**UPDATE For those interested in the inserts here is an exclusive code for you! (watch my insert/organizer comparison if you wanted to see more detail) 7RP Website: 7rueparadis.com/shop-linsert EXCLUSIVE OFFER: Enter "MIM40 " to get 40€ OFF 1 insert or MIM85 to get 85€ off 2 inserts + FREE WORLDWIDE SHIPPING
I have no interest in getting these bags, but I wanted to know more about the differences in these two styles. This was so in depth and know I know so much! Great video!
To me the Birkin looks better. But the Kelly looks like can fit more things, and you can carry it on your shoulder. Thats huge for me, I like only cross body bags.
I didn't really like the look of the Kelly before but when I saw someone with the same bag as you last year I think, it made me super like it! I like how it can be worn casually or formally!
this is the best in depth bag video ever shows functionality and how u go in and out the bag literally awesome and brilliant! i cracked up at the gapey and venus flytrap omg
I've been putting off my purchase for two years, every once in a while I shop online for both of these. The reason I couldn't purchase one was: 1) what color; 2) what size; 3) which one. I'm so glad I stumbled upon this video!
I'm not interested in ever investing into these bags from Hermés, although beautiful, I loved learning the history, similarities and differences, how the bag functions, etc. Your reviews are my favourite! So thorough. I love the look of the birkin but the functionality of the kelly only because of the shoulder strap. 😅
Thanks Mel for your comment!!I learned a lot.I baught a bag(model kelly 32)Al in leather,not structured. There is nothing mentioned on the bag. I think it's a coie but.....So old and so nice!!!!.Did you my picture?Have a nice day!!!!!
Awwww you are just the sweetest Achini!!!! Thank you so much! I wish Hermes would make me an ambassador! don't think that will happen though lol. I am glad however that you enjoy my reviews and information on Hermes products as I do genuinely love them xoxo
Best video on B vs K I've watched so far on UA-cam! Very informative and love the mod shots. Well done Mel. Personally I'm team Birkin. My Kelly gets really heavy even with just a few things and the strap would dig into my shoulders. But love that they're both so well made! Yes a video on inserts would be great! Thanks dear. x
This is the most comprehensive comparison I've ever seen. Excellent video, Mel. And yes, I would love to see a review of your different bag inserts. And any other videos you can think of on the Birkin and the Kelly. You've probably already covered everything about them, but I'm so strangely fascinated that I'd watch even if you were just repeating yourself.
Wonderful comparison video! Both bags are BEAUTIFUL. I Love the Birkin, always have. I will never own either, but this girl is going to dream & admire yours. You are blessed. 💕💕💕
Thank you so much my dear! Yes I feel very blessed. I really appreciate you watching and always taking the time to leave me such lovely compliments! Blessed with such a great YT family too xx
Such a great comparison of these two bags!! I have been watching a bunch of Kelly videos for more information and this is honestly the best overview of the 32 size that I've seen. :)
I just love the construct of your videos . You’re both “down-to-earth” and a “classic lady” Those bags are way above my pay grade (I purchase my LV’s from the pre-loved market) nevertheless, l love you videos Mel 👍🏾
Mel hunnie, you make the best comprehensive reviews of Hermes bags! I learned a lot in this video and would definitely rewatch it again and again if/when I am ready to get a B or K (maybe one day). Hard to pick, I love the practicality of the K but I love the look of the B much more💋💋
Awww thanks so much babe! That feedback means a lot to me! I'm so glad you learned a lot from this vid...it took me ages to film! lol I was trying to edit it down from like 50 mins! Sounds like you are a B lover which a lot of people are! Def one to consider and save for in the future! xoxo
I never understaood why people were so obsessed with the Birkin in 200s-2010s because I thought they were boring most of the times boring or even ugly,then I recently saw some really good bags but I didn’t know they were Kelly. Indeed, it’s just easy to understand what it a Kelly because it’s more “compact” and I like it more. It’s incredible how small changes can totally change an opinion. I personally prefer the Kelly a way more. Thanks for this review,it’s so complete and detailed,now I do understand their differences better.
Amazing video, quite lovely! One thing : we can actually find Hermes Birkin Sellier, they are quite rare on the market, but quite interesting on the look! Christie's had an auction of a lovely Birkin Sellier 30 Nicolitus Croco in Night Blue, and it was so unique! Thank you again!
Loved this comparison, and they are both beautiful. Personally I would choose the Kelly, but just because she's got the strap. And yes, some bags are hard to get into, but hey, who would say no to a Kelly 😀 Have a lovely weekend 🙋🏻☀️💐😘
a bit more details about these 2 wonders : Kelly: “le sac à dépêche” (basically an old-fashioned way to call a brief case) was inspired by « le haut à courroies » which was a bag used by horsemen to store they boots and saddles. The bad changed around the 30s to become smaller and more more of a trapeze shape which ultimately give it a more feminine flair. Birkin: Hermes CEO, also took inspiration from « le haut à courroies » to design it with Jane. Making it smaller with two handles and a wider opening for more practicality.
What a fabulous video! You are so well spoken and explain everything so exquisitely and I also just love your accent and I’m dying for their’s purse and inserts for any bag I have!
I am so glad you did this video because I really enjoyed seeing both the similarities and differences between the two bags!!❤️👜❤️Hermes is such an outstanding luxury brand and both bags are beautiful and in a class of their own!😍 I really enjoyed hearing how they got their names...you always are so sweet and explain everything so well!!💖💞💕
I was Team Kelly before the video because of the shoulder option but after watching your amazing in depth video I am now Team Birkin! I simply love the casual style and I think I could cope with the hand held option. Yes please review your inserts!
I saw your latest 'how to score a Birkin in Paris' video and subscribed after watching this video on Kelly vs Birkin. I appreciate the numerous tips and have decided that I am a "Kelly' girl. I am going to Paris in December and hope to be offered one. Wish me luck and thank you for all the videos. Your pieces are just beautiful and you are a lovely person as well!
Kudos to u Mel ! Yours is one of the most detailed comparison betw the 2 'Queens of Handbags'. It shows tt u put effort into making a meaningful presentation. Great work !
Hi Mel, This is Kelly from the Philippines, i love both bags so much but for my first Hermes bag i will choose Birkin size 30, its perfect for me and i will also choose black color..I am watching your videos everyday and i learned some tips from you.. Take care always and God bless!!!!
Video title, how you make a film, full explanation, detailed, clear. You have the right to get my subscribe. Very good video content and I found this in you.
Love your gold Kelly! That's definitely on my list but for a K28. I recently bought a vintage K32 in excellent condition (hardly worn by the owner) and brought it to Hermes to have it sent to Hermes Spa but the SA said there is no need for one because it is in almost perfect condition. As I closed my Kelly the same way you do, the SA warned me that if I want to keep my handbag in the same condition, I should put the belt in the turnlock as not doing so could create the worst (and most expensive) damage to my handbag! She said, letting the turnlock carry all the weight without support (of the belt) can damage it easily and it is, apparently, the most expensive and difficult part to repair (Hermes needs to remove the whole plate and change it - that means, opening the leather tab of the bag!). So yeah, inasmuch as it is easier to leave it 'undone' I have since painstakingly close my bag by putting the belt in before turning the lock.
Love the B 35 ❤ My husband and I are going to Paris for the first time to celebrate our 10 year Anniversary at the end of August. We are going to try our luck at the FSH. Wish me luck!
Very informative, I think you are a fabulous woman! However, now I know WHY I have always thought that these bags remind me of old ladies bags, cause if they were worn by Grace Kelly in the 50's, well then I was a kid in the 60s AND the are, in fact , old ladies bags! As I remember! These prices are a bit of a scam. And the "one craftsman " that makes them, oh be real! Has he been making them since 1945?
I'll never be able to afford either. It eas still a very interesting video. I enjoyed it. If I could buy one I think I would get the Kelly one size up from yours. Helena
Thank you so much Pratt I really appreciate you taking the time to leave me such positive feedback. Def more comparisons to come in the future! Have a great weekend! :)
Mel, always enjoy your video and the in depth review. I collect bags for over 20 years and had 3 Birkin and would like to acquire a Kelly in my next Europe trip. Love love love your video.
Hi Sarah, I'm so happy to hear your enjoyed my video lovely. Wishing you lots of luck to get your Kelly in your next trip! Out of your 3 Birkins, which is your fave and why? :)
Red & Gold- 35 cm Orange- 30 cm. My all time favorite color is red & orange and since orange is Hermes signature color so I must have to get it. My most use & fav is red and I like the size and I think red is black now; it goes with everything.
Aww thanks my sweet! So happy you loved it, it did takes me agessss to film lol However worth all the time if it helped a few people. Hope you had a fab weekend! xoxo 😘
Hi mel im 5 ft 0 so what size i should get in either these bags i do prefer the larger sizes tho can u help me . (I do like the kelly in the retourne style not the other one the sellier ) .
I so appreciate this video Mel, thank you! I would love to see an insert video. Also, on your next overseas trip, I would love to see how you pack your haul items for coming home! Thank you for all your fun and informative videos:)))!
This was really helpful! I've always liked the look of the Hermes bags, but I hate getting in and out of a bag with too many closures. This definitely put me back on the path to a Birkin! Sounds like it has exactly the features I want. Going to go see if you have a video on those organizers now.
Very much appreciate this comprehensive video on the comparison between these two bags! Helps me understand the difference to make my choice. Thank you very much! PS: Love the inserts that are featured here.
Wonderful video Mel! Thank you for all of the information. I think I would prefer a Birkin as I am quite tall and wear my bags in the crook of my arm. I would love to see an insert video.
Thank you so much sweetie! So glad you enjoyed it! Sounds like the Birkin is your kinda bag then! I wish i was taller! lol Noted I plan to film an insert comparison for the B/K in the near future! x
Love your earrings, Mel! This was a great vid! I'm really starting to be Team Kelly! There something about the shape 😍 Missed seeing your Mallie Birkin--she's so pretty 🌺
Great video and very helpful. I understand so much more. Wondering if the Kelly Sangle straps could be attached with the turnlock then tuck in the top like with the Birkin? Would it then maintain a sort of cinched feel thereby keeping the bag more closed and keeping it from flopping open? .
Hi Mel, thank you so much for your video, it is so much helpful as I am searching for a birkin 30 myself. The kelly looks so good and elegant but to me it is a bit not convenient due to accessing the bag but the colour is my favourite. Hermes is a dream bag for every girl who love lux goods and also a good investment as well in term of re-sale later. You are so lucky not only to have one but 3.
An excellent, comprehensive review. Learned alot. Thanks so much! Edited: If I ever decided to take the plunge, based on this video it would be the Birkin for me.
A really great video, Mel. I am definitely team Kelly. I don't like the birkin at all. I guess it just depends on everybody's own style and taste. I totally agree with you that the kelly shouldn't be worn open. I have seen several youtubers wearing it like that lately and to me it just seems to make a sleek, elegant bag look like a sloppy joe. A video on the organisers would be really helpful. What also caught my eye was your bag holder. I have never seen one of those before. Could you give us some more information about those in one of your future videos? Keep up the good work, lovely.
Best Birkin & Kelly comparison video I’ve seen! Both beautiful bags! I recently got the Kelly bag in retourne Togo. I’ve noticed that there is air space between the outer leather & inner leather of the flap. Is this how it’s supposed to be in Kelly bags?
I wanted something bold so every time I looked inside it's like a second pop of happiness hehe I'm so glad you agree me that it's super striking too :) Thank you so much for your feedback too it means a lot! xx
Great & informative!!! I am in love with the style of the Kelly but not a fan of the crazy prices. To each their own, I can't nor would I personally spend that amount on a bag but they are still beautiful. I admire from a far.
I love this video! Thank you so much for doing this comparison. One day I hope to have one of these beautiful bags and I had been leaning toward a birkin because I am more of a totes gal but after seeing this video I am thinking that the Kelly may be more practical! And yours in the retourne is simply gorgeous 💗.
Wonderfully informative video and your bags are so beautiful, the only downside being that now I REALLY want a Kelly or Birkin when I've been telling myself it's not time yet, lol. :)
I'm back from Paris and scored my Kelly 28 in blue zanzibar! Your videos were a wealth of knowledge before my trip. I'd love for you to do a review of the inserts. Thanks!
Hi Christina! First of all a huge congrats! Blue zanzibar is a stunning colour! I'm so happy for you! Thank you for your feedback too that was really the aim of my videos so it makes me so happy to know that it helped you in Paris. Yes insert video is coming up next week, it will be an in depth one as I know there isn't a lot out there. I did so much research before getting the ones I did. Hopefully you find it useful too! :) x
Please Please do a video on the inserts comparison. I have the silk forbe and while I love it, I would love an alternative. Thanks for another great video.
Absolutely will do Kathryn! It seems so many people would like one, so I'm thinking of comparing the ones shown with the Hermes versions, I have the canvas version but will try borrow my friends silk version so I have more to compare. Will try film in the near future! xx
Thank you! I'm so happy you found it so informative! Yes it seems heaps of you guys want a video on bag organisers so I will def do one comparing mine with the Hermes fourbi. In terms of leathers/colours I will def put that one on the list for future videos. Thanks so much for watching! x
This is truly a great, informative video. Thank you, Mel! Sometimes it is difficult to find a video talking about Birkin or Kelly on UA-cam without a slight hint of showing off (or at least I being jealous feel so), but your video is truly for the purpose of sharing your knowledge and your love. I never wanted a Birkin or a Kelly before, but after seeing how functional it is from your video, now I really want to work the hardest I can just in case I may want one in the future :)
Hi lovely! I would if I had a Kelly sellier lol Hopefully I can get on in the future and when I do get one I can do a proper comparison then. Thanks for watching! :)
Mel, which leather is better, Togo or Epsom? I'm thinking of ordering from my SA - she told me to think about Epsom leather for my black Birkin 30 GHW, but I really like Togo. She told me the Togo will slouch after a few years, but the Epsom will stand
This is a great video! It answered all my questions and more! Considering a kelly and this helped a lot. I have that same purse holder for when I go out! I love it, so handy to have. 😁
**UPDATE
For those interested in the inserts here is an exclusive code for you! (watch my insert/organizer comparison if you wanted to see more detail)
7RP Website: 7rueparadis.com/shop-linsert
EXCLUSIVE OFFER: Enter "MIM40 " to get 40€ OFF 1 insert or MIM85 to get 85€ off 2 inserts + FREE WORLDWIDE SHIPPING
This is too funny Mayweather daughter Yaya put me on to this when she was on Instagram trying to explain the difference 2021
I have no interest in getting these bags, but I wanted to know more about the differences in these two styles. This was so in depth and know I know so much! Great video!
I thought so too, and after watching and watching, I end up to get Hermes bags😂
In my opinion the kelly is much more elegant
To me it is the birkin
Birkin for me...juz a dream😜
Joey Thomas I agree!
Both of them are equally elegant but kelly has more of a ladylike look
To me the Birkin looks better. But the Kelly looks like can fit more things, and you can carry it on your shoulder. Thats huge for me, I like only cross body bags.
If they incorporated a shoulder strap with the Birkin it would be the perfect bag for me
Yes if only right? lol
The content on your channel is so enriching. i'm such a fan
Thank you so much Alanna xx
I didn't really like the look of the Kelly before but when I saw someone with the same bag as you last year I think, it made me super like it! I like how it can be worn casually or formally!
Yes the Kelly really can be dressed up or down, it's such a beautiful bag! x
this is the best in depth bag video ever shows functionality and how u go in and out the bag literally awesome and brilliant! i cracked up at the gapey and venus flytrap omg
I've been putting off my purchase for two years, every once in a while I shop online for both of these. The reason I couldn't purchase one was: 1) what color; 2) what size; 3) which one. I'm so glad I stumbled upon this video!
I'm not interested in ever investing into these bags from Hermés, although beautiful, I loved learning the history, similarities and differences, how the bag functions, etc. Your reviews are my favourite! So thorough. I love the look of the birkin but the functionality of the kelly only because of the shoulder strap. 😅
I LOVE the colours you chose. Can you do another video on all the Hermes leathers, colours, hard wears and why you picked the combos you did ?
Thank you for your suggestion lovely! I will def see if I can do that in the future. :)
Thanks for this comparison, Mel! I purchased my first ever Kelly 32 today in gold on gold! I appreciate your thorough reviews!
the LYXBAG would be super cute during the fall with a nude or tan or even tonal outfit! i’m thinking a tan wool coat with that bag!!
Thanks Mel for your comment!!I learned a lot.I baught a bag(model kelly 32)Al in leather,not structured. There is nothing mentioned on the bag. I think it's a coie but.....So old and so nice!!!!.Did you my picture?Have a nice day!!!!!
Hermes needs to sponsor you and make you an ambassador or something Mel! 🙂🙂🙂💕💕💕You always give great feedback/info on the Hermes bags! 🙂🙂🙂💕💕😘😘😘🙂🙂
Awwww you are just the sweetest Achini!!!! Thank you so much! I wish Hermes would make me an ambassador! don't think that will happen though lol. I am glad however that you enjoy my reviews and information on Hermes products as I do genuinely love them xoxo
Best video on B vs K I've watched so far on UA-cam! Very informative and love the mod shots. Well done Mel. Personally I'm team Birkin. My Kelly gets really heavy even with just a few things and the strap would dig into my shoulders. But love that they're both so well made! Yes a video on inserts would be great! Thanks dear. x
This is the most comprehensive comparison I've ever seen. Excellent video, Mel. And yes, I would love to see a review of your different bag inserts. And any other videos you can think of on the Birkin and the Kelly. You've probably already covered everything about them, but I'm so strangely fascinated that I'd watch even if you were just repeating yourself.
Wonderful comparison video! Both bags are BEAUTIFUL. I Love the Birkin, always have. I will never own either, but this girl is going to dream & admire yours. You are blessed. 💕💕💕
Thank you so much my dear! Yes I feel very blessed. I really appreciate you watching and always taking the time to leave me such lovely compliments! Blessed with such a great YT family too xx
You are so welcome. Please keep sharing & inspiring.💕💕💕
Yes you will. Believe in yourself and work hard. Wishing you the best and much success!
Never say never!
Such a great comparison of these two bags!! I have been watching a bunch of Kelly videos for more information and this is honestly the best overview of the 32 size that I've seen. :)
I just love the construct of your videos . You’re both “down-to-earth” and a “classic lady”
Those bags are way above my pay grade (I purchase my LV’s from the pre-loved market) nevertheless, l love you videos Mel 👍🏾
Mel hunnie, you make the best comprehensive reviews of Hermes bags! I learned a lot in this video and would definitely rewatch it again and again if/when I am ready to get a B or K (maybe one day). Hard to pick, I love the practicality of the K but I love the look of the B much more💋💋
Awww thanks so much babe! That feedback means a lot to me! I'm so glad you learned a lot from this vid...it took me ages to film! lol I was trying to edit it down from like 50 mins! Sounds like you are a B lover which a lot of people are! Def one to consider and save for in the future! xoxo
I never understaood why people were so obsessed with the Birkin in 200s-2010s because I thought they were boring most of the times boring or even ugly,then I recently saw some really good bags but I didn’t know they were Kelly.
Indeed, it’s just easy to understand what it a Kelly because it’s more “compact” and I like it more.
It’s incredible how small changes can totally change an opinion.
I personally prefer the Kelly a way more.
Thanks for this review,it’s so complete and detailed,now I do understand their differences better.
What a wonderful and detail comparison on the Hermes bag. Amazing video.
Would love to see a review of the inserts!
Sarah Chaudhary me too!
Noted Sarah, this is def on the list of things to do soon. Was thinking a review/comparison of the ones I have vs the Hermes versions x
Hi Mel, love your videos! There is no difference in cost between the Togo and Epsom. There is a premium for the Clemence however.
Amazing video, quite lovely! One thing : we can actually find Hermes Birkin Sellier, they are quite rare on the market, but quite interesting on the look! Christie's had an auction of a lovely Birkin Sellier 30 Nicolitus Croco in Night Blue, and it was so unique! Thank you again!
Loved this comparison, and they are both beautiful. Personally I would choose the Kelly, but just because she's got the strap. And yes, some bags are hard to get into, but hey, who would say no to a Kelly 😀
Have a lovely weekend 🙋🏻☀️💐😘
a bit more details about these 2 wonders :
Kelly:
“le sac à dépêche” (basically an old-fashioned way to call a brief case) was inspired by « le haut à courroies » which was a bag used by horsemen to store they boots and saddles. The bad changed around the 30s to become smaller and more more of a trapeze shape which ultimately give it a more feminine flair.
Birkin:
Hermes CEO, also took inspiration from « le haut à courroies » to design it with Jane. Making it smaller with two handles and a wider opening for more practicality.
What a fabulous video! You are so well spoken and explain everything so exquisitely and I also just love your accent and I’m dying for their’s purse and inserts for any bag I have!
Thank you for comparing the difference between Birkin & Kelly. Finally! I just had my education in Hermes Bag 101. Thanks again Mel~
I want to congratulate you on the quality of your videos, I love them
Well explained. I like Birkin more...bcos the in n out is simpler. I prefer my Gucci sylvie. Thank you so much Mel👍👍❤
I am so glad you did this video because I really enjoyed seeing both the similarities and differences between the two bags!!❤️👜❤️Hermes is such an outstanding luxury brand and both bags are beautiful and in a class of their own!😍 I really enjoyed hearing how they got their names...you always are so sweet and explain everything so well!!💖💞💕
I was Team Kelly before the video because of the shoulder option but after watching your amazing in depth video I am now Team Birkin! I simply love the casual style and I think I could cope with the hand held option. Yes please review your inserts!
Changed my mind...Team Kelly again...lol
@@Lifeplasty 😂😂😂
I saw your latest 'how to score a Birkin in Paris' video and subscribed after watching this video on Kelly vs Birkin. I appreciate the numerous tips and have decided that I am a "Kelly' girl. I am going to Paris in December and hope to be offered one. Wish me luck and thank you for all the videos. Your pieces are just beautiful and you are a lovely person as well!
Kudos to u Mel ! Yours is one of the most detailed comparison betw the 2 'Queens of Handbags'. It shows tt u put effort into making a meaningful presentation. Great work !
Extremely helpful video! Love all your videos!!
Hi Mel, This is Kelly from the Philippines, i love both bags so much but for my first Hermes bag i will choose Birkin size 30, its perfect for me and i will also choose black color..I am watching your videos everyday and i learned some tips from you.. Take care always and God bless!!!!
Video title, how you make a film, full explanation, detailed, clear. You have the right to get my subscribe. Very good video content and I found this in you.
What is the brand of the handbag organizer at 13:50
I like the Birkin a bit more for the easier entry. I would love the insert video. Love your videos
Love your gold Kelly! That's definitely on my list but for a K28. I recently bought a vintage K32 in excellent condition (hardly worn by the owner) and brought it to Hermes to have it sent to Hermes Spa but the SA said there is no need for one because it is in almost perfect condition. As I closed my Kelly the same way you do, the SA warned me that if I want to keep my handbag in the same condition, I should put the belt in the turnlock as not doing so could create the worst (and most expensive) damage to my handbag! She said, letting the turnlock carry all the weight without support (of the belt) can damage it easily and it is, apparently, the most expensive and difficult part to repair (Hermes needs to remove the whole plate and change it - that means, opening the leather tab of the bag!). So yeah, inasmuch as it is easier to leave it 'undone' I have since painstakingly close my bag by putting the belt in before turning the lock.
You always do fabulous reviews and comparisons Mel! Great video!!! 😘
Thank you so much hun! I appreciated you always leaving me such sweet compliments! Have a fab day! xx 😘
Love the B 35 ❤ My husband and I are going to Paris for the first time to celebrate our 10 year Anniversary at the end of August. We are going to try our luck at the FSH. Wish me luck!
The B35 is actually the most popular size in Europe! It is gorgeous! Wishing you lots and lots of luck lovely! Congrats on 10 years as well! ❤️
I love your review, very informative and clearly compare. I wish one day i will have them both like you.
Very informative, I think you are a fabulous woman! However, now I know WHY I have always thought that these bags remind me of old ladies bags, cause if they were worn by Grace Kelly in the 50's, well then I was a kid in the 60s AND the are, in fact , old ladies bags! As I remember! These prices are a bit of a scam. And the "one craftsman " that makes them, oh be real! Has he been making them since 1945?
I'll never be able to afford either. It eas still a very interesting video. I enjoyed it. If I could buy one I think I would get the Kelly one size up from yours. Helena
The idea of bag organizer is genius in its usefulness and simplicity!!! I never knew!)))
great review video! So much relevant and helpful details.
And yes, I would love to see a bag insert review video.
Loved this review Hun! So comprehensive and very informative. And please do an insert review! 💕💕
Thank you so much hunnie! Yes I will do! Happy weekend xoxo
Kelly is less produced than the Birkin. As far as I can recall, in every 10 or 100 Birkins made, 1 Kelly is made.
C Crisostomo wow really!! Why - i prefer the Kelly by far !
I love this review!!! all your videos are so thorough and thoughtful and sweet :)
Thank you so much, makes me so happy you enjoyed it! xoxo
Just a fabulous review, thorough and clear. You did a good job thinking it out before you taped. Gold standard for videos.
Thank you so much Pratt I really appreciate you taking the time to leave me such positive feedback. Def more comparisons to come in the future! Have a great weekend! :)
Mel, always enjoy your video and the in depth review.
I collect bags for over 20 years and had 3 Birkin and would like to acquire a Kelly in my next Europe trip.
Love love love your video.
Hi Sarah,
I'm so happy to hear your enjoyed my video lovely. Wishing you lots of luck to get your Kelly in your next trip! Out of your 3 Birkins, which is your fave and why? :)
Red & Gold- 35 cm
Orange- 30 cm.
My all time favorite color is red & orange and since orange is Hermes signature color so I must have to get it. My most use & fav is red and I like the size and I think red is black now; it goes with everything.
I like the look and function of the Kelly a lot better after watching this video. Thanks Mel!
Great video my dear Mel. Very informative and I enjoyed it so much!!!
love this video Mel, especially the amount of effort you put into each segment! Your B30 is my holy grail 😻😻😻
Aww thanks my sweet! So happy you loved it, it did takes me agessss to film lol However worth all the time if it helped a few people. Hope you had a fab weekend! xoxo 😘
Hi mel im 5 ft 0 so what size i should get in either these bags i do prefer the larger sizes tho can u help me . (I do like the kelly in the retourne style not the other one the sellier ) .
I so appreciate this video Mel, thank you! I would love to see an insert video. Also, on your next overseas trip, I would love to see how you pack your haul items for coming home! Thank you for all your fun and informative videos:)))!
This is such a helpful video! What a thorough coverage comparing a Birkin vs Kelly. Thank you!
This was really helpful! I've always liked the look of the Hermes bags, but I hate getting in and out of a bag with too many closures. This definitely put me back on the path to a Birkin! Sounds like it has exactly the features I want. Going to go see if you have a video on those organizers now.
Does anyone know where I can get those organizers for the bag? I think she didn’t tag them in the description 😊 thanks a lot
Very much appreciate this comprehensive video on the comparison between these two bags!
Helps me understand the difference to make my choice.
Thank you very much!
PS: Love the inserts that are featured here.
Wonderful video Mel! Thank you for all of the information. I think I would prefer a Birkin as I am quite tall and wear my bags in the crook of my arm. I would love to see an insert video.
Thank you so much sweetie! So glad you enjoyed it! Sounds like the Birkin is your kinda bag then! I wish i was taller! lol Noted I plan to film an insert comparison for the B/K in the near future! x
wow I'm not a fan of luxury items but this video is so informative and I couldn't stop watching. Good content!
Team Kelly!! Please do a video on the leathers, colours as well as the inserts!! Love you!
Absolutely gorgeous! Love both and put Kelly 25 on my wish list as the first bag.
Love your earrings, Mel! This was a great vid! I'm really starting to be Team Kelly! There something about the shape 😍 Missed seeing your Mallie Birkin--she's so pretty 🌺
Incredibly useful video! Really helpful! Thanks!
great review! I'm both! I love each bag for different reasons
Mel, your Kelly bag is stunning!!!!
Great video and very helpful. I understand so much more. Wondering if the Kelly Sangle straps could be attached with the turnlock then tuck in the top like with the Birkin? Would it then maintain a sort of cinched feel thereby keeping the bag more closed and keeping it from flopping open? .
I’d love to see you do the birkin 30 vs the Kelly 28!
Could you please do a video like this comparing Chanel classics vs boys? And the different sizes with what fits in them? I loved this video!
ooh good idea!
Hi Mel, thank you so much for your video, it is so much helpful as I am searching for a birkin 30 myself. The kelly looks so good and elegant but to me it is a bit not convenient due to accessing the bag but the colour is my favourite. Hermes is a dream bag for every girl who love lux goods and also a good investment as well in term of re-sale later. You are so lucky not only to have one but 3.
Dear Mel
I loved the inserts that you have , please kindly do a video on the inserts and where can we buy them from ?
Thanks
Hi Jennifer, thank you so much! I did so much research on them and yes the video is coming next week comparing them vs the Hermes Fourbi :)
An excellent, comprehensive review. Learned alot. Thanks so much! Edited: If I ever decided to take the plunge, based on this video it would be the Birkin for me.
A really great video, Mel. I am definitely team Kelly. I don't like the birkin at all. I guess it just depends on everybody's own style and taste. I totally agree with you that the kelly shouldn't be worn open. I have seen several youtubers wearing it like that lately and to me it just seems to make a sleek, elegant bag look like a sloppy joe. A video on the organisers would be really helpful. What also caught my eye was your bag holder. I have never seen one of those before. Could you give us some more information about those in one of your future videos? Keep up the good work, lovely.
This is very good comparison of them. Thank you so much 😊
Best Birkin & Kelly comparison video I’ve seen! Both beautiful bags! I recently got the Kelly bag in retourne Togo. I’ve noticed that there is air space between the outer leather & inner leather of the flap. Is this how it’s supposed to be in Kelly bags?
Love ALL your videos! I would love to see how you store/organize and clean your handbags and shoes!
Very good comparison and very thorough review! I initially thought about the Kelly but after watching this I feel like I'm more of a birkin person!
So happy you enjoyed the comparison Linda! xx
The purple looks really striking as an insert against the black. 5 stars for this vid :)
I wanted something bold so every time I looked inside it's like a second pop of happiness hehe I'm so glad you agree me that it's super striking too :) Thank you so much for your feedback too it means a lot! xx
I can't afford any of these bags but if I could, I would definitely go for the kelly 😊
Great job and very informative… I love Kelly ♥️
Great & informative!!! I am in love with the style of the Kelly but not a fan of the crazy prices. To each their own, I can't nor would I personally spend that amount on a bag but they are still beautiful. I admire from a far.
I love this video! Thank you so much for doing this comparison. One day I hope to have one of these beautiful bags and I had been leaning toward a birkin because I am more of a totes gal but after seeing this video I am thinking that the Kelly may be more practical! And yours in the retourne is simply gorgeous 💗.
Wonderfully informative video and your bags are so beautiful, the only downside being that now I REALLY want a Kelly or Birkin when I've been telling myself it's not time yet, lol. :)
I'm back from Paris and scored my Kelly 28 in blue zanzibar! Your videos were a wealth of knowledge before my trip. I'd love for you to do a review of the inserts. Thanks!
Hi Christina! First of all a huge congrats! Blue zanzibar is a stunning colour! I'm so happy for you! Thank you for your feedback too that was really the aim of my videos so it makes me so happy to know that it helped you in Paris. Yes insert video is coming up next week, it will be an in depth one as I know there isn't a lot out there. I did so much research before getting the ones I did. Hopefully you find it useful too! :) x
Please Please do a video on the inserts comparison. I have the silk forbe and while I love it, I would love an alternative. Thanks for another great video.
Absolutely will do Kathryn! It seems so many people would like one, so I'm thinking of comparing the ones shown with the Hermes versions, I have the canvas version but will try borrow my friends silk version so I have more to compare. Will try film in the near future! xx
Fantastic informative video!! I'm team Kelly!! Please do more videos on leathers/colours and on bag organisers!!
Thank you! I'm so happy you found it so informative! Yes it seems heaps of you guys want a video on bag organisers so I will def do one comparing mine with the Hermes fourbi. In terms of leathers/colours I will def put that one on the list for future videos. Thanks so much for watching! x
This is truly a great, informative video. Thank you, Mel! Sometimes it is difficult to find a video talking about Birkin or Kelly on UA-cam without a slight hint of showing off (or at least I being jealous feel so), but your video is truly for the purpose of sharing your knowledge and your love. I never wanted a Birkin or a Kelly before, but after seeing how functional it is from your video, now I really want to work the hardest I can just in case I may want one in the future :)
Please share where you consign your Hermès
Love, love this comparison.
Great job!
Yay I'm so happy to hear you loved it! xx
What a fantastic video you did Mel! It would be nice if you could do a review on inserts too!
Wonderful video; I learned a lot, very well explained ...you only miss to say the prices, which one is more expensive?
Hi Mel, it's a great video. Can you do a video describing pro and cons between sellier and retourne please?
Hi lovely! I would if I had a Kelly sellier lol Hopefully I can get on in the future and when I do get one I can do a proper comparison then. Thanks for watching! :)
awesome review. i'll never be able to afford either bag but I do admire them and enjoy seeing videos.
Hi Mhel, may I ask how much for a B30/35 roughly is in store in togo leather. Would be awesome if you can send me your response soonest. Thank you.
Mel, which leather is better, Togo or Epsom? I'm thinking of ordering from my SA - she told me to think about Epsom leather for my black Birkin 30 GHW, but I really like Togo. She told me the Togo will slouch after a few years, but the Epsom will stand
Great video! Really help me much on understand this 2 legendary bags! Thanks so much...
This is a great video! It answered all my questions and more! Considering a kelly and this helped a lot. I have that same purse holder for when I go out! I love it, so handy to have. 😁