Great interview. It’s such a relief to watch an interview with sensible questions. It shows the difference between print journalists vs “ you tube journalists”. For the UA-camrs, please think beyond the Ajith, Vijay, Lokesh Kanagaraj questions. The world does not revolve around them.
Great interactive section from Sudhir Srinivasan. It could've been more than 1 hour and I will still be listening to both of you conversing at ease with each other!
Great interview. Sila press meet la silly questions kettu Mani sir eh mood out panna maari irunthuchu. Avara open up aaga vechu super ah information vangirukeenga. Good job anchor
I don’t usually appreciate the interviewer but I just couldn’t not mention this. You are the most intelligent sensible interviewer in tamil media. Period. Keep it up. Don’t change anything. Your questions are very satisfactory.
Sudhir's probing questions & Maniratnam Sir's honest , intense answers make a great interview and a pleasure for the audience. Thank u 🙏. Salute Mr Maniratnam ... ARRahman included!❤
I really didn't realise this was 30 mins long. Wish it was longer.. But, looking forward to you and Mani sir discussing scene by scene from 1 and 2....PS I loved this interaction... You da besssst Sudhir Sir ❤
Sudhir u always set and maintain standards. when good minds meet makes me to feel , cha its only 30mins conversation !!! Good questions gets great reply's , Sudhir i expect more in ur next one with him soon . Try to get whats his next project !!! lol
A FANTastic and a most intelligent, interesting and informative interview and lesson on nearly all aspects of filmaking .Thank you to the Master and the Enquirer.
Please try to make the coversation at least one hour long after the release again with mani sir and your questions really matured enough and not like others which can be predictable what they will ask.Thanks for this conversation
Manimegalai ah pathi oru kelvi ketrukalam..... Antha character iruka ilaiyanu achu therunjurukum..... I think antha character iruka matanganu ninaikuren😢
Sir, fantastic interview.... I request you to have an interview with yaathisai director....(and also a late review for the movie....) Such a bold impressive layered movie
I don't know why people creating over Hype for maniratnam ??? மணிரத்தினம் படங்கள் எடுப்பதை நிறுத்தி விடலாம் என்று நினைக்கிறேன்...அவர் தொடர்ச்சியாக எடுத்த அனைத்து படங்களும் தோல்வியை சந்தித்தன..கடல், காற்று வெளியிடை,ஓ காதல் கண்மணி,செக்கச் சிவந்த வானம் இதில் எதுவுமே பேர் சொல்லும் அளவுக்கு ஓடவில்லை அதுபோல படங்களும் சரியில்லை..இந்த வரிசையில் இப்போது பொன்னியின் செல்வன் சேர்ந்து இருக்கிறது இதனால் இவர் எதுக்கு படங்கள் எடுக்க வேண்டும் என்று நான் நினைக்கிறேன்..இவர் இருக்கும் பேர் புகழ் மரியாதை உடன் அப்படியே இருந்து விடலாம்...எனவே இவர் படங்கள் எடுப்பதை நிறுத்தினால் நன்றாக இருக்கும்..
There are hundreds of talented directors in Tamil film industry. Maniratnam is not only outdated but also the most overrated director that made most failures in Tamil! See the way he took this masterpiece story into a repulsive trash! The Tamil social media hits him hard that PS2 already becomes a flop! Pitiful!
sudhir neenga pesaradhe puriyala neenga kekka vara vishayangalayum theliva present panna mudiyala. erichala varadhu. mani sir is very clear in his thoughts and expressing them to the viewers.
@13:28 Maniratnam romba amateurish ah war sequence eduthu vachitu, atha "realistic" solli muttu kudukuraru...old sivaji n mgr hit movies la vara sword fights PS1 fights ah vida romba nalla irukum...
Corona time la edukapatta movie..so many restrictions.. He already mentioned it.. Its not amateurish.. Namba yarum war lam paalthadhu ila.. Ur referencing another movies to do war scene like this.. This direction idea if interpretation.. He is not interested in grandeur or war scenes.. It about emotion within the wars..
@@saranraj2239 Maniratnam's idea to make a realistic war scenes rather than Bahubali kind of action scenes is good. But on the big screen it came very amateurish. In this interview, Maniratnam didn't mention COVID restrictions as any reason. He seems happy the way it came out on the big screen. And he is not taking people's criticism seriously 😑.
PS-1 was CHAOS at its best! Wrong cast, Zero emotional connection, bad choice of music director, too many characters: half of them having no sense of Thamizh and the other half are merely proud that they are cast in a branded director's movie, and they all did door-to-door canvassing like gaining election votes by hook or crook; there were funny promos too - all for the sake of making it a "hit" just to collect $$$ at the box-office! I could not "feel" for any of the character given their lukewarm performances! WHERE IS THE ART OF CINEMA? Climax was meh unlike a Baahubali-1 where at least people had curiosity in knowing why Kattappaa slayed Baahubali with B2 being even better. MR's post-1991 movies are pure expensive fluff with high aesthetics: fair-skinned good-looking cast, stylish costumes, lavish sets, good cinematography, frame composition, color palettes, song picturization, so-called "richness" and little-to-very little-to-no content that capitalizes on touch-and-go-base on (faux) patriotism or "actual" history (e.g.: Dil Se, Bombay, Roja, PS; Iruvar being cloyingly artificial). All these channels, anchors, critics and film trackers seem to be well-PAID to go gaga for a big nothing-burger.
Maniratnam over rated director. PS1 & PS2 not a good movie at all. for this high budget, it doesn't show in screen at all, art work seems so cheap, nothing left a real mark in the people who are watching. terrible story telling. they are just using stars to sell the movie and innocent people buying it. Watch Yaathisai to know what a good historical movie is. he did not even portray true history or greatness of Cholas
Please do your interview either in English or in Tamil, don’t use the interview to showcase your English acumen and proficiency…..this anchor is irritating!
எடுக்குறது தமிழன் வரலாறு படம் தமிழ் படம், ரெண்டு பேருக்கும் உருப்படியா தமிழ் தெரியும்...? ஆனால் உங்க வாய்களுக்கு தாண்டா தமிழ் பேசுறதுக்கு வலிக்குது 😡😡😡 இங்கிலிஷ்லேயே பேசணும்னா போய் ஹாலிவுட் ல படம் எடுங்கடா....
Great interview. It’s such a relief to watch an interview with sensible questions. It shows the difference between print journalists vs “ you tube journalists”. For the UA-camrs, please think beyond the Ajith, Vijay, Lokesh Kanagaraj questions. The world does not revolve around them.
Views apathana varum
Exactly, so annoyed by those questions.
I second that. Sudhir is different than others.
Exactly
1111
Great interactive section from Sudhir Srinivasan. It could've been more than 1 hour and I will still be listening to both of you conversing at ease with each other!
Mani Sir, you should show the deleted scenes of PS 1
and PS2 in small screen or OTT, so that we can see those scenes also.
Mani sir , is a semma positive person... 2k kids will find their way out of too much internet..
We cannot go back to the old age nor change it..
Mani sir is so mature man.
When two people with brains speak it'll be like this.Frankness of Mani Sir is the most appealing thing.
Simply an intellectual exchange of ideas. The anchor is simply brilliant!! Mani as usual is a legend!!
Such a beautiful interview ❤ sensible questions and genuine answers.. Loved the interview Sudhir 😇
High quality interview with the film maker . So grateful for the intelligent questions . 🙏
Ps1,2 movies is lift audience maturity.
Favorite mani sir 😍💞💞
Great interview. Sila press meet la silly questions kettu Mani sir eh mood out panna maari irunthuchu. Avara open up aaga vechu super ah information vangirukeenga. Good job anchor
I don’t usually appreciate the interviewer but I just couldn’t not mention this. You are the most intelligent sensible interviewer in tamil media. Period. Keep it up. Don’t change anything. Your questions are very satisfactory.
Colours that are chosen, have a story to tell...amazing😊
Fantastic questions, Sudhir. Love the style and approach.
Sudhir's probing questions & Maniratnam Sir's honest , intense answers make a great interview and a pleasure for the audience. Thank u 🙏. Salute Mr Maniratnam ... ARRahman included!❤
The King Raja Raja History sonah nala irukkum - PS3 wairing
As usual, great interview!
Thankyou for interviewing in Tamil 😭👍
Sudhir srinivasan is a beauty❤, his skill of inteviewing is what makes him vimarsagar thilakam.
Mani Sir Ur Matured interview Make Me as A fan of ps🎉❤
Love you, Mani sir. Love your Tamil, Mr Srinivasan. Hats off
Very nice interaction😊
Such an intelligent interview
I really didn't realise this was 30 mins long. Wish it was longer.. But, looking forward to you and Mani sir discussing scene by scene from 1 and 2....PS I loved this interaction... You da besssst Sudhir Sir ❤
It is as good as your previous one….so far the best interview..
Mani sir expressing more here, he is more comfortable answering questions here compare to cringy behindwoods.
Thank you for this lovely interview 🙂☺️😊
Atlast an urupadiyana interview with sensible questions
Mudhalvan Raghuvaran style la sollanum’na… “That was a good interview !!”
Amazing interview.. Thanks Sudhir.
A mind that works only for cinema he needs to be celebrated like speilberg and nolan
Sudhir u always set and maintain standards. when good minds meet makes me to feel , cha its only 30mins conversation !!! Good questions gets great reply's , Sudhir i expect more in ur next one with him soon . Try to get whats his next project !!! lol
A FANTastic and a most intelligent, interesting and informative interview and lesson on nearly all aspects of filmaking
.Thank you to the Master and the Enquirer.
Sudhir Srinivasan GIO cinema IPL commentary is good too
Great questions Sudheer , u being urself great one
Thamizh was so colloquial ❤
Please try to make the coversation at least one hour long after the release again with mani sir and your questions really matured enough and not like others which can be predictable what they will ask.Thanks for this conversation
Ok First prize interview
Eagerly waiting for PS2 🔥😊 in Dubai 😊❤❤
Sensible from mani- His reality understanding is good - green mat
Manimegalai ah pathi oru kelvi ketrukalam..... Antha character iruka ilaiyanu achu therunjurukum..... I think antha character iruka matanganu ninaikuren😢
A director like MR shouldn't have quoted the Mysogynistic Lovetoday as an example 🥺
Sir, fantastic interview....
I request you to have an interview with yaathisai director....(and also a late review for the movie....)
Such a bold impressive layered movie
I had a nice time watching this Interview :)
I don't know why people creating over Hype for maniratnam ???
மணிரத்தினம் படங்கள் எடுப்பதை நிறுத்தி விடலாம் என்று நினைக்கிறேன்...அவர் தொடர்ச்சியாக எடுத்த அனைத்து படங்களும் தோல்வியை சந்தித்தன..கடல், காற்று வெளியிடை,ஓ காதல் கண்மணி,செக்கச் சிவந்த வானம் இதில் எதுவுமே பேர் சொல்லும் அளவுக்கு ஓடவில்லை அதுபோல படங்களும் சரியில்லை..இந்த வரிசையில் இப்போது பொன்னியின் செல்வன் சேர்ந்து இருக்கிறது இதனால் இவர் எதுக்கு படங்கள் எடுக்க வேண்டும் என்று நான் நினைக்கிறேன்..இவர் இருக்கும் பேர் புகழ் மரியாதை உடன் அப்படியே இருந்து விடலாம்...எனவே இவர் படங்கள் எடுப்பதை நிறுத்தினால் நன்றாக இருக்கும்..
An interview a class apart.
I hope they work on the sound quality in the future.
Marudhanayagam serndhu panni release pannividunga sir..
There are hundreds of talented directors in Tamil film industry. Maniratnam is not only outdated but also the most overrated director that made most failures in Tamil! See the way he took this masterpiece story into a repulsive trash! The Tamil social media hits him hard that PS2 already becomes a flop! Pitiful!
sudhir neenga pesaradhe puriyala neenga kekka vara vishayangalayum theliva present panna mudiyala. erichala varadhu. mani sir is very clear in his thoughts and expressing them to the viewers.
❤
@13:28 Maniratnam romba amateurish ah war sequence eduthu vachitu, atha "realistic" solli muttu kudukuraru...old sivaji n mgr hit movies la vara sword fights PS1 fights ah vida romba nalla irukum...
Corona time la edukapatta movie..so many restrictions.. He already mentioned it.. Its not amateurish.. Namba yarum war lam paalthadhu ila.. Ur referencing another movies to do war scene like this.. This direction idea if interpretation.. He is not interested in grandeur or war scenes.. It about emotion within the wars..
@@saranraj2239 Maniratnam's idea to make a realistic war scenes rather than Bahubali kind of action scenes is good. But on the big screen it came very amateurish. In this interview, Maniratnam didn't mention COVID restrictions as any reason. He seems happy the way it came out on the big screen. And he is not taking people's criticism seriously 😑.
Unmaiya oru war nadantha ipdithan irukkum... Over perfection irukathu.. Manirathnam great
@@heynanba3607 leave those idiots. don't reply them.
please put subtitles
Bahubali madhiri over the top elevation illa masala ilanu polamburavangaluku Director Maniratnam indha interview la theliva badhil solirkaru ❤
Questions are ordinary...but atleast mani sir opened up ..
One should have a selective status, range, and taste to like the Ponniyin selvan movie or novel.
I think that is subjective.
Guru 🫶🏼❤️🥹
👍
Interviewer is wearing a suit where as Maniratnam is wearing a simple neatly ironed shirt ;)
PS-1 was CHAOS at its best! Wrong cast, Zero emotional connection, bad choice of music director, too many characters: half of them having no sense of Thamizh and the other half are merely proud that they are cast in a branded director's movie, and they all did door-to-door canvassing like gaining election votes by hook or crook; there were funny promos too - all for the sake of making it a "hit" just to collect $$$ at the box-office! I could not "feel" for any of the character given their lukewarm performances! WHERE IS THE ART OF CINEMA? Climax was meh unlike a Baahubali-1 where at least people had curiosity in knowing why Kattappaa slayed Baahubali with B2 being even better. MR's post-1991 movies are pure expensive fluff with high aesthetics: fair-skinned good-looking cast, stylish costumes, lavish sets, good cinematography, frame composition, color palettes, song picturization, so-called "richness" and little-to-very little-to-no content that capitalizes on touch-and-go-base on (faux) patriotism or "actual" history (e.g.: Dil Se, Bombay, Roja, PS; Iruvar being cloyingly artificial). All these channels, anchors, critics and film trackers seem to be well-PAID to go gaga for a big nothing-burger.
mani tamil thana aprom tamil la pesavendiyathuthana why engilsh interview
Not just an interview includes paid promotion
The only question this pineapple hasn't asked is Vijay oda eppa padam panna poringa.
After 2000 maniratnam films all are flop movies
# Ponniyin Selvan. Novel and this movie had deliberately achieved showcasing fake history and culture among Tamils. 👎😤
generic and boring questions
Maniratnam over rated director. PS1 & PS2 not a good movie at all. for this high budget, it doesn't show in screen at all, art work seems so cheap, nothing left a real mark in the people who are watching. terrible story telling. they are just using stars to sell the movie and innocent people buying it. Watch Yaathisai to know what a good historical movie is. he did not even portray true history or greatness of Cholas
AR Rahman music not suitable for this movie.
Please do your interview either in English or in Tamil, don’t use the interview to showcase your English acumen and proficiency…..this anchor is irritating!
எடுக்குறது தமிழன் வரலாறு
படம் தமிழ் படம், ரெண்டு பேருக்கும் உருப்படியா தமிழ் தெரியும்...?
ஆனால் உங்க வாய்களுக்கு தாண்டா தமிழ் பேசுறதுக்கு வலிக்குது 😡😡😡
இங்கிலிஷ்லேயே பேசணும்னா போய் ஹாலிவுட் ல படம் எடுங்கடா....