I would recommend you Abhijit Chavda on this crisis in Manipur...he has a good knowledge of Manipur history... thank you Rami ma'am again for spreading the truth
When illigal emmigrants refuge come to Manipur in the name of kuki chin or zo kuki or any kuki tribe they get st status and more benifits from Indian government.. that means indian govt is richest country in the world helping illigal emmigrants wow, and if main land Indian wanted come to Manipur they need to pass ILP ,, an ineer line permit wow outstanding wow nice governance hamara bharat mahaaan
@@riddance1 there in no importance or reason for a library when refugees are creating too much drama pretend to look better then historical fact and and even trying wipe out indigenous people 😂😂😂
We meitei are proud of India. We will not compromise our land to myanmar immigrants kuki. We will Bring NRC to our state. We will safeguard our nation.
Nation needs know the role of Mizoram. Mizoram CM former militant openly demanding part of Manipur to unite with Mizoram. Is he the guru of Manipur conflict?
He absolutely is playing a big role. Let's not forget that Chins coming in from Myanmar are also Zos. Chins call themselves Zomis. Chin is what the Burmese call them. Kukis are also Zos. They are the Zos who did coolie work for the British and from the word coolie came the name Kuki. So in effect they are all one and the same. Zoramthanga is playing a big role in fueling the conflict. Illegal Chin immigrants get their fake Aadhar Cards in Mizoram and move into Manipur. Kuki MLAs are seeking support from him too.
@@phobictoeverythingthe one who always has propaganda will never understand true fact...you don't like her as you can't buy her with your poppy money just like you did to leftist journalist who have propaganda
Cookies=problems makers in Myanmar, Bangladesh,Tripura, Assam and now in Manipur. Kuki -paite 1997, Kuki -naga 1993, Kuki -karbi,Kuki -tripuri, Kuki -Myanmarese,kuki-bangladeshi and now with Meetei in Manipur...etc etc
Ram mam should be in ministry......she has lot of understanding of northeast deeply...she always facts ...we want Ram mam in ministry to command the northeast region.....
All started from chin state war with the military junta, huge number of chin people (on record) have entered mizoram (mizoram welcoming their ethnic brother) and the state is bearing the expenses. As the war progresses more people (including chin revolutionaries) want shelter in mizoram. As mizoram is saturating, part of the chin people now want to be shifted to manipur-mizoram border which is inhibited the same chin ethnic people (kuki) and the mizoram has great influence in such areas. Not only the people, but the culture of poppy cultivation also which is a huge resource for the ongoing chin state war in myanmar and the future of chin originated people. The difference is govt of mizoram supports the influx but the govt of manipur does not. When the govt opposes the influx and the poppy cultivation, the problem started. In order to not intervened by the govt of manipur, kuki started plan for separate administration where they could help the immigrants in all aspects. And the immigrants need to stay as long as the war goes on there, which could be only for few years or hundreds, in which mizoram is suffering on the other side and things can be learnt from them.
Excellent analysis by James Joseph. If the kukis are hogging all the jobs etc ...then making the selections of majority of the jobs into a merit based system and reducing the percentage of reservation for ST- kukis might me a solution. Both sides have to be balanced. But taking away or reducing a portion of the benefits is not going to be easy. The private sector jobs are based on merit and qualifications unlike the govt jobs and benefits. Wish there were a robust private sector creating more such jobs. I agree that religion might not be a big issue here....but the overall situation is a very unfortunate development. Govt should form a commission involving eminent persons of both communities and find a solution for this vexing issue once amd for all.
Political dominance wes Meity Forte.But most Govt machienery controlled by Kukis.Most land with kukis.poppy cultivation , infiltration favour Kukis.Most external elements are with Kukis. Meitis are Victims.
@@ramachandransg7971 Exactly. But what is projected outside and why!? Because Kukis are Christians and entire world of Christians along with them muslims who are hobnobbing here though at each others' throat outside the world supporting them as usual.. Hindus supporting Meteis is Hindu fundamentalism. Government though knows everything can't support them. What a treachery planned against not only Meteis but also Hindus as a whole to project minorities not safe under Modi. They used CAA on muslims, farm laws on Sikhs and Manipur on Christians. Pappu's rant that all minorities are not safe fulfilled. It's another toolkit in operation.
Really!? Meteis are victims of conversations and killings from Kuki Christian. Being foreigners want not only settle in Manipur and want to grab 90% of it as a separate state,!? Government is not definitely that fool though fool all.😁😁😁.
In Manipur (most cases by ST) when the constitution or Indian law favour them then they will demand or go by it but if it does not favour them then they will avoid or will not follow it saying customary law. Let the law be same for hills and valley coz we go to the same school, play together eat together without any discrimination ❤
Sre Iyerji i have come to San jose from India in the month of March and have been listening to your videos since then. The content is so good that i have not missed a single video. Appreciate your efforts ❤
A brave journslist who stood against all forms of violence including narco terrorist activities called Rami R Desai must be respected with highest degree of honour by all of my dear citizens of our country Hats off madam 🙏
After that video went viral a few days ago (one needs to question the timing of it going viral, because things were slowly returning to normal by then), most other channels started portraying the Kukis to be the victims and the Meitis to be the perpetrators but no one is addressing the point about who started the violence? Clearly it was the Kukis who attacked the Meitis 1st, burnt down their whole villages etc and then when Meitis retaliated to protect themselves, Kukis started playing the victim card. Kukis carried out horrid atrocities on the Meitis and there are videos of these which are being prevented from being circulated so the whole world is only getting one side of the story. This is so typical of crimes in India where the perpetrators from the minority communities are protected by always playing the victim card. And the international media are having a field day by alleging that Christians are not safe in India. Why doesn't someone put the truth out to shut up the mouths of all the internal and external enemies of India! Don't see any media channels actually reporting from Manipur and when they do they are not trying to find out the reason for the violence & who started it? I have heard on another channel from a Meiti guest, that Meitis are very angry because they have always been dealt a bad hand compared to the Nagas & the Kukis 1st by the British and then by all the Indian Governments, none of whom have even attempted to right the wrongs of the past so typically the Meitis keep suffering. Does this not sound familiar to how Hindus have always been treated in India as 8th class citizens.
They have plenty of Christian countries and muslims in India always support them. They unitedly defeated BJP in Karnataka also. We Hindus are orphans with no country to support and not enough we have full of Jaychands making our position helpless as they get the chance to say see your own people saying so.
Clearly your perspective on the issue is one-sided and inadequate at best,you said it yourself and I quote "I heard it from a meitei guest in a news channel".your understanding of the issue is sentimentally inclined towards the meitei community with no goodwill intention.. you are simply another fanatics tuning your perspective only on communal lines.. you are a danger to yourself and the fabric upon which the constitution of this great country stood upon
Rami ma'am's answer to the question of who started the violence was a masterclass in how to answer diplomatically. She didn't openly take sides but she answered, in a thorough manner, the question of which side did really start attacking the other.
It's really important to educate the whole nation and highly respected people like you are doing great job to describe what is the cause n who is responsible n what is their targets... These so called zo Kuki how dare n who they are to decide hill is their land these people are guess of Manipuri Meitei now time to say goodbye to our lovely n very friendly people guess in Manipur
The first thumb rule of governing a landlocked territory - Never ever allow a scope for internal tension among people in the region right close to the border areas. This is fact right from ancient Roman Empire. Yet for some mysterious reasons BJP has been at the backfoot. Except for Hemanta, there's been no one taking a strong stand in the eastern part of India.
Wow, her arguments are so beautifully nuanced and deeply thought through. I hope she can advise the local & national govts to take the next steps towards normalcy
Correctly brought out.. Maximum of the national media channel are purchased with drugs money and hence u can find fake narratives base on Christian cards, minority cards, refugees cards, victims cards which favours kukis circling all around in their channel..
Very difficult and complicated to solve the problems of North East unless all tribes forget their differences and trust each other and allow the Govt. to economically develop their individual states which is happening since 2014 as lot of money is being pumped by central govt and infrasture is being developed which was not seen since independence till 2014. violence is not the solution as it will only brings misery for all the groups. It’s time for all political parties to bring all parties to negotiating table and solve the problems instead of doing dirty politics on any issue.
Very balanced views. Basically, this is an old legacy and any government will need time to untangle the root issues. A magic wand expectation would be misplaced. Politicising is not helpful to finding solution!
The root cause of the Manipur issue is a pre-planned from last thirty years. I am sharing my view on ground of our National favour. It needs to know every people of India. Step by step actions were taken up in last thirty years to achieve their Gold. There steps will be told later, I am telling in short as ..... After case study of last 30 years of clashes between different communities, geographical, demographical and geopolitical analysis of Kuki Chin community, the demand of separate state is only first step to forming a Kuki Country with the support Western Christan Countries. This is security threat to India and depressing Indian Economy to be a World Supper Power country as all World knows that India is on the trench to become a Super Power Country in the World. Think about, why is the other state Mizoram and kuki community from Myanmar involving in present violence, because they have to win first step by any means/anyhow. After that next turning point, Lead by this Kukiland in India then the Kuki communities in India, Myanmar and Bangladesh will come together to form a Kuki Country. Think about what will be happened in India if Kukiland formed. They will try to get a funding of big amount to establish a country by means of drug production and narco terrorism. As a citizen of India, we have to pay attention early before happening such kind of act in future that this is not a civil war to meitei community only and we have know that it is a emotional war against India's prosperity/Indian Economy/Government of India/all jb public of India. To defend from them is not only the responsibility of meitei community but all also all citizens of India for our India's bright future.
As an outsider, I've noticed many penalists mention that the kukis have clashed with every community they have come in contact with. Maybe it's their problem and fault and they play the victim.
Mizo and Kukis r like cousin tribes. It also happens that both of them r Christian communities. You see the Buddhists from Myanmar r not coming in to settle in Manipur but why r the Christian tribes coming in. That's the big question. The reason is they want to create a different country which includes some part of North East India, Myanmar and Bangladesh.
Because its their ancestral land and their hills, ruled by none other than the British and their community along with their land divided by the British.
@@robertralte5710 The British imported the Kukis into northeast. There r documents present. Go and find out. And their ancestor were not Christians mind you.
Really excellent, eloquent speaker; i'm still absorbing from another podcast Rami did with abijit chavda. The background info to the conflict can be useful, imo, in resolving the animosities between the communities, aum
Rami is the owner and the founder of Manipur. She knows everything than the people who live there in Manipur. Narendra Modi needs to give her gallantry award. She is the God of Meitei community. She is the backbone of Biren mihuh pa. Meitei should worship her like saibaba.
Thanks for the excellent analysis of the Manipur situation by Ms Desai. It wa really interesting. However, the possible complicity of the head of the state, which seems quite evident and the 'Mind bogling' silence of the prime minister to the extent if suggesting 'complicity' fir pilitical gains (??) still remains a big question!!!. How come center did not intetvene with the use of central forces when the state was liteterally burning, which they are doing now, after three months? It is just difficult to undetstand.
The unfortunate thing is you have only 3.53 lakh subscribers! Where are all the desis in the US? They should all be listening to Sree ji! Maybe you can have an ad or outreach programme.
A very thoughtful discussion, would have loved to hear the impact on climatic conditions of the state post flourishing poppy plantation and subsequently to the state economy.
Its like mizos helping Kuki Opium traders that make all sens. But india will find solution but not in the way that Indira Gandhi did like bombing through airplane not that way.
Wonderful! We need such matured, well informed and unbiased journalists. Thank you Mr Iyer for getting Rami on your channel to clear misconceptions in the minds of well meaning citizens of this country and also those keenly following the developments in Manipur from near and far.
Rightly pointed out the demographic changes in the valley region will spurt discontent amongst locals but the developments should not stop. But the mistakes & policies of previous govts is also a contributing factor
Before May 3rd, Manipur Govt. had been cutting down poppy plantations in hills and it was mostly in chin kuki mizo residing areas. Plus started the work of identifying illegal immigrants in Manipur. There are full evidence and documents on these with the government as well as available in media. This is the main cause of this orchestrated or engineered conflict.
SC CJI was extremely saddened by the video from Manipur. This same CJI will stop any harsh steps centre takes. They will stay any displacement of illegal occupants on forest lands.
SC stayed the removal of illegal Rohingyas. That is what SC is famous for. They meddle in affairs suo moto that have nothing to do with them. Government will need to bring in legislation controlling the SC judges to remain within their remit. SC judges are not elected whereas Government's are and they must be allowed to deal with executive matters. Judiciary has no business poking their noses in everything. One should question the SC why they never take suo moto action against the W Bengal government where women are disrobed in public and attacked by TMC goons. There have been over 50 deaths around the Panchayat elections and over 150 after the last state elections. How is W Bengal different to Manipur? Also why no action by SC with regards to attacks and murders of Hindus in Rajasthan, Chattisgarh, Bihar?
Kukis instead of appealing against High Court's directive on inclusiin of Meiteis in the SC, they have started attack to the Common Meiteis settling at Churachandpur where Kukis dominate. They have done a blunder by attacking to a Community(Meitei) who are a great worriers. Similiar actions were done to Kukis dwelling in the valley, dominated by Meiteis.
Unfortunately international community doesn't want to see Indian subcontinent peaceful and economically developed. Probably India is the only country in an unenviable position having to fight forces from across the globe. India can handle local/regional challenges with ease. What do we do when those powers that keep lecturing about peace, democracy, freedom, etc themselves are guilty of fomenting unrest all around? Still, India will deftly handle all such challenges. Just a matter of time. A bit of faith and patience is the least we can offer to our motherland during all these testing times..
Yes, yes. yes. Let's blame it on the British. The whole world knows the best country is India and how wonderful, honest and holy Indians are. Look at the long queues and how they are tripping over each other in trying to migrate to India. We should charge them millions of dollars if they want to come to India and eat fafda and dokla from the biggest teashop in the world - Modi's tea shop. The whole world is dying to say Howdy Modi you are the Hinduon ka Samrat.
It's good to hear from Mrs Desai, about some unknown information. But on 25 July 2023 BBC News India UA-cam has posted a news " The cost of violence in Manipur" The two indian reporters have done there job (as said). In videos they didn't touch on drugs farming & it's impact on humanity. Infrantion of Roinghia & Mayanmur in Manipur & there evil purpose. BBC didn't touch on drugs caught at border & it's value & it's probably bad effect if not caught by military forces & Police. So this international BBC British Betrayal Company has to be taught a very good lesson by completely banning from India because this BBC is trying to set a very bad narrative to rest world so called Western nations & in some world forums. So intectul community should think on this & initiate some actions. Ofcourse it's present government responsibility to bring back the state to normalcy.
The main issue is land. The meiteis consider Manipur is theirs and want to eliminate any community that possess threat to their dominance. One has to listen to the Meitei Leepun chief Pramot Singh calling the Kukis as outsiders. He is being patronized by the CM and the titular King Sanajaoba, who is also a Rajya Sabha MP. The Kukis, being tribals, are not as advanced as the meiteis and are only about 16% of the population, an easy pick for the meiteis. Being tribals may not be the perfect community to live with. But the atrocities carried out against them cannot be justified because of the underlying problems mentined by Rami. It is not a conflict, it's an attempt to drive out Kukis from Manipur.
First the British split the society created fault lines to forward their own interests then they coerced Indian Govt to continue with their policy and retain and reward these divisions with special privilages to people who maintained these fault lines and indulge in antinational activity terrorism drug cultivation and human trafficing... They have no social economic or political obligations towards India and members across North East.. With Indian money Indian food Indian security they create instability and violence in India...With Their newly acquired relegious affiliation they ridicule their own culture deities environment and people...
A strong THREE LAYER border fencing done on a war footing way can curb these illegal immigrants from myanmar and banglades. Yes it's going to be a herculean task for the BRO, but once completed it will be huge relief to all my north east fellow Indians.
Firstly, good you have finally chosen to discuss Manipur. One point to appreciate Rami is not to go discussing what USA or UN says or does about Myanmar refugees. These are our neighbours and its necessary to keep dialogues open or else as she mentioned because of US sanctions on Myanmar China enters the scenario which will become difficult for India. This has happened in Srilanka, its happening in Nepal, may will happen in Pakistan too. So relationships with our neighbours is more important than US or UK etc.😮
Thanks a lot dear Sis. Rami and Thanks a lot brother Sree. Great and insightful discussion. Audio from Ramiji side would have been better. Please take care of it. 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
I would recommend you Abhijit Chavda on this crisis in Manipur...he has a good knowledge of Manipur history... thank you Rami ma'am again for spreading the truth
No he is heavily biased and seems to justify the violence
@@arunk.7708then u make a video 😂
When illigal emmigrants refuge come to Manipur in the name of kuki chin or zo kuki or any kuki tribe they get st status and more benifits from Indian government.. that means indian govt is richest country in the world helping illigal emmigrants wow, and if main land Indian wanted come to Manipur they need to pass ILP ,, an ineer line permit wow outstanding wow nice governance hamara bharat mahaaan
@@ALSalvadorian00glen2😂😂😂 your women’s tried to burnt the library 😂
@@riddance1 there in no importance or reason for a library when refugees are creating too much drama pretend to look better then historical fact and and even trying wipe out indigenous people 😂😂😂
We meitei are proud of India. We will not compromise our land to myanmar immigrants kuki. We will Bring NRC to our state. We will safeguard our nation.
Long live manipur long live India. Jay bharat mata ki, jay
Dont compromise 700sq miles, long live.
Its like mizos helping Kuki Opium traders that make all sens. But india will find solution but not in the way that Indira Gandhi did before
Nation needs know the role of Mizoram. Mizoram CM former militant openly demanding part of Manipur to unite with Mizoram. Is he the guru of Manipur conflict?
He absolutely is playing a big role.
Let's not forget that Chins coming in from Myanmar are also Zos. Chins call themselves Zomis. Chin is what the Burmese call them.
Kukis are also Zos. They are the Zos who did coolie work for the British and from the word coolie came the name Kuki.
So in effect they are all one and the same.
Zoramthanga is playing a big role in fueling the conflict. Illegal Chin immigrants get their fake Aadhar Cards in Mizoram and move into Manipur.
Kuki MLAs are seeking support from him too.
Thank you Rami Desai ji for your indept analysis of Manipur and the way you presented for viewers to comprehend is commendable, Hats off i loved it!❤
Rami is great she gave the true fact on Manipur issue.
Yes she is the one who knows about the Northeast Region very well
And a pro meitei supporter
@@phobictoeverythingthe one who always has propaganda will never understand true fact...you don't like her as you can't buy her with your poppy money just like you did to leftist journalist who have propaganda
Only for meiteis she is great because she support Rapist community and their propogandas and we can see it from day 1
@@phobictoeverything jalte raho teri dil mein. Your heart is killing much by talking some truth from other people rt
We see Rami mam true leaders.....She is India's future Jhansi ki Rani ...salute u mam for understanding northeast history deeply
Very beautiful with grace smile with a brahmincal gesture proud of it
@@rrao7963 she is great woman without unbiased....she is true leader Rami mam as a leader
Thankyou Rami ji for standing up to the truth!!
Rami ji is a well tuned expert knowing every details of the Manipur issue as well as the whole NE region.
Thank you Rami Ma'am for postulating things exactly as they are 🙏
Rami is a voice of truth and reason. She should be consulted for any policy change
Thank you Rami to explain something so complicated to a depth….
Cookies=problems makers in Myanmar, Bangladesh,Tripura, Assam and now in Manipur. Kuki -paite 1997, Kuki -naga 1993, Kuki -karbi,Kuki -tripuri, Kuki -Myanmarese,kuki-bangladeshi and now with Meetei in Manipur...etc etc
Kukis must be sent to mars now
Ans still playing propaganda and victim card
Rami Desai only 🎉🎉🎉 May God bless you from strength to strength to defy propaganda of kuki terrorirts attacking meeteis on hourly basis
You rightly said it.
Fantastic programme. Thank you Rami for saying things exactly as they are.
Absolutely Right Ma'am
Jai Hind Jai Bharat 🙏
Ram mam should be in ministry......she has lot of understanding of northeast deeply...she always facts ...we want Ram mam in ministry to command the northeast region.....
Thank you ma'am for telling the real truth
Thank you very must for knowing our problems...unbiased, hats off to you
Deep knowledge of Manipur n North East by Rami Ji 👍
Rami mam wisdom is wonderful amazing
Very concerned and praying for peace in Manipur !!!
All started from chin state war with the military junta, huge number of chin people (on record) have entered mizoram (mizoram welcoming their ethnic brother) and the state is bearing the expenses. As the war progresses more people (including chin revolutionaries) want shelter in mizoram. As mizoram is saturating, part of the chin people now want to be shifted to manipur-mizoram border which is inhibited the same chin ethnic people (kuki) and the mizoram has great influence in such areas. Not only the people, but the culture of poppy cultivation also which is a huge resource for the ongoing chin state war in myanmar and the future of chin originated people. The difference is govt of mizoram supports the influx but the govt of manipur does not. When the govt opposes the influx and the poppy cultivation, the problem started. In order to not intervened by the govt of manipur, kuki started plan for separate administration where they could help the immigrants in all aspects. And the immigrants need to stay as long as the war goes on there, which could be only for few years or hundreds, in which mizoram is suffering on the other side and things can be learnt from them.
Thanks both of u for sharing us the truth n thanks especially Rami Niranjan Desai mam for your best knowledge of NE.
Excellent analysis by James Joseph. If the kukis are hogging all the jobs etc ...then making the selections of majority of the jobs into a merit based system and reducing the percentage of reservation for ST- kukis might me a solution. Both sides have to be balanced. But taking away or reducing a portion of the benefits is not going to be easy. The private sector jobs are based on merit and qualifications unlike the govt jobs and benefits. Wish there were a robust private sector creating more such jobs. I agree that religion might not be a big issue here....but the overall situation is a very unfortunate development. Govt should form a commission involving eminent persons of both communities and find a solution for this vexing issue once amd for all.
Political dominance wes Meity Forte.But most Govt machienery controlled by Kukis.Most land with kukis.poppy cultivation , infiltration favour Kukis.Most external elements are with Kukis.
Meitis are Victims.
@@ramachandransg7971 Exactly. But what is projected outside and why!? Because Kukis are Christians and entire world of Christians along with them muslims who are hobnobbing here though at each others' throat outside the world supporting them as usual.. Hindus supporting Meteis is Hindu fundamentalism. Government though knows everything can't support them. What a treachery planned against not only Meteis but also Hindus as a whole to project minorities not safe under Modi. They used CAA on muslims, farm laws on Sikhs and Manipur on Christians. Pappu's rant that all minorities are not safe fulfilled. It's another toolkit in operation.
Meiteis as victims is the biggest joke I heard today.
Really!? Meteis are victims of conversations and killings from Kuki Christian. Being foreigners want not only settle in Manipur and want to grab 90% of it as a separate state,!? Government is not definitely that fool though fool all.😁😁😁.
In Manipur (most cases by ST) when the constitution or Indian law favour them then they will demand or go by it but if it does not favour them then they will avoid or will not follow it saying customary law. Let the law be same for hills and valley coz we go to the same school, play together eat together without any discrimination ❤
The Kukis should be put in their place as they are the aggressors. Affirmative policies should be applied equally and not just for the Kukis
Excellent analysis, the fact & root cause being touched.❤❤❤❤❤
Sre Iyerji i have come to San jose from India in the month of March and have been listening to your videos since then. The content is so good that i have not missed a single video. Appreciate your efforts ❤
A brave journslist who stood against all forms of violence including narco terrorist activities called Rami R Desai must be respected with highest degree of honour by all of my dear citizens of our country Hats off madam 🙏
Rami mam you are the best of our country 🙏🙏💞🙏💞🙏💞💞
This is the first news Channel that ask.... "what start the violence"
She always stands for the truth.
She thought Meiteis lies documents is a truth... Meities will lies n spread fake n lies news .. meitei will lies till death
After that video went viral a few days ago (one needs to question the timing of it going viral, because things were slowly returning to normal by then), most other channels started portraying the Kukis to be the victims and the Meitis to be the perpetrators but no one is addressing the point about who started the violence? Clearly it was the Kukis who attacked the Meitis 1st, burnt down their whole villages etc and then when Meitis retaliated to protect themselves, Kukis started playing the victim card.
Kukis carried out horrid atrocities on the Meitis and there are videos of these which are being prevented from being circulated so the whole world is only getting one side of the story. This is so typical of crimes in India where the perpetrators from the minority communities are protected by always playing the victim card. And the international media are having a field day by alleging that Christians are not safe in India. Why doesn't someone put the truth out to shut up the mouths of all the internal and external enemies of India!
Don't see any media channels actually reporting from Manipur and when they do they are not trying to find out the reason for the violence & who started it?
I have heard on another channel from a Meiti guest, that Meitis are very angry because they have always been dealt a bad hand compared to the Nagas & the Kukis 1st by the British and then by all the Indian Governments, none of whom have even attempted to right the wrongs of the past so typically the Meitis keep suffering. Does this not sound familiar to how Hindus have always been treated in India as 8th class citizens.
They have plenty of Christian countries and muslims in India always support them. They unitedly defeated BJP in Karnataka also. We Hindus are orphans with no country to support and not enough we have full of Jaychands making our position helpless as they get the chance to say see your own people saying so.
Absolutely correct point 👍
Bjp govt needs to be removed
Clearly your perspective on the issue is one-sided and inadequate at best,you said it yourself and I quote "I heard it from a meitei guest in a news channel".your understanding of the issue is sentimentally inclined towards the meitei community with no goodwill intention.. you are simply another fanatics tuning your perspective only on communal lines.. you are a danger to yourself and the fabric upon which the constitution of this great country stood upon
First get yr facts right
Very very informative and thanks for bringing truth in public space.
Thank U so much for sharing the true information to public.... 🙏
Hats off Ramiji.. truly said!!
The main reason is kuki militants...
Rami ma'am's answer to the question of who started the violence was a masterclass in how to answer diplomatically. She didn't openly take sides but she answered, in a thorough manner, the question of which side did really start attacking the other.
It's really important to educate the whole nation and highly respected people like you are doing great job to describe what is the cause n who is responsible n what is their targets...
These so called zo Kuki how dare n who they are to decide hill is their land these people are guess of Manipuri Meitei now time to say goodbye to our lovely n very friendly people guess in Manipur
The first thumb rule of governing a landlocked territory - Never ever allow a scope for internal tension among people in the region right close to the border areas. This is fact right from ancient Roman Empire. Yet for some mysterious reasons BJP has been at the backfoot. Except for Hemanta, there's been no one taking a strong stand in the eastern part of India.
Unbiased analytical view. Thank you ma'am
Amazing and in-depth mature analysis which is balance. Great going @ramindesai
Salute Rami mam we want leaders like you.......
The meitei peoples are the kind of peoples who believed in their own lies than the persons they lied to
@@Chinzahau mostly kuki migrated ...learn history first
@@Chinzahau kuki from kukiland in Burma
@@poseidon4977 The meitei peoples are the kind of peoples who believed in their own lies than the persons they lied to
Its like mizos helping Kuki Opium traders that make all sens. But india will find solution but not in the way that Indira Gandhi did
Wow, her arguments are so beautifully nuanced and deeply thought through. I hope she can advise the local & national govts to take the next steps towards normalcy
Drug business is threatened . Otherwise who can get such sophisticated weapons and ammo for last 70 days .
Thank you Rami for such a great gin depth facts about Manipur
Well said, tq Rami Mam😊
Already I said Sir, P.Guru's each Statement bis Researched and Presentation is Very Palatable. Wisdom Always Excellent😊🙏
Manipur matter stage managed by Shehzada' s trip to Manipur a month back must have been .
Correctly brought out.. Maximum of the national media channel are purchased with drugs money and hence u can find fake narratives base on Christian cards, minority cards, refugees cards, victims cards which favours kukis circling all around in their channel..
I agree with you
Very insightful discussion.
Very difficult and complicated to solve the problems of North East unless all tribes forget their differences and trust each other and allow the Govt. to economically develop their individual states which is happening since 2014 as lot of money is being pumped by central govt and infrasture is being developed which was not seen since independence till 2014. violence is not the solution
as it will only brings misery for all the groups. It’s time for all political parties to bring all parties to negotiating table and solve the problems instead of doing dirty politics on any issue.
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
A very good decision to be accepted and also to be acted upon fourth with
Only after solving narco terrorist in Manipur we will get restored with real indigenous kuki brothers and sisters and elders.
@@alienangom116 indigenous people are not Kukis but Meitis
Is evangelical church wants another Rwanda in Manipur?
Thank you Ramiji 🙏🏼
This channel is so genuine.
Very balanced views. Basically, this is an old legacy and any government will need time to untangle the root issues. A magic wand expectation would be misplaced. Politicising is not helpful to finding solution!
The root cause of the Manipur issue is a pre-planned from last thirty years. I am sharing my view on ground of our National favour. It needs to know every people of India. Step by step actions were taken up in last thirty years to achieve their Gold. There steps will be told later, I am telling in short as .....
After case study of last 30 years of clashes between different communities, geographical, demographical and geopolitical analysis of Kuki Chin community, the demand of separate state is only first step to forming a Kuki Country with the support Western Christan Countries. This is security threat to India and depressing Indian Economy to be a World Supper Power country as all World knows that India is on the trench to become a Super Power Country in the World. Think about, why is the other state Mizoram and kuki community from Myanmar involving in present violence, because they have to win first step by any means/anyhow. After that next turning point, Lead by this Kukiland in India then the Kuki communities in India, Myanmar and Bangladesh will come together to form a Kuki Country. Think about what will be happened in India if Kukiland formed. They will try to get a funding of big amount to establish a country by means of drug production and narco terrorism. As a citizen of India, we have to pay attention early before happening such kind of act in future that this is not a civil war to meitei community only and we have know that it is a emotional war against India's prosperity/Indian Economy/Government of India/all jb public of India. To defend from them is not only the responsibility of meitei community but all also all citizens of India for our India's bright future.
Absolutely right
As an outsider, I've noticed many penalists mention that the kukis have clashed with every community they have come in contact with. Maybe it's their problem and fault and they play the victim.
@@SlimJim3082yes it is true ….they fought among themselves too…
Nobody believes Meitei anymore... The Majority Meitei should apologise for tarnishing India Image...
Meiteying (lying) again😂
Awesome to see Rami ji on PGurus!
I too watch every show of yours and give a thumbs 👍
Ekdum sahi kaha rami ji🙏
Mizo and Kukis r like cousin tribes. It also happens that both of them r Christian communities. You see the Buddhists from Myanmar r not coming in to settle in Manipur but why r the Christian tribes coming in. That's the big question. The reason is they want to create a different country which includes some part of North East India, Myanmar and Bangladesh.
Because its their ancestral land and their hills, ruled by none other than the British and their community along with their land divided by the British.
Evn b4 they became christian these tribals were here. Stop distorting history.
@@robertralte5710 The British imported the Kukis into northeast. There r documents present. Go and find out. And their ancestor were not Christians mind you.
@@COSSACK67 After becoming Christians we see how they treat other communities. Start accepting facts.
@@ang4065Historical documents made in Imphal?
Really excellent, eloquent speaker; i'm still absorbing from another podcast Rami did with abijit chavda. The background info to the conflict can be useful, imo, in resolving the animosities between the communities, aum
I watched so many videos of Rami ji, I love the smile of Ramiji
Rami is the owner and the founder of Manipur. She knows everything than the people who live there in Manipur. Narendra Modi needs to give her gallantry award. She is the God of Meitei community. She is the backbone of Biren mihuh pa. Meitei should worship her like saibaba.
Insightful and informative - a clear perspective. Finding solutions are the responsibility of the local communities, state and central governments.
Thanks for the excellent analysis of the Manipur situation by Ms Desai. It wa really interesting. However, the possible complicity of the head of the state, which seems quite evident and the 'Mind bogling' silence of the prime minister to the extent if suggesting 'complicity' fir pilitical gains (??) still remains a big question!!!. How come center did not intetvene with the use of central forces when the state was liteterally burning, which they are doing now, after three months? It is just difficult to undetstand.
❤❤❤❤❤🙏👌👍 Thank you for this video
Belated Happy Birthday Shree Sir
The unfortunate thing is you have only 3.53 lakh subscribers! Where are all the desis in the US? They should all be listening to Sree ji! Maybe you can have an ad or outreach programme.
A very thoughtful discussion, would have loved to hear the impact on climatic conditions of the state post flourishing poppy plantation and subsequently to the state economy.
Well said.. Great
Rami ji needs to be in a Ministry
Rami Desai does not know the history. Her knowledge comes from WIKIPEDIA.
@@DipakBose-bq1vv so whom would you recommend who is knowledgeable?? Open to 2nd 3rd 4th ...nth opnions here...
Ministry of biasedness and fake propoganda yes
@@DipakBose-bq1vvShe is a great anthropologist, scholar, author, columnist.. U better look for her background before leaving comments..
Its like mizos helping Kuki Opium traders that make all sens. But india will find solution but not in the way that Indira Gandhi did like bombing through airplane not that way.
I endorse the views expressed.
Wonderful! We need such matured, well informed and unbiased journalists. Thank you Mr Iyer for getting Rami on your channel to clear misconceptions in the minds of well meaning citizens of this country and also those keenly following the developments in Manipur from near and far.
Thank u Rami ji
All these problems boil down to one principal fact - we have failed to effectively guard our borders.
Great insight
I appreciate Ma'am
Only solution to problem stop, restriction,on illegal cultivation
Thank you❤
Rightly pointed out the demographic changes in the valley region will spurt discontent amongst locals but the developments should not stop. But the mistakes & policies of previous govts is also a contributing factor
love you rami ❤
Please go through the "A Page from the Secret Diary" of a Kuji Militant leader for the root cause (Hueiyen Lanpao July 10
Very Humanly Words
This problem was subdued during the democratic rule in mynanar .The army taking over has complicated the manipuris existence
Before May 3rd, Manipur Govt. had been cutting down poppy plantations in hills and it was mostly in chin kuki mizo residing areas. Plus started the work of identifying illegal immigrants in Manipur. There are full evidence and documents on these with the government as well as available in media. This is the main cause of this orchestrated or engineered conflict.
SC CJI was extremely saddened by the video from Manipur. This same CJI will stop any harsh steps centre takes. They will stay any displacement of illegal occupants on forest lands.
SC stayed the removal of illegal Rohingyas. That is what SC is famous for. They meddle in affairs suo moto that have nothing to do with them. Government will need to bring in legislation controlling the SC judges to remain within their remit. SC judges are not elected whereas Government's are and they must be allowed to deal with executive matters. Judiciary has no business poking their noses in everything.
One should question the SC why they never take suo moto action against the W Bengal government where women are disrobed in public and attacked by TMC goons. There have been over 50 deaths around the Panchayat elections and over 150 after the last state elections. How is W Bengal different to Manipur? Also why no action by SC with regards to attacks and murders of Hindus in Rajasthan, Chattisgarh, Bihar?
Thanks madame
Kukis instead of appealing against High Court's directive on inclusiin of Meiteis in the SC, they have started attack to the Common Meiteis settling at Churachandpur where Kukis dominate. They have done a blunder by attacking to a Community(Meitei) who are a great worriers. Similiar actions were done to Kukis dwelling in the valley, dominated by Meiteis.
Your messages are good to hear. Jeep it up
Rami knowledge is fixed in Manipur valley only
Welcome Remiji
Unfortunately international community doesn't want to see Indian subcontinent peaceful and economically developed. Probably India is the only country in an unenviable position having to fight forces from across the globe. India can handle local/regional challenges with ease. What do we do when those powers that keep lecturing about peace, democracy, freedom, etc themselves are guilty of fomenting unrest all around?
Still, India will deftly handle all such challenges. Just a matter of time. A bit of faith and patience is the least we can offer to our motherland during all these testing times..
Yes, yes. yes. Let's blame it on the British. The whole world knows the best country is India and how wonderful, honest and holy Indians are. Look at the long queues and how they are tripping over each other in trying to migrate to India. We should charge them millions of dollars if they want to come to India and eat fafda and dokla from the biggest teashop in the world - Modi's tea shop. The whole world is dying to say Howdy Modi you are the Hinduon ka Samrat.
Its like mizos helping Kuki Opium traders that make all sens. But india will find solution but not in the way that Indira Gandhi did
It's good to hear from Mrs Desai, about some unknown information.
But on 25 July 2023 BBC News India UA-cam has posted a news " The cost of violence in Manipur" The two indian reporters have done there job (as said).
In videos they didn't touch on drugs farming & it's impact on humanity. Infrantion of Roinghia & Mayanmur in Manipur & there evil purpose.
BBC didn't touch on drugs caught at border & it's value & it's probably bad effect if not caught by military forces & Police.
So this international BBC British Betrayal Company has to be taught a very good lesson by completely banning from India because this BBC is trying to set a very bad narrative to rest world so called Western nations & in some world forums.
So intectul community should think on this & initiate some actions.
Ofcourse it's present government responsibility to bring back the state to normalcy.
Well spoken Rani
THANK U MADAM. OUTSTANDING.
The main issue is land. The meiteis consider Manipur is theirs and want to eliminate any community that possess threat to their dominance. One has to listen to the Meitei Leepun chief Pramot Singh calling the Kukis as outsiders. He is being patronized by the CM and the titular King Sanajaoba, who is also a Rajya Sabha MP. The Kukis, being tribals, are not as advanced as the meiteis and are only about 16% of the population, an easy pick for the meiteis. Being tribals may not be the perfect community to live with. But the atrocities carried out against them cannot be justified because of the underlying problems mentined by Rami. It is not a conflict, it's an attempt to drive out Kukis from Manipur.
First the British split the society created fault lines to forward their own interests then they coerced Indian Govt to continue with their policy and retain and reward these divisions with special privilages to people who maintained these fault lines and indulge in antinational activity terrorism drug cultivation and human trafficing... They have no social economic or political obligations towards India and members across North East..
With Indian money Indian food Indian security they create instability and violence in India...With Their newly acquired relegious affiliation they ridicule their own culture deities environment and people...
Meiteis mouthpiece
I don't miss out your videos
A strong THREE LAYER border fencing done on a war footing way can curb these illegal immigrants from myanmar and banglades. Yes it's going to be a herculean task for the BRO, but once completed it will be huge relief to all my north east fellow Indians.
To start with reimposing AFSPA across not only Manipur but adjoining areas.
Firstly, good you have finally chosen to discuss Manipur. One point to appreciate Rami is not to go discussing what USA or UN says or does about Myanmar refugees. These are our neighbours and its necessary to keep dialogues open or else as she mentioned because of US sanctions on Myanmar China enters the scenario which will become difficult for India. This has happened in Srilanka, its happening in Nepal, may will happen in Pakistan too. So relationships with our neighbours is more important than US or UK etc.😮
Thanks a lot dear Sis. Rami and Thanks a lot brother Sree. Great and insightful discussion. Audio from Ramiji side would have been better. Please take care of it. 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Audio from Ramiji's side
Agreed her audio was not clear at all. Could hardly make out what she was saying. Ended up having to strain a lot which became quite painful.