Nasa’s Voyager-1 sends usable data from deep space | BBC News

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 22 кві 2024
  • The US space agency says its Voyager-1 probe is once again sending usable information back to Earth after months of spouting gibberish.
    The Nasa spacecraft is humanity's most distant object, being more than 24 billion km (15 billion miles) away.
    A computer fault stopped it returning readable data in November but engineers have now fixed this.
    Subscribe here: bit.ly/1rbfUog
    For more news, analysis and features visit: www.bbc.com/news
    #NASA #Space #BBCNews

КОМЕНТАРІ • 2,4 тис.

  • @brianbks02
    @brianbks02 24 дні тому +2178

    Voyager 1: "I GOT ONE MORE IN ME"

    • @wookie-zh7go
      @wookie-zh7go 23 дні тому +123

      "I didn't hear no bell"

    • @dom4591
      @dom4591 23 дні тому +27

      I'm not leaving!

    • @FighterFlash
      @FighterFlash 22 дні тому +11

      Ah Vygr live long and learn

    • @ricyman5110
      @ricyman5110 22 дні тому +2

      they jailed the cameraman from fox 7 too😂😂😂. AIPACmake american Communis is real😂

    • @db5094
      @db5094 22 дні тому +22

      @@ricyman5110 tf are you talking about this is about a space probe

  • @JDBD13
    @JDBD13 24 дні тому +2197

    To be fair to Voyager 1, I'm not even 30 yet and I barely function.

    • @gustavgnoettgen
      @gustavgnoettgen 23 дні тому +6

      Anymore

    • @eamonahern7495
      @eamonahern7495 23 дні тому +32

      I'm 48, so a little bit older than voyager, and some of my hardware doesn't function either. For instance, as of a little over 5 years ago, I no longer have a functional pancreas.

    • @janparchanski9242
      @janparchanski9242 23 дні тому +1

      @eamonahern7495
      Why?

    • @eamonahern7495
      @eamonahern7495 23 дні тому

      @@janparchanski9242 because of a glitch in my immune system

    • @pawsnpistons
      @pawsnpistons 23 дні тому +3

      But you didnt cost millions and millions of dollars to be made and maintained...

  • @Manskilz
    @Manskilz 23 дні тому +374

    Voyager. The Nokia phone of probes.

    • @sixstanger00
      @sixstanger00 22 дні тому +21

      Maybe that's why aliens haven't visited. They think, 'Damn if their PROBES are built like this..."

    • @Defirence
      @Defirence 21 день тому +1

      @@sixstanger00 lmao good one

    • @user-qw1pz4xh2i
      @user-qw1pz4xh2i 20 днів тому

      You sir are the Human of Microbes 🦠

    • @agagab1280
      @agagab1280 18 днів тому

      ​@@user-qw1pz4xh2ieh

    • @technicianbis5250-ig1zd
      @technicianbis5250-ig1zd 9 днів тому

      Nar, Motorola brick, you could drop it in water and it would still work. I finally bought a Motorola smart phone and it is a great phone, has glass screen not plastic and still clear despite dropping it several times.

  • @envitech02
    @envitech02 24 дні тому +330

    I'm glad they built it in the 70s, otherwise programmers had to click skip ad every they need to talk to Voyager.

    • @user-lv7ph7hs7l
      @user-lv7ph7hs7l 23 дні тому +18

      Interstellar spacecraft have premium subscriptions.

    • @AlfaGiuliaQV
      @AlfaGiuliaQV 23 дні тому

      @@user-lv7ph7hs7l But you´ll still be charged 9.99 to unlock all of the data.

    • @LuKiSCraft
      @LuKiSCraft 23 дні тому

      @@user-lv7ph7hs7l One day baby, one day

    • @littleman787
      @littleman787 21 день тому

      @@user-lv7ph7hs7l Interstellar spacecraft now have Stories! Click here to learn more.

    • @CheckmateSurvivor
      @CheckmateSurvivor 20 днів тому +1

      Ha ha ha!

  • @RealUlrichLeland
    @RealUlrichLeland 24 дні тому +2170

    The computer on voyager 1 has about 68 kB of memory. It's amazing that NASA can still do cutting edge science with a computer that's about as powerful as a talking birthday card, even while it's on the edge of the solar system. The software engineers for the voyager program must be some of the best in the world.

    • @samsmith2635
      @samsmith2635 24 дні тому +143

      Its like your laptop talking to a simple calculator

    • @MrSimonw58
      @MrSimonw58 24 дні тому +50

      68kb is a lot

    • @RickPeake01
      @RickPeake01 24 дні тому +11

      Happy birthday 😂😂🎉

    • @dexterrity
      @dexterrity 24 дні тому +181

      ​​​​@@MrSimonw58the irony of you posting your comment of about a dozen characters in length using a device with at least several GB of memory.
      That is, our current consumer devices might have about 6 orders of magnitude more memory than voyager.
      can we take a moment to appreciate a million times more memory than voyager (to play video games etc) is wild 🤯

    • @Dr.Kay_R
      @Dr.Kay_R 24 дні тому +56

      ​@@MrSimonw58I can give a strong argument against this but don't wanna sound like a nerd. 😂
      It's hard. Believe us. 😅

  • @romeshbhat8362
    @romeshbhat8362 24 дні тому +843

    Billions of miles away and still sending signals
    And my bank's OTP has still not reached me

  • @yeahboyiiiii222
    @yeahboyiiiii222 24 дні тому +441

    In 2021 NASA put out a job application for someone who could program in Fortran 5. Some un named person took the job and here we are, they got a spacecraft from the 70's working again from 15 Billion miles away. Bravo un named hero.

    • @Space-Audio
      @Space-Audio 24 дні тому +41

      Oh, I assure you that FORTRAN IV was for ground data systems, most of which were long ago "updated" to Sun/SPARC/Solaris platforms (FORTRAN 77). Onboard is purely assembly for the custom processors.

    • @noobscoopsies1100
      @noobscoopsies1100 23 дні тому +3

      I also read the same thing in other video but for assembly coding language.

    • @yeahboyiiiii222
      @yeahboyiiiii222 23 дні тому +4

      @@Space-Audio So Voyerger is updated in ...... Fortran 5 ... they havent been doing system updates to java mate

    • @DerBingle1
      @DerBingle1 23 дні тому +20

      I doubt it's written in Fortran. Probably it's BAL or direct machine language. They want every bit to count.

    • @itstoasty7089
      @itstoasty7089 22 дні тому +2

      They lying

  • @splifsend
    @splifsend 24 дні тому +304

    45 years and it's almost 1 light day away - 65,000 years to get to Alpha at that speed

    • @Participant616
      @Participant616 23 дні тому +29

      Mind boggling.

    • @YellowKurt
      @YellowKurt 23 дні тому +16

      1000 years from now
      they will make a device,
      that will reduce that time frame to 1 second

    • @rybobz
      @rybobz 23 дні тому

      We will likely create a new form of propulsion that allows us to catch up to voyager then we will bring it back and put it in a museum sadly none of us will see that day or it's incredibly likely we won't but I suppose never say never

    • @Jean-PierreGrenier-yl3wp
      @Jean-PierreGrenier-yl3wp 23 дні тому +23

      @@YellowKurt Speed of light is a constant cop on interstellar highway… Even at maximum light speed, Voyager 1 would take 4 years to reach to Proxima - our nearest neighbouring star. But I get what you mean: we may find ways to built a device that will zoom past Voyager 1 to reach destination before it.

    • @user-ts6lv8qr4p
      @user-ts6lv8qr4p 23 дні тому +17

      Let's hope humans will not destroy the civilization in the next 100 years first​@@YellowKurt

  • @Donjuanthesecond
    @Donjuanthesecond 24 дні тому +1507

    And my iPhones stops working every 4 years

    • @rossicourvosi218
      @rossicourvosi218 24 дні тому +251

      That's intentional though

    • @BurtonHohman
      @BurtonHohman 24 дні тому +92

      Well if you paid 200 million dollars and made it the size of a small car I bet you could get your iPhone to last longer

    • @GreenStorm01
      @GreenStorm01 24 дні тому +34

      Radioactive batteries man

    • @Gryzor88
      @Gryzor88 24 дні тому +81

      Planned obsolescence.

    • @wildandbarefoot
      @wildandbarefoot 24 дні тому +20

      If it was made by apple it would have received a terminal update years ago.

  • @mosshark
    @mosshark 24 дні тому +853

    Incredible. This now interstellar spacecraft was built in the bloody 1970's!

    • @rustshoo5068
      @rustshoo5068 24 дні тому +16

      Like the music back then, the chirps are coming back, melodiously, crystal clear.

    • @Chromastellia
      @Chromastellia 24 дні тому +1

      @ForbiddenPlanetB That is just so cool.

    • @CountScarlioni
      @CountScarlioni 24 дні тому +29

      @@rustshoo5068 It's really not what could _ever_ be described as crystal clear. I'd probably describe it more like a vanishing whisper in black static.
      The bitrate has dropped to around 0.16k/sec and the signal heard on Earth comes in at less than a trillionth of a watt in strength. At present only the largest dishes of the Deep Space Network are capable of catching the signal at all and even they frequently don't get all the data first time around due to it being broken up by the background static of the cosmos. Thankfully Voyager 1 constantly repeats its data.
      Voyager's transmissions also require digital processing to enhance the signal to noise ratio in order to make it useful. The technology to do that didn't even exist when Voyager was launched and its creators probably didn't expect the probe's signals to remain detectable in the 2020s.

    • @mbbb9244
      @mbbb9244 24 дні тому +26

      @@CountScarlioniI live about 20km from one of these dishes. It sits in an empty field. There are signs on the footpaths saying “beware of snakes”.
      And inside there is a large screen which lists all the probes and missions they communicate with and what time of day. It even tells you what they are talking to at that very moment.
      Sometimes it’s the Mars Rovers and orbiters, but it could be Juno and Jupiter, or New Horizons and Pluto. 9pm tonight it will be talking to Voyager 2 - that’s 20.4 billion km away.
      It’s quite a bizarre feeling looking out the window at the 64m dish and knowing it’s talking to something outside our solar system……
      Wish they did something about the snakes though.

    • @wicken8895
      @wicken8895 24 дні тому +6

      What a great time to be alive !!!

  • @armyveteran101st
    @armyveteran101st 23 дні тому +49

    I was 9 years old when the Voyager 1 spacecraft was launched in 1977, and I remember being excited about it as a kid. I will turn 56 years old in three weeks, and it is unbelievable that the spacecraft is still going and working!

    • @spacelemur7955
      @spacelemur7955 22 дні тому +2

      Well, whippersnapper, I was in college when it launched, but also thought it was great.

    • @NAVEEN-ef4zd
      @NAVEEN-ef4zd 22 дні тому +1

      It's not working.. but the signal it have send years back have travelled all this year and reached now that's it...

    • @peamutbubber
      @peamutbubber 20 днів тому +3

      Happy birthday when it arrives!

    • @RipMinner
      @RipMinner 2 дні тому +1

      I was born in 1978 so I was -1 years old.

  • @Machiavelli21st
    @Machiavelli21st 23 дні тому +132

    Voyager 1: sends alien signals
    NASA scientist: it's sending gibberish

    • @artofsam
      @artofsam 23 дні тому +13

      Just imagine that’s what it actually was this whole time that would be a great premise for a movie.

    • @Hobbes746
      @Hobbes746 23 дні тому +6

      We know it wasn’t alien signals. The signal consisted of all zeroes, i.e. no data at all.

    • @artofsam
      @artofsam 23 дні тому +21

      @@Hobbes746 I see we have an expert on alien translation!

    • @interstellarbeatteller9306
      @interstellarbeatteller9306 22 дні тому

      I am an expert. Black holes are really cloaking devices. Aliens are just waiting for global warming to boil us off the Planet before they visit

    • @geoffmower8729
      @geoffmower8729 22 дні тому +2

      @@artofsam NANU NANU. 🖖🏻

  • @lord_scrubington
    @lord_scrubington 24 дні тому +452

    "what on earth is it sending back"
    nothing from earth I should imagine

    • @NightElveee
      @NightElveee 24 дні тому +30

      Your moms shock waves data everytime she gets out of bed.

    • @fargoth391
      @fargoth391 24 дні тому +38

      @@NightElveee HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAA THATS A REAL KNEE SLAPPER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! IM DYING OF LAUGHTER YOU'RE SO FUNNY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! AHAHAHAHAHAAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAAAHAAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHWAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

    • @Dr_Doctor_Lee
      @Dr_Doctor_Lee 24 дні тому +11

      @@fargoth391 best commend i have seen

    • @5655nasir
      @5655nasir 24 дні тому +16

      @@fargoth391never use these emojis again

    • @fanatamon
      @fanatamon 23 дні тому

      @@5655nasirever

  • @JTan74
    @JTan74 24 дні тому +147

    V-ger trying to contact the creator.
    "So, where's it going?"
    "Where no one has gone before."

    • @szimultan00
      @szimultan00 23 дні тому +11

      Live long and prosper!😉

    • @panaderofilms
      @panaderofilms 23 дні тому +1

      That was actually Voyager 6...which doesn't exist..

    • @swaggerfm9838
      @swaggerfm9838 23 дні тому +2

      Yet lol ​@@panaderofilms

    • @eastofwarden
      @eastofwarden 23 дні тому +1

      It's just going lol

    • @Oxley016
      @Oxley016 22 дні тому +1

      @@eastofwarden currently everywhere it is going, nobody else has gone before....

  • @shmookins
    @shmookins 24 дні тому +82

    From Nasa's website:
    "It will take about 300 years for Voyager 2 to reach the inner edge of the Oort Cloud and possibly about 30,000 years to fly beyond it.
    Voyager 2 is heading away from the Sun about 36 degrees out of the ecliptic plane (plane of the planets) to the south, toward the constellations of Sagittarius and Pavo. In about 40,000 years, Voyager 2 will be closer to another star than our own Sun, coming within about 1.7 light years of a star called Ross 248, a small star in the constellation of Andromeda."

    • @bwhog
      @bwhog 22 дні тому +13

      Which means that it technically isn't in interstellar space yet and won't be until it reaches the outer edge of the Oort cloud, which will happen in approximately a great many thousands of years after we'll all be dead.

    • @zikkicharade
      @zikkicharade 22 дні тому +2

      How a star from another galaxy is only 1 ly away😂

    • @db5094
      @db5094 22 дні тому +4

      @@zikkicharade You don't have good reading skills.... Read it again.

    • @mistertagnan
      @mistertagnan 22 дні тому +2

      @@bwhog it’s in the interstellar medium AFAIK, which counts as “interstellar space” as it is different from the interplanetary medium. But like you said, it hasn’t really left the solar system per-se

    • @bwhog
      @bwhog 22 дні тому +1

      @@mistertagnanHopefully we won't have to wait that long and, within 100 years, we'll simply be able to simply fly out and go get it and stick it in a museum. 😜

  • @Jussle364
    @Jussle364 22 дні тому +18

    Voyager 1: Golden record
    San-Ti: "Do Not Answer"

    • @starmaster191
      @starmaster191 14 днів тому

      I just finished episode 5 tonight.

  • @joji_okami
    @joji_okami 24 дні тому +336

    Your car's key fob has more memory than the computer on voyager 1. Imagine that.
    *edit: i learned that from the Astrum YT channel. shout-out!

    • @willieboy8798
      @willieboy8798 24 дні тому +4

      waste of key fob or memory?????

    • @thesjkexperience
      @thesjkexperience 24 дні тому +5

      Apollo computers were silly small too. Those guys were truly amazing! 🎉🎉. Doing so much with so little.

    • @adorp
      @adorp 23 дні тому +5

      Well yes, but Voyager's memory has to withstand cosmic rays.

    • @espressomatic
      @espressomatic 23 дні тому +5

      Pretty sure a keyfob has no RAM. What it has is ROM. And a very small amount, smaller than 68kB. More like 4kB.

    • @joji_okami
      @joji_okami 23 дні тому +1

      @@espressomatici read that they range from 4kb to 100kb and some even have a few mbs

  • @davemanone3661
    @davemanone3661 23 дні тому +50

    This is the kind of thing that makes me angry with people that attack NASA and say it is a waste of money. "They do so many wonderful things, but sometime things don't go according to plan. Our space program is the best there is and worth every penny. Even when things go wrong there is a lot to learn!

    • @Jean-PierreGrenier-yl3wp
      @Jean-PierreGrenier-yl3wp 23 дні тому +12

      Yes, there is “waste” of money because not every scientific research leads to practical applications. BUT if you would STOP all scientific researches because statistically most of them do not bring improvements in our lives, then there would NEVER be any future improvement…. You can’t tell in advance which research will bring practical results. This is the part that these people complaining about “waste of money” do not understand. (And the fact that knowing more about our surroundings tell us more about ourselves too.)

    • @davemanone3661
      @davemanone3661 23 дні тому +3

      @@Jean-PierreGrenier-yl3wp Well said!

    • @kenmoraes6843
      @kenmoraes6843 22 дні тому

      NASA hides alot of information too. They know about UFO's and everytime it comes on camera they cut the feed "due to technical difficulties".

    • @JamesAllen-mv4bj
      @JamesAllen-mv4bj 22 дні тому

      we should spend that money on the military

    • @davemanone3661
      @davemanone3661 22 дні тому

      @@JamesAllen-mv4bj There is plenty of money to go around. We don't need uneducated morons like t-rump telling people that science is not important

  • @bokami3445
    @bokami3445 22 дні тому +12

    For those who are interested, there is a documentary called "It's quieter in the Twilight" in which you get to meet some of the scientists and engineer's who are still working on the project and the decisions they have to make in order for Voyager 1 to continue on it's epic voyage to the stars. Highly recommended!

  • @keithhudson6460
    @keithhudson6460 23 дні тому +26

    NASA: We have a message from Voyager1
    Voyager1: "YEAAAHHHHH BOIIII"

  • @ivanlawrence2
    @ivanlawrence2 24 дні тому +125

    I love that the Dr's background has the new space telescope, dinosaurs, something about OCD, yoga skeleton, and a moose. Also, fixing a computer that has outlived it's creators and is also billions of miles a way is also cool.

    • @stuartslyper1479
      @stuartslyper1479 24 дні тому +10

      Dr Jen Millard is great! You can hear more of her on the Awesome Astronomy podcast

    • @JaSon-wc4pn
      @JaSon-wc4pn 24 дні тому +3

      The plastic dino is made from Real Dino matter.

    • @FlitwickGE
      @FlitwickGE 22 дні тому +2

      Even Harry Potter books are there

    • @ColinRichardson
      @ColinRichardson 22 дні тому +1

      @@JaSon-wc4pn plastic is made from trees and other vegetation that was not broken down by bacteria. I believe most oil predates dinosaurs by a few hundred million years.
      And remember, The T-Rex was closer in time to us humans now, than they were to the Stegosaurus.
      So we are talking MASSIVE timeframes..

    • @persianpride1989
      @persianpride1989 22 дні тому

      Better than having a dildo!!!!

  • @seventeeen29
    @seventeeen29 24 дні тому +141

    These guys took we'll fix it in prod to the next level

    • @djangbahevans1
      @djangbahevans1 24 дні тому +2

      😂

    • @bakdiabderrahmane8009
      @bakdiabderrahmane8009 24 дні тому +5

      the ultimate debugging in production engineering.

    • @Karuska22ps
      @Karuska22ps 24 дні тому

      Software engineering is not impressive

    • @N1ckZ
      @N1ckZ 6 днів тому

      ​@@Karuska22pssounds like you are jealous you don't know anything about it.

    • @Karuska22ps
      @Karuska22ps 6 днів тому

      @@N1ckZ it's really not impressive. It's so mainstream now

  • @jimnorthland2903
    @jimnorthland2903 22 дні тому +9

    I was eighteen when Voyager-1 was launched in 1977. Now I'm sixty five.

    • @crazyaces4042
      @crazyaces4042 22 дні тому +1

      I was 16.. seems so surreal so many decades have gone by. I'm very proud of the Voyagers and glad they can at least get some contact with one of them.

    • @ketanovas
      @ketanovas 21 день тому

      I was dead yet.

  • @DrHelloWorld30
    @DrHelloWorld30 23 дні тому +5

    We need more news articles like this. Absolutely amazing.

  • @captainbuggernut9565
    @captainbuggernut9565 24 дні тому +87

    Grandad knew some stuff, eh kids.

    • @Dr.Kay_R
      @Dr.Kay_R 24 дні тому +2

      We know more than them now. But yeah. Still cutting edge 😅

    • @wicken8895
      @wicken8895 24 дні тому +3

      Yeah, and then forgot where he put it. 😂

    • @apple54345
      @apple54345 23 дні тому +1

      tell me you're projecting your personal frustrations without telling me you're projecting your personal frustrations.

    • @YellowKurt
      @YellowKurt 23 дні тому

      There's nothing extraordinary about it.
      Just a compressor converting uranium decay and using a stupid dish to beam numbers to earth

    • @NoClue-rat
      @NoClue-rat 23 дні тому +2

      Legend has it grandad landed in a tincan on the moon

  • @treelonmusk5723
    @treelonmusk5723 24 дні тому +53

    The coders who still probably write in assembly i guess are doing a good job

    • @Ryan256
      @Ryan256 22 дні тому +4

      Fortran 5

    • @Scottyd21UK
      @Scottyd21UK 22 дні тому +1

      That's what you call a job for life at this point 😂

  • @alzeNL
    @alzeNL 24 дні тому +17

    what a brilliant interview - decent questions and answered without interruption. others at the BBC take note, this is how you conduct a science interview.

  • @ptonpc
    @ptonpc 24 дні тому +15

    Good to hear Voyager is still alive. Kudos to the team.

  • @lippydalips4537
    @lippydalips4537 24 дні тому +119

    Did you try turning it off and on again🤪😂🤣

    • @killeryuan08
      @killeryuan08 24 дні тому +11

      To be honest, they tried it once a few years ago to solve another problem.

    • @Trey4x4
      @Trey4x4 24 дні тому +3

      Get out 😐👉

    • @pekka75
      @pekka75 24 дні тому +2

      😂👍

    • @richardhart9204
      @richardhart9204 24 дні тому +4

      The Russians tried that with the Phobos probe, and it didn't end well for them.

    • @emerbrkah
      @emerbrkah 24 дні тому

      @@Trey4x4 🤣😂

  • @rbanerjee605
    @rbanerjee605 24 дні тому +126

    Imagine if aliens went and fixed it for us lol

  • @davidioanhedges
    @davidioanhedges 24 дні тому +19

    The Voyager Golden Disks have more memory capacity than Voyager ...

  • @playeryoshi252
    @playeryoshi252 24 дні тому +9

    Wow! Its up and running again! Amazing work NASA!

  • @differenceispreadin
    @differenceispreadin 24 дні тому +4

    What a fantastic, clear, polite and friendly explanation. Great guest ✨

  • @aiman9365
    @aiman9365 22 дні тому +3

    Taking 22 and a half hours to send a message and the same time to receive a message from something 15 billion miles away *IS FAST.*
    They say it's slow, but no... that's FAST.

    • @BlackFlagHeathen
      @BlackFlagHeathen 19 днів тому

      That’s probably close to the speed of light, honestly. Which would make sense for electromagnetic waves of data, which aren’t a tangible object.

  • @MrKennyroger
    @MrKennyroger 22 дні тому +1

    The cameraman who went with voyager 1 and has been videoing it for years should receive a nobel price definitely cous he keeps getting beautiful shots of the probe...

  • @laRoz67
    @laRoz67 22 дні тому +2

    Incredible. If you can, find the documentary The Farthest. A surprisingly touching film about these incredible craft. So glad they got it back online.

  • @Kadag
    @Kadag 24 дні тому +19

    And, of course, cred for the genius who put the gold platter on there, Carl Sagan!

  • @DiRtYLaWs2007
    @DiRtYLaWs2007 23 дні тому +13

    Carl Sagan would be proud.

  • @ShihTzuNinja
    @ShihTzuNinja 22 дні тому +1

    Shout out to the people who designed, built, launched, and continue to monitor this thing. Amazing feat for humanity.

  • @huebdoo
    @huebdoo 23 дні тому

    it was launched in 1977 ... basically a dial up modem in basic programming and its still working is amazing in itself

  • @divisiona3974
    @divisiona3974 24 дні тому +7

    Just unbelievable.

    • @tubecated_development
      @tubecated_development 23 дні тому

      Some people think so. They are usually really knowledgeable people 😉 /s

  • @fett713akamandodragon5
    @fett713akamandodragon5 24 дні тому +4

    Being of the same age, all I can say is, keep on chugging along there my friend!

  • @OliverGrumitt
    @OliverGrumitt 21 день тому +1

    It is a great tribute to the ingenuity of the engineers who designed Voyager that the craft is still working getting on for half a century after launch. It is certainly one of the greatest engineering achievements, ever.

  • @vincent21212
    @vincent21212 20 днів тому +2

    that we can still ping the damn thing at all is mind blowing enough. This has been an astounding fact to me for over 20 years - Id never imagined that we'd still be able to track the thing at this point in time

    • @bloqk16
      @bloqk16 19 днів тому

      Acquaintances of mine can't seem to grasp the significance until I use this analogy: Imagine being able to see or detect a lit candle from 1K miles/1.61K km away.

  • @BlackLotuses
    @BlackLotuses 24 дні тому +50

    22.5 hours to send data 15 billion miles away is actually something out of Star Trek or Star Wars 😅

    • @jessemazo4791
      @jessemazo4791 23 дні тому

      i call bs do th math even at lightspeed!

    • @JohnRandomness105
      @JohnRandomness105 23 дні тому +6

      In general, "Star Trek" and "Star Wars" had no sense of scale. (That's a problem with many science fiction writers.) 22.5 hours is just about right for that distance.

    • @user-lv7ph7hs7l
      @user-lv7ph7hs7l 23 дні тому +5

      ​@@jessemazo4791 It's exactly 22.5 light-hours away.

    • @ketanovas
      @ketanovas 21 день тому

      @@user-lv7ph7hs7l don't bother with flerfers

    • @jessemazo4791
      @jessemazo4791 21 день тому

      @@user-lv7ph7hs7l the can talk 22 light hours away but cant give an expalnation why were banned form th lunar surface! i smell bullshit and you guys are goin gback for seconds!

  • @gavriloking5637
    @gavriloking5637 24 дні тому +11

    If they built it today it would shut off in less than a month because you didn't renew your subscription and then in less than 10 years it would break. I mean it could be fixed but the repair price is about the cost of new model which apparently will be "better" and "last longer".

  • @augustus331
    @augustus331 4 дні тому

    Amazing. The fact humankind produced a device that is now cruising through interstellar space is amazing, and should receive more awe and amazement in popular culture than it currently does.

  • @lexruptor
    @lexruptor 24 дні тому +1

    Ah, Voy. Gotta love it.

  • @user-yy9hk9od9u
    @user-yy9hk9od9u 23 дні тому +17

    Unmanned mission: Already left the solar system.
    Manned mission: Haven't been back to the Moon in 56 years.

    • @Tuggerdrums
      @Tuggerdrums 23 дні тому +10

      Easier to replace dead computer rather than a dead person.

    • @anonymes2884
      @anonymes2884 23 дні тому +2

      52 years (last human on the moon was during Apollo 17 in December 1972).
      (but yep, still not a great record)

    • @-.._.-_...-_.._-..__..._.-.-.-
      @-.._.-_...-_.._-..__..._.-.-.- 22 дні тому

      After someone dies on the moon, we'll never look at it the same way again.

    • @wattsmichaele
      @wattsmichaele 22 дні тому +1

      We never sent men onto the moon

    • @michelmilaneh8963
      @michelmilaneh8963 22 дні тому +8

      ​@@wattsmichaelestfu the adults are talking

  • @dgtheone
    @dgtheone 24 дні тому +5

    Awesome!

  • @OfentseMwaseFilms
    @OfentseMwaseFilms 21 день тому +1

    Billions of miles away and still sending signals,
    but I can't even get my son to get me a beer from the fridge

    • @yellowface6314
      @yellowface6314 21 день тому +1

      Man you gotta get up and get it yourself cuz those calories ain’t gonna burn themselves lol

  • @chicobicalho5621
    @chicobicalho5621 22 дні тому

    Voyager 1 is nothing short of a scientific miracle. I watched its launch as a teenager, "saw" it live on television as it left our solar system, and it still lives in my heart like a mechanical family member.

  • @averyboringchannelmadebyar3649
    @averyboringchannelmadebyar3649 24 дні тому +66

    apparently we now have 0.01% more chance of finding aliens

    • @nikr1d3r32
      @nikr1d3r32 24 дні тому +11

      Oh you are too generous 😂
      Edit: damn autocorrect

    • @roberts7961
      @roberts7961 24 дні тому +9

      We already have them in the UK, Islamist's

    • @stevenmoore3480
      @stevenmoore3480 24 дні тому

      @@roberts7961 "Islamist's" is that right, we also have a lot of native people are thick as shit, and they just as bad, I say kick you the fuck out and the UK will be golden.

    • @froufou100
      @froufou100 24 дні тому +3

      What will they think of us?

    • @samsmith2635
      @samsmith2635 24 дні тому +4

      a generous number lol

  • @brianharoldvidal2374
    @brianharoldvidal2374 24 дні тому +26

    The San-Ti just made the repair works. Thanks to them...

    • @syntheticsandwich190
      @syntheticsandwich190 24 дні тому +5

      Imagine voyager sends back: DO NOT ANSWER!!! DO NOT ANSWER!!! DO NOT ANSWER!!!

    • @causticchan4617
      @causticchan4617 24 дні тому +4

      @@syntheticsandwich190 yo i got chills

    • @rootyroot
      @rootyroot 24 дні тому

      @@causticchan4617 You need to watch last stand (ai short film) exactly this happens!

    • @PiscatorLager
      @PiscatorLager 23 дні тому +1

      ​@@syntheticsandwich190let's hope that this isn't received by a scientist who had lost all faith in humanity

    • @moonshoes11
      @moonshoes11 23 дні тому +1

      They fixed the bugs? ;)

  • @espressomatic
    @espressomatic 23 дні тому +1

    Pretty cool. Insane to think of how far away VGER has traveled. And it's still not 1 Light-Day away.

  • @zenzo4815
    @zenzo4815 21 день тому

    It's just fascinating that it still in active

  • @exploretheobvious
    @exploretheobvious 24 дні тому +3

    “Reset button” comes to mind 😙

    • @CountScarlioni
      @CountScarlioni 24 дні тому

      Even in space, they sometimes have to turn things off and then back on again!

  • @myblueandme
    @myblueandme 24 дні тому +3

    Aliens? It's like an ant sending signals to an Elephant "look down".

  • @PtolemyJones
    @PtolemyJones 22 дні тому

    So love this mission, I was a kid when it launched, along with it's sister, and always interested in news about them.

  • @Alexander-eu8kl
    @Alexander-eu8kl 24 дні тому +1

    Great interview

  • @petevan8942
    @petevan8942 24 дні тому +7

    And they say man didn't land on the moon because we didn't have the technology...well 45 years on this old tech is still working wonders...we definitely had the tech to land on the moon.

    • @aykutlondon4784
      @aykutlondon4784 24 дні тому +1

      That's the dumbest thing I've ever heard. Just because we could launch satellites into space, doesn't mean we could land humans onto the moon. The logistics of such a task is so immense and not even comparable to launching a satellite. Yet you have just compared it.

    • @abisaiamatalo2769
      @abisaiamatalo2769 22 дні тому +1

      they should now easily land man on the moon using modern tech and materials. Strange that no country is trying to do it.

    • @geoffmower8729
      @geoffmower8729 22 дні тому

      @@aykutlondon4784 Now that is the dumbest thing I've ever heard!

    • @aykutlondon4784
      @aykutlondon4784 22 дні тому

      @@geoffmower8729 how so? I explained why i said what I said. You didn't. That's the difference. I never actually said that we didn't land humans on the moon. I said there's a massive difference between launching a satellite into deep space and launching a rocket with people and a moon lander onboard and it successfully landing. Does your small IQ brain think those two things are logistically the same thing? Who knows what you think, because you haven't bothered to explain your comment.

    • @microscopic.caterpill
      @microscopic.caterpill 22 дні тому

      Black Bolt is on the moon, I wouldn’t go back neither

  • @MorganSeveret
    @MorganSeveret 24 дні тому +11

    V.ger is back! 😉

  • @LukasKlein
    @LukasKlein 21 день тому

    During the length of this video, Voyager 1 traveled roughly 2500 miles (about 4000km).

  •  23 дні тому

    Thank you BBC News. Greetings from Popayan, Colombia.

  • @kayskreed
    @kayskreed 24 дні тому +16

    Is there a sci-fi story where Voyager-1 and 2 are discovered by aliens and sent back to us? Or one where they are the last remnant of humanity in some distant future?

    • @johngwheeler
      @johngwheeler 24 дні тому +13

      several sci-fi stories have used the Voyager probes in their plot: one of the Star Trek movies from the 1980s comes to mind.

    • @cressmanfoster
      @cressmanfoster 24 дні тому +9

      That is the plot of the first Star Trek movie. Although the probe is called Voyager 6.

    • @marcd1981
      @marcd1981 24 дні тому +7

      @@cressmanfoster V-GER, I remembered that as I read your comment. That would be a pretty awesome turn of events, an advanced race finding it and upgrading it to get back here.

    • @CountScarlioni
      @CountScarlioni 24 дні тому

      They've popped up in several scifi stories being encountered by aliens. The first Star Trek movie being the most notable example. However aliens will never find the Voyager probes.
      The real fate of Voyager 1 is to end up in the Smithsonian.
      In the coming centuries, nuclear propulsion technologies will make their way to space, and humans will rapidly establish manned and/or robotic outposts across the solar system using ships that accelerate at a constant 1G velocity. Such ships would be so fast that they would be able to journey out to Voyager 1's location in a few weeks. Some space-archaeologists will decide to have the Voyagers, and many other ancient space relics collected, brought back and put on museum pedestals.

    • @Space-Audio
      @Space-Audio 24 дні тому +1

      Just to rain on this parade: Both spacecraft are slowly being eroded away by high-velocity impacts with micron-sized (think smoke) dust. Our best measurements indicate about one such impact per hour which produces a tiny divot and a little plasma explosion we detect with the PWS instrument. If that rate were to persist, there wouldn't be much of anything left in several million years.

  • @jaker3151
    @jaker3151 24 дні тому +5

    The thought of some advanced civilization picking up the Voyager and decoding our information, all the way out there, gives me goosebumps.

    • @DK-gy7ll
      @DK-gy7ll 24 дні тому +1

      Let's just all hope that they're not an invading species and they figure out where it came from. Let's also hope that none of the sounds on that golden disk are considered insults in their language...

    • @nuntana2
      @nuntana2 24 дні тому +1

      ​@@DK-gy7ll Easy to figure out since there is a star map of earth's location in there too.

    • @Realndeep99
      @Realndeep99 23 дні тому +2

      In the grand scheme of things this object just travelled a distance let’s say 1 schoolbus from your home if we think our universe as the size of our entire galaxy so there’s very little chance of detecting life I think 🤔

    • @anonymes2884
      @anonymes2884 23 дні тому +1

      @@DK-gy7ll We've been sending a pretty much constant "Hi, we're here !" signal out into the universe in every direction _at the speed of light_ for about a hundred years.
      So one golden record that's vanishingly unlikely to ever be found is the very least of our problems in that regard.

  • @DjAmerillion
    @DjAmerillion 23 дні тому

    That is awesome that it is communicating again!

  • @madstylesnz
    @madstylesnz 23 дні тому

    Geez that old thing is still going strong after all this time, impressive engineering.

  • @eckeck1996
    @eckeck1996 24 дні тому +6

    Gulp.. not sure if telling aliens where to look for us is such a great idea.

    • @nuntana2
      @nuntana2 24 дні тому +2

      Wouldn't make a difference. They would already know our location through the decades' worth of the radio signals we've been chucking out, and if they're clever enough to make it to Voyager 1 or 2, one more light day to earth would be a blip.

    • @Space-Audio
      @Space-Audio 24 дні тому

      To be fair, the golden record was mostly for us Earthlings. If we're really really lucky, our technology will advance quickly enough to catch up with the Voyagers and return them to museums. Or, maybe, they'll be the most sought-after space salvage of all time. (I'll be passing trajectory data on to my progeny. ;-) )

    • @IZn0g0uDatAll
      @IZn0g0uDatAll 23 дні тому

      It will take Voyager 1 16700 years to reach Proxima the closest star from earth. And we are quite certain there are no aliens over there.
      So we are safe.
      Also, a fun fact is that scientists expect Voyager 1 to survive earth by at least a trillion years. So it might be one of the only trace of our existence for an incredibly long time.

    • @microscopic.caterpill
      @microscopic.caterpill 22 дні тому

      Right like Voyager baby you on your own. By time they come, I hope I’m light years decEASED.

  • @aerohk
    @aerohk 24 дні тому +4

    It's amazing we have people getting paid full time, running around to work on cool things without expectation of making a profit or any economic return.

    • @Space-Audio
      @Space-Audio 23 дні тому

      Science return, human knowledge return, is more than economic return.

    • @michaelrains64295
      @michaelrains64295 22 дні тому

      Not all progress is measured in dollars.

  • @BubbleMix-96
    @BubbleMix-96 22 дні тому +1

    We need to make a new one of those Gold discs

  • @quantumradio
    @quantumradio 24 дні тому

    Very good explanation from the Dr. Thank you.

  • @Lords1997
    @Lords1997 24 дні тому +5

    “After months of sending gibberish” Id like to believe an alien repaired Voyager for us :)

  • @JasonPurkiss
    @JasonPurkiss 24 дні тому +16

    Makes you wonder why apple retires there laptops after 10 years, perhaps they should employ some NASA engineers 😂

    • @tubecated_development
      @tubecated_development 23 дні тому +2

      You really wonder?
      🤑

    • @nickofzo
      @nickofzo 23 дні тому +2

      To make you buy new ones. Mercedes once almost went bankrupt because their cars wouldn't break down and no-one bought a new one because of that.

    • @alt8791
      @alt8791 21 день тому

      Because spacecraft have dead-simple, potato-quality computers and longevity is the absolute biggest concern in mission design (because you can’t fix it).

  • @jaylm4112
    @jaylm4112 23 дні тому

    It went quiet for a long time then it started just repeating the same code information... I'm Happy we have it back

  • @MultiSweeney1
    @MultiSweeney1 20 днів тому +1

    Voyager 1: "I didn't hear no bell"

  • @hans3691
    @hans3691 22 дні тому +4

    don 't forget Voyager 1 made the foto called: the pale blue dot. Earth photographed from millions of kilometers away..

  • @DjHazardous
    @DjHazardous 24 дні тому +12

    *Never understood why there are no plans for Voyager 3 and 4 with modern tech*

    • @benjaminalston8884
      @benjaminalston8884 24 дні тому +4

      Cos it’s all a lie my man

    • @inventor121
      @inventor121 24 дні тому +13

      The voyagers relied on gravity assists from the outer planets based on certain alignments. Chances for another Grand Tour using similar planetary alignments won't happen until at least 2150. And by that point tech will have advanced significantly. The only other option is to burn way more fuel than anything else before and that's just not feasible.

    • @CDee-if9og
      @CDee-if9og 24 дні тому

      They've chucked that out too with all the previous knowledge of the moon landings 😂 Just chucked in the bin.

    • @nic.h
      @nic.h 24 дні тому +3

      @@inventor121 we have other means of accelerating craft which are feasible. Laser assisted solar sails for example as proposed for the solar gravitational lense project and breakthrough slingshot.

    • @fnorgen
      @fnorgen 24 дні тому +1

      @@inventor121 Also, there have been quite a few missions of similar impact to the Voyagers. The Mars rovers for example, or Osiris Rex, the asteroid booping sample return mission, or the James Webb Space Telescope. There's been no shortage of more modern Voyager equivalents.

  • @ateamfan42
    @ateamfan42 22 дні тому

    @0:50 As a person who is also 4-1/2 decades old, I can confirm that not all systems work quite the way they did when freshly manufactured.

  • @amicablefire9693
    @amicablefire9693 23 дні тому

    Little guy is working hard up there🥺 just won’t let us down

  • @AeonMusicRecord
    @AeonMusicRecord 24 дні тому +8

    u can still get connection from billion miles away but so hard to get connection from across the world

    • @mbbb9244
      @mbbb9244 24 дні тому +4

      That’s because the data equivalent of 5,125,000,000,000,000 Voyagers is transmitted around earth EVERY DAY. Pretty reliable I’d say.

    • @mistertagnan
      @mistertagnan 24 дні тому +6

      @@mbbb9244 it also helps that there is basically nothing in between Voyager and Earth, whereas there is an entire Earth in the way between opposite sides of the Earth

    • @microscopic.caterpill
      @microscopic.caterpill 22 дні тому

      I would agree, but then I remember how humongous the land antennas we got for those space craft are, then how they are spread in specific regions of the planet in diameter and range, and then how it’s specifically calculated to shoot a certain signal in a specific direction and frequency, then how it’s different how a GPS satellite would have to scatter amongst many devices compare to- 💥

  • @wildandbarefoot
    @wildandbarefoot 24 дні тому +4

    Im very glad this has been fixed.
    I do think a Alien did the fix.

    • @thedman7305
      @thedman7305 23 дні тому +2

      cuz u a bot

    • @alt8791
      @alt8791 21 день тому +1

      Amazingly insulting to the team of extremely talented engineers who have dedicated most of their lives to keeping this spacecraft alive

    • @thedman7305
      @thedman7305 21 день тому +1

      @@alt8791 well said

  • @DanElton
    @DanElton 22 дні тому

    Props to the BBC for covering this!!!

  • @applepeel1662
    @applepeel1662 22 дні тому

    That's absolutely incredible

  • @user-wt6co4ot3i
    @user-wt6co4ot3i 24 дні тому +28

    Wish this could make the world more peaceful with less misery

    • @RedFail1-1
      @RedFail1-1 24 дні тому +2

      How would that even make the slightest bit of sense? Data about space solving all the problems in the world?

    • @CountScarlioni
      @CountScarlioni 24 дні тому

      Voyager 1 already tried its best to do that. Look up "the pale blue dot."

    • @connycontainer9459
      @connycontainer9459 24 дні тому +7

      It's a nice change from the usual news. So for you and me and some other people it already did.

    • @cicakaki6587
      @cicakaki6587 24 дні тому +1

      @@RedFail1-1the way people live their lives still in 2024.. and the beliefs they have.. imagine what a groundbreaking discovery from space or news of a highly intelligent species would do. We still fight with each other right here on earth about money and about who’s cult is better

    • @Blodhelm
      @Blodhelm 24 дні тому +1

      @@cicakaki6587 Our governments would never tell us. They profit off our disfunction.

  • @Mitchell527
    @Mitchell527 24 дні тому +4

    Some day, we will catch it in space.

    • @moonshoes11
      @moonshoes11 23 дні тому

      That is an interesting concept.

    • @BloodyCrow__
      @BloodyCrow__ 21 день тому

      Hope its not some shitty future where the rich control everything. Some rich asshat with the golden disk on a plaque on the wall of his space yacht.

  • @maxqproductions1
    @maxqproductions1 23 дні тому

    Good stuff but one of your photos of the tracker equipment belongs to Ed Geiger with USLaunch Report.

  • @NOT.MI5.MI6.
    @NOT.MI5.MI6. 23 дні тому +1

    Brian cox saying something about it before about space travel and time travel etc I j
    just wondering if the probe if it had atomic clock on it and one on earth would they have different times on ? eg if they checked the time on voyager now and calculated the time of the signal to travel threw space would it be different times ?

    • @Hobbes746
      @Hobbes746 23 дні тому +2

      Yes. The difference is small (less than a second, if I remember correctly).

    • @NOT.MI5.MI6.
      @NOT.MI5.MI6. 22 дні тому

      ​@@Hobbes746 Thanks for your reply 😊

  • @quinkydinkend
    @quinkydinkend 24 дні тому +4

    An alien pressed ctrl alt delete

  • @MaheshWalatara
    @MaheshWalatara 24 дні тому +4

    It's also got a galactic map that pinpoints the location of the Sol System to any potential aliens which I don't think was a good idea. 😢

    • @mbrackeva
      @mbrackeva 24 дні тому +5

      Why not? God knows we need all the help we can get...

    • @nic.h
      @nic.h 24 дні тому +2

      It's a very small needle in a very large haystack. You should be much more concerned with our electromagnetic emissions if you are worried about aliens locating us, as they are multi directional and travel at significantly faster speeds and still allow the source to be located, although they do get weaker the further they travel as per the inverse square law.

    • @raptorwhite6468
      @raptorwhite6468 24 дні тому +1

      Aliens have no reason to fight us, if they can travel between planetary systems, we aren't a threat and if they needed resources, they'd rather take it from a planet with no life on it

    • @jeffreyadams8264
      @jeffreyadams8264 24 дні тому

      46 years in space and dodged all thoses meteors! Stop it! Get some help!

    • @ThisHandleFeatureIsStupid
      @ThisHandleFeatureIsStupid 23 дні тому +1

      By the time Voyager 2 even launched, it was already several decades too late to stop that problem.
      We've been venting information into space since at least 1936.

  • @Nath4n1977
    @Nath4n1977 22 дні тому

    Props to the engineer that went out there and fixed it and came back alive

  • @rickintexas1584
    @rickintexas1584 23 дні тому

    This machine is extraordinary by every measure. Kudos to the men and women who developed this machine, and are continuing to work on it still.

  • @homesteadireland7473
    @homesteadireland7473 24 дні тому +5

    We didn’t know that we had advanced chips like that all that time ago ? We just thought we had fish ands chips then lol 😂

    • @wizardgherkin
      @wizardgherkin 24 дні тому

      just because mass produced microcontrollers weren't (broadly) around, doesn't mean there were no electronics!

  • @echomike78
    @echomike78 24 дні тому +8

    V'Ger🛰🚀🤓

  • @CMBurns1000
    @CMBurns1000 23 дні тому

    3:47 this gives me chills 🥺

  • @Kallekringla3
    @Kallekringla3 22 дні тому

    Wow. Beautiful! And the Voyger-1 is cool too!

  • @mtheory85
    @mtheory85 24 дні тому +4

    "Failure is not an option." - NASA
    "Durr if rocket no go boom it success!" - SpaceX

    • @mbrackeva
      @mbrackeva 24 дні тому +2

      Even if it does go boom SpaceX says it's a success.

    • @nicholashylton6857
      @nicholashylton6857 24 дні тому +1

      ​@@mbrackevaYeah. It bugs me that that philosophy is now the "in thing." It would have been excusable in the 40s & 50s, but not in the 21st century.

    • @mistertagnan
      @mistertagnan 24 дні тому +2

      Failures of LVs during testing are extremely common and expected. Thor and Atlas failed many, many times when they were first being made, and now they’re the basis for some of the most launched LVs ever
      Failure with crew is not an option, failure during tests is preferable to complete success. Better to fail frequently during testing and discover problems, than to let a potentially lethal problem slip through the cracks as it awaits the day it claims its first victim

    • @anonymes2884
      @anonymes2884 23 дні тому +3

      I'm no fan of Elon Musk as a human but SpaceX's _established_ launch vehicles have a success rate comparable to any on the planet.
      Sure, their _tests of prototypes_ often end in explosions. That's _why_ you test. Prototype rockets are basically _going_ to explode, the point is what you learn as a result.

    • @mbrackeva
      @mbrackeva 23 дні тому

      @@anonymes2884 Do you actually have any inside numbers on this? Or do you base yourself on popular news? I'm under the impression this is a very naive statement.

  • @user-oy3mg6jh1f
    @user-oy3mg6jh1f 23 дні тому +3

    NASA: We’re the smartest government agency out there. We sent a man to the moon!
    Also NASA: *forgets to maintain archaic code, doesn’t realize it’s a software issue for decades, and doesn’t do anything to fix it until it’s almost to late.
    But seriously, what is our generation coming to; when organizations like NASA are failing us in there endeavors within space exploration?
    EDIT: To be explicit, the chips on Voyager 1 were malfunctioning for years, and NASA fixed them with a simple software-patch; which altered the program that managed the chips onboard Voyager 1. If somebody is telling ya that this was only a hardware issue, then they don't know what they're talking about, and they've probably never worked in IT a day in their life.

    • @Hobbes746
      @Hobbes746 23 дні тому +2

      Nope. Voyager 1 failed because one of the memory chips in one of its computers malfunctioned. This is not a software issue.

    • @user-oy3mg6jh1f
      @user-oy3mg6jh1f 23 дні тому +3

      @@Hobbes746 the reporter in the video just explained that the chips weren’t routing properly. The solution was software based. But the issue itself was hardware related. Did you even listen to the video?

    • @biggerdickus
      @biggerdickus 22 дні тому

      It is hard to maintain stuff, I know, the old engineers I worked with left poor notebooks with many things missing.

    • @bobmusil1458
      @bobmusil1458 22 дні тому +1

      What are you even talking about?
      The communication failed last November because of a hardware issue. And then they fixed the hardware problem with a software patch. Before November 2023 Voyager had worked for 40 years flawlessly.
      .

    • @Hobbes746
      @Hobbes746 22 дні тому

      @@user-oy3mg6jh1f No amount of software maintenance can prevent electronic circuits from failing. You were claiming Voyager’s problem was due to an issue in the software that NASA had failed to spot for “decades”, which is not at all the case.

  • @dafalzonAUS
    @dafalzonAUS 22 дні тому +1

    Sometimes the simpler the device, the less for things to go wrong, best way to explore deep space, less complicated, more durable

  • @ronaldtreitner1460
    @ronaldtreitner1460 21 день тому

    still amazing what a good mind and a slide rule can do, the way stuffs built today i doubt anyone could build another one that would last so long.