The Progressive Era: Crash Course US History #27

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 7 лют 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 2,6 тис.

  • @rachelmaybeidk
    @rachelmaybeidk 9 років тому +1453

    To be honest, I have a crazy APUSH teacher that doesn't really teach so this is how I'm learning more in 15 minutes than 3.5 hours a week.

    • @emthornsbury
      @emthornsbury 9 років тому +26

      +RachelEverdeen that is so sad. Teachers should be teaching !!!! Hope it gets better for you!

    • @rachelmaybeidk
      @rachelmaybeidk 9 років тому +25

      +emthornsbury thanks so much for your kind words! I'm pushing through the 2nd semester and just trying to enjoy other classes as much as possible! :)

    • @Plxtinum9029
      @Plxtinum9029 7 років тому +3

      So tru

    • @ilovebrittanator
      @ilovebrittanator 6 років тому +8

      BIG MOOD IM STRUGGLIN

    • @waverlyritchie383
      @waverlyritchie383 6 років тому +1

      Omg same

  • @YouLovesChloe
    @YouLovesChloe 8 років тому +4354

    All these AP history comments... I'm simply here for my U.S. history class lol

    • @samuelketner1391
      @samuelketner1391 8 років тому +21

      Chloe Marie Same!

    • @MultiSonixx
      @MultiSonixx 8 років тому +113

      Be glad, idk if I'm speaking for anyone else but my APUSH teacher is a joke, she legit doesn't teach, like in all seriousness

    • @jahinoel1365
      @jahinoel1365 7 років тому +1

      Chloe Marie FACTZ

    • @nicholascooper945
      @nicholascooper945 7 років тому +1

      Regress.
      *YOU JUST GOT PRANKD*

    • @river6007
      @river6007 7 років тому

      Me too

  • @spike9653
    @spike9653 7 років тому +1226

    90% of the comments: APUSH students. 10% of the comments people who are legitimately just interested in history

    • @Sable_ish
      @Sable_ish 7 років тому +25

      88% of comments: APUSH Crammers. 9% of comments: People interested in History. 2% of comments: Both. 1% of comments: Trolls

    • @RM-th9ur
      @RM-th9ur 6 років тому +13

      Most APUSH students are interested in history.

    • @EmilyHaoEM
      @EmilyHaoEM 6 років тому +7

      And you believe they are mutually exclusive?

    • @rxdlne
      @rxdlne 5 років тому +6

      @@RM-th9ur Can not confirm

    • @sannarah1456
      @sannarah1456 5 років тому +8

      You forgot about us non native speakers of english studying english 😢

  • @kavyac700
    @kavyac700 9 років тому +4702

    To APUSH students:
    We're all in this together

    • @1337b3nnyvav00m
      @1337b3nnyvav00m 8 років тому +48

      Test tomorrow, we made it!

    • @katali5780
      @katali5780 7 років тому +10

    • @Word3111
      @Word3111 7 років тому +52

      Bruh, I have that test tomorrow.

    • @RB-do4mc
      @RB-do4mc 7 років тому +22

      same bro, the grind is real

    • @erichughes3987
      @erichughes3987 7 років тому +6

      Have a test tomorrow 🙏

  • @lil.liz99
    @lil.liz99 8 років тому +2405

    When your AP test is Friday so you're just watching the whole series

    • @3thanguy7
      @3thanguy7 8 років тому +16

      We all doin that.

    • @obiesenpai3869
      @obiesenpai3869 8 років тому +4

      +Lizzie Burnham SAME!!!

    • @gregorybest6580
      @gregorybest6580 8 років тому +27

      More like the morning of...

    • @kelseyperkins1210
      @kelseyperkins1210 8 років тому +2

      SAME

    • @SpencDonut
      @SpencDonut 8 років тому +1

      +Lizzie Burnham yep same two but now count how many shocks he had in all videos

  • @mustang6172
    @mustang6172 10 років тому +532

    Upton Sinclair later said, "I wanted to touch America's heart, but instead touched her stomach."
    ... Or something to that effect.

  • @xenacuevas8811
    @xenacuevas8811 8 років тому +102

    Mr. Green, you are simply THE BEST because unlike many many school teachers you don't scream, get neurotic or lose patience and you have precise and clear thoughts. Most importantly passion!

  • @AriannaWhitacre
    @AriannaWhitacre 8 років тому +140

    He should be a History teacher, like I have to take a test early on this and Gilded Age so watching his videos

    • @AriannaWhitacre
      @AriannaWhitacre 8 років тому +9

      but like he should be my history teacher cause yeah

    • @haelynnestudio
      @haelynnestudio 7 років тому +2

      Yeah I am writing an essay for APUSH on the progressive era and this video gives me enough information to write about it.

  • @aliciaselvera2233
    @aliciaselvera2233 9 років тому +311

    Our APush teacher made us spend two days listening to a reading of The Jungle. The only reaction I got from that novel, besides vomitting into my mouth, was joy from guessing the mystery document correctly.

    • @nc2748
      @nc2748 7 років тому +5

      Alicia Selvera I studied this in middle school lol...I was sick to my stomach and I didn't eat the meat in school cause it would always remind me of the books description..took me long to get over it lmao.

    • @friendlycreature6375
      @friendlycreature6375 5 років тому

      What APUSH stands for

    • @b3gaming673
      @b3gaming673 5 років тому +3

      @@friendlycreature6375 AP us history

    • @nickhartman9898
      @nickhartman9898 5 років тому

      SAME

    • @manswine7735
      @manswine7735 5 років тому +4

      @@friendlycreature6375 Advanced Placement United States History

  • @FakeWonder
    @FakeWonder 11 років тому +451

    "I can only imagine how LONG and HARD you've worked to get the phrase beef-boner into the show and you finally did it." You have one sense of humor John

  • @DANversusWTP
    @DANversusWTP 9 років тому +80

    He concluded so strongly that I was subconsciously waiting for "Hank I'll see you on Friday"

  • @TheLesliericheytoo
    @TheLesliericheytoo 11 років тому +35

    Hey! Thanks so much for what you do. I teach AP and Dual US History (and government and Eco) and use these to either introduce a unit or sum it up. They are awesome! Showing the TARDIS and using the phrase "timey wimey" just bumped you and your writers to the top of my high esteem list. These quiky ditties filled with both historical facts and current pop culture entertain my little nerds and broaden the horizons of my bright, but non-nerds as we go through and explain the references. Keep it up, you are very much appreciated.

  • @ybba15
    @ybba15 8 років тому +655

    *AGGRESSIVELY WATCHES THE ENTIRE SERIES IN ONE NIGHT TRYING TO CRAM FOR THE APUSH FINAL*

    • @col.sanders5987
      @col.sanders5987 5 років тому +6

      Amen. Test is tomorrow, and I'm prepared to get a 2.

    • @aidenburke6037
      @aidenburke6037 5 років тому +3

      Col. Sanders same brother

  • @musicrulesmylife123
    @musicrulesmylife123 11 років тому +19

    I'm just glad John is helping me not fail my AP US history test tomorrow. Thank you to crash course!

  • @MrMusicman456
    @MrMusicman456 9 років тому +15

    The Rush joke at the beginning earned you my undying loyalty

  • @nishatnguyen
    @nishatnguyen 9 років тому +62

    "touch your nose to prove literacy" - animations in this video do not have noses. Great. Good.

  • @spankylewis2010
    @spankylewis2010 5 років тому +19

    Anyone watching in 2019? This is super helpful (where we started and where we are)

  • @Shiftyeyedog
    @Shiftyeyedog 10 років тому +181

    This is the first time I guessed the Mystery Document author! GO ME!

    • @declyn1380
      @declyn1380 9 років тому +1

      Shiftyeyedog same!!!!!

  • @hannahweibel2631
    @hannahweibel2631 9 років тому +339

    I totally guessed "the Jungle" was going to be the mystery doc

  • @bunney3272
    @bunney3272 9 років тому +1061

    If pro is the opposite of con, what is the opposite of progress?

    • @mastercaster02
      @mastercaster02 9 років тому +63

      +Sir George Severn LEL DOOD SO CLEVAR Y U NOT RUNNING 4 PRES RYTE NAOW LOL GET IN ON DA RACE MAN THE ELECTION IS NXT YR

    • @bunney3272
      @bunney3272 9 років тому +12

      *****
      *****?
      You need to be 35.

    • @mastercaster02
      @mastercaster02 9 років тому +9

      Sir George Severn LEL 35 WUT DOOD YEARS DAYS MUNTHS OR ALL OF THE ABOVE

    • @bunney3272
      @bunney3272 9 років тому +6

      *****
      35 years old.

    • @Davbay2
      @Davbay2 9 років тому +123

      Congress

  • @griffinforsgren7720
    @griffinforsgren7720 10 років тому +36

    4:05
    "I aimed for the heart of America, but I hit it in the stomach"
    - Upton Sinclair

  • @eglnst74
    @eglnst74 11 років тому +12

    I love you. You've helped me understand the Progressive Era so much better, and I definitely needed this to get ready for my APUSH unit exam. Green, YOU are awesome.

  • @dylaneidson5466
    @dylaneidson5466 9 років тому +197

    how do you talk so much with out breathing????????????????? :O

  • @Itsph4nt0m
    @Itsph4nt0m 11 місяців тому +6

    As much as I like my AP teacher, APUSH doesn't let him teach everything in 2 semesters. So I gotta do, currently 8 AMSCO's and 40+ US History Crash Courses. The AP test in on April.

  • @HoniBunni
    @HoniBunni 4 роки тому +384

    Who else is here cramming for the Online AP exam?🤪

    • @ed93435
      @ed93435 4 роки тому +7

      @@belizbaloglu4400 honestly were lucky we get to have study guides out

    • @belizbaloglu9771
      @belizbaloglu9771 4 роки тому +3

      Elda Desta truly

    • @ed93435
      @ed93435 4 роки тому +9

      @@belizbaloglu9771 im 1000% depending on all the notes I took I actually can't belive I was gonna take this test with just my pencil out in a classsroom lolll

    • @JohnBrown-dx8kp
      @JohnBrown-dx8kp 4 роки тому +12

      i want to cry lmao

    • @amanda-pp1rx
      @amanda-pp1rx 4 роки тому +5

      @@JohnBrown-dx8kp same

  • @psychxkappa5788
    @psychxkappa5788 5 років тому +95

    When your APUSH TEST is in two days and you just finished chapter 30

    • @jonl727
      @jonl727 5 років тому

      i'm so screwed

    • @brij5778
      @brij5778 5 років тому +1

      Watch it on x2 speed

    • @maximoruiz2945
      @maximoruiz2945 5 років тому +1

      We didnt even get to chapter 30

  • @kevinr.9733
    @kevinr.9733 9 років тому +6

    What's great about these videos is that they are highly informative but don't take themselves too seriously.
    Anyone else notice the Pokéball in the cornucopia?

  • @hootenanny.in.e
    @hootenanny.in.e 5 років тому +38

    Good luck to everyone tomorrow!!!

  • @shawnsea624
    @shawnsea624 11 місяців тому

    Thanks!

  • @scottylilacleona9193
    @scottylilacleona9193 7 років тому +47

    Wobblies! The I.W.W. was an amazing union, and they still are. Still, it's hard for any group to recover from having ALL OF THEIR UNION HALLS BURNED DOWN BY THE GOVERNMENT! 1917. It happened.

  • @Decetop
    @Decetop 10 років тому +236

    A video on the Progressive Era without mention of the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire? One of the biggest work place tragedies in American History? The event responsible for nearly all workplace safety laws in the U.S.? That Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire? And you omitted it? Come on, man.

    • @4esolid
      @4esolid 6 років тому +4

      Decetop my thought exactly too

    • @blixer8384
      @blixer8384 6 років тому +29

      He also omitted the Battle of Blair Mountain the largest Labor Uprising in American History and the largest uprising since the American Civil War.

  • @DianeJasmine
    @DianeJasmine 6 років тому +5

    Watching these videos transports me to a very specific time in my life and it is WILD because I'm supposed to watch these in teacher mode and instead I feel like I'm in 10th grade.

  • @fartzinwind
    @fartzinwind 10 років тому +409

    When you say "the first book", does that mean you have barfed on multiple occasions while reading?

  • @foreverandeveryt919
    @foreverandeveryt919 Рік тому +2

    You saved my butt in a test that I study last minute for I’m not sure how to show my thankfulness to you but I want you to know that I’m thankful for you making these videos

  • @capnbobretired
    @capnbobretired 7 років тому +2

    I've watched a number of your courses. One of the things I like about your series is that you talk really fast. If you are covering something I am familiar with, its not tedious to hear you talk about it. If its new to me, I can usually absorb the information. If I need to, its not a bother to back up and listen to the not fully assimilated section again. Good job, and entertaining in a "learning something important" way.

  • @michaellastname2421
    @michaellastname2421 10 років тому +192

    Why is it so hard for me to understand history? I have practically no idea of what you just said.

    • @23cokebottles
      @23cokebottles 10 років тому +38

      to be fair, CC usually does a crappy job of communicating main ideas/events/consequences/relations/basically everything clearly and effectively. I find John's attempts at humor muddying and the graphics more distracting than helpful...that said, this is the only source I know that'll give me a summary/overview of whatever unit I'm working on atm...I get what they're trying to do, they're trying to keep it entertaining and engaging but I find it unhelpful. So yeah, that could be it.

    • @cheyennedobie6828
      @cheyennedobie6828 10 років тому +4

      Same. I suck at history

    • @michaellastname2421
      @michaellastname2421 10 років тому +20

      Cheyenne Dobie Same. I'm more of a math and science person. Most people I know are really good at history and English, so I feel really dumb when they find a history lesson or English essay so simple when I'm completely lost. I guess that's why I want to become a mechanical engineer.

    • @WVU.STEELERS.CELTICS
      @WVU.STEELERS.CELTICS 7 років тому +10

      Michael LastName I'm a history and English guy.... You should be happy because math and science gives you jobs.

    • @mna9211
      @mna9211 6 років тому +4

      He actually made progressivism hard to understand but it is easy.

  • @corrines4270
    @corrines4270 5 років тому +48

    is he kinda awkwardly cute or is it just 1am and my brain is fried from studying for my test tomorrow..

  • @KingDrew
    @KingDrew 8 років тому +45

    YES I WAS RIGHT ON THE MYSTERY DOCUMENT. BOUT TO ACE THIS FINAL!

  • @ahobbitstail7022
    @ahobbitstail7022 6 років тому +1

    I listen to these lectures while working in a hotel kitchen, and I've got to say, they keep me sane. Stay in school kids.

  • @fuzzydunlop7928
    @fuzzydunlop7928 8 років тому +1

    After reading the comments I feel weird watching these for my own enjoyment rather than for a course.

  • @rockwall5329
    @rockwall5329 6 років тому +9

    To anyone cramming these videos the day before the test, best of luck :)

    • @jennifertorres4743
      @jennifertorres4743 6 років тому

      Rockwall you too!!! im freakin scared of the short answers but aNYWaYs good luck to you

    • @rockwall5329
      @rockwall5329 6 років тому

      Jennifer Torres Thanks, just finished and I found it pretty easy

    • @Farlian_
      @Farlian_ 6 років тому

      Lol, doing this before a different test, but I'll be coming back in May.

    • @meganc.1232
      @meganc.1232 5 років тому

      Keaton Spell Well, it’s May. I got to take it tomorrow RIP

    • @meganc.1232
      @meganc.1232 5 років тому

      Rockwall Really? Thanks, that gives me some confidence.

  • @MrTeacherDO
    @MrTeacherDO 9 років тому +24

    The "Wibbly Wobbly" got me

  • @teresabrown4741
    @teresabrown4741 10 років тому +12

    I get so excited when we watch Crash Course during social studies because John Green is hella rad ❤️

  • @madisonleigh2963
    @madisonleigh2963 4 роки тому +57

    2 hours till the exam.
    I am watching this at twice speed...
    Welp...
    Procrastination is great!

  • @Roenazarrek
    @Roenazarrek 11 років тому +51

    OTP means "one true pairing" meaning Hazel and Agustus were people's favorite combination of characters in fandom, in case anyone was wondering.

  • @qayyahsplace5041
    @qayyahsplace5041 4 роки тому +17

    Me: seeing all these AP comments
    Also Me here before taking my junior yr history final: “Heyy...how y’all doing”

  • @ashleighlewis9282
    @ashleighlewis9282 4 роки тому +9

    no better place to be at 2 am, 8 hours before the exam :)

  • @solar_109
    @solar_109 4 роки тому +7

    Cramming on the day before the test. People tell me not to do it but I can't help myself

  • @acponyluv
    @acponyluv 11 років тому +1

    Now I know I'm not the only one who always thinks of "wibbly wobbly timey wimey" when I hear wobbly! You have totally earned my respect ;)

  • @robertvanlowe-davis1911
    @robertvanlowe-davis1911 2 роки тому

    instead of being in class for 2 hours trying to learn this i can learn this in 15 mins this dude is a life saver

  • @Krebons1200
    @Krebons1200 11 років тому +19

    This definetely helping me out with my American Studies class. It's much easier to remember like this

  • @keiraw1113
    @keiraw1113 4 роки тому +10

    Who’s here cramming the day of the May 2020 exam.

  • @ggalloway1
    @ggalloway1 11 років тому +15

    John, I have to say this is my favorite US History episode yet. Thanks for watching? No sir, thank you for sharing this with us all.

  • @stephanpierson7235
    @stephanpierson7235 6 років тому +1

    Love this guy! Going back and watching all of them again. Where is you sure, we need more content!

  • @chrismaginn4251
    @chrismaginn4251 10 років тому +2

    John with the Prog Rock shoutout! xD
    Thanks for calling on my favorite genre.

  • @calebbrown243
    @calebbrown243 9 років тому +95

    Anyone else here for APUSH finals

    • @jasona1000
      @jasona1000 9 років тому

      yes.

    • @hiimsky4381
      @hiimsky4381 9 років тому +4

      +Caleb Brown I'm cramming some study for a Gilded Age & Progressive Era test. We got so behind this year because of all the snow days we've recently had.

    • @LazyStormTrooper
      @LazyStormTrooper 8 років тому +1

      +Hi, I'm Sky You sound lucky. I have a test from the Progressive Era to the start of the Cold Wars tomorrow.

    • @SabbathSilverclaw
      @SabbathSilverclaw 7 років тому

      no...

    • @jordanthomas4379
      @jordanthomas4379 7 років тому

      Caleb Brown what the hell is “APUSH”?

  • @coffee4laffdip
    @coffee4laffdip 11 років тому +41

    "'Broad participatory democracy doesn't always result in an effective government' he said, sounding like the Chinese national Communist Party" hahah

  • @AS-fe9hd
    @AS-fe9hd 8 років тому +130

    'CRAMMIN #APUSH2k16

    • @fabfooyum9292
      @fabfooyum9292 8 років тому

      +Aaron Stewart LOL TRU

    • @chailatte44
      @chailatte44 8 років тому

      +Aaron Stewart Same tho

    • @witchboob
      @witchboob 6 років тому +1

      BRO IM CRAMMIN IN 2019 YEET

  • @gabrieladabrowska458
    @gabrieladabrowska458 5 років тому

    John Green still here, helping desperate students pass their history exams in 2020, thanks John

  • @yaslinreyes4011
    @yaslinreyes4011 9 років тому +1

    I've got my US History midterm on Monday. This is extremely helpful

  • @nishatnguyen
    @nishatnguyen 9 років тому +24

    Pointing to Germany....... *points to all of Eastern Europe* ok nice job John.

  • @buggranger4781
    @buggranger4781 9 років тому +304

    Who else got the AP US test tomorrow ?

    • @jherc12990
      @jherc12990 9 років тому +1

      Same!!!

    • @rhi9025
      @rhi9025 9 років тому +1

      I do too!!! Good luck!!! :)

    • @Link-wy3zi
      @Link-wy3zi 9 років тому

      Bug Granger yup, that late night cramming be very much real

    • @danielahernani3933
      @danielahernani3933 9 років тому +1

      Link6579 IS ANYONE IN THE NEW YORK TIME ZONE WHO WANTS TO TELL ME THE ESSAY PROMTS TOMORROW?

    • @Link-wy3zi
      @Link-wy3zi 9 років тому

      Daniela Hernani sorry im from California

  • @nathangiannini3282
    @nathangiannini3282 6 років тому +19

    Test is tomorrow boys, time to start studying

  • @livvyisawsum
    @livvyisawsum 11 років тому +2

    As someone from the greenpartsofnotamerica these videos are really interesting, because we do learn about the period from the American revolution to the American Civil War in school but we always just stop there :)

  • @kittehgorawr4993
    @kittehgorawr4993 9 років тому +1

    Thank you John Green for helping me study at the last minute for my US history test.

  • @amitzkeylah9231
    @amitzkeylah9231 5 років тому +3

    When you have a test the next day and don't want to read your history book, so you just watch the entire series on repeat for 24hrs.

  • @Perfect.Spirited.
    @Perfect.Spirited. 10 років тому +14

    I never thought I would know the mystery document!

  • @skullyairsoft80
    @skullyairsoft80 11 років тому +4

    YES finally I see a picture of rush in a non rush video.

  • @flibbertigibbet448
    @flibbertigibbet448 11 років тому

    "It goes 'bing' when there's stuff!" That's not the only thing I got out of this. Thanks for helping me truly understand the stuff that was discussed in my sadly boring history lectures. You are a godsend.

  • @aranzamurillo8729
    @aranzamurillo8729 5 років тому

    i'm new to the US and i'm in US history and this helps me more than my teacher, thank you

  • @AustinJ2
    @AustinJ2 5 років тому +7

    Watching Crash Course the night before the APUSH exam at 2x speed

  • @aviskolnick4448
    @aviskolnick4448 4 роки тому +7

    As a potterhead I appreciate all the HP references.

  • @MG-sj2re
    @MG-sj2re 10 років тому +13

    That moment when you know the author of the mystery document before it's revealed.
    "Yasssssssss"

  • @aleccubides2570
    @aleccubides2570 Рік тому +1

    very very good video, It helps me understand more compared to when my history teacher teaches. Plz make more videos

  • @MoreOrLessIt
    @MoreOrLessIt 9 років тому +1

    This week, you are a saviour to all A level students in this godforsaken land, Mr Green.

  • @ShandoGuardian
    @ShandoGuardian 8 років тому +23

    "your nephew's sister's cousin" translates to either, 'your son/daughter' or 'your nephew/niece'

  • @kaylarachellerichmond
    @kaylarachellerichmond 11 років тому +6

    I would be learning a lot more in American History if you were my professor.

  • @allisonsmith2702
    @allisonsmith2702 8 років тому +4

    Lol, we watch these in my U.S. History Class! They're awesome! Love John Green's books btw😂💕

  • @SolusEclipse
    @SolusEclipse 8 років тому

    I have a midterm tomorrow and this helps more than you could imagine...

  • @BethTaylormuzic01
    @BethTaylormuzic01 10 років тому

    You have aided me in the success of my AMH2020 exam and for this I am grateful.

  • @tinbitberhanu8125
    @tinbitberhanu8125 9 років тому +80

    I'd suggest a caption for the libertage but I'm afraid I'm 3 years late...

    • @raintalonxOc
      @raintalonxOc 9 років тому +6

      +Tinbit Berhanu o my god yes

  • @melissa8313
    @melissa8313 8 років тому +3

    This is a great series, you really present the information well given the limited time. Thank you for making these! They've been a Perfect way to go over concepts! 👍💕📚

  • @AlanNadeauIII
    @AlanNadeauIII 8 років тому +3

    6 no-shocks to 4 shocks. Great work John. You might just make it to the Mystery Document Playoffs, if you know what I mean.

  • @shivampathak152
    @shivampathak152 4 роки тому +1

    I’d like to thank this video for getting me thru my reform prompt for my APUSH DBQ

  • @conorkrystad4634
    @conorkrystad4634 4 місяці тому +1

    I've watched a lot fo Crash Course and this maybe my favorite

  • @samuelspencer2823
    @samuelspencer2823 8 років тому +10

    Thumbed up for Rush.

  • @Drakelx55
    @Drakelx55 11 років тому +8

    OMG yes! John finally said Wibbly Wobbly Timey Wimey! Allons-y!

  • @emmaglad951
    @emmaglad951 5 років тому +4

    when everyone is saying AP history struggles and you have this for your grade 7 US history class

    • @oliviad444
      @oliviad444 4 роки тому

      That was me back in 7th grade too lol, but now I'm back 4 years later for APUSH... wish I could go back.

    • @emmaglad951
      @emmaglad951 4 роки тому

      Olivia D nah me be wishing I was in first grade 😂

  • @e7venjedi
    @e7venjedi 11 років тому +2

    1:36 This is why I love history so much. This question has been percolating in my mind for a while now. What happens when the majority gets it wrong? Is there a better system than having everyone get an equal vote? What if the majority of people in a democracy want something like slavery, [to use an example from past episodes]? Or what if they want to be short-sighted and burn fossil fuels without care of the consequences [to use an issue I'm greatly concerned about]?
    9:42 And this is why I love this show so much. They ask hard questions, and they provide possible answers -- and often, more questions :P
    Any thoughts, enlightened CC viewers? :-)

    • @DeHerg
      @DeHerg 10 років тому +1

      I am not so sure if I would call myself enlightened but will give it a shot anyway.
      In order to grasp at the question which political system could give the best results I think we first have to ask the question of what is the nature of political action. It is basically a collective action that commonly effects proponents as well as opponents of each possible way within the system(so at the center of it there is almost always a conflict of interest that has to be resolved).
      Ergo the question is not only of who can make the best/most informed decisions but also of who is able to look past his/her specific/personal benefit the most and in which system the ruling body is least susceptible towards "illegitimate" manipulation by either side.
      The most direct form of democracy possible (every decision individually is up for vote) would commonly not have the benefit of high expertice in the field in which the decision is made but due to the broad nature of the ruler (in this case the populus) personal/specific beenifits are mostly not taken to account except for the possible manipulation due to political campains.
      As a form of polar opposite we could take a technocracy (a system in which the rulers are soley chosen due to ther expertice in the field the are making decision in), this sytem of course has the atvantage of being able to be the most informed one but runs a very high risk of manipulation in the form of corruption because this group would be a)rather small whereas each member has alot of influence and b)not answerable to anybody
      Combinations of the two are possible in a multitude of ways(one of which is more or less like the republican system).
      Personally a combination, I find most interesting in getting rid of 2 of the 3 problems, would be a forum of experts that present multiple well thought out options which are then up to vote by the populus although this system would still be in danger of being manipulated by campains aswell as bribes.
      I think to get rid of the last part can only be undertaken by a cultural shift itself which had to emphasize manipulation as one of the most offensive things a person could do.
      those are my two cents on the matter, I hope they are a good starting point for further thoughts
      PS: sorry for possibly many spelling mistakes (not a native english speaker)

    • @nalleniverson
      @nalleniverson 10 років тому

      That's not classical liberalism or democracy. Holding others' votes/opinions above another others' because one group's opinion is "enlightened", "correct" etc. creates a segregated country. Progressives and leftists today hold the idea that they are correct in all their endeavors because they are enlightened or whatever they may want to call themselves. Progressives are the antithesis of what they claim to be, as they create social disruption, segregation, and notably in the past and present: racism and just about every other -ism out there.

    • @e7venjedi
      @e7venjedi 10 років тому

      DeHerg
      Hey there, thank you for your very thought-provoking reply! And I didn't notice any spelling issues -- your English is very good! [Where you from?] I wanted to give myself some time to digest and think before I responded, so that's the main reason for the delay ;-) I don't think it really helped much :P seeing as I started going down my rabbit hole lol.
      I really like your way of framing the question into how much power do we want to give to experts vs. diluting power to limit corruption.
      I guess that really is the ultimate question when you think about governance. Of course there is also the other line to take of trying to foster an educated, fair-minded community, so that the need for enforcement is unnecessary in most matters.
      I really like your idea of a panel of experts presenting multiple options for the entire group to decide on.
      That is a really great point about the cultural shift. Thinking about all this really makes me think that it is really in the community's hands. Of course different systems will favor different results to some extent, but it makes me think that the population probably gets more or less what it wants no matter what system you use [with the exception of violent oligarchies/dictatorships obviously, then they have to fight for freedom first].
      I tend to find myself always coming back to a limited government idea of just providing for the safety [military/police] of citizens and maybe a safety net for the most basic needs. I wonder too about making things very local-based, but then I always immediately worry about 'tribalism' and how alliances inevitably get formed between small groups against others who are opposed in some way.
      I guess another way of looking at government is that it is the choices we make about what we are going to pool our resources for. Ultimately why and when we do that is a question of values I suppose.
      So much to think about. :-)

    • @e7venjedi
      @e7venjedi 10 років тому

      Nick Allen
      Riiiight... So electing people and giving them more power than the average citizen is doing what exactly? Those individual's votes/opinions are literally 'above' others' because they are weighed in a pool of hundreds as opposed to millions.
      lol. Why would the left uniquely “hold the idea that they are correct in all their endeavors” and the right not? What are you even trying to say? Doesn't everyone hold the beliefs they do because they believe they are correct?
      I'm all for embracing complexity [one of this channel's main themes], being humble, and listening to differing opinions with respect. How is the left any better or worse than the right in this regard? Aren't both “sides” filled with people of all types?

    • @nalleniverson
      @nalleniverson 10 років тому

      I understood it that you meant that some citizens would have more weight to their votes than other citizens, in the case of voting for officials, which wouldn't and shouldn't work in the US.

  • @chakaflocka55
    @chakaflocka55 7 років тому

    Nothing makes me happier than being in my main man JRuts US History class. I learn everything from how to love and how communism spread fear throughout the states. Jrut likes warm snuggles. I have nothing but respect for him😤😤😤

  • @mollyvitamin2461
    @mollyvitamin2461 6 років тому +4

    i didnt read and i have a test tomorrow... pray for me friends

  • @starwarsgaming7918
    @starwarsgaming7918 4 роки тому +13

    Didn't bother to learn this when we reviewed it... and now the AP test is Friday...

  • @shiaawasee
    @shiaawasee 4 роки тому +5

    John Green's hands literally can't stop moving. lmao

  • @anthonyover
    @anthonyover 7 років тому

    These videos were good back in apush... still good refreshers in college!

  • @vatow7502
    @vatow7502 5 років тому +2

    Test tomorrow boys. Grind time is the prime time.

  • @docpi3141
    @docpi3141 5 років тому +11

    My apush test is tomorrow and im binging crash course lol

  • @hannahleighfriedman6665
    @hannahleighfriedman6665 10 років тому +6

    teehee...I guessed the document. Alright, let me at that AP test!

  • @alejandrahernandez5062
    @alejandrahernandez5062 7 років тому +10

    The exam is here my friends

  • @ceciliafaye2813
    @ceciliafaye2813 7 років тому +2

    Your videos are awesome! Thank you for your insights and knowledge of our country and its history.

  • @atypicalfrenchy
    @atypicalfrenchy 9 років тому

    WIBBLEY WOBBLEY TIMEY WIMEY!! Seriously though, these crash courses are a great help.