Thank you so much for comparing this to Mercury Retrograde, I knew they were twinsies! While I do like Disney, this collection is a pass because Mercury Retrograde is already in my collection and much loved. Thank you again 😊
Gosh, I love this palette. My Ulta put it out too early and I grabbed the palette, the blush color you also like best, and the lighter highlighter and I've been using them all. I think the palette is a great affordable alternative to Mercury Retrograde, which I still haven't picked up. I really like the look of the layout, but I wonder if the diamonds are giving us less product. I think it works pretty well with the Muppets palette too. I totally would have gotten one or 2 of the lip stains if they were split up. Don't need all 4. I definitely have warm Disney park feels, thought I'm not into this particular ride. I think these colors and the packaging fit it perfectly, though. I'm personally hoping they'll do a Haunted Mansion collection with greens and purples.
Thank you so much for all the swatch comparisons, especially for the blushes and highlighters! I ended up picking up almost the entire collection, except for the light pink blush and rose gold highlighter. 🙈 I know I didn't need the palette because I already have Mercury Retrograde, but I like the idea of having a more "travel-friendly" option of my favorite color story.
I do have a lot of warm nostalgic feelings about this ride. (Yes, it's at WDW in the Magic Kingdom.) The cookie guy is a big part of the theming. I think the square/circle shapes in the palette really go with the theming, too. OTOH, I'm not going to buy it because I have too many palettes and I'm sure I already have all of those colors.
The shimmer on the lip stains has been done before! I have one from the Tinkerbell collection that I used recently and it has tiny glitter sparkles throughout it. It's very subtle tho so if anyone who's reading this wants more sparkle, I'd suggest topping a clear shimmery gloss over it
OMG I HAVE Mercury Retrograde and I still bought this. Should have waited for your review!! But, I do have fondness for the ride. My grandparents took me to WDW for the first time when I was 14 and even though I thought I was "too old" for it, I went on that ride with them.🥰
Love the shoutout to the Eat 'n Park Smiley cookies! I'm from Pittsburgh and didn't think anyone not from the tri-state area knew about them. :) Great video as usual, Amanda. 💜
I am with you on that deja Vu feeling with this from it's similarity to the mercury retrograde palette. Thank you for identifying that connection. I like the ride, but I don't need a dupe for a palette I already own. It's my grandma-in-law's favorite ride, so my husband is the one with fond childhood memories of it.
Love the look you created. I am obsessed with watching you tippy tap those tiny little brushes on your eyelids. I can't even explain why I find it so mesmerizing!! Thanks for all of the detail and hard work you put into these videos 💜
Ngl I was sooo tempted by some of these products but I was waiting on your review and comparisons to make my decision bc I just made a CP order and the babycakes heart blush was one of the items I picked up so it's good to know I won't accidentally buy a repeat. I'd love to see a comparison with the coast to coast blush from the mauve collection and the vogue blush from the dark blooms collection. I have those two mauvy, cool-toned shades but I don't know how these are different from the ones in this collection, if they even are. If you're doing more swatch comparisons on your ig pls let me know!
im really interested in the lip stains. i love those generally and i like a shimmery lip. i just wish they would have released them individually because i would only get two of them if i could. i dont like when they make you buy a whole set of something.
This channel should be called "I love your face" because it's such a trademark of yours! I like the color story of the palette, but the pan size collage is not for a Virgo like me. Also, since I have so many ColorPop palettes, a new palette needs to check all my boxes; (packaging + quality + color story) for me to actually want it, because one or two good shades is not going to do it.
I think they did previously have the shimmer in the Glossy Lip Stains from the Tinkerbelle collection as well. (Tinkerbelle was pinky nude and Clap if You Believe was more true nude) I should know. I have all of them, and it’s my favorite lip formula. Lol. Obviously bought the set. I also got two blushes and will get the third and the highlighter in the future. The palette wasn’t vegan, but I was ok with that as the odd pans drove me crazy. Lol. Love watching all your videos! ❤
Hey Amanda I love the ride but not this collection! I have the Mercury Retrograde palette so I don’t think I need this! Thanks Amanda! I saw they are releasing a new mega palette ! Can’t wait for your review 😊
I always love staying to the very end of your videos, so silly & uplifting lol ❤️ I honestly did not even think of mercury retrograde, I knew it looked similar, but once you showed it I was like that's what it was! Lol
Hey Amanda love your videos. I am wondering about the lip stains, my teeth are a bit crooked and leave marks on my lips so I can’t really wear lip stick without it coming off on my teeth. Do you think the lip stains would be a good option for me to add some color to my lips and not my teeth?
Oh man I DO have strong feelings about It’s a Small World. I hate that ride! It’s so creepy. 😂 The packaging and layout/pan shapes seem very on brand though. They did a good job. Still gonna skip it though. Thanks for the comparisons. Gonna go bust out my mercury retrograde and So Jaded palettes. On the other hand I did order the Muppets collab and I have absolutely no ties to that. Just really liked that color story.
Love the review but I think I’ll pass on this collection. Though I love Disney, I have an unfortunate memory of a trip from the park, going on this ride which is in Disney World FYI. My family got stuck on the ride for almost 2 hours so the music which is fun for a short colorful ride now makes me shutter a bit lol. When I went back as an adult later I avoid that whole section lol but did go with my kid when he wanted to ride it. Super fun for the kids and nostalgic memories
I immediately thought of Mercury Retrograde when I saw this! I loved It’s a Small World. I grew up in CA and was able to go often. I feel like this could have been more special but I’m thinking they couldn’t make it like the ride due to cultural appropriation. That said, I still would not have bought it because I have Mercury Retrograde.
Does colorpop always charge $22 for their 12 pan palettes? That's not as affordable as I thought! (I don't buy colorpop because shipping is too expensive)
What happened with the shimmers? Like the midnight masquerade was 10 times better and was released a few years before. Also the new glitter, in the so jaded had a lot of colours mixed. And the new one is plan. Colourpop please🙏🙏
I am not the target audience for this release. I have never been to Disney Land and I always found the It's A Small World song to be super annoying. I'm an elder millennial and have no connection to that part of Disney lore. The retro packaging is cute, but I hate the reflective paper around the eyeshadow. But I love your face!
Yay, another review 🥳 Still have Mercury Retrograde in my collection, though some of the formulas are starting to feel a bit off. It might not last much longer 🥲 Got great use out of it while it lasted though and have your glowing review to thank for picking it up!
Thank you so much for comparing this to Mercury Retrograde, I knew they were twinsies! While I do like Disney, this collection is a pass because Mercury Retrograde is already in my collection and much loved. Thank you again 😊
Thank YOU for watching I'm happy to help! 💜💜
That palette color story is actually pretty cute! Dang! Thx!! ⭐🌍⭐
Gosh, I love this palette. My Ulta put it out too early and I grabbed the palette, the blush color you also like best, and the lighter highlighter and I've been using them all. I think the palette is a great affordable alternative to Mercury Retrograde, which I still haven't picked up. I really like the look of the layout, but I wonder if the diamonds are giving us less product. I think it works pretty well with the Muppets palette too. I totally would have gotten one or 2 of the lip stains if they were split up. Don't need all 4. I definitely have warm Disney park feels, thought I'm not into this particular ride. I think these colors and the packaging fit it perfectly, though. I'm personally hoping they'll do a Haunted Mansion collection with greens and purples.
love the eyelook
I'm late here but so glad to always be able to watch your videos before purchasing something!
This collection is super cute! The Mercury Retrograde comparison stunned me in a good way!
Thank you so much for all the swatch comparisons, especially for the blushes and highlighters! I ended up picking up almost the entire collection, except for the light pink blush and rose gold highlighter. 🙈 I know I didn't need the palette because I already have Mercury Retrograde, but I like the idea of having a more "travel-friendly" option of my favorite color story.
I do have a lot of warm nostalgic feelings about this ride. (Yes, it's at WDW in the Magic Kingdom.) The cookie guy is a big part of the theming. I think the square/circle shapes in the palette really go with the theming, too. OTOH, I'm not going to buy it because I have too many palettes and I'm sure I already have all of those colors.
The shimmer on the lip stains has been done before! I have one from the Tinkerbell collection that I used recently and it has tiny glitter sparkles throughout it. It's very subtle tho so if anyone who's reading this wants more sparkle, I'd suggest topping a clear shimmery gloss over it
You've gotten me addicted to the Fresh Kiss Lip Stains, I have most of them and am very excited about this kit. :) Thanks for swatching! :D
You are truly a makeup genius for comparisons!! Thank you!!
OMG I HAVE Mercury Retrograde and I still bought this. Should have waited for your review!! But, I do have fondness for the ride. My grandparents took me to WDW for the first time when I was 14 and even though I thought I was "too old" for it, I went on that ride with them.🥰
I loved your review. I just found your videos from the collaboration with Angie . I liked and subscribed 💜
Thank you so much! Happy to have you here 😊
Good morning Amanda!! Excited to see and hear your review on this! Hope you have an amazing day! 💜 😊
Good morning Christa! 💜
Love the shoutout to the Eat 'n Park Smiley cookies! I'm from Pittsburgh and didn't think anyone not from the tri-state area knew about them. :) Great video as usual, Amanda. 💜
I grew up in West Virginia and went to WVU… Eat n Park was def an important part of my college experience 🤣🙌
I am with you on that deja Vu feeling with this from it's similarity to the mercury retrograde palette. Thank you for identifying that connection. I like the ride, but I don't need a dupe for a palette I already own. It's my grandma-in-law's favorite ride, so my husband is the one with fond childhood memories of it.
Thanks for sharing!!
Not into this collection, but I still enjoyed the video and I just wanna say that I love your face too 😁
Love the look you created. I am obsessed with watching you tippy tap those tiny little brushes on your eyelids. I can't even explain why I find it so mesmerizing!! Thanks for all of the detail and hard work you put into these videos 💜
Ngl I was sooo tempted by some of these products but I was waiting on your review and comparisons to make my decision bc I just made a CP order and the babycakes heart blush was one of the items I picked up so it's good to know I won't accidentally buy a repeat. I'd love to see a comparison with the coast to coast blush from the mauve collection and the vogue blush from the dark blooms collection. I have those two mauvy, cool-toned shades but I don't know how these are different from the ones in this collection, if they even are. If you're doing more swatch comparisons on your ig pls let me know!
im really interested in the lip stains. i love those generally and i like a shimmery lip. i just wish they would have released them individually because i would only get two of them if i could. i dont like when they make you buy a whole set of something.
I like how you matched your sweater/ top to your eye colors
Thank you Amanda for another interesting review! 🤩
Always glad to see another of your videos.
This channel should be called "I love your face" because it's such a trademark of yours! I like the color story of the palette, but the pan size collage is not for a Virgo like me. Also, since I have so many ColorPop palettes, a new palette needs to check all my boxes; (packaging + quality + color story) for me to actually want it, because one or two good shades is not going to do it.
We went to Disney for the first time this yr so I quite like this collection, would only want two of the blushers tho. Another fab video x
I think this just encouraged me to buy the Mercury Retrograde palette 😅 but I want the blushes! I might have to pick them up at Ulta
I think they did previously have the shimmer in the Glossy Lip Stains from the Tinkerbelle collection as well. (Tinkerbelle was pinky nude and Clap if You Believe was more true nude) I should know. I have all of them, and it’s my favorite lip formula. Lol. Obviously bought the set. I also got two blushes and will get the third and the highlighter in the future. The palette wasn’t vegan, but I was ok with that as the odd pans drove me crazy. Lol. Love watching all your videos! ❤
Hey Amanda I love the ride but not this collection! I have the Mercury Retrograde palette so I don’t think I need this! Thanks Amanda! I saw they are releasing a new mega palette ! Can’t wait for your review 😊
I always love staying to the very end of your videos, so silly & uplifting lol ❤️ I honestly did not even think of mercury retrograde, I knew it looked similar, but once you showed it I was like that's what it was! Lol
Thank you so much!!
Hey Amanda love your videos. I am wondering about the lip stains, my teeth are a bit crooked and leave marks on my lips so I can’t really wear lip stick without it coming off on my teeth. Do you think the lip stains would be a good option for me to add some color to my lips and not my teeth?
Oh man I DO have strong feelings about It’s a Small World. I hate that ride! It’s so creepy. 😂 The packaging and layout/pan shapes seem very on brand though. They did a good job. Still gonna skip it though. Thanks for the comparisons. Gonna go bust out my mercury retrograde and So Jaded palettes. On the other hand I did order the Muppets collab and I have absolutely no ties to that. Just really liked that color story.
Love the review but I think I’ll pass on this collection. Though I love Disney, I have an unfortunate memory of a trip from the park, going on this ride which is in Disney World FYI. My family got stuck on the ride for almost 2 hours so the music which is fun for a short colorful ride now makes me shutter a bit lol. When I went back as an adult later I avoid that whole section lol but did go with my kid when he wanted to ride it. Super fun for the kids and nostalgic memories
I immediately thought of Mercury Retrograde when I saw this! I loved It’s a Small World. I grew up in CA and was able to go often. I feel like this could have been more special but I’m thinking they couldn’t make it like the ride due to cultural appropriation. That said, I still would not have bought it because I have Mercury Retrograde.
Does colorpop always charge $22 for their 12 pan palettes? That's not as affordable as I thought! (I don't buy colorpop because shipping is too expensive)
No their 12 pans are typically $18 but the collaboration palettes are always more expensive!
What happened with the shimmers? Like the midnight masquerade was 10 times better and was released a few years before. Also the new glitter, in the so jaded had a lot of colours mixed. And the new one is plan. Colourpop please🙏🙏
Pd: I love so much your reviews💜💜
I am not the target audience for this release. I have never been to Disney Land and I always found the It's A Small World song to be super annoying. I'm an elder millennial and have no connection to that part of Disney lore. The retro packaging is cute, but I hate the reflective paper around the eyeshadow. But I love your face!
Yay, another review 🥳 Still have Mercury Retrograde in my collection, though some of the formulas are starting to feel a bit off. It might not last much longer 🥲 Got great use out of it while it lasted though and have your glowing review to thank for picking it up!