The Beatles - Sgt. Pepper Vinyl LP Review And Comparison What Version Is The Best
Вставка
- Опубліковано 12 вер 2024
- I do a review of the best sounding copy's of The Beatles - Sgt Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band. What are the copy's you should own?
Get a 'In' Groove T-Shirt
www.ebay.com/it...
Check us out Online
www.theingroove...
The 2017 stereo Giles Martin mix sounds great to me
Yeah that's my go to stereo vinyl to me. I really love it.
Leave Giles Martin Out Of The Mix
Awful. Its a ‘remix’
@@mrjamescurry and? Are 4k remasters of a film from the 60s awful as well? Or is it simply impossible to fathom that like 99 percent of everything, we have found ways to make it better in 60 years?
@@mikechivy Its an interesting angle but flawed I think. With film you are effecivley cleaning it up for todays standards using tools to remove any noise and sharpen image. Effectively this would be like remastering a completed audio mix if we switched the analogy to audio. The Giles Martin mix uses Digital technology to pick apart flattened audio and then remix it. its unecessary in my opinion - BUT if it give the band a new audience then, in today moden pop dross; that can only be a good thing.
I love these in depth pressing reviews.
Strange how we all have a different perception on sound. Just to add my opinion on this thread, I absolutely love the new remix, it's the Pepper I've been waiting years for😊
Good reviews, keep up the good work.
I love the new Miles Martin stereo mix.
But I have to ask have you heard the other versions? I mean if you like it then that's great because it's very affordable...
The 50th is the best sounding stereo copy IMO, the album needed a proper stereo mix, the stereo that George Martin did in 67 sounded incomplete IMO.
But still the mono kicks ass
Totally agree. I don’t have a true original stereo pressing - I have an original UK mono and the 2017 remix - but have heard pbthal’s needledrop of the Sydney HiFi LP. It’s by far the best stereo version I’ve heard, TONS of bass!
Yeah the 2017 blows my socks off. I've had difficulty finding an affordable old mono copy
pickoffking A VG++ sounding mono copy goes for about the same as a sealed mint 2014 mono. Sound quality wise, the 2014 LPs are definitive, but maybe best seeking out the whole box set. Do the math and you’ll see it’s probably worth saving up for the whole set instead of purchasing just one.
i have the og stereo and mono on parlaphone both in NM, i also have 2014 mono,,, the 2017 to me is good but its different,, when your used to playing the uk stero for 40 years its tough to say whiuch one is better ,,, i like them both the voices and the shimmer of the drums and guitars arent there on the 2017 and the bass seems to be jacked up on the 2017,, but sometimes that is a good thing,,, i guess it depends on the mood your in,,, but i agree with this guy on the og capitol Us pressings of pepper they all suck and are unlistenable
@@spittindatruthaboutrecords9421 the Vinyl of the 2017 one, don't own one but someone told that it's better on vinyl
This comment is for those who are newer to this sort of thing…
It’s important to remember that this video is entirely subjective. I’m not saying he’s right or wrong. He’s very knowledgeable and informative. However not everyone has this guy’s equipment, or his particular room acoustics, and how he listens to this album, and any album in general, is not how another may listen. We all listen differently as we are all tuned a bit differently. This is why most of us don’t own identical equipment and/or brands. We all tend to differ.
Keep that in mind.
Toss in the fact that everyone is using their own preferred turntable & turntable cartridges and what you have left is an opinion that carries very limited weight. This applies to everyone, myself included. You and you alone are always the best judge.
As for this particular album…
I own the 2017 stereo version of Sgt. Peppers’s and it sounds outstanding on my kit. I’m very happy with it. I’m not one to own multiple pressings and/or mono versions of albums. My go-to is stereo.
But that’s just me.
The description should include a time-stamped list of each record mentioned, along with more details like the year since you didn’t mention all of them.
I can start it:
00:54 UK mono original
01:13 US mono first pressing
01:26 UK stereo original
Idc what he says, I LOVE the 2017 Remix of Sgt Pepper!!! It is easily the best stereo mix of the album, and the most bang for your buck!! But the Mono versions kick ass too! Lol
One mistake in your video: the 2012 stereo IS NOT remixed, but it is digitally sourced.
The EU pressings are cleaner than the US Rainbo. Still, not cut from tape. Not as compressed as the 2009 cd, in fact it's not compressed at all.
My favorite that you did not mention is the German Apple (ca 1973) cut from tape,
it's the most "un-futzed with, straight off the tape" sounding Pepper of the 23-25 diff pressings I have heard (including the UHQR).
You are correct, sir. This man wins a cookie!!!
Thom Osburn sir, could you clarify, on Discogs I cannot find any German Apple 1973 releases, only Odeon. 🤷🏻♂️
@@vanyaechoes second this. Please help @thom osburn. Also, do you happen to know the exact release he mention at 3:35 mark, brand new mono pressing? Thanks a bunch!
"One mistake"?? There's quite a few mistakes in this video.
dave idmarx yes, very boring video. Why doesn’t he rename the video-come buy these crappy overpriced reissues from me!
The mono box set is the reference version of most if not all the Beatles albums. That's if you ok with mono. Since most of us are so used to the stereo versions, the mono might not appeal to everyone. There is more detail in the mono, no channel panning or reprocessed stereo. One example is Baby Your A Rich Man. Paul's bass roll off in the intro is unreal, sounds amazing. I'm sorry I didn't stockpile the mono box sets. In the years to come it will be the most sought after Beatles collection and no one expected that from a reissue set from 2009 to be the reference set. It sure beats buying heavily played original pressings that are way way overpriced.
Great overview of my favourite album of all time! I have 2 vinyl versions, the 2014 mono as part of the mono boxset, and Giles 2017 (single disc album only) remix. I like to swap between the 2 as each bring their own benefits to me. The clarity on some of the remix is fantastic but agree the bass can be boomy in places. A little too much compression on the end of A Day In The Life takes away some of the impact of the final piano chord, but the clarity of, for example, the start of Lovely Rita, is great to hear.
But yeah, the mono kicks ass! :-)
Cool to hear an opinion from someone who is so familiar with this album
I have a 1967 pressing of the album on stereo and a Capitol label and it sounds great
Just discovered your channel and am enjoying it immensely. I'm not an audiophile but I've been buying records since the days of Elvis, Ricky Nelson, The Everly Brothers, Sam Cooke....etc. And with the resurgence of vinyl, I've once again begun to buy vinyl records. One album I've purchased recently which I think is really terrific is Ryan Adams' new release, "Prisoner." Would be interested to hear your take on it.
I just paid a little over 250 bucks for a sealed copy of the 2014 mono release. I saw one go for about 230 on ebay. So I would say this is about what to expect and what these are going for now.
Agreed.. In mono. It's stunning. In fact i play it 4 times a day when i can.. Mono, stereo, stereo left speaker, stereo right speaker. It's a well-spent day.
You don't have to seek out a black and yellow parlophone to get a first pressing of pepper. Early 70's sgt's use the same cuts (and sometimes a good re-cut) My copy is a 73' and it's really good for me!
I would love to hear your best versions of any Pink Floyd LP's! Great work and I am enjoying your videos very much,
Israel -red harvest, black harvest, CBS Quad..HTM mastered/dead wax
I bought the UHQR version back in 1982 and stopped there.. i believe I played it only three times.. wonderful version...
I agree ! New one, all over the place. Bass is distractingly loud on a few songs. Some parts jump out far too much in the mix.
the best way to hear pepper...is still the 67 uk mono pressing....and then is german stereo pressing....
Great review, Mike! How about a recommendation for Revolver?
Get your hands on a UK or Australian mono. Outstanding.
-1/-2 mono U.K. Revolver , Danish Parlophone for the stereo
I would suggest to wait for remixed stereo version. It is on its way, I believe. As for mono, there are a lot of flaws which sounds weird nowadays. Listen to `Taxman` and `I want to tell you` in mono to understand what I mean. As a whole mono catalogue sounds not bad, but there are a lot of differnces between different editions and you will never understand what is good and what is bad for you.
Correct The Beatles intended Sgt Pepper to be listened to in mono in the days when stereo was regarded as a gimmick - i loved the idea of stereo and waited years before i could afford a stereo system and leave mono far behind, saying that early albums in 1967 sounded very bright to be played on the record players of the day but were recut and remastered to suit the technology evolving over time until today where they needed a lot of work to sound suited to modern playback systems, though really reviews like this should be entitled "which pressing sounds the best on my system to my taste".
The recent 2017 stereo press is fantastic in my opinion. Question: have you done a review of the recent 2 lp editions of Jimmy Page mixed Zeppelin releases on vinyl?
What about the one with the apple on the label produced in England by George Martin?
I did review, a - b comparison, my mofi UHQR copy to my nimbus supercut copy and for what its worth both sound really good and pretty close. But if I had to pick one it would be the mofi UHQR over the nimbus supercut. To my ears and thru my system both had great bass however the mofi upper frequency's sounded a little more warmer. Still very clear but warmer.
Haha, my mum has a first press Australian mono pressing on the original black and gold Parlaphone label. Pretty much did what you said people "didn't" do. It was hardly played and mint. She never liked it. But she was never a big Beatles fan, she preferred the Stones.
Sadly it was lost in 2000 when our house was sold and we moved. I loved "Beatles For Sale" as a kid, but Pepper was a bit weird for my 3 year old self. I remember listening to it when I was about 13 and liking it. Damn I wish mum still had those records. I was going to buy a mono re-issue just recently and discovered the thing is now $299 or so. Wish I knew about it earlier. Damn scalpers, piss me off. I will buy Beatles For Sale, wish it had the Aus cover here. With and For Sale had unique covers, mum had original mono With The Beatles as well and a bunch of EPs. I always preferred early Beatles, probably because that is what I know from when I was a kidvin the 80's.
Original US version sounded fine by me.....
and it didn't have the inner groove at the end of the album. I much prefer the silence after the long chord ending.
I'd like to buy the mono re-issue you are mentioning. How do i know i am getting the right one? Are you referring to the 2009 release? Can I buy one from you?
The Beatles in mono was reissued on CD in boxset form in 2009 (The same year they did the stereo remasters) They did Mono vinyl reissues in 2014 which are supposedly great, now out of print and expensive. I remember when they were released and am kicking myself for not buying at least a few of them.
Foreal, why didnt he just say the year lol
I've got the original UK mono pressing but must admit I have never liked mono. Same with my copy of Rubber Soul. I just love the separation of stereo even if it wasn't the 'intended' way to listen.
I have to assume that the referenced current release mono (from 2014) is the same version found in The Beatles In Mono vinyl box from 2014, cut from the mono tapes, correct?
Yes.
Jonathan Blackhall yes 200$ now😧
Do you have any extra copies
My favorite was the inner groove. Creepy.
Arfan Eka Diandra
Supremely creepy for 50.
Very informative! Would love to see an episode featuring Dark Side of the Moon or the White Album
Dark Side is coming soon.
@@TheInGroove *1 year ago*
The 'In' Groove where is dark side
To add, Syd Barrett and John Lennon dropping acid at points through this recording and Floyd's Piper sessions, who were next door at the time. Would be nice to get some film.
You forgot to mention the 1982 Japanese red vinyl mono release. They released all their albums that year in a box set on red vinyl in mono. They sounds superb! These were on the Odeon label.
Indeed they do.
Yes, they're great, as well as the 1986 re-release of the red vinyl mono records as well.
Which CD copy sounds the best (for shits and giggles sake) Dont be a snob
Which CD copy sounds the best (for shits and giggles sake) Dont be a snob
@@davidkornblatt851get the 1987 CD version.. It's pretty much a flat transfer from the original tapes and sounds way better than the recent version.
Thanks so much for giving an overview of the "Sgt Pepper" album pressings through the years! I never knew all of that... now I have some knowledge to use in my quest for the best-sounding versions of whatever I'm seeking.
Nimbus and German Apple from 70’s excellent Stereo copies to get 🍏
The Australian mono originals and early re-issues are as good as the UK version. People forget that Australia used original UK mothers to make their record stampers. And they pressed far less copies so the quality remained quite strong. And the Australian LPs go for far less that the UK counterparts.
I love your no bullshit reviews man!
Those are some amazing vu meters, I'm so jealous of your setup.
Agree with you 100%. Ive had many copies of that album, and I only held onto my 1st pressing Parlophone stereo, but the new 2014 mono copy is hands down the best. In fact, the entire Beatles mono box set is all probably the best sounding pressings. Great review.
And what about 2009 mono CD version?
bombardier
This is about what vinyl LP is best, not what CD. I’m not saying that to sound like a jerk either. lol 🎶✌️🔊
@@NickP333 In your opinion, are there any significant differences in headphone listening between the mono 2009 and 2014?
bombardier
Hi there. I unfortunately don’t ever listen with headphones. Also, the 2009 set was only released digitally on CD, which I very rarely listen to, so I can’t really say anything or give any kind of opinion. There’s plenty of forums and websites regarding the subject though. Good luck! 🎶✌️🔊
Gret Stuff mike. Killer review very honest and straight forward. we need more videos like this. thanks
Glad you liked it!
Thanks for reassuring my suspicions about Capitol Beatles pressings 😉. I've just ordered a copy of the original UK Parlophone mono pressing on Discogs for under 30€, apparently in "very good" shape according to the site. I hope it'll be worth it. Ever since I first heard the original mono mix of Sgt. Pepper's I was totally sold on 60's mono. It was a complete ear opener to me. The prices for the mono reissues were just too Utopian for my budget though. After all, I only want to buy a record, not a new car.
I have the first US stereo pressing, a 1976 pressing, the 2012 pressing and the 50th anniversary pressing. I really want the mono and stereo UK first pressings
i have a us original with the "capitol rainbow" label. its not noisy and the dynamics are fantastic.
Love your videos and the attention you give to all of the versions. Thankbyou
How about Dark Side Of The Moon?
Israeli Red Harvest
Could you do more videos like these? I would like to hear your opinions about the other Beatles vinyl. Thank you!
favorite mono version - 1st uk pressing
favorite stereo version - 1984 nimbus supercut
Great video as always. I'll stick with the new reissue as, 1) us youngsters don't have a lot of money to spend on vinyl, 2) I like the Beatles, but not as much as some other people, so I'll leave the mono for them to grab.
you are amazing, i never knew any of this stuff, and i am 51 and have been collecting since 1979
Brilliant review, no technical Jargon, funny and straight forward.
Well done!
Did I miss the orange label Capitol? I loved it regardless of the sound. Bought it used on the 20th Anniversary in 1987 when I was 12.
The album came out in 1967. Don’t you mean the 20th anniversary?
@@King_Colombia_Inc Haha Yes 20th...what can I say?! I'm getting up there!
Since the release of 090909 I am still quite happy with my mono box and love it for all the pros and cons. Unfortunately, listening carefully with headphones and conducting comparative studies, I find more and more flaws. Although the packaging is beautiful, what, of course, is important, the 090909 sound obviously is not for audiophiles as it was advertised. Overall, the 090909 edition is far from the best. Let`s face it at last. How to get on with that? Easily. The best stereo for early albums can be found in US Capitol boxes 2004-2006 and UK stereo 1987 cd box (later albums). The best mono for early albums can be found in UK stereo 1987 cd box and EP cd 1992 box. Pepper, White Album, Revolver, Rubber Soul from 090909 mono box ain`t bad too. However, If I could buy newly made remixes in cheaper editions instead, I would ignore it altogether and saved some money.
The main reason I don’t regret buying a mono box is that I collect mini vinyl CDs. If not for this circumstance, it would be best to just download everything you need in mono and buy a new stereo. I don't think the remixed albums are perfect, they have a lot of absurdities and illogicals, but if you need to stop at something, this is the way.
I disagree. The Giles Martin stereo mix is my favorite.
It is good I agree.
I agree with exception to Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds. That song was stylistically changed, and I think it sounds weird
Could you also review the different Revolver-pressings by the Beatles? That would be great!
Thanks a lot and best regards from Germany. I do appreciate your channel very much. Wish I'd had an equal recordstore in my hometown.
The Nimbus is the one to have if you necessarily want a stereo... Lennon said the Mono is the one to have.
Thanks for your informed opinions on these different pressing and versions. I was just able to finally purchase the 2 LP Anniversary Edition of Sgt. Pepper for a real decent price. The record store owner I purchased it from said they were imported from Canada. Not familiar with Canadian pressings. QUESTIONS? Any good in your opinion? Maybe better than the 2014 Stereo Remasters? It'll take me a few days to get it.
"All beatles capital pressing sound like shit" I would love to see you do a blind test.
*Capitol*
do you see the equipment he has? I bet he could spot differences with those beautiful Mcintosh's
they sound great with a crappy setup
Great review. Glad I have the recent Mono box.I suggest a review of Steely Dan's Aja.
I have an original 1967 mono Australian copy of Sgt Pepper on Parlophone (black & yellow label). It was cut using the original UK first pressing mono -1/-1 masters....and sounds fantastic.
this was a lot of help thanks so much!
I have a '78 UK stereo which is very nice
Un disco igual de legendario como mi poderosa maquina cementera del cruz azul 👌😎
I know someone that has the Australian half speed and has reviewed it to many other versions. Surprisingly it is one of the best versions to get, but good luck trying to find one. EXTREMELY RARE.
Hey Mike
Thank you for the very good and informative videos about the pressings you do.
At 3:36 you refer about the brand new pressing in mono
Which one it is?
Is it made in europe or us?
I can’t find it on discogs
Is it a 2017 press?
Good Day I'm in the market for a mono version of Sergeant Pepper's preferably on parlophone. Originals will cost me so I'm going for a reissue. You mentioned 2012 mono German version, I will take that into consideration. What I'd like to know is what's your take on a 2014 parlophone mono version that's the one that I am currently eyeing up?
Did you ever hear the Japan Red Vinyl Mono? ~Peace
I must say I agree with most of what you said. I also have the reissue from the mono box set which is outstanding!! from the sleeve to the vinyl itself outstanding!! and I also have the original pressed in I think July or June 1967 that is incredible but the new mono I mentioned is better. Here is where I disagree with you.
The new stereo by Giles Martin and cut by miles Showell is genius. I think the placing of the instrumentation is exactly the way it should be.
I just watched this 6 y.o video. What "brand new" mono is it that is so great? 2014 probably wouldn't be considered brand new in 2017. Can you or someone elaborate please? I have the 2014 mono box set so I am hoping you are referring the SPLHCB in that set. I also have a stereo German issue mid-70's that is great. I was hoping you were going to mention that too!
What years was the mono German reissue?
2014
@@TheInGroove Is this it? www.discogs.com/The-Beatles-Sgt-Peppers-Lonely-Hearts-Club-Band/release/6075023
Great video with lots of amazing info. Does the 2017 50th anniversary edition was pressed in the USA or Germany?
After watching turntable reviews I don't want to turntable after watching speaker reviews I don't want to get speakers and after watching vinyl reviews I don't want to get a vinyl record.
I was in the car accident 1997 I was driving at night I hit a deer while listening to Ziggy stardust I have been able to listen to music since I'm trying to listen to music now. I started by watching flips on UA-cam and then Amazon prime music has really good full albums without being chopped up.
Great job, man... Thanks! I'll go for 2014 mono reissues, they have very good reputation. I'll go for stereo only in that records that were never released in mono...
I agree with you on all but one thing.... The mono mix pretty much sucks. It sounds like it was put together with spit and bubble gum. It has zero dimension and is dull sounding. The stereo version is an experience. That mix, in my opinion defines psychedelic!
How about a doing a video on the John Lennon Plastic Ono Band LP variations?
I should of bought a 2014 mono back when they were easy and cheap to get, now all the 2014 Mono pressings are selling for over $200
Mike, again you are right on the money with your rankings.
Wow,you must be a SUPER Serious audiophile.and i like the album you are talking about.
Love what looks like the MC 1200 Is that right
Not true in saying that every Beatles record released by Capitol sounds like garbage. For the 1983 (retro-rainbow label) and 1988 analogue (pre-1967 US albums on the purple Capitol label) pressings, Capitol switched to a much quieter vinyl and the result is records that sound excellent. Granted, on albums like The Beatles' Second Album, the mixes still suck, but for The White Album, Abbey Road, Hey Jude, Revolver and Sgt. Pepper (most on the '83 rainbow label), they sound excellent, but they're all stereo only. If you're craving mono, most of the '83 rainbow pressings of Beatles VI and Yesterday And Today were pressed using the mono mixes by mistake. They both sound amazing.
Records made from 3rd-5th generation masters and sometimes doctored in the mastering. ( Echo Ect. ) even with quieter vinyl are no match for the better versions of this record. It's been done to death who wants the 27th best sounding pressing?
good to know, I'm looking at them on reverb lp now
So you stockpiled the new mono pressings, you say? No wonder I haven't been able to find any copies. Thanks for being that guy everyone hates!
What's the name of the German company that pressed the 2014 mono record? I know I've heard it mentioned but I can't remember it.
Hi Mike
Great review, thank you.
When you say the latest mono is that 2013 or is there a 2017 mono?
Regards Brett
Mike do you think the MFSL Beatles box set lps are better than the old Parlophone EMI stereo black label ?
Hi Mike thank you for some great reviews. Regarding Sgt Peppers I bought a stereo GN records (2016 reissue) in a shop here in Australia. GN Records aka the Gold Note Record Label from Italy. Have you ever heard of GN? On Discogs it says the release was blocked from sale in the marketplace? Seems strange because I bought this new from a real shop its limited edition 500 copies from the original master tape mastered by Flavio Lenzi. Any help would be very much appreciated.
I have only ever listened to Sgt Peppers on a capitol stereo copy (late 60s/early 70s probably) and the 2017 stereo. Let me tell you that was a night and day difference.
I'm sure the mono sounds great. Sadly, I can't seem to find a copy anywhere (even digitally) to listen.
Best record reviewer on UA-cam, hands down! Many thanks for your sage advice.
“The Beatles thought Stereo was a ‘Gimmick.’”
Every song today is in stereo. 🤣
"The Beatles thought Stereo was a 'Gimmick.'. Source?
They didn’t actively participate in stereo remixes until the White Album.
From Help to the MMT EP, they actively participated in the mono remixes only.
A. Rael Mantilla most of the songs from the last years are mono because people only listen to them on a bluetooth box they dont mix stereo
No. Actually, most new songs are a mostly mono with some stereo mix. Usually the core parts of a song (lead vocal, drums [snare/kick] and bass [though often a bit stronger on one channel than the other to give an off centre positioning]) are on both channels, with percussion, synthesizers, horns, etc split up.
Looks like the Beatles knew what they were talking about after all. lol
I just purchased a 1967 Parlophone mono Germany export version. Did I make a bad decision?
I have an Australian first press (Black and Silver label), and it sounds amazing. Not in the best shape, but somehow found it in a Savers for cheap, and uses the UK plates
I have an Australian (Orange and black label) in stereo and sounds amazing also.I'm not sure if it's a first pressing but I bought it either in 69' or 70.It might not be ?
I think you owe yourself a listen to the Quality Records Press of this release then update after you hear it. I have both USA/UK and after doing an A/B, the QRP has low end that is simply not on the UK press. Weird since the plates are both from Abbey Road, but I swear its not me being a flag waving American. Love your reviews and the gear in the background. KEEP EM' COMING!!!
I have and will do an updated video in the future.
I bought the mono at the release date in 1967. Unfortunatly a few years later I was broke and had to sell most of my albums, including all my Parlophone Beatles, for a few pounds. I have been slowly replacing them as funds allow, but I could only afford the sterio copy of Pepper.
Please do more. Best pressing reviews ive seen.
The 2014 mono is definitely not $23 more like $200 plus
Thanks for this video, grabbed a UK, '76 RE in Stereo. I wouldn't even know where to start, so thanks!
Great video. Any idea where to buy a copy of the NEW Sgt. Pepper's MONO ?? Thanks
the 2014 reissues are a lot harder and expensive to find now. It'd be a lot easier/cheaper to find an original in vg+ shape than lay down something like $200 for the newer one.
Would like a similar rundown of White Album pressings. Where do you stand on the 2018 remix ? Seems to be generally liked as an alternate experience to a good UK original. Not quite as drastic a departure as Sgt Pepper's stereo remix.
do you have any vids comparing all the box sets thru the years
Dude you did not spend enough on your media center/stereo system lol 😂
I know. I'm looking into upgrading.
Uh you're joking right
The 'In' Groove McIntosh equipment has a very colored sound.
McIntosh, too colored..he probably is wanting to upgrade.
I was being Very Sarcastic. Ive listened to Sgt Pepper in any number of ways and REVOLVER IS THE BEST
I prefer the sound of the model version to me it sounds the best I have US and UK versions and yeah I think you’re right the UK does sound better
Saying any Beatles production is "garbage" is a disgrace.