@@Freedomforeverall Are you know? Wouldn't it be better to not announce it? ps..old rule in advertisement..always emphasise the qualities "the product"actually is lacking on. But I am guessing, by your tagname, you knew that one already
If you watch the first video of this debate where Mohammed El-Kurd is speaking the opposition is always immediately shut up whereas in this video they just let them scream and yell. They're pathetic.
To be fair, many governments with exclusively grown up adults constantly interrupt speakers. Including the Isrli government. It’s not great that the speakers are interrupted but let’s not clutch our pearls that tightly over it.
Which children? The mos-sad man and that shouty Joseph?? The arrogance of the loud men Nothing of substance because nothing of substance can justify apart heid
The youth of today in large portions fails to learn the basics of civilization like agreeing to disagree or agreements or how to discuss. This is because we lost track about what influences our children and what we don't teach them. They are radicalised by the news and by the lack of proper intervention from making them catastrophists.. unable to rule and to think they will he out last generation of the west we know. They show us our monstrous failure
I’m a Jew. I live in London. I’ve been personally harassed in the street twice in the last six months. I now have to conceal any signs of my visible Judaism while walking around the streets. No kippah, no star of David, no Cultural cues, I can’t speak on my phone to my family back in Israel in public. Is this normal for a western democracy like Britain? It’s the reality. And this video where you see exactly how this audience is permitted to behave…. Shows you just how deep the rot goes. Has England fallen? Maybe…
I watched a previous recording of Jonathan giving the same speech, but it didn’t include all of the interruptions by children having tantrums!! It is the responsibility of the Union to release the complete and total recording, not to eliminate certain parts!! This is dishonesty by the Union!!
The whole „debate“ was a setup the union president even gave a speech in which he ranted against Jonathan and Israel. The president who should be there for the check and balances atleast during the debate. Absolute disgrace, that shows how science and what should be a scientifical debate is treated.
In this scenario, you should be confident enough to fight using your arguments. People will have opposing views , you're going to have to deal with it. The lack of respect is really surprising... people on their phones not listening... The vibe is awful and immature.
I would call this a "public execution" not a fair "debate." Both the panel and the audience already had minds on lock down. Many/most were not listening with open minds. Makes Oxford Union feel more like a cult factory than a debating society. Audience disregard and hostility towards the presenter was disgraceful. Are they invited or scheduled speakers?
Their pupils in the Union are the next generation of radicalised adults. Spewing lies about Israel and the Jewish faith. It's disgraceful that Oxford, of all places, has fallen to extremist idealogy. Shameful and a warning to the next generation!
Yea reminiscent of fascist show trials in the 30’s and 40’s Oxford Union should be recognised as having been institutionally captured by terror supporters and shut down.
Finally, you have released another version of this disgrace, albeit with slight edits. The Oxford Union had been taken over by vulgar and disrespectful individuals. Despite the constant interruptions, the speaker delivered an eloquent and respectful speech. It is not possible to alter reality to conform to one’s narrative. Simply stating something does not make it factual. Break the feedback loop you have perpetuated and taught to believe in.
@@connie.22 Saw this for the first time here and was shockingly surprised over the lack of push back against his speech. Is this by design to root out comments that criticize him...?
They've edited many of the speakers that are stating facts and information on the pro-israel side. It's actually embarrassing, but more so disgraceful!
Frankly, the quality of the attitudes of the Oxford Union student generation is embarrassing, they are narrow-minded, like zombies, intoxicated only by social media but lazy to find out the truth of the news.
What an embarrassment those screeching children are. Are they REALLY students of our most esteemed seat of learning? God forbid, what does the future hold?
@@nigelbrayshaw2709 Well imagine listening to a debate 1941 of a German government justifying what is happening to the polish. I doubt you will sit still.
This clip doesn't just illustrate how disrespectful and infantile the audience for this debate were, it also shows how carefully the Union had to edit the footage to hide the shameful behaviour of the participants. Sad.
@@Freeeedumbno it's not opposed to that at all. It's nothing to do with anyone in Oxford. It's two different countries in the middle east. But you just want to play the victim card so go on talk about some dead children
A voice of clarity & reason. A speaker who if not interrupted constantly by the obviously childish & brainwashed students here, might have been able to provide them with the truths they do not want to hear. Thank you to all the opposition for your honor & bravery !
Exactly, isn't it?? The disgrace of this country is NOT supporting g3no cid3 The disgrace is the "jeering and screaming" of these students. Yeah, right. Got it 😂
If you’re incapable of been civil to one another in the Oxford union, then you have no serious criticism of the civility of people born on either side in a perpetual war zone.
@@jagamarszewska6158 and none of those organizations can explain how killing nearly 500,000 Japanese civilians in one day wasn’t even a war crime, let alone genocide, and killing an unknown number of civilians out of 40,000 casualties in over a year IS genocide… It’s almost like there are special rules for certain countries.
@@jagamarszewska6158 so because someone you've never met publishes a report saying something that's evidence all of a sudden? All the reports are done by un peacekeepers who have been accused and tried of helping hamas, what do you say to this?
@@Freeeedumb What a demented take.. You didnt even watch the video did you? Maybe watch it and you will see the lack of quality in Oxford Uni student, rude and no debate. The Uni should be ashamed of themselves
It will never stop to impress me the fact that the “peace people” the “moral high-grounders” are always shouting, insulting, threatening, and closing their ears and minds to the “other side” opinions and feelings. It's an absolute shame what happened in his debate as a whole, the total lack of the most basic education in such a prestigious room, the clearly biased direction from the presidency, the bellicism of some speakers (on both sides)… we all talk about “good” and “moral” am then act like this when another person is talking… shame, shame, and sorrow.
I thought the oxford university is one of the respectful and reputable one but in this debate, where is the respect or educated manners...shame on the Oxford university students...
well done for uploading the unedited versions but an absolute disgrace the Oxford union took not upon themselves to censor the terrible behaviour their students in the first place
If you add up all the Muslims, Christians and Jews that all follow God (or Allah in arabic) then God is by far the most worshiped God worldwide. However following God, and by which route - as a Jew, Christian, or Muslim is for individuals to chose. It is meaningless if you are forced to pretend to follow it or obey its rules. Then we are no longer liberated by God but oppresses by man in the name of religion.
Some people will criticize you for not showing the full speech to begin with. I will, instead, congratulate you for finally doing the right thing, under duress, after recordings of the speeches were already made public and the black-eye to the Oxford Union was already given. Nevertheless, you couldn't PAY me to take Oxford seriously now. I mean, I ALREADY saw it as a factory of classist apartheid, but your now-vocal support for politically-fashionable antisemitic genocide and theocratic oppression makes you a posh, twee enemy of the human race.
We all owe the Jewish people a big apology, but its way over due. From australia, Im ashamed of the antisemitism that has escalated since Oct 7. Its unbelievable. Please know many stand by you and are well aware of the lies and decietful tactics of Hamas, The UN, UNRWA and unfotunately the majority of Palestinians Israel has been amazing and we love you.
@@jbuda4263 True, Arabs have been attacking Israelis since the day they were established & lost & attacked many times since then & keep losing. It's like Arabs are not allowed to win and close this and Arabs are not allowed to lose it with support from Iran and 6 other Arab nations.
Jonathan perfectly explains why Israel is not an apartheid state and then when he says that people in Palestine get paid less than in Israel they say "sounds like apartheid to me" and everyone claps. This level of ignorance
The apartheit consept does not apply in Israel at all, but in many countrys it does. Gaza is not an exeption. I have in possession shool material form the strip that clearly resembles the naziproduced during wwII.
The president (Egyptian Arab) set up the double motion (genocide and apartheid), packed up the audience with people who keep cursing the debaters and interrupting the debaters opposing the motion , and finally censored the debate.
Because what he is saying isn’t true and has no proof. The situation on the ground speaks for itself. Even paramedics are being shots and not allowed to rescue injured civilians, many children with gunshot wounds to the head and the raping of Palestinian prisoners has been documented by the Israeli own media. Also Israeli government is blocking the foreign aid to enter Gaza and yet this guy saying Israel providing 3k calories to each gazen, this is just laughable
So far he is just lying. I was hoping he would come up with valid reasons, but so far just spread totally debunked properganda. Perhaps the second half will be better. There are better arguments he could have made.
@@happydays4302 Happy You are WRONG. It was an Amazing speech by Jonathan Sacerdoti. If you think you heard a lie prove it. You can't. What was damning is when asked only 5 percent of the audience raised their hands to say they would have warned the Israelis if they prior knowledge of the planned 7 October attack by Hamas.
@@avacigar5502 it's a while since I watched it but one clear misdirection I remembered is he says that the Polio vaccinations were given by Israel and N didn't do that... Well no because it wasn't invented then!!!! Also Israel didn't give the vaccinations- aid agencies did and were attacked by the IOF. Obviously the main reason was to protect the IDF from polio, an out break in Gaza could easily lead to one is Israel depending on thier vaccinations.
I used to believe that prestigious universities like Oxford must be incredibly difficult to get into and imagined that studying there would be an exciting experience, surrounded by a diverse community of people and a wide range of classes. However, this video has made the small private university where I completed my Master’s degree look far more admirable in comparison. It’s disheartening to see students blindly following the lies and propaganda of antisemites without questioning, doubting, reading credible sources, or even visiting the region to form their own opinions. Adult students screaming hysterically and hurling insults at a speaker, without showing the basic respect to let them speak, is shocking. This behavior resembles a 1990s American talk show more than the decorum expected of a distinguished university.
The audience in the foreground of this video, with eyes rolling, jeering and laughing, really upsets me. Why come to a debate when before you even hear the man’s argument you have decided he is wrong based on his religion. It’s really crazy to see at an institution such as Oxford university. The academics should be ashamed.
This talk was gaslighting and misdirection at its finest. So one 'fact' he gave was "Israel has vaccinated 97% of the Gazan population against Polio, you did not catch the Nxxx doing that" No you didn't.... polio vaccination wasn't invented until 1952!!! The first effective polio vaccine was developed in 1952 by Jonas Salk and a team at the University of Pittsburgh that included Julius Youngner, Byron Bennett, L. James Lewis, and Lorraine Friedman, which required years of subsequent testing. Also Israel didn't give the Polio vaccinations, aid agencies did, and even then some in aid conveys where killed by the IDF. "However, UN officials warned that Hamas and the Israeli military “must respect” the humanitarian pauses negotiated to allow the vaccinations, after two incidents this week - one deadly - when Israeli forces fired on aid vehicles, raising questions over how safely the vaccinations could be conducted." The guardian Also Israel only allowed the vaccinations to prevent Israelis from being exposed to Polio, there wS nothing altruistic in it.
@@ill3gal1 The Holocaust on the other hand was targeted towards one particular group : The Jews. It was intended to wipe the Jews off the face of the Earth, without any provocation from the Judeans in the first place. It killed 6 million Jews at the very least for no reason. I pity your parents, imagine birthing a child without a fully developed brain.
Students? Probably a bunch of junkies with a privilege to attend (box ticking?) of the most prestigious universities in the UK (or what it used to be once upon a time). Such a shame. 😢
I dont understand, even if I disagreed withe everysingle thing he said, I would not be acting like some monstrous teenage child, who hasn't got their way. How were these people raised omd
The audience were absolutely disgraceful! This classy, intelligent, educated speaker has the patience of an angel and more class in his little finger than the whole room combined..Kol Hakavod 👏👏👏
Porque a primeira publicação estava muito mais editada que esta e depois do orador ter publicado um vídeo sem qualquer tipo de edição, que obteve mais de um milhão de visualizações, para tentarem salvar a face eliminaram o primeiro e publicaram este menos editado!😢
This joke of a debate exposes Oxford as a complete disgrace.
Jesus how many times do these children get to scream and interrupt before they get thrown out? ridiciolus.
Hi they are Muslims ☪️ if u are an Islamophobe please don't say anything about it because of PC culture and stuff
As many times as they want because the Egyptian running everything agrees with them.
@@Eleriol84 Borat impersonators should not be allowed
Why do you use "Jesus" as an exclamation?? How ridiculous
If you were a Christian, you wouldn't use that name like that. Have some respect
Until he stop lie
Oxford is such a disgrace
Hasbara bot
Why? People dont buy lies and zionists propaganda?
The moderator is horrible
@@Freedomforeverall Are you know? Wouldn't it be better to not announce it? ps..old rule in advertisement..always emphasise the qualities "the product"actually is lacking on. But I am guessing, by your tagname, you knew that one already
@@reddragonready shut up diddy
these entitled, rude, ignorant Oxford Union screaming students are a disgrace...is this what the new generations are all about ? God forbid
If you watch the first video of this debate where Mohammed El-Kurd is speaking the opposition is always immediately shut up whereas in this video they just let them scream and yell. They're pathetic.
We don’t need to respect Nazis, thanks
To be fair, many governments with exclusively grown up adults constantly interrupt speakers. Including the Isrli government. It’s not great that the speakers are interrupted but let’s not clutch our pearls that tightly over it.
its not the new generation, it's a foreign generation that doesn't belong in europe
Actually I think you will find they have received the perfect training…to enter into politics 😂
I am disappointed at the lack of respect for debate these children are demonstating. People either respect the rules or leave.
Which children?
The mos-sad man and that shouty Joseph?? The arrogance of the loud men
Nothing of substance because nothing of substance can justify apart heid
Muslims has no respect for other
The youth of today in large portions fails to learn the basics of civilization like agreeing to disagree or agreements or how to discuss. This is because we lost track about what influences our children and what we don't teach them. They are radicalised by the news and by the lack of proper intervention from making them catastrophists.. unable to rule and to think they will he out last generation of the west we know. They show us our monstrous failure
Just a bunch of junkies. I doubt they go their for the education.
what's truly disappointing is that many old people were doing that as well
I’m a Jew. I live in London. I’ve been personally harassed in the street twice in the last six months. I now have to conceal any signs of my visible Judaism while walking around the streets. No kippah, no star of David, no Cultural cues, I can’t speak on my phone to my family back in Israel in public. Is this normal for a western democracy like Britain? It’s the reality. And this video where you see exactly how this audience is permitted to behave…. Shows you just how deep the rot goes. Has England fallen? Maybe…
But muslims have been suffering your odeal for years. Welcome to the party.
@@ytbmQC Muslims are the most visible minority in the UK - if you have zero sympathy to what Jews are going for its clear you're part of the problem
@@ytbmQC
Muslims have been marching in London in the past 1 year and harassing other people.
Where have you been?
why arent you christian?
@@romeisfallingagain MYOBB
I watched a previous recording of Jonathan giving the same speech, but it didn’t include all of the interruptions by children having tantrums!! It is the responsibility of the Union to release the complete and total recording, not to eliminate certain parts!! This is dishonesty by the Union!!
The whole „debate“ was a setup the union president even gave a speech in which he ranted against Jonathan and Israel. The president who should be there for the check and balances atleast during the debate. Absolute disgrace, that shows how science and what should be a scientifical debate is treated.
Welcome to the Forgers' Union.
Oxford!? Oxford acts more like a subway station, with eye rolling, laughing, and jeering. These are not serious people. Truly pitiful.
In this scenario, you should be confident enough to fight using your arguments. People will have opposing views , you're going to have to deal with it. The lack of respect is really surprising... people on their phones not listening... The vibe is awful and immature.
These people don't care about logic, facts, or the meaning of words.
I would call this a "public execution" not a fair "debate." Both the panel and the audience already had minds on lock down. Many/most were not listening with open minds. Makes Oxford Union feel more like a cult factory than a debating society. Audience disregard and hostility towards the presenter was disgraceful. Are they invited or scheduled speakers?
Completely agree. "This house believes" already sounds like the creed of a cult, not like the thesis for a debate.
Their pupils in the Union are the next generation of radicalised adults. Spewing lies about Israel and the Jewish faith. It's disgraceful that Oxford, of all places, has fallen to extremist idealogy. Shameful and a warning to the next generation!
Yea reminiscent of fascist show trials in the 30’s and 40’s
Oxford Union should be recognised as having been institutionally captured by terror supporters and shut down.
@@himmel-erdeundzuruck5682 the questions are always done as a for or against.
@@happydays4302 That's not common in high ranking debates. Common is to give a thesis, to agree or disagree with, not a creed.
Finally, you have released another version of this disgrace, albeit with slight edits.
The Oxford Union had been taken over by vulgar and disrespectful individuals. Despite the constant interruptions, the speaker delivered an eloquent and respectful speech.
It is not possible to alter reality to conform to one’s narrative. Simply stating something does not make it factual.
Break the feedback loop you have perpetuated and taught to believe in.
proof?
Why did you release the edited version first? You need to explain yourselves !
Because the imam wants so.
Im glad the Union had the decency to re upload this clip amongst others, not filtering out the disgraceful behaviour of the audience.
But it did filter out all the comments and people that watched the previous version.
@@connie.22 Saw this for the first time here and was shockingly surprised over the lack of push back against his speech. Is this by design to root out comments that criticize him...?
All the speakers were interrupted multiple times in this debate. Stop with this absurd perpetual victim complex.
They've edited many of the speakers that are stating facts and information on the pro-israel side. It's actually embarrassing, but more so disgraceful!
It was censored... Did you watch the video?
Frankly, the quality of the attitudes of the Oxford Union student generation is embarrassing, they are narrow-minded, like zombies, intoxicated only by social media but lazy to find out the truth of the news.
Maybe you are the one who is narrow-minded and indoctrinated?
What an embarrassment those screeching children are. Are they REALLY students of our most esteemed seat of learning? God forbid, what does the future hold?
Exactly!
Try getting a German government speaker in a debate with a polish survivors in 1941. And hear yourself screaming every time the Germans lie.
not much...
@@nigelbrayshaw2709 Well imagine listening to a debate 1941 of a German government justifying what is happening to the polish. I doubt you will sit still.
@@yahiasameh5960 xD
This clip doesn't just illustrate how disrespectful and infantile the audience for this debate were, it also shows how carefully the Union had to edit the footage to hide the shameful behaviour of the participants. Sad.
Only those shouting idiots don’t know respect and law order. What a shame on those young adults with “high education”😢
The behavior among the audience is a disgrace!!
as opposed to the behaviour in Gaza..
how so?
@@littleflags Did you watch the video?
@@Freeeedumb Yeah, hamas are messed up
@@Freeeedumbno it's not opposed to that at all. It's nothing to do with anyone in Oxford. It's two different countries in the middle east. But you just want to play the victim card so go on talk about some dead children
tomorrow's title:"This house believes that the Earth is flat'
U have lost respect for your institution
And votes in favour after inviting 80% flatearthers
It does, the paigambar said so.
Yes the earth is round. Just like Theodor Herz was a European.
@@RobPires Herzl was as more jewish than Yasser Arafat was Egyptian.
What a speaker, thank you.
"Just because you dislike loosing an unnecessary war you started does not make something genocide." 🔥
Disgraceful behaviour. Such open bias. Abhorrence roams the halls of Oxford!
Great speech Mr. Jonathan Sacerdoti.. It shocked me to see a bunch of idiots full of prejudices and disturbing the room inside Oxford
A voice of clarity & reason. A speaker who if not interrupted constantly by the obviously childish & brainwashed students here, might have been able to provide them with the truths they do not want to hear. Thank you to all the opposition for your honor & bravery !
Honor and bravery is apparently what is now called spewing propaganda for the most oppressive regime in 2024.
Are the students jeering and screaming, the future of our society? No wonder the UK has gone to the dogs 😢
Exactly, isn't it??
The disgrace of this country is NOT supporting g3no cid3
The disgrace is the "jeering and screaming" of these students.
Yeah, right. Got it 😂
it's rising inequality to blame not rich kids in fancy school (atho they are part of the rising inequality)
Wow. I had no idea that there are so many immigrants in the oxford union 😲
As members sign up to debates they are interested in, it’s really not surprising…
The absolute state of Oxford's students.
If you’re incapable of been civil to one another in the Oxford union, then you have no serious criticism of the civility of people born on either side in a perpetual war zone.
Just class from Jonathan, Bravo.
Oxford "students" are pathetic.
Zios are pathetic. FACTS
How worrying that our supposedly best minds are so incredibly stupid, rude and chidlish, shame on them!
dont like? Dont come here. Simples :)
@@newdude1258says the invader!
Wow, the similarities between the islamist and the woke are amazing.
Similarities between the zionists and nazis are also amazing 👌
@@zainubumar it's not antisemitic, it's antiseptic
It's true most woke are atheist or Christian haters but obsessed for some reason with Muslims.
Usually people who blame Jews for everything are not well
@@zainubumaryet another October agent.
To hecklers in that chamber, instead of raising your voice and yelling at the speaker why don't you improve your arguments?
I'm guessing its because they don't actually have anything to say, and if they shout loud enough maybe nobody will notice.
Their arguments end at the number of civilians hamas is claiming to have died, something something genocide something something colonisation
their arguments are in every human right organisations raports, UN, ICC and ICJ, easy access
@@jagamarszewska6158 and none of those organizations can explain how killing nearly 500,000 Japanese civilians in one day wasn’t even a war crime, let alone genocide, and killing an unknown number of civilians out of 40,000 casualties in over a year IS genocide…
It’s almost like there are special rules for certain countries.
@@jagamarszewska6158 so because someone you've never met publishes a report saying something that's evidence all of a sudden? All the reports are done by un peacekeepers who have been accused and tried of helping hamas, what do you say to this?
Oxford is a joke now
It is, how this guy was allowed in is beyond me
@@Freeeedumb What a demented take.. You didnt even watch the video did you? Maybe watch it and you will see the lack of quality in Oxford Uni student, rude and no debate. The Uni should be ashamed of themselves
@@Kushdeeskates i did and he lied through his teeth.
@@newdude1258 You have been led astray my friend
@@Freeeedumbyour name says it all.
It will never stop to impress me the fact that the “peace people” the “moral high-grounders” are always shouting, insulting, threatening, and closing their ears and minds to the “other side” opinions and feelings.
It's an absolute shame what happened in his debate as a whole, the total lack of the most basic education in such a prestigious room, the clearly biased direction from the presidency, the bellicism of some speakers (on both sides)… we all talk about “good” and “moral” am then act like this when another person is talking… shame, shame, and sorrow.
4:05 Why do pro-hamas people resist so hard against hearing what attrocities Hamas have commited???
Like the black woman shaking her head that way?
becos it is alleggations and no evidence. Still waiting for 40 babez with no domes. Can ya point me to it
I thought the oxford university is one of the respectful and reputable one but in this debate, where is the respect or educated manners...shame on the Oxford university students...
What wonderful words... And so full of truth
😂😂😂😂😂
The chairman is a living joke
How did he get to the place ,by reciting Quran or what?
well done for uploading the unedited versions but an absolute disgrace the Oxford union took not upon themselves to censor the terrible behaviour their students in the first place
The Mosab’s video is still edited
also censored
They are edited and censored. E.g. the Union president asked Mossab to leave, but that was edited out.
This was still edited!
@@ds_7why did they ask him to leave
Oxford has disgraced itself
What an extraordinary and dignified speech in the face of brainwashed ignorant entitled fools.
Oxford debate in 2045 : why is the west so hesitate to accept there is no god but Allah ?
why 2045? It looks like it will happen even sooner
If you add up all the Muslims, Christians and Jews that all follow God (or Allah in arabic) then God is by far the most worshiped God worldwide. However following God, and by which route - as a Jew, Christian, or Muslim is for individuals to chose. It is meaningless if you are forced to pretend to follow it or obey its rules. Then we are no longer liberated by God but oppresses by man in the name of religion.
2025
Allah is the Arabic word for god. Muslims worship the same god of the Jews and Christians they are an Abrahamic religion
Some people will criticize you for not showing the full speech to begin with. I will, instead, congratulate you for finally doing the right thing, under duress, after recordings of the speeches were already made public and the black-eye to the Oxford Union was already given. Nevertheless, you couldn't PAY me to take Oxford seriously now. I mean, I ALREADY saw it as a factory of classist apartheid, but your now-vocal support for politically-fashionable antisemitic genocide and theocratic oppression makes you a posh, twee enemy of the human race.
Antisemitic genocide? Are you referring to the Semites living in Palestine?
Oxford supports hamas and absolutely discriminates on Jewish people!! It's been documented by this house!
jews are hyksos
We all owe the Jewish people a big apology, but its way over due. From australia, Im ashamed of the antisemitism that has escalated since Oct 7. Its unbelievable. Please know many stand by you and are well aware of the lies and decietful tactics of Hamas, The UN, UNRWA and unfotunately the majority of Palestinians
Israel has been amazing and we love you.
Thank you for this message
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏🫶
You seem to forget this didn’t start on October 7th or you only care about white poll?
@@jbuda4263 since they aren't white, your comment means nothing.
@@jbuda4263 True, Arabs have been attacking Israelis since the day they were established & lost & attacked many times since then & keep losing. It's like Arabs are not allowed to win and close this and Arabs are not allowed to lose it with support from Iran and 6 other Arab nations.
Jonathan perfectly explains why Israel is not an apartheid state and then when he says that people in Palestine get paid less than in Israel they say "sounds like apartheid to me" and everyone claps. This level of ignorance
The shame of a once reputable university 😢
The apartheit consept does not apply in Israel at all, but in many countrys it does. Gaza is not an exeption. I have in possession shool material form the strip that clearly resembles the naziproduced during wwII.
The president (Egyptian Arab) set up the double motion (genocide and apartheid), packed up the audience with people who keep cursing the debaters and interrupting the debaters opposing the motion , and finally censored the debate.
that can't be a legit president of anything.
19:26 why can't they hear that? Why when there are awful facts they scream at him? It's so sad to see Jews in 2024 need to defend themselves... Again.
Such disgrace, the 2 girls in black rolling their eyes.Reminds me of spoiled brats that are not getting thier own way.
Because what he is saying isn’t true and has no proof. The situation on the ground speaks for itself. Even paramedics are being shots and not allowed to rescue injured civilians, many children with gunshot wounds to the head and the raping of Palestinian prisoners has been documented by the Israeli own media. Also Israeli government is blocking the foreign aid to enter Gaza and yet this guy saying Israel providing 3k calories to each gazen, this is just laughable
Amazng speech by Jonathan Sacerdoti.
So far he is just lying. I was hoping he would come up with valid reasons, but so far just spread totally debunked properganda. Perhaps the second half will be better. There are better arguments he could have made.
@@happydays4302 Happy You are WRONG.
It was an Amazing speech by Jonathan Sacerdoti.
If you think you heard a lie prove it. You can't.
What was damning is when asked only 5 percent of the audience raised their hands to say they would have warned the Israelis if they prior knowledge of the planned 7 October attack by Hamas.
@@happydays4302
What did he say that was a lie?
Specifically
@@avacigar5502 it's a while since I watched it but one clear misdirection I remembered is he says that the Polio vaccinations were given by Israel and N didn't do that... Well no because it wasn't invented then!!!! Also Israel didn't give the vaccinations- aid agencies did and were attacked by the IOF. Obviously the main reason was to protect the IDF from polio, an out break in Gaza could easily lead to one is Israel depending on thier vaccinations.
Pathetic and liars, shame on Oxford.
Jonathan, thank you from all of us here in Israel💙🇮🇱
reuploading so it would blend the mossab debate. shame
Shameful educated new generation, dont know how to behave.
"educated new generation" 🤔 "educated" 😳... "educated" 🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😅😆😁🤨😬🤢🤮
Oxford just became a Kindergarten
Funny how emotional you get when your homeland is being eradicated
I used to believe that prestigious universities like Oxford must be incredibly difficult to get into and imagined that studying there would be an exciting experience, surrounded by a diverse community of people and a wide range of classes. However, this video has made the small private university where I completed my Master’s degree look far more admirable in comparison.
It’s disheartening to see students blindly following the lies and propaganda of antisemites without questioning, doubting, reading credible sources, or even visiting the region to form their own opinions. Adult students screaming hysterically and hurling insults at a speaker, without showing the basic respect to let them speak, is shocking. This behavior resembles a 1990s American talk show more than the decorum expected of a distinguished university.
What a shame! I stand with Isreal!!!
What a clown 💩💩
Golda Meir had a PALESTINIAN PASSPORT 🇵🇸..
Thank you 🙏 Mosab
I heard your speech and now I support Palestine 🇵🇸 even more.
Am Palestine Chai…
mr. sacerdoti, respect. you are a real champion of justice and truth
The audience in the foreground of this video, with eyes rolling, jeering and laughing, really upsets me. Why come to a debate when before you even hear the man’s argument you have decided he is wrong based on his religion. It’s really crazy to see at an institution such as Oxford university. The academics should be ashamed.
They continue to try changing the truth !!! 1 vs many Thank you !
he spoke no truth. Care to list bullet points on what truth he spoke about?
This man is speaking facts
This talk was gaslighting and misdirection at its finest.
So one 'fact' he gave was "Israel has vaccinated 97% of the Gazan population against Polio, you did not catch the Nxxx doing that"
No you didn't.... polio vaccination wasn't invented until 1952!!!
The first effective polio vaccine was developed in 1952 by Jonas Salk and a team at the University of Pittsburgh that included Julius Youngner, Byron Bennett, L. James Lewis, and Lorraine Friedman, which required years of subsequent testing.
Also Israel didn't give the Polio vaccinations, aid agencies did, and even then some in aid conveys where killed by the IDF.
"However, UN officials warned that Hamas and the Israeli military “must respect” the humanitarian pauses negotiated to allow the vaccinations, after two incidents this week - one deadly - when Israeli forces fired on aid vehicles, raising questions over how safely the vaccinations could be conducted." The guardian
Also Israel only allowed the vaccinations to prevent Israelis from being exposed to Polio, there wS nothing altruistic in it.
@@happydays4302 You are Brain-washed
@@happydays4302can i have the source?
@@StephanzDiwize of course, which particular bit would you like the source on?
@@StephanzDiwize of course, seems to be deleting my answer, good old you tube!! Which bit would you like the source for?
Excellent rational speaker making truthful points with clear evidence.
Genocide denial isn’t making truthful points
@@ill3gal1 Just because you dislike losing an unnecessary war that you started does not make something genocide.
@@WyattB666 I guess the Holocaust wasn't a genocide either then, just because Jews disliked losing the Warsaw uprising
@@WyattB666 guess the Holo coast wasn't a genocide either then. We can play this game if you want
@@ill3gal1 The Holocaust on the other hand was targeted towards one particular group : The Jews. It was intended to wipe the Jews off the face of the Earth, without any provocation from the Judeans in the first place. It killed 6 million Jews at the very least for no reason. I pity your parents, imagine birthing a child without a fully developed brain.
kind of crazy that i watch this debate last week on this channel and now it just got uploaded and hour ago.
The utter state of Oxford Union. Disasterous.
This debate has been censored by Oxford Union.
Release the full debate.
People that keep interrupting the speaker, aren’t individuals that really take conversations and their content seriously.
Brilliant speech, the other side disgraced themselves
Israel defending her citizens as it should and must do
Get em Mosab! God loves men like him.
The lack of decorum is just… embarrassing. But also, are we shocked? Not particularly.
He speaks well
lol finally forced to release the video, huh?!
These children (and I mean children) are too young to know what they're screaming about. Get them out.
@oxfordunion are you reading the comments? The world is not a cultish and antisemitic echo chamber after all.
Students? Probably a bunch of junkies with a privilege to attend (box ticking?) of the most prestigious universities in the UK (or what it used to be once upon a time). Such a shame. 😢
Mr Mosan hasan yosef is saying the only truth there is. May God bless him.❤
It seems that in Oxford, “a point of information” is a student screaming “LIES”. This says it all!! Disgraceful
This man's patience and composure must studied.
What a gentleman.
😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
When you’re wrong you tend to be loud.
"Just because you dislike loosing an unnecessary war you stared does not make something genocide" 👏
“This house believes pigs fly”
Oxford has fallen.
😂😂😂😂
shame on you oxford students!!!!
I love and appreciate Jonathan
now Oxford=oxfordistan
I dont understand, even if I disagreed withe everysingle thing he said, I would not be acting like some monstrous teenage child, who hasn't got their way. How were these people raised omd
The woman at the front seat with coverd head will never change.
I thought he was gonna have a deeper voice like Matt Walsh.
Free Palestine!
Laughing and jeering in such a debate isn’t on either side.
The audience were absolutely disgraceful! This classy, intelligent, educated speaker has the patience of an angel and more class in his little finger than the whole room combined..Kol Hakavod 👏👏👏
Where is the Oxford union to debate the massacre of peaceful lebaneses by the palestiniens?it should be mentioned.
Here to express my deep respect and thanks to my brother Jonathan!
Why the repost? were you not happy with the comments?
Porque a primeira publicação estava muito mais editada que esta e depois do orador ter publicado um vídeo sem qualquer tipo de edição, que obteve mais de um milhão de visualizações, para tentarem salvar a face eliminaram o primeiro e publicaram este menos editado!😢
Jonathan❤❤❤❤❤
What awful students! They have no manners, discipline or respect. How embarrassing for the university.
The 2 Arabic when in camera, either do not hear nor understand what is being said.
Those smug eye rolls from behind the speaker in the crowd mean nothing in truth.
Major Yousef,God is with you and God wil always bless and protect you for being objective and and frank
Proud of you Sacerdoti, you are a great debater.