The Big Picture - Education agenda for New India
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 вер 2024
- There is a dire need for revolutionary changes in the India's education system, there is no doubt about that. The cut-offs at some of the top universities is over 99% if not 100%. Students are pushed to the brink to try and further their educational ambitions. Several aspects need to be addressed if we have to achieve the desired results and head in the right direction. India has one of the youngest populations in an aging world. By 2020, the median age in India will be just 28, compared to 37 in China and the US, 45 in Western Europe, and 49 in Japan. But for us to reap the benefit of this demographic dividend we need to ensure that we see an overhaul in our education system. The Finance Minister, Mr. Arun jaitley in an exclusive interview to me over the weekend, said that education will be one of the key focus areas if his government comes back to power. On this edition of the big picture we will analyse the education agenda for a new and changing India.
Guest:
Prof. Saroj Sharma, Former Member, Ministry of Human Resource Development, HRD Ministry
Anita Rampal, Professor, Department of Education, Delhi University
Dr. Manisha Priyam, Senior Academician
Aditi Tandon, Special Correspondent, The Tribune
Anchor - Frank Rausan Pereira
India currently have 15 lakh schools upto class 8th whereas China have only 5 lakh but the results are totally opposite in quality education.
your information is wrong.
India has about 7 lakhs villages... according to u , every village has 2 schools , which is quite wrong.
Get ur facts right ! 🙏
I liked your approach by the way you showed disagreement. The data which I had mentioned there is collected from Times of India which might be wrong.
@@shyamu431 I also read such numbers on internet , but the point is ....... In India about 1.8-1.9 crore children born each year now.
and if we have 15 lakhs school, then it seems every school is opened for just 12 children only.... that sounds hilarious :)
15 lakhis number for primarym upper primary, secondary and senior secondary... only primary ar around 8.4 lakh by 2014-15 which may have incread by nowup to 10 lakh
It's not primary so I corrected the information whereas aproposof 15 lakh its true according to TOI newspaper of 31st March 2019,page number 15.
Hey Frank I've been watching RSTV since there were anchors like Tracy Silsy and Bharat Bhushan,but still you're unmatched.
There will always be an Nostalgia associated with you.
All the best for your future assignments
BTW plz don't shave, u r looking cool with this beard☺️☺️
I bet you haven't seen late Girish Nikam's anchoring at the Big picture.
@@nitishnair8736 I've heard about him.He was critical to Modi Govt
@@anakarnayak9246 He was an unbiased journalist. But since you have just heard of him, why don't you watch few of the old Big picture episodes before forming an opinion.
@@nitishnair8736 dude I just heard within my UPSC circle that he was critical to current Govt which is good for a journalist.I'm not opinionated on anyone.
Btw Prelims after 2 months,so no time to see old episodes
I do feel the same..
Thanks Rajan and RSTV for bringing such a quality program upto us. Intelligent panelist specially Prof Anita Rampal and other guests. Major difference in their views are philosophy in which they believe. Prof Rampal believe a humanistic approach of education while others have economist view on education. One believe education is an endivour to make human and develop a humanistic society while other's think it as a medium for economic contribution of the nation. So all have different arguments. However, Frank you summed up the entire discussion nicely
Great to see 4 women talking wise points about educational reforms.
Intro-भारत में सर्वाधिक युवा आबादी, उसका पूरा use कैसे
1.Language, mathematics and extracurricular activities and good books, library,lab etc
2.Invesrt in teachers and taking support of willing full persons.
3.Attract youngsters for teaching job
4.सर्वशिक्षा अभियान, माध्यमिक शिक्षा व उच्च शिक्षा अभियान these three level system may not be good for some highly intelligent student.
5.if a student is good in music/poem,he should be given different environment.
6.Private institution for teacher training is not well working
7.Public education must be addressed for overall development.
8.Every 6 km, schools open without quality maintain.
9.2022 तक शिक्षा पर खर्च 26% से 36% हो(नीति आयोग)
10.विश्वद्यालयो को स्वतयत्ता दी जाए,नए कोर्स शुरू करने की।(पोसिटिव)
10.स्वायत्तता प्राप्त विश्विद्यालय और उनके अधीन कॉलेज फर्जी डिग्री बाँट रहे
11.online teaching and DLP programme should be addressed.
12.डिग्री देने का काम कॉलेजो का,they should provide skill, coordinate with skill development department and the head of skill development center must be a industry expert.
Samagra shiksha abhiyan
Issue :- teacher education needs to relooked on
National mission on teacher training can also not been put in place
It’s about focusing on teachers ,learning etc ...!
At primary level :- delhi govt have set a good example for public education
We all have to take the responsibility
Parents -teachers -children’s -society
Secondary :- Rashtriya madhyan siksha abhiyan
Tertiary:- rastriya uchhatkar shikshya abhiyan
Improving substandard quality of education
Marks outcome based - performance skills based
Investment should raise from 26% to 36 % in education
Hand holding taking and management stakeholders
Distant learning programs should be looked very carefully
Greater diverfication on formal education
Much needs to be done in the Indian Educational System to make it more qualitative and modern.
Dear sir,
When next time u have discussions on educational problems and policy in india, plz invite Prof JBG Tilak from NUEPA New Delhi. We will get the real insights from him.
Dr. Manisha Priya really had the most to offer in this debate!
Hope the education ministry is listening!
Please close all private school, college and educational organisations up to 12th standard . This will help a lot in good and equal education system because there are many discrimination in our society towards private school and government school . If there will be not any options for private schools then most of people ( politicians, bureaucrats and officers of education ) concentrate on development of government schools.
Also set up micro manufacturing unit in the Government school ( above 6th standard ).
#Discrimination creates differences
This is my own opinion, if any body agree with me. Like and raise your voice in favour of United India and developing India.
Jay Hind .
Thanks
Thanks for this, also the education system of ours was created by the British who implemented this for no creativity in children of India
Therefore the whole education system must be recreated which doesn’t make children memorise stuff but also enhance their creativity, their mentality, their knowledge but more importantly teach them to be a good person by teaching them good values and how to respect others.
Jai Hind!
Prof A. Rampal is the female version of Shashi tharoor !! Such a pleasing speaker
how can we get better output from public education by following preindependence time obsolate mode strategies.
our education has merely inject the aim on childrens to crack exams. It needs much more social integration than isolation.
Diversification and quality building programs are needed in education sector.
Asses the quality of teachers .
Robust Online learning system will be the most revolutionised solution. I agree with priyam ma'am. Engineering degree is the new degree mania. Also short vocational courses with education atleast government universities will be great.
Diploma courses are vocational courses I think
MAY ALMIGHTY GOD 🙏🙏 SAVE AND BLESS INDIA AND ALL INDIANS OF SOVEREIGN, SOCIALIST, SECULAR, DEMOCRATIC AND REPUBLIC OF INDIA.
Excellent topic discussion sir your fabulous work
Rajya Sabha best of knowledge , and information.
Why we not Trying "ONOE-System : One Nation One Education System", it'll help to improve Education system of India. Although Education is the part of concurrent List, so there is no issues to implement.
I don't know how finance minister is adressing on HRD.. What an integrated governance.. Thanks RSTV
Anita maam, you are spot on about the nature of skills being imparted. it is industry centered and not education.
Yeah bcoz the sad part is there arent many instructors jobs compared to industry jobs. Moreover even further refinement reqd in courses to align more with industry requirements. But persons like anita lives in her own little fairyland oblivious to these concepts
Education should have twin approach- 1. What society, market, culture systems required from a student and 2. What/how a student can contribute to make thing better.. Both are missing in today's education..
Insightful dr priyam
Our indian forefathers were very worried about the education system dished out by the Brits. They thought education was turning into something that was all about jobs. BEFORE the industrial revolution, (after which education became all about jobs) WHAT was education all about? If attention was paid to that on top of focusing for jobs, a much better society could've been achieved. Btw, I too am running after jobs, but those jobs from where I can make an impact. You should too, for our kids sake.
Quality education is lacking day by day from kg level to higher education level. The government needs to work on quality education on ground level not only on paper. This is time to think for all the Indians for the solutions and make education skillful.
Diversity of thoughts that's not a shouting match. What a breather!
Revoked? What is revoked?
What a great discussion,all the guest are learned
Best anchor...
Since India independence there no any kind of its own Indian educational system where inidan fundamental education like programme that must compulsory for ours culture ,simbols ancient Bharat and one education system for every Indian peoples.
Frank was fooling everyone today on Twitter by announcing that after 6 years he is stepping down and some fall this trap and become emotional 😂😂😂
Sir, what about tertiary education ? Not discussed?
I was also 😂
Thanks sir
The discussion is quite well and give us a perspective on how to make improve in better education
Best Anchor Mr. Frank. Just saw your interview with finance mininster.. amazing questions.
Wow
Miss anita..you should discuss how those children who are not capable of performing cab be performer using various techniques rather than highlighting just discrimination. Who will highlight teachers are also under skilled. They hire cheap teacher those who become teacher accidentally.schools are taking lakhs of donations and still waiting for government for help. What a non sense!
I think shushma yadav ma'am also bring in the education agenda for new India.
We need to focus on quality education not quantity..
Doubts are very genuine if one is seeking for knowledge.Our indian education specially teachers are trained to teach what only of every concept not why,how and what further can be done.Accumulation of these doubts really frustrates students and starts hating subject.
I recommend govt to start one congnitive curriculum where all doubts of students as a feed back should be recorded and these doubts needs to be taught in schools by a competent teachers.
Majority of schools are private & majority of Pvt school teachers (especially in small towns) are underpaid just to maximize profits on the part of owner
Y teachers are not assessed every year like students,why only students are assessed good or bad and not teachers...sometimes sources are at fault for bad products.MCH completed Dr can not do basic proper skin incision as they are not hand held by their mentors....same Dr become well versed when they are into a private enterprise hospitals
Basic education condition are worst in Uttar Pradesh. Resently up govt started teacher recruitment for that. Govt set high cutoff so that only good student can become teacher. But there were few having low marks went court against it. They complained that proper Rules were not adopted. So finally high court struck down govt high cutoff and lowered the cutoff . As court said it was against the right to equality.😀
Though central government has been implementing various policies regarding education but education is a state subject,every state have different approach to it n accordingly they have been doing their things whether it will good or bad,so central should directly guide the state to reform education.
Be frank! Did any of the panelists send their kids to Govt. run schools? lol.. I doubt.
please sir provide of just index powerity of india
Saroj Sharma right on CCE..its just a lot of home work for teachers..there is no time for teachers to teach lot of writing work to teacher..they made teacher a clerk rather than a teacher
Our schools are not more than certificate providers,that too much in many instances not internationally recognized
Economic approach will lead to monetization of education which ideally should be available to all .education will start serving as means of class differentiation
better to focus on quality rather than quantity in every 2 km we can see a college without proper infrastructure and well qualified teachers most of the students dnt even come in college due to no compulsory of attendance
Why graduate students are not qualified for jobs?.. answer lies in lack of industry- academia coordination.. In acedemic study we are learning old subject that are not in demand or relavent today in market.. for eg AI, machine learning, big data etc. In our country there is good example of medical colleges which are linked to hospitals so that students could learn and as well practice. We should adopt these kind of model in other sectors too, like engineering, tourism, etc.
Frank u r the best for big picture
Everyone talking about quality education... what about reservation in even education sector...is providing reservation in such sector going to bear any fruit??
what they are saying is theoretical written in books,,but reality is different...
Hey!! that's not true we don't like old teachers whoa are experienced but, they are not learning day to day like the 21-year-old freshers
Question kuch or puch rhe h frank sir..jawab ye wahi de rhi h jo rat ke aayi hai ye ghar se 😂 ye hai indian education system.. wo puch rhe loopholes in primary education ye bata rhi hai delhi sarkaar bohot bekaar kaam kar hi hai..
If you elect Pragys Thakur instead of Atashi, how you suppose to bring good education with your discussion.
The comments and example mostly in delhi base senario.....
Govt teachers never attend school, what do you expect from them?
So many qualified teachers are available,but what can you expect if you required Bed degree or all non sense certificate.
Even PhD are applying for Peon jobs, don't think that there's no supply and available human resources
We have not quality education system for all classes of society
Sor please hindi m bhi laye
Age of different countries
37 china and us
45 in uk
Education will be key
Starting with Primary education; politican need to understand. What has gone wrong in primary education. Education
Class three: against democratic right. Schools are hierarachial Understand that. Aa far as primary what is biggest challenge is that Schools are you need to
Challenge; teacher education. Pakistan public school. Good school gives library. Science lab. None of them is available in public school. Teacher's driving is not. Invest in good teacher. Good labs for science. Education system has not worked well in Pakistan. Quality of school education. Teaching has become job for people not profession to learn and teach.. Quality teachers will produce quality students. Are we promoting teaching?
Parents do not send public school. First priaroty of parents is to send children to private schools.. Untill and unless we take serisuly the education.
Konse anpad ko utha layeho sir ji tum kuch Puch rheho our o kuch bata the hai . Only focus on rural education .
Captions nhi ha
Even Frank got nostalgic today. A rare sight.
Jai ho rstv
Hindusta baad Raha h
Please don't bring people like Prof. Saroj Sharma among such prestigious panel... She seems to be a correspondent of the govt.
Panelists are deviating all over, to the questions posed by the anchor.
PS : Please maintain gender diversity amongst panelists
So I m not alone who felt that :/
@@varsharajput4166 yeah it wasn't that opaque...
It is also a big problem in U P
Phle 5 saal kya kar rahe thai....No bjp now
Yahaan bhi
BJP VS OTHERS😂😂😂😂😂
Hadd h
There is much demand for proficiency in English but why they want to promote education in local or mother tongue..India is not educating its masses on basis of skills required in future but they just want to increase literacy rate not skills
Today's discussion went a bit politically infulenced.
tondon is also defending government failures
Such a fuss! Every panelist is trying to cu through another panelist's point! Would have expected better panelists!
Seems like Delhi University people speaks same shit at every place
Why do always call prof anita rampal she does not have any insights about education in india and wastes time with no quality inputs, only verbosity. The whole panel is in agreement with disagreement towards her flawed logic. Prof Priyam was welcome change gave some new nice pts
Not productive
you forgot to debate about female education .
The debate ultimately went to employment issue.
Education is an education for everyone on which this debate is n should be so...please don't segregate like male education, female education, transgender education , scheduled caste education etc. .please. please 🙏🙏. .try to have a holistic view
gender disparity in our society is being disgraceful especially in educational sector. education is the base which determine the freedom of choice of a person. female education should have to debate on this section , because the status of our nation is not well on the same.even soudhi Arabiaand Pakistan has better status than us.
ASER report 2018
BJP=only agenda
Go to Sadhguru jaggi vasudev and he will solve many problems in nation
Anita Rampal mam u have sold ur self by bjp
sharma is agenting of bjp
Can u explain how?
Modi is doing nothing
Very bad
Very bad