We count on good people to pay for good journalism. Pl subscribe/contribute to ThePrint here: theprint.in/subscribe/ this includes the link for subscriptions from overseas too.
Can you shut this old man india is at war with its own all his good journalism is of no use until this butcher modi will go and bjp will disappear india is a big circus you need British to come back and rule and kick on the back side of so called rulers. Modi is nothing but just a indian Mr Bean who can entertain us
Make your content paid. I shall still pay for your monolouge with half baked truths and cherry picked anecdotes. It is fun seeing you say nonsense with that serious deminor.
Have ever seen a PM of nation washing feet of others and picking rubbish 🗑 and why dose india need election just make modi PM until he dies. Ho sorry for bhakt modi is God who will never die but for sensible people if and when ge dies will bhakt become orphans
@@thirumalairaj4365 the only people looting from tirupathi are TDP supporters , new government has allowed complete CAG audit of TTD . DON'T listen to lies spread by caste mafia of TDP , CAG can audit each and every transaction in TTD 👍
Manmohan Singh's comments on the NGOs are not wrong. Every time there are protests even for the construction of a small Factory. Then the same people protest on unemployment. Reminds me of a scene from Khosla ka Ghosla.
It is astonishing that the Indian farmer was still under colonial rule until the year 2020. And when the government wants to free it, every Tom and Jack coming to oppose it? Strange😂
Sterlite and kudankulam are classic example of missionaries using foreign money to pursue agenda.in so called Sterlite protests pastors were walking hand in hand flaming the rioting. Good move by govt
@@kareemkhan-hv1yp bhai i am from thoothukudi district where sterlite has been located,even there are many coal power plants and fertilizer factory in the causing pollution target was only sterlite which producing copper.Church of England had a sizeable investment in vedanta group which control sterlite,before the closure of sterlite church of england get their money back.We are losing 2 billion dollar a year and become net importer of copper.
Your so uninformed.Church of England had a huge holding in Vedanta.You tend to draw stupid conclusions based on your prejudice.If I pollute your land,would you want me there?It's as simple as that.Mining in niyamgiri Orissa was done after exploiting tribals,are these things right?.
i guess, its a good law. Protect us from foreign interference in our domestic issues. And its proven fact that they do influence some of our policies. Im in support of this law.
They amended the FCRA in 2016 because they broke the law. Tell me again how does the party who itself is influenced through foreign money protecting us from foreign influence. They are just protecting the interests of the foreign entities that are paying them.
@@71espn okay I want that to stop as well. But that is not as bad as the NGOs fundings because political parties have to contest elections and they are scrutinized by the people of India and if they do something funny, it comes to limelight quite early while these NGOs are not answerable by anyone and run their agendas driven campaigns which does harm to our national security and interests. And it's better that we get something (atleast controlling NGOs foreign funding) than nothing.
There are lot of NGO who works for improvised children and sanitization. e.g. Malinda gates foundation for sanitization. They see the government action/implementation on ground and complaint about that. But after this if you complaint regrading anything FCRA will come and the NGO which was actually helping people will be banned or hounded.
Umm jao 2016 ka FCRA AMENDMENT BILL padho. Directly political parties ko influence karne ka privilege de diya foreign companies ko kyunki the BJP itself violated the FCRA.
Isn't modi govt being advertised by so called, godi media 24/7 365 days especially one's like network18 channels, which is owned by their biggest well wisher and donor. Isn't that influencing 🤔. Or influencing by insiders are ok for the democracy as per BJP fans.
@@kumbhajverma9090 So as long as its not from pak or china side, its absolutely fine as per you. There is nothing surprising on the state of our country, considering the type of people, who are ruling and voted for them.
When it comes to Politics, It doesn’t matter if issue is of east or west, To Understand our #Cuttheclutter is The Best... I have read FCRA bills but never been able to connect the dots that explicitly!
He did not cover most imp objection for FCRA which is forced conversions with allurements on the guise of doing social service. (rice bag conversions as we say in Tamilnadu)
We dont know which political party pushing foriegn agenda like few big Ngo . Exceptional case Congress and communist party. Communist part 100%chinees. Congress party 25% chinees 25% Soviet 25% Italian 25 % us. One is histroy one is confused. Guess who.
Since the may 2014, when Modi government came to power, it has served show cause notice to approx 10500 NGOs to why not cancel their registration, as they didn't complied with requirements of FCRA... Neither they filled return nor provided any explanation to the government, who's so interested in India to putting money through NGOs, what's the reason... Except few, rest of these NGOs were not able to reply about this.. their bank account has been freezed, registration cancelled... Welcome step by government...
Dude congress shops are based on these loopholes in our laws... they never did any changes because thier shops running... thier shops are closing and you are telling dont oppose
Most of the North East Indians has been converted Christianity because nobody kept any check on fundings coming from West to Christian Missionaries in India. A lot of Conversion programs are also happening in South India too.
If this is true, then how have so many madrassas come-up with "foreign fund", as we are told by the media. Hope this will not be considered an "Islamphobic" question..
Agriculture reform is good for the nation......FCRA is important we have seen instances of Islamic countries funding illegal Movement and anti Hindu lobby in India and Missionary activities in India
@@71espn Not only that, Superpower Pakistan's companies fund Aliens of Andromeda Galaxy and export Jf17 aircraft to them to wage war against hostile aliens of Kepler 186F.
" passing bills in noise is not a good way to reform" ......yes they should only be passed after Rahul Gandhis blessings and Sonia Gandhi's motherly love!
Right. Also the politicians must pay for the death and disability of every individual hurt by the environment disaster. And not from the tax payer funds.
Rohan Tiwari Nope plz listen to his words carefully these r communists they r good in manipulating.Study The print journalism on Tahir hussain,Safoora zargar main culprit of delhi riots the print is saving them. So beware of these Supari journalists bhai
George Soros vows to fight PM Modi and Nationalists: Here are some Indian ‘intellectuals’ and NGOs connected to him www.opindia.com/2020/01/india-george-soros-nationalism-pm-modi-indian-intellectuals-ngo-connected/
That might happen in next 20 years. The one thing about Indian democracy is, they do take care of everything, but slowly, not in one go. Wait for it, this too shall happen.
@@shreyanshsangal7058 I think you successfully called out a fake person. Kudos! And @MUFC Fan.. even I want to donate. Tell me your Organisation name. After 20 years, I'm sure you have a website. Provide a link. Funny how this circuit operates. They want to influence people's perceptions. Posing as "first hand information". Shameful.
SG sir, you have cleverly avoided the use of foreign money in conversion activities that is rampant in many states. but glad that you covered money used for political activities/dharnas/chakka jams etc...
@@prasannatayade334 Because Modi is a Hindu Nationalist who loves his motherland that's why he won't Sell India to Foreign Powers but can't say that about Left and Congress.
Good that laws are tighter. Overseas influence has been restricted. Already we have seen Kundamkulam & other projects. NGOs delayed Konkan Rail for years. Many more. In 50's & 60's and even later religous conversions were done by giving financial incentives as well as food stuffs like Milk powder, Rices, Wheat etc.
Best thing is to read the bill and history ourselves instead of believing reports from media houses or other persons. Everyone has their agenda. Now, note following points of you have an iota of concern for future of your children. 1. Uranium based nuclear technology has heavy dependency on Nuclear Suppliers Group. As India has bare minimum Uranium reserves. Secondly Uranium reactors are too risky. 2. India has abundant Thorium reserves say 60 % of world's total. So, India, in 1950, decided to become energy sufficient by developing Thorium technology. It was vision of none other than Homi Bhabha. Energy is fundamental requirement for development. 3. Google below link en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/India's_three-stage_nuclear_power_programme. 4. Kudamkulam Plant is the last leg of Thorium based nuclear power generation National plan of farther on Indian nuclear program Dr. Homie Bhabha. 5. India has become world leader in Thorium technology with 60 years of research. And residue is non radioactive which means extremely safe. 6. BUT, All are not happy with India becoming Energy Secured. Many international NGOs put legal hurdles, funded locals to create strikes, file cases in Indian courts in order to stop India's Thorium program. 7. It was necessary to BAN many NGOs involved in anti development activities to pave the way for smooth implementation of programs of National interests. 8. Why nobody thought about Thorium reactors earlier ? . Reason is Uranium is dual use radioactive material. Weapons can also be made. But, thorium cannot be made into weapons. But, thorium technology is more complicated. Now, request all intelligent Indians to join the dots. Many times we, without knowing the larger plot, our own acts become detrimental to our own growth. We play in the hands of more intelligent people. We Indians, like a sheep follow the leading sheep without a thought. If ones keeps eyes and ears open, you can join the dots sequentially to understand the entire plot. Now tell me you want to give your next generation a richer and developed India or not ? Or at least provide them energy security so that your children can build the Nation further. BE PROUD OF OUR NUCLEAR SCIENTISTS and SUBSEQUENT GOVERNMENTS FOR SUPPORTING THEM.
I do know that Indian Thorium project is in Phase 3 (the cycle has started now) and it will take another 25 years for it to start production of energy because of the Chemistry/Physics behind it. But yes, once that happens, India will no longer be needing to import Uranium as Uranium is one of the by-products of the fission reaction.
Meanwhile, Amnesty International decides to halt it's operations in India... And, this is so true even in states like Bihar. In our town, a so called NGO in the name of Christian Missionaries, would receive funds for other motives. The head happened to be an acquaintance...
NOO!! Guys plz I want to send funds to you my special Indian friends! We both have so much we can share like defence weapons, Sputnik Covid vaccine, trade, etc.😭
You may like or dislike Modi, you may agree or disagree with Modi.... But he is a risk-taker. He takes big risks willing to face the consequences, good or bad. He doesn't like sitting and just passing time.
What is Holding back the Congress : Leftists, Activities, vested interests organizations.... What is Holding back the BJP : Swadeshi jagaran Manch, RSS...
What appears from this episode is that it is an improvement of earlier FCRA version. I think that if I am getting money from foreign sources to eradicate poverty and spending 90% of the amount as administrative expenditure then it means that donation has not been properly utilized. Their might be other intricacies that I m not aware off.
The first clause mentioned in the bill says that ‘sub-granting’ of foreign funds is not allowed. This alone will drastically change how NGOs work in the country, in such a collaborative nature. It is because of sub-granting that many small NGOs that do genuine work are able to get funding, especially during the covid crisis when most of India funders gave their money to PM-CARES instead of supporting urgent on-ground crisis of reverse migration and livelihood
Sir, I have 2 questions🙋. 1. If the limit to spend on the administrative purposes is 20% then what will NGOs do with rest of 80% of the donations ? 2. What is draconian in this law? Should not we and the government be cautious about where the money from NGOs come from? How is violating anyone's fundamental rights?
The environment ministry during the UPA2 regime was essentially being run by Rahul Gandhi via his proxies Jayaram Ramesh and then Jayanthi Natarajan and many of the NPAs in India today can be traced back to that period when the environment ministry was essentially a closed door that would give zero clearances under the guise of environment protection . They were thus at loggerheads with their own Prime Minister.
"sab mile hue hain" also applies to all George soros and commi funded journos, media houses, and thousands of politically motivated ngos like green peace and amensty international ...
Well done Shekar u have done a lovely job of breaking complex issues to be understood by a layperson like me. Keep up the good job. Thanks shekhar once again. Ramesh Babu
Thanks a lot for sharing the knowledge........just in 20 mins, i learnt "Why FCRA ?" & "How it is evolved over a time ?". After watching this video, i feel my mind tasted some clarity over this act and now I am going to study act as a part of my exam preparation.
Shekhar ji, if FCRA regulation act is illegitimate because it was made by Indira Gandhi during emergency,then so is the inclusion of the words "secular" and "socialist" which was added to the preamble during the same period.
Mr. Shekhar Gupta is amazing. The moment I start getting an income (as I am a student now 😅) I will contribute a small amount to The Print. It's quality journalism. Especially Mr. Gupta's. ❤️. We need to talk about the same issues in our local/regional channels.
Having someone influence public institutions by the means of donations is bad and restricting it by laws is a good strategy in my opinion. If someone wants to invest then be official investor upfront and retain that position openly. What's wrong with that?
I think the #CutTheClutter episode 571 (agriculture reform bills) did not present the facts at all. It looked more like opposition bashing, which is right given their reason for ruckus. I expected CTC to present facts both in favour and against these bills. It's no brainer to understand that the free market is good for the supply side, but the question is how in this case? When 82% of our farmers (according to Niti Ayog) just has 2 acres (approx) of land, and the part which is used for agriculture is less than 1.5 acres. Most APMC (or mandi's) are located in Punjab and Haryana, am not sure about the percentage but it's a definitely significant chunk, farmers of Bihar, for example, do sell their produce In Haryana and Punjab, not to the local business because APMC provides better rate which we all know is also minimum. This business has failed in Europe and America, the corn price for farmers has been stagnant since 1970 in USA. Europe provides a large number of subsidies to their farmers, which enables farmers to survive. I am trying to say is why are we doing a copy-paste of a model which has already failed in the west, why can't our economists or government come up with a strategy which actually will work?
Modi Ji and his govt is doing the CORRECT thing ...NGO's are used by other countries to play politics contrary to the prime objectives they claim in their vision statement. India has a lots of money ...the country does not need any NGOs.
Dr. Singh was right, in fact it’s worse, print should do an investigative piece on ngo actions in Tamil Nadu - kudankulam, sterlite, jallikattu, highway projects Good move by the government
Manmohan Singh. As famously said in economics - there is nothing like free lunch. These money has been spended in religious conversion, environmental activism, University professor propaganda machinery and ofcourse fighting every case in supreme court. Everyone remember that what George sores said I commit $1 billion for democracy propagation.
It’s amazing how skilfully one can keep on the right side of the powers that be. The criticism of the present dispensation is muted when compared to that of the past dispensations! God bless good journalism.
Very one sided picture, No effort to explain how this was misused by NGOs. It appears everyone including MMS can't think in India's interest. Is it because of ur own vested interest?
Sorry SG, disagree with you and feel that even this amendment is very cute with current standards, I have no doubts, future govt will tighten it even more. With the conversion of tribal & poor to Christians, to the funding of green peace activist in poorest area of our country, NGOs have respectfully earned the bad name, and will be made to pay for it.
Mostly by Vatican group funded the NGO for conversion purpose. Is there any provision to stop the NGO to file case against Indian laws in the court. Since it is a indirect way influenced by the foreign funded group to stop any action of GOI.
SAY it Chahchu: Words like secularism and socialist were also added then in the emergency, therefore these are also illegitimate words added by an illegitimate govt.
@@vbond585 if bjp or Congress is using the money like missionaries and commies that should also be banned .by law no foreign contribution can be used for conversation activities but it's a open secret church uses the money brought in in the name of charity
@@naguok There are no ifs here. Both were actually taking money from foreign sources but before the court could hear the case they amended the law in 2016, changing the definition of what a foreign company means. And they applied it in retrospect which means that the law became operational not in 2016 but from the time it was first introduced. This means both of them committed a crime and 1hennthey were caught the BJP changed the law.
I'm sure you would agree that a rich benefactor's opinion somewhere outside India should not shape public opinion in India. If NGO's are to be given a free leash, why not allow foreigners to even vote in your elections, stand as candidates , get elected as president?
@@kareemkhan-hv1yp Hindus do not support conversion. This is our sentiment. We got freedom from Muslim and Christian rule. Still Islamic and Christian countries want to convert us. Many of us would rather die than to convert to Islam or Christianity. We are not dalal of any political party rather they are dalal of us.
We count on good people to pay for good journalism. Pl subscribe/contribute to ThePrint here: theprint.in/subscribe/ this includes the link for subscriptions from overseas too.
Can you shut this old man india is at war with its own all his good journalism is of no use until this butcher modi will go and bjp will disappear india is a big circus you need British to come back and rule and kick on the back side of so called rulers. Modi is nothing but just a indian Mr Bean who can entertain us
But very good people count on very good journalism 😂😂🤣🤣
Make your content paid. I shall still pay for your monolouge with half baked truths and cherry picked anecdotes. It is fun seeing you say nonsense with that serious deminor.
@@amonnoma1370 Consider it paid content and you just pay.
And Pay significant.
Have ever seen a PM of nation washing feet of others and picking rubbish 🗑 and why dose india need election just make modi PM until he dies. Ho sorry for bhakt modi is God who will never die but for sensible people if and when ge dies will bhakt become orphans
Christian missionaries in North east Andhra and Tamil Nadu will be crying after this bill becomes law.
YCP headed by Christian CM supported the bill , nation over party I guess
@@ramk2443 he loots money from tirupathi so he dosent care about this bill
@@thirumalairaj4365 the only people looting from tirupathi are TDP supporters , new government has allowed complete CAG audit of TTD .
DON'T listen to lies spread by caste mafia of TDP , CAG can audit each and every transaction in TTD 👍
@@ramk2443 it was filled by Dr swamy in AP high court and the TTD accepted it
@@srividyadhardantu6 it was accepted by current government and denied by TDP
BJP: *proposes a bill to make RG as PM*
Congress: *opposes*
Even a politically neutral person will oppose that bill.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
That will be a true "kaal kanoon".😂😂😂
@truth seeker modis nunnu is your point of concern? No wonder why rationalists roasts self proclaimed truth seekers like you.
Not congress.. Rahul Gandhi himself!
😁
Manmohan Singh's comments on the NGOs are not wrong. Every time there are protests even for the construction of a small Factory. Then the same people protest on unemployment. Reminds me of a scene from Khosla ka Ghosla.
That movie was awesome.
@@lookintoit4537 true that! 👍😎
Khosla ka ghosla or ngo's how relate?
@@bobinpune shut up talk to china,usa,russia,europe and west,middle east and others,i know our politician is corrupt
@Indian Stars yeah, recent example is Mumbai Metro .. so much drama happened when bjp in power. now no more voice :)
It is astonishing that the Indian farmer was still under colonial rule until the year 2020. And when the government wants to free it, every Tom and Jack coming to oppose it? Strange😂
Putin they are funded by Xi.Any unrest will have the sponsorhip of him.
Vikas ka pahiya..
Putin bhaiyaa... 😂😂😂
By that logic, our use of "british parliamentary system" still should count as India as a colony...what say?
Comrade, put these people in gulag.
What if this is really vladimir putin?
George soros must be really unhappy today.
Open Society Foundation 😢
The bastard who looted UK.. And is now on the path to destruct India, by building NGOs and NGOs...😤
He & his followers should be banned
He is just one of the TATTAS of thousand tatta ROTHSCHILD ANd 7 other BLOODLINERS
Yes😂
Sterlite and kudankulam are classic example of missionaries using foreign money to pursue agenda.in so called Sterlite protests pastors were walking hand in hand flaming the rioting. Good move by govt
BALATKARI JANTA PARTY KA DALAL SPOTTED DOING DALALI
@@kareemkhan-hv1yp bhai i am from thoothukudi district where sterlite has been located,even there are many coal power plants and fertilizer factory in the causing pollution target was only sterlite which producing copper.Church of England had a sizeable investment in vedanta group which control sterlite,before the closure of sterlite church of england get their money back.We are losing 2 billion dollar a year and become net importer of copper.
Your so uninformed.Church of England had a huge holding in Vedanta.You tend to draw stupid conclusions based on your prejudice.If I pollute your land,would you want me there?It's as simple as that.Mining in niyamgiri Orissa was done after exploiting tribals,are these things right?.
@@kareemkhan-hv1yp ironic, you seems to be the keyboard warrior dalla of our bhikari neighbour.
Kha in jihadiyo ko smjha rhe ho.. They hate our country.
i guess, its a good law. Protect us from foreign interference in our domestic issues. And its proven fact that they do influence some of our policies. Im in support of this law.
They amended the FCRA in 2016 because they broke the law. Tell me again how does the party who itself is influenced through foreign money protecting us from foreign influence. They are just protecting the interests of the foreign entities that are paying them.
@@71espn okay I want that to stop as well. But that is not as bad as the NGOs fundings because political parties have to contest elections and they are scrutinized by the people of India and if they do something funny, it comes to limelight quite early while these NGOs are not answerable by anyone and run their agendas driven campaigns which does harm to our national security and interests. And it's better that we get something (atleast controlling NGOs foreign funding) than nothing.
There are lot of NGO who works for improvised children and sanitization. e.g. Malinda gates foundation for sanitization. They see the government action/implementation on ground and complaint about that. But after this if you complaint regrading anything FCRA will come and the NGO which was actually helping people will be banned or hounded.
ua-cam.com/video/ZSUXhbFKa6A/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/ZSUXhbFKa6A/v-deo.html
If "The Hindu" says it should be repealed I am pretty convinced it is surely a good law.
its a great law..we dont want any foreign power to influence our media or other institutions
Umm jao 2016 ka FCRA AMENDMENT BILL padho. Directly political parties ko influence karne ka privilege de diya foreign companies ko kyunki the BJP itself violated the FCRA.
@@71espn but not media
Isn't modi govt being advertised by so called, godi media 24/7 365 days especially one's like network18 channels, which is owned by their biggest well wisher and donor. Isn't that influencing 🤔. Or influencing by insiders are ok for the democracy as per BJP fans.
@@rkt81 atleast not by CHINA or PAK
@@kumbhajverma9090 So as long as its not from pak or china side, its absolutely fine as per you. There is nothing surprising on the state of our country, considering the type of people, who are ruling and voted for them.
We should strictly apply this law so that no NGO can misuse the fund.
Need cut the clutter on 4 labour codes
saradhiroy yessssssssss please The Print! 🤞🏻
Absolutely....very soon....thanks for the suggestion....sg
ThePrint 💖
@@ThePrintIndia Thanks SG
@@ThePrintIndia where you will justify the latest industrial relation bill in which there is no space for labour rights 😡😡😡
When it comes to Politics, It doesn’t matter if issue is of east or west, To Understand our #Cuttheclutter is The Best... I have read FCRA bills but never been able to connect the dots that explicitly!
He did not cover most imp objection for FCRA which is forced conversions with allurements on the guise of doing social service. (rice bag conversions as we say in Tamilnadu)
We dont know which political party pushing foriegn agenda like few big Ngo . Exceptional case Congress and communist party. Communist part 100%chinees. Congress party 25% chinees 25% Soviet 25% Italian 25 % us. One is histroy one is confused. Guess who.
Ramni Sundereshen thanks for the suggestion
Since the may 2014, when Modi government came to power, it has served show cause notice to approx 10500 NGOs to why not cancel their registration, as they didn't complied with requirements of FCRA... Neither they filled return nor provided any explanation to the government, who's so interested in India to putting money through NGOs, what's the reason... Except few, rest of these NGOs were not able to reply about this.. their bank account has been freezed, registration cancelled... Welcome step by government...
ua-cam.com/video/ZSUXhbFKa6A/v-deo.html
Opposition must realise that you shouldn't oppose everything.
arey sab mile ve .. bol rey political party fcra mei ni aati..
Madaari ka scene dekho .. sacchai ye hai..
ua-cam.com/video/M0Bulogh_S4/v-deo.html
@@ShowTranscript just write in election manifestos but not bring any amendments.
GST A GOOD IDEA ...BUT BLUNDER...
@Ramdoot Hanuman Dhrunpv shows Complete BIAS with half Information
Dude congress shops are based on these loopholes in our laws... they never did any changes because thier shops running... thier shops are closing and you are telling dont oppose
Most of the North East Indians has been converted Christianity because nobody kept any check on fundings coming from West to Christian Missionaries in India. A lot of Conversion programs are also happening in South India too.
On top of that, Church has a VERY strong influence on the lives of people. It's like a parallel authority.
Except Tripura and Sikkim the NGO are busy in converting in other states*
And every Northeast Christian are being proud of Christian. So you should not worry about them.
@meet anonymous haha I happy that u r enjoying.
Can you ensure that none of these ngo money wasn't used for Muslim and chiristian conversion or terrorism???
Foreign fund is surely favour foreign countries,
ua-cam.com/video/ZSUXhbFKa6A/v-deo.html
So PM CARES is getting foreign funds too! When foreign companies are giving crores, they want something in return, right?
Bbc news.. 🙏😀
If this is true, then how have so many madrassas come-up with "foreign fund", as we are told by the media. Hope this will not be considered an "Islamphobic" question..
Agriculture reform is good for the nation......FCRA is important we have seen instances of Islamic countries funding illegal Movement and anti Hindu lobby in India and Missionary activities in India
Foreign companies fund the BJP. Pakistani companies fund the BJP. That is why it is hell bent on destroying our economy and constitution.
@@71espn Not only that, Superpower Pakistan's companies fund Aliens of Andromeda Galaxy and export Jf17 aircraft to them to wage war against hostile aliens of Kepler 186F.
@@memelord7551 😹😹😹😹😳😹 dude 💀
" passing bills in noise is not a good way to reform" ......yes they should only be passed after Rahul Gandhis blessings and Sonia Gandhi's motherly love!
The Problem is these Bill s are passing in Modi's period not in their period.
Good one. The bias and whining is so loud
George Soros crying is corner.
Kshitij Gupta was waiting for a George Soros conspiracy theorist.
😭😅
You got it exactly. Foreign Fund is the only fuel they utter nonsense everyday on tv. Best move by Amit Shahji. Ab dekhte he kab tak chillate he
One bill that is needed : protesters will have to pay the price of the violence protest.
Right. Also the politicians must pay for the death and disability of every individual hurt by the environment disaster. And not from the tax payer funds.
Good idea: do the same for riots. Im sure tadipaar wil go bankrupt
abe chutiye bjp bankrupt hojayegi fir hahaha
What is going on? Is shekhar gupta really turning unbiased? This is a welcome surprise 😲
I was thinking the same
I feel the same way
Rohan Tiwari Nope plz listen to his words carefully these r communists they r good in manipulating.Study The print journalism on Tahir hussain,Safoora zargar main culprit of delhi riots the print is saving them. So beware of these Supari journalists bhai
A chutiya will always be chutiya (sg)
Same here bro
17:50 Pallava Bagla the ndtv guy who shouted on ISRO scientists during chandrayan 2 announcement
Yeah shameless creature.
Yes. That same shameless person. Sad to see SG quoting him. He shd had blurred his name 🤣🤣
Oh ,
Gupta Ji be Like: Will Open Society still pay my salary? 😭
Why is Mr. SG silent about Soros?
know all about Pm cares fund ua-cam.com/video/ZSUXhbFKa6A/v-deo.html
Soros Controls everything. But the king 👑 is the Rothschild family
George Soros vows to fight PM Modi and Nationalists: Here are some Indian ‘intellectuals’ and NGOs connected to him www.opindia.com/2020/01/india-george-soros-nationalism-pm-modi-indian-intellectuals-ngo-connected/
Absolutely right step by the government. Rampant misuse of foreign funds. Government had taken the right step.
I definitely support this law, Its a need of the hour.
Government should add conditions that NGO should not indulge in protest against infra projects.
Sudhindra kini yes
I think that's what the new eia draft is for
That might happen in next 20 years. The one thing about Indian democracy is, they do take care of everything, but slowly, not in one go. Wait for it, this too shall happen.
@@VipinKumar-kh5bd how long are they gonna last without foreign funding
You are out and out coming in defence of the Modi Government. Hats off to you
20% is a reasonable cap. at most they can add a minimum amount clause. otherwise as we know people will use it for dubious agendas or booze.
Agree there should be price limit not %.
Will this stop conversions
@@shreyanshsangal7058 I think you successfully called out a fake person. Kudos!
And @MUFC Fan.. even I want to donate. Tell me your Organisation name. After 20 years, I'm sure you have a website. Provide a link.
Funny how this circuit operates. They want to influence people's perceptions. Posing as "first hand information". Shameful.
SG sir, you have cleverly avoided the use of foreign money in conversion activities that is rampant in many states. but glad that you covered money used for political activities/dharnas/chakka jams etc...
Foreign donation poses security issue to the nation...... If not you got the permission anyway
@@prasannatayade334 Because Modi is a Hindu Nationalist who loves his motherland that's why he won't Sell India to Foreign Powers but can't say that about Left and Congress.
How come foreign donation for political parties is fine ???? Same country but two rules ?
Tightening of NGOs is must. Too much misuse of freedom by these people against the interest of Nation.
Good that laws are tighter. Overseas influence has been restricted. Already we have seen Kundamkulam & other projects. NGOs delayed Konkan Rail for years. Many more. In 50's & 60's and even later religous conversions were done by giving financial incentives as well as food stuffs like Milk powder, Rices, Wheat etc.
Best thing is to read the bill and history ourselves instead of believing reports from media houses or other persons. Everyone has their agenda.
Now, note following points of you have an iota of concern for future of your children.
1. Uranium based nuclear technology has heavy dependency on Nuclear Suppliers Group. As India has bare minimum Uranium reserves. Secondly Uranium reactors are too risky.
2. India has abundant Thorium reserves say 60 % of world's total. So, India, in 1950, decided to become energy sufficient by developing Thorium technology. It was vision of none other than Homi Bhabha. Energy is fundamental requirement for development.
3. Google below link en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/India's_three-stage_nuclear_power_programme.
4. Kudamkulam Plant is the last leg of Thorium based nuclear power generation National plan of farther on Indian nuclear program Dr. Homie Bhabha.
5. India has become world leader in Thorium technology with 60 years of research. And residue is non radioactive which means extremely safe.
6. BUT, All are not happy with India becoming Energy Secured. Many international NGOs put legal hurdles, funded locals to create strikes, file cases in Indian courts in order to stop India's Thorium program.
7. It was necessary to BAN many NGOs involved in anti development activities to pave the way for smooth implementation of programs of National interests.
8. Why nobody thought about Thorium reactors earlier ? . Reason is Uranium is dual use radioactive material. Weapons can also be made. But, thorium cannot be made into weapons. But, thorium technology is more complicated.
Now, request all intelligent Indians to join the dots.
Many times we, without knowing the larger plot, our own acts become detrimental to our own growth. We play in the hands of more intelligent people.
We Indians, like a sheep follow the leading sheep without a thought. If ones keeps eyes and ears open, you can join the dots sequentially to understand the entire plot. Now tell me you want to give your next generation a richer and developed India or not ? Or at least provide them energy security so that your children can build the Nation further.
BE PROUD OF OUR NUCLEAR SCIENTISTS and SUBSEQUENT GOVERNMENTS FOR SUPPORTING THEM.
I do know that Indian Thorium project is in Phase 3 (the cycle has started now) and it will take another 25 years for it to start production of energy because of the Chemistry/Physics behind it. But yes, once that happens, India will no longer be needing to import Uranium as Uranium is one of the by-products of the fission reaction.
Sir it’s about 25% of world thorium Results , Really didn’t knew abt this thank you 🙏 for this very insightful information
This bill was much needed .
These NGOs have had free hand for a very long time
Meanwhile, Amnesty International decides to halt it's operations in India...
And, this is so true even in states like Bihar. In our town, a so called NGO in the name of Christian Missionaries, would receive funds for other motives. The head happened to be an acquaintance...
A bill very much in need to stop dubious NGOs.
Why does media needs money from someone who doesn't read the paper?
NOO!! Guys plz I want to send funds to you my special Indian friends! We both have so much we can share like defence weapons, Sputnik Covid vaccine, trade, etc.😭
Dont worry KGB can work something out
NDTV : 🎵🎶 mere toh..... L lag gaye🎶 🎵
Truly unbiased.. kudos to u Mr shekhar ji..
Bjp has done good thing. Even with these tough law, lakhs of churches are getting money and are converting poor hindus
@China ki face pe Pakistan ka tatti how many rice bag did your religion help to the needy people?
@gener8enigma who's gonna provide employment to people??your uncle?
I support the Modi govt., but i love such honest journalism. Great job!
The most dangerous are those who are involved in missionary activity in tribal areas
Those who were in support of this law like here ......
👇
👇
👇
👇
3:12 Shekhar ji that illegitimate government/parliament also inserted the word secularism and socialism in the preamble of the constitution
Yes, People like SG ji conveniently forget that. And even today not a word on Christian Conversion Mafias using NGOs as cover.
Shrimaan Guptaji
Appreciate presenting Fcra matter in quite an objective manner.
Well researched.
Regards
You may like or dislike Modi, you may agree or disagree with Modi.... But he is a risk-taker. He takes big risks willing to face the consequences, good or bad. He doesn't like sitting and just passing time.
Sir,I love your journalism by facts telling .
Gold Standard of journalism. Neutral and Objectives without any propaganda.
What is Holding back the Congress : Leftists, Activities, vested interests organizations....
What is Holding back the BJP : Swadeshi jagaran Manch, RSS...
Thanks for clearing it up. Indian youth needs such clearance of govt plans
What appears from this episode is that it is an improvement of earlier FCRA version. I think that if I am getting money from foreign sources to eradicate poverty and spending 90% of the amount as administrative expenditure then it means that donation has not been properly utilized. Their might be other intricacies that I m not aware off.
Administration expenses are inflated and then utilized for unacceptable activities.
Yes, the purpose of foreign funding shd not be to maintain administrative work or paying salary. Good job modi government.
The first clause mentioned in the bill says that ‘sub-granting’ of foreign funds is not allowed. This alone will drastically change how NGOs work in the country, in such a collaborative nature. It is because of sub-granting that many small NGOs that do genuine work are able to get funding, especially during the covid crisis when most of India funders gave their money to PM-CARES instead of supporting urgent on-ground crisis of reverse migration and livelihood
Sir, I have 2 questions🙋.
1. If the limit to spend on the administrative purposes is 20% then what will NGOs do with rest of 80% of the donations ?
2. What is draconian in this law? Should not we and the government be cautious about where the money from NGOs come from? How is violating anyone's fundamental rights?
The rest of their donations will be taken by the government
@@SACHINYadav-sn4op no, They have to use it for the purpose like Education, Environment etc.
The environment ministry during the UPA2 regime was essentially being run by Rahul Gandhi via his proxies Jayaram Ramesh and then Jayanthi Natarajan and many of the NPAs in India today can be traced back to that period when the environment ministry was essentially a closed door that would give zero clearances under the guise of environment protection . They were thus at loggerheads with their own Prime Minister.
"sab mile hue hain" also applies to all George soros and commi funded journos, media houses, and thousands of politically motivated ngos like green peace and amensty international ...
Well done Shekar u have done a lovely job of breaking complex issues to be understood by a layperson like me. Keep up the good job. Thanks shekhar once again. Ramesh Babu
NOG just made india from the largest copper exporter to a copper importer in TN
Good bill 🙏🙏🙏
I couldn't understand why it's a bad idea? Through FCRA govt will be able to track foreign money
Thanks a lot for sharing the knowledge........just in 20 mins, i learnt "Why FCRA ?" & "How it is evolved over a time ?". After watching this video, i feel my mind tasted some clarity over this act and now I am going to study act as a part of my exam preparation.
We are habituated seeing you your sleeves up.
Thank you for pointing out. Have to protect myself from mosquitos. Dengue is bad enough once! Best wishes, SG
ua-cam.com/video/ZSUXhbFKa6A/v-deo.html
Shekhar ji, if FCRA regulation act is illegitimate because it was made by Indira Gandhi during emergency,then so is the inclusion of the words "secular" and "socialist" which was added to the preamble during the same period.
"Mrs Gandhi" even today are most powerful words India has ever seen..
(US knows this better)..! 👌🧐
One of the best episodes of Cut the clutter. Very clearly explained by SG
2:27 funny motives
Why don't name christian and Islamic ngos
Fantastic points
Really neutral(read unbiased)
Thanks SG
Mr. Shekhar Gupta is amazing. The moment I start getting an income (as I am a student now 😅) I will contribute a small amount to The Print. It's quality journalism. Especially Mr. Gupta's. ❤️.
We need to talk about the same issues in our local/regional channels.
"Hamam mein sabhi nange, sabhi mile hue hain": S.G.
Ji lagado last me... : Kejriwal 😂
Sheker Gupta you are the biggest Threat to the Security of India
George Sorrows 😭
Here after AMNESTY INTL bank accounts are freezed. Kudos to the Govt. Next One should be GREENPEACE India.
I think it's not all that bad these ngo guys created chaos and uncertainty with money from overseas and uncertainty is the thing companies fear.
This kind of laws are much more needed in today's situation
Having someone influence public institutions by the means of donations is bad and restricting it by laws is a good strategy in my opinion.
If someone wants to invest then be official investor upfront and retain that position openly. What's wrong with that?
शेखर गुप्ता ने विरोध किया मतलब देशहित में है मामला ...
NDA should tighten FCRA regulations further to keep the foriegn influence at bay.
Our nation is in need of political parties run by people like you.. ....
Isn’t Pallav Bagla that chap who misbehaved with the ISRO guys after the moon landing thing didn’t work out?
Sahi pakde hain. NDTV ka banda hai
I think the #CutTheClutter episode 571 (agriculture reform bills) did not present the facts at all. It looked more like opposition bashing, which is right given their reason for ruckus. I expected CTC to present facts both in favour and against these bills. It's no brainer to understand that the free market is good for the supply side, but the question is how in this case? When 82% of our farmers (according to Niti Ayog) just has 2 acres (approx) of land, and the part which is used for agriculture is less than 1.5 acres. Most APMC (or mandi's) are located in Punjab and Haryana, am not sure about the percentage but it's a definitely significant chunk, farmers of Bihar, for example, do sell their produce In Haryana and Punjab, not to the local business because APMC provides better rate which we all know is also minimum. This business has failed in Europe and America, the corn price for farmers has been stagnant since 1970 in USA. Europe provides a large number of subsidies to their farmers, which enables farmers to survive. I am trying to say is why are we doing a copy-paste of a model which has already failed in the west, why can't our economists or government come up with a strategy which actually will work?
Modi Ji and his govt is doing the CORRECT thing ...NGO's are used by other countries to play politics contrary to the prime objectives they claim in their vision statement.
India has a lots of money ...the country does not need any NGOs.
Do you think Indian NGO's will get that support from the country's own big firms?
Dr. Singh was right, in fact it’s worse, print should do an investigative piece on ngo actions in Tamil Nadu -
kudankulam, sterlite, jallikattu, highway projects
Good move by the government
Manmohan Singh. As famously said in economics - there is nothing like free lunch. These money has been spended in religious conversion, environmental activism, University professor propaganda machinery and ofcourse fighting every case in supreme court. Everyone remember that what George sores said I commit $1 billion for democracy propagation.
It’s amazing how skilfully one can keep on the right side of the powers that be. The criticism of the present dispensation is muted when compared to that of the past dispensations! God bless good journalism.
Very one sided picture, No effort to explain how this was misused by NGOs. It appears everyone including MMS can't think in India's interest. Is it because of ur own vested interest?
As always.. superb journalism 🙏
Sorry SG, disagree with you and feel that even this amendment is very cute with current standards, I have no doubts, future govt will tighten it even more.
With the conversion of tribal & poor to Christians, to the funding of green peace activist in poorest area of our country, NGOs have respectfully earned the bad name, and will be made to pay for it.
Mostly by Vatican group funded the NGO for conversion purpose. Is there any provision to stop the NGO to file case against Indian laws in the court. Since it is a indirect way influenced by the foreign funded group to stop any action of GOI.
INDIA POLITICS IS ON A ALL TIME. LOW nd INDIAN MEDIA TOO leaving our SHEKHAR JI
Due to opposition only , central government just fullfiling their manifesto.
@@pradyumnasingh1063 yes but voting was a Democratic right of. the opposition MP s
Now it makes total sense. Thank you SG. You are the best decluterrer (new word) 😀
Despite NGOs contributing immensely during COVID 19, this is how the government rewards. Nice bill to boost our morale.
Not all NGOs are good. Few good NGOs have lost popularity because of the damage several other NGOs did.
For the first time I love the NDA government. Their intent is good.
SAY it Chahchu: Words like secularism and socialist were also added then in the emergency, therefore these are also illegitimate words added by an illegitimate govt.
Rightly said, "Nothing bad is amended"...
Guptaji is upset that commies and missionaries hands are been tied . Oops
wellsaid
You mean BJP, which allowed foreign funding in political parties and was supported by Congress while doing so is pious ?? Wow
@@vbond585 if bjp or Congress is using the money like missionaries and commies that should also be banned .by law no foreign contribution can be used for conversation activities but it's a open secret church uses the money brought in in the name of charity
@@naguok There are no ifs here. Both were actually taking money from foreign sources but before the court could hear the case they amended the law in 2016, changing the definition of what a foreign company means. And they applied it in retrospect which means that the law became operational not in 2016 but from the time it was first introduced. This means both of them committed a crime and 1hennthey were caught the BJP changed the law.
Nagarajan K bhai conversion as much is a problem, foreign funded Political parties are worse
I'm sure you would agree that a rich benefactor's opinion somewhere outside India should not shape public opinion in India. If NGO's are to be given a free leash, why not allow foreigners to even vote in your elections, stand as candidates , get elected as president?
gupta sir can you speak christian and muslim convertion
2 RUPEE PER TROLL WALA DALAL SPOTTED OF BALATKARI JANTA PARTY
@@kareemkhan-hv1yp Hindus do not support conversion. This is our sentiment. We got freedom from Muslim and Christian rule. Still Islamic and Christian countries want to convert us. Many of us would rather die than to convert to Islam or Christianity. We are not dalal of any political party rather they are dalal of us.