The Ukraine FACTS The West Doesn't Want To Hear | With Nicolai Petro, Ruslan Kotsaba, and A. Duleba.
Вставка
- Опубліковано 12 гру 2023
- Listen to a radio broadcast too "controversial" for (West-)European ears.
(** POST-PUBLICATION INFO : Due to a technical error, the very last sentence of Dr. Petro's voice was cut from the video. He ends his explanation by saying "That's what I see the tragedy of Ukraine being." [min. 24:16] **)
A few days ago, Jonathan McCormick, the producer and narrator of this program contacted me saying that as a freelance journalist, he had produced a broadcast about the roots of the Ukraine War, which his usual outlet, Radio Slovakia International, refused to air. He was given various reasons but the bottom line is that the story was simply too controversial given the prevailing political mood in the country and in the West more generally.
Jonathan reached out to me if I wanted to publish it and sure I do, because he created a wonderful short radio piece featuring three interesting personalities:
Ruslan Kotsaba, a Ukrainian journalist and pacifist who some years ago was imprisoned in Ukraine for his peace activism and now lives in exile in Brooklyn.
Then, for the sake of balance, he asked for comment from Slovakia's foremost 'Russia expert', Alexander Duleba, whom he had interviewed a number of times before.
Last but not least, he also got extensive comments from a good friend of this show, Nicolai Petro, who’s a Professor of Political Science at Rhode Island University.
What seems to have made this piece too controversial for the Europeans was simply that Jonathan approached the story like a real journalist, trying to find answers and not to conform the story to a pre-determined narrative.
The fact that the pacifist Kotsaba was persecuted by the Ukrainian government speaks volume.
Kotsaba is a Nazi himself: he was the director of the Bandera Museum (Hitler's collaborator). He found himself in the opposition because after the coup in 2014 he did not get a monetary place in the new ruling elite. That's all: he was left without money and was offended by it.
Professor Duleba is lying. The Russian language is prohibited not only in all official spheres, but also in cultural ones. Russian culture is completely banned in several regions of Ukraine, including Tchaikovsky, Tolstoy, Dostoevsky, Rachmaninov, etc. Let Duleba study the law of language properly.
Pushkin, Dostoyevsky, Tolstoy, and practically all other giants of Russian literature (including Ukrainian Nikolai Gogol, who wrote in Russian, as there was no pre-existing country-state of "Ukraine") have all been officially branded as "propagandists" by the Kiev regime, and their works banned, with millions of books destroyed, as being a mere "propaganda". Not literature, mind you, but "imperialist propaganda". One wonders whatever has happened to the Ukraine's pride and glory, the National Bard, Tara's Shevchenko's prose: while composing his poetry in Ukrainian, his choice of language when writing prose was Russian.
This is a consequence of the war that Russia started.
This is false. Ukraina law prohibits only russian music/books which is produced materially in the enemy state of Russia. You can freely import russian music litterature produced in Germany or Poland. It's Russia which exterminate all traces of ukrainean culture in occupied regions, and even kidnap ukrainean children for forced adoptions. War crimes.
@@user-lx2oe9zs4q How reasonable is it to say that a child has been _kidnapped_ from an orphanage so that it can grow up in a somewhat notmal family? Are those kids the property of the Ukrainian state?
Doleba lze kdyz tiskne
As a foreigner who lived in Ukraine I can support the facts that public sector staff, including restaurants, refused to speak in Russian language to me, despite the fact that many could not speak English and that was the only common language we could use to communicate. I lost count of the number of arguments I had with them about this(as I remember many of them even one month before this new law were happily talking in Russian to me!!) , and the number of times I told them that nothing good will come of this illogical prejudice behaviour
What's not logical about this? It's the same mechanism as when an African colony doesn't want to speak French.
Russia has regularly committed genocide in history Ukraine so that they do not speak their own language, even though Ukraine's history has had a different course than Moscow's.
@@comment2462yeah. You’ve been stuck in the 90’s unlike other counties in the interim
@@comment2462 Ukraine as a part of Russia (USSR) had population 52 million and before 2014 ,then became an independent state, ---- how many 38-40 million. Historically Ukraine SSR appeared thanks to the Russian Bolsheviks and later as a state to Russian nationalist ,before Ukrainian territory was always part of other states.
@@comment2462Your comparison with Africa is wrong. Ukraine had been a part of Russia until 1991, Ukrainians and Russians are genetically identical.
How Ukraine is not considered amongst the most racist counties is beyond me.
Ukraine is. So are Baltic states and Scandinavian countries.
@@hk3339Scandinavian countries mainly In their deranged russophobia. Other than that, they seem to love 3rd world people just walking In from every corner of the world. So they Don't seem to care much about "the White".
Americans say they are against racists, but on top of that, Americans are against Russians.
That is, a racist who is against the Russians, is totally fine to a good liberal mind American.
Because of the large amount of fascist and nazis in Ukraine.
They are NATO attack dogs. An owner would not disparage their dog, especially if it does the things the owner likes.
Thank you so much. Im Ukrainian, a Russian speaking Ukrainian.
In Spain, 6 different languages (Castilian, Catalan, Basque, Valetian, Galician and Aranese) and about 20 local dialects are officially recognized and protected by law, including the language of the Gypsy people. Personally, I am satisfied and proud to share this valuable and diverse cultural treasure with my compatriots.
Yes! international "experts" simply knowingly lie in your face.
Queen Isabella would be pleased lol
@@jeremygardner5987 I don't know about Queen Elizabeth, but the International Brigades would surely be.
No less than 75 languages are recognized as ' languages of France, the top3 are French,Occitan and German.
25 official languages beside Russian en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Languages_of_Russia#Official_languages
Western hostility towards Russia continued even after Russia had accepted normalization and ended the Cold War.
Why should a Soviet focused organization (NATO) have been kept alive after the Soviet Union and Russia had been stripped off its Western buffer space. Militarizing that in-your-face space was obviously a chilling threat for Russia. And one must commend Russia for patiently accepting NATO, *until* with NATOfication of Ukraine, Western missiles could be stationed 3 mins from Moscow.. in Sumy and Chernhiv.
Note how in a similar position the US had a neurotic attack when missiles had been stationed in Cuba in 1962.
The use of Military Threats to promote economic effects has been a hallmark of Capitalism.
As the Western Powers lose their power to extort resources from the former Colonies, the need to increase the level of threats appear to increase?
Looking at the economic status of the G-7, who all had their own Empires at some time, the effect of their Colonies trading with each other appears to have caused some dramatic economic effects.
Their "Supply Chain" seems to have stopped delivering Tribute to the Empires?
Russia trying to justify invading and annexing their neighbours territory. 🙄
Not only missiles: you forgot about the 36 Pentagon biological laboratories on the territory of Ukraine. The existence of which Victoria Nuland admitted in Congress.
Let me guess: Duleba believes the division of Czechoslovakia along ethnic and cultural lines was a very good thing, but he balks at the division of Ukraine along similar cultural and ethnic lines? As they say about people like him: if they didn't have double-standards, they wouldn't have any standards at all.
Because Duleba doesnt speak about Ukraine at all. He speaks about Slovak internal politics, where there is the 600.000 ethnic hungarians, whom he wants to be silenced under the same nazi BS what he tries to use on the Ukraine case. He simply supports Ukraines illiberal policies, because thats exactly what Slovakia is doing to its minorities.
This is not an " illiberal " policy. This is racist genocidal self destructive crap. To all of those lost souls who believe that denial is a river in Egypt Victoria Bondarenko Tsareva offers her would famous tour of SF and the Peninsula. Don't be scared- my world famous tour of the Tenderloin is not included.
@@gaborrajnai6213So I guess according to him, it is perfectly fine for Slovakia to split from Czechia for language and cultural reasons, but when Hungarians want to preserve their language and culture on their ancestral lands, they can’t do that? Hypocrisy much?
He not only balks at the division of Ukraine, but the also balks at the prospect of Ukrainian Federalization. It is important to note that if they would have federalized 10 years ago and set up a system akin to the one in Canada, there would be no war and Crimea would still be part of Ukraine. Because if the Russian-speakers’ rights were respected and protected under the law, there would be no desire for them to split off and join Russia.
This is why the Quebec independence movement isn’t as lively as it was before. Simply because most French Canadians are fine with the status quo when it comes to their language and culture. The same could be said for Swedish-Finns. But if Canada were to ban French and Finland were to ban Swedish, do you really expect the people in those areas to just sit there and go along with it?
@@gaborrajnai6213 - Ukraine government today practices rather totalitarian politics rather than liberal ones. All the labels seems to be confused nowadays.
This is my own research, feel free to disagree.
Nazi war criminals were almost never put on trial for their crimes, but instead were installed in top positions in NATO, in the western German government, army, industry and western German society at large.
The most famous of them was Adolf Heusinger, chief of the Operationsabteilung from 1940-1944.
He was actually Hitler's chief of staff and helped plan the Nazi’s invasions of Poland, Norway, Denmark, and France. He was promoted to colonel on August 1, 1940 and became chief of the Operationsabteilung in October 1940.
After the war, this German war criminal, the man who helped Hitler plan and execute his invasion of neighboring countries which directly led to the deaths of millions of people, was not even put on trial, quite contrary he was allowed to take over the newly established West German army, the "Bundeswehr".
In 1961, Heusinger was made the Chairman of the NATO Military Committee (essentially he was NATO's chief of staff). He served in that capacity until 1964.
General Hans Speidel, a Nazi general who was Erwin Rommel’s chief of staff during WWII. After the war he served in the Western German army and became the Supreme Commander of NATO’s ground forces in Central Europe from 1957-1963.
Johannes Steinhoff, Luftwaffe fighter pilot during WWII and recipient of the Knights Cross of the Iron across (the Nazi military’s highest award), was Chairman of the NATO Military Committee 1971-1974 (among other NATO positions beforehand).
Johann von Kielmansegg, General Staff officer to the High Command of the Wehrmacht 1942-1944, was NATO's Commander in Chief of Allied Forces Central Europe 1967-1968.
Ernst Ferber, a Major in the Wehrmacht and group leader of the organizational department of the Supreme Command of the Army (Wehrmacht) from 1943-1945 and recipient of the Iron Cross 1st Class, was NATO's Commander in Chief of Allied Forces Central Europe from 1973-1975.
Karl Schnell, battery chief in the Western campaign in 1940/later First General Staff Officer of the LXXVI Panzer Corps in 1944 and recipient of the Iron Cross 2nd Class, was NATO's Commander in Chief of Allied Forces Central Europe from 1975-1977.
Franz Joseph Schulze, a Lieutenant in the reserve and Chief of the 3rd Battery of the Flak Storm Regiment 241 and recipient of the Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross in 1944, was NATO's Commander in Chief of Allied Forces Central Europe from 1977-1979.
Ferdinand von Senger und Etterlin; Lieutenant of 24th Panzer Division in the German 6th Army, participant in the Battle of Stalingrad, adjutant to Army High Command, and recipient of the German Cross in gold, was NATO's Commander in Chief of Allied Forces Central Europe 1979-1983.
There were at least two dozens such former Nazi high level officers in NATO’s ranking.
United States senator Harry S. Truman's statement in 1941 regarding the invasion of the Soviet Union by Nazi Germany and its allies, Italy, Hungary, Finland, and Romania: "If we see that Germany is winning, we ought to help Russia, and if Russia is winning we ought to help Germany, and that way let them kill as many as possible.” As soon as Germany was defeated, Russia immediately became the new enemy of the ruling class in Washington and London.
Before the war started in 2022, even major mainstream media like BBC and VICE reported the alarming rise of Nazism in Ukraine with Nazi militias like the Right Sector, the C14 and the Azov Battalion. Those documentaries are still available on UA-cam:
“Ukraine's far-right children's camp” - by The Guardian
“Inside A White Supremacist Militia in
Ukraine” - by TIME
“Neo-Nazi threat in new Ukraine” - by BBC Newsnight
Here’s the result in the UN General Assembly [Anti-Nazism Resolution] in 2021.
Vote: 130-2. Against: America, Ukraine.
See the picture?
Some people said this proxy war in Ukraine against Russia started in 2022. Some people said it started in 2014 after the US orchestrated the Maidan coup and shelling of ethnic Russian in Donbas. Some people said it started in Bucharest in 2008, after NATO chief Jaap de Hoop Scheffer openly said he would like Georgia and Ukraine to join NATO. Some people said it started after 1991 because Victoria Nuland said the US spent 5 Billion dollars since 1991 to put Ukraine in that position (to counter Russia). But as explained by former US Marine Corps officer Carlton Meyer on his channel “Tales of the American Empire”, it started right after WW II.
What is the best tool to fight Russia? Nazis.
Good list of examples...
Awesome painstaking documentation. Western hostility towards Russia never ended with the end of the Cold War. 👌
Why should a Soviet focused organization have been kept alive after the Soviet Union and Russia had been stripped off its Western buffer space. Militarizing that in-your-face space was obviously a chiing threat for Russia. And one must commend Russia for patiently accepting NATO, *until* with NATOfication of Ukraine, Western missiles could be stationed 3 mins from Moscow.. in Sumy and Chernhiv.
Note how in a similar position the US had a neurotic attack when missiles had been stationed in Cuba in 1962.
This is an awesome explanation of "after the battle"...I didn't realize the prevalence of all those guys in German politics after the war. I did notice just about everybody in Europe involved with this ukraine fiasco had soldiers in the waffen SS. The summer offensive seems on par with "operation citadel".
Remind us how many Russian war criminals have been put on trial for their crimes.
@@iriemon1796 A number of Soviet soldiers were tried and executed on the orders of Soviet Army command for crimes against the civilian population of Germany in 1945. Naimark, Norman M. (1995). The Russians in Germany: A History of the Soviet Zone of Occupation, 1945-1949. Cambridge: Belknap. p. 92. ISBN 0-674-78405-7. Need more reminders?
War for me began back in 2014. When national batallions like Donbass, Aidar, Above and etc. Came in our town. They were out of law organizations with AK. They could seize and torture people and police couldn't do anything. That's why we rebelled
Same for russian backed Girkin battalions, no? Im just making sure that both sides are recognized accordingly
@@leonbishop7404 no, you are making sure that naming streets after bandera is justified
@@grdev3066 what
@@leonbishop7404
LOL... THE NAZI WAS FIRST AND THE SELF DEFENCE BATALLIONS BORN AFTER THE MASIVE BOMBARDEMENTS ORDERED BY BIDEN
@@leonbishop7404no not the same, not even close 😮
In Finland we have this party of the Swedish speaking Finns, they get about 4,5% of the votes, which represents their size of the whole population, and so we have two official languages They say it's such an enriching thing to have two official languages, but their Party leader Anna-Maja Henriksson is firmly all against two official languages in Ukraine! She insists on this. So it's only enriching here...for them.. in no way in Ukraine .. go figure.. For all the Finnish speaking Finns it's mandatory to learn their language to be able to serve the Swedish speakers in public offices.
That is a wonderful example for several reasons. Shows how great 2 languages can get along, even if one is only a tiny minority AND how the entire Ukraine story has eaten up the brains of ppl who should know better. To explain this, we‘d need some reasonable psychological theory, I suppose, of why ppl become completely devoid of (strategic) empathy for other circumstances that should be clear to them-but isn‘t.
the answer to this paradox is simple imo, it's western russophobia
Outstanding. I especially liked Prof Petro’s remark “In an ideological world, you follow your fantasies.”
Ukrainian is a recognized language in Russia (where many Ukrainians live, incidentally). And it's protected by law, as are dozens of other languages. As for the French, Mr. Duleba, I don't recall them shelling their non-French speakers with artillery or attacking them with aircraft. Slovakia might consider finding a more qualified Russian/Ukrainian expert.
@@sergeyg436 It is exactly this perverse lying, that brought the ukrainians to the brink of self destruction. Pathetic and sad.
@@sergeyg436 "Didn't you know that the Ukrainian language, songs, and flags are banned in Russia now?"
Any reference?
@@sergeyg436 it is not 100% true. Yes, you can get to a police department if you’re sing pro UA war songs or you are wearing UA flags but you get there for explanations. It is the way to prevent any kind of conflict or terrorists attack. Ukrainian language is not prohibited in any point. But of course nowadays when the conflict is in the middle some people are overreacting to any possible threat (especially because of many terrorists attempt by SFU)
@@sergeyg436 "You can go to the jail for mentioning anything Ukrainian related" this is simply a lie. For example, there's a famous Ukrainian cuisine franchise "Taras Bulba" in Russia. It still successfully working in Russian. In particular one of their restaurants is happily operating 24/7 right in front of the Kremlin www.google.com/maps/place/Taras+Bulba/@55.750581,37.6101281,15z/data=!4m6!3m5!1s0x46b54a5b56c6cc03:0x94828ef7df5dfd73!8m2!3d55.750581!4d37.6101281!16s%2Fg%2F1th80m8p?entry=ttu
@@sergeyg436 literal BS.
That is the exact problem for the Hungarian minority in Transcarpathia. They had been imposed strict language laws. Furthermore the Kiev regime wants to eradicate Hungarian culture. The Hungarian names for city's was forbidden. Cultural monuments of fx writers, poets was vandalised by thugs showing up in the ethnic Hungarian city's. The same thugs harrassed the locals, of waving with flags with rightwing symbols. A Hungarian culturecenter was arsened. Local political leaders was added to the infamous kill list Myrotvorets. What's not to dislike for any democratic minded person?
I am perplexed that people outside of Ukraine can dismiss the issues that were present in places like Kherson and Odessa. I have been many times to Kherson and Odessa and there people who were raised speaking Russian first and Ukrainian second were made to feel uncomfortable to speak Russian in the street after 2014. That is a simple reality. Kiev is VERY different to Donbas, Kherson and Odessa. There are reports by Amnesty international and OSCE of kidnap, rape and murder of Ukrainians by the SBU (Ukraine secret police) which were presented to UN in 2016. These have been ignored and Amnesty International then withdrew from Ukraine. The country has become more fascist.
Also there are documented instances of people being killed in Ukraine simply for being accused of being a "Russian sympathiser" based on nothing other than filming the conflict and publishing that content. All information is censored, journalists jailed and tortured, and distributed now of press releases only through Kiev, churches closed and only one political party is allowed. Men cannot leave the country since 2021. There is no freedom in Ukraine and since 2014 when the US led coup took place the economy has been wrecked, just check the UAH exchange rate.
The CIA admissions of employing former Nazi Soldiers to promote Bandera sympathy since 1950, prove that the USA was dedicated to division in Ukraine.
The Area was the victim of just about every Empire that existed on this planet.
Now the US Empire attempts to extend the influence of Blackrock and all the other harmful Opportunists to profit from dividing up Ukraine Real estate and degrading Russian Influence in the Region.
The work of Victoria Nuland since she began to work for the Clinton Administration, indicates a clear trajectory that seemed to put Moscow in the crosshairs.
The ability to obtain Majority Investor Status was apparently stopped by Russian limitations of 30% of outside investment in Russian Assets.
So the effort to take Russian resources by force of military conquest, while on the surface seemed impossible, has proven to be a fact.
The employment of Saakashvili as Odessa Oblast Governor in 2014, was another use of a plainly willing CIA Stooge, after his willingness to invade South Ossettia proved the useful nature of someone who had been schooled in the USA.
The apparent lack of prosecution of the Thugs who were very visible at the Trade Union Fire, seemed to provide the backbone of the Azov Goons who were able to invade Mariupol in 2015.
The media coverage of Maidan Events clearly show Saakashvili working with Nuland to promote the Coup.
The events that appeared as the Russians began to free Mariupol showed just what type of thugs they became.
Survivors report atrocities by Azov Guys all over Mariupol as they were driven into Rinat Akhmetovs Steel Mill.
The intentions of the USA appear to implicate American State Department Officials as War Criminals.
The ignorance of the millions of former Soviet Soldiers who settled in Donbas after WW2 seems to have allowed the illusion of some single heritage in the Ukraine region.
The words of the Citizens of the region appaer to uncover the fact that there were a lot of Folks East of the Dniepro who were related to Russian Ancestors.
The use of the Name Artemivsk in reference to the use of the name Ukraine designated to Bachmut, was just one apparent indication of the heritage of the region.
The accurate targeting of Kyiv's Headquarters seems to suggest the Russian loyalty remains within the region.
The US State Department Lies do not erase the heritage.
Nearly everything you said is a lie. If anyone felt uncomfortable speaking Russian then that is on them. It has nothing to do with anything the government was doing. The osce did not document cases of tape and torture and murder and present them to the un. The country has not become more fascist. Their are hundreds of active political parties in Ukraine.
buddy we have no critical thinking in this world. I'll give you an example, Iran has been launching their own satelites into orbit since 2009. but because some authority doesn't announce that they have ICBM you have new media dolts on youtube like task and purpose make videos where they say with a straight face that they dont know when Iran will get ICBMs. Everyone with two braincells knows Iran has it since 2009. What is this? This is lack of critical thinking. No one knows how to think anymore. They have to be told everything.
Where are Gonzalo Lira and Oleg Novikov?
What rape, what killing people only because they speak Russian in Ukraine! ..Are you delirious!..Try harder to justify killing children in thousands in Ukraine! 🇺🇦😢Fascists! ..You are lying!!!Как сивый мерин!!!
Duleba sounds like he just woke up in Germany in 1935
Fascinating and really thought provoking interview. Thanks for sharing, Pascal. Shame on Slovak media for censoring it!
Very recently a very young boy was spotted singing a song by a famous Soviet singer Visotsky sonewhere in Lviv. And he got arrested, insulted, abused and threatened. Some government representative called him a traitor and told him he is a 3d class citizen. So the problem in Ukraine is very real.
The problem with Duleba’s position is that there is empirical evidence to the contrary, namely that 6-7 specific acts of legislation were passed that significantly restricted the use of Russian language in the media and official settings, one of which was so egregious that it was rescinded by Ukraine’s highest court. Even the EU courts, pre 24/02/22, admonished Ukraine over its language policy
We can pretend to be Stanford and Harvard Ph.Ds till the cows come home but it all comes down to this- how I feel about Spanish and my Mariachi bands and my Day of the Dead is my own frigging business! I have the right to decide just how much of Anglo and Mexican culture I want in my life! Not Aunt Jackie. Not the FBI. Not the Republican Party. Me! And that is the reason why the Ukrainian Donbass exploded but the Mexican States are still standing. And to those who're planning another " experiment "- don't even think about it! So NOT a good idea.
No wonder Ukraine "understands " Israel. Ukraine and Israel are striving for a homogeneous getto 😢 ( no pun attended). How this modern getto would have been different from the past getto. The entrance to the getto would be saying:
Ukraine only
Jews only.
Dilemma
Yes, this is part of the political/cultural background - but the geopolitical background is, first off, that the new Kiev elite (an elite cultivated and "paid" by the US) willingly accepted to let America use Ukraine as a battering ram against Russia. Both because Kiev thought it would offer them a quick victory, and because they reasoned that fighting a war on behalf of the US would catapult them inside NATO and the EU, would let them skip the long and tedious processes of membership negotiations, reforms, legal adaptation and so on that are normally entailed before a country (especially an impoverished and corrupt country like Ukraine) is allowed to join either of these two blocs. And ever since February 2022, Kiev has tried to claim, again and again, that "we really are a de facto member of NATO" or that it's a matter of historical justice that they must be allowed in: "you have no right to keep us out". Both Reznikov and Zelensky have been making those pitches so many times.
This is a verry educated comment as far as I understand the situation.
Well they can make pitches but they wont enter ever. The thank you letters should be sent to Orban, who stands up to their blackmailing.
@@gaborrajnai6213 Orban is completely right, but Kiev have been relying on support from the US and its clients & hangarounds to boost and push their claims through (the US is "the man behind the curtain" in EU/NATO politics).
Sounds like Duleba is closely related to Ukrainian Kuleba!
¡Excelente episodio! Muchas gracias por dar espacio al periodismo independiente, no propagandístico. Siempre sigo sus episodios, son una luz en medio de este período obscuro de la posverdad.
"As an Ukrainian you should be forced to learn Ukrainian"
So, tell me as a Swiss what shall I be forced to learn ?
I was taught French as I lived in the French speaking region - and German, but not even Swiss-German, no, we were taught hochdeutsch, as used in Germany...
We have 3 national languages, in every region everything is written in the 3 languages. Buy some orange juice and you can learn from reading description in those 3.
And now, we had so much immigration that more than 23% of people living here do not even have one of the official languages as a main language...
That "Duleba" is a political activist of the very dangerous kind.
A very simple technology that was done in Ukraine: they will make you a mixture of all these languages, distorting them as much as possible, then for a couple of generations they will tell you that you are the most special and most ancient race who lived in a civilized way even before the appearance of the Cro-Magnon man, and then came the barbaric, primitive tribes of French, Germans and others - occupied you, stole your civilization and culture, and rewrote your history. And everything is ready: they made Ukrainians out of you.
It’s literally like the Russians who populated these lands for 1035 years, since the baptism of Rus, were made into so-called “Ukrainians”.
Excellent! I missed a longer interview with Ruslan Kotsaba.
Thank you. Excellent program. Language laws in Ukraine make news sometimes, usually with banning something .
I ve just written an e mail to kuleba asking him:"How can you be an academic?".
I ve written that in Bolzano everywhere, schools,hospitals, public bureau, etc etc people can choose between german and italian... everything is written in italian and german.
I ve never heard so many silly words, I really can t comprendendo how this guy could be teaching at faculty of politica sciences
Even the German Nazis did not forbid speaking their native language. Many opposition leaders were killed in public. Thousands and thousands of people have been taken away by the security services and no one else knows what's wrong with them. Those who managed to escape from hell were lucky.
I live in Belgium, and we have 3 official languages. . . .because people who live in this area speak this language .....and of course there are some problems, but like always this problems are created by politiciens ((((, who hopes to make "profit" from the situation. . . and the victims are the normal citizens. . . ((((
But at the end, we can manage. .in Belgium, in Ukraine they has made this big mistake to block the Russian language. . . .under pressure from there USA "friends". . . .Like they say, be the anime of the USA is a bad thing, to be there friend is real "catastrophe" !!
Not only Russian: they ban both the Hungarian and Romanian languages, which are spoken in the Ukrainian territories bordering these countries.
Thanks for this information, i aw not knowing that .@@alexgainsborough4921
So Duleba wouldn't object if Slovak language was gradually aboilished in Czechoslovakia and he wouldn't feel "humiliated" if Slovak language was banned in schools because the capital of Czechoslovakia was Prague, not Bratislava? And he was called an "imperialist" for defending the rights of Slovak speakers he wouldn't feel offended?
Well its not just Russian. The new education laws in Ukraine make it near impossible for ethnic Hungarians in Tanscarpathia to undertake many (if any) high school subjects in their own language. So its not just about being bilingual. This has been one of the main drivers in the growing animosity between Budapest and Kyiv, and therefore a major roadblock for Ukraine's EU membership ambitions.
Ethno-Nationalism is toxic where ever it raises its ugly head. There just are no "pure" nation-states possible in Eurasia (and Africa, too, for that matter) if they are supposed to be larger than a few square kilometres because of the super high heterogeneity of its populations. Petro points that out strongly in his writings that the only viable solution for Ukraine (but it goes for other states too) is a civic Ukrainian identity, not a ethno-national one. Never mind the language or origins, everyone can be Ukrainian as long as they identify with the nation. That's how other multi-cultural and multi-lingual states work successfully, too.
As an Australian, with our liberal mult-ethnic society, I absolutely agree@@neutralitystudies
@@neutralitystudies I have noticed you often comment on this you tube channel. Can I urge that you to stop watching it. It is truly dreadful.
Well, the suppression of just the Russian language, which is, by the way, native to at least 70% of the Ukrainian people, wouldn't be a roadblock for the EU membership, would it? After all, Latvia and Estonia are both the EU members and both have been, and still are, discriminative against their Russian population and suppressing the Russia language for 30 years.
Well, let's add another roadblock to the roadblock party!
That's rich coming from a Slovak professor.
When the Slovaks had to fight for their language under Austrian Hungary. He would be for the Germanization of his people, culture.
And at that time there wasn't much of Slovak culture.
Disturbing to hear Petro say Russia's military operation is not justified, destroys his credibility as an analyst and reduces him to a data accumulator. Russia is not only doing the necessary thing, it is doing the right thing. For many academics and pols expressing that is a bridge too far.
History will show that in 2022 there was a rampant USA that had been marching around the globe for the previous 75 years causing mayhem while it's racist voting age citizens partied, bought houses, made $, watched TV, ignored their kids and complained about taxes. Then they messed with Russia, and Russia knocked them back on their heels like you do a schoolyard bully. This is heroic national behavior that should be lauded but apparently Petro can't wrap his mind around standing up to power. You are supposed to suffer the bully.
It's mind numbing how people who acknowledge US imperialism, acknowledge Ukrainian oppression of their own Russian people, acknowledge US malfeasance all over the world for decades, cannot dare to acknowledge the good Russia is accomplishing. They knocked out the German Nazis, now they are straightening out the US, both of whom were supposed to kick their butts. As a US citizen sick of waiting for my fellow Americans to stop our military adventures I absolutely applaud the Russians, for the good of my country.
Как человек, проживающий в Украине, могу вам ответить - не опладируйте русским. В России нищета, и большинство русских пошли воевать за деньги, по контракту. Россия бомбит те регионы, где больше всего русскоязычного населения. Ни целей войны, ни идеи, ни планов на будущее - ничего, со стороны России.
Where is my comment UA-cam??
@@peace_toyou, the problem is that new Ukrainian government is much worse than one in Russia. Furthermore, Russia came to Ukraine after horrible crimes and atrocities of Ukrainian nazi government against their own citizens in Donbass and Lugansk
@@Burgalo2001 Поверьте, я тоже так думала, пока не пообщалась с переселенцами с Донецка. Хотя, не исключаю, что вы просто "я русский"😉. Пропаганда шла с обеих сторон с 2014 года. Долго рассказывать, и у каждого есть право пребывать в своей иллюзии😉
I have counted at least 10 european countries with at least two official languages. What the hell is this guy from Slovakia talking about? In Switzerland 22% speak french and it is official language. Why is it such a big deal. I have a friend from eastern ukraine who got forcefully changed name from russian to ukrainian version. That is an example of humiliation and dehumanization that Ruslan was talking about. Imagine your name is George and someone changes it to Yuri just like that.
a simple non exclusive piece of research reveals more viz: Belgium
France
Luxembourg
Spain
Ireland
UK
Cyprus
Malta
Finland
Russia
Belarus
Germany
Switzerland
Denmark
Hungary
Netherlands
Sweden
Austria
@@georgesibley7152Note how the countries you listed are predominantly from Western Europe. Here’s just a small list the of post soviet countries, where only the “titular” language has the official status, despite having a major portion of their country from other minorities.
Latvia
Lithuania
Estonia
Ukraine
Moldova
Georgia
Despite large portion of former soviet citizens who lived, worked and remained in these countries who speak russian as the mother tongue the have been discriminated for their language, culture and state’s direct victim blaming them for supposed refusal of these people to integrate while disenfranchising of these people on government level.
@@valkyrie9553 All f which are ex soviet union countries , which accounts for their dislike of Russian. I note you omit Poland and other non soviet dominated countries. However . i responded to this statement " have counted at least 10 european countries with at least two official languages" by the original author.
What a lie.George is Hryhorij and not Yurij.
@@welena1739 that was an example, was not giving actual names in that case, but thx for pointing it out
Everyone should consider Ukrainian conflict from all sides, including hidden. As Elon Mask said: "Zelensky is a butcher", and he was right, wasn't?. Thank you 👍🏻
Putin is a butcher. Agree?
? 13:29 Nie wiedziałem że Ukraińcy wymordowali Rosjan w buczy i bombardujac rosyjski kijow odesse i lwów. Pragnę zaznaczyć że moskwa jako trzeci Rzym chce wziąść pod opiekę europe. . Syria też należy się Rosji bo z tego kraju przyszła wiara chrześcijańską do Rosji. Rosja słusznie uważa? Ze kraje słabsze i mniejsze powinny zostać pod panowaniem silnych państw z atomowkami.. Rosja ma misję dziejów i musi panować nad jak największym terenem. A to co słyszę tu wśród widzów chcecie pokoju tracąc honor i zasady. Stracicie honor i zasady A i tak bedziecie mieć wojne.l Rosja planuje , jak poczytajcie ruskich to będziecie wiedzieć, zdobyc europe. Nie pozwolić im na samodzielne rządy. Rosja będzie się rozwijać i nastąpi dobrobyt w rosjikosztem innych narodów...
Zelenskyy appears to be Victoria Nuland's Sock Puppet.....
@@danielhutchinson6604 Zelensky President who was elected with a result of 73%.
@@vitaliyt8571 Trump was a President who achieved Election because of assistance from the Robert mercer Marketing group, apparently was not re-elected in 2020 as the Mercer group apparently did not represent Trump.
Elections are a multi billion dollar business.
Why do you suppose Mercer quit His Day Job?
Zelenskyy was elected by the marketing,
the input of Citizens was not so much of an element as the marketing.
The US Investors bought Zelenskyy the job.
As a Ukrainian which is raised in South-Eastern part of Ukraine, I have a couple of arguments for Alexander Duleba:
- I was studying in Russian class at school. I had x2 times more Russian lessons than of Ukrainian.
- I voted 2 times for president election programme that asserted Russian language as the official language of the state. The demand for Russian language to be recognized was tremendous.
- I was working at high school in admission commitee of university. This was the time when the Ukrainian government accepted the law to make Russian language only accepted in some regions of Ukraine. It was allowed to accept documents for university application in Russian. However, it didnt happen. There was bureaucracy to avoid such cases.
- I had 2 friends which were killed (or detained) by Ukrainian nationalist in the 2nd of May on 2014. All of them wanted to have Russian language as an official one.
Very many Russian speaking people resorted to supporting Russia not because people dream of Stalin or Putin. Ukrainians didnt want to provide the respect and rights for us to speak our own language. If Ukrainians had accepted Russian language as an official one, the war wouldnt have happened. Putin wouldnt have got any argument to "defend Russian speakers".
This is not the main reason though it's one of
Your identification of Stalin with Putin is inappropriate. They are completely different people and political leaders. Although personally I respect both of them. And yeah, for a Russian speakers you understand the reasons for this conflict quite poorly.
@@MrDY888 Mentioning of Stalin and Putin is just a hyperbole to make an anti-thesis for Western media.
Calling my understanding `poor` is a bold move from your side. However, the burden of justification lies on you to prove that.
Let's say, in 2003 I received quite a strange gift - the book given by NATO officer which described the structure of organization. I clearly remember NATO ships and military drills in Ukraine with NATO soliders.
@@lilhatik yep, this is just a social-culture perspective, there're others. Western Ukrainians have got a loads of things to say as well.
Ukraine REPRESSES the Greek Minority (150.000!) who were living in the area before Ukraine even existed! They also repress the Hungarian minority.
China has recognized ethnic groups that has protected status. Like the Uyghurs. Which means their culture, language and religion are all protected, and must be allowed to be taught in school and freely practiced. Yes Uyghur children are taught both their mother tongue and Mandarin Chinese which is necessary for them to participate in the country's economy.
The boogeyman of the west literally has more rights than their darling.
Bravo and thank you professor Petro. Nice to know there are brave people like Ruslan Kotsaba. Will someone ever stop this madness? Can't we just all be respectful humans and get alone with each other no matter color of skin, no matter nationality and origins? This world would be a much better place then. And, yes, wars don't resolve issues. Look at the Balkans, they still hate each other. Talking to each other and compromising is a much better solution.
If you study the economic effects that created the conflicts, you begin to notice a thread.
The Western nations have run out of resources.
The Communist ones appear to have retained a lot of essential elements.
When we view those effects we begin to discover what might be motivating the Masters at War?
Sayangnya umat manusia sudah menjadi terlalu busuk dan tidak dapat dikembalikan lagi.
great to hear in-depth about the language issue and the Ukraine authority's desire, since Maidan, to become a monolithic nationalistic and illiberal democracy
This is fascinating! Thank you for the education!
Welcome! Thanks for the support!
@@neutralitystudiesDreaful you tube channel.
@@SirWilliamDeHooton Typical Russian, telling other people what to do. Well in the hated West we have freedom. As long as this dreadful you tube channel exists I will mock it.
i think ukr should have peacefully split in 1990s along the language line like checkslovakia.but west interests didn't allow it but in yugoslavia wests interests allowed the countries to split up.
I think this is what is going to happen now.
Ruslan Kotsaba is native western Ukrainian. He was born in Ivano-Frankivs'k region which is the most nationalistic region along with Lviv's oblast of Ukraine. In spite of the fact of his origin he is the most adequately thinking dude from the west I know. I don't understand how come you invited another guy from Slovakia to have second opinion about the situation in Ukraine. Do you think he knows better than Ukrainian about it? Yeah... Right. You're trying to convey the same western propaganda here. Russians are evil and Ukrainians (western puppets) are all victims. They are just heavily brainwashed for 30+ years by their governments that's all. It will take time to get back to normal for Ukrainians.
You are unfair. It’s good to present another view, reflecting true Ukrainian nationalism, especially in such an inept way . So people should know exactly what it means in practice.
@@vulgarisopinio Both of you forget that several times in history the Ukraianian language was suppressed by the Russian Empire, Even under the soviet Union as part of the Russification program it was banned, so too in the polish part of Ukraine.. Also towns and cities were originally settled by Ukrainian settlers and not Russian, after their conquest Russian immigrants were brought in. There is always some truth behind the Nationalist ideas, Though it is true that apart from a few ultra nationalists in the west both Russian and Ukrainian speakers got along well prior to 2014.
Even after 2014 the two breakaway republics simply wanted more autonomy. their referenda were not about breaking away,
@@georgesibley7152
Not true that "towns and cities were originally settled by Ukrainian settlers". It was Lenin who joined mostly Russian areas south and east from Odessa to Kharkov line, to the newly created Soviet republic and imposed forced ukrainization.
@@georgesibley7152utterly wrong. Ukrainian language was the language af peasants. When Lenin attached industrial cluster of donbass, Bolsheviks started the program of ukrainisation. Also Bolsheviks created literature pattern of Ukrainian language, supported book printing of contemporary Ukrainian writers.
@@georgesibley7152also, most of the cities of eastern, central and southern ukraine were founded by Russian empire while wars with Crimea and Osmans. Older cities are part of both russian and ukrainian legacy.
There is no "Ukrainian" Language!
The Galichan Mova is NOT "Ukrainian". It is a tiny minority dialect, which is native to Galicia and was imposed by decree of the Supreme Soviet of Ukraine in 1989. They have been replacing the native language of Ukraine since 1989, on purpose, to create a new artificial nation.
The presence of Saakashvili in Odessa as the beating of burning bodies falling from the Trade Union Building Fare seemed to get dramatic coverage in media, now is forgotten.
Saakashvili standing alongside Victoria Nuland in Maidan Square passing out Candy and Guns seemed to imply that Victoria was not promoting peaceful transition in Ukraine, any more than her effects aywhere in the Balkans in the last 30 years.
This Conflict is all Hers, the credit as well as the War Crime Indictments are deserved to be applied to Her as she represents the wishes of Wall Street.
The Western Media appear to need to be seated alongside Her as she answers for what she has done.
Then we can start to discuss what to do with wealthy Capitalists everywhere.....
Я рад, что кто-то в ЕС начинает хотя бы задавать вопросы.
Similar thing happened in Croatia in 1990s. Serbian language and script was subdued because the Croatian politicians used it to divide Croatian citizens against each other. It’s a shame.
What an intelligent man - the professor. Speaks about facts. Compared to this “expert” who says “if you were using Russian language your whole life, but cannot decide to abandon your own language because the state tells you so - you are imprerialist”
This slovakian guy is funny.
Didn't Slovakia split from Czeckoslovakia because they felt subdued by the Czechs?
Czechoslovakia was once called Bohemia. Western portion were western Slavs and eastern portion was eastern Slavs. There has always been minor tribal differences in that part of Europe for centuries.
The same what happened in Latvia
One of the main reasons of the conflict: after USSR collapsed - Ukraine has got regions that has absolutely no relation to the "ukranian etnos" - eastern and southern provices were never speaking urkanian language, or has identified themselves with ukranial culture. For 30 years the curse for urkanization of these provices took place and after american inspired "maidan" in 2014 (see JFK interview to Tucker Carlson for example) where usa officals pay 500000000 to enspire coup de etat in ukrain - the "ukranazation" of these provices intensifies, that causes a civil war, where all current 'actors' got their roles, Russia on one side, Usa and its colonies on another...
There is one very strong point that the West tends not to see. What lessons did Soviet leaders learn from the German invasion of the USSR? The lesson was very simple: that the war could start "out of the blue" for some reasons not connected directly with you or your policy. For several months the Soviets registered German concentrations at their borders combined with utter diplomatic silence. There were no demands or grievances said. Simply inexorable movement of troops to Soviet borders. From the Putin's point of view he sees exactly this: an inexorable movement of the new and new NATO bases to Russian borders. The situation of a boiled frog. Now everyone in the west very conveniently tends to forget that right before the invasion there were security talks between Putin and NATO, and NATO refused to make any even smallest concession. What Putin demanded from Ukraine? Neutrality status. Absence of any NATO bases. He got only categorical refusal as a response. Hence his reaction. It may be considered foolish, clumsy or even idiotic. But you can't say it's totally unfounded. And the West knew exactly what it was doing. No doubts.
Great episode. Thank you!
Duleba is lying. I belong to the Russian-speaking Greek minority of Mariupol (by the way, do you know that this city as well as 26 villages on the coast of the Azov Sea and the Don Basin (DonBass) were founded by the Greeks who came from Crimea after the Russo-Turkish wars? It was Catherine 2 who bequeathed them these lands of the Russian Empire around 1776). During the USSR, Ukrainian lessons - language and literature - were compulsory at school. It wasn't easy for us children, whose parents spoke local Greek and Russian, but we learned it, considering it as an additional asset. And we sang Ukrainian folk songs, and we danced Gopak...
After the Maidan of 2014 they banned teaching in Russian in schools. They forbade children to speak Russian - their native language! - even during recess. You realize? [Can you imagine a coup d'état, let's say..... Corsican (or Breton, or else, whatever ) in Paris after which French children will no longer be able to study in French but in Corsican, Breton or other ??? ] And they displayed the portraits of Bandera and Shukhevich in the hall of MY school on the board honoring "prominent politicians of Ukraine." Disgusting. For 9 years my compatriots lived heads down and mouths shut. It is now finished. Mariupol is back home.
Thank you, that was a very well produced and presented program.
In Czechoslovakia, the Czechs should have cleansed the Slovak language, culture. 👍
As a Ukrainian, I really appreciate how deeply Nikolai Petro studied the issue. He did not stop at the surface and did not repeat Ukrainian propaganda, but he did not repeat Russian propaganda either. This language issue is a real problem. Recently there was a scandal when a Ukrainian teacher accused the soldiers of speaking Russian... they just told her to f*** *** and society supported them. This is a good sign.
Because those Russian Loyalists are protecting her sorry behind.
It's amazing to hear about imperialism of people who lived on those territories for centuries.
In Italy we are not the best democracy in the world but in any case in regions where there are multiple languages in schools the use of different languages is allowed even during lessons. For example, in Trentino Alto Adige you can speak at school and even hold lessons in three languages: Italian, German and Ladin. It is not the language that makes the cultural identity of a nation!
The problem is that one of the language has the name of the country and the other has the name of the next one. Can we imagine Belgium with one of the two language labeled as "true Belgian" and the other as "invader language". It's the case in Ukraine.
Most countries have more than 1 official language . In Canada we have 2 English and French despite the Majority of people speaking English wevhave engish Schools and french schools and nobody is forced to learn either language .Basic french is compulsary up to and including 9th grade but after that its completely optional
Despite there being only 2 official languages many public institutions including finiancial and Goverment institutions offer services and severla different languages including Spanish Arabic Hindu and Mandarin and in some regions Nigerian and Somali .
Why not Inuit, Lakota, and Iroquois?
I dont see what is so controversial about this podcast and why Slovakian media refused to broadcast it. This is promoting a greater understanding of an issue that most of us barely appreciate.
Thank you for bringing this journalism to your platform!
What argument is that, France? What about Belgium, Switzerland? Two, three languages, so?
Phenomenal piece Pascal.
That Slovak professor would be for the cleansing of Slovak language and culture in Austrian Hungary. 👌
England tried to make all Welsh people speak English Thankfully now Welsh is spoken widely in Wales as it should If England can do it so can Ukraine
His location shouldn't have been revealed in my opinion.
Excellent show. I got it straight now.
Причину конфликта прекрасно разъяснил Сеймур Херш, так же терракты на газовых потоках. Нам сейчас уже и так понятно, как раскрутили маховик вражды, с помощью Украины, нашли шестёрку...на днях Арестович назвал запад гнилью, так оно и есть. Прекрасно помню как в начале 90- х на наших огромных оборонных предприятиях, в отдельных кабинетах сидели американцы и следили, чтобы по-быстрее вместо технологичного оружия начали делать кастрюли. Улыбались, жали руки, называли друзьями, Ельцин кричал : Боже храни омерику.. Переобулись быстро.
Truth is the first casualty in wars
Just to remind - there are 37 official languages in Russia. Because Russia has made an absolutely tremendous improvement in understanding and accepting its rich cultural heritage. Ukraine is similar - its a multicultural country however its doing the opposite and is trying very hard to become a monoculture and monolanguage country. Lets take Crimea - since Russians took over Crimea back in 2014 they made Tatar language the official language equal to Russian and Ukrainian. This pacified any cultural issues in Crimea and in fact, improved the relationship between the different groups of people. Ukrainians have never done that and have no interest in doing that.
No to Naziukropnato....🤗❤️🇷🇺👍.
Mr. Duleba is a great intellectual disappointment. He should not resort to lies. He also knows nothing about geopolitics.
Great.... thank you
Doluba is simply not an academic. In fact I am tempted to refer to him as an idiot 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Thank you for posting.
"Zelensky is from the eastern part of Ukraine! Hi cant do bad things to the east of Ukraine!" - great argument (not). Lets not go in to any details - his from the east therefore his good.
Great interview
The government is the SERVANT of the people not the other way round so the government has to provide services in all major languages to promote and persuade the voting population of the validity of its policies to ensure they get re-elected. There's no way Ukraine would be allowed to join the EU with the approach outline in the video.
Zelensky is a Joker !!
@@raulnicolaueffgen5655 Putin made the situation far worse by ordering the murder of so many civilians and massively increasing the pre-existing hatred. Pretty much what the Israelis are doing now. All parties will pay for that and round we go again. Morons the lot of them.
Herzlichen Glückwunsch zum Geburtstag! Many happy returns of the day, Pascal! Have a wonderful year ahead and keep up the good work. 🎂🎉🎊🎁 It is still Dec 13 in the USA!
Sounds like a good story for Radio Free Europe.
As a Canadian, official bilingualism and multiculturalism are natural, even sacrosanct, to me. Strangely, I’ve heard no Canadian politician defend Russian-speaking Ukrainians on the same basis that they defend Quebec’s right to determine its own language and cultural policies. I don’t know if it’s blindness, stupidity, or hypocrisy.
I thought the EU held Multiculturalism as a core value and righfully so point being Ukraine doesnt seem to share this value at the administrative level yet the EU seems to igore this when it comes to Ukraine and always claim Ukraine shares our Europeon values and are fighting for our Values. Makes me suspect that the EUs dedication to the value of Multiculturalism isnt as Sincere as we would hope our is a complete facade.
The G-7 Guys respect all Cultures,
they exploit all of them equally....
I am become quit used to watching your shows as you have interesting subjects etc from Australia
Excellent analysis 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
Thank you Pascal, I found this discussion very interesting.
Thanks! Glad you enjoyed it. It is really interesting to hear this, especially the way Duleba frames the situation. Under this mental outlook, one can justify anything against the minority populations. Very scary.
Thank you
thnxs for the great report
The Ukraine people have and are paying with their lives for taking the American Dollar, John Mearsheimer can give you a history of events.
Imagine speaking one of the rirchest language on earth (Russian) and being forced to speak a language which close to nothing jad been written or translated.
Thank you for showing your "chauvinism"
I'm a lover of slavic languages, but Ukrainian sounds like a Russian spoken by an orc. Bliznets is bliznyuk, mladenets - malyuk. How ugly us that?
Great podcast, thank you
"Do you want the state to be subordinate to you?" I love the blunt retort here: "Uh, yes. That is called liberal democracy" [which, of course, Ukraine hollowly claims to be].
thank you
I love this channel so much.
Pure academia, pure intellect. Pure fact and yruth
In the east Movie theatres could only show moviess in Ukrainian.
Informative.
finally...altera pars audita
...bravo
Did anyone expect anything different in the West?
When we add up the economic effects that appear to have motivated the West to attack Russia, the effects appear pretty simple?
The Inflation that emerged as BRICS began to organize all the G-7 former Colonies,
the economic effects are pretty dramatic.
Germans assumed they were correct,
until the Russian Tanks convinced them they were wrong.
"Collective Fear Stimulates Herd Instinct; which tends to produce a ferocity towards those who are not regarded as part of the herd" Bertrand Russell Foundation.
Very interesting!!