For 6:30, you compared O and S; couldn't you argue that O is more stable because its more EN? Or are these two methods of evaluating basicity relative to the atom rule? Size being the most important factor compared to EN? Size takes priority over E.N? Or does it have to do with what you're given; if you're given something in the same row you know they're the same size so you have to evaluate with EN. If EN does not differentiate then move on to the Resonance rule correct?
I think size definitely trumps electronegativity. Having more surface area to distribute the charge over makes it more comfortable without a hydrogen than the smaller oxygen
The Legendary Chad
very nicely explained
Thank you.
when determining the orbitals atoms have, do we taking into account whats around the interested atom AND the lone pairs?
yes exactly - how many atoms are attached to it and how many lone pairs does it have
For 6:30, you compared O and S; couldn't you argue that O is more stable because its more EN? Or are these two methods of evaluating basicity relative to the atom rule? Size being the most important factor compared to EN? Size takes priority over E.N?
Or does it have to do with what you're given; if you're given something in the same row you know they're the same size so you have to evaluate with EN. If EN does not differentiate then move on to the Resonance rule correct?
I think size definitely trumps electronegativity. Having more surface area to distribute the charge over makes it more comfortable without a hydrogen than the smaller oxygen
Thanks
You're welcome, Phinias!
Saint Chad
Sainthood? They must have lowered their requirements!😜 Happy studying!