They had to get rid of Shane. The only way Rick would be come the main character is if Shane was not there. Shane was more liked than Rick at that time.
Lucas Nephew absolutely , at the time they prob thought it was necessary but you don't get rid of someone like Jon bernthal that quickly . Should have had him go off on his own and be the lead of a spin off show instead of fear the walking dead
I liked Shane and he was strong but in season 2 he was annoying..he went crazy..he would Lori and Lori wouldnt but he kept going..on his last ours he would kill Rick..its sad he went crazy cause he was strong..
@@Brodawg-rv8ne Wrong, Carls death was Carls own fould....not Ricks foult. Rick teached Carl how to survive and Carl screwed it up. Carl would have died anyway even if Shane was alive.
my version is, if Rick didn't kill Shane and Shane left Rick alone and gone somewhere like Morales did then in the 7-season Rick would meet Shane again and they would fight against Negan together. The 7 season would be greatest if it happened
I love this video its 100% accurate Shane actually was a better leader at the time he got what needed to be done way more then RIck but today RIck has learned from Shane and now he is built for this world I still think Rick was stronger with Shane then without really to bad they couldn't get back what they lost.
REQUEST: have Shane witness Ricks death (edit footage to make it seem like Rick died) and have black and white flashbacks of their friendship as he prepares to take revenge! Maybe on Negan.
I think Shane should have lived because he would make the whole team tough but instead, rick just sits there and stares at nothing while tears and Negan takes the gun
Believe me..without Rick the whole camp would be eaten up..Rick came with strong weapons and saved the most people..without Rick im sure only Daryl would still be alive..Rick is so much smarter than Shane..Shane could never do it better than Rick couse Shane cant keep thinking he is strong but very dumb
louwe post that’s were your wrong Shane would also be alive because in this world the crazy survive but I like Shane being crazy because if he was not he would not have stood out The Should Be Bad Ass Leader Shane Walsh
@@louwepost4421 Rick became Shane, sorry your wrong Rick learned a lesson from Shane without Shane teaching him and everyone else how to live they all be dead. Darryl himself has become exactly like Shane you mess with any of the group your dead! The problem with Rick he was in a coma missed out on all the crap Shane seen with his own two eyes when the military comes threw and shoot civilians you learn really fast that the people are worse then any zombie. Its really the main reason Shane was turned colder then Rick yet later Rick treats every choice just like Shane would of done killing anyone that was a threat to the group it was clear after he lost Lori that he regrets killing his best friend it was a choice he couldn't take back yet in his dream he admitted as much to Shane.
@@BioZombie77 And look where it brought him....he is dead because he was crazy lol. That proves that you are wrong. Shane was strong, but he brought the group in dangerous situations without thinking of the group. He was only thinking about Lori...he was selfish....Rick was smarter and Shane is dead because of his actions so you are wrong
@@dalelapointe9289 Rick did not became Shane because Rick went smarter than Shane and do you know why? Shane would have killed Negan after the war but Rick showed mercy and created peace among the commumitys. We both know that Shane was too angry and selfish for that so you are wrong. I have to admit that Rick learned alot from Shane but Rick never stepped in his footsteps. Rick is smarter and cares about every last one of them, even the saviors he gave a second chanse. And look what an empire he has build now. Shane was not capable to think further than just surviving and killing in the woods. And Daryl was always stronger than Shane and thats why Daryl is alive and Shane is dead lol. Shane got himself killed and for what. RICK IS THE BEST
I disagree. He could of abandoned them all and started a new life. He fought to come back to them and forgave Lori for messing around with Shane and getting pregnant. He never gave up and as much as I like Shane's character he was dangerous and Rick saw that. I have a lot of admiration for Rick and what he did to keep those safe around him.
Almost everyone ends up failing as those things if they are them in the first place in this apocalypse. Shane would have done worse. He’s stronger than Rick but he’s nuts and takes too many risks like Negan or The Governor
@@sam.lipchutz no shane was ahead of his time Rick isn't a bad leader but the point is at the time he was too soft I'm glad he finnaly got over his bs and now he does whatever is needed to be done
Dude Shane’s very dead I wish he wasn’t because he was my favorite character then Merle but Shane was stabbed by rick and it was all because of Whori oops I mean Lori see Shane was smart he knew what to do and I’m saying it’s Lori’s fault because Shane went to leave before they even got to the farm and she made him stay
I really liked shane, before he went a little crazy. But he was too cold and too hostile to outsiders. I know that you have to be very suspicious of strangers in a apocalypse, but he would always go straight for killing the stranger. I think that's a road that leads to the way the governor was, killing everyone you met and taking their stuff. Rick has gotten very ruthless and dark at times, but he was a good person to start with so he could be brought back. Rick was pushed to being ruthless, you can't bring someone out of that when that's how they started in this world He also didn't seem like he really cared for anyone in the group other than lori and carl. I think he would have be okay letting anyone else in the group die if he could survive with those two. Shane also had not sense of other people's feelings. I think if he had killed rick and led the group he would have killed or pushed everyone else away. After the walkers invaded the farm he probably wouldn't have waited for rest of them, he would have taken carl and Lori and been the first one to go when he saw the herd. I would really have liked to see him stay as rick's right hand man. He was a damn good shot, shooting teacher, and he was good at keeping people organized or in line (for a lack of better words). He had the original camp somewhat organized, despite the people in it and the fact that they were strangers. And after Sophie went missing he made sure to keep the other people workingff to keep them from having the time to be worried.
Carol is wrong. She must've forgotten that when Rick was still in the hospital she was traveling with the group when Shane was the leader. I think if Shane killed Rick, at that point he wouldn't care about the group other than him, Carl and Lori. So at that point he wouldn't care if anyone else died he would just keep them safe. But if Shane didn't go psycho and Rick never woke up, then Shane would've led the group to safety many times and he wouldnt have even crossed Negan and the Saviors because he would be far East.
well , what is one supossed to do if he risks his life and gets the group away from danger for months only to be dropped off for some guy that is delusional they were painting him as the enemy and its their fault he had to die !
Everyone is commenting they want Shane back. He had more potential not being Shane. And admit it, he would've been dead by Negan. And when Lori died, he would go insane like Rick did, but Shane would go crazy and go killing people. He would've died by The Governor and the attack. So stop commenting you guys want him back he had more potential not being in The Walking Dead
Actually Shane would of killed the Governor pretty quickly he was a marksman easy kill for Shane. Now for Negan that might of been different because the reason Negan pick Abarham was because of his size and will against him he never quivered when Negan killed him. Yet there is a chance Shane wouldn't of even got caught when Rick took off with Maggie he might of hung back and protected the camp like always. Shane would then still been a live when they came back and told him what happen then who knows what would of happen because Rick was stronger with Shane !
Carol is wrong. She must've forgotten that when Rick was still in the hospital she was traveling with the group when Shane was the leader. I think if Shane killed Rick, at that point he wouldn't care about the group other than him, Carl and Lori. So at that point he wouldn't care if anyone else died he would just keep them safe. But if Shane didn't go psycho and Rick never woke up, then Shane would've led the group to safety many times and he wouldnt have even crossed Negan and the Saviors because he would be far East.
Jon Bernthal is such a badass. He's one of the best actors I've ever seen.
Godamn I really wish Shane was still alive.
Best character ever.
spotty112 2 coming back season 9 🔥
Yes I know
He is a great character. He’s like a Frank Underwood or Walter White Anti Villain
Yes
i agree
I'd do anything to have Shane back
anything?
*well im right here*
anything? ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
@@zacharyhalecomstock5227 Oh God...
@@zacharyhalecomstock5227 yea i will do anything too
Shane is just the BEST !
He’s the Anti Villain
Yes
Nothing against Kirkman but I think he threw Shane away he had potential as an amazing part who else agrees
They had to get rid of Shane. The only way Rick would be come the main character is if Shane was not there. Shane was more liked than Rick at that time.
Lucas Nephew absolutely , at the time they prob thought it was necessary but you don't get rid of someone like Jon bernthal that quickly . Should have had him go off on his own and be the lead of a spin off show instead of fear the walking dead
I liked Shane and he was strong but in season 2 he was annoying..he went crazy..he would Lori and Lori wouldnt but he kept going..on his last ours he would kill Rick..its sad he went crazy cause he was strong..
@@About36Greekss Yes! Absolutely
@@tcop30 could have made him leave and reappear much later
Best character ever.
Yes
I agree
shane is badass
Cant imagine how the series would look if he still was alive
Eranuzz I would be a better show, Carl would be alive, Glenn would be alive, Lori would probably still be dead, Rick might even be alive
Negan would have totured him instead of Daryl because of how he is.
@@Brodawg-rv8ne Wrong, Carls death was Carls own fould....not Ricks foult. Rick teached Carl how to survive and Carl screwed it up. Carl would have died anyway even if Shane was alive.
@@Brodawg-rv8ne How would Glenn be alive? Rick couldnt do anything so Shane too. You saw what happened when Daryl hits Negan
Better
my version is, if Rick didn't kill Shane and Shane left Rick alone and gone somewhere like Morales did then in the 7-season Rick would meet Shane again and they would fight against Negan together. The 7 season would be greatest if it happened
Freak Head yeah like if he left with Andrea then came across him later in the show would be awesome
Shane is like a combination of Rick and The Governor
people that claim that Shane should come back are the true fans of TWD because every season they compare how this guy could have get away with it
Yeah but they’re not thinking about how he goes overboard and would eventually take too many risks like Negan or The Governor
He is the best leader in the World 💖💖💖
Underrated channel. Great work.
I love this video its 100% accurate Shane actually was a better leader at the time he got what needed to be done way more then RIck but today RIck has learned from Shane and now he is built for this world I still think Rick was stronger with Shane then without really to bad they couldn't get back what they lost.
SHANE !!!!!😭😭😭😭
The only Leader of the group *SHANE*
We missed Shane so much
REQUEST: have Shane witness Ricks death (edit footage to make it seem like Rick died) and have black and white flashbacks of their friendship as he prepares to take revenge! Maybe on Negan.
Shane was cool
I think Shane should have lived because he would make the whole team tough but instead, rick just sits there and stares at nothing while tears and Negan takes the gun
LOL what? Shane would do absolutely NOTHING if Negan had him surrounded by 50+ men. You're delusional
We all know Shane was the better leader.
Nah he near as good as Rick but not better
Shane was the best
@@botstheychetmygrsfe7738 really
0:13 lmao
Shane was the best I love Shane so much I really do
"all methed out with your buck knife and geek ears around your neck...She'd run in the other direction!"
Our hero
Great Montage. Shane was a better leader than Rick All of S1&S2. Rick couldn't make the decisions to stay alive
Shane was always the good guy he kept the camp safe... until rick showed up and the camp went down hill from there.
Believe me..without Rick the whole camp would be eaten up..Rick came with strong weapons and saved the most people..without Rick im sure only Daryl would still be alive..Rick is so much smarter than Shane..Shane could never do it better than Rick couse Shane cant keep thinking he is strong but very dumb
louwe post that’s were your wrong Shane would also be alive because in this world the crazy survive but I like Shane being crazy because if he was not he would not have stood out The Should Be Bad Ass Leader Shane Walsh
@@louwepost4421 Rick became Shane, sorry your wrong Rick learned a lesson from Shane without Shane teaching him and everyone else how to live they all be dead. Darryl himself has become exactly like Shane you mess with any of the group your dead! The problem with Rick he was in a coma missed out on all the crap Shane seen with his own two eyes when the military comes threw and shoot civilians you learn really fast that the people are worse then any zombie. Its really the main reason Shane was turned colder then Rick yet later Rick treats every choice just like Shane would of done killing anyone that was a threat to the group it was clear after he lost Lori that he regrets killing his best friend it was a choice he couldn't take back yet in his dream he admitted as much to Shane.
@@BioZombie77 And look where it brought him....he is dead because he was crazy lol. That proves that you are wrong. Shane was strong, but he brought the group in dangerous situations without thinking of the group. He was only thinking about Lori...he was selfish....Rick was smarter and Shane is dead because of his actions so you are wrong
@@dalelapointe9289 Rick did not became Shane because Rick went smarter than Shane and do you know why? Shane would have killed Negan after the war but Rick showed mercy and created peace among the commumitys. We both know that Shane was too angry and selfish for that so you are wrong. I have to admit that Rick learned alot from Shane but Rick never stepped in his footsteps. Rick is smarter and cares about every last one of them, even the saviors he gave a second chanse. And look what an empire he has build now. Shane was not capable to think further than just surviving and killing in the woods. And Daryl was always stronger than Shane and thats why Daryl is alive and Shane is dead lol. Shane got himself killed and for what. RICK IS THE BEST
Great Video I miss Shane.
Me to
Good as usual! I want a new "Shane Kills ...." with Gareth, or Joe or AlphaWolf ! :) It would be cool
shane 💖💖💖💕😍😍😍
Rick failed as a husband as father as leader and especially as a best friend.
Arnold Johnson Jr so it’s ricks fault shane fucked his wife ? 😲 . oh and it’s ricks fault carl went out of his way to help someone ? 😲.
I disagree. He could of abandoned them all and started a new life. He fought to come back to them and forgave Lori for messing around with Shane and getting pregnant. He never gave up and as much as I like Shane's character he was dangerous and Rick saw that. I have a lot of admiration for Rick and what he did to keep those safe around him.
Almost everyone ends up failing as those things if they are them in the first place in this apocalypse. Shane would have done worse. He’s stronger than Rick but he’s nuts and takes too many risks like Negan or The Governor
@@sam.lipchutz no shane was ahead of his time Rick isn't a bad leader but the point is at the time he was too soft I'm glad he finnaly got over his bs and now he does whatever is needed to be done
Wow !! Great work men!!!
Thank You for this video!
Hes a leader and a great substitute father. sadly he turned into a lunatic.
#22 is my number as well. Back in high school.
Dude 100 percent with u
Shane we need Shane back please please
If we r lucky Shane might still be alive !
Maybe there was an invisible dumpster
Dude Shane’s very dead I wish he wasn’t because he was my favorite character then Merle but Shane was stabbed by rick and it was all because of Whori oops I mean Lori see Shane was smart he knew what to do and I’m saying it’s Lori’s fault because Shane went to leave before they even got to the farm and she made him stay
@@BioZombie77 there joking do you not know what a joke is lol
I'll never over shane's death😭😭😭😭
Me too
If Lori died Rick and Shane would've been a super team but I don't know what would've happened with Daryl :(
M’ask yew sumthin, Rick.
I don't truly think Shane was wrong. I think did the best he could.
Shane is best leader
can someone please tell me what scene carol said at the beginning "Shane could of never of done that"
When will there be more videos
soon :)
I really liked shane, before he went a little crazy. But he was too cold and too hostile to outsiders. I know that you have to be very suspicious of strangers in a apocalypse, but he would always go straight for killing the stranger. I think that's a road that leads to the way the governor was, killing everyone you met and taking their stuff. Rick has gotten very ruthless and dark at times, but he was a good person to start with so he could be brought back. Rick was pushed to being ruthless, you can't bring someone out of that when that's how they started in this world
He also didn't seem like he really cared for anyone in the group other than lori and carl. I think he would have be okay letting anyone else in the group die if he could survive with those two. Shane also had not sense of other people's feelings. I think if he had killed rick and led the group he would have killed or pushed everyone else away. After the walkers invaded the farm he probably wouldn't have waited for rest of them, he would have taken carl and Lori and been the first one to go when he saw the herd.
I would really have liked to see him stay as rick's right hand man. He was a damn good shot, shooting teacher, and he was good at keeping people organized or in line (for a lack of better words). He had the original camp somewhat organized, despite the people in it and the fact that they were strangers. And after Sophie went missing he made sure to keep the other people workingff to keep them from having the time to be worried.
la neta chidos vídeos grandes tributos a shane
Si we la neta
Carol is wrong. She must've forgotten that when Rick was still in the hospital she was traveling with the group when Shane was the leader. I think if Shane killed Rick, at that point he wouldn't care about the group other than him, Carl and Lori. So at that point he wouldn't care if anyone else died he would just keep them safe. But if Shane didn't go psycho and Rick never woke up, then Shane would've led the group to safety many times and he wouldnt have even crossed Negan and the Saviors because he would be far East.
Shane was ready to leave everybody tho
well , what is one supossed to do if he risks his life and gets the group away from danger for months only to be dropped off for some guy that is delusional
they were painting him as the enemy and its their fault he had to die !
U got to think if he had an argument with Rick then tried to kill him he'd do it again
And Rick never learned.
💕💕💕💕❤️❤️❤️❤️😘😘😘😘😘
Everyone is commenting they want Shane back. He had more potential not being Shane. And admit it, he would've been dead by Negan. And when Lori died, he would go insane like Rick did, but Shane would go crazy and go killing people. He would've died by The Governor and the attack. So stop commenting you guys want him back he had more potential not being in The Walking Dead
Nope cause he was not smart..Shane should wanna kill him on his own..Rick is so much better than Shane
Actually Shane would of killed the Governor pretty quickly he was a marksman easy kill for Shane. Now for Negan that might of been different because the reason Negan pick Abarham was because of his size and will against him he never quivered when Negan killed him. Yet there is a chance Shane wouldn't of even got caught when Rick took off with Maggie he might of hung back and protected the camp like always. Shane would then still been a live when they came back and told him what happen then who knows what would of happen because Rick was stronger with Shane !
Shane was good but he did go a little crazy but I think if he was stel alive he would of been a great leader I believe that .......
Shane could of done that
Don’t lye y’all if Shane survived past season 2 he would of died to negan
Shane can be the best leader in the show not rick
Yes
Carol is wrong. She must've forgotten that when Rick was still in the hospital she was traveling with the group when Shane was the leader. I think if Shane killed Rick, at that point he wouldn't care about the group other than him, Carl and Lori. So at that point he wouldn't care if anyone else died he would just keep them safe. But if Shane didn't go psycho and Rick never woke up, then Shane would've led the group to safety many times and he wouldnt have even crossed Negan and the Saviors because he would be far East.