There’s no doubt Mario got soiled by that kid and tripped out when the accident happened. Sounds like Mario was being a real ass friend and got stabbed in the back
Yeah, I actually feel bad for Mario. The mother even made up a story saying that Mario was bullying and intimidating her "sweet little boy". When in fact Mario got himself in trouble to cover her son's butt.
True, Mario should have kept lying for his friend. Yes I was driving your honor but I didn’t take the keys he gave me permission. Then the blame would have been back on Andre.
I would say the four scam the show by making everything up. there was an accident. there was an unsuccessful claim. the rest of it are all made up stories. that is why there wasn't a police report.
the son obviously did it. he was incredibly nervous the whole time. the friend was very calm and confident the whole time because he thought for sure he did nothing wrong until jj informs him he made the mistake of taking the fall for him by telling the cops he was the driver. then his demeanor changed.
I believe Mario was driving. There is NO NEED for him to LIE to the police and say he was driving. Plus, Mario didn’t have a license, who in their right mind would take the fall of an accident and they don’t have a license? By your logic, Mario would rather get into legal trouble rather than have his friend get in trouble with his mother? Please make that make sense…
Son was nervous.. but if he was terrified of this Mario he may have acted out in ways that don't make sense. But also would explain his fear speaking out against him in court
I think Andre's mother told him she didn't want him hanging out with Mario, but he did it anyway. I also believe she told him not to have anybody in the car or allow them to drive it, and he disobeyed her again, then he made up the story about Mario bullying him because he was scared. She knew her son was lying. She seems like a no nonsense mother, so her only purpose was there was to be reimbursed.
Absolutely!! 💯 And the plaintiffs mother will never believe that, even if her own son looked her in the eye and told her it was true. Seriously mommy blind
@@Nevaeh1 I think both things are true. Andre is a nerdy 'goody 2 shoes' but he wants to be liked by the 'cool kids'. The Mario guy does probably bully him (which is why the Mom doesn't like him) but the kid clearly wants to be liked by Mario (who gives off the "I'm the tough cool kid vibe) and therefore does what Mario likes even though he knows it will get him in trouble. Mario is a practiced liar - his story is just too smoothly delivered, while the Andre kid is obviously nervous but he readily rattles off the names of all the people present and the exact times that things happen.
@Bernard Ordiz I think Mario was lying about "lying to the police". He really was the one driving and came up with that story about Andre asking him to switch seats
@@Nevaeh1 my theory is he was on a learners intermediate permit like my state has. This let's high-school aged drivers enter a stage where they do not need an experienced driver in the passenger seat overseeing them. BUT they can not have any passengers except immediate family members, or licensed drivers of 5 years. In the final stage you are allowed 1 friend or maybe more I don't remember the details exactly. But no more unless they meet the earlier criteria or over 18 maybe. Then if they don't have any accidents through those 3 stages, and don't get any tickets. They get a full fledged license earlier than they normally would. Let's kids drive to school and help their family by having another driver. But doesn't allow the driver to go around town with kids their own age being a distraction to their driving. If you are caught with a passenger that you aren't allowed. You instantly lose your permit and the perks that you were progressing through. Since his buddy had no car before becoming an adult, nor plans for one. He didn't care about losing a license he didn't have in the first place. Now his buddy can keep driving and has no mark on his record that currently affects him. Insurance will cover it everything's good. Well that plan backfired. Now he can drive. But they are out of the cost of a car cuz insurance said no. Where as if the son owned up and took the consequences. He'd be unable to drive, but they'd have money for a new car. Which he'd be able to drive again when he turned 18... which he was by the time they went to court xD So they're whole plan just backfired and would have been better if they owned up to it because now if they own up to it. It's a false police report perjury etc. So mom tells her son to say his friend, who she doesn't even approve of in the first place, stole the car from him. Because then it could become a matter where the insurance covers a stolen car. But that's just absurd as we all heard lol. Judy ain't gunna allow this Karen of a mom to ruin a young adults legal record for an insurance cover up of $1500. However the moron did take responsibility for the accident. It's out of her hands because he's already sealed his fate. Since he crashed the car, he's responsible for the damage. He said he drove. Driver assumes all responsibility of operating the vehicle including making sure they and the vehicle are licensed and insured to the minimum requirement by law. So he's responsible for the financial burden of everyone involved. And he admitted to being responsible for an uninsured vehicle without proper brakes. He's screwed himself, and that Karen got her way with it. "Under an intermediate license, you must follow these rules: For the first 6 months, you are not allowed any passengers under 20 years old except immediate family members. For the next 6 months, your passengers are restricted to no more than 3 people under 20 years old who aren't members of your immediate family." I think he was in the first 6.
I mean unless you are guilty. In that case you better be a *very* good liar. Because assuming they received standard interrogation training they are very good at catching lies.
@@5starStones That’s ridiculous. I don’t know if there was bullying and neither do you. I don’t know if the plaintiff was being truthful and neither do you. I don’t know if Mario took the fall and *neither do you*
@@5starStones I do believe there was lines crossed. That unfortunately happens with young people. However, it's sketchy that the mom let her son multiple go to the house of someone she doesn't even like nor trust... that's bad parenting.... Also doesn't matter who was lying both kids need to learn what it means to take accountability. If he was a bully, you don't put yourself purposely in a vulnerable situation.. if the defendant did cover his friend.. you don't do so unless the situation is dire, it just teaches your friend how not to take responsibility.
They aren’t working so they couldn’t pay it off on their own right now anyway. Who’s gonna hire someone in debt at age 18. Also I’m not sure if Mario can even be held accountable at 18 in JJ’s district only his family could.
That mother still believes her sweet little son did nothing wrong although he’s lying to her face. It’s a shame he fears her to this extent. He’ll never be honest with her nor genuine out of fear.
Nah, the mother is a big fat liar too. She opened the complaint with lies. She taught his son how to lie. She is happy with her work. Disgusting person.
You need to put yourself in her shoes. she didn't like Mario to begin with (it seems) and she has to believe what her son tells her. The fault is 10000% with the son, who wouldn't even tell his mother the truth when she said she would sue Mario. The case was over as soon as Judy told Mario "you told the police it was your fault, now these are the consecuences" no matter who was lying.
It's brave, but not anything to be proud of. He lied to the police and had to pay alot of money for something he didn't do for someone not willing to take responsibility for their mistake. If it was a more serious situation and someone was hurt or killed, he would have gone to jail and faced charges and even be in bigger trouble since he was the one without a license.
I very much doubt that this kid would’ve taken the fall for someone dying, let’s not be ludicrous. I think it’s a very kind gesture if what Mario is saying is true. Being willing to take the fall for someone that you consider a friend is a bold and crystal clear indication of your character, and it IS something to be proud of. My brothers and I would take the shit end of bad deals from our parents for one another, and even to this day I’ll take the blame for others I care about if it’s something they can’t handle. Caring about people isn’t something frivolous or outrageous, it’s something we don’t see enough of in the modern world. If what Mario said is true, then the plaintiff should feel terrible for treating his friend this way and putting him through this.
Her son is a fibber. That’s an understatement. He manipulated his “friend” to take the fall for him AND lied and allowed the court to fine his “friend” Who needs enemies? 🤷🏽♀️
Andre was spending so much brainpower trying to remember what his mother invented for the court case that he couldn't remember what was truth and what was lies. For a start his mother only knew to mistrust Mario because he was visiting at their house - she wasn't going to go to Mario's house to ascertain his character. It fits with Andre's weasel-like personality for him to swap seats with Mario and let Mario take the blame not because of some insurance nonsense, but because he didn't want to take the blame with his mother. He is a lying snivelling coward. However Mario is the idiot for telling the police he was driving. He needs to learn that there are real-world consequences for playing these kinds of children's games. Andre is extremely immature, and Mario is just plain dumb.
The mom made up a bogus lie to paint the picture of Mario being a bully. Her son went right along with her and made up his story about Mario being intimidating. When it comes to legal stuff never take the fall for anyone! I low key wanted to cry for Mario. That’s a real kick in the gut. It’s a hard lesson for sure. Not to mention he has that hefty ticket on his record.
Anyone else see the irony of mom warning about Mario when it's her own son conspiring to lie to the cops to save his own behind and make someone else pay for his mistakes?
The irony is real! The plaintiff has clearly learned to lie and manipulate situations to bypass getting in trouble with his helicopter mom. The mom hasn't realized what she has created. Mario turned out to be the stand up guy her son is not
From the second that Judge Judy started to check the plaintiff's mom calling her out on her lie I could see the guilt on her face and I knew she coerced her son into saying that he was bullied.
I disagree; she was lied to by her son. She looked mad, and I've been a mother of 3 teenagers, I know that look. 😂 He lied to her, and the plaintiff couldn't keep his own story straight.
I worked with at risk youth for more than a decade. I can always tell when a kid is hiding something. One of my good friends was discussing her teenage daughter and basically described her as a saint. Whenever there was an incident involving another student or peer she immediately believed her daughter. I told her that her daughter was not perfect and she shouldn’t believe everything she tells her. This caused a riff in our friendship. Over the next two years her daughter went from being on the national junior honor society and head cheerleader to a high school dropout. She ran away from home after assaulting her mother when she caught her sneaking an adult man in her window and her disappearance made the local news. She spent two years as an exotic dancer, couch surfing from place to place. One day we were driving around a bad area searching for her daughter an my friend apologized to me for reacting so harshly when I tried to open her eyes. I cried as she said “I wish I listened to you”. Parents please open your eyes and realize that your children aren’t perfect angels. They’re imperfect and flawed just like the rest of us.
Yes, when girls start to menstruate, they demeanor changes drastically and boys ( or girls ) become a focal point in their lives. That s why, back in the day, girls would be married off at that time, so they wouldn t end up being passed around from one male to another.
Why do you feel bad for lying kids look at the mother of one of the kids no excuse for him lying to the judge and his mother sitting right there not acceptable my mother didn't bring me up that way to lie definitely not in front of her haven't you ever heard of lead-by-example is this something his mother did lie lie lie so now he feels it's okay to lie lie lie something's not right and you don't see no problem with it
@@cherrylove3656 Your comment reads like insane gibberish. Also while I’m happy YOUR mother helped you value truth, a lot of kids are trained to lie because their parents will go berserk if they heat a truth they don’t like. The kid looks terrified to speak in front of his mom, I suspect for that reason.
I feel for both kids. Mario took the fall and his friend is so afraid of his mom that he threw him under the bus in front of millions of people for something he clearly didn't do. There are no winners here. The plaintiff is clearly terrified of his mom which makes me wonder about his home life.
Nope. The black kid sold his friend out after he pleaded with him to take the rap cuz he s a moma s boy and still sucking on his mother s titty. With a friend like that, who needs enemies.
This is why you never let anyone off their responsibility when they are in a car accident. They are desperate in that situation and desperate people will do anything to save themselves.
Don't take blame for your friends. Look at the mess he got himself in. The plaintiff lied, clearly lied. The defendant told the truth. Its unfortunate the plaintiff got away with it despite the huge, obvious lie. His worst part was when he said Mario got in the car with two other friends, Uli and I don't who was the other person. OF COURSE, because it was you. You couldn't name someone else. It was you. Wish at least they would mention on the report that the plaintiff was there. Disgusting people. Bad example. Lying mother too. Bad people.
The amount of times he furrowed his brown with serious thinking shows he was lying up a storm. He was literally flying by the seat of his pants, sprinkling enough truth to seem believable but 90% lie
That plaintiff was stumbling all over the place because he’s a liar. He was too cowardly to face his mother, you could see it in her face but she still went along with the accusation. ZERO INTEGRITY. Hopefully Mario learns to pick better friends.
Wow this kid's a liar and his mother sitting right there what's that make her he had no problem throwing Mario under the bus by lying saying he bullied me to get the keys and if Mario took the blame for it that was just downright ignorant but listening to the whole case they both are liars
I'm somewhat surprised by this one. Pretty sure I recall Judge Judy holding the plaintiff at least responsible in part in other similar cases (where the owner allowed the at-fault driver to drive the car knowing they had no license, etc.).
The turning point was that the defendant lied to the police to cover for the plaintiff. His lie is all over the police report and established as a matter of fact as if he's responsible. Judge judy heavily relies on police reports to make a judgment and in doing so turned to the plaintiff's direction as the chain of evidence, the police report, indicates the defendant was at fault. Now everyone in the audience knows the plaintiff clearly did it, but it's not provable in a court. Hence Judge judy made the fair decision based on evidence: the defendant is responsible for the incident.
@@RJWaynerium But what I'm saying is that whether the defendant lied is irrelevant. For the sake of the argument, we assume the defendant did in fact drive the car. In other cases, where it was clear the defendant drove the car, with either explicit or implicit consent from the owner (or, as is often the case, owner's children), JJ will find the plaintiff partially at fault.
@@madad0406 Neither the defendant nor the plaintiff claim that they allowed him to drive the car. Plaintiff claims he didn't allow it and wasn't present. Defendant claims he wasn't driving, but is contradicted by his statement to the police. How can you expect Judy to hold to her prior findings for permissive use when neither plaintiff nor defendant are claiming permissive use?
@@kylenielsen5341 JJ clearly did not buy plaintiff's story. The owner never admits to allowing the defendant-to-be to drive, otherwise they would have no case. I can try to dig up one of those cases for reference.
It doesn't matter what the truth is. The two guys know and their friends know and this is going to be one lovely story to pass around friends, school and town. lol
This mom is so frustrating. Mario is clearly trying to help out Andre and he got screwed. Andre didn’t ever have the dignity to just say he did it. Mario is a real one.
Someone is definitely lying to Judge Judy! 🤣 Her son acts as if he's special needs, or something is not right with him. Because who would just give their keys to someone like that! And still call that person a "friend".
I feel bad for Mario :( The plaintiff's kid is clearly terrified of telling his mother the truth about both his friendship with Mario and the accident. I don't think Andre wanted to burn the bridge with Mario but had to do so to keep up the lie with his Mum.
I feel badly for the defendant and disgusted because the mother learns nothing from this. She will probably fix the car and give it back to her lying son. The son learns he can get away with lying.
Mario sure deserves a man reward for taking the fault for all that. I hope he never makes friends again with people who can’t take responsibility for their actions.
I'd be ashamed to take Mario to court over some accident when my son was also involved. My son would have had to work and pay for the damages because obviously Mario already paid a fine. Plus, why would a mother say someone is bullying her son when they aren't. Why would any "mother" do that?! Then they wonder....
I believe Mario. The plaintiff was obviously lying. I knew that when he said Mario never came to his house. And when the mother had written that Mario had been bullying her son, I knew my hunch was right. Why would her son be hanging out with someone who bullied and threatened him? And his explanation about Mario threatening him and forcing him to give him the keys was just nonsense. I don't think JJ believed that either. The only reason the plaintiff got money was because Mario lied for him and he couldn't prove that the plaintiff was driving.
I believe the defendant. Took the fall for his friend and got stiffed with a financial loss. The least the plaintiff could have done was come clean to his mom before the friend got sued!
Why didn't either of them bring Ulisa who could have told what really happened since she was the common denominator in both of their tales of who was in the car?
You can still be friends with a bully because they can be very manipulative until you had enough. Poor guy you can tell he has a good heart and got fooled easily
Prime example to not take the fault for anyone, not even a friend; they'll sell you out as soon as they can.
it depends on the friend, but for most cases I agree
Watch the second half there’s proof the defendant is lying.
@@ihavefelines284 this is the second half lol
Stop trippin, moms made him do it
Not all 😊
I feel sorry for the other kid, he thought he was a good friend but he got stabbed in the back....good life lesson for him tho
puhleeze.... that kid is shady as hell.
Yes, Johanna!!
@@jdsiv3 the black kid? Ya he is shady he can't even speak right
@@jdsiv3 I agree. Doesn't look 18. Very manipulative bully.
@@johanna8250 he's probably nervous. The big dude a smooth talker under pressure. He had two girls too? He was showing off and wrecked the car.
There’s no doubt Mario got soiled by that kid and tripped out when the accident happened. Sounds like Mario was being a real ass friend and got stabbed in the back
Yeah, I actually feel bad for Mario. The mother even made up a story saying that Mario was bullying and intimidating her "sweet little boy". When in fact Mario got himself in trouble to cover her son's butt.
True, Mario should have kept lying for his friend. Yes I was driving your honor but I didn’t take the keys he gave me permission. Then the blame would have been back on Andre.
The back stab was "inevitable". 😀
@@TheAray6 that’s not true. Even driving with permission it’s still your fault.
I would say the four scam the show by making everything up. there was an accident. there was an unsuccessful claim. the rest of it are all made up stories. that is why there wasn't a police report.
the son obviously did it. he was incredibly nervous the whole time. the friend was very calm and confident the whole time because he thought for sure he did nothing wrong until jj informs him he made the mistake of taking the fall for him by telling the cops he was the driver. then his demeanor changed.
I believe Mario was driving. There is NO NEED for him to LIE to the police and say he was driving. Plus, Mario didn’t have a license, who in their right mind would take the fall of an accident and they don’t have a license? By your logic, Mario would rather get into legal trouble rather than have his friend get in trouble with his mother? Please make that make sense…
@@moniquewatkins9952 he didnt have his license on his person. He was a licensed driver.
@@moniquewatkins9952 you weren't paying total attention I see
Son was nervous.. but if he was terrified of this Mario he may have acted out in ways that don't make sense. But also would explain his fear speaking out against him in court
@@Orangutan_Stella Thank you.
I believe the defendant; his story made the most sense.
I think Andre's mother told him she didn't want him hanging out with Mario, but he did it anyway. I also believe she told him not to have anybody in the car or allow them to drive it, and he disobeyed her again, then he made up the story about Mario bullying him because he was scared. She knew her son was lying. She seems like a no nonsense mother, so her only purpose was there was to be reimbursed.
Absolutely!! 💯
And the plaintiffs mother will never believe that, even if her own son looked her in the eye and told her it was true. Seriously mommy blind
@@Nevaeh1 I think both things are true. Andre is a nerdy 'goody 2 shoes' but he wants to be liked by the 'cool kids'. The Mario guy does probably bully him (which is why the Mom doesn't like him) but the kid clearly wants to be liked by Mario (who gives off the "I'm the tough cool kid vibe) and therefore does what Mario likes even though he knows it will get him in trouble. Mario is a practiced liar - his story is just too smoothly delivered, while the Andre kid is obviously nervous but he readily rattles off the names of all the people present and the exact times that things happen.
@Bernard Ordiz I think Mario was lying about "lying to the police". He really was the one driving and came up with that story about Andre asking him to switch seats
@@Nevaeh1 my theory is he was on a learners intermediate permit like my state has. This let's high-school aged drivers enter a stage where they do not need an experienced driver in the passenger seat overseeing them. BUT they can not have any passengers except immediate family members, or licensed drivers of 5 years. In the final stage you are allowed 1 friend or maybe more I don't remember the details exactly. But no more unless they meet the earlier criteria or over 18 maybe. Then if they don't have any accidents through those 3 stages, and don't get any tickets. They get a full fledged license earlier than they normally would.
Let's kids drive to school and help their family by having another driver. But doesn't allow the driver to go around town with kids their own age being a distraction to their driving.
If you are caught with a passenger that you aren't allowed. You instantly lose your permit and the perks that you were progressing through.
Since his buddy had no car before becoming an adult, nor plans for one. He didn't care about losing a license he didn't have in the first place.
Now his buddy can keep driving and has no mark on his record that currently affects him. Insurance will cover it everything's good.
Well that plan backfired. Now he can drive. But they are out of the cost of a car cuz insurance said no. Where as if the son owned up and took the consequences. He'd be unable to drive, but they'd have money for a new car. Which he'd be able to drive again when he turned 18... which he was by the time they went to court xD
So they're whole plan just backfired and would have been better if they owned up to it because now if they own up to it. It's a false police report perjury etc.
So mom tells her son to say his friend, who she doesn't even approve of in the first place, stole the car from him. Because then it could become a matter where the insurance covers a stolen car. But that's just absurd as we all heard lol. Judy ain't gunna allow this Karen of a mom to ruin a young adults legal record for an insurance cover up of $1500.
However the moron did take responsibility for the accident. It's out of her hands because he's already sealed his fate. Since he crashed the car, he's responsible for the damage. He said he drove. Driver assumes all responsibility of operating the vehicle including making sure they and the vehicle are licensed and insured to the minimum requirement by law.
So he's responsible for the financial burden of everyone involved. And he admitted to being responsible for an uninsured vehicle without proper brakes. He's screwed himself, and that Karen got her way with it.
"Under an intermediate license, you must follow these rules: For the first 6 months, you are not allowed any passengers under 20 years old except immediate family members. For the next 6 months, your passengers are restricted to no more than 3 people under 20 years old who aren't members of your immediate family."
I think he was in the first 6.
I believed the defendant. But because he made that lie, he has to live with consequences…. You NEVER lie to the police for anybody
I mean unless you are guilty. In that case you better be a *very* good liar. Because assuming they received standard interrogation training they are very good at catching lies.
The plaintiff is being truthful. Even though he don’t seem like If you don’t think Mario was bullying him your clearly naive
@@5starStones That’s ridiculous. I don’t know if there was bullying and neither do you. I don’t know if the plaintiff was being truthful and neither do you. I don’t know if Mario took the fall and *neither do you*
@@5starStones JJ doesn't even know that, but she is paid to use her best judgement
@@5starStones I do believe there was lines crossed. That unfortunately happens with young people. However, it's sketchy that the mom let her son multiple go to the house of someone she doesn't even like nor trust... that's bad parenting....
Also doesn't matter who was lying both kids need to learn what it means to take accountability. If he was a bully, you don't put yourself purposely in a vulnerable situation.. if the defendant did cover his friend.. you don't do so unless the situation is dire, it just teaches your friend how not to take responsibility.
I totally believe Mario. Shame his "friend" sold him out.
Both parents gotta take the loss and hold both their CHILDREN accountable!!!
Exactly
The second kid wasn't even doing anything wrong. That black kid is a snake a big coward who betrayed his friend just to save his own ass.
Um Mario doesn’t need held accountable for anything besides being a real ass friend.
They aren’t working so they couldn’t pay it off on their own right now anyway. Who’s gonna hire someone in debt at age 18. Also I’m not sure if Mario can even be held accountable at 18 in JJ’s district only his family could.
That trick isn’t gonna hold anymore responsible. She thinks she can do no wrong and raised Jesus. She’ll blame everyone else but her boy.
That mother still believes her sweet little son did nothing wrong although he’s lying to her face. It’s a shame he fears her to this extent. He’ll never be honest with her nor genuine out of fear.
Very true
All black families abuse the fuck out of their kids to the point that the kids cannot say anything because of fear of getting beat
Nah, the mother is a big fat liar too. She opened the complaint with lies. She taught his son how to lie. She is happy with her work. Disgusting person.
I have a parent like this and you are so right
He probably has no male figure in his house. He does not seem brave enough to take responsibility.
That's so not right. Should have been 50% each. Poor Mario, he learnt his lesson. Never accept it's your fault. The plaintiff guy, was lying.
Well since he said he did it to the police that’s all she could rule
It was close to that. She got $1500, the value of the car. Were you not listening?
@@kimm6589 then she should have got just 750. Half the value of the car.
That’s crazy. Mario takes the fall for something her son actually did and then she takes mario to court to pay for the damages? Disgusting.
You need to put yourself in her shoes. she didn't like Mario to begin with (it seems) and she has to believe what her son tells her. The fault is 10000% with the son, who wouldn't even tell his mother the truth when she said she would sue Mario. The case was over as soon as Judy told Mario "you told the police it was your fault, now these are the consecuences" no matter who was lying.
The plaintiffs body language says it all. He is so afraid he can't even talk confidently. The credit goes to mom.
SORRY TO SAY I BELIEVE Mario!!! The boy was too scared to tell his BIG MAMA!🤷🏿♀️😂
Lmfaooo
I'M NOT Sorry to say, that guy and his mama are DISGUSTING!!!!
Yup. Single mothers act like men creating simps. She’s typical. Poor kid
You are blind sis… he’s not scared of his mother he’s scared of Mario.
@@5starStones NUH CIS ...HE SCARED BOTH!🤔🤨🤷🏿♀️😅
Mario's father should be proud and appreciate his son's bravery.
you mean stupidity
It's brave, but not anything to be proud of. He lied to the police and had to pay alot of money for something he didn't do for someone not willing to take responsibility for their mistake. If it was a more serious situation and someone was hurt or killed, he would have gone to jail and faced charges and even be in bigger trouble since he was the one without a license.
Why would he be proud of his son for being an idiot?
I very much doubt that this kid would’ve taken the fall for someone dying, let’s not be ludicrous.
I think it’s a very kind gesture if what Mario is saying is true. Being willing to take the fall for someone that you consider a friend is a bold and crystal clear indication of your character, and it IS something to be proud of. My brothers and I would take the shit end of bad deals from our parents for one another, and even to this day I’ll take the blame for others I care about if it’s something they can’t handle. Caring about people isn’t something frivolous or outrageous, it’s something we don’t see enough of in the modern world.
If what Mario said is true, then the plaintiff should feel terrible for treating his friend this way and putting him through this.
Or his stupidity. Now he’s out 2k over a “friend”
Her son is a fibber. That’s an understatement. He manipulated his “friend” to take the fall for him AND lied and allowed the court to fine his “friend” Who needs enemies? 🤷🏽♀️
That is true
Literally
With Friends like these... Who needs enemies...🙃😁
Mom’s side eye…they may have won, but Andre lost a friend and his Mom gonna open up a can of whup…
Andre said Mario was a bully, so he was likely afraid of him
If nothing else Judy’s court was the place to say so. But I noticed Andre started sweating raindrops about what his Mom would say, rather than Mario.
@@Moe4now
It's not normal to go hang out with bullies who intimidate you...over and over again.
@@Moe4now what do you think he’s going to saw with his mother glaring down his neck?
@@Moe4now why would you hang out with a bully tho?
Andre was spending so much brainpower trying to remember what his mother invented for the court case that he couldn't remember what was truth and what was lies. For a start his mother only knew to mistrust Mario because he was visiting at their house - she wasn't going to go to Mario's house to ascertain his character. It fits with Andre's weasel-like personality for him to swap seats with Mario and let Mario take the blame not because of some insurance nonsense, but because he didn't want to take the blame with his mother. He is a lying snivelling coward. However Mario is the idiot for telling the police he was driving. He needs to learn that there are real-world consequences for playing these kinds of children's games. Andre is extremely immature, and Mario is just plain dumb.
Yes but JJ gone figure it out
"If you lie, you gotta tell it all the way through" 😂
This mom is in so much denial it's crazy
She knows the truth but she need to get her car fixed or the value for car..
Yup, my boy is perfect and all others are not to be trusted. Delusional to the max.
Mario looks 45! I thought he was the defendants dad. The plaintiff is lying he just doesn't want to get in trouble with his mother.
😅🤣😂 not 45 but atleast 35!!! I believe he did take advantage of the nerdy kid! 🤓
@amma2x,lol! I thought he was in his 30’s/40’s too!
The mom made up a bogus lie to paint the picture of Mario being a bully. Her son went right along with her and made up his story about Mario being intimidating. When it comes to legal stuff never take the fall for anyone!
I low key wanted to cry for Mario. That’s a real kick in the gut. It’s a hard lesson for sure. Not to mention he has that hefty ticket on his record.
She should have split it between the two boys. So they each learn a lesson.
Mario is not a boy...he is close to 40
@@See-if_I_care he is 18 shut up
Isn't gonna be much of a lesson either since the show will cover the 1500$ judgement
@@See-if_I_care lol
Yes
I don’t think the plaintiff should get anything since they all lied.
not how the law works sadly
@@RscccAnderlecht sadly indeed
I totally agree with you!
Yea I wonder why she did not apply the doctrine of clean hands since they both lied 🤥.
That mom is definitely a liar about the car being stalled in the drive way them Toyotas can do 70 rolls and still run perfectly fine 🤣
😂😂 she is a freaking liar. We all know that.
😂😂😂😂😂😂🎉🎉
Anyone else see the irony of mom warning about Mario when it's her own son conspiring to lie to the cops to save his own behind and make someone else pay for his mistakes?
The irony is real! The plaintiff has clearly learned to lie and manipulate situations to bypass getting in trouble with his helicopter mom. The mom hasn't realized what she has created. Mario turned out to be the stand up guy her son is not
Mario version makes perfect sense.. . Especially how Andre conveniently "forgot" the third person that was in the car **cough** (himself)
From the second that Judge Judy started to check the plaintiff's mom calling her out on her lie I could see the guilt on her face and I knew she coerced her son into saying that he was bullied.
The guilt? I saw anger and hate for been caught. Like ready to pounce.
Yup anger. Single mother can never be wrong. Masculine, rude He will be a simp if he’s not already
I disagree; she was lied to by her son. She looked mad, and I've been a mother of 3 teenagers, I know that look. 😂 He lied to her, and the plaintiff couldn't keep his own story straight.
I worked with at risk youth for more than a decade. I can always tell when a kid is hiding something. One of my good friends was discussing her teenage daughter and basically described her as a saint. Whenever there was an incident involving another student or peer she immediately believed her daughter. I told her that her daughter was not perfect and she shouldn’t believe everything she tells her. This caused a riff in our friendship. Over the next two years her daughter went from being on the national junior honor society and head cheerleader to a high school dropout. She ran away from home after assaulting her mother when she caught her sneaking an adult man in her window and her disappearance made the local news. She spent two years as an exotic dancer, couch surfing from place to place. One day we were driving around a bad area searching for her daughter an my friend apologized to me for reacting so harshly when I tried to open her eyes. I cried as she said “I wish I listened to you”.
Parents please open your eyes and realize that your children aren’t perfect angels. They’re imperfect and flawed just like the rest of us.
Yes, when girls start to menstruate, they demeanor changes drastically and boys ( or girls ) become a focal point in their lives.
That s why, back in the day, girls would be married off at that time, so they wouldn t end up being passed around from one male to another.
She’s the prime example of my child can do no wrong. Always someone else’s fault.
I am very impressed by how well Judge Judy is able to drill down to the most relevant facts and expose inconsistencies in the testimonies.
I feel bad for both kids. I hope the kid with the mother gains some confidence because he can’t be under his mothers thumb but so long.
Why do you feel bad for lying kids look at the mother of one of the kids no excuse for him lying to the judge and his mother sitting right there not acceptable my mother didn't bring me up that way to lie definitely not in front of her haven't you ever heard of lead-by-example is this something his mother did lie lie lie so now he feels it's okay to lie lie lie something's not right and you don't see no problem with it
@@cherrylove3656 Your comment reads like insane gibberish. Also while I’m happy YOUR mother helped you value truth, a lot of kids are trained to lie because their parents will go berserk if they heat a truth they don’t like. The kid looks terrified to speak in front of his mom, I suspect for that reason.
They’re adult men.
@@cherrylove3656 dude… did you ever hear of a thing called punctuation? 😂
@@debshaw680 thank you I was living on my own working and attending college St 18
I feel for both kids. Mario took the fall and his friend is so afraid of his mom that he threw him under the bus in front of millions of people for something he clearly didn't do. There are no winners here. The plaintiff is clearly terrified of his mom which makes me wonder about his home life.
Nope. The black kid sold his friend out after he pleaded with him to take the rap cuz he s a moma s boy and still sucking on his mother s titty. With a friend like that, who needs enemies.
This is why you never let anyone off their responsibility when they are in a car accident. They are desperate in that situation and desperate people will do anything to save themselves.
Mario’s story is the most believable, the kid is obviously scared of his mom so he lied about his friend driving
Andre don’t look like he should be driving 🤣🤣🤣
Don't take blame for your friends. Look at the mess he got himself in. The plaintiff lied, clearly lied. The defendant told the truth. Its unfortunate the plaintiff got away with it despite the huge, obvious lie.
His worst part was when he said Mario got in the car with two other friends, Uli and I don't who was the other person. OF COURSE, because it was you. You couldn't name someone else. It was you. Wish at least they would mention on the report that the plaintiff was there. Disgusting people. Bad example. Lying mother too. Bad people.
3:40 When she was looking at the pics, during that silence, she should’ve asked the plaintiff “so what did you hit?” Just to see if he would crack 😂
That poor kid is terrified of his mom!
Poor Mario. I feel so bad for him - the way his face looked when his so-called 'friend' lied on him. So sad.
He is so nervous…
Cause he's lying
He's making up the story as he goes.
The amount of times he furrowed his brown with serious thinking shows he was lying up a storm. He was literally flying by the seat of his pants, sprinkling enough truth to seem believable but 90% lie
Mario got screwed by his friend.
If a "friend" asks you to take the rap he is no longer a friend.
A true friend can never ask.
Andre is pooping in his pants 😂
Terrified of JJ & Mom
Never would I lie and say I was driving for ANYONE.
He really threw his mans under the bus wtf terrible friend
That plaintiff was stumbling all over the place because he’s a liar. He was too cowardly to face his mother, you could see it in her face but she still went along with the accusation. ZERO INTEGRITY. Hopefully Mario learns to pick better friends.
Wow this kid's a liar and his mother sitting right there what's that make her he had no problem throwing Mario under the bus by lying saying he bullied me to get the keys and if Mario took the blame for it that was just downright ignorant but listening to the whole case they both are liars
I'm somewhat surprised by this one. Pretty sure I recall Judge Judy holding the plaintiff at least responsible in part in other similar cases (where the owner allowed the at-fault driver to drive the car knowing they had no license, etc.).
The turning point was that the defendant lied to the police to cover for the plaintiff. His lie is all over the police report and established as a matter of fact as if he's responsible. Judge judy heavily relies on police reports to make a judgment and in doing so turned to the plaintiff's direction as the chain of evidence, the police report, indicates the defendant was at fault.
Now everyone in the audience knows the plaintiff clearly did it, but it's not provable in a court. Hence Judge judy made the fair decision based on evidence: the defendant is responsible for the incident.
@@RJWaynerium But what I'm saying is that whether the defendant lied is irrelevant. For the sake of the argument, we assume the defendant did in fact drive the car. In other cases, where it was clear the defendant drove the car, with either explicit or implicit consent from the owner (or, as is often the case, owner's children), JJ will find the plaintiff partially at fault.
@@madad0406 Neither the defendant nor the plaintiff claim that they allowed him to drive the car. Plaintiff claims he didn't allow it and wasn't present. Defendant claims he wasn't driving, but is contradicted by his statement to the police. How can you expect Judy to hold to her prior findings for permissive use when neither plaintiff nor defendant are claiming permissive use?
@@kylenielsen5341
This is a good point
@@kylenielsen5341 JJ clearly did not buy plaintiff's story. The owner never admits to allowing the defendant-to-be to drive, otherwise they would have no case. I can try to dig up one of those cases for reference.
Where is Ulisa? She's a witness.
Sadly, Mario would have still lost.
She's scared of Mario.
If there was someone else in the car why not bring them to witness for you.
Giod point
I’m not qualified to be a Judge but, even I can see that her son is lying.
You can tell people are lying when their story has to be told really slowly
It doesn't matter what the truth is. The two guys know and their friends know and this is going to be one lovely story to pass around friends, school and town. lol
I was once Mario. The consequences of being a "good friend/ girlfriend" cost me way more than 1500 though, smh. This too shall pass.
This mom is so frustrating. Mario is clearly trying to help out Andre and he got screwed. Andre didn’t ever have the dignity to just say he did it. Mario is a real one.
Someone is definitely lying to Judge Judy! 🤣 Her son acts as if he's special needs, or something is not right with him. Because who would just give their keys to someone like that! And still call that person a "friend".
That’s so sad he could do that to a friend! Wow.
Ooh! She ran circles around the plaintiff! They're both in trouble with their parents at least I hope!
I feel bad for Mario :( The plaintiff's kid is clearly terrified of telling his mother the truth about both his friendship with Mario and the accident. I don't think Andre wanted to burn the bridge with Mario but had to do so to keep up the lie with his Mum.
the woman in the back 0:39 😂😂😂
Just judging by the coherence of each story and demeanor of each person speaking, the defendant seemed like the one who was being truthful.
It’s sad .. I believe Mario .. but he learnt a huge lesson.
I’m not going to fall for the banana in the tale pipe.
Plaintiffs son is a liar as I think He was driving the car
1st off this little boy don't have any business hanging out with this adult! This man is in his 40s!
JJ should start penalizing people for lying. That woman should not have gotten a dime.
Why would you take the fault of an accident. That's no friend!!!
If you tell the truth you don’t need to have a good memory
I feel badly for the defendant and disgusted because the mother learns nothing from this. She will probably fix the car and give it back to her lying son. The son learns he can get away with lying.
Should have brought the girl as a witness
Poor Mario. Feel bad for him. He was being a friend.
Fun fact: Today is Mario day
Mar 10
Kidding!
The mom should still hold her son accountable, see where lying gets you?
Mother doesn’t seem like a nice person.
His mama got a little attitude. Lol
I believe the defendant did it. I believe the plaintiff allowed his friend to drive. I believe they were all in the car.
Bad parents raise bad kids
Dope pt 2 is up
Mario sure deserves a man reward for taking the fault for all that. I hope he never makes friends again with people who can’t take responsibility for their actions.
one thing I hate about car cases is that you're only awarded the value of the car not the damages. I guess thats only if its a total loss.
Wow that was so effed up!! Mario looks out for his friend gets called a bully and sued for something the other kid did!!
Why didnt they bring the friend
really sad to hear about one of my brothers, seeing the pictures was especially heart breaking. Get well soon.
I'd be ashamed to take Mario to court over some accident when my son was also involved. My son would have had to work and pay for the damages because obviously Mario already paid a fine. Plus, why would a mother say someone is bullying her son when they aren't. Why would any "mother" do that?! Then they wonder....
Good lesson for Mario not to take the fault for others. The karma will come back 3x worse for Johnson.
Shame on this mother
LOL if you told the police you were driving you already lost
I always wondered what happened to Steve Urkel.
Poor kid. He can’t tell the truth with his mother glaring at him. Wow.
I believe Mario. The plaintiff was obviously lying. I knew that when he said Mario never came to his house. And when the mother had written that Mario had been bullying her son, I knew my hunch was right. Why would her son be hanging out with someone who bullied and threatened him? And his explanation about Mario threatening him and forcing him to give him the keys was just nonsense. I don't think JJ believed that either. The only reason the plaintiff got money was because Mario lied for him and he couldn't prove that the plaintiff was driving.
I believe the defendant. Took the fall for his friend and got stiffed with a financial loss. The least the plaintiff could have done was come clean to his mom before the friend got sued!
HAHAHA "You Lie, You gotta tell it all the way through"
that mother's attitude 🙄
Lmfaooooooooo Andre is realllyyyy hilarious he one of those sneaky ones .
Why didn't either of them bring Ulisa who could have told what really happened since she was the common denominator in both of their tales of who was in the car?
Cuz she got her azz whipped by her own parents!
But the son said he wasn’t in the car when the accident occurred. Isn’t perjury grounds for dismissal
They both were driving. Andre was sitting on Mario's lap with his hands on the wheel steering, while Mario was pumping the gas and working the stick?!
Unbelievable!!!!!
Most important parenting 101 is that your kid is able to tell you the truth!
You can still be friends with a bully because they can be very manipulative until you had enough. Poor guy you can tell he has a good heart and got fooled easily