Yo Rocko! I just started coin collecting, like 4 days ago, sry for my noobness. You prefaced this video something like “The definitive video to answer finally answer the question, should you clean your coins or not… .” I agree 100%, . To me, I figured out the answer about half way through. I need to develop my coin restoration skills to the max. You see, 4 days ago I didn’t know what a proofs were or what uncirculated meant, but I pretty sure I do now. Look, let me try to put this in perspective. I get the same impression from you in this video and other big-time coin collectors. You guys are spending 10,000 a year if not more just on getting coins graded let alone buying and selling coins you have all the ins and outs And access to all the best coins. All the uncirculated proof coin sets you have so many of them you can even sacrifice 15 coins to this video. It’s not much of a risk if all you gotta do is make 15 coins that look totally brand new and keep them looking brand by going through the motions of washing a dirty coin. Hell, one of the procedures MS 70 is specifically designed for the coin industry and seems to be accepted as a staple from all the old timers , with a simple 3-4 step process should always work if followed perfectly, you would think. Even made the pennies look brand new again. Anyways, I get the impression that when you guys go to send in a batch of cards to get graded, you’ve already went through probably twice as many coins to make that batch. I don’t know I’m gonna look up more videos but if you’re worried about your coins, getting crappy grades, houses even possible for anything that’s been rattling around in a pocket all day have a chance at getting a MS grade even a low one.
The MS 70 seemed to work the best but those darn milk spots are just a pain. Good luck with the grading , can't wait to see. Thanks for sharing and have a great day.
Holy rollercoaster of emotions, Batman! I was so nervous…..when you were counting down the dip time, I couldn’t look! My heart broke right along with yours over that penny 😢 The suspense was killing me on every clean that you did! Now I can’t wait to see how they will grade!I I admire your courage. THANK YOU for risking your coins, giving your time, spending your money to have them graded, and THEN sharing this with us! #Respect
There's a difference between cleaning and conservation. The major grading services do some of these procedures for restoration services, they just like to make extra money.
Well in my opinion they call it restoration just so they can clean it and say it isn’t lol. It’s really just “controlled cleaning.” Since they are the “professionals” and can do it in a controlled environment. Part of this order has already been completed and I’m looking forward to the results video.
Ezest protocol, get a plastic basket to dip your coins in the solution with then rinse in distilled water and immediately submerge into acetone to ensure there are no water spots.
Just catching this and certainly interested in "testoring" some coins I have. Would you suggest rinsing after acetone? I have seen numerous videos where they did just that. ?? Thx.
Good idea but turns out that lightly dragging it doesn’t cause any damage to the coin. Since this video I’ve done it dozens of times and never gotten a details grade
Hi Rocky, im praying you get a good result. This is by far the most suspenseful and terrifying video i've ever seen!!! I've downloaded it and plan to watch it every Holloween from now on. If you love coins this will make you recoil in HORROR!!!! I actually screamed at one point! again Thank you for the info.
I’m a mechanic and I’ve used a cleaning supply called new finish aluminum polish cleaner try it let me know what you think it comes with very soft cotton compound
Thanks! I was told by someone else to use distilled because the companies can detect fluoride from city water but I live rural and have a cistern so maybe that’s why I didn’t get caught.
I bought my first 2 one once silver coins a month ago. They are from the perth myth and legends collection. I was unaware that you should not handle coins with your bare hands, and took one of them out of the protector. Because of this, it turned slightly yellow compared to the other one I didn't touch. Is there any way I can reverse this yellowing without ruining the coin? Any help is appreciated 😅
my go to for cleaning is several steps, works great for silver anyway and pretty good for copper, CLR mixed with some water to dilute it some, then rinse in Lemon Juice and final rinse in plain water and DAWN ( just a few drops of Dawn. ) works great and last submission I sent to ANACS I got a 64 which was what I suspected I'd get.
Rocky I love watching you do all this crazy shit that supposedly SHOULD NEVER BE DONE! And you do it! I just ordered everything you use. Thanks a million Rocky!
Thanks so much! The world is filled with narratives that just aren’t true. I run into it with my job all the time and it drives me nuts. Best of luck to you!
Don’t you think the speckled was from the rag when you was tapping down to dry ? I’ve heard of people blow drying them right after the rinse and not tapping dry with anything
I’m not sure which part of the video you’re referring to. If it’s those white spots, those are milk spots. I’m not sure what causes it but it happens to a lot of those old silver coins
@@rockysramblings you said after the dip all the coins looked grainy and I think that happened when you padded them down , I’ve heard people blow drying them after the dip and rinse to avoid any surface contact Even soft cloth can put a mark on it
Very Cool I will be doing some cleaning , the E Zest seems like it is a little shiny compared to the MS70. But I'm glad i watched your video . Id clean more coins for PCGS . Thanks for sharing and have a Great Day
Thanks for doing the experiment. A properly conserved coin is absolutely allowed and can be graded. An improperly conserved coin will be called cleaned. There is no one best solution as the different metals call for different treatment. Ezest is great for silver, but I wouldn't use in on copper or nickel. Acetone is always safe but is very limited in what it can do. All three are different. Ezest is an acid -- MS70 is an alkaline -- Acetone is neutral. For copper I find Coin Care to be the safest, it is not very aggressive. Looking forward to the results. Cheers!
Works fine as was shown in vid. You just want to dip in in it's own jar or pour some out just for copper. It will come out pinkish as that is what they look like before stamping. Just leave it out for a few days to come back to normal color.@@don951
I have become a master at turning those Benji's into cameos. All you need is wax to cover the fields, and a very fine medium in a soda blaster. Probably took me 50 coins to master but haven't gotten a details or damaged grade after I got good.
@@rockysramblings I'm not really a video guy but it's easy to explain. Melted wax to cover the fields. A thin coat will do. Then grab the finest medium you can find for your soda blaster and start practicing frosting those devices. Heat gun to remove the wax when done. It takes a lot of practice so be prepared to ruin a lot of coins. Once you get it down they're indistinguishable from true cameos.
Hi buddy. I used to work recently on aircraft engine components, and we used acetone sometimes to remove wax and one chemical we used that was better than acetone, especially at removing milk spots and toning, which was called Evolve. Hope this helps as I'm sure it might do a better job as carefully removing marks
Also, I wasn’t going to do any “conservating” below extra fine because if you have an older coin that is G we’re VF and it is shiny and bright, then they’re just gonna conclude that it was cleaned. Do you have any thoughts on that?
I had a proof set with a blue edge or strip my Grandfather gave me along time ago. I opened it and found a couple finger prints on them. And I know they wernt feom me, cause I only tounched the rims. I don't have it any more but I got one in change that looks like those I had opened. Wonder what its worth.
I have all ready experimented with some of that stuff. On copper. The Acetone didn't work for me. The pennies were really dirty. And how long do safely soak them.? I didn't want to rub them. I just soaked them for a few minutes. Washed in dish soap.
Gotta be careful with Pennie’s. I think MS70 is the best at removing gunk. However I soaked an old Indian head that was beautiful for over an hour and it ended up removing what must have been soft spots in the metal and pock marked it pretty bad. Copper is a whole other animal. So far I have no issues with silver and soaking a coin. I only dip in EZest for 5 seconds. No more, no second dip. It can remove the luster.
I know little about this, but I’ve seen several posts regarding cleaning coins that’s not detected by firms like PCGS…my only thought is, if it becomes common, couldn’t Firms like PCGS simply devise a way to detect the presence of those chemicals used?
Possibly. But if the price of detecting it becomes more than what people are willing to pay then it’s not really feasible. I would imagine to detect it after being rinsed thoroughly it would require some pretty intense chemistry.
Yes. I rinsed in water each time. However I have been told water with fluoride can be detected. I have a cistern so there is no fluoride in my water. You may want to used distilled water.
I see a lot of pitting in the field of the coins now, I really couldn't see it in the camera before you did the dip in the E-zest, but it really came out afterwards.
Rocky, thank you so much for the test. I know it was a little while ago and I’ve watched it twice. In your opinion, what is the best solution for copper? What is the best solution for nickel? What is the best solution for 90% Silver/Clad? I think I’m going to do a little bit of “cleaning“ this weekend Before a large submission to ANACS. Thanks, Joe
I like ms70 the best. However don’t let it soak old copper too long. I had a beautiful Indian cent and soaked it for an hour and it pitted. For nickel and silver a quick dip in eZest brings out the shine.
You don't drop coins in especially if you have dipped a few coins already as the sediment on the bottom as well as your fishing around can harm the coin. There is a drop well to put the coin on and just submerge or even a plastic tongs. Also never dip different metals in the same jar. Copper will come out real pinkish so best to leave out a few days to get back some color.
Others were telling me to use the basket but I had no basket included. I didn’t mean to drop the first one. 😅 good advice on the moving of metals but it didn’t effect my grade surprisingly. I thought for sure I’d get details on it.
You could have saved yourself a lot of money just asking those that have experience. Dipping 1 time other than the fact that it looks too good (no toning) won't get details as under glass you have not affected the finish. I have seen Indian pennies come back non graded because of questionable color. I sent in a barber half dipped but let it tone back a bit before sending it because it was too white for 120 years old. Now if someone is dumb and dips it again it will make the surface etch as it is an acid and will give it a steel dull look. Great content but kinda pricey for cheap proofs just to get a lesser grade company to put in plastic. @@rockysramblings
Thank you so much for doing this I wanted to see if alcohol would do anything to it or hydrogen peroxide too but its ok. Could you possibly do a video explaining on if it damages idk if you have i formation on that or not
Thank you i did try it on both hydrogen isnt good on pennies i used a coin that’s worth nothing and alcohol is great on both just like you said with the acetone it didn’t do anything to the penny either so thats good.
The quarter that you hit with the MS70, wouldn't it be interesting if you discovered a new coin category distinction of Proof CAM on just the IN GOD WE TRUST? It would be cool to have witnessed it, however long after this was originally filmed.
In test 3 with the ms70, on the benji, could see some hairline scratches from rubbing those milk spots too aggressively, think that will be a dead giveaway to the graders it was cleaned but we’ll see..
It may have been die polishing marks. I was looking for marks from cleaning as I did them with my loop and I wasn’t seeing them but I could be wrong. We will see when they come back I guess.
I make sure to dry immediately. I have heard that pcgs can detect fluoride in the water. I use a cistern so maybe that’s why ANACS didn’t catch it or maybe they don’t have the same ability as pcgs. Or maybe that’s not true. I think it would be wise to use distilled water, but since I get away with it, I continue to use the tap water.
So basically what you're saying is that a lot of coins come right out of the mint with polishing marks already on them. So how is that take away from the value when that is original.
Because part of the grade is eye appeal. If you can find one without polishing marks and a great strike etc, that’s more likely to get a higher grade. MS70 is the goal of every coin geek
???? I can see "dopping" a toned coin but these I would never consider. The term cleaning denotes polish,friction, as opposed to liquid. Also what do you have here that is zinc??? You have silver, copper and nickel.
I don’t recall saying I was doing a zinc but I remember I was considering doing it, but after I saw what it did to the penny I figured it would be a waste of money. So if I said it and didn’t do it that’s why. Guess I didn’t edit that out.
I found a best way of cleaning coins without liquids. Oils and dirt can be removed easily by placing the coins in cornflour and leave them to allow the oils to be absorbed by the cornflour. From minutes to days depending upon how much dirt has accumulated. No need to rub just blow off the cornflour.
After EZest I wash in boiling hot gentle non chemical dish soap and distilled water. Then I use a hair dryer. I don't use distilled water for junk silver. No water marks this way.
Seems to me the acetone does some things, and the M 70 does others, why don't you do them in acetone and then in M 70 and you might get the best of both worlds
It’s not a fair test, because you are taking perfect coins without natural aging and even wear. That is the big question, can you take a dirty 1850 coin and make it dirt free and give it some luster without removing aging.
My intention was to see if the cleaning solutions and the cleaning process would be detectable by the grading company. So cleaning near flawless coins is ideal because if any marks or imperfections from cleaning happens they would be the most detectable on a proof coin.
Answer: No. Nor should you try. If you do, you will destroy the coin and no collector will buy it from you because it has been damaged due to improper cleaning by morons who don’t know what the hell they are doing. Leave the restoration work to proper conservationist services that know what can be restored and how and who also know when to leave a coin alone.
Those coins can never be replaced. The surviving population of non-fucked with specimens of 1961 proof coins just went down again so some fool could get more views on a YT video. Disgusting…..
Here is a something that you are not actually using that is easy safe and there is one other one that is actually created for use for dental teeth porcelain veneers and stuff and they even use Coins as testing for what does to the metals and be amazed what they found out and they use it matter of fact both of them two different ones to preserve and stuff and anyone is able to actually purchase it
Why would anyone clean perfectly preserved coins? They didn't need cleaning at all. And, it doesn't show that if these techniques actually remove tarnish etc.
Corrosive To Metals, Category 1 Skin Corrosion/Irritation, Category 1B Serious Eye Damage/Eye Irritation, Category 1 kleen. Acetone should only be fingernail polish remover. Careful of the things you use indoors
"Ugly" toning should never mark a coin down in grade. (Exception is MS-70 because thats not allowed any toning.) Good toning could mark up but bad shouldnt knock down. That's a BS opinion influencing something that ought to be objective. Some people find certain toners ugly that I find beautiful.
Results Video: Cleaned coins grading results! Can you avoid details grades?
ua-cam.com/video/UIPhBPLipY4/v-deo.html
Thank you for this link. Usually if I see the first part of a 2 part video, there's no link to the second. They forgot to do it.
Yo Rocko! I just started coin collecting, like 4 days ago, sry for my noobness. You prefaced this video something like “The definitive video to answer finally answer the question, should you clean your coins or not… .” I agree 100%, . To me, I figured out the answer about half way through. I need to develop my coin restoration skills to the max. You see, 4 days ago I didn’t know what a proofs were or what uncirculated meant, but I pretty sure I do now. Look, let me try to put this in perspective. I get the same impression from you in this video and other big-time coin collectors. You guys are spending 10,000 a year if not more just on getting coins graded let alone buying and selling coins you have all the ins and outs And access to all the best coins. All the uncirculated proof coin sets you have so many of them you can even sacrifice 15 coins to this video. It’s not much of a risk if all you gotta do is make 15 coins that look totally brand new and keep them looking brand by going through the motions of washing a dirty coin. Hell, one of the procedures MS 70 is specifically designed for the coin industry and seems to be accepted as a staple from all the old timers , with a simple 3-4 step process should always work if followed perfectly, you would think. Even made the pennies look brand new again. Anyways, I get the impression that when you guys go to send in a batch of cards to get graded, you’ve already went through probably twice as many coins to make that batch. I don’t know I’m gonna look up more videos but if you’re worried about your coins, getting crappy grades, houses even possible for anything that’s been rattling around in a pocket all day have a chance at getting a MS grade even a low one.
The MS 70 seemed to work the best but those darn milk spots are just a pain. Good luck with the grading , can't wait to see. Thanks for sharing and have a great day.
Thanks. I’m looking forward to it too!
Milk spots won't come out no matter what you do.
@@bl7121 I can believe that .
Big balls of fire! Glad you made this video and added all the details. Cheers
Thanks for watching!
Milk spots are attributable to improperly washed/rinsed planchets. They become part of the coin and can not be removed.
That's a bummer. Just wondered how or what they were. Thanks.
I can remove some milk spots. A few coins I'm still working on that are almost gone.
very bold. it takes your kind to help those of us with no guts. thnx
Thanks. But all I did was have the idea and ability to test it 🤷🏼♂️
Holy rollercoaster of emotions, Batman!
I was so nervous…..when you were counting down the dip time, I couldn’t look!
My heart broke right along with yours over that penny 😢
The suspense was killing me on every clean that you did!
Now I can’t wait to see how they will grade!I
I admire your courage.
THANK YOU for risking your coins, giving your time, spending your money to have them graded, and THEN sharing this with us!
#Respect
Thank you! Here are the results!
Cleaned coins grading results! Can you avoid details grades?
ua-cam.com/video/UIPhBPLipY4/v-deo.html
I just cleaned a Morgan dollar with silver polish and vigorous brushing with a tooth brush. It was heavily tarnished and now it isn't. Thoughts?
That would probably be labeled as cleaned. Does it still have luster and the cart wheel? I would imagine they’ll be able to see the scrubbing marks.
@@rockysramblings I can't say for sure about the cartwheel. I probably wouldn't have cleaned it if I had known about this beforehand.
E zest works well on silver but not copper. Thanks for doing the coin dipping testing.
Thanks for watching!
There's a difference between cleaning and conservation. The major grading services do some of these procedures for restoration services, they just like to make extra money.
Well in my opinion they call it restoration just so they can clean it and say it isn’t lol. It’s really just “controlled cleaning.” Since they are the “professionals” and can do it in a controlled environment. Part of this order has already been completed and I’m looking forward to the results video.
What's the difference besides the person doing it?
Ezest protocol, get a plastic basket to dip your coins in the solution with then rinse in distilled water and immediately submerge into acetone to ensure there are no water spots.
Just catching this and certainly interested in "testoring" some coins I have. Would you suggest rinsing after acetone? I have seen numerous videos where they did just that. ?? Thx.
@@1011Shke nope, just pat dry straight out of the acetone.
👍🏻
Don't pat dry... hair dryer on high. Much safer!!
@@1011Shke I do final rinse business strike coins in lots of distilled water.
If you were to put the q-tip in the end of a straw it would probably make it easier to roll back and forth without any dragging or tension on the coin
Good idea but turns out that lightly dragging it doesn’t cause any damage to the coin. Since this video I’ve done it dozens of times and never gotten a details grade
Hi Rocky, im praying you get a good result. This is by far the most suspenseful and terrifying video i've ever seen!!! I've downloaded it and plan to watch it every Holloween from now on. If you love coins this will make you recoil in HORROR!!!! I actually screamed at one point! again Thank you for the info.
😂😂 Glad you enjoyed it! Results coming soon!
I’m a mechanic and I’ve used a cleaning supply called new finish aluminum polish cleaner try it let me know what you think it comes with very soft cotton compound
Got a brand?
Yes it’s called nevr-dull by eagle one u can buy at and parts store I got mine at Napa lmk what you think if u try it thank you for your time bud
I bought a pair of wooden tongs to hold the coins when I dunk them. Works great.
I use plastic tongs and grab the coin by the edges
Update please! Thank you, for these experiments and videos.
Coming soon! Waiting for the last batch to get graded and returned
Best to use distilled water to rinse. Great video, thank you!!
Thanks! I was told by someone else to use distilled because the companies can detect fluoride from city water but I live rural and have a cistern so maybe that’s why I didn’t get caught.
This makes me want to fiddle around with my proof sets lol. Great video
Thank you! But before you do that let’s wait for the results. I’d hate for you to ruin your proofs if this doesn’t work 😅
I bought my first 2 one once silver coins a month ago. They are from the perth myth and legends collection. I was unaware that you should not handle coins with your bare hands, and took one of them out of the protector. Because of this, it turned slightly yellow compared to the other one I didn't touch. Is there any way I can reverse this yellowing without ruining the coin? Any help is appreciated 😅
I’d try the EZest dip first. If that doesn’t work you could try the ms70
@@rockysramblings thanks for the advice
my go to for cleaning is several steps, works great for silver anyway and pretty good for copper, CLR mixed with some water to dilute it some, then rinse in Lemon Juice and final rinse in plain water and DAWN ( just a few drops of Dawn. ) works great and last submission I sent to ANACS I got a 64 which was what I suspected I'd get.
You’re braver than me. I worry about strong chemicals and acids. Even eZest scared me but it passed the test still. 🤷🏼♂️
Rocky I love watching you do all this crazy shit that supposedly SHOULD NEVER BE DONE! And you do it! I just ordered everything you use. Thanks a million Rocky!
Thanks so much! The world is filled with narratives that just aren’t true. I run into it with my job all the time and it drives me nuts. Best of luck to you!
Got a follow up video for these coming soon?
Yes. Hopefully within the next couple weeks. Maybe even this weekend but it’s going to be tight.
Great Thanks, a small tip, when you apply the cleaning liquid on it on a cotton bud, don't roll the bud, thenbu can see the black dirt on the bud
Can you tell me what the name of the product was that was pink? Thanks.
MS70
@rockysramblings my ms70 i ordered is clear
So, did the E Z Est etch your stainless steel sink like it did mine?
I didn’t get it on the sink and when I rinsed the coins I made sure to use plenty of water cuz I figured it may have an effect.
Thoughts on ultrasonic coin cleaning.
Haven’t tried it
@rockysramblings regardless you had great results.
In 5 mins into this video and loving every second of it. Thankyou
what do u do if you have overdone it and its lost its lustre
Unfortunately there’s nothing you can do. It won’t get a straight grade
Don’t you think the speckled was from the rag when you was tapping down to dry ? I’ve heard of people blow drying them right after the rinse and not tapping dry with anything
I’m not sure which part of the video you’re referring to. If it’s those white spots, those are milk spots. I’m not sure what causes it but it happens to a lot of those old silver coins
@@rockysramblings you said after the dip all the coins looked grainy and I think that happened when you padded them down , I’ve heard people blow drying them after the dip and rinse to avoid any surface contact Even soft cloth can put a mark on it
Don't you blow on it as you will see spots later from your moisture spittle. Blowing air from a can seems to work well:)
Very Cool I will be doing some cleaning , the E Zest seems like it is a little shiny compared to the MS70. But I'm glad i watched your video . Id clean more coins for PCGS . Thanks for sharing and have a Great Day
Thanks. My personal favorite is the MS70. Ive cleaned many and haven’t had any issues yet. The eZest scares me just cuz it’s so powerful.
Thanks for doing the experiment. A properly conserved coin is absolutely allowed and can be graded. An improperly conserved coin will be called cleaned. There is no one best solution as the different metals call for different treatment. Ezest is great for silver, but I wouldn't use in on copper or nickel. Acetone is always safe but is very limited in what it can do. All three are different. Ezest is an acid -- MS70 is an alkaline -- Acetone is neutral. For copper I find Coin Care to be the safest, it is not very aggressive. Looking forward to the results. Cheers!
I would agree, you can use dip for copper but never mix with silver as the silver can transfer to the copper coin. Copper will come out ugly pink.
@@RobertLee-wi5kc I would never recommend dipping copper. Not good.
Works fine as was shown in vid. You just want to dip in in it's own jar or pour some out just for copper. It will come out pinkish as that is what they look like before stamping. Just leave it out for a few days to come back to normal color.@@don951
First time seeing any of your videos. I immediately recognized you used the same audio for your transition edit as Rob Finds Treasure channel.
It’s one of the transitions from iMovie. There’s no intention behind it. 🤷🏼♂️
I have become a master at turning those Benji's into cameos. All you need is wax to cover the fields, and a very fine medium in a soda blaster. Probably took me 50 coins to master but haven't gotten a details or damaged grade after I got good.
I’d be interested to see your process
@@rockysramblings I'm not really a video guy but it's easy to explain. Melted wax to cover the fields. A thin coat will do. Then grab the finest medium you can find for your soda blaster and start practicing frosting those devices. Heat gun to remove the wax when done. It takes a lot of practice so be prepared to ruin a lot of coins. Once you get it down they're indistinguishable from true cameos.
ChapStick black and a cotton swab And whatever Madge used for dishes. Old cotton baby diapers dry well. No bleach residue
Hi buddy. I used to work recently on aircraft engine components, and we used acetone sometimes to remove wax and one chemical we used that was better than acetone, especially at removing milk spots and toning, which was called Evolve. Hope this helps as I'm sure it might do a better job as carefully removing marks
Also, I wasn’t going to do any “conservating” below extra fine because if you have an older coin that is G we’re VF and it is shiny and bright, then they’re just gonna conclude that it was cleaned. Do you have any thoughts on that?
Thanks for the tips going to try some on my type sets 👍
No problem 👍 Don’t push too hard. A little pressure is ok.
I love new ideas! Thank you for sharing ❤
What happened to part 2? I don't see you ever posted it?
I Cleaned Valuable Coins & Sent them to PCGS - Results!
ua-cam.com/video/LwnBnXF-N7A/v-deo.html
I had a proof set with a blue edge or strip my Grandfather gave me along time ago. I opened it and found a couple finger prints on them. And I know they wernt feom me, cause I only tounched the rims. I don't have it any more but I got one in change that looks like those I had opened. Wonder what its worth.
I have all ready experimented with some of that stuff. On copper. The Acetone didn't work for me. The pennies were really dirty. And how long do safely soak them.? I didn't want to rub them. I just soaked them for a few minutes. Washed in dish soap.
Gotta be careful with Pennie’s. I think MS70 is the best at removing gunk. However I soaked an old Indian head that was beautiful for over an hour and it ended up removing what must have been soft spots in the metal and pock marked it pretty bad. Copper is a whole other animal. So far I have no issues with silver and soaking a coin. I only dip in EZest for 5 seconds. No more, no second dip. It can remove the luster.
Nice demo😊
Thank you!
I know little about this, but I’ve seen several posts regarding cleaning coins that’s not detected by firms like PCGS…my only thought is, if it becomes common, couldn’t Firms like PCGS simply devise a way to detect the presence of those chemicals used?
Possibly. But if the price of detecting it becomes more than what people are willing to pay then it’s not really feasible. I would imagine to detect it after being rinsed thoroughly it would require some pretty intense chemistry.
Did you rise the coin after using acetone?
Yes. I rinsed in water each time. However I have been told water with fluoride can be detected. I have a cistern so there is no fluoride in my water. You may want to used distilled water.
I see a lot of pitting in the field of the coins now, I really couldn't see it in the camera before you did the dip in the E-zest, but it really came out afterwards.
The ezest is definitely the most aggressive cleaner
Conserv safe and bu plus is the actual real two that used for two different purposes
Follow up video?!
Thanks for sharing!
Coming soon!
Rocky, thank you so much for the test. I know it was a little while ago and I’ve watched it twice. In your opinion, what is the best solution for copper? What is the best solution for nickel? What is the best solution for 90% Silver/Clad?
I think I’m going to do a little bit of “cleaning“ this weekend Before a large submission to ANACS.
Thanks, Joe
I like ms70 the best. However don’t let it soak old copper too long. I had a beautiful Indian cent and soaked it for an hour and it pitted. For nickel and silver a quick dip in eZest brings out the shine.
You don't drop coins in especially if you have dipped a few coins already as the sediment on the bottom as well as your fishing around can harm the coin. There is a drop well to put the coin on and just submerge or even a plastic tongs. Also never dip different metals in the same jar. Copper will come out real pinkish so best to leave out a few days to get back some color.
Others were telling me to use the basket but I had no basket included. I didn’t mean to drop the first one. 😅 good advice on the moving of metals but it didn’t effect my grade surprisingly. I thought for sure I’d get details on it.
You could have saved yourself a lot of money just asking those that have experience. Dipping 1 time other than the fact that it looks too good (no toning) won't get details as under glass you have not affected the finish. I have seen Indian pennies come back non graded because of questionable color. I sent in a barber half dipped but let it tone back a bit before sending it because it was too white for 120 years old. Now if someone is dumb and dips it again it will make the surface etch as it is an acid and will give it a steel dull look. Great content but kinda pricey for cheap proofs just to get a lesser grade company to put in plastic. @@rockysramblings
Is this a re-upload? I thought we already saw pt. 1
Yes. Sorry. I had a copyright claim on the last video.
Leftover Covid hand gels were usually 50 to 70% Ethanol and are great for cleaning both metals and plastics.
Go for it!
Thank you so much for doing this I wanted to see if alcohol would do anything to it or hydrogen peroxide too but its ok. Could you possibly do a video explaining on if it damages idk if you have i formation on that or not
Well I don’t think alcohol would hurt it. I think it’s similar to the acetone. HP, I’m not sure. Thanks for watching!
Thank you i did try it on both hydrogen isnt good on pennies i used a coin that’s worth nothing and alcohol is great on both just like you said with the acetone it didn’t do anything to the penny either so thats good.
What's the update on this video? I wanted to see the results
Been busy with work and kids being in summer break made it difficult to find silence to film. I’m gonna have it out soon. Stay tuned!
Looking forward to it Rocky. I have the same keen interest on a few coins I'd like to clean and submit.
I can almost tell all you cleaned . But been at this since 1979. Hope it works out.
I have the results video out.
The quarter that you hit with the MS70, wouldn't it be interesting if you discovered a new coin category distinction of Proof CAM on just the IN GOD WE TRUST? It would be cool to have witnessed it, however long after this was originally filmed.
With the EZ Est You didn't harm any of your silver coins, they were polished prior to you getting them.
Grading Results are coming soon
In test 3 with the ms70, on the benji, could see some hairline scratches from rubbing those milk spots too aggressively, think that will be a dead giveaway to the graders it was cleaned but we’ll see..
It may have been die polishing marks. I was looking for marks from cleaning as I did them with my loop and I wasn’t seeing them but I could be wrong. We will see when they come back I guess.
@@rockysramblings thanks for running this experiment, looks like ms70 is the winner in most cases, what would you say?
@@esurfrider7687 I think so too. But the final judge is the grading companies so fingers crossed!
You should’ve submitted a 4th set that no improvement were attempted, so as to have a control group.
Can I clean with hot water?
I rinse with warm water
I hear distilled water is a better rinse to avoid spotting.
I make sure to dry immediately. I have heard that pcgs can detect fluoride in the water. I use a cistern so maybe that’s why ANACS didn’t catch it or maybe they don’t have the same ability as pcgs. Or maybe that’s not true. I think it would be wise to use distilled water, but since I get away with it, I continue to use the tap water.
IS this the same video you already posted a while back??
Yeah sorry. The last one had copyright claims
yea right, try it with pcgs,or even ngc,that's what i really wanna see
I intend to
So basically what you're saying is that a lot of coins come right out of the mint with polishing marks already on them. So how is that take away from the value when that is original.
Because part of the grade is eye appeal. If you can find one without polishing marks and a great strike etc, that’s more likely to get a higher grade. MS70 is the goal of every coin geek
???? I can see "dopping" a toned coin but these I would never consider. The term cleaning denotes polish,friction, as opposed to liquid. Also what do you have here that is zinc??? You have silver, copper and nickel.
I don’t recall saying I was doing a zinc but I remember I was considering doing it, but after I saw what it did to the penny I figured it would be a waste of money. So if I said it and didn’t do it that’s why. Guess I didn’t edit that out.
I use any kind of hot sauce the spicier the better, and it is excellent for cleaning tarnish from any type of coins or jewelry.
I found a best way of cleaning coins without liquids. Oils and dirt can be removed easily by placing the coins in cornflour and leave them to allow the oils to be absorbed by the cornflour. From minutes to days depending upon how much dirt has accumulated. No need to rub just blow off the cornflour.
That’s interesting. Perhaps I’ll have to give it a try
@@rockysramblings I’m happy with the results.
So where is Part 2?
Coming soon. I’m a little tied up with work right now.
After EZest I wash in boiling hot gentle non chemical dish soap and distilled water. Then I use a hair dryer. I don't use distilled water for junk silver. No water marks this way.
I used MS70 on modern (gold tone) dollars… turned them dark… almost purple… ruined. Failed experiment.
Haven’t tried it on them. Thanks for the warning
I think they’re manganese coated
Why are you cleaning perfectly shiny coins?
Open your ears. It’s an experiment
Seems to me the acetone does some things, and the M 70 does others, why don't you do them in acetone and then in M 70 and you might get the best of both worlds
I have tried that with some circulated coins
It’s not a fair test, because you are taking perfect coins without natural aging and even wear. That is the big question, can you take a dirty 1850 coin and make it dirt free and give it some luster without removing aging.
My intention was to see if the cleaning solutions and the cleaning process would be detectable by the grading company. So cleaning near flawless coins is ideal because if any marks or imperfections from cleaning happens they would be the most detectable on a proof coin.
Answer: No. Nor should you try. If you do, you will destroy the coin and no collector will buy it from you because it has been damaged due to improper cleaning by morons who don’t know what the hell they are doing. Leave the restoration work to proper conservationist services that know what can be restored and how and who also know when to leave a coin alone.
@@marianmoses9604 morons like me I guess who can restore them without damaging them. 🤷🏼♂️
Scratching and wear are the two major factors in grading shiny is a much less a factor.
Yes but my purpose for doing the experiment was to see if any scratching could be detected from cleaning them.
Good lord ! They had you pull it again ? That has to be frustrating.
Lol yeah. It was annoying. I wanted to be more detailed but without music it was kinda boring so I chopped what I could
That was with the E- zest
Gently roll qtip w ms70. No rubbing. Milk spots are permanent
Great video. But I’m glad you did that and not me. I would have needed CPR.
much rather see already opened sets sitting around this taking coins with no problems sealed from the mint and giving them problems
It’s an experiment
Those coins can never be replaced. The surviving population of non-fucked with specimens of 1961 proof coins just went down again so some fool could get more views on a YT video. Disgusting…..
I buy those uncleaned roman coins so I am always looking for a better way to clean without damaging them.
Here is a something that you are not actually using that is easy safe and there is one other one that is actually created for use for dental teeth porcelain veneers and stuff and they even use Coins as testing for what does to the metals and be amazed what they found out and they use it matter of fact both of them two different ones to preserve and stuff and anyone is able to actually purchase it
Damn it's so difficult to read comments when they don't use punctuation
What is it called?
@@rockysramblings conserv safe and bu plus two that are what is used in the conservation of cleaning and and best use a jewelry brush for it.
They use ultrasonic cleaners too
I drop em directly into a bowl of distilled water and swish em around and then rinse w falling RO water
Since the results of this came back positive I’ve become an MS70 fan. I use it often and haven’t gotten a details grade yet.
Yes speckles was not going to say it but yes
Thanks
No problem
Why would anyone clean perfectly preserved coins? They didn't need cleaning at all. And, it doesn't show that if these techniques actually remove tarnish etc.
It’s a test to see if cleaning them with these cleaners will be detected by the grading company
Corrosive To Metals, Category 1
Skin Corrosion/Irritation, Category 1B
Serious Eye Damage/Eye Irritation, Category 1 kleen. Acetone should only be fingernail polish remover. Careful of the things you use indoors
I have coins that are hundreds of years old and coin shops tell me that are not worth anything
They are right
Ola jaumah 1 set
I don’t know what you said but thank you for commenting!
Make sure you rinse that stainless steel sink out cuz it's going to clean it and make funny black spots in your stainless
ms70 sucks on copper turns pink
I haven’t had any issues with ms70 on copper but EZest seemed to change the color. Check out my results video.
Mint sets not proof sets
?
"oh crap" drops it down the drain "oh 🤬" a grain of sand can hide a mountain (if in your eyes) or scratch a surface. Marble mechanic.
Corrosive To Metals, Category 1
Skin Corrosion/Irritation, Category 1B
Serious Eye Damage/Eye Irritation, Category 1
if i had a $10,000 coin - i probably wouldn't clean it ... if i had those state quarters - id probably clean them
@@markhellman-pn3hn yeah that’s probably a safe route. I have cleaned coins worth thousands tho and avoided details grades. I made a video about it
How dare you gamble with money? In a totally different way than most of the population, lol.
😈
I see some difference
TWO Denture cleaning tablets will clean a copper penny without changing color, perfectly let sit overnight.
Have they graded tho?
"Ugly" toning should never mark a coin down in grade. (Exception is MS-70 because thats not allowed any toning.) Good toning could mark up but bad shouldnt knock down. That's a BS opinion influencing something that ought to be objective. Some people find certain toners ugly that I find beautiful.
The subjectivity of grading is an issue imo. I’m not a fan of AI but I can think in coin grading it could be helpful. Take out the human subjectivity.
@@rockysramblings 100% Human graders aren't the best option in these days of technology
Using tap water is a mistake. Using your kitchen sick is sacrilegious.
But it worked 🤷🏼♂️
YooHoo!... Wear Gloves!!!
Not necessary