As a Bombers fan , I'm insulated you put Merrett in B tier. He is such a big improvement from Dyson . He is leading by example and his he is good with the media . Dyson wasn't a good captain last year and up until now Zach is a big improvement
Great list Cados, would put almost all of them in the exact same spot. Glad you moved Dawson up to A tier and agree with Toby Greene being underrated. Moore best captain in the league this season. 👍👍
It was Pendles who directed Daicos to stay in the middle before Geordies second goal. Directed many of the positional changes as well. Deserved to be a premiership captain and would have been if he didn’t step down. Such a shame that we lost in 18 as well when he was captain.
Harris was vice for a couple years but he has been leading the backline for the last few years too and is often the one we depend on down back. Zorko was our best player after beams had his issues and stood down crom captaincy (zorko was also all aus in 2017 too). Zorko has been injured recently so harris has stepped up but was always next in line to he captain. Wont be shocked if dunkley becomes captain in a year or two and then ashcroft tbh
Parker’s gotta be in at least A tier he is the bloods culture. But great list, good call on Toby last couple of seasons sinces he’s stopped getting suspended for stupid things he’s been an incredible leader for the giants
Can agree with where you put Jonas. Very inconsistent this year. Even though I am a port fan I 100% agree with you. Although I am happy to see if he finally gets to return this round
Great vid dos. The reason brayshaw and Serling weren’t voted as captain was because they are still very young and aren’t very well experienced like Pearce is, if they were a bit older and had been in the game for longer, no sound they would be probably vice captains and stuff
Cripps has lots of confidence in the club after not making a finals appearance in his whole AFL Career. Hopefully the Blue Baggers have some success over the captaincy of Cripps time
As a Swans fan I'll be honest you've done our captains dirty. Mills i can get as a B, maybe in a year or 2 he'll be A tier but Parker should be at least an A borderline S tier, one of the most courageous captains in the AFL and a great leader. And if this tier list was in 2019 then i get Rampe being where you put him but he's definitely got those weird acts out if his game since that year so you can't use what happened 4 years ago as an argument to put him in D. He grown more and more as a captain and without his leadership in defense we look lost and miss his presence. Plus we've had the whole "3 captains" thing for as long as i can remember and at 2 captain's since our premiership year in 05, it's kind of like a tradition to have multiple captains at our club each year. Also Dawson was not a fringe player by the time he left Sydney. He missed 3 total games in his final 3 years at Sydney and literally finished 3rd in our B&F in his last season with the Swans. Some people in the media act like he wasn't good at all in Sydney 🤦♂️
Zero ball knowledge if you think Dawson was a ''fringe'' player at Sydney He came 3rd in Sydney's best and fairest the year he left and was traded for a first round pick ...
Good work cados personally in my opinion Marcus bontempelli is the best captain since I’m a doggies fan but… I feel that big max Gawn makes a great captain but I also think patty crips has alot of potential to help his boys bring home a granny
I think its honestly insane that Green wasn't even a co-captain till last season and this is his first season as the only captain, he has felt like the Giants skipper for about 5 years.
I would personally put Neale and danger in b tier not a. Great footballers but don't think there as good as captains plus both of them started off and played many games for other teams other than that good list cados
Logan Mcdonald probably rated a bit too high here. Would have simpkin above him. Don't know why LDU is not captain. If Baker is Richmond captain next year, surely he will be S tier
Darcy Moore is so far infront on Dangerfield it isn’t funny. Geelong had a poor start to the year due to Dangerfield not being ready to take the reigns.
luke shuey lead west g=coast to a premiership and one the norm smith. Just becuse the eagles arent doing well now doesnt mean hes a bad captain should at least be a B
I’m a gIants fan and Not being bias but Toby Greene is the best and one of the most underrated players in general in the AFL, as I said I’m not being bias and you’ll hear it from every commentator and other teams, love the list though ❤
Richmond fan but Nank is too high. Undisciplined and unnecessary acts resulting in 50m penalties, free kicks and suspensions (even before Thursday night), plus he's not the best public speaker (BT would agree) and just doesn't set the example I would want for my club... Cotchin was S tier though, on and off field champion.
As a Bombers fan , I'm insulated you put Merrett in B tier. He is such a big improvement from Dyson . He is leading by example and his he is good with the media .
Dyson wasn't a good captain last year and up until now Zach is a big improvement
Agree up the dons🔴⚫️
Was better than Dyson day one. Wouldn't put him higher than B yet though
prime heppel was good
Merrett should be an A
Merrett done dirty in B, deserves at least A.
Yeah
Ture
100%
S tier
Facts
Love that you have Sicily at A
Have a feeling as we grow in our rebuild he'll soon become S tier
Doso’s Demons 😈 v TikTok Tigers 🐯
Coming out in 2 weeks 🤝
Yesss
Great list Cados, would put almost all of them in the exact same spot. Glad you moved Dawson up to A tier and agree with Toby Greene being underrated. Moore best captain in the league this season. 👍👍
Good to see Darcy Moore up the top but Pendle's efforts in the Grand Final would suggest he is still captain material as well.
It was Pendles who directed Daicos to stay in the middle before Geordies second goal.
Directed many of the positional changes as well.
Deserved to be a premiership captain and would have been if he didn’t step down.
Such a shame that we lost in 18 as well when he was captain.
Harris was vice for a couple years but he has been leading the backline for the last few years too and is often the one we depend on down back. Zorko was our best player after beams had his issues and stood down crom captaincy (zorko was also all aus in 2017 too). Zorko has been injured recently so harris has stepped up but was always next in line to he captain. Wont be shocked if dunkley becomes captain in a year or two and then ashcroft tbh
merrett b taking the piss caden
He's growing on me! Love how he speaks in the media, putting together a crazy season too
Love the respect for Jordan Dawson no one knows how good his leadership is
Parker’s gotta be in at least A tier he is the bloods culture.
But great list, good call on Toby last couple of seasons sinces he’s stopped getting suspended for stupid things he’s been an incredible leader for the giants
Moore should have his own category. I'm not even a collingwood supporter. He even inspires other teams to lose for him
Merrett has to be S teir
great list @cados love your work brother need to link up for a goal kicking comp this year sometime !!!
Can agree with where you put Jonas. Very inconsistent this year. Even though I am a port fan I 100% agree with you. Although I am happy to see if he finally gets to return this round
Such a great player for a long time 💪🏻
@@CadenMacDonald yeah sad to see him out but he probably knows that it is the best interest of the team
Sicily has an incredible impact on our team.
I need to ask this because I go for crows would you call crows a popular team because 🤷♂️ idk
Go crows
Melbourne demands are average
Maxy deserves S i reckon, its not bias from you i go for richmond and i reckon max is a top 3 captain in the league
Can you please do more updated versions of some of your old tiermakers like ranking coaches, forwards, etc.
Great vid dos. The reason brayshaw and Serling weren’t voted as captain was because they are still very young and aren’t very well experienced like Pearce is, if they were a bit older and had been in the game for longer, no sound they would be probably vice captains and stuff
also pearce essentially captained freo last year when fyfe was constantly injured
Cripps has lots of confidence in the club after not making a finals appearance in his whole AFL Career. Hopefully the Blue Baggers have some success over the captaincy of Cripps time
As a Swans fan I'll be honest you've done our captains dirty. Mills i can get as a B, maybe in a year or 2 he'll be A tier but Parker should be at least an A borderline S tier, one of the most courageous captains in the AFL and a great leader. And if this tier list was in 2019 then i get Rampe being where you put him but he's definitely got those weird acts out if his game since that year so you can't use what happened 4 years ago as an argument to put him in D. He grown more and more as a captain and without his leadership in defense we look lost and miss his presence. Plus we've had the whole "3 captains" thing for as long as i can remember and at 2 captain's since our premiership year in 05, it's kind of like a tradition to have multiple captains at our club each year.
Also Dawson was not a fringe player by the time he left Sydney. He missed 3 total games in his final 3 years at Sydney and literally finished 3rd in our B&F in his last season with the Swans. Some people in the media act like he wasn't good at all in Sydney 🤦♂️
Moore 🐐 🐐 🐐
Moore best captain followed by Bont
Zero ball knowledge if you think Dawson was a ''fringe'' player at Sydney
He came 3rd in Sydney's best and fairest the year he left and was traded for a first round pick ...
I love the Bont great to see him in s tier
Good work cados personally in my opinion Marcus bontempelli is the best captain since I’m a doggies fan but… I feel that big max Gawn makes a great captain but I also think patty crips has alot of potential to help his boys bring home a granny
I think its honestly insane that Green wasn't even a co-captain till last season and this is his first season as the only captain, he has felt like the Giants skipper for about 5 years.
Love the vids. Great tier list!
Harris Andrews was our vice captain n and in the leadership group but this year is his first year as captain.
Great video enjoyed it and good to be back commenting on videos
You should put Max gawn in s tier he is a great player but no hate great tier list keep it up
I would personally put Neale and danger in b tier not a.
Great footballers but don't think there as good as captains plus both of them started off and played many games for other teams other than that good list cados
Swans fan from the states and I don’t understand the three captain thing. Just pick between Parker or Mills until Gulden or Warner are ready for it.
I think Cados is going to get a concussion from running through this many brick walls!
Hey dados love the videos you’ve really improved the quality.
Appreciate it mate, We're slowly getting there!
I reckon ur Tier maker list is great
100% agree with Toby Greene he is such a gun but although I am a giant supporter
If there in the AFL there a s tier players
Nice vid cados nice and entertaining also new to channel
Even tho freos my fav team Pearce is probably our worst captain we’ve ever had
McDonald above Simpkin when North fans are calling for him to be dropped is funny
Love this, agree with the tierlist fully
Merrett 🔛🔝
Good vid dos, but with Nankervis he wasn’t the captain at the time, if he was he would of talked to BT because he’s the captain so yeah.
Luke shuey is a A tier captain but he just always injured
Dawsons a goat 🐐 no cap 🧢
He’s grown on me massively
No match day vlog from the lions game??? 😂❤
Love love the vids mate keep it up ❤️❤️
Cheers finn!
dawson was the most underrated caption at the start of the year
Do the ladder predictor for the rest of the season
Would Joel Selwood be s tier for you?
absolutely
this is fire cados keep it up 🔥
Gawny is the only current premiership captain and you rate him A. Should be a S mate 😮
Who’s your favourite captain apart from gone caden??
Darcy Moore probably
Yeah def. I was there in Anzac Day and he spoke so well, I’ve never seen a captain speak like that before
Lmac is a VFL quality player. Coming from a north fan
You are amazing I forgot to say
Logan Mcdonald probably rated a bit too high here. Would have simpkin above him. Don't know why LDU is not captain. If Baker is Richmond captain next year, surely he will be S tier
I'd have Merrett at least in A and knocking on the door of S.
B for zack morn like A
Bit stiff on Merritt
huge W for sicily
As a blues fan, Darcy Moore is the best captain in the leauge
tbh honest, i think dangerfield should be s, not the best but his prime was some of the best prime ever. dunno abt darcy moore call tho
Darcy Moore is so far infront on Dangerfield it isn’t funny. Geelong had a poor start to the year due to Dangerfield not being ready to take the reigns.
The shuey one was funny cause you put him in C and then talk about he’s a great player and leader😂
Dawson should be in S imop
great work keep on going
Merrett in B? He has been essendons best player by far this year, I would say bottom of A personally
idc what anyone says Parker is an S
Shuey is a premiership captain, he should be instant S, same as Gawn
Another great vid💪
luke shuey lead west g=coast to a premiership and one the norm smith. Just becuse the eagles arent doing well now doesnt mean hes a bad captain should at least be a B
Harris Andrews was Vice-Captain at one point
If Neale said run into a brick wall would you?
Yeah, Merrett is done very dirty, he is a great captain who deserves S or A
Toby Green, what about his dog and the bad sportsmanship to the umpires
Good vid thanks for making vids
you have to admit caden is the best afl youtuber
Great vid cados but just saying you forgot Tom stewet
I reckon he’s a Vice Captain, in a year or two I’ll do it again when he’s in!
@@CadenMacDonald fair enough go Melbourne for tommorow night even tho I’m a Richmond supporter
Toby Greene in S? Very unpopular opinion like you said.
Merret is a solid ssss tier up the dons
toby easy s
Cant wait
when u said whos been a captain for a long time u forgot pendles
Yep, spot on, Fyfe too. So many changes this year
I’m a gIants fan and Not being bias but Toby Greene is the best and one of the most underrated players in general in the AFL, as I said I’m not being bias and you’ll hear it from every commentator and other teams, love the list though ❤
you need to continue on from your afl evolution 2 career in afl 23
Good vid cados
Ollie wines has been done dirty for not making the list
Moore, then Daylight
Richmond fan but Nank is too high. Undisciplined and unnecessary acts resulting in 50m penalties, free kicks and suspensions (even before Thursday night), plus he's not the best public speaker (BT would agree) and just doesn't set the example I would want for my club... Cotchin was S tier though, on and off field champion.
Great video
Dos Banger Again!
pre watch, if pearce isnt last i might rethink life
Nice one
I’d put Parker in A coz he’s been a captain since 2020
So?That dosent change anything
@@AFL_NBA it does, he is more experienced than most of theses captains
harris was vice before. captain first time
Maxi in A is an F for Cados
Srsly, how can you not put Big Maxi in S tier?
Swap Luke Mcdonald and sympkin around and the list is good
Merret and Gawn up a tier and Sicily down because he’s undisciplined
Reckon youll get the dub today? I do