+ develop what already exists -- Navi Mumbai. Navi Mumbai has immense potential but lacks well developed connectivity in terms of road , rail & access to airport as well as lacks large clearly demarcated Industial & Electronic zones
Why Should Maharashtra Government Development Development Aurangabad In Bihar State It Will Be Developed By Bihar Gov . For the Marathwada Region Of Maharashtra We Will Develop "CHATRAPATI SAMBHAJI NAGAR"
Building new water reservoirs is also important because whole MMR region is currently facing water supply issues. Hopefully govt has also considered it in it's plan.
Yes correct. I think some inland city should have been developed in eastern Maharashtra. That would have been better option and that also would be closer to Hyderabad so that would also be an advantage.
Does People from those areas pay tax to goverment unlike Mumbai and it's suburbs?? People in Mumbai-pune work harder and also they invest in the economy many entrepreneurs are from those areas and Outside Enterprises rather than interior parts of Maharashtra would choose Mumbai/Pune rather than smaller cities And also another factor is are there people who are in those areas encouraging industries? really going to give thier own land for Industrial purpose When a plant was going to built in konkan People opposed the plant As they wanted to preserve ''eco-system and nature of konkan" This leds to investors and industrialists being low in confidence for investment in that area... In Mumbai, Except for Arrey depot incident, many people have supported the development rather than other factors That why, people and industries are inclined towards the Mumbai Pune and its suburbs nagpur is somewhat developing but nashik requires good transport like Metro and suburban line like Manmad to Igatpuri Other towns in MH(Chh. Sambhaji nagar,Nanded,Latur,Jalna, Amravati) are not that suitable currently unless Entrepreneurs are being given some allowances and assurance about future development or else they would not try to invest
I won't be surprised if this news is sponsored by some builder/builders planning projects in the so-called "Third Mumbai". And for ur kind info Navi Mumbai has not FAILED..but surely needs more improvement
Some businessmen, one related with this video own huge SEZ, port and Airports along with huge tracts of land that they plan to get developed by our beloved Sarcar, so let's plan a new city.
Instead of keep increasing size of one city, politicians in India should improve tier two and three cities. That's the only way India's huge population can be benefitted.
@@mlg1279 There is always the option of small airports & smaller planes for direct connectivity to larger city Airports. Many small/ remote cities n towns in Western countries have such facility.
There are just 4- 5 cities in India that offer better opportunities for better jobs. And these are the cities facing increasing people & traffic congestion. Developing well planned infra + travel n commute connectivity in smaller cities near these big cities would be the better option . No purpose further over burdening an already over burdened large city
We dont have enough money to develop all cities. Our tier 1 cities are behind China's and USA's tier 2 cities in terms of infrastructure. So forget your dreams. Tier 1 city will always develop and have more investments. Tier 3 will degrade and tier 2 will be slow.
@@maheshsathe9197 Arey Apla Kalyan Dombivali Ambernath Badlapur ithe pann development paahije ithun loka sakaali loka Mumbai la jaatat aani ratri ghari yetaat. Mahanje kaay Kalyan chi loka fakht local cha dhakke khanya saathi ahe kaay
First of all Navi Mumbai didn't fail.. It's flourishing at its own pace.. the growth is slow because of the govts inablity to provide basic amenities on time.. The bus facilities are inadequate, trains aren't running on time, shared auto and taxi have their own mafia squads which is not controlled by authorities. Govt. simply couldn't provide when needed. Still the presence of private services are more helpful than the public transport. Secondly I can only figure out that influential people have a lot of investment in new panvel and outskirts of panvel which is not selling because of lack of amenities and with the name PANVEL attached.. Hence Third Mumbai.. because mumbai is easy to sell.. You should literally change your video title.. its misleading for new buyers and whatever the case be it will be costlier to travel from third Mumbai to Actual Central Mumbai..
@@ThankYouGoogle4 Its not a con at all. Old panvel area is already well established with transportation, hospitals, schools. So the builders and may be govt. decided to build a "New Panvel" which is way out of panvel, away from easy transport so it seems people who are aware of the area are not investing in their projects. 1 because they are charging too much in the name of "Panvel", 2 areas in New Panvel are not so much established. Hence they got the idea of making Third Mumbai. Which will cover all the projects in New Panvel renamed as Third Mumbai. That doesn't mean that it is not a good investment. If you are planning for a long term investment you can sure go for it. But for a similar price you can get a flat in New Mumbai which is way closer to Mumbai and connectivity is available via different means..
@@ThankYouGoogle4 It will completely depend on your budget and requirements.. If you can pay a premium price then you must look for places between Vashi and Belapur (Railway stations). If slightly low on budget then for Kharghar, Taloja, Khandeshwar etc. Prices also differ as per the distance of property from Railway station and Highway and amenities..
@@ThankYouGoogle4the prices are insane, I went to new panvel thinking it might be cheaper , 1bhk flat costs between 55lac - 70lac new construction. And if you want to rent it out you would only get between 8k - 12k . I don’t understand this maths of investing 60lac and getting 12k , even FD and LIC will give better returns 😂😂
Funfact: So called " Third Mumbai" will be auctually closer to Pune so just name it New Pune because " Navi Navi Mumbai" will sound weird. Why don't they just issue tender for Vandelocals so that Mumbai Suburban railway can go beyond Kasara & Khopoli & develop infra for Nashik & Pune.
*शंभर मुंबई शहर तयार केले तरी परप्रांतीय लोंढे काहि थांबणार नाही* *शिवाय त्याचा मराठी माणसाला काहिच फायदा होणार नाही.* *निसर्गाची वाट लाऊन कसला विकास करताय काय समजत नाही महाराष्ट्रात बाकिचे पण शहर आहेत तिकडे काहितरी करा !!!*
Navi Mumbai isn't a failure. It is a planned city and was never designed to take in say half of Mumbai's population. In 1972, Mumbai's population was half of what it is today. And the biggest disadvantage of Navi Mumbai is its distance from Mumbai. How is that going to be solved by building a third city even further away from Mumbai?
Exactly. Even travelling from Navi Mumbai to Main mumbai is hell of a hectic task and time consuming... Coming to main mumbai from third mumbai would be like going on a trip for sure lol, not at all feasible.
This is simply meant for the builder lobby. It does not benefit citizens and is certainly another burden on the fragile environment of the western ghats. This should never be approved. Also, Cidco and NMMC are responsible for messing up Navi Mumbai.
It seems that the competition between both the old and new Mumbai regarding business hubs have stalled new Mumbai. Don't know if the government is going to do something about it.
Thane mein bhi rail , road connectivity ka major issues hai. Metro bhi kai saal se incomplete hai & 2023 mein bhi kuch kaam hota hua nahin dikhta . Adhiktar Roads narrow hain aur unka quality bekaar hain. Traffic management sahi nahin hain. Jab ki ye CM Shinde & family ke political rise ka area raha hai
Please develop Tier-2, Tier-3 cities in Maharashtra. At the end this people are only coming for jobs in Tier-1 cities why not build opportunities in their own hometown itself
Instead of focusing on third mumbai developntje existing new mumbai which lacks many of the basic facilities. Invest in infrastructure and public transport there. Make navi mumbai a finance,tech and manufacturing hub like how NCR is doing with noida and gurgaon. Automatically Mumbai will start to decongesy and also the overall gdp of mumbai will increase along with quality of life in the MMR. MMR should consider this. Also pune is also lagging in development, there should be focus of development in pune as well.
Govt changes & the work of previous govt gets deliberately stalled/ delayed / restructured . Thackeray govt restructured the Mumbai Metro work that cost the State & alongwith it India multiple millions of loss. Same for AP's Amravati city project. Ditto for Vajpayee Govt's work. Aam junta needs to be educated abt the implications of their vote
Nagpur la develop karayala hav.. data centre wagarele port connectivity nahi lagat... Tari pan anvin project suru karun crore rupees cha ghotala kaalrach😢
Declare Navi Mumbai as Capital of Maharashtra ( like NewDelhi as capital of India , side tracking old Delhi )and also develop another city as second capital preferably of central Maharashtra. Former J&K had two capitals
A totally ridiculous idea. Jobs need to move to Tier 2 and Tier 3 cities and towns. Jobs being handled in Mumbai and Delhi and Bangalore are being handled in Tier 2 cities in the US
The Leaders of Navi Mumbai were Smart Enough not to over populate it.. Its much better than Old Mumbai to Live.. Also The New Mumbai airport plan was introduced by Congress and much earlier than 2010 as I am 39 now and aince I was 20 years old I was hearing that there will be New Mumbai airport also in future.. Third Mumbai is a Burger between Pune and Old Mumbai but I understand that middle class and lower middle class can live happily by saving on rent and can work both sides Mumbai and Pune
Mumbai should be declared as a UT. What about rest of Maharashtra if funds will go only to develop Third Mumbai? Financial centres are funded by the central govt around the world and here the city is taking most of the state's budget.
In fact it is because of Mumbai that the Maharashtra government can spend in other regions too. Declaring Mumbai as a UT will be big blow to the state like how Andhra Pradesh suffered after it lost Hyderabad to Telangana. It will be dependent on Pune & Nagpur for funds.
Navi Mumbai continues to be under developed & under utilized when it has immense potential. And now they are trying build a 3rd Mumbai ! What a waste of funds
😂😂😂 name whole India as Mumbai such a 3rd class Unworthy minds.... When our Politicians dont have Capacity to develop single city these selfish idea will come out from their brains... Maharashtra and Karnataka both have same problem... Both Capital cities are complete in corner of the map😢😢😢
India is a large country. Why concentrate so much people and capital in one urban area, instead of spreading it out more evenly across India's territory by building up (and building out) already existing second- and third-tier cities?
This will become a fuckin nightmare for pilots of Mumbai bound flights in next 2 decades ( if they survive AI) because there will be more Mumbai's than manganlal chikki in Lonavala.
Please think to develop other districts also or there will be two parts of Maharashtra one with mumbai and without mumbai means developed and undeveloped
Just to benefit politicians ,builders and businessmen- more money while resources and infrastructure get worse . Mumbai is already bursting and has to be decongested but the politicians are more interested in their own vested interest .
Actually that economic , job sector is the main reason why the Navi Mumbai is behind or else the population , the infrastructure has grown or has swollen up.
The video explains that the Third Mumbai project is intended to solve the problem of overcrowding and other issues in Mumbai. This project could have a big effect on the economy of Maharashtra. Even though Maharashtra gets less tax money from the central government than the northern states (Maharashtra gets 7.7rs per 100rs as compared to up and bihar getting 333rs and 922rs respectively), it can still develop, and the northern states are also growing.
Why not develope cities like nagpur instead, they're asking for development for years, the CM seat is from nagpur post 2014, It was in hand of sena during covid but post Shinde coup it's again in the hands of BJP and yet they're ignoring nagpur as a whole, wtf
No ones ignoring nagpur it's THE biggest hub for logistics in india each and week big investments regarding logistics and small scale industries supporting them come by its not much shown in media cause its not glamorising enough
What about Satara,Sangli,Karad,Hingoli,Wardha,Washim,Jalgaon,Dhule,Nandurbar,Bhandara,Nanded,Latur,Dharashiv,Ahilyanagar,Gadchiroli,Yavatmal,Chandrapur?
We don't need Third Mumbai at all at this moment Mumbai & Maharashtra only needs one thing & that is people from other parts of India who have migrated to Maharashtra should now go back & Mumbai & Maharashtra have exhausted it's capacity how much urbanisation is Government going to carry our in Maharashtra, it's time to develop other states of India instead of creating Third Mumbai develop cities like Lucknow, Kanpur, Jaipur etc & other cities in North & South India. How much are you going to pound on Mumbai & Maharashtra. If we want India to develop than every city & state needs to develop to achieve this goal ,development can't be concentrated in a particular city & State.
Why not make entire Thane District including part of Vasai Virar area (which was part of Thane District before attachment with Palghar) as Another Mumbai ?
Hire some cityplanners from The Netherlands or any Scandinavian countries. The quality of living and the city itself will be much better than American inspired cities.
I hope and pray it better not be alibaug.....as i live in south mumbai and the way traffic has increased here parking,socialising area falls short for open spaces this is all made easily for developer lobby to earn lots n lots of money also majority developers are coming with idea of amenities so they can pile amenities on middle class people so that they can dispose their newly given possession flats....and move away from prime areas and reside to vasai and virar
No thank you. No IT hubs please 🙏 We are trying to disperse people & here you are suggestign IT hub? Pune & Nagpur is the city which you should look forward to then.
Instead of developing it further east and away from main Mumbai they should have went north and developed it in Mira-Bhayander, Vasai-Virar and Thane collectively which are geographically and culturally more connected to the Mumbai island also giving easier access to both Mumbai and Navi Mumbai
Corrupted ? Or congested ? Mumbai is a long strip of land with plenty reclaimed land. So congestion is expected . Lack of forethought to development & urban planning makes the situation worse
If you are going to build navi-navi-mumbai or navi-mumbai-2, Build it next to water body. like arabian sea. So you do not need to build a port. you can build canals for inland ports for land locked cities. But first learn to use what we have properly.
The trick is to have forests surrounding the city and also, less legalised pollution by industries around the city. India Can do it if they truly want to make the city successful
Mumbai’s main issue is it does not have a whole lot of industries- so the metro area’s GDP is pretty small at $150 billion for a city that wants to be a global city. Shanghai’s gdp is $600 billion as a comparison. Maharashtra despite having a lot of land and a long coastline has a gdp of only $450 billion for a population of 120 million people. that is pretty low for a so-called industrial state. Better set up a lot of export oriented industries. Mumbai metro area has a lot of unutilized land. Maharashtra needs to double its GDP quickly and for that Mumbai has to more than double its GDP.
BC Marathwada, vidarbh kya sirf vote ke liye hai kya ???. Marathwada me talent hai par opportunity bilkul bhi nahi mil Rahi. Latur ko develop Karo thoda.
दिल्ली की मेट्रो मुंबई से सस्ती है। क्यों? मेट्रो की सुविधा मुंबई, नई मुंबई और होनेवाली मुंबई में नहीं है। पोलुटेड समंदर किनारे, मॅंगृज की कमी और भी समस्या है जहा केंद्र सरकार की सहायता नहीं मिली।
A simple strategy can be naming the whole area as Mumbai. Navi Mumbai, Third Mumbai creates a comparative cobtext among cities. Develop infrastructure like Mumbai and name the whole area as Mumbai. Kaam khatam paisa hazam.
Mumbai ecosystem will collapse! Too much pressure on natural resources! Politicians just want to make money - especially from the most corrupt industry- Housing construction industry! Even public limited companies are paying kickbacks thru subcontractors/ vendors to the politicians/ corporators. Ghanerda Phasavnooknis is an idiot! He doesn’t care much about Mumbai- how can one forget the fact that he was once the architect of separate “ Vidarbha” movement. Just disgusting to see that Maharashtra’s green belts/ Mangroves are becoming concrete jungles! Need Marathi revolution to save Maharashtra! Pl go and build in fucking UP/ Bihar/Zharkhand third Mumbai. Stop converting Maharashtra into an extension of UP/Bihar/Zharkhand. Pl Wake up Marathi people- otherwise our rich heritage will be lost!
Yes I also have same opinion. Existing development of Navi Mumbai is not at all good. They are planning for third Mumbai. Pehle Navi Mumbai ko toh behter banai in terms of infrastructure,job opportunities,road network and health care. If our politicians keep on doing what they did till now,UP would soon take Maharashtra. Given Delhi ncr doing so well and Bangalore, Hyderabad too. We don't want to end up like Kolkata
@@emotionalwibes7400 Bc Maharashtra coastal state h or UP landlocked. Ydi up landkocked na hota to shayd piche chor deta Maharashtra ko , lekin koi chance nhi h . Maharashtra geographical advance will always keep it at top . UP at most 2nd pe aa sakta h bas , vo bhi abhi sure nhi h because tamilnadu acha perform kar rha h or tamilnadu ke pass bhi geographical advantage h over UP. Lekin fir bhi mujhe lagta h longterm me UP 2nd pe aa jaega GDP me (mainly because of its population or thoda bohot western UP me jo kam ho rha h. Eastern Up to khatam h bilkul, ekdum Bihar jesa ).
You are funny atleast let them build 3rd mumbai which most likely to fail unless all corporate want to move too, it's not people who decide it's corporates and jobs which decides whether it will succeed or not, and most likely what you are saying that public transport must be good it will require lot of money which would go waste if it fails and If they didn't build public transport it's going fail for sure, make jobs available there in local region so traveling is less to main mumbai, so they depend on it. This channel is sponsored by builder and capitalists who just want to build building and want projects from government to build quick money and leave, they don't care about people in general
Better to develop tier 2 cities like Nashik, Nagpur and Aurangabad by creating better connectivity with the capital, ports and airports.
+ develop what already exists -- Navi
Mumbai. Navi Mumbai has immense potential but lacks well developed connectivity in terms of road , rail & access to airport as well as lacks large clearly demarcated Industial & Electronic zones
Dont be so jealous. Just because you live in those lower class cities, this doesn't equate them to mumbai class.
Hmm, you got a point
Why Should Maharashtra Government Development Development Aurangabad In Bihar State It Will Be Developed By Bihar Gov .
For the Marathwada Region Of Maharashtra We Will Develop "CHATRAPATI SAMBHAJI NAGAR"
@@Dhruv-Kumar people from second tier cities then move to big tier 1 cities and everyone lives a 3rd class life. Think 🤔
Building new water reservoirs is also important because whole MMR region is currently facing water supply issues. Hopefully govt has also considered it in it's plan.
Its just another reason for MF politicians to grab prime land
why would MMR region not face this ? It is common sense.the idea of 3rd city is just bogus. it is just shifting /deviating issue for few years
Vaitarna is in thane
Totally agree to your point. The aforementioned site for "Third Mumbai" has Morbe Dam in it's vicinity.
@@darsheetvora what will happen after we build the city and open the dam gates
There are other regions as well in Maharashtra, it seems government thinks there are two regions of Maharashtra, Mumbai, Not-Mumbai.
you nailed the issue.
Seriously bro, as someone from Mumbai they keep staging some new bs. Fadnavis Maharashtra viktoy
Yes correct. I think some inland city should have been developed in eastern Maharashtra. That would have been better option and that also would be closer to Hyderabad so that would also be an advantage.
Politicians equation is like - Mumbai for money, rest of mh for votes to control Mumbai
Does People from those areas pay tax to goverment unlike Mumbai and it's suburbs??
People in Mumbai-pune work harder and also they invest in the economy many entrepreneurs are from those areas and Outside Enterprises rather than interior parts of Maharashtra would choose Mumbai/Pune rather than smaller cities
And also another factor is are there people who are in those areas encouraging industries? really going to give thier own land for Industrial purpose
When a plant was going to built in konkan
People opposed the plant
As they wanted to preserve ''eco-system and nature of konkan"
This leds to investors and industrialists being low in confidence for investment in that area...
In Mumbai, Except for Arrey depot incident, many people have supported the development rather than other factors
That why, people and industries are inclined towards the Mumbai Pune and its suburbs
nagpur is somewhat developing but nashik requires good transport like Metro and suburban line like Manmad to Igatpuri
Other towns in MH(Chh. Sambhaji nagar,Nanded,Latur,Jalna, Amravati) are not that suitable currently unless Entrepreneurs are being given some allowances and assurance about future development or else they would not try to invest
I won't be surprised if this news is sponsored by some builder/builders planning projects in the so-called "Third Mumbai". And for ur kind info Navi Mumbai has not FAILED..but surely needs more improvement
Devendra is very close to some real property developers.
Some businessmen, one related with this video own huge SEZ, port and Airports along with huge tracts of land that they plan to get developed by our beloved Sarcar, so let's plan a new city.
Instead of keep increasing size of one city, politicians in India should improve tier two and three cities. That's the only way India's huge population can be benefitted.
Couldn't agree more! Why not just develop Maharashtra!
@@mlg1279 There is always the option of small airports & smaller planes for direct connectivity to larger city Airports. Many small/ remote cities n towns in Western countries have such facility.
There are just 4- 5 cities in India that offer better opportunities for better jobs. And these are the cities facing increasing people & traffic congestion. Developing well planned infra + travel n commute connectivity in smaller cities near these big cities would be the better option . No purpose further over burdening an already over burdened large city
We dont have enough money to develop all cities. Our tier 1 cities are behind China's and USA's tier 2 cities in terms of infrastructure.
So forget your dreams. Tier 1 city will always develop and have more investments. Tier 3 will degrade and tier 2 will be slow.
@@Dhruv-Kumar India has the funds but political intent is lacking.
Third Mumbai should have been built in Thane district area, covering the area of Thane city, Kalyan Dombivali, Mira Road and Palghar
Navi Mumbai is in Thane bro and this new also will be in Thane only
@@maheshsathe9197 Arey Apla Kalyan Dombivali Ambernath Badlapur ithe pann development paahije ithun loka sakaali loka Mumbai la jaatat aani ratri ghari yetaat. Mahanje kaay Kalyan chi loka fakht local cha dhakke khanya saathi ahe kaay
Overcrowded ho chuka hai ye sab area
It comes in thane district
@@MrPrandhirBhava tu Badlapur madhye aple business ka nahi kholat? Job culture sodvave marathi mansa ne
First of all Navi Mumbai didn't fail.. It's flourishing at its own pace.. the growth is slow because of the govts inablity to provide basic amenities on time.. The bus facilities are inadequate, trains aren't running on time, shared auto and taxi have their own mafia squads which is not controlled by authorities. Govt. simply couldn't provide when needed. Still the presence of private services are more helpful than the public transport.
Secondly I can only figure out that influential people have a lot of investment in new panvel and outskirts of panvel which is not selling because of lack of amenities and with the name PANVEL attached.. Hence Third Mumbai.. because mumbai is easy to sell..
You should literally change your video title.. its misleading for new buyers and whatever the case be it will be costlier to travel from third Mumbai to Actual Central Mumbai..
Why is the name Panvel attached a con? I was taking this video into consideration and came across your comment which sounds aware. Can you let me know
@@ThankYouGoogle4 Its not a con at all. Old panvel area is already well established with transportation, hospitals, schools. So the builders and may be govt. decided to build a "New Panvel" which is way out of panvel, away from easy transport so it seems people who are aware of the area are not investing in their projects. 1 because they are charging too much in the name of "Panvel", 2 areas in New Panvel are not so much established. Hence they got the idea of making Third Mumbai. Which will cover all the projects in New Panvel renamed as Third Mumbai.
That doesn't mean that it is not a good investment. If you are planning for a long term investment you can sure go for it. But for a similar price you can get a flat in New Mumbai which is way closer to Mumbai and connectivity is available via different means..
@@bilalansari348 Thanks a lot man! So Navi Mumbai is a big area it seems and so which area in there would be better for investment there now?
@@ThankYouGoogle4 It will completely depend on your budget and requirements.. If you can pay a premium price then you must look for places between Vashi and Belapur (Railway stations). If slightly low on budget then for Kharghar, Taloja, Khandeshwar etc. Prices also differ as per the distance of property from Railway station and Highway and amenities..
@@ThankYouGoogle4the prices are insane, I went to new panvel thinking it might be cheaper , 1bhk flat costs between 55lac - 70lac new construction. And if you want to rent it out you would only get between 8k - 12k . I don’t understand this maths of investing 60lac and getting 12k , even FD and LIC will give better returns 😂😂
Funfact: So called " Third Mumbai" will be auctually closer to Pune so just name it New Pune because " Navi Navi Mumbai" will sound weird. Why don't they just issue tender for Vandelocals so that Mumbai Suburban railway can go beyond Kasara & Khopoli & develop infra for Nashik & Pune.
Or they can name it as " Navi Mumbai Suburban city"
So basically builders got a new jargon.
Why? It’ll still be closer to actual Mumbai.
A very simple answer- Mumbai is an astronomically bigger brand than Pune.
Mumbai local cannot go beyond Kasara & Khopoli. You need RRTS for that.
*शंभर मुंबई शहर तयार केले तरी परप्रांतीय लोंढे काहि थांबणार नाही*
*शिवाय त्याचा मराठी माणसाला काहिच फायदा होणार नाही.*
*निसर्गाची वाट लाऊन कसला विकास करताय काय समजत नाही महाराष्ट्रात बाकिचे पण शहर आहेत तिकडे काहितरी करा !!!*
Navi Mumbai isn't a failure. It is a planned city and was never designed to take in say half of Mumbai's population. In 1972, Mumbai's population was half of what it is today.
And the biggest disadvantage of Navi Mumbai is its distance from Mumbai. How is that going to be solved by building a third city even further away from Mumbai?
Exactly. Even travelling from Navi Mumbai to Main mumbai is hell of a hectic task and time consuming... Coming to main mumbai from third mumbai would be like going on a trip for sure lol, not at all feasible.
This is simply meant for the builder lobby. It does not benefit citizens and is certainly another burden on the fragile environment of the western ghats. This should never be approved. Also, Cidco and NMMC are responsible for messing up Navi Mumbai.
Correct. Mumbai -> Navi Mumbai -> Navya Naveli Mumbai 👍
New Mumbai name is maha Mumbai
Gujratis Mumbai specially मोटाभाई Adani ।
Thanks
It seems that the competition between both the old and new Mumbai regarding business hubs have stalled new Mumbai. Don't know if the government is going to do something about it.
Thoda thane k baad k development kardo at the end of the day log kaam karny toh thane ya thane k baad sy hi aaty hai
Thane mein bhi rail , road connectivity ka major issues hai. Metro bhi kai saal se incomplete hai & 2023 mein bhi kuch kaam hota hua nahin dikhta . Adhiktar Roads narrow hain aur unka quality bekaar hain. Traffic management sahi nahin hain. Jab ki ye CM Shinde & family ke political rise ka area raha hai
after sometime mumbai and pune will mix together🤣
Yeah the outskirts of pune will also be outskirts of Mumbai 😂 Jo bhi ho Maharashtra ki GDP 1 trillion dollar honi chahiye.
@@emotionalwibes7400abhi toh boht time hai it will reach 500 billion in atleast 5 years estimated
@@kzcciynk
Na , 450B$ to already ho chuke h Maharashtra ke GDP .
Next 5 ye me around 800B$ ke aaspas hoge . 1 trillion$ in next 5 yr to mushkil h
@@sidy6526 lets hope for political stability of our state and the land of Chatrapati Shivaji Maharaj
Bengaluru also needs something like this
Regional Economic growth , expansion and development.
Please develop Tier-2, Tier-3 cities in Maharashtra. At the end this people are only coming for jobs in Tier-1 cities why not build opportunities in their own hometown itself
Develop Karnataka also. Don't depend on maharashtra and shift whole karwar, manglore and north Karnataka.
Instead of focusing on third mumbai developntje existing new mumbai which lacks many of the basic facilities. Invest in infrastructure and public transport there. Make navi mumbai a finance,tech and manufacturing hub like how NCR is doing with noida and gurgaon. Automatically Mumbai will start to decongesy and also the overall gdp of mumbai will increase along with quality of life in the MMR. MMR should consider this. Also pune is also lagging in development, there should be focus of development in pune as well.
Hope this New Mumbai will be well planned city like *Chandigarh* and *Gandhinagar*
well they need land to build more slums 😜😂!!
There is no need of third Mumbai.
Interior of Maharashtra is suffering from low development,need to address this.
Why dont they develop Marathwada??
It works only if every requirement you say is done on time, otherwise it will fail
If politics is kept aside then it will be done... otherwise like Mumbai metro, dharavi even this will stop
Govt changes & the work of previous govt gets deliberately stalled/ delayed / restructured . Thackeray govt restructured the Mumbai Metro work that cost the State & alongwith it India multiple millions of loss. Same for AP's Amravati city project. Ditto for Vajpayee Govt's work.
Aam junta needs to be educated abt the implications of their vote
Pune is the third mumbai
Nagpur la develop karayala hav.. data centre wagarele port connectivity nahi lagat... Tari pan anvin project suru karun crore rupees cha ghotala kaalrach😢
Declare Navi Mumbai as Capital of Maharashtra ( like NewDelhi as capital of India , side tracking old Delhi )and also develop another city as second capital preferably of central Maharashtra. Former J&K had two capitals
And affordable apartments? Or will the same corruption & builder-neta nexus ensure multi-crore prices in 3rd Mumbai also?
Make big roads like dubai
Also focus on east, central, and North Maharashtra
NOT Third mumbai, but satellite cities around all metros & tier 1 cities with all facilities & rail, road connect also.😮😮😊😊
A totally ridiculous idea. Jobs need to move to Tier 2 and Tier 3 cities and towns. Jobs being handled in Mumbai and Delhi and Bangalore are being handled in Tier 2 cities in the US
The Leaders of Navi Mumbai were Smart Enough not to over populate it.. Its much better than Old Mumbai to Live.. Also The New Mumbai airport plan was introduced by Congress and much earlier than 2010 as I am 39 now and aince I was 20 years old I was hearing that there will be New Mumbai airport also in future.. Third Mumbai is a Burger between Pune and Old Mumbai but I understand that middle class and lower middle class can live happily by saving on rent and can work both sides Mumbai and Pune
Mumbai should be declared as a UT. What about rest of Maharashtra if funds will go only to develop Third Mumbai? Financial centres are funded by the central govt around the world and here the city is taking most of the state's budget.
In fact it is because of Mumbai that the Maharashtra government can spend in other regions too. Declaring Mumbai as a UT will be big blow to the state like how Andhra Pradesh suffered after it lost Hyderabad to Telangana. It will be dependent on Pune & Nagpur for funds.
whatever tax etc. revenue mumbai generates for the maharashtra state govt.. the govt should utilize that money to develop rural places in the state
Navi Mumbai continues to be under developed & under utilized when it has immense potential. And now they are trying build a 3rd Mumbai ! What a waste of funds
Why are you so jealous 😢
@@Deb_deCodermumbai's money belong to mumbai. Dont steal
😂😂😂 name whole India as Mumbai such a 3rd class Unworthy minds.... When our Politicians dont have Capacity to develop single city these selfish idea will come out from their brains... Maharashtra and Karnataka both have same problem... Both Capital cities are complete in corner of the map😢😢😢
India is a large country. Why concentrate so much people and capital in one urban area, instead of spreading it out more evenly across India's territory by building up (and building out) already existing second- and third-tier cities?
This will become a fuckin nightmare for pilots of Mumbai bound flights in next 2 decades ( if they survive AI) because there will be more Mumbai's than manganlal chikki in Lonavala.
Jokes apart talks are also going for 4 Mumbai surrounding Wadhavan port in Dhananu/Palghar.
Why IFSC was not planned for third mumbai
Deputy CM is now became a CM
Please correct it.
Thanks
Navi Mumbai should open spaces marked as well multi story parking facilities gardens huge parks for
Food parks
Yes! they lack it high time.
Please think to develop other districts also or there will be two parts of Maharashtra one with mumbai and without mumbai means developed and undeveloped
Just to benefit politicians ,builders and businessmen- more money while resources and infrastructure get worse . Mumbai is already bursting and has to be decongested but the politicians are more interested in their own vested interest .
Actually that economic , job sector is the main reason why the Navi Mumbai is behind or else the population , the infrastructure has grown or has swollen up.
Create DHOLERA, GIFT city kind of project at marathawada region
No design available about this so called Third Mumbai.
Maharashtra don't need third mumbai, each state should have thier mumbai in thier States, special north hindi states.
Exactly, If UP, Bihar had job hubs it'll help not only their own states but northeast and bengal. Hope it happens as well
The video explains that the Third Mumbai project is intended to solve the problem of overcrowding and other issues in Mumbai. This project could have a big effect on the economy of Maharashtra. Even though Maharashtra gets less tax money from the central government than the northern states (Maharashtra gets 7.7rs per 100rs as compared to up and bihar getting 333rs and 922rs respectively), it can still develop, and the northern states are also growing.
It is requested that,
1)Dharavee slum may be redeveloped faster.
2)50%school fees may be reduced or shared.🙏
Why not develope cities like nagpur instead, they're asking for development for years, the CM seat is from nagpur post 2014, It was in hand of sena during covid but post Shinde coup it's again in the hands of BJP and yet they're ignoring nagpur as a whole, wtf
No ones ignoring nagpur it's THE biggest hub for logistics in india each and week big investments regarding logistics and small scale industries supporting them come by its not much shown in media cause its not glamorising enough
@@boeingotaku3723 not true , i have been there
Navi mumbai did not fail. It was a haphazard solution even at that time (trying to disguise out of control urban sprawl as a revolutionary move).
What about Satara,Sangli,Karad,Hingoli,Wardha,Washim,Jalgaon,Dhule,Nandurbar,Bhandara,Nanded,Latur,Dharashiv,Ahilyanagar,Gadchiroli,Yavatmal,Chandrapur?
We don't need Third Mumbai at all at this moment Mumbai & Maharashtra only needs one thing & that is people from other parts of India who have migrated to Maharashtra should now go back & Mumbai & Maharashtra have exhausted it's capacity how much urbanisation is Government going to carry our in Maharashtra, it's time to develop other states of India instead of creating Third Mumbai develop cities like Lucknow, Kanpur, Jaipur etc & other cities in North & South India. How much are you going to pound on Mumbai & Maharashtra. If we want India to develop than every city & state needs to develop to achieve this goal ,development can't be concentrated in a particular city & State.
Why not make entire Thane District including part of Vasai Virar area (which was part of Thane District before attachment with Palghar) as Another Mumbai ?
Yeah right? I don't understand why they keep avoiding those regions.
Vasai-Virar is back of beyond
Mumbai pe Mumbai, Mumbai pe Mumbai milti rahi he milord...
Hire some cityplanners from The Netherlands or any Scandinavian countries. The quality of living and the city itself will be much better than American inspired cities.
100%
Prefer living in Norway & Sweden much more than US and even UK!
When did Navi Mumbai fail? Its a clean, beautiful city. Its not failed just because Mumbai is congested and squalid. Nonsernse.
Im excited I'm from PEN😮🎉
me bhi pen se
Infrastructure should be planned taking into consideration of 100 years future.🙏
The main reason was Charles Correa couldnt muster sypport from the bureaucracy who decided to destroy his plans.
Good to know. And we have started planning ahead, which in itself is an important thing!
I hope and pray it better not be alibaug.....as i live in south mumbai and the way traffic has increased here parking,socialising area falls short for open spaces this is all made easily for developer lobby to earn lots n lots of money also majority developers are coming with idea of amenities so they can pile amenities on middle class people so that they can dispose their newly given possession flats....and move away from prime areas and reside to vasai and virar
New DLC , coming soon
Mumbai 3.0, pre order today
आमची मुंबई ❤❤❤
We need urbanisation. Fast and better
Mumbai needs IT hub
No thank you. No IT hubs please 🙏
We are trying to disperse people & here you are suggestign IT hub? Pune & Nagpur is the city which you should look forward to then.
No IFSC in Mumbai ?
Knowledgeable video, but didn't tell how far is 3rd Mumbai from old Mumbai. ( kilometres)
Instead of developing it further east and away from main Mumbai they should have went north and developed it in Mira-Bhayander, Vasai-Virar and Thane collectively which are geographically and culturally more connected to the Mumbai island also giving easier access to both Mumbai and Navi Mumbai
What abt d bird sanctuary?
Og Mumbai is almost corrupted that's why we are giving birth to the New Mumbai. 😂
it will still be part of Mumbai Metropolitan region genius
Corrupted ? Or congested ? Mumbai is a long strip of land with plenty reclaimed land. So congestion is expected . Lack of forethought to development & urban planning makes the situation worse
Go to Colaba , good empty sea views
@@eggbenedict-gt7mw Colaba is congested esp the causeway . Even near Gateway random construction blocks one side of Taj & direct view of the sea
@@aosaeanor there are plenty secret spots bro, do r&d , in Colaba
If you are going to build navi-navi-mumbai or navi-mumbai-2, Build it next to water body. like arabian sea. So you do not need to build a port. you can build canals for inland ports for land locked cities. But first learn to use what we have properly.
Whatever happened to all local train conversion to AC locals ??
Navi Mumbai failed, no wonder media has names like presstitute
Why not simultaneously develop pune and nagpur?
India needs to make it clean, and not so dusty
The trick is to have forests surrounding the city and also, less legalised pollution by industries around the city. India Can do it if they truly want to make the city successful
Mumbai’s main issue is it does not have a whole lot of industries- so the metro area’s GDP is pretty small at $150 billion for a city that wants to be a global city. Shanghai’s gdp is $600 billion as a comparison. Maharashtra despite having a lot of land and a long coastline has a gdp of only $450 billion for a population of 120 million people. that is pretty low for a so-called industrial state. Better set up a lot of export oriented industries. Mumbai metro area has a lot of unutilized land. Maharashtra needs to double its GDP quickly and for that Mumbai has to more than double its GDP.
Title itself says that how it will benefit the MMR. Nothing is for Maharashtra,everything is for Mumbai.
BC Marathwada, vidarbh kya sirf vote ke liye hai kya ???. Marathwada me talent hai par opportunity bilkul bhi nahi mil Rahi. Latur ko develop Karo thoda.
Thanks to Congress for slow infrastructure development
They ought to call the next one new Bombay for the sake of nostalgia .
Devendra Fandavis is a big fakeu...his party now a days not taking him seriously...
So.. should I invest there??
दिल्ली की मेट्रो मुंबई से सस्ती है। क्यों?
मेट्रो की सुविधा मुंबई, नई मुंबई और होनेवाली मुंबई में नहीं है।
पोलुटेड समंदर किनारे, मॅंगृज की कमी और भी समस्या है जहा केंद्र सरकार की सहायता नहीं मिली।
IT company are some switched to wfh this will reduce a lot and now mall business are slowdown
Devendra Phadnavis should become CM with immediate effect
We can’t do anything about the lateral space the one floor slums are taking..
A simple strategy can be naming the whole area as Mumbai. Navi Mumbai, Third Mumbai creates a comparative cobtext among cities.
Develop infrastructure like Mumbai and name the whole area as Mumbai. Kaam khatam paisa hazam.
MMRDA should go thru the plans of Amrawati in AP..
Where is the point where you talk about local?
Time to shift important establishments to other locations
I request maharashtra govt. to develop pune , nagpur , aurangabad (chattrapati sambhaji nagar) , nashik and other cities .
Mumbai 3.0 ? Navi Navi Mumbai?
Poore MMR reigion ko planing k saath redeveloped karna chahiye
Mumbai ecosystem will collapse! Too much pressure on natural resources! Politicians just want to make money - especially from the most corrupt industry- Housing construction industry! Even public limited companies are paying kickbacks thru subcontractors/ vendors to the politicians/ corporators. Ghanerda Phasavnooknis is an idiot! He doesn’t care much about Mumbai- how can one forget the fact that he was once the architect of separate “ Vidarbha” movement. Just disgusting to see that Maharashtra’s green belts/ Mangroves are becoming concrete jungles! Need Marathi revolution to save Maharashtra! Pl go and build in fucking UP/ Bihar/Zharkhand third Mumbai. Stop converting Maharashtra into an extension of UP/Bihar/Zharkhand. Pl Wake up Marathi people- otherwise our rich heritage will be lost!
Yes I also have same opinion. Existing development of Navi Mumbai is not at all good. They are planning for third Mumbai. Pehle Navi Mumbai ko toh behter banai in terms of infrastructure,job opportunities,road network and health care. If our politicians keep on doing what they did till now,UP would soon take Maharashtra. Given Delhi ncr doing so well and Bangalore, Hyderabad too. We don't want to end up like Kolkata
@@emotionalwibes7400
Bc Maharashtra coastal state h or UP landlocked.
Ydi up landkocked na hota to shayd piche chor deta Maharashtra ko , lekin koi chance nhi h . Maharashtra geographical advance will always keep it at top .
UP at most 2nd pe aa sakta h bas , vo bhi abhi sure nhi h because tamilnadu acha perform kar rha h or tamilnadu ke pass bhi geographical advantage h over UP.
Lekin fir bhi mujhe lagta h longterm me UP 2nd pe aa jaega GDP me (mainly because of its population or thoda bohot western UP me jo kam ho rha h. Eastern Up to khatam h bilkul, ekdum Bihar jesa ).
Make 4th Mumbai too - just build proper sidewalks and don't cut trees
You are funny atleast let them build 3rd mumbai which most likely to fail unless all corporate want to move too, it's not people who decide it's corporates and jobs which decides whether it will succeed or not, and most likely what you are saying that public transport must be good it will require lot of money which would go waste if it fails and If they didn't build public transport it's going fail for sure, make jobs available there in local region so traveling is less to main mumbai, so they depend on it. This channel is sponsored by builder and capitalists who just want to build building and want projects from government to build quick money and leave, they don't care about people in general
बात बैलट पर भी हो🙏🙏
Ye sub thik hai but pehle original Mumbai ka road to thik karo, fir 3rd and 4th Mumbai bananeka plan karo.
Third airport search land coz navi mumbai has got only 2 runways while noida airport will be getting 4 runways..
Farmers offing themselves but these politicians want another Mumbai. Mumbai is a cash cow for politicians, so they want more
Coastal city but it's useless , if u want to do rod fishing, all netting on shore,
After the Nitin gadkari, another leader likes Devendra fadwanish, who has the potential to become PM of india. Though i am from Bihar.
No he doesn’t have and I’m saying this as a Maharashtrian. Gadkari saheb is the only one.
cities dont fail or pass... with trans harbour link and NMIA Navi Mumbai will soar
It is better to move to Dubai than this navi navi Mumbai 🤣
What about solapur ?
Solapur should first improve their Marathi accent. Sorry, frank opinion.
@@clodhopper-dodo 😂😂😂😂
Wrong map. The maps show Mumbai is smaller than Navi Mumbai!
I guess Navi Mumbai didn't failed..