJoe🇺🇲 🩵
LOVE, OVER HATE.
Globalist oligarchs vs trump*
“Don’t don’t don’t…..pause. Repeat the line.”
~President Potatobrains
This happens to me and I’m more than half Biden’s age. 💙💙💙
I can't help but noticing the hate language being spewed in comments
This is my favorite comedy channel.
If Joe is fine then release the hur tapes
Trump claimed executive privilege over EVERYTHING. Biden is also entitled to executive privilege.
Read the complete transcripts, they're available, of can't you read.
@@sallylapradd2900 what's the matter you don't want to hear Joe talk or at least try to.
*1.3% GDP growth*
*Rampant Inflation*
*Lousy Jobs Market*
- We got to keep this guy. Harris/Biden 2024
LOL. Anyone with your obvious inability to tell the truth is not to be trusted.
2round trip trans Atlantic trips within 6 days is NOT “routine travel” even for a 40 year old
Man if a Dr can’t see what everyone on the world stages sees then he needs to go back to wherever he got his degree from and get a refresher course.
Excellent points Dr Gupta - thank you.
@@5959Lawrence your lost soul needs Jesus Christ
I also agree with Dr. Gupta. Given Biden's busy schedule, he's done pretty good for his age.
Joe missed a critical NATO meeting yesterday. The NATO leaders moved the time of the meeting ahead so Joe Biden could attend. He did not attend because he was in bed. He was sleeping.
😂😅
Trump sat in his trial and fell asleep. As his head wobbled, a terrible stench filled the courtroom. Trump sharts constantly. Not presidential material.
Cool story bro, but no one is interested in your fetish
I think that was you who sharted. 😂
The late great Hannibal Lecter wants to have Trump over for dinner.
@@whodey2112 Probably not- he prefers fresher ingredients.
The Doctors tell me I'm doing just fine for a 95 year old patient.
Yes, but you're only half that age, *physically*.
The issues are pundits and Despicable Média
"Start your tape right now, because I'm about to tell you the truth. And f-you if you can't handle the truth. This version of Biden intellectually, analytically, is the best Biden ever. Not a close second. And I've known him for years. The Brzezinskis have known him for 50 years. If it weren't the truth, I wouldn't say it." - Joe Scarborough 😂😂😂😂😂
maga hate
@@tinay9491 How's that "Bidenomics" treating you, Tina? You still believe Hunter's Laptop was "Russian Disinformation?" Better yet, how's those wars that President Poopy Pants got us into going, huh? How many "vax" shots have you gotten? Better yet, how many more you plan on getting? Democrats are soooooooo dumb.
Why do we have a vice president if they cannot make decisions should the president be incapacitated?
I think Mike Pence did exactly that on Jan 6. He was the one who authorized the National Guard, not Trump.
I think Pence and the Pentagon decided, after several hours of Trump glued to the tv and refusing to talk with family and staff begging him to authorize the Guard (as only the President can do for DC), that Trump was incapacitated and so the authority went to the Vice President.
The President acts like the Governor of a state for DC in calling for the National Guard. He had to be incapacitated for the Vice President Mike Pence to be able to authorize the National Guard.
Joe Biden will be lucky to get to November and he needs to stay in because that's an easy win for Trump. Lol lol lol. FJB AND FMSNBC.
'You did it Joe... you answered all the questions !!!' - Elder Ab*ser Jill.
Kevin Roberts is my Hero
Muffy Mika looks saddened and broken
Age is everybody's issue. Fortunately Kamala is next in line. Go girl!❤
How are they able to diagnose someone without physically examining them?
In bidens case, it's obvious that he is low on mental cognition.
Well they're Democrats they're able to do that they have a lot of special gifts.
@@bobevans9955 like getting legislation passed that repubs can’t. I think you’re on to something
@@Gabreyes093 what has the Senate passed absolutely nothing in the last 2 years. Prove me wrong
@@Gabreyes093 passing legislation and passing good legislation are 2 very different things.
Listen to Dr Vin Gupta.
RELEASE THE HUR TAPES!!! 🚨 🚨
Release the Epstein files.
@@hemihead6645 release both. They'll never release epstein tapes because too many elites would be exposed
@@hemihead6645 DJT didn't visit the island though. Those were only the Dems. 🤣
As a Democrat I prefer to see the edited version of Biden we get from the media. The debate was devastating to me having to see him unedited like that. I'm still not over it.
@@swimminginthoughts🫢
Why not do the same for trump?
I think Biden is quite high functioning as an olive. (Fixed it for you).
That is hateful to olives.
Troll
@@joancooney7724 democrat
@@joancooney7724 You are? Oh, thanks for informing us!!!
@@joancooney7724yes you are..and a horrible one at that 😂😂
"Im the first Black VP woman working with a Black President." Joe Biden aka Gaffe Master 😂
Joe Biden approved 👌 👍 🙌 👏 😎
@@rickfraser5756here’s some tissues for those sad tears 😂😂😂
Trump baby❤❤❤
I won’t jump on Presidents goofs or demean him, as getting old sucks. But, the policies of his administration indicate he’s not aware of what others are doing. If so, he’s gone to the dark side of politics. A train wreck from foreign policy to crime,
ignoring the border for political gain, ignoring crime, and compelling speech on all is us. Thad a violation of free speech.
Played by Putin from day 1 of that war. Empowering Iran/terrorists and then bowing to Hamas (for political purposes).
This is the best version of Biden ever boy that really aged well 😂
Dehydration is what we saw at the debate. Loss of cognition and garbled speech is a symptom of dehydration in the elderly. Look it up! I’ve had 3 friends go to ER due to those symptoms, were checked for stroke, etc, and diagnosed with dehydration. They received fluids and were sent home fine.
I imagine a man with 80 year old plumbing might not drink much before standing at a podium for 90 minutes. Then as soon as he left stage would be given a bottle of water and be fine later in evening just like Joe was.
Exhaustion & mild illness and dehydration could account for his symptoms. I’ve seen it in 3 people over 60.
Will Biden accept Trump’s challenge to a golf game? Trump said he would donate $1-million to any charity of Biden’s choice. After all, Biden did say during the debate he would be willing to.
Who cares besides you
Who cares besides you
Shame on doctors who give medical opinions on people they have never examined 😮
Have you ever listened to biden?
@DaleYork-gw8vgAre you really asking if we believe a doctor who performed an examination over doctors who haven’t?
@DaleYork-gw8vg You mean Independence Day?
The signs of parkinsonism in Biden cannot be unseen.
@DaleYork-gw8vg In your narcissistic mind you think you shamed me. Your argument against me was in me referring to the holiday by its proper name, Independence Day. I do not have any shame in calling it that.
Seriously? It doesn't matter who was sitting in the oval office. A cold would still wipe them out. It's ridiculous to think age would make a difference. You all make the stories. Choose better ones to follow. Talk more about what these candidates have done while in office. Talk more about what the plans are of each one. Stop focusing on one bad debate.
Trump looked like death warmed over while he had COVID. He was in no shape to make any decisions for several days.
Illness and injury can happen at any age. A President undergoing surgery can't make decisions either. The Vice President acts in the President's place when needed. That's the whole idea of a VP.
Biden is a great president and will continue to be so! He can win and every one needs to just calm down 😎
I agree 💯 with Dr .Gupta
Whatever happened to Stolen Valor?
Remember when Dean Phillips challenged Joe and said he's not all there? Then the Democrats laughed at him. He was the only guy that could think ahead for the Democrat party. He should be an Independent. The others were either naive, or playing the game along with the Legacy Media's. Obviously the Democrats can think for themselves. And I promise. They were all playing along, crossing their fingers. And to me, that's absolutely delusional. 🤷
Seriously, Ezekiel is so judgemental! Let’s not forget Biden has a lifelong stutter and this can worsen during a debate type speech. Cut the man some slack! The MAGA crowd enjoys Trump’s ramblings. Biden was still on point despite his difficulty speaking that night.
I am voting Biden..nothing will make me prouder than to cast my vote on November 5th!
More gaslighting.🤢🤮
FACT: Trump would be 82 during his term!
I’m not a mechanic but I know when I see a car on the side of the road with a flat tire.
And Joe has a flat tire
"Of all the self-fulfilling prophecies in our culture, the assumption that aging means decline and poor health is probably the most deadliest."
~ Marilyn Ferguson, "The Aquarian Conspiracy." (1980)
Ah, high functioning. So when he poops his pants he’s still aware that he pooped his pants. Understood.
He does not poop in his pants. He uses a diaper. In fact, the majority of the White House budget is used for purchasing bulk quantities of union-made diapers. 😂
Maralargo diapers 👶
@@Kgrukbbgj5656utter ignorant nonsense, age shaming while we are all also aging n declining is crazy 💀, like actually crazy.
@@MissDookiee😂shut up
Wow still on the excuses? Let it go.
It's pretty disrespectful how Mika called Dr. Emanuel Zeke but she referred to Dr. Gupta as doctor.
If MSDNC has been lying to us for years about Potato joes health, what else have they been lying to us about?
Russian collusion hoax, Hunter's laptop was Russian disinformation. ..
Russian Collusion & Insurrection.
@@rickfraser5756 Do you have any rebuttal or are you just trolling? perhaps YOU are lost.
The cope that sunk an empire.
ROOMBA JOE IS DONE 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂PANIC MODE 😂😂😂😂😂
@@rickfraser5756 Joe is done 🤣🤣🫵🏼🫵🏼🤣🤣🤣🤣🫵🏼🫵🏼😂😂😂
Trump is slowly declining but no one talking about it
"In youth we learn; in age we understand."
~ Marie von Ebner-Eschenbach, "Aphorisms." (1905)
Man woman camera person tv
Let’s add sharks, electric batteries, sharpies, windmills, toilet flushing, bleach injections….…
Wouldn't the issues have come out in the past? THEY DID!!! WHY DO YOU THINK PEOPLE HAVE BEEN SCREAMING ABOUT THESE "LIMITATIONS" FOR MONTHS?
No, they haven't, because the people "screaming" about them are partisan hacks who ignore Trump's obvious mental debility
Joe shouldn't be in this situation, Mika says she loves Joe, it's got to break her heart to see him going through this and it's those closest to him that are to blame.
"jet lag" my dude was at camp david preparing for a week
To Drs. Ezekiel Emanuel and Vin Gupta: a Latin proverb: 'Here's your Rhodes, jump!'
---
There was a man who had been away on a journey and had then come back home. He strutted about town, talking loudly and at great length about the brave deeds he had accomplished in the various lands he had visited. In Rhodes, the man said, he had jumped such a long jump that no man alive could equal it, and he claimed that there were witnesses who could back up his story. A bystander then remarked, 'Alright! If you're telling the truth, here is your Rhodes: go on and jump!'
The fable shows that talking is a waste of time when you can simply provide a demonstration.
====
let Biden show his mettle, instead of calling Morning Joe, briefing the Governors, etc.
“The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command.”
"We did not change as we grew older; we just became more clearly ourselves."
~ Lynn Hall, "Where Have All the Tigers 🐅 Gone?" (1989)
I’m a independent and I just can’t vote for Biden , I watched this with my grandfather and I know what’s coming and it’s sad 😢 I hope he steps down if not , I just won’t vote
Vote Dementia Blue in 2024'
Great now he can face impeachment and prison sweet
This was the most consequential interview I've heard about concerning age. Thank you! Everyone now is an armchair expert and can diagnose even if they have no training nor have even met the person in question. This is different two doctors, both qualified. One is calling for the said individual to step aside without evidence. The other actually works with patients and is an expert on aging. We know which to believe 😏 and can be trusted. We saw him daily and know his dedication to science and not an emotional judgment. Doesn't matter who you are going to vote for.. because we won't have a candidate who can defeat the ex-president in November with all these "volunteers" who know more than the expert here. 😉
Gaslighting never ends
They pull out the whole excuse books 📚 to cover for biden 😂
Troll
@@joancooney7724democrat
@@joancooney7724wow that’ll show us 😂😂😂😂😂
@@rickfraser5756Joe is done 😂😂😂🫵🏼🫵🏼🫵🏼🫵🏼🫵🏼🫵🏼🫵🏼🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😂
Yeah Biden is old, let's talk about trump on Epstein's list now.
I told you guys you couldn't conceal Old Joe's cognitive decline forever.... Now look atcha just 4 1/2 months before the election.
(And he won't drop out because Jill and Hunter won't let him) 😆 .
But doctors can! Biden is doing just fine public knowledge.
We know absolutely nothing about Trump!
So yeah, dingleberry !
@@user-ug3hb1nn2c 🥴
@@user-ug3hb1nn2c
That's called a whataboutism.
@@user-ug3hb1nn2c Why does he refuse to do any cognitive tests?
@@roguetrader33it a guy thing. Why do I refused to go see a doctor?