@@statinskill in this specific test yes. We have no knowledge of where those samples actually came from and a true test would be multiple samples from each country using multiple steel suppliers. Just saying…
@@statinskill It would actually be a failure if the didn't come first, their best quality in terms of metal production during the USSR was achieved with steel alloys; it was the thing they were best at, and they always had a tendency to overharden everything steel, which is good in some applications, bad in others.
@@tegrqbarv0510 The reason is the contact surface, is just an small area the contact between the hardest steel and the ceramic ball. In consequence, the applied stress is so high that the steel breaks.
It’s because of the small surface area at the point of contact to the press and the strength of a sphere. Plies the tool head could have been a non hardened piece for dramatic effect. This video is very suss to me with the hardness and outcomes and no ceramic ball test of US steel.
This puts into perspective how amazing steel alloys are and why a lot of our world is built from steel. Seeing the tungsten squish more than the steel was fascinating. Seeing the ceramic split the steel of the press was astonishing
Hardness usually isn't the only quality you want from steel unless you are using it for tools or something that hardness is the most desired quality. For buildings you need the right mixture of hardness and resilience or corrosion resistance for example. There are vast number of different steel alloys with different qualities for different use cases. Other metal alloys may have better desired qualities sometimes but they can be too expensive compared to steel products
Not sure about astonishing. The ceramic ball was proven to be quite hard so it effectively was transferring all the energy of the press to the point where the ball interacted with the block. All that energy on a single point yeh even really strong steel is only so strong and it had already suffered stress from its own testing (you can see little stress cracks in the blocks).
For context, this is the cheaper material used for body armor. *Cheaper Considering kevlar exists. But yea, most commercially available ballistic vests for law enforcement is made of ceramic armor plates, made to withstand multiple shots of rifle bullets. Most bullets are made of lead... We seen how much lead bends with a a hydraulic press, and a ceramic ball broke a press...
@@TheHammerGuy94 Kevlar is used mostly because it's lightweight and can be used to make something like a cloth. So it's armor plates inside kevlar vest. Lead is used because it's hard enough against human flesh but it's way softer than barrel of a gun so it can shoot tens of thousands of bullets.
So the reason the steel is so much stronger than the pure metals like tungsten and aluminum is because in an alloy the intermixture of carbon and steel break up the crystalline structure of the metal. Unalloyed metals are pretty uniform, so once enough energy is applied on the Y axis, the mass shifts on the X axis. With alloys, the intermix causes deformation and structure that act as bracing on a molecular level. As the steel cools, millions of tiny pockets of varying concentration precipitate out at random as the steel fixes. The result is an internal structure that is far stronger than the pure, crystalline metal. Then when you process the steel, you are actually manipulating these structures into more effective shapes, fixing them when the steel is quenched and hardened. It's a huge science and really interesting to see it in action.
очень много стали маркируют как HSS но на самом деле это какая-то подъеба, особенно если заказывать из китая. настоящая HSS особенно та которая с 8% кобальта на самом деле очень твердая и износоустойчивая. но вообще да, именно так
I work at a heavy machine shop. We have a 100 ton press. I'll personally not be trying this at home because the chances of something becoming a projectile enough to scare most sane people.
over 80 tons, that is 160,000 pounds per single 1/4 inch. Imagine if there was just a 1/4 inch thick weld by 1/4 long. It could support a big rig. Wild to think of that.
Этот эксперимент лишь малая часть работы технологов. Четвертый год обучаюсь металлургии, знаю в общих чертах производство, но никак не могу выбрать область в которой хотел бы работать, всё нравится) Если кто-нибудь знает проблемы измерения плоскостности горячекатанного листа, то я был бы рад послушать
(переводчик Google) Вы можете поступить на инженера по материалам и специализироваться в этой области. Исходя из того, что я понял по вашему вопросу, я бы сказал, что это будет неточность в измерении, из-за неравномерного расширения пластины.
Salut. Je suis impressionné, jamais je n'aurais cru, malgré les traitements subis, que de l'acier serait plus dur que du tungstène. Les russes ont clairement une longueur d'avance, même si elle est minime, sur leur technologie de l'acier... Merci, vraiment intéressant.
65HRC is almost the hardest one for the alloy steels. so as you can see the platform is pressed with a little pit. also due to its extremely high hardness, it's so brittle and cracked into pieces after being pressed by a steel ball
You can prevent that with a better case hardening method though, and steels can go over 65 hrc. It is not uncommon to sometimes see 67-68 hrc surface hardness (it's usually nitriding)
This video contains no information on the source of these materials or heat treatment info. A few things to, m35 is not the hardest, m42 is and both aren't 69 hrc, around 64 hrc. If you need the hardest steel look for Rex 121, an American steel regarded as the hardest up to 71 hrc.
@@Spencer19165 ryan... definitions for a snow flake are a person who hide and draw with crayons and not telling others all usa can sell this day are nothing... not even a war... so re define your comment
@@torbisoder4768 I say don't dish it out unless you can take it.... And the definition of a "snowflake" is a individual crystal of ice formed in the atmosphere
@@nigelsmith7366 nigel... thats the old definition.. who ever come up with the new one.. i rather not be involved in this definition... i guess this definition was evolving out of California.... as it is definitely a American side most genuine yankee doodles are ashamed of
What metal are the two cylinders the press uses, made from? I've always wondered that. Same thing with molten steel. The crucible where the steel is mixed obviously has to be stronger than the steel to withstand the temperatures reached during the process.
I also wonder about these cylinders but for the steel I can tell you that the most common thing on a small scale is graphite or alumina. I'm not sure what modern steel mills use, but the big Bessemer converters back in the day were mostly steel but lined with ceramic on the inside to insulate them.
The crucible used for holding molten steel are lined with refractory. I'm not sure what it's made from but from my knowledge was and/or is still commonly used in those type of applications.
@@yunellenriqueberdugogonzal6164 Fuck The What? Do you think that your steel is more stronger than Russia? Will your wrong, your state of the art products is now scrap today Russia and China is the most advance than the u.s.a. and try to review this video and compare it properly so that you see the difference.
@@rated-gr3983 on board our China built ships, well call the RVS 'rusts very swiftly'... That's all I can say on the matter, but in the end, in any country, you get what you pay for.
@@LADY_JEMIMA_FORTESCUE Actually peoples fear Russia More now. You are just seeing fake west media. See Carefully first, NATO and US both refused to help Ukraine, and no country in the world tried to go against Russia. Russia Openly proved again that it alone is enough for entire NATO.
There are a great deal of products ( and skills) from Russia that are made to last..... it is a shame that the Western countries demonize Russia so much. Full of engineers, scientists, astrophysicists, vast and diverse country, full of natural resources and amazing landscapes and people. Mad respect for Russia, despite decades of antiRussia propaganda in North American film and tv industry.
@@macarthur3169 мы очень мирные, но зря ваш Байден влез в наши разборки с Украиной. Теперь экономика США пойдет вниз. Это конец америуанского мировоготпооядка и рассвет нового русско-китайского. Самый адекватный президент был Дональд Трамп, он знал, что с русскими не надо воевать,с русскими надо дружить. Привет из России)😊😘
The Russian steel started flexing earlier than the two, but I am guessing it resisted malleability more and that's why it has less deformation when compared to the new cube.
My Dad worked 37 years at Timken Roller Bearing he said they used the best chrome steel available, there are train bearings that have 10 million miles on them. 👍🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
@@detroitwhat4017 yessir , I guess Dad knew the ol Man himself Henry Timken , if we wouldn’t have sold out to Japanese steel in the late 70’s early 80’s, places like Canton would still be thriving, but I won’t start waving the flag.
You might try M42 for kicks if you want. It's a cobalt HSS like M35 but harder. I don't know that it's any stronger in terms of compressive strength. Both are used for high quality drill bits since they retain a hard edge at significantly high temperatures.
The reason the ceramic ball soloed the steel is because unlike the press, all the pressure is being applied to one spot, while the press evenly applies the pressure due to the flat surface it had
I thought that HY 100 steel was the most difficult to work with. They tried to use it for the pressure hull of the Virginia class subs but it was too difficult to weld.
An anecdote for you: here in Russia we build submarine hulls out of titan alloys (apparently, we have plenty of it). In US they build SR71 Blackbird out of titan; we make filters for water, shovels and pots out of it, I've seen some myself. I guess, a titan paperweight is next. It would be funny if it weren't so sad.
@@Saiga-saiga Видимо, по этой причине американцы делают из титана сверхскоростные самолёты-разведчики и прочую дефицитную лабуду, а мы - фильтры для воды, кастрюли и лопаты.
Here is a video from the main channel of the author, on the assembly of a hydraulic press: ua-cam.com/video/4BbG6or2fz4/v-deo.html The video is in Russian language, but I think if you want to see how it looks like this is enough)
The quality of steel is a function of hardness and strength. Very hard steel is also brittle and will fracture easily. Steel that does not fracture is stronger. The type of steel you get depends on what is added to it. So it depends on what exactly you plan to do with the steel, you adjust the specific qualities accordingly.
Kinds hard to draw our own conclusions of the results by eyesight on our screen. You could've used a micrometer to exactly measure for us the clear winner.
Well to be fair the Russian piece only reached around 95 tons while the American one reached 100 tons. They both began to deform around the 90-95 ton marker though so measuring by deformation makes no sense because the loads weren’t equal.
yes that is also cane be a reason why is the American get bit more deformed than Russian . But you see that , what i had mentioned , there is a different between , and the USA piece has deformed more.
from tools perspective... it all depends on specific brands... I have never seen good Chinese steel tools.... good yes but not top of the shelf...the rest depends of the price.... cheap Chinese chisel may definitely outperform expensive west chisel in short term on price but not on quality or performance
That's what most Chinese manufacturers looks for though, they knew its hard to compete in high end products so instead they make high CP ratio low to mid tier stuff, but that's also why I buy Japanese tools instead, much more reliable in long term, last longer and lower chances of buying defective product, but for simple tools it doesn't really matter, and sometimes Chinese brands will have tailor made tools for very specific situation that you can't expect to find in other brands. On the other hand you can also look at products that uses imported materials, for a non-tool example, there is a workshop in China making coffee grinders that uses imported steel burr and do titanium surface coating themselves to further harden the burr, other parts of the grinder uses local materials and the result is a surprisingly good grinder at a relatively cheap price, it basically combines the best of both worlds.
Bravo, another good video. I have used hss and M35 cutting tools for years. Not familiar with the Russian tool steel. What material are the bolster plated made from? Got to have very high pressure properties. Thank you for sharing.
There's even better alloy thats used in drill bits in Russia. Called P6M5K5 if I remember right. got cobalt in it. 5 is the % from overall mass of steel. P is steel with tungsten, M is molybdenum and K is K is cobalt. Drill bits made from this alloy are really hard.
I'm not understanding why you use three steels from three countries. Why not use the same type from all three? I dunno about Russia, but both China and the US make and use most HSS types for cheap steel cutting tools. Different types of HSS and different heat treatments will change hardness, wear resistance, shock resistance, etc.
In Russia, most people refer to "chinese" steel, a cheap one, as HSS, because it's written on crappy chinese tools. Technically M35, russian P6M5 or P4M2 and dozens (hundreds?) of others are all HSS, including crappy chinese or indian steel. Of course, China produces good tools out of good alloys too. It's a popular video so don't expect much. I work on a plant with people (METALworkers!) who thinks that "HSS" is a sort of a steel and don't understand what "high-speed steel" (even the russian equivalent "быстрорежущая сталь") means.
Not sure why the country matters. Wouldn't its resistance just depend on the percentage carbon and other elements (Magnesium, Chromium, etc) that was used to create the steel, rather than where it was made? For what it's worth, the Russian cube seems to have retained its shape the best under this particular test. In a real world setting, there are obviously other desirable properties than just resistance to compressive stress.
@@elliotmyers9071 You mean different COMPANIES have different manufacturing processes? Even two batches of steel made by different manufacturers within the same country are bound to be different if their steel has different composition and quenching/annealing process.
It looks to me that you barely touched 100 tons for Russian and USA cubes. So, I don't think this is a fair comparison. Neither you listed the price of all three steels, but that is a different topic.
I’d have those sample size metals tested, I wouldn’t be surprised if they aren’t the metals they claim to be, not suggesting dishonesty on the UA-camrs part, but they’re all over eBay, and it wouldn’t be hard to falsify it, I’m surprised at how easily titanium and tungsten both crushed that easily and quickly
exactly, i was amazed to see tungsten being that plyable... it should be harder than HSS (keep in mind that concrete drill bits use tungsten tip with HSS body, so by theory, tungsten should be in top tier in hardeness)
@@tomasgogashvily5350 But we don’t have as many homeless people as in America, medicine is largely free, there are many more positive aspects that you are not told about
@@JustFP Ты рассказываешь парню из России о России? В США бомж подал бы в суд, в России можно убить бомжа и всем будет насрать. Особенно, если олигарх пустил тебе пулю в лицо, LOLOL. Тот факт, что вы можете позволить себе Интернет, да еще постить на "капиталистическом" свино-злобном сайте Американской Империи, шокирует не меньше.
Damn. I was going to try this at home. Then I realised that I didn't have a 500 tonne hydraulic press. Damn.
You can use my brother instead of hudraulic press
You can use my sister instead of his brother
You can use these 2 imbeciles instead of hydraulic press
Mom jokes: allow us to introduce ourselves
@@foxyy2048...or @user-wk7xo9vc6j 's mom!
I always thought this press was huge till I seen your fingers lol
@Edward Elizabeth Hitler yes
He may have massive fingers. 🤔
Same
He has hulk hands. Those cubes are actually 4 inches a side
it's still impressive
In Russia, steel compresses you.
*Soviet Russia*
I would say that will happen everywhere
@@gintry2 that was a Soviet joke u didn't get it
It indeed does, because safety measures are neglected.
Ukraine is proving Russia is actually just soft and filled with corruption and incompetence.
Can we just take a moment to appreciate the fact that on an atomic level, these materials are all held together by simple electrical bonds.
Right after we appreciate that Russia has the best steel way ahead of China and the US.
@@statinskill in this specific test yes. We have no knowledge of where those samples actually came from and a true test would be multiple samples from each country using multiple steel suppliers. Just saying…
@@statinskill It would actually be a failure if the didn't come first, their best quality in terms of metal production during the USSR was achieved with steel alloys; it was the thing they were best at, and they always had a tendency to overharden everything steel, which is good in some applications, bad in others.
Plot twist: They are all from China
@@rxpsycho7326 you sound salty. You should be questioning the channel
Hardened Steel: "I fear no man but that thing"
**Ceramic ball**
It scares me."
Dont meet him alone 😅
Yo for real what's up with the ceramic ball
@@brandonzacher5263 Balls are made of ceramics. It can break the press because the shape or you can google to know more
@@tegrqbarv0510 The reason is the contact surface, is just an small area the contact between the hardest steel and the ceramic ball. In consequence, the applied stress is so high that the steel breaks.
It’s because of the small surface area at the point of contact to the press and the strength of a sphere. Plies the tool head could have been a non hardened piece for dramatic effect. This video is very suss to me with the hardness and outcomes and no ceramic ball test of US steel.
This puts into perspective how amazing steel alloys are and why a lot of our world is built from steel. Seeing the tungsten squish more than the steel was fascinating. Seeing the ceramic split the steel of the press was astonishing
Yeah but those steels were definitely forged, and the tungsten definitely wasn’t.
Hardness usually isn't the only quality you want from steel unless you are using it for tools or something that hardness is the most desired quality. For buildings you need the right mixture of hardness and resilience or corrosion resistance for example. There are vast number of different steel alloys with different qualities for different use cases. Other metal alloys may have better desired qualities sometimes but they can be too expensive compared to steel products
Raw tungsten is one thing. Tungsten Carbide on the other hand...
@@paulinadeluca9117 It is not the forging. It is the heat treatment that matters.
Not sure about astonishing. The ceramic ball was proven to be quite hard so it effectively was transferring all the energy of the press to the point where the ball interacted with the block. All that energy on a single point yeh even really strong steel is only so strong and it had already suffered stress from its own testing (you can see little stress cracks in the blocks).
When the ceramic ball broke the press I kind of went wide eyed.
I know, right? Check me on this...ceramic is baked clay, right?
@@jbrisby this one probably not
For context, this is the cheaper material used for body armor.
*Cheaper
Considering kevlar exists.
But yea, most commercially available ballistic vests for law enforcement is made of ceramic armor plates, made to withstand multiple shots of rifle bullets.
Most bullets are made of lead...
We seen how much lead bends with a a hydraulic press, and a ceramic ball broke a press...
@@TheHammerGuy94 Kevlar is used mostly because it's lightweight and can be used to make something like a cloth.
So it's armor plates inside kevlar vest.
Lead is used because it's hard enough against human flesh but it's way softer than barrel of a gun so it can shoot tens of thousands of bullets.
@@TheHammerGuy94 I think the shape of that ceramic ball had as much to do with damaging the press as much as anything. Just my opinion.
USA and China: oh no hydraulic press scary Russia: is nothing
That is some high quality Stalinium
@@ber_gx2966as russian i'll open a secret of power of russian steel, on russian it's sounds like STAL', it use the power of Stalin
Actually Russia was the weakest, China was the strongest. Russia started getting squished at around 80, USA around 90 and China just over 100.
Also he used more force on those two rather than the Russian one
@@slonya_4982Сталь
Болел за наш кубик как на Олимпийских играх! С победой, товарищи русские и народы России!
😆
😂😂😂🇷🇺
видео фейк. 😂
@@ChatJokey пруфы?
@@Total_pizdecc ты чо, каждый американец знает что наши спортсмены в олимпийских играх на стероидах сидят
I’m impressed with the Russian.
😎
They stole it from the Czech
So the reason the steel is so much stronger than the pure metals like tungsten and aluminum is because in an alloy the intermixture of carbon and steel break up the crystalline structure of the metal. Unalloyed metals are pretty uniform, so once enough energy is applied on the Y axis, the mass shifts on the X axis. With alloys, the intermix causes deformation and structure that act as bracing on a molecular level. As the steel cools, millions of tiny pockets of varying concentration precipitate out at random as the steel fixes. The result is an internal structure that is far stronger than the pure, crystalline metal. Then when you process the steel, you are actually manipulating these structures into more effective shapes, fixing them when the steel is quenched and hardened. It's a huge science and really interesting to see it in action.
Thx for your description
Crystalline is an improper term. You mean lattice.
@@SausageRoll4u true. Lazy terminology on my part.
intermixture? = mixture
Very complex. Definitely a huge science. Really fascinating material.
Imagine a shelter made out of the Russian steel
Imagine a main battle tank made out of the Russian steel
It won't save you against the sh*t that flying with x8 speed of sound tho
That's where Putin is hiding
What about Stalinium )))))))
@@Guardrailkid Stalin means means man of steel hahaha.
Р6М5 действительно хорошая сталь. Например, свёрла по металлу Р6М5 в разы лучше HSS
очень много стали маркируют как HSS но на самом деле это какая-то подъеба, особенно если заказывать из китая. настоящая HSS особенно та которая с 8% кобальта на самом деле очень твердая и износоустойчивая. но вообще да, именно так
Got to love the disclaimer at the start about not trying this at home. Hands up how many of you have an industrial press in the back yard 🤣.
I work at a heavy machine shop. We have a 100 ton press. I'll personally not be trying this at home because the chances of something becoming a projectile enough to scare most sane people.
break out the old nut cracker
It is nuts to think those little cubes can withstand that pressure
over 80 tons, that is 160,000 pounds per single 1/4 inch. Imagine if there was just a 1/4 inch thick weld by 1/4 long. It could support a big rig. Wild to think of that.
@@superchuck3259 not quite. leverage is your enemy
@@superchuck3259 the cube is not 1/4 inch
@@superchuck3259 Don't be so uncivilized and use metric, American.
The Russian hardened steel look more harder than the US ones lmfao 😹😹😹
Я сам в шоке
@@duche_boyда быстрорез удивляет
The thing is - there was astonishingly little difference between them all
Also harder steel isn't always better
@@KnightMinson cope
Всем мира, добра и позитива 🇷🇺🤝🇺🇸🤝🇨🇳
👍👍👍👍
sure～
GET OUT OF UKRAINE‼️😠🤬
Кто тоже сидел, "болел" за свой кубик? 🤣🤣🤣
Same to you.
Этот эксперимент лишь малая часть работы технологов. Четвертый год обучаюсь металлургии, знаю в общих чертах производство, но никак не могу выбрать область в которой хотел бы работать, всё нравится) Если кто-нибудь знает проблемы измерения плоскостности горячекатанного листа, то я был бы рад послушать
(переводчик Google) Вы можете поступить на инженера по материалам и специализироваться в этой области. Исходя из того, что я понял по вашему вопросу, я бы сказал, что это будет неточность в измерении, из-за неравномерного расширения пластины.
Вы можете стать блогером и снимать видео о твёрдости гвоздей и влияния на нее солнечной активности. Главное, что не нужен 500 тонный пресс!
Студент-металлург не Анатолий, случаем?)))
Salut. Je suis impressionné, jamais je n'aurais cru, malgré les traitements subis, que de l'acier serait plus dur que du tungstène. Les russes ont clairement une longueur d'avance, même si elle est minime, sur leur technologie de l'acier...
Merci, vraiment intéressant.
65HRC is almost the hardest one for the alloy steels. so as you can see the platform is pressed with a little pit.
also due to its extremely high hardness, it's so brittle and cracked into pieces after being pressed by a steel ball
You can prevent that with a better case hardening method though, and steels can go over 65 hrc. It is not uncommon to sometimes see 67-68 hrc surface hardness (it's usually nitriding)
i happened to drop such a steel tool on the floor ( lathe tool ) it broke like glass !
This video contains no information on the source of these materials or heat treatment info. A few things to, m35 is not the hardest, m42 is and both aren't 69 hrc, around 64 hrc. If you need the hardest steel look for Rex 121, an American steel regarded as the hardest up to 71 hrc.
this comment deserves more respect. nice info, i appreciate
The press assy must be made out of REX 121.
But the real Hillary Rodham Clinton is the hardest HRC of all.
Thanks for the correct information!
Thanks. God bless.
My grandfather's 70 year old sledge hammer is tougher than all of these.
++++++++
That's actually true as it's funny! You know why? because Carbon steel, get's better as it olds! It get's stronger, way more dense!!
You haven't see the soviet-time kindergarten wooden chair
@@g00sepocalypse soviet style apartment complex 🌚
Grandfather's hammer was made by love, and imbued with his passion
Would have like to seen the US and the ceramic ball.
it just proves it ..us are a softi😂
@@torbisoder4768 ok snow flake
@@Spencer19165 ryan... definitions for a snow flake are a person who hide and draw with crayons
and not telling others all usa can sell this day are nothing...
not even a war...
so re define your comment
@@torbisoder4768 I say don't dish it out unless you can take it.... And the definition of a "snowflake" is a individual crystal of ice formed in the atmosphere
@@nigelsmith7366 nigel...
thats the old definition..
who ever come up with the new one..
i rather not be involved in this definition...
i guess this definition was evolving out of California....
as it is definitely a American side most genuine yankee doodles are ashamed of
What metal are the two cylinders the press uses, made from? I've always wondered that. Same thing with molten steel. The crucible where the steel is mixed obviously has to be stronger than the steel to withstand the temperatures reached during the process.
Indeed
I also wonder about these cylinders but for the steel I can tell you that the most common thing on a small scale is graphite or alumina. I'm not sure what modern steel mills use, but the big Bessemer converters back in the day were mostly steel but lined with ceramic on the inside to insulate them.
The crucible used for holding molten steel are lined with refractory. I'm not sure what it's made from but from my knowledge was and/or is still commonly used in those type of applications.
Adamantium lined with Vibranium. Pure Vibranium is too expensive.
I figured they used “unobtainium”
1. Russia
2. USA
3. China
WTF??
@@yunellenriqueberdugogonzal6164 Fuck The What? Do you think that your steel is more stronger than Russia? Will your wrong, your state of the art products is now scrap today Russia and China is the most advance than the u.s.a. and try to review this video and compare it properly so that you see the difference.
@@rated-gr3983 Claro, yo no digo lo contrario, es que el orden que pones esta mal para lo que muestra el video, 1. Rusia 2. China 3. U.S.A.
@@rated-gr3983 on board our China built ships, well call the RVS 'rusts very swiftly'... That's all I can say on the matter, but in the end, in any country, you get what you pay for.
so it looks like the Russian steel compressed less than the American how come you didn't do the ceramic ball on the American steel?
That's the reason US fears Russia war machines 😂
no one 'fears' russian weapon after the fiasco in ukraine.
@@LADY_JEMIMA_FORTESCUE Actually peoples fear Russia More now. You are just seeing fake west media. See Carefully first, NATO and US both refused to help Ukraine, and no country in the world tried to go against Russia. Russia Openly proved again that it alone is enough for entire NATO.
He doesn't want cia visit.
@@Blitzkers99 look to the war in Ukraine =))
There are a great deal of products ( and skills) from Russia that are made to last..... it is a shame that the Western countries demonize Russia so much.
Full of engineers, scientists, astrophysicists, vast and diverse country, full of natural resources and amazing landscapes and people. Mad respect for Russia, despite decades of antiRussia propaganda in North American film and tv industry.
Nobody is against Russia or the Russians but the Russian government is a different story.
@@macarthur3169 мы очень мирные, но зря ваш Байден влез в наши разборки с Украиной. Теперь экономика США пойдет вниз. Это конец америуанского мировоготпооядка и рассвет нового русско-китайского. Самый адекватный президент был Дональд Трамп, он знал, что с русскими не надо воевать,с русскими надо дружить. Привет из России)😊😘
Nobody demonizes russia more than russia itself. Would you like to come over to Ukraine to see what russian orks did in Bucha?
Hardness is technically a materials resistance to scratching and abrasion. These materials are being tested for compressive strength
The ceramic ball showed pretty well what hardness means
Man, now I'm hungry for some aluminum cookies! 💪😎
I have a 50 ton press and used to like to crush things in it. This channel is much safer. Thank you
3:44 The "new" is the strongest of all, not even a scratch!
Esa sólo la puso para comprarar cuanto se comprimieron los demás metales.
@@erickherrerapena8981 oh yeah ?
The Russian steel started flexing earlier than the two, but I am guessing it resisted malleability more and that's why it has less deformation when compared to the new cube.
Its one of the principles of Russian reactive armor
Russian one was the hardest, while chinese steel is the squishiest.
What I want to know is how did you get Chuck Norris's left ball?? 😂
USA VS Ceramic ball?
Yes
youtube banned
Steel: Squished.
Ceramic ball: Breaks press
"I've got balls of Ceramic!"
Doesn't quite have the same ring to it.
Insane how much pressure ceramics can take
My Dad worked 37 years at Timken Roller Bearing he said they used the best chrome steel available, there are train bearings that have 10 million miles on them. 👍🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
Canton in the house!
@@detroitwhat4017 yessir , I guess Dad knew the ol Man himself Henry Timken , if we wouldn’t have sold out to Japanese steel in the late 70’s early 80’s, places like Canton would still be thriving, but I won’t start waving the flag.
You might try M42 for kicks if you want. It's a cobalt HSS like M35 but harder. I don't know that it's any stronger in terms of compressive strength. Both are used for high quality drill bits since they retain a hard edge at significantly high temperatures.
Надо сравнить М42 с русской Р18
The ceramic ball broke the steel press because the contact point of a sphere is infinitely sharp.
its not because of slight microbumps in both ceramic and press
but its still high
Russian steel is the best of all!
Goida
If im not blind i think i saw that the russian steel got crushed the least so ur right
The reason the ceramic ball soloed the steel is because unlike the press, all the pressure is being applied to one spot, while the press evenly applies the pressure due to the flat surface it had
For the first time the press is not lying.
I was really disappointed that the max pressure and the time under max pressure was noticeably different for every steel sample.
👍💯
I thought that HY 100 steel was the most difficult to work with. They tried to use it for the pressure hull of the Virginia class subs but it was too difficult to weld.
Both Seawolf and Virginia class submarines use Hy-100 steel
An anecdote for you: here in Russia we build submarine hulls out of titan alloys (apparently, we have plenty of it). In US they build SR71 Blackbird out of titan; we make filters for water, shovels and pots out of it, I've seen some myself. I guess, a titan paperweight is next. It would be funny if it weren't so sad.
@@Johnny_3_D ВСМПО-Ависма крупнейший производитель Титана в мире потому что, у них нет конкурентов
@@Saiga-saiga Видимо, по этой причине американцы делают из титана сверхскоростные самолёты-разведчики и прочую дефицитную лабуду, а мы - фильтры для воды, кастрюли и лопаты.
Virginia class solos every sub in the world 🇺🇲🦅
That tiny block can withstand 100 tons?!? Wth.
how did a ceramic ball break a hydraulic pressure???!!!! 😱
It's because of the shape
Bueno caballeros, si no vi mal, el metal que más resistió, fue el ruso ... 🤷
Viste bien.
Yo también lo vi
En efecto mi estimado.
Russia😎😎😎
Thank papa Stalin
"DONOT REPEAT AT HOME
THEN WHAT YOU SAW IN THIS VIDEO"
~Dang here goes my weekend plans
Why didn't you test the ceramic ball with the us steel?
It's a disappointing ending but I still enjoyed the video and appreciate your hard work!
Don't you by chance think that the main character of the vid is the US cube? XD
Just out of curiosity: how much did you pay for the cubes ? what is the average cost of a video like this ?
Me want to lnow
@Imontothem i want know too
@Imontothem About Tree Fiddy . . . (in Chef's Parent's voice.)
And the parts for the press.
I’ve never seen 40% of bender crushed so many times over
hi . what ?
Bender is 40% Titanium.
@@parkershaw8529 i dont think so
Can you show the entire press please? I’m curious to see how the base is flexing.
Here is a video from the main channel of the author, on the assembly of a hydraulic press: ua-cam.com/video/4BbG6or2fz4/v-deo.html
The video is in Russian language, but I think if you want to see how it looks like this is enough)
@@ЧижовАлександр-т7ж thanks
The quality of steel is a function of hardness and strength. Very hard steel is also brittle and will fracture easily. Steel that does not fracture is stronger. The type of steel you get depends on what is added to it.
So it depends on what exactly you plan to do with the steel, you adjust the specific qualities accordingly.
Russian product,... Is the best 👍👏👏👏
Based on what lol? This test shows that quality of all 3 steel pieces is pretty much the same
@@ampeg187 did you look carefully?
Germany: *laughing in the corner
Russian steel is trash
Kinds hard to draw our own conclusions of the results by eyesight on our screen. You could've used a micrometer to exactly measure for us the clear winner.
@Edward Elizabeth Hitler Well, the Chinese one was clearly (and unsurprisingly) inferior. US .vs Russian was much closer.
Russian was the winner . You can see that clearly .
Well to be fair the Russian piece only reached around 95 tons while the American one reached 100 tons. They both began to deform around the 90-95 ton marker though so measuring by deformation makes no sense because the loads weren’t equal.
yes that is also cane be a reason why is the American get bit more deformed than Russian . But you see that , what i had mentioned , there is a different between , and the USA piece has deformed more.
@@aidanatkinson7717 That's what I meant, give the russian a little more & it would've been more equal.
I Love Rusia 🇷🇺
You really shouldn t especially in this time
Слава Богу
ZOV💪🏻🇷🇺
I hate russia
The RUSSIAN STELL IS STALLIINNIIUMM, BEST OF THE BEST
not even close to the best, just do a quick google or look in this comment section and you will find better and harder steels.
Aussie.
Thanks for showing Iron vs. Steel. Shows how far materials tech has evolved in less than 150 years. Kinda scary.
150 years?
Why he didin't use the ceramic ball with de USA steel??
Broken equipment?
Second one's initials should have been HFS for Harbor Freight steel.
New element found: Russianium
Digging the subtle t2 inspired music in the background. Def fits the theme of crushing metals
I do wish that titanium alloy and tungsten carbide had been done as well, but interesting.
What is amazing that the RC 69 USA steel didn't shatter.
Probably 10$\cube
If three types of the strongest steels that are crushed are shown here, then what is the press piston made of?))
Thank you🌹
Russia is the strongest 🦾
The Russian steel sounds like the characteristic of Russian❤
mother russia 🇷🇺 🔥
F.ck Pidarassia
The music is giving it some major "Terminator" vibes. Pretty cool.
So satisfying to watch! The ceramic ball was awesome...
The symbolism in this video is strong 🔥
Don’t let the Chinese steel this competition! 🤣
? wdym
@@EisFunnyLetter it's a pun...
@@syrez156 yeah but i dont get how Chinese will steal/steel this comp
@@EisFunnyLetter china is notorious for copying/stealing technology. A good example is the J20.
@Joe wang "cry ab it"
1:24 pretty nice hardness level
69
Nice
That's what she said.
The background music reminds me of something related to the Terminator movies.
Steel is an alloy of many elements seen here. So when you mix these elements together you get an even stronger metal.
In Russia, you don’t press steel. Steel presses you.
High quality Russian goods
from tools perspective... it all depends on specific brands... I have never seen good Chinese steel tools.... good yes but not top of the shelf...the rest depends of the price.... cheap Chinese chisel may definitely outperform expensive west chisel in short term on price but not on quality or performance
That's what most Chinese manufacturers looks for though, they knew its hard to compete in high end products so instead they make high CP ratio low to mid tier stuff, but that's also why I buy Japanese tools instead, much more reliable in long term, last longer and lower chances of buying defective product, but for simple tools it doesn't really matter, and sometimes Chinese brands will have tailor made tools for very specific situation that you can't expect to find in other brands. On the other hand you can also look at products that uses imported materials, for a non-tool example, there is a workshop in China making coffee grinders that uses imported steel burr and do titanium surface coating themselves to further harden the burr, other parts of the grinder uses local materials and the result is a surprisingly good grinder at a relatively cheap price, it basically combines the best of both worlds.
Who would have thought a damn ceramic ball was that damn tough?!?!?
Haha that's the advantage of well made ceramics
The chill terminator music in the background was a nice touch. 👌
Would love to see your hydraulic press pressing another hydraulic press.
🇷🇺🤜🏻🇺🇦☠️
Russia metal produces the best metals
Hard is also more rigid.
Flexibility versus hardness is the key.
What material is thr press cylinder made of?
Bravo, another good video. I have used hss and M35 cutting tools for years. Not familiar with the Russian tool steel. What material are the bolster plated made from? Got to have very high pressure properties. Thank you for sharing.
There's even better alloy thats used in drill bits in Russia. Called P6M5K5 if I remember right. got cobalt in it. 5 is the % from overall mass of steel. P is steel with tungsten, M is molybdenum and K is K is cobalt. Drill bits made from this alloy are really hard.
@@srg.graphouni6628 Thank you for sharing. That's good to know.
I'm not understanding why you use three steels from three countries. Why not use the same type from all three? I dunno about Russia, but both China and the US make and use most HSS types for cheap steel cutting tools. Different types of HSS and different heat treatments will change hardness, wear resistance, shock resistance, etc.
In Russia, most people refer to "chinese" steel, a cheap one, as HSS, because it's written on crappy chinese tools. Technically M35, russian P6M5 or P4M2 and dozens (hundreds?) of others are all HSS, including crappy chinese or indian steel. Of course, China produces good tools out of good alloys too. It's a popular video so don't expect much. I work on a plant with people (METALworkers!) who thinks that "HSS" is a sort of a steel and don't understand what "high-speed steel" (even the russian equivalent "быстрорежущая сталь") means.
Russian steel for the win
On a quiet day you can hear it rusting.
@@AUmarcus but still tighter than all of them
My dumbass thought they were all gonna explode😂😂😂
Russia good love from indonesia..
Not sure why the country matters. Wouldn't its resistance just depend on the percentage carbon and other elements (Magnesium, Chromium, etc) that was used to create the steel, rather than where it was made? For what it's worth, the Russian cube seems to have retained its shape the best under this particular test. In a real world setting, there are obviously other desirable properties than just resistance to compressive stress.
Countries have different manufacturing processes.
@@elliotmyers9071 You mean different COMPANIES have different manufacturing processes? Even two batches of steel made by different manufacturers within the same country are bound to be different if their steel has different composition and quenching/annealing process.
Click bait.people are curious which one is the hardest
It looks to me that you barely touched 100 tons for Russian and USA cubes. So, I don't think this is a fair comparison.
Neither you listed the price of all three steels, but that is a different topic.
I Think the Russian and Chinese got more pressure than the USA.
🙄🙄🙄
😭🤣
But clearly Russian р6м5 standart is better than opponents both de jure and de facto.
@@ПетрВрангель-т8п
They are different standards, russia uses hss steel just in different applications
I’d have those sample size metals tested, I wouldn’t be surprised if they aren’t the metals they claim to be, not suggesting dishonesty on the UA-camrs part, but they’re all over eBay, and it wouldn’t be hard to falsify it, I’m surprised at how easily titanium and tungsten both crushed that easily and quickly
exactly, i was amazed to see tungsten being that plyable... it should be harder than HSS (keep in mind that concrete drill bits use tungsten tip with HSS body, so by theory, tungsten should be in top tier in hardeness)
@@GrulbGL What if drill bits use tungsten alloys, which are much stronger than elemental tungsten?
We all thought that chinesse piece was going to fail big time. Don`t we?
I like how such videos don't even roast china, like a lot of video say
"However, I have no faith of products that come from China"
Russia top 🔥👍
Hundreds of destroyed russian tanks think otherwise.
Russia is top, but people are poor LOLOLOLOLOL
@@tomasgogashvily5350 But we don’t have as many homeless people as in America, medicine is largely free, there are many more positive aspects that you are not told about
@@JustFP Ты рассказываешь парню из России о России? В США бомж подал бы в суд, в России можно убить бомжа и всем будет насрать. Особенно, если олигарх пустил тебе пулю в лицо, LOLOL. Тот факт, что вы можете позволить себе Интернет, да еще постить на "капиталистическом" свино-злобном сайте Американской Империи, шокирует не меньше.
I thought that titanium was better than steel, it turns out that a good steel could be even more resistant
It's a kind of alloy steel.
@@syrez156 nope, titanium is not as hard as steel, It is famous only because his density is 4.5 g\cm3 meanwhile steel is 7.5g\cm3
Just like steel, there are different grades of titanium.