Of course being an overseas Pakistan I will sure help you support so that you can keep doing what “YOU” love to do, but before I do that could you please tell me that do you guys even know the reality of India’s economy, let alone the economy of our own country?
The reason India is progressing (atleast at a better rate than Pakistan) is because Indian experts are not sitting down and discussing Pakistan's or China's economy.
What a blatant lie.Indians are busy in spreading disinformation by every means available. What is notable is that why Russian dod not accept Indian rupees for payment against purchase of oil instead they pressed on Chinese Yuan for repayment. No one describe why fespite Indian hue and cry why Brics is expanding by inclusion of more members. Finally why after 30 years of yearning and convassing no one accepting India as permanant SC members. Indians are busy laughing.
@@rehanahmad5465most of those who experts in India who talk about Pakistan or Chinas economy are retired or too rich to talk .. here we have productive age group spending time on useless discussion on economy than working
Absolutely. The Gini Coefficient which is a measure of equality has been improving for the last ten years. The so called expert is also off the mark on other aspects of Indian economy.
@@nikhildeshmukh6221 well informed criticism is always welcome . Although it’s quite rich coming from someone who clearly seems to be assumptive prick. I am sure if I call you a buffoon without proper knowledge of who you are and you get triggered for it . Would it be fair calling you a pusedo liberal or a darbari then
@@nikhildeshmukh6221 Here comes the Congi, as always supporting clueless Pakistanis. More likely you are a Pakistani masquerading with an Indian name. Regardless, one thing is clear - you hate India and will go to any length to support those who oppose India.
Bhai the same for indian analist.ham 1 dusre ko samaj nahi patte.india me bahot si nations baste heen. Pakistan me bi yahi ha.sab sa bahtar hal ye haa ke sab ko autonomy deen..aur central power kam sa kam dahal andazi kareen..power awam ke pass ho.aur giudiciary honestly apna kam kareen..Pakistan aur indian loog appas me bat chit sa masail ka hal nikaleen.european ne 100 sal tak 1 dusre ko mara.abb european union haa.ye kam yahan pa kiun nahi ho sakta..
I will give you prime example, country called Uganda which kicked Indian's from country in 1971 and the country has not recovered since, hindus play huge part in success of any nations.
@@noparallel7987 No, Baniyas actually have a bad reputation (wrong reputation but that’s how it ia). Hindus as a whole, wherever they are, they form the more progressive, more financially stable than those around them. Except in India where everyone except Hindus has been appeased and supported for more than a thousand years.
Mashallah when our people have this level of understanding of economy and especially when our pseudo and self proclaimed intellectuals talk with almost no knowledge about the economy of our neighbors then, Allah Hi Hafiz hai Mulq Ka. Inna lilla e rajeoon !!
Pak has previously utilized that blackmail. By claiming to be nuclear power and that it cannot survive without money, it has already amassed a sizable fortune. Countries will now demand that Pakistan sell Saudi Arabia and other countries nuclear weapons.
If this is the level of knowledge and understanding of economy, especially when you guys tried to discuss the economy of our neighbour India, then Allah Hi Hafiz Hai. I can only Do Dua for you - Allah Tala Apko Hidayat De. You should do bit of research before talking about any topic, otherwise it all comes down garbage in garbage out.
People look at income inequality as a bad thing. Income inequality which means concentrated wealth is a requirement for diruptive innovation. This is why Europe cannot come up with any innovations while the US can. Also income inequality in India now being better than colonial times is a good news not a bad news
What will happen when a country default ----Country is pushed to civil war and anarchy - imports come to grind halt as no bank can operate letter of credit... There will be run on banks..
Apart from all the issues discussed in this podcast another important issue is and has been the question on the capacity of our policy and decision makers
Complete Non-understanding of K-Electric's achievements. More than 70% of Karachi is Load shedding free. Line losses are the lowest in the country at 15%. Bill received 97% in 2022 and 93% in 2023 best in the country. State-of-the-art distribution in PMTs, Meters, and sub-station transmission equipment.
My very simple question: WHY can't Pakistan make its own roads, ports, power plants, dams and other infrastructure? Why does pakistan have to depend on foreigners to make all this?
One big problem in my view with Pakistan is the lack of good planning system which can foresee all possible present and future domestic and international scenarios and include the same to reduce the risks and ensure success
Why should Pakistan default. What Pakistan does not have? Stop ur water going 2 sea. A dam can b built in one week. 200 million people, it is one person laying one brick each.
This guy's funny,British times s zyada inequality,bhai headlines se aage b kuch padhlo,Oxfam is a socialist NGO acc to itself,it's not an economics research organisation ,so obviously they'll say these things,all their assertions r based on market cap of companies,they just use that to extrapolate,never a good idea😂😂
Inequality increasing in India is a fact: - scooter and tractor sales have decreased. While there is bumper sales of luxury cars - the income of the bottom 60% of the population has declined. Only top 20% has seen an increase - income share of top 10% is now ~60% bottom 40% is ~25% During 2002, they used to be equal at 40% each - the wealth of the top 0.001% has doubled, and is just below Russia. It is indicative of oligarchy & plutocracy (adani and Ambani) who corner all wealth in the country The current regime won't let any negative news come out. No media will report on it. Fanboys won't accept it even when they read it. And then you react with surprise when you hear it from outside.
@@mrgyani Make every body poor then there will be equality. This is Congress formula. Indira Gandhi increased income tax to 97% for the rich and the poverty went up greatly.
@@mrgyani Stay on topic is the inequality more than in british times?? Prove it. The pir needs to be bigger, which firstly will go to the 1%. India does not exist in a vacuum. Many new millionaires are coming up in India from middle class population, number of middle class people increased, number of out of poverty increased by a few hundred million. The Gov isn't perfect, I'm not denying that but giving sweeping statements like "The current regime won't let any negative news come out" is totally false. I knew of all the stats you provided. It is not an indication of oligarchy or plutocracy, it's just fear mongering from your end. Spending for the benefits to the poor increases every year. Oversimplification of complex issues is making you look dumb.
This expert is suffering from huge bias, Pakistan condition is next to srilanka in all debts records still he is saying it will not be srilanka Pakistan is protected because US, China & India (I know) but say in private India does not want pak to go ballistic, it's being protected. Else by now pak pm house and military headquarters would have been raided.
Full respect to u both educated brothers. When others hear stories about churches and mandirs being attacked and someone killed 4 blasphamy, that scares other people 2 invest in Pakistan. If someone innocently (or may b not mentally right) appears 2 b blasphamous u don't kill him or her. U explain politely that it is wrong. Once a traveller urinated innocently facing holy place. The people were going 2 kill him. Respectable Messenger realised his innocence, gave him bath ,fed him and gave him money 4 travel. He was never askjed 2 change religion.
Absolutely spot on analysis, brilliant delivery and extremely non-judgmental point of view. Guys, "aik puppi idhar, aur aik doosri taraf".. If i ever decide to sponsor this channel, it will be just because of this type of quality content.
Tasweeran Geet Toń Baad Ajj Milya A-Seef Bai. Jeonde raho Dekho kado tak Indian DNA larh skda Arabic Cult naal. Islamic County (Arabic Cult) Me sirf Pakistan, Bangladesh Me Kuch democracy hai Due To Hindi DNA. Lekin abb Arabic Cult Brain me dakhil ho chukka hai..
Ali bhai, sharing a feedback, today you seem like more of cutting fahad and suddenly changing the topic. Seemed like you are establishing you know more or you are right.. doesnt look good
@@MunnaMobile000 haha bro Allah Muhammad ka bnaya fictional character h apni tharak puri krne k lye...ram krishna sb hain sanatan Teri smj me nhi ane wala...Winston Churchill rightly said islam in a man is like rabies in a dog
Gini coefficient, does this expert know what that is? I don’t know if it ignorance or idiocy that results in their opinion on their enemy country India 😂
Of course we like and subscribe to you content that is likeable and credible, but if you don’t know the realistic understanding of our neighbors economy, and do a discussion which is irrelevant then it’s hard to give like.
@@priortokaraew7569 Islam is good and cannot be blamed for the poor state of Pakistan . Most Pakistanis are Barelvis which is not considered islamic outside Pakistan.
@@priortokaraew7569 they do but Barelvis also consider people like Ghouse Pak, Waliullah , Ahmad Raza etc as rasools. Henc they are not considered muslims
Support the channel and help me produce what I love!
www.patreon.com/aliaftab_saeed
Jazz Cash / Easy Paisa / Raast | 0325 6555592
Of course being an overseas Pakistan I will sure help you support so that you can keep doing what “YOU” love to do, but before I do that could you please tell me that do you guys even know the reality of India’s economy, let alone the economy of our own country?
The reason India is progressing (atleast at a better rate than Pakistan) is because Indian experts are not sitting down and discussing Pakistan's or China's economy.
This is all they do. You should see their videos. they are obsessed with Pakistan.
What a blatant lie.Indians are busy in spreading disinformation by every means available.
What is notable is that why Russian dod not accept Indian rupees for payment against purchase of oil instead they pressed on Chinese Yuan for repayment.
No one describe why fespite Indian hue and cry why Brics is expanding by inclusion of more members.
Finally why after 30 years of yearning and convassing no one accepting India as permanant SC members.
Indians are busy laughing.
@@rehanahmad5465most of those who experts in India who talk about Pakistan or Chinas economy are retired or too rich to talk .. here we have productive age group spending time on useless discussion on economy than working
It’s truely astonishing how these so called experts have absolutely zero understanding of India and its economy.
Absolutely. The Gini Coefficient which is a measure of equality has been improving for the last ten years. The so called expert is also off the mark on other aspects of Indian economy.
Bhagt can't take criticism
@@nikhildeshmukh6221 well informed criticism is always welcome . Although it’s quite rich coming from someone who clearly seems to be assumptive prick. I am sure if I call you a buffoon without proper knowledge of who you are and you get triggered for it . Would it be fair calling you a pusedo liberal or a darbari then
@@nikhildeshmukh6221 Here comes the Congi, as always supporting clueless Pakistanis. More likely you are a Pakistani masquerading with an Indian name. Regardless, one thing is clear - you hate India and will go to any length to support those who oppose India.
Bhai the same for indian analist.ham 1 dusre ko samaj nahi patte.india me bahot si nations baste heen. Pakistan me bi yahi ha.sab sa bahtar hal ye haa ke sab ko autonomy deen..aur central power kam sa kam dahal andazi kareen..power awam ke pass ho.aur giudiciary honestly apna kam kareen..Pakistan aur indian loog appas me bat chit sa masail ka hal nikaleen.european ne 100 sal tak 1 dusre ko mara.abb european union haa.ye kam yahan pa kiun nahi ho sakta..
I will give you prime example, country called Uganda which kicked Indian's from country in 1971 and the country has not recovered since, hindus play huge part in success of any nations.
A good case is that Indian Hindus are the richest ethnic group in the US. Their Per Capita income is double than that of the US as a whole.
Exactly
Hindu baniyas are famous for a reason
@@noparallel7987 No, Baniyas actually have a bad reputation (wrong reputation but that’s how it ia). Hindus as a whole, wherever they are, they form the more progressive, more financially stable than those around them. Except in India where everyone except Hindus has been appeased and supported for more than a thousand years.
@noparallel7987 every country where the hindus 🕉 are living that country never fails and remains successful for as long as they live in the country.
Mashallah when our people have this level of understanding of economy and especially when our pseudo and self proclaimed intellectuals talk with almost no knowledge about the economy of our neighbors then, Allah Hi Hafiz hai Mulq Ka. Inna lilla e rajeoon !!
Pak has previously utilized that blackmail. By claiming to be nuclear power and that it cannot survive without money, it has already amassed a sizable fortune. Countries will now demand that Pakistan sell Saudi Arabia and other countries nuclear weapons.
Nuclear suicide jacket is our saviour?
So, what about Muslim Allah's Islamic finance? Is it not working? Impotent?
It's not applied as it should be.
If this is the level of knowledge and understanding of economy, especially when you guys tried to discuss the economy of our neighbour India, then Allah Hi Hafiz Hai. I can only Do Dua for you - Allah Tala Apko Hidayat De.
You should do bit of research before talking about any topic, otherwise it all comes down garbage in garbage out.
People look at income inequality as a bad thing. Income inequality which means concentrated wealth is a requirement for diruptive innovation. This is why Europe cannot come up with any innovations while the US can. Also income inequality in India now being better than colonial times is a good news not a bad news
The level of discussion in Pak is very mediocre.
What will happen when a country default ----Country is pushed to civil war and anarchy - imports come to grind halt as no bank can operate letter of credit... There will be run on banks..
Itni halat khasta he phir bhi india me terrorists bhej raha he
Army is rich
Apart from all the issues discussed in this podcast another important issue is and has been the question on the capacity of our policy and decision makers
Complete Non-understanding of K-Electric's achievements. More than 70% of Karachi is Load shedding free. Line losses are the lowest in the country at 15%. Bill received 97% in 2022 and 93% in 2023 best in the country. State-of-the-art distribution in PMTs, Meters, and sub-station transmission equipment.
My very simple question: WHY can't Pakistan make its own roads, ports, power plants, dams and other infrastructure? Why does pakistan have to depend on foreigners to make all this?
One big problem in my view with Pakistan is the lack of good planning system which can foresee all possible present and future domestic and international scenarios and include the same to reduce the risks and ensure success
increase i.T exports and computer i.T and spread english language learning ....😮😮😮❤❤❤❤
Why should Pakistan default. What Pakistan does not have? Stop ur water going 2 sea. A dam can b built in one week. 200 million people, it is one person laying one brick each.
increase i.T exports and computer i.T and spread english language learning ....❤❤❤❤😮😮😮😮❤❤❤❤
increase i.T exports and computer i.T and spread english language learning ....❤❤❤😮😮😮😮
Awesome episode. Looking forward for another episode with the same guest.
This guy's funny,British times s zyada inequality,bhai headlines se aage b kuch padhlo,Oxfam is a socialist NGO acc to itself,it's not an economics research organisation ,so obviously they'll say these things,all their assertions r based on market cap of companies,they just use that to extrapolate,never a good idea😂😂
Inequality increasing in India is a fact:
- scooter and tractor sales have decreased. While there is bumper sales of luxury cars
- the income of the bottom 60% of the population has declined. Only top 20% has seen an increase
- income share of
top 10% is now ~60%
bottom 40% is ~25%
During 2002, they used to be equal at 40% each
- the wealth of the top 0.001% has doubled, and is just below Russia. It is indicative of oligarchy & plutocracy (adani and Ambani) who corner all wealth in the country
The current regime won't let any negative news come out. No media will report on it. Fanboys won't accept it even when they read it. And then you react with surprise when you hear it from outside.
@@mrgyani Make every body poor then there will be equality. This is Congress formula. Indira Gandhi increased income tax to 97% for the rich and the poverty went up greatly.
@@mrgyani Stay on topic is the inequality more than in british times?? Prove it. The pir needs to be bigger, which firstly will go to the 1%. India does not exist in a vacuum. Many new millionaires are coming up in India from middle class population, number of middle class people increased, number of out of poverty increased by a few hundred million. The Gov isn't perfect, I'm not denying that but giving sweeping statements like "The current regime won't let any negative news come out" is totally false. I knew of all the stats you provided. It is not an indication of oligarchy or plutocracy, it's just fear mongering from your end. Spending for the benefits to the poor increases every year. Oversimplification of complex issues is making you look dumb.
Thanks Ali for replacing the previous mutalika Pakistan economy expert!
When will Maho come back?
What happened to Islamic economic system? 😅😅😅😅
informative sirr!
This expert is suffering from huge bias, Pakistan condition is next to srilanka in all debts records still he is saying it will not be srilanka Pakistan is protected because US, China & India (I know) but say in private India does not want pak to go ballistic, it's being protected. Else by now pak pm house and military headquarters would have been raided.
Full respect to u both educated brothers. When others hear stories about churches and mandirs being attacked and someone killed 4 blasphamy, that scares other people 2 invest in Pakistan. If someone innocently (or may b not mentally right) appears 2 b blasphamous u don't kill him or her. U explain politely that it is wrong. Once a traveller urinated innocently facing holy place. The people were going 2 kill him. Respectable Messenger realised his innocence, gave him bath ,fed him and gave him money 4 travel. He was never askjed 2 change religion.
P@kistan me awam se jadda expert aur youtubers hai.😮😮😮😮😮
Are ye keh raha hai ye Finance ka banda nahi hai😂😂😂😂 BC ye kya kar raha hai ek ghante ki podcast me 😢😅😮
Wo Economist hai. Tujhe nahin pata tha ye alehda cheezen hotin 🤣🤣🤣
Dollars ke kharche reduce kyon nahi kurtee. Tea, coffee, paan, cold drink, KFC, imported shoes and garments , foreign travel reduce kyon nahi kurte😅😅😅😅
Absolutely spot on analysis, brilliant delivery and extremely non-judgmental point of view. Guys, "aik puppi idhar, aur aik doosri taraf".. If i ever decide to sponsor this channel, it will be just because of this type of quality content.
Musbat🥰🥰🥰
❤❤❤❤
Tasweeran Geet Toń Baad Ajj Milya A-Seef Bai. Jeonde raho Dekho kado tak Indian DNA larh skda Arabic Cult naal.
Islamic County (Arabic Cult) Me sirf Pakistan, Bangladesh Me Kuch democracy hai Due To Hindi DNA.
Lekin abb Arabic Cult Brain me dakhil ho chukka hai..
🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
❤🎉❤🎉❤🎉
Ali bhai, sharing a feedback, today you seem like more of cutting fahad and suddenly changing the topic.
Seemed like you are establishing you know more or you are right.. doesnt look good
Bhari episode. Allah khair karay hamaray Mulk ke liye 😢
Pr Allah to h hi nahi...see zafar heretic and nabi asli bro
@@anujdev22222 in that case, Ram, Shiva, Hanuman, Ishwar, Ganesh etc. also do not exist. Easy ho jao.
@@MunnaMobile000off course all these are stories 😂
AAMEEN sum AAMEEN ya Rubbal Allameen
@@MunnaMobile000 haha bro Allah Muhammad ka bnaya fictional character h apni tharak puri krne k lye...ram krishna sb hain sanatan Teri smj me nhi ane wala...Winston Churchill rightly said islam in a man is like rabies in a dog
Pseudo analysts at its best. Lage raho bhai
Bhai Maza aagaya Ali Malik KO B bula lo arsa hi ho Gaya hai
musbat show khdr hai?
don't tell me you didn't see "ur mom" in the patron list lol
Gini coefficient, does this expert know what that is? I don’t know if it ignorance or idiocy that results in their opinion on their enemy country India 😂
Woh desh isiliye tarakki nhi karr raha kyunki aise log majority me hai😂😂
Your stat will not in world mape in. 2026
Like | Share | Comment | Subscribe
Of course we like and subscribe to you content that is likeable and credible, but if you don’t know the realistic understanding of our neighbors economy, and do a discussion which is irrelevant then it’s hard to give like.
Joker kahi ke😂😂😂..
Musbat show???
Musbat
Allah is punishing us because of letting Barelvis lead us.
Pakistan has rich donor friend
China
Saudi Arabia
Usa
Other rich arab
No worries
Pakistan can relax & enjoy
❤❤❤
Allah is punishing us because of letting Barelvis lead us.
What a great example pakistan is of what Islam's results are.
@@priortokaraew7569 Islam is good and cannot be blamed for the poor state of Pakistan . Most Pakistanis are Barelvis which is not considered islamic outside Pakistan.
@@Adi-ev1uh I see. Do these barelvis not shout Allah hu Akbar?
@@priortokaraew7569 they do but Barelvis also consider people like Ghouse Pak, Waliullah , Ahmad Raza etc as rasools. Henc they are not considered muslims
@@Adi-ev1uh so that means more than half of pakistan is not muslim.