What if Germany became Communist in 1933? (Alternate History World War 2)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 5 чер 2024
- What if Germany became Socialist instead of becoming Nazi in 1933? This is an alternate history scenario. How will the world change in this alternate timeline? Who will win World War 2? Watch this Alternate History Video to find out.
- Комедії
There are errors in this scenario.
1) Franco would not have won the civil war in Spain because Germany, which would be communist, would have supported the Republicans instead of supporting the nationalists and Spain later would therefore have become communist.
2) Germany in reality invaded Denmark and Norway to prevent the allies from having the resources of Norway and Sweden and in reality Sweden and remain neutral but as the threats are not the fascists but the Nazis it is possible that Sweden would not have remained neutral.
3) The Soviet Union in reality to attack Finland which it would have done in this scenario but it would have invaded all of Finland thanks to the help of Germany and the additional troops that the Soviet Union would have thanks to the controls of the Baltic countries since 1937.
4) In reality Germany, Poland and Hungary claim territories from Czechoslovakia so it is three countries plus the Soviet Union which claims a region of eastern Czechoslovakia which in reality was annexed by Hungary during the dismemberment of Czechoslovakia in 1939 and then annexed by the Soviet Union after the Second World War would have attacked Czechoslovakia which would have just lost the territories that its neighbors claimed and the rest would be communist.
5) the Soviet Union claiming Bessarabia so there would have been an invasion of Romania unless Romania cedes Bessrabia as in reality and Hungary and Bulgaria would have had the territories it claims from Romania by making the war or as in reality.
6) Portugal would have participated in the Second World War to fight communist Spain but would have lost especially after the invasion of France.
7) If Romania chooses to make war instead of ceding Bessarabia then Hungary and Bulgaria take advantage of it but after the new communist government of Romania asks for the help of the Soviet Union and its allies to attack Hungary and Bulgaria.
After that the communists in Yugoslavia and in Greece which had a lot of popularity especially in Yugoslavia and would have started a civil war or they would have attacked Ypugoslavia for the same reason as in reality which is a pro British coup d'etat or else for having the territories that Germany, Hungary and Bulgaria claim and Italy claiming territories would have supported Yugoslavia because of the communist threat and Greece would attack because Bulgaria claim territories.
After that they would have invaded Albania which has been part of Italy since 1939 as in reality and suddenly they occupy all of Europe Except Iceland, Ireland, the United Kingdom, Switzerland and the South of l Italy if there is this treaty which for me is very unlikely because the Soviet Union and its allies would rather choose to continue the fight so that all of Italy is communist and can be French and Spanish colonies in Africa s there is a kind of communist Vichy regime.
If all this happens then the only thing the Communists would have lost are Spanish and French colonies in Central Africa which would be under the control of General Charles de Gaulle.
After that I think for Japan the fate would be different because Korea would be I think entirely communist because there is no UN and World War II against Nazism.
Japan would be divided in two with the north which would be communist and the south which would be capitalist because the Soviet Union planned to invade the north of Japan which they would have done or else would have forced Japan to accept the occupation of the north of their country left the Soviets after the invasion of Manchuria and Korea who played an important role in the capitulation of Japan.
For China I think that suddenly it would be like in reality because all the communist countries would have intervened and Nationalist China had political and economic problems like corruption but the Chinese civil war would be different and longer than in reality.
For Indochina it would be different, we would have been more or less like the reality for the Indochian war which would pit General de Gaulle's France against the Viet Minh or a victory for General de Gaulle's France supported by NATO.
For the Jpaon the animated ones exist but have less influence in the world until the end of the cold war and the reunification of Japan by the communists who suddenly win the cold war.
As a German Communit who lived in 1933 i can confirm this is all true except for one part Bosnia owned Germany and forced it to be communist but other than that all the information is correct good job Comrade 🇩🇪 ☭
XDDD
@@marshalbaliXDDDD
🇳🇪😌🇳🇪😇💰😅😡😅😁😅😁☺️🇪🇪😂💰✝️🇭🇷✝️💰☺️🇳🇪😅💰😂💰😅💰😃😁😄🇳🇪😅✝️☺️🇳🇪😂😁😂🇳🇪🤣💰🤣💰
Aaint no way you got a YT account at age 99+ 💀
Just to think you guys would have had a military alliance with the USSR, and you also say that you were a part of the Communist Party in Germany at the time, what was it like? I mean anytime I look at the German point of view on things I always hear the Nazi story, but what was the head of your party like? Was Ernest Thalman also a gifted orator?
Another Epic Video 😱
thanks :)
This video has instailled a weird desire in me to conquer Europe and turn it into COUNCILS COUNCILS COUNCILS
epic
Councils in russan is soviet
Actually pretty good video keep it up my man
thanks :)
Finnaly best vid
this is actually good.! keep up the good work my man.
thank you!
Apic video! :D
Plot twist:
Bosnia owns Germany 🥱
🥶💪
5:25 is just, majestic
This is my fav UA-camr this dude is a legend
Thanks🥶😎💪
Request: What if Germany attacks Switzerland in WW2
If I continue doing ahis videos I will do it at some point
Hey, your alternate timeline is so cool like Possible history one
Thanks🥶Subscribe if you enjoyed
@@marshalbali i have already subbed. I have subscribe 2 months ago
I don't think some people understand why France was invaded so easily: their borders were pretty weak in certain areas and the french couldn't cover up all of it. It wasn't really the french's fault, but what was the french's fault was how the public reacted, some people not doing anything or caring about the ss regime
Yeah I think Germany just got pretty lucky. If the French Generals expected an attack in the Ardenes Berlin would be in Soviet Hands by 1942. The same is in this alternate universe.
There was no luck involved since Germany planned for a way longer war against the French and british ground troops . Also aerial reconnaissance and spionage already showed that the maginot-line was undermannend in 1939 . It was literaly the whole german startegy to encircel the allied army in western france . In fact the germans where suprised how poor the france army was performing
wow, this is actually pretty accurate!
Thanks!
Actually, good video! You should do like "What if czechoslovakia joined the allies" instead of the germany taking sudetenland, i think it would be good video.
Well, theoretically communism is the better ideology than capitalism. Practically in our scenario communism doesn't works though, as we haven't found ways to patch it's flaws.
In that timeline communism might actually be a "good" ideology, working for Europe very well, meaning they could develop it further, adapting to democratic forms of communism to make it perfect. Thus I can just say, it "could" be a better scenario. But even if it isn't. We aren't living in it, so that's that.
Request: what would a united Communist Germany look like in the 1930's culturally speaking? Would it be basically Nazi-Germany minus the anti-Semitic aspect? Or something totally different? Something similar to that of the DDR(East Germany) . It's a question that I'm very curious about.
Interesting, here is my opinion. It would most likely generally be your classic weimar culture but with more militarism and communist symbols and ideals. I dont think it would be much alike either the nazis nor the DDR, most likely being the closest to weimar itself.
So in this timeline Germany would have had in the end all the strength that Hitler promised it would have just happened more slowly over a period of time.
perhaps yeah, one could put it that way. more importantly, they wouldnt have to fight a two front war.
@@marshalbali I'm playing this timeline out on Hearts Of Iron, Darkest Hour, I went with Communist Germany, we have a military alliance with the Soviet Union, our head of state is Ernst Thalman.
@@bradleyhoyt3188 🤣
Thank you so much for this video about Deutschland 🇩🇪
🥶💪Np brah
@@marshalbali wait wrong flag 🇾🇪 here we go
❤🇩🇪❤❤😎
@@baumkuchen-treecake1328hello my father 🤨
0:30 did you mean WWI? Lol
yes I wrote ww1 as a correction
MARSHAL BALI I FORGOT TO COMMENT ON THIS VIDEO PLEASE FORGIVE ME I WAS KIND OF DYING AÀÁÂÄÆÃÅĀÅÃÆÄÂÁÀA
Germany is a rich democrasy country and stands for justice and peace and wealth🇩🇪❤🇩🇪❤🇩🇪❤🇩🇪❤😎❤😎❤😎😎🇩🇪😎🇩🇪😎🇩🇪😎❤😎❤😎😎 DO MORE GERMANY MONEYYYYY🇩🇪❤🇩🇪😎🇩🇪😎🇩🇪😎🇩🇪
XDDDD well germany won in the video, watch to the end
@@marshalbali I did I did😎❤🇩🇪❤🇩🇪😎🇩🇪 Do pls pls pls a Germany vid for me🇩🇪❤🇩🇪❤❤🇩🇪❤🇩🇪❤🇩🇪❤🇩🇪❤🇩🇪❤❤🇩🇪❤🇩🇪❤🇩🇪
Hab dich wieder gefunden lol
@@dsp1035 lol
i thought this was a hoi4 video
Haha
For za fathe- i mean motherland
What if Germany became Nazbol in 1933?
dont kill me papa stalin 😥😥😥
Good ending
Wouldnt yugoslavia also be communist? They were highly influenced by russians and become the yugoslav SFSR
The reasons the partisans existed in the first place is Yugoslavia got invaded by Germany. Without it Yugoslavia will stay a monarchy.
Can you do algerian Independence war and unite the arabs
If I continue making videos like this I'll do a United Arabia scenario
@@marshalbali thanks bro
Next is japan
W
w
W