Punjab's Canada dream is wilting. Study abroad & travel shops see massive dip in footfall
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 вер 2024
- Canada's tightened visa and immigration policy has hurt the visa and IELTS consultancy industry back in Punjab. Watch #ThePrintGroundReport by Shubhangi Misra.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/su...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/su...
» Subscribe to our UA-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Some of these students are so poor in English they would be rejected even by Indian colleges.
I absolutely agree
Not colleges but MNCs
Poor in ENGLISH? Just watch few youtube videos - They can't speak a single sentence of english and now protesting in Punjabi!!! A bog favour to Kaneda!!!
Phone scams, immigration scams what next??
I'm a white guy born in Canada and I work a part time job with a lot of Indians from Punjab that are relatively new to Canada. Most of them have horrible English. I can't even have a proper conversation with most of them, and have to speak very slowly and use extremely basic words, or they won't understand what I'm trying to tell them. I have no idea how they're even allowed here. And most of them don't even try to improve their English and just prefer to speak amongst their fellow Indians in their native language chatting amongst themselves - they do not want to branch out and talk outside of their clique groups (so there is very much a "us against you" vibe from them where they don't seem to care to assimilate or ever speak in English) this causes a lot of tension between them and other non-Indians - there is a huge divide.
And the majority of them do not even like it here because of the colder weather and very high cost of living. I get the vibe from most of them that they absolutely hate being here and are now stuck.
This is the greatest thing that could have happened to Punjab. We should thank Trudeau and Jagmeet Singh. This has the power to rid Punjab of it's stagnancy and galvanize Punjabis to demand their politicians for more than just a passport
who is going to give employment?
bro you are being too optimistic. you think that this is going to be Punjab's 1991 moment where Punjabi youth demand reforms and industrialisation. I afraid the feudal landholding class is just too strong they will oppose industrialisation till last moment. More and more radicalisation of youth on identity politics will happen. Govt should find new destinations in Europe and South America.
More farmers on streets begging money.. why do Punjab farmers think they deserve more money than rest of Indian farmers.
@@user-uh1kp3kc3l send them to Africa..
That's right
Studying abroad doesn't mean automatic citizenship, take your education and go back and make your own country better
They are fed up of Tim hortan employees, can’t even frame a complete sentence in English, bad hygiene, fighting in plazas, failing courses and then protesting on the streets.
Do you get proper BELT/BLT? Or a double-double! They Tim coffee is worst that many stopped going there!!
Rehne de bhai@@vinnyshama1066
Typical Punjab behavior 😂
I live in Canada, the situation over here is not good.! Dont trust this Association guy
No jobs
Same here
You import the third world you become the third world. What did you expect from these loud mouthed,ignorant louts?
Greatest thing, business in Punjab was already down but immigration made it worse. But finally stay in Punjab, go into your family businesses, innovate.
Lol 😅
Now these people will join farmers protest demanding money money free free
@@randomguy7175 BJP is giving 18000 per year to women in J&K for free. See their manifesto.
Punjab farmer avg land hold- 10 acres
India farmer avg land hold- 2.5 acres
No genuine Farmers can do strike for months and demanding 10k per month after retirement as pension and I think bjp got trapped with congress khat khat khat scehme.
@@randomguy7175 80 cr people are getting free ration acc to thier manifesto hhahaha
Not everybody has a family business and jobs hardly exist for youth.
As a former Indian citizen in Canada, this is great news for Indian-Canadians in Canada. The welcoming attitude of Canadians towards immigrants got thrown down the drain because of the uncontrolled immigration - especially from India and Punjab. Even previous Indian immigrants here do not want to see more immigration because there are simply no houses left for people live, no doctors available for healthcare, traffic is the worst, and prices are going up everywhere.
Most illegals are Gujaratis.
India and Punjab??????? Punjab is part of India.
So are you retuning to India?
@@ShreyasBharadwajwhats there to return?
@@manmohanr7840 to live with dignity or die fighting for it haq se and not as a 2nd class lesser colour citizen
How would they study in Canada if their English is so poor? The instructions would be in English.
"Study" is just a means to get one foot through the door, I guess. They'll prolly settle down with a blue collar job.
English?
I saw a video on DW that they are illegally entering Italy to work on Italian Vineyards as slave workers
You are assuming they come to Canada to study. Maybe some. But most join fake colleges and just work all the time.
No they are demanding it should be in Poonjabi to compete with Chinese and Americans!!!
They aren't going there to study, they are going there to work in Tim Hortons and gas stations.
Canada and Australia indirectly telling that they don’t need DUNKIES 😂
Most dunkies are from Gujarat actually.
@@RMNewton992 joker 😂😂😂😂
dunkies and donkeys
No directly telling them - YOU CAME FOR STUDY!!! Once your study OVER - Get the f out of here!!
Oh Punjabis ...baley baley...you dreamt of 3Ws in KENADA...Wealth Whisky and Women ( Gori Mems). 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Seriously you guys and girls think that the next government will be kind to immigrants from Punjab/India? No that ship has sailed.
Nobody will discuss why Canada relaxed the rules around the Pandemic and how these ‘students’ and their ‘spouses’ who really wanted to settle in Canada and had little to do with education abused the laws. Of course the Visa guys and Instagram influencers were there to cheer for profit.
We have created a serious problem in Canada. It is not that the next Government is going to reverse the situation, it has to find a better solution. Student visa is not a PR assurance.
100%
But who will explain this to the Sikhs and Punjabis
@@rohanutep81 and malayalies
You raise a very important question that is often not discussed in the media. The reason for this massive immigration was a political ploy by Trudeau to shore up his vote bank.
How can they be accepted to get a PR if they cannot even speak a common english not even on a IELTS level
Visa industry or scam industry?
Csnada is upto the brim with these Punjabis and the local populace here is fed up with their boorish and loud behaviour.
They watch bhangra videos and think it is the way to get beautiful girls!
Pretty much
💯......They don't wish to study 😅 I will say they don't have the brain to study 😂
Their Aim is to get CANADIAN PR
for that they will do any kind of crazy shit
Not to forget, Canadians are getting fed up with Khalistanis. Also, for the amount of money involved, much smarter to open new colleges in Punjab.
It was idea of J. Sing of NDP and liberal for future VOTE BANK!!!
We're not upset with Khalistanis. We're upset with India.
They r upset with hindus
Hated by all communities around the globe
@@MamaJanellaWho cares whom are you upset with , get lost from here
It's only hindus who are obsessed with khalistan not Canadians or even most sikhs... just u bored jobless hindus
To assume PR as a matter of birthright is funny. Also locals are fed up of immigration, impact on costs, housing, etc.
I am Canadian Indian, a lot of these students scheduled to go back do not meet the minimum requirements (points) to stay here, barely speak English, have failed courses. Plenty of students who went to good universities will stay here, which is what most people here want. Highly qualified candidates, not low wage workers.
but the highly qualified candidates get here to then pick oranges in farms.
@@priortokaraew7569 well that part is not wrong, I didn’t say what Canadians want and what they Have to offer these days is the same sir .
@@InderMand79 very clever of them to get post graduates of india to work as farm hands. i mean why not if they can pull that off with ignorant holders of degrees.
@@priortokaraew7569 to be fair, it’s not just farm hands but yes, why not get over qualified people if they are willing to come. Even pump we here can get rIch, in good times.
The reality is that these countries know about the low academic ability of some of these students. They have seen this as a way of bringing in low wage young labour to subsidize their education system and lower wages. They are not stupid or naive, it’s just that their program was more successful than they had imagined.
As a Canadian, I think the immigration laws was way too lenient. A country accepting immigrants need to ensure there are able to house them in the job market and living conditions. Otherwise both the new immigrants and the domestic population will struggle.
Finally some good news for Punjab 😭🙌 the whole cult of going abroad have destroyed Punjab and its culture where villages are empty with lavish mansions and old parents sitting in them!!
True
Really. Who is going to provide jobs to them? For those who have gone abroad, their next generations will be much better off than those in Punjab.
@@RMNewton992 For that to happen this generation needs to work hard and at the same time the economic stability and job creation should be happening there 🤦🤣 if not things will get worse as it’s already happening with housing, food and job crisis in Canada and what the govt is doing cutting off students work hours as well as capping immigration ✌️
@@RMNewton992" need" was not the reason to migrate. Fashion was the reason. Trend was the reason. Till 10+2 everything is good. How come things turn bad after that? Jobs. If a country of more than 1 billion population doesn't have jobs as per your statement, then certainly I pity your thinking. There's so much to do only if you are willing to do. If you are willing to learn the skills. Every type of institute exists in india. As for the 2nd generation, how many generations do you want to worry?
Same in Kerala at least we have genuine reasons
The part of the comments made by the immigration consultant is not correct! “The Canadian economy runs because of monetary contributions of international students” -rough translation in English. This reflects the poor level of understanding, false narrative, and desperation media, students and immigration consultants have about economic trends and job. Advanced economies including Canada will be more tech intensive for its survival in the future, reducing the necessities of unskilled/low skilled jobs. So the “students” whose primary intent is doing things other than studies, will find themselves at extreme odds. Please don’t be under the impression that it’s entirely political!
💯 it was actually a political move to bring over so many people. I get it people want to move to the West for their future but it needs to be sustainable.
finally a sane comment!
It's got almost nothing to do with politics. We just don't have the infrastructure.
Pubjabis must start own responsibility and work....even south indians go to Canada USA .. but they bring back high tech knowledge and skills when ever they called by the country...they also being investment in Hyderabad Bangalore....by lobbying their companies...bht Punjabis do nothing exceot for buying more land and building a lavish home in rural village...The entire AADHAR UPI DIGILOCKER ......al Digital infrastructure in india are all build by South NRI Engineers..(all100%)....NRI ounjani must bring investment not buying land on relatives name
Punjab has to industrialise again. But it is not possible with radical Sikh sentiment brewing up there.
Agree on punjab reindusrial8zing but real hinderence is hindu radicalism of last 70 years and subsidization of industry to neighbouring brahmnical himachal with explicit intention to completely deindustrialize non hindu majority region of punjab.
Hindu radicalism doesn’t allow anything positive to happen in whole north india.
@@cb9461 Hindu Radicalism doesn't believe in subsidizing anything. The truck Mafia in Himachal Pradesh is anti-business. Sikh are cowards and cannot compete in open business. That is why they opposed Ambani and Adani entering the farm business. Khalistani terrorists killed any business industrialisation that Punjab had.
Look at situation in Manipur. Radical Hindus and Christians killing each other for more than 15 months. More than 300 dead, including security personnel and 60,000 displaced, women paraded naked and gang raped. Not even 1% of that violence in Punjab.
@@cb9461 India is paying a LOT more to Punjab for their subsidies!
extremly happy to hear this news. these people havw made canada a mess. They need to be shut.
I AM AMAZED THAT ON ONE HANDCANADIANS ARE TRYING TO GO TO USA FOR BETTER PAID JOBS QND BETTER LIFE WHILE INDIANS ( PARTICULARLY PUNJABIS ) , AFRICANS , AND OTHER FOOLISH PEOPLE WANT TO GO CANADA AND LIVE IN TUNDRA , DO THE SHOPPING UNDERGROUNDS IN BLACK HOLES , NEVER SEE THE SUN IN THEIR LIFE TIME , NO DOCTORS TO SEE WHEN ILL , PAY HIGH RENTS TO LIVE . JE SUIS DÉSOLER ; MAIS MERCI BEAUCOUP ET BONNE CHANCE EN HIVER .
Till 2015 Canada was accepting only 250,000 to 350,000 people across all streams. It was more steady and stable immigration. The economy was good and there were better job opportunities. By 2023, that number went up to 1.2 million. That caused a lot of issue’s within Canada. I totally disagree when people say Canada’s economy depends on international student’s money. If that is the case, then there should be an economic boom in 2023 with these many international students. Immigrantion consultants spread these lies since they are the ones who benefit from these international students.
$30 Billion. That's 1% of Canada's GDP. BUT Canadian Economy ONLY grew by 1% in 2023.
Now, lots of variables at play. and economies are huge. But they DEFINITELY benefit from student fees.
Why are there only students from punjab protesting when there's students from all over the world?
Because they are desperate to stay
@@rohanutep81why are there only farmer's from punjab protested but not the farmers from other states because punjabis in this generation can't do shit and wants to blame everyone else for their problems created by themselves
When I speak with some new Punjabis here in Canada I always wonder how did they manage to get the required score in IELTS😅😅
You will get a reply in an “accent” which they picked up within 2 months of moving to Canada
Come on fellas. Have some self respect. Why do you wanna go some place where they do not welcome you and worst yet, dislike your very presence there
Meh let them go. Too much people here.
Punjab which was in the 3rd position economically during independence. Now it has slipped to 16th position. There are no good engineering colleges, with low entrepreneurship, lot of free flow of drugs, misguided youth, feudalism, radicalism, they are emulating their counterparts across the border...
MANY SIKHS ARE CONVERTING IN TO CHRISTIANITY AND ONLY FOR SHOW THEY GO TO THE GURDWARAS .
DRUGS IS THE MAIN PROBLEM IN PUNJAB AT PRESENT .
THEY WANT TO GO TO KANNNNADA AND LIVE IN TUNDRA LIKE CONDITIONS , 8 MONTHS NO SUN AND SHOPPING IN BLACK HOLES , INDIANS ARE FIRST CLASS FOOLS AND FOREIGN COUNTRIES ARE TAKING ADVANTAGE OF POOR STUDENTS . SORRY .
only 3rd because entire India was dirt poor back then and Punjab had good agriculture. With growth in industries and IT Punjab has fallen way behind.
Very good reporting and analysis. I know a little about Punjab .. shed a tear for Punjab people and kids for what they are facing. Their leaders have failed them
Never feel bad for Punjabi people. They are proud racists and staunch anti-Indians.
I had a hard working employee who kept trying his luck to find greener pastures and shift to Canada. He put all his life's savings along with some significant contribution from his parents i believe to get a work permit over there.
2 months later. He's back for good.
He got scammed by an another Indian over there. Somehow managed to get back 60-70% of his investment.
Can't imagine the bad luck he went through. Life teaches lessons. Overall i think he's glad to be back, and even I'm relieved i got back a hard working employee. Got to give him a raise now so that he doesn't think of going anywhere anymore!
The situation is really bad according to him. No guaranteed jobs, too much struggle and high cost of living.
Worse is he got scammed by an Indian over there.
Those who are able to settle in Canada will be much better off than those in India. Where are the jobs in India? Even army job is now a 4 year contract
@@RMNewton992 I agree. But one who is earning a decent lively hood in India would have a greater to chance to excel within India itself. I personally know 4 people who've returned because they had a base in India.
One who is struggling would have a greater chance in Canada to improve his condition.
@@arjunnarula2978 what you said is true to some extent, I for one example had decent earnings(1.5L per month )in India but when I got the chance to move to Canada, I took it without a second thought. I work in the same field in Canada and I make decent money. So money wise the improvement is not too pronounced but my living standards have improved drastically. Clean. Dust free and beautiful nature. I live in a normal neighborhood and I have to tell you that it’s better than those multi crore properties of India. Those could have a better interior but they don’t even come close when it comes to outside.
He tried to scam his way into Canada. A genuine candidate will not be scammed.
@@arjunnarula2978 Problem is over population, corruption, low wags and high inflation and future population explosion 💥. India is great, but these problems will make it unliveable for people.
The immigration/Travel agent from India (especially Punjab, Haryana & Gujarat), the immigration/Travel agent from Canada, and the so-called 1 classroom university are the culprits who lure students with the Canadian dream and get money from them. They should be checked for authenticity if found illegal, fined & the license canceled, and give them harsh punishment. for destroying these student's career.
You are asking for the Moon bro.
Just a suggestion - don't think "repatriating" is the right word to use here.
This type of mistake seems to be common amongst a number of Print journalists/ presenters. It may be due to low quality education.
It's not an industry, it's a racket
Sorry but the truth is because of Punjab all relations between Canada and India was ruined, keeping the Khalistan issue aside, everything else from Punjab has been low skilled immigrants. It’s really made it worse for everyone
I am surprised by the level of English of the students. It will be hard to get jobs for them in Canada or USA. They need to move beyond IELTS into spoken English
Punjabis don’t want to live in Punjab lol
Soon they will demand a free Bramptonistan.
They don't even want to live in Canada. They just want the pr so they can go to some next country to sabotage that country as well.
Oh people in India, Zambia, Pakistan, Bangladesh etc please ask your governments to have solid policy on Population control.
As a Canadian that manages a company I would like to say that canada has been lying to you about opportunities here. Jobs are not easy to get even for the Canadians with full schooling behind them. This country isn't what you think it is. Protect yourself and work on yourself in your country you will be much happier. Iv had to turn away so many applications and the disappointment is getting hard to watch.
Its not really canada lying to them about the reality they will face here - more like their immigration brokers that work in India that are scamming them into a fake dream. And then they get to Canada and realize everything is obscenely expensive, its impossible to get a job, the weather sucks, and saving money is out of the question; constantly living paycheck to paycheck drowning financially. That is the reality for any Indians moving to canada for these student visas etc.
India has let its young people down. It's really important to invest in the younger generation for the future of the country.
You guys have buggered up Punjab. Spoiled your name in UK , Canada and Australia and thus shamed Indians and India.
What the heck are you talking about?
😢😢Last night, 22 years old young pubjabi guy was stabbed from behind in edmonton by a 40 yrs old man, and sadly, he lost his life in hospital. He is just 22 thinking of a beautiful life in Canada.
It's time India did something so that people feel like living in India rather than escaping India ‼️
Most of these students from Punjab are not even able to speak proper English and select institutions that does not even require any English exam.
This is quite good for India. I have been in all large Candaian cities multiple times in the past 10 years. Almost all kids are from India (with virtually no skills) and are 'studying' at very very shady schools. You should only go to Canada if you have study admit from a top tier university such as UoT or UBC. Else, it will become a nightmare for such kids...
6:28 So, these guys only indulge in protesting. If in India, it is Farmer protest and overseas ‘Give us Visa ‘ protest. Once they get visa, they turn that place into mini Khalistan. Collectively bring down the value of real estate by playing loud music at odd hours. Threatening neighbours with Guns and their religious Kripan and continue to show how much they have been suffering. If you take crime and dishonesty from this community, their total HR value is absolutely zero.
India ko canada bananeke bajaye canada ko india bana diya
Canadian government can make laws. It’s there a right. They can create laws in their own interest
My Punjabi friends tell me now it's the Australian dream..
They wish 😅😅😅
Even Australia has reduced the intake this year with tougher rules than Canada
Aussies are not pussies like Canadians..
Please don’t ruin Australia too
@@johnydesparado123I mean that's on Australia if they make policies for their ruin. These guys will go anywhere.
A drop in international students in Canada would not impact Canada financially. Usually the international students go to private colleges not the public colleges. Furthermore, during the pandemic, international students didn’t have to show they can support themselves while in Canada and they didn’t close that loophole when the restrictions were lifted post pandemic. Then thousands used that loophole to come to Canada because there were no cap on their work hours and the money they had to show that they can support themselves
Superpower Vishvaguru India se youth, do kowri ka mazdoor bann ne Canada Australia jaa rahe hai ..yeh koi garv ki baat hai kya
Sab South Asians aise hi toh hain, kuch toh terror bhi export karte hain.
Punjabis scammed the system
Well known for it Jugad
People are fed up with poverty, casteism, unemployment thats why they leave India... Even rich are leaving becos of lack of security...
Let them leave, this era is of great Indian migration.
@@joyid U mean population control🍀😇
Sirrrr we are punjabi sir not Indian we work in tim hortons and scam system sir just like you sir please accept us sirrrrrrr
Anti immigrant and anti international student sentiment is also on a rise in Canada. So it's good for both sides.
Punjab is stuck in wheat rice, and Bhindranwale for the last 40 years.
India stuck in poverty for ever
You, people, nail your own feet. The Canadian government is only going to be elected if they look Canadian FIRST. Even the Indian diaspora in Canada is saying that🤔🇨🇦
In recent years Canadian government has facilitated useless education shops to make money out of gullible student migrants who pay exorbitant education fees, rents and other living costs to support Canadian economy. There are not enough jobs for this glut student immigration and education quality is poor in many almost cheat colleges with no quality check by Canadian government. The students actually suffer. Greedy consultants in Canada and India misguide and lure them. This immigration policy is also opposed by Canadians. It is good for both India and Canada that a blind open gate immigration via pay for play education route has been reduced.
Find ways to strengthen jobs scenario in India.
Relax and be patient. The real experts predict the US will increase visas (across categories) for Indian citizens after the election in November, regardless of the winner. Both parties are very enthusiastic about increasing Indian immigrants and decreasing Chinese immigrants 👍
You’re overly optimistic 😂😂😂good luck with that thought!!
Solution for you guys is to apply for PR after finishing school go back to India and apply what you learned. What you is to work not to study in Canada.
International Punjab students think it will be not possible after returning back to india
I thank Trudeau and his failed governance for saving Punjab. After all these years of immigrating and working for dollars our youth finally understands that at the time of peril they're nothing but a scapegoat. Even people who immigrated 5-6 years ago and have gotten their PR are now cursing and blaming those exact students they once were themselves. Trudeau and his administration is at fault not the students.
Will affect Khalistani funding too.
NOP!!! Khalistani funding is from Punjab!! Money from Pakistani drug smuggled and sold in Punjab!!
I might be wrong.But only solution of Punjab will be highlighting and discussing more with Punjabi politician and academics. irony Punjab was the land of iconic Punjab university which given Hargovind Khurana (Nobel Laurate) many scientist great schools like DAV. It’s pathetic to see land of greats like Sir Ganga Ram, Mahatma Hansraj, Lala Lajpat Rai is turned into so mess.
My Sikh friend from MP is data scientist at Amazon making 30 LPA and here in Europe I have seen Sikh kids in flock can’t speak proper English spending 40-50 lakh for studies here.
Everyone has right for better life but there should be logical cost for it.
Meet a girl done MBA from Birmingham City University working in subway for 22G as she get 5 yrs visa sponsership.
I got abused earlier to comment better to get experience in India as doctor or engineer in Bangalore, Gurgaon and come here on great package. Hope i will invite those comments again.
People of Punjab have lot of entrepreneurial skills and work hard. They could build good life and businesses in Punjab itself which would boost the state
Good job by Canada. Every country should consider their own citizen's first not the outsiders.
What is baffling is why is it such sadness on this so called wilting of the terrible Canadian nightmare, I also think that this actually can be a blessing in disguise and a chance for our governments to strap up there boots and create better opportunities in Punjab itself rather than being sloppy & lazy which they are, also good time for Canada to get a reality check.
Good thing for Punjab ✌🏻
Punjab’s Canada dream became Canada’s nightmare.
It also became a nightmare for these poor students themselves and people coming from Punjab and elsewhere.
They were lied to by immigration consultants.
What Mr. Malhotra is saying in this video is incorrect:
1. Canada’s economy is not being run by international students. It’s a massive exaggeration and a baseless claim. Many students are told this and they somehow start feeling way too important just to be woken up by a rude shock of reality. That’s unfair to them !
2. This change is not political. This change is there to stay. This rise in student population was mainly allowed to compensate for post covid labor shortages. Sorry to be blunt but for Canada these students were low wage unskilled workers. Their $20,000 fee might be important to that cheap college but not even a drop in the bucket for a G-10 economy. They all were sent to diploma level studies at cheap, low ranking colleges. None of them were recruited in 4 year bachelor or Maters level degrees in universities. Immigration consultants knew that. How can one expect to land PR from a private 3 room college or at best a community college studying some 6-12 months HR diploma and working minimum wake job at McDonald’s while Canadian and international student university Graduates with degrees in business, IT and engineering are struggling.
That said, the next government is expected to be of Conservatives. So please make a guess yourself.
What he is saying is just based in his own opinions. Please please research the data on jobs, economy and cost of living before taking any decisions which can cost you not just a lot of money but many years of your precious youth wasted chasing an unrealistic dream just to be back to square one empty handed.
This is no big deal.
Canada is full. All Punjabis dont come to Canada
Ha ha as if anyone will listen. You have to do it through policies not request. You guys may have democracy but you guys make sht immigrant policies.
Indians are hated in Canada
Australia me meri beti 2016 me gayi thi. 2022 me wapis aana pada . Australia govt ne koi help nahi Kari. Unke rules hai follow to karna padega.
Great to see all our global communities making their contribution towards international cultural enrichment.
Forge & Fake Agency will make Huge Money 💰
Stay in India. why so crazy to go abroad?
Here is few reason - In Kaneda - dollars hidden under snow, White girls are too eager to sleep with SARDARji, White people LOVE India/Gandhi/Taj mahal/ Chicken butter & Samosa, Weed/Ganja is sold in local shops, Once in Kaneda you can go to Aamrika no questions asked, Tremendous Labour shortage, Brampton & Surrey is Poonjabi town, Kanedian Govt. protecting all the criminals from Poonjab. Finally just RECAH on Toronto Pearson Airport and PM Jastinder Singhji Trudeauwal will come to carry your luggage!! Just reach Kaneda!!
Why canada taking workers from outside because skilled workforce are not sufficient to run their businesses at canada. In between May 2024 to Dec 24 nearly 536505 work permits are set to expire who were invited to work under INTERNATIONAL MOBILITY PROGRAM. 70000 temporary permits of students also expired . Now Getting pr under express entry is very difficult due to high csr score and expenses are above the mark. No part-time work,No field work on pgwp . Now visa rejection %is 55%.Gic is double . Mut jao abhi Paisa dubega.
These countries were doing a great favour to India taking
Trudeau abandoned the point system which helped us get the right immigrants. Now we have half of India here. Every outlet I go to I have to hear an Indian accent
Punjab's Canada dream is wilting. Yup, spread the word.
Good for Mann. The number of punjabis abusing Modi will increase substantially in Punjab.
Why can’t anyone criticise Modi. He may be god for you but not for majority of Indians, this bhakt mentality has led Indian economy to mediocre growth economically . Criticism of politicians is must in a healthy democracy.
@@karate2252 We don't have the "Bhakt" mentality. It is you Sikhs who have the Bhakt mentality. You people oppose the desecration of your stupid Granth Sahib. This shows it is you who are Bhakts, not us.
@@karate2252 you guys have irrational hate against modi and BJP, that's problem
@@karate2252your hate against Modi reeks of your hatred of Hindus due to narrative that you have been fed. Tell me one thing that Modi did to harm sikhs
@@karate2252 True but praising those who bring tons of freebies instead of focusing on capex is what really plays a role in mediocre growth
In Australia a major chunk of students who come here in last 25 years, their focus was to get a PR and Australian government played along as the economy was balanced out. You pass out as an Accountant, but could get a PR and choose to be a retailer, logistics, hotelier or property dealer. Australia is now acting as its impacting the local population's job opportunities and housing options.
Canada always was a welcoming country, the problem is that those recent years it was to much people for the capacity that Canada can provide, most of people come in big cities and those suffer because of prices increase, the demand exceeds the offer, and also to many people put pressure on healthcare systems and other services…to much of a good thing makes it bad…but Canada hopefully will go through this crisis and be welcoming again with kept in mind to never accept more than you can support….most of us we don’t hate people we hate bad situations and bad decisions.
Stop doing lame jobs in western countries and boasting about it. Do stay in your home country. Lots of opportunities are there in India.
There are no elections in Australia at least this year..the next federal elections are on 27th September 2025😊.
That is only if they elect house of representatives , but usually half senate elections are also held at the same time , its gonna be in May 2025
Let them go and make Khalisthan there instead sitting on the border of UP, Haryana
India no 1 in population, but nobody in Olympics inspite having 140 crore population. Its not helping India or countries if you are migrating unless you are higly skilled.
All thanks to corrupt politicians and bureaucrats who only want to fund their own dreams with the money spent on sports in India. But population is a bigger problem here and human beings have always migrated in search of greener pasture since the beginning. I believe Canada should get its laws tighter before these middlemen get people in via the loopholes in the immigration system.
Actually indians suck ...but on the other hand Punjabis are super athletic and add value to the west...gujratis just scam😊
Australia and Canada are no longer the best countries for foreign students to get permanent residency. In AUS, visa hopping is no longer allowed! Once your visa is expired, you have to go back to your country and apply again for another type of visa! Students have to passed English test too!
I've had an Indian student workmate his English was SO BAD it was like he was speaking Tamil Klingon gibberish and the only words that I understood was "yes', "no" and "oke"
Canada is trying to help India by educating its young so they can build a great india country. JUst like China has done. Don't give up on your country. Only the young can change it.
these are precisely the type of guys who misguided the students in the first place
Of course when you increase immigration from 500,000 a year to over a million year. There us already housing, health care and unemployment issue. So certainly a million more will makes things worse.
It is not just election but Canadians have been exceeding patient. Trudeau and Liberals have used immigration as vote bank politics.
India should cancel the OCI card of any Canadian of Indian origin if such an individual was in any way associated with the Khalistani movement. Further, any family of such an individual also should be canceled. All such people should be banned from ever entering India. That way, their only option would be to fight for a Khalistan in Canada which is always supporting them and it should be easy to get their Khalistan there.
These immigration consultants need to go back to having real jobs. Like scam calling.
Canada can have Khalistani supporters 😅😂😂
Honestly Canada needed once upon time working class not educated class Punjab fill the gap in USA South America usually fill this gap . Nothing wrong now Canada is on recession.
Kindly teach these people about civic sense.
ਪੰਜਾਬੀ ਉਦੋਂ ਤੱਕ ਰੁਕਦੇ ਨਹੀਂ ਜਦ ਤੱਕ ਸਭ ਕੁੱਝ ਦਾ ਬੇੜਾ ਨਾ ਗਰਕ ਕਰਨ।
Reminded me of a Doordarshan News feature from the 80s
People would start flooding/going into another country perhaps 😮
Thank God. Please stay in Punjab. There are no jobs, no housing for average Canadian’s. We can’t allow professional student Uber drivers and Tim Hortons workers.
Feel bad for genuine aspirants but there are many who are not genuine and destroy the image of Punjabis and Indians overseas. They are loud, rude, leave a mess wherever they go
. So not surprised that Canada and other countries are trying to be mindful of students from these parts of India.
Canada have a far smaller population than India, we cannot take everyone that wanted to come here, if we take in too many, that can make conditions here as bad or worse than your home country. A student visa is a permit to allow you to study here, then hopefully, armed with the knowledge of the education, you will go home and make the best of it. It must not be a back door way for you to jump the queue to get in as immigrant. The rules were changed because there were too many of you abusing it and is a right of any country to change the rules. India have the same rights. We do not have the jobs or housing for all of you and we should not be supporting you here forever through welfare. The Muslims already made us wise to that trick.
We are full . Stay in India
I have met some punjabis in Australia who cant even speak proper english... Only prefer to stay in their community.. speak very limited english. No importance on education even after coming here... dont know why they come.... they are hardworking bo doubt but thoda padai pe dhayan de to acha hai... I am not against anyone.. just want their best....