It wasnt unspoken beef he wanted to get paid more but they wanted to pay him as a kid and plus the actor said he wanted to live his life and go to collage
@@Mr562comegetthat no he didn’t he bought a house by where they were filming cause he thought he’d be on the show for years and obi he wants a pay raise from a kids wage 1st of all he’s a grown man and he got way more screen time in his last few season because he wasn’t a little kid anymore how can you blame him for wanting more money he was most likely the lowest paid main character too cause of his age so yeah stfu
Biggest mistakes killing carl in show, gimple fired chandler but you all can see chandler did great on his job and in the end they killed carl bullshit.
Well he had some good moments when he was younger and even less in the later seasons. I love Carl but yeah he couldn’t really deliver what he needed to
@@cohen3460 He was bad when he was young because...well...obviously, he was just a fucking kid. From season 5-6 and on, you can actually see a huge improvement in his acting. He shouldn't have been fired.
FUN FACT: Carl was supposed to live, and Morgan was supposed to take his death. However there was a change of plans with the crossover and they decided to kill Carl.
Dante Aguilar for me makes more sense Judith becomes the last standing because se was kept safe by a lot of people that are now dead. So seeing her and remember her story we will remember everyone that kept her safe that died. But yeah killing of Carl was stupid!
Right, that's why they faced so much struggled and they are trying their best to revived it by collabing FTWD to TWD, but then FTWD itself is a big flop since the main character nick died too lol.
@@intothe643 they lost so much, i lost interest watching TWD & FTWD after carl and nick died. I laugh when gimple gave up on holding the shows, he's a big mistake and he made terrible decision to kill two characters who should live longer.
so true I mean idc that rick left the show if carl was alive cus I honestly thought Carl's the future and shit. it was a big mistake and judith shouldn't have taken her place. even with Glenn's death carl would've revived the show. I still like watching it cus of daryl but would've been better if carl was alive
5:18 Just realized that they recreated Carl’s last scene in the comics for Chandlers last epsiode 10:15 and I don’t think the last comic had been released yet when this was on tv?
I feel like Carl shoulda lived into Season 9 and every other season unless he has a huge build up and a bunch of episodes are about him, then he dies saving alexandria, or dies saving Judith, but other than that, I think that Carl could have and should have been the main character until Rick is found.
Killing off Carl was the worst mistake Scott Gimple ever made, and that's saying a lot considering his track record. Thank fuck for Angela Kang is all I can say.
She did a good job on season 9, but she isn't much better than gimple, she ruined season 10 and 11 in my opinion, those seasons were honestly God awful
Like i understand that chandler was aging more than his comic variant but instead of killing him off, they could have deviated from the comics a bit and let him and judith combine for the story.
Hate to say it but I would rather have Rick die in the show and Carl live. In the comics Carl stepped up and in the show Carl was already starting to step up and become the leader he was destined to be.
@@nf2086 I'm not gonna hold up in s10 but i agreed that s9 is doing great. Like what happened in s3 to s7 but after that it flop and it's sucks to be disappointed.
Carl never cutting his hair again because his mom always cut it and she died it's actually really cool. Not to mention it covers the eye hole pretty well lol
I'd also like to point out that the talk Morgan had with Carl before he turned, was the point of no return for Carl imho, cause that's when Carl officially decided to be a good person. Because he was about to do something terrible.
If they really needed someone close to Rick to die to pass on the message of having mercy, why not use Morgan? Have him die in a scenario where his bloodlust got him killed, and he says to Rick "don't let it overcome you, stay true to yourself, you're a good man", then when he cuts Negan's throat he remembers what Morgan told him and decides to save him. Would've made a lot more sense than killing off the embodiment of the future of the story. Or just have it like the comics where saving Negan to have him see the future they build, showing him that his way was wrong, was a good enough reason.
@@realamerican8900 After Nick wanted to go, they could've made Madison the lead instead of killing her as well, I don't think it was her decision to leave. And yeah, Gimple was great for 4, 5, and 6, then 7 and 8 just tanked. Like you said, 9 and 10 are amazing, but without having Carl as the central thread it feels weird. Judith is a fine enough replacement but she doesn't have the history.
Carl was done insanely dirty in the TV series. Hopefully TWD can get another, more comic-accurate series, à la _FMA: Brotherhood_ maybe even in an animated medium too. Amazon's _Invincible_ (coincidentally, another series by Robert Kirkman) has proven that this could definitely work.
They killed him off to save siddiq just to kill siddiqs character off two seasons later. Making carls death feel even more unnecessary and frustrating.
im convinced that carl is alive their are may things that can sort of prove it aswell the creator said "if rick ever dies carl will lead the show" and the day carl shot himself they didnt show it and its also possible that rick could have hallucinated like he did with lori in season 3 and it could possible that rick just told everyone what he saw and believed him and carl is out their surviving and in the comics their was a time jump thats similar to season 9 and most of season 10 so far im convinced that carl is alive and going to show up and if you use the excuse that he was bared alot of people died that day they could have bared anyone.
Why did Scott Mmmmm Gimple have to do Chandler Riggs so dirty though? Carl should not have died, especially to save a side character who is dead now anyway.
Because gimple himself doesn't have sense of great, he's a suckass himself he might be taking all the money of chandler riggs since he doesn't want to pay higher for a legal age so he has a reason to fired him. If chandler played an annoying character and got so much haters then gimple has reason to fired him. But chandler is a great actor you can see it by watching "Inherit the vaper" "Now" "Keep watching" "Mercy" "A million little things" :-) chandler is just following the orders it's not him who wants to be dirty as carl.
They shouldve had carl bit. Then rick goes to find him in the cabin after the battle or something. hes gone, carls disappeared and rick and the audience are meant to assume he turned and roamed off. later on during ricks fake death we get some reference to "We got him, we got his father". So Carl was taken to wherever rick is, this not only keeps carl alive but it gives Rick a reason to not leave.
People had theories at the time of why the kid was written off the show A: he wanted to go to college B: Riggs didn't want to renew his contract for another 3 years C: riggs got fired 2 weeks before his 18th birthday because him and gimple had problems with each other D: Gimple couldn't pay riggs anymore because he was becoming an adult
And they did his death for shock value and gimple thought it would boost views and ratings. But that backfired and lost 11.8 million viewers in the after math.
@@SpiderCreep still Carl deserve to live with judith and rj they're siblings after all. Judith lost her mom and she lost her older brother, she doesn't deserve to lost a family member.
@@SpiderCreep i feel like they gonna kill Judith if she grow up as the same age of Carl and put rj as a replacement of Carl and judith. They don't want to fill the gap where it's place for carl, they want it as a mystery and make the show longer than we expected but they already lost Carl it's never been the same.
A Character that got wasted unfortunately.
Yep!
Fr amc had some unspoken beef with Carl I swear they killed him out of no where in the dumbest way possible
It wasnt unspoken beef he wanted to get paid more but they wanted to pay him as a kid and plus the actor said he wanted to live his life and go to collage
Truuueee
@@Mr562comegetthat no he didn’t he bought a house by where they were filming cause he thought he’d be on the show for years and obi he wants a pay raise from a kids wage 1st of all he’s a grown man and he got way more screen time in his last few season because he wasn’t a little kid anymore how can you blame him for wanting more money he was most likely the lowest paid main character too cause of his age so yeah stfu
I will NEVER get over Carl's death on the Show.
Biggest mistakes killing carl in show, gimple fired chandler but you all can see chandler did great on his job and in the end they killed carl bullshit.
Well he had some good moments when he was younger and even less in the later seasons. I love Carl but yeah he couldn’t really deliver what he needed to
He was a bad actor and couldn’t deliver his lines for shit
Not to mention that Carl being killed off influenced Andrew Lincoln to leave the show
@@siavashmassoudi As well as many other characters that died, left soley because of Gimple. Andrew will be back for the end of the series
@@cohen3460 He was bad when he was young because...well...obviously, he was just a fucking kid. From season 5-6 and on, you can actually see a huge improvement in his acting. He shouldn't have been fired.
They could have this ending with judith in the show. She could have a son named Carl since Rj already took the name rick
Kinda weird to name your son after your dead brother
Eontrix yea but carl names his after his step mom
Eontrix my middle name is based on my mom’s deceased younger brother so not weird in my opinion
Eontrix: My cousin was named after his mother’s dead brother...
@@Eontrix I dont find that weird at all.
I’m so glad that they added that Carl Poppa reference.
Me too
FUN FACT: Carl was supposed to live, and Morgan was supposed to take his death. However there was a change of plans with the crossover and they decided to kill Carl.
No in season 8 rick was supposed to die
But plans changed for gimple
@@intothe643I heard that as well.
Something To do with Morgan being Gimple's favorite character.
YESSSSS. Still sad about Carl’s death in the show 😔
I’m mad he died but if he HAD to die I wish he would have got a better death
Gasondem 09 exactly
Yeah
Well with a walker bite death, it gives you the chance to say goodbye. Better than being blown up....
Abbas Farhat I’m cool with him getting bit if he had to but the way it happened was dumb, they should have done it better
Gasondem 09 elaborate plz
Carl is the legacy of Rick , the show should have ended like comics
HArry Puttar but Judith is the legacy of everyone that kept her safe!
Carl is supposed to be last man standing can’t believe they killed the main protagonist of the franchise like that very stupid
Dante Aguilar for me makes more sense Judith becomes the last standing because se was kept safe by a lot of people that are now dead. So seeing her and remember her story we will remember everyone that kept her safe that died. But yeah killing of Carl was stupid!
Short answer: *A PERSON WHO SHOULDNT HAVE BEEN KILLED*
Thank gimple for that
Carl’s death is still a huge ass mistake!🤦♂️😡😭
Definitely, and that's why the show is suffering
Right, that's why they faced so much struggled and they are trying their best to revived it by collabing FTWD to TWD, but then FTWD itself is a big flop since the main character nick died too lol.
@@flagellationynfluencia1971 yep when killing two important characters in two shows will cause some trouble in a bad way
@@intothe643 they lost so much, i lost interest watching TWD & FTWD after carl and nick died. I laugh when gimple gave up on holding the shows, he's a big mistake and he made terrible decision to kill two characters who should live longer.
so true I mean idc that rick left the show if carl was alive cus I honestly thought Carl's the future and shit. it was a big mistake and judith shouldn't have taken her place. even with Glenn's death carl would've revived the show. I still like watching it cus of daryl but would've been better if carl was alive
They should totally put a scene in Season 11 of Judith reading a letter that past Carl wrote for her before he died
Carl had the most anti climactic death in the walking dead
Lol
I’m still mad he died
They did Carl so dirty in the show. Him dying literally killed the show.
Ahhh 😔 we miss Carl, I’m watching the entire collection of Walking Dead again and it’s fascinating to watch him grow up on this show 😎
5:18 Just realized that they recreated Carl’s last scene in the comics for Chandlers last epsiode 10:15 and I don’t think the last comic had been released yet when this was on tv?
That’s so cool
I feel like Carl shoulda lived into Season 9 and every other season unless he has a huge build up and a bunch of episodes are about him, then he dies saving alexandria, or dies saving Judith, but other than that, I think that Carl could have and should have been the main character until Rick is found.
Im assuming Daryl will get Carl’s comic ending. I see an old Daryl with Connie and a kid named Merle or something.
Or Beth
Killing off Carl was the worst mistake Scott Gimple ever made, and that's saying a lot considering his track record.
Thank fuck for Angela Kang is all I can say.
She did a good job on season 9, but she isn't much better than gimple, she ruined season 10 and 11 in my opinion, those seasons were honestly God awful
Like i understand that chandler was aging more than his comic variant but instead of killing him off, they could have deviated from the comics a bit and let him and judith combine for the story.
CARL GRIMES IS MY BABY
RIGHT
Wtf
@@dwyaneandreil.inciong2979 Lydia is also Carl's gf before quickly marrying Sophia in the TWD comics after Rick's death.
"Who is Carl?"
The son of Rick Grimes, and wasted potential
Even After 5 years, I'm still trying to Comprehend Carl's death.
Hahaha! I love the opening!
Cor-al!!!
I'm glad he lived in the comics. I wish AMC and Gimple good luck with the show.
Hate to say it but I would rather have Rick die in the show and Carl live. In the comics Carl stepped up and in the show Carl was already starting to step up and become the leader he was destined to be.
Even enid was doing a better work than him..saving glenn n maggie n hilltop people
Even saving carl...when negan was going to attack him...bringing kingdom
They pretty much wasted his childhood just to get bit by a zombie
And AMC wasted a great show by ending it by killing carl.
Flagellation Ynfluencia nah s9 and 10 are good until they said they were gonna drag the episodes
@@nf2086 I'm not gonna hold up in s10 but i agreed that s9 is doing great. Like what happened in s3 to s7 but after that it flop and it's sucks to be disappointed.
Carl never cutting his hair again because his mom always cut it and she died it's actually really cool. Not to mention it covers the eye hole pretty well lol
carl and ron fighting was so funny cause we’ve seen this kid shoot people with no hesitation and he can’t even throw a punch
They could’ve had gnarly spin offs if Carl was alive. He could’ve been the center piece to bridge all these series together.
The episode where Carl gets bit and spends the day wit Judith was only episode to make me cry
Ok if Carl got that ending that would be so interesting
Carl! Carrrrrrl , CARRRRRAL
Chandler Riggs.
Andrew Lincoln
Norman Reedus
Steven yuen
@@ShyamSundar-ii8uv Sarah Waynes
Lauren cohan
My favorite memory is when you whacked a character that was supposed to survive longer than the person with a mullet...
Yay been waiting for this episode
I will never forgive Gimple for Carl's death.
The boy who always tripped over himself
Top ten dumbest changes for show/movies from page to screen at number 1-10 we have Carl dying in the All Out War story ark
I really miss you Carl :((
already love it !
Yes I love Carl
I HAVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS
I’m upset you didn’t reference the ta ta carl gives sebastion while walking away from the cell
I'd also like to point out that the talk Morgan had with Carl before he turned, was the point of no return for Carl imho, cause that's when Carl officially decided to be a good person. Because he was about to do something terrible.
3:16 actually he was 13 after the time jump, turned 14 shortly later.
funny the very company that produced the comics cant even get shit right
Carl was never supposed to die
That felt so unexpected when he died
I wish Carl was still alive and was in love with Lydia
Nor Sophia
Sophia's better
@@Moonshine449 well in the sjoe sophie dead so of she was alive then yeah I would agree but...
@@juniorsigala5028 we are talking about the comic's
@@Moonshine449 ah shit
the carl moment that hit me the hardest was when he said "le jiggy jar jar doo dur dee dur dee dur"
If they really needed someone close to Rick to die to pass on the message of having mercy, why not use Morgan? Have him die in a scenario where his bloodlust got him killed, and he says to Rick "don't let it overcome you, stay true to yourself, you're a good man", then when he cuts Negan's throat he remembers what Morgan told him and decides to save him. Would've made a lot more sense than killing off the embodiment of the future of the story. Or just have it like the comics where saving Negan to have him see the future they build, showing him that his way was wrong, was a good enough reason.
@@realamerican8900 After Nick wanted to go, they could've made Madison the lead instead of killing her as well, I don't think it was her decision to leave. And yeah, Gimple was great for 4, 5, and 6, then 7 and 8 just tanked. Like you said, 9 and 10 are amazing, but without having Carl as the central thread it feels weird. Judith is a fine enough replacement but she doesn't have the history.
Carl was done insanely dirty in the TV series. Hopefully TWD can get another, more comic-accurate series, à la _FMA: Brotherhood_ maybe even in an animated medium too. Amazon's _Invincible_ (coincidentally, another series by Robert Kirkman) has proven that this could definitely work.
Rip Carl
my mans deserved way better. he didn’t deserve to die
Omg I loved the Taylor Swift reference thnx for that
I MISS Carl
Good night and always remember that's life
Killing Carl was a fucking unforgivable sin
And they lost 11.8 million viewers after that
Who is Carl? A badass
I KNOWWWW THIS IS 2 YEARS AGO BUT I CANT GET OVER HIS DEATH
They killed him off to save siddiq just to kill siddiqs character off two seasons later. Making carls death feel even more unnecessary and frustrating.
ALL OUT WHISPERER WAR!!
Fucking clever
Rick Andrea and Carl are the family. ...Carl and Rick loved her very much Carl call her mom
Bob Stookey? he has a completely different stories in the comics/novels comp compared to show him.
3:29 I assumed we all screamed at this moment.
People check under their bed for Negan but Negan checks for Corall under his bed
Carl Papa is a great song
omg, ima fight you w/ all these Coral jokes! 😆😆🤣🤣🤣
CORAL MY BABY 😂
im convinced that carl is alive their are may things that can sort of prove it aswell the creator said "if rick ever dies carl will lead the show" and the day carl shot himself they didnt show it and its also possible that rick could have hallucinated like he did with lori in season 3 and it could possible that rick just told everyone what he saw and believed him and carl is out their surviving and in the comics their was a time jump thats similar to season 9 and most of season 10 so far im convinced that carl is alive and going to show up and if you use the excuse that he was bared alot of people died that day they could have bared anyone.
found out the comic is WAY MORE different than I thought it was
Carl is not one of my favorites but this was good!
CORAL
Not hating but,
CARL > Judith,R.J.
On gawddddddd
Someone who led The New World.
Carl
Next do rick
That jiggly jar doe 😂
Killing Carl was a mistake. I said what I said.
CORAAAAL?!
Why did Scott Mmmmm Gimple have to do Chandler Riggs so dirty though? Carl should not have died, especially to save a side character who is dead now anyway.
Because gimple himself doesn't have sense of great, he's a suckass himself he might be taking all the money of chandler riggs since he doesn't want to pay higher for a legal age so he has a reason to fired him. If chandler played an annoying character and got so much haters then gimple has reason to fired him. But chandler is a great actor you can see it by watching "Inherit the vaper" "Now" "Keep watching" "Mercy" "A million little things" :-) chandler is just following the orders it's not him who wants to be dirty as carl.
They shouldve had carl bit. Then rick goes to find him in the cabin after the battle or something. hes gone, carls disappeared and rick and the audience are meant to assume he turned and roamed off. later on during ricks fake death we get some reference to "We got him, we got his father". So Carl was taken to wherever rick is, this not only keeps carl alive but it gives Rick a reason to not leave.
Thank you Scott Gimple for ruining the character and show
I feel that since they killed Carl early the show should've for Rick and Carl's story. Ended with Season 8.
legend
He got shot twice just to die by a walker.
When the video started, I thought that it was an add, lol
Whhyyyy did they KILL HIM?! I'm still not over it 😭💔
Same here.😡🤦♂️
Because that's life
Abram Sullivan no it’s a tv show
People had theories at the time of why the kid was written off the show
A: he wanted to go to college
B: Riggs didn't want to renew his contract for another 3 years
C: riggs got fired 2 weeks before his 18th birthday because him and gimple had problems with each other
D: Gimple couldn't pay riggs anymore because he was becoming an adult
And they did his death for shock value and gimple thought it would boost views and ratings. But that backfired and lost 11.8 million viewers in the after math.
BRUh i just got a brawny add after the brawny reference
So “fetching” is a word now
Now humpkins come at me
I'm so glad Scott Gimple isn't showrunner anymore
But still they lost the heart of the show who's a new beginning and it's carl.
@@flagellationynfluencia1971 Hopefully Judith & RJ can some what fill that gap
@@SpiderCreep still Carl deserve to live with judith and rj they're siblings after all. Judith lost her mom and she lost her older brother, she doesn't deserve to lost a family member.
@@SpiderCreep i feel like they gonna kill Judith if she grow up as the same age of Carl and put rj as a replacement of Carl and judith. They don't want to fill the gap where it's place for carl, they want it as a mystery and make the show longer than we expected but they already lost Carl it's never been the same.
I'm still upset for what gimple did to carl and sophia. Those two characters should live longer.
Dammit I miss Carl. :(
CORAL!!!!
Best intro so far xD
OMG!!! MY SWIFTIE ASS GOT SHOOKT WHEN THIS IS WHY WE CAN'T HAVE NICE THINGS PLAYS!!!!!!!
This is so unfair ;_; Carl was supposed to be the last man standing! I still can't forgive what they did to Carl!
COOORAL
Who is Carl? Dead.