One other word I ought to have mentioned in the section about words related to "rune" is Finnish "runo," apparently derived directly from the Proto-Germanic word, except that in Finnish it means "poem" (note that each of the individual constituent poems/stories of the Kalevala is called a "runo"). Finnish isn't related to the Germanic languages, but it has borrowed words from them at every stage of their development, including Proto-Germanic. Anyway, this meaning adds one more wrinkle to the surprisingly complex picture of what this word might have originally meant.
As a Swede it's funny when I see a Finnish text, with tons of Swedish words but with an i or an o at the end. Sometimes with an extra vowel stuck in there.
Rún means secret in Irish. Also as I'm watching this video, I just keep thinking of Ron saying to Hermione "Ancient Runes? Just how many classes are you taking?"
I'm Danish. I named my son Rune, because I've learned, that it meant secret (not a lot of men in my life until I met my husband). I've always thought the secret came from the fact, that only few could actually read what the runes meant. They were meant for the few - and therefore had a sense of mystery about them.
Amazing video, as always! You mentioned Rune being related to something like the swedish Ränna, meaning to drive. Ränna also means furrow or cut or groove. I find the idea funny that they might simply have called these furrows from cutting them into stone.
Runes are just as associated with magic, as the Roman alphabet it is ~ meaning, under almost every doorsill in the Roman Empire you would find a small rolled-up piece of lead or copper foil with a spell to ward the home against evil. Indeed, sometimes those same rolled-up pieces of foil have been found with curses, tugged into a crevice near the home of someone a Roman sought to cause misfortune. That it, it's the WORDS that are magical ~ NOT the individual characters of the alphabet.
I'm fascinated by the idea of writing being an almost magical secret to the masses in a world where most people were illiterate. The idea of writing being a metaphorical whisper is also intriguing.
Fascinating video, my Old English course at uni only touched this subject only very briefly so I am grateful for you covering it completely free of charge! A huge shoutout to the Patreon supporters who enable Dr. Crawford to share his knowledge publicly!
Doc I know you're not a Heathen yourself but your work helps those of us trying to be historically accurate in our faith practice as closely as we can and I can't thank you enough. I feel it in my gut that you are good people and I wish you the very best in life.
The whispers/secrets correlation makes sense given that the Old/Proto Norse societies would have been semi-literate. So you would only know what was said if you had been taught to read.
Hi, I've been learning Old Norse and everything you've talked about for over 4 years now. Is there any other way than patreon to support you? You're a star made of gold and we need more people like you! Thanks for all you're doing to spread the knowledge!
@Marion L. Click on the 'Thanks' or the heart icon with a $ symbol. Usually it lets me set the amount to donate. This one had a fixed $1 donation, which I've never seen before. Maybe just check another video of his.
Thank you. This is interesting. As a Norwegian we learn about the runic alphabet in school. I was taught about them, and now my teens have been taught as well. I can't say I know them, because I can't write the Futhark just based on memory, but in most generations of Norwegians alive today, there will be someone who have used runes as a secret code language :) Myself included!
I remember when I was on a pagan bulletin board on the web back in the Nineties, people were outraged when I claimed that the main purpose of runes is writing, and that everything else (i.e. the magic stuff) is gravy. They thought I meant the use of runes in magic was bunk, whereas I meant it was a rare and secondary use, like modern pagans writing their magic spells in the Latin alphabet. I was surprised at how many people got angry at what I considered an entirely reasonable statement.
If I was to guess about the meaning of rune it would be memory. One reason is that it's more or less the modern Swedish meaning of the word - in memorial. The more logical one is that it's what you always do when you write something down. Unless the writing is destroyed it will remain readable long after you are dead and gone.
In Latvian language we have a word "runa", which means "speech" and "to speak" - "runāt". These words sound very similar to the Old Norse "rúnar" and have a similar meaning - they are related to speech, talking.
I appreciate your presentation. Thank you . I look at the evolution of writing from the “mystical” perspective of, what is a word? It begins as a spark of inspiration, presumably due to some stimulus. It manifests as a thought, which births another…. The thought is expressed in a word, which also begets offspring. Who knows all the echoing whispers? Writing was the way to remove the corrupted loyalty relying on messenger memories…as long as literacy segregated the classes.
Great work! As a swede learning this it is a huge help. When I hear "ek erilaz" it says "I the jarl". To me it fits, the strong and learned man wrote what few can read.
As someone with no academic background - indeed, I'm not even a college graduate - these videos have been invaluable to my personal studies and deep interest in this and related subjects. The Patreon is a pittance for the knowledge gained.
I appreciate the time you take to make these available to everyone. You've helped me understand more about Norse Mythology then I ever thought possible. Please don't stop posting 💜
Until your intro in this video I had no idea that Runes were associated with magic in the public mind, or rather any more so than magic is associated with Classical Latin or Koine. There are ample extant magical incantations and curse tablets in these languages of course, but I don’t have the impression that anyone sees these two Mediterranean languages as anything to do with mysticism. Very interesting.
Can't wait for the following videos about this topic! Just one short note about Frisian. It was spoken along the north sea coast of Belgium, the netherlands and Germany. Or as it is often called, between the Zwin (Bruges) and the Weser(Bremen).
When odin hangs himself to obtain the runes, and given the context of the rest of havamal, i cant help but feel that Odin hanged himself to obtain the advise (and or magic) he gives in the other sections
Thanks so much for this. I am so pleased that you are producing a sensible overview of the runes based on the most up to date evidence and research with no speculation about magic. Nice hat too!
I am sincere in my question here: Is that "speculation about magic" really so wide-spread or deeply ingrained? I mean, among at least semi-intelligent people? As much as I enjoyed this video, I felt that the protestations almost seemed to validate the (utterly absurd) "magic" connection. If I served my guests a big pot of stew, I wouldn't say, "Nope, no witch's brew here! Uh-uh, didn't use a bit of eye of newt or toe of frog!" I sort of found the emphasis on it a bit off-putting.
@@pricklypear7516 As a linguist, you are almost always forced to do long preludes and put down some common understandings when you communicate to the broader public. What can be frequently encountered are some unhelpful derailments via esoteric/nationalist/hyperspritualists who think that a chart on Pinterest has educated them definitely than those """dirty biased""" (sic) academics
I appreciate this series, Jackson.The same politics apply in other disciplines like literature, and some topics are "off topic" for "true" academics (whomever they are, really). As an academic locked out of rune studies since that's not my field, I truly appreciate the time and attention you are taking professionally to provide content. While I do read runes daily for divination on social media, I try to be clear that this usage of them is modern and not necessarily historical since no evidence suggests they were used for anything more than an alphabet. I also think that divination tools, as they stand, can be made of anything since they are intended to bring the user meaning. So, if a stack of bananas is meaningul to a user, that can be a divination tool. But just because it's a tool for one person doesn't mean it's a tool for another. In any case, I love the series, and I am eager to learn more about each rune :).
Nice intro to runes. Looking forward to the next part. To me, the possibility that the word "rune" came from or is associated with council is plausible. Look at the etymology of our word "thing", which originally meant meeting, assembly, council. Over the years the meaning changed, so it now means an item. Language makes for a fascinating study.
You're so awesome Dr. Crawford! This is everything I hoped education can and should be, accessible and affordable or free to the public. Thank you (and other academics that I follow in this space) for sharing your knowledge to counteract all the mystical rune bunk out there. I will definitely be following this course!
Hmmm! It's hard to resist imagining a connection between the word rune and the modern Irish words: Rún = secret, beloved person (noun) Rúnda = secret (adjective) Rúnaí = secretary But I believe the only alphabets ever used to write in Irish were Ogham and the Roman (or Latin).
Fascinating stuff mr. Jackson, runes are fascinating, you were able to sum up very well to the point that I as a complete novice to languages was able to understand clearly, great work and keep it up!!
Being of the more "magical" mind when I was first introduced to the Elder Futhark 30 years ago, I have since come to realize that words didn't just happen, we pick the sounds we put together to represent the thing we talk about, or the idea we are trying to transmit. Written language is much younger than spoken, and spoken took a long time to formalize everywhere, so the original "magic" is in the sounds a language makes, then later in the shapes they pick to represent those sounds. The letters represent these sounds, thus hold "magic". Even the names of each letter hold a vibration.
I also find it interesting how in the Phoenician letters that all later European writing systems come from, has the first letter representing a bovine creature as well. In their case, it represented a glottal stop that most European languages don't typically have. 'Aleph, where the apostrophe represents the glottal stop. Turn the A upside down and you can clearly see the animal head with horns rising up. When the Greeks borrowed the writing system, since they didn't have a glottal stop in their language, they used the first letter to represent the first vowel that comes after the initial glottal stop in the word 'Aleph, in other words "A". But it's interesting to me that even though an F sounds nothing like an A, the symbol of the cow needing to be first in the row was so important that the first letter was changed from a letter representing an A sound, to one that represented the first sound of the word that DID mean cow in their language, F for Feoh.
So I was thinking, because of what you said about the text saying "xx wrote him a runa" and thought about the fact that most runestones, at least around where I live, is what we today also,refers to as a "runa" which I believe in English is called an obituary. Amazing that the word survived untouched until this day when everything else has changed so much that I can't even understand most of my own language from, say the 1400s. I am Swedish by the way. I know Norwegians have always been known for protecting their language more, whereas we often traditionally just adopt words from other languages and let them replace the old ones.
Thank you for sharing your knowledge - I'm looking forward to getting through all of your videos. I've been studying runes since 2015, when I was first introduced to them.
I know this is off current topic, but I came across something interesting. Have you seen the hand of Irulegi? A brass shaped hand found in Northern Spain from what they believe came from Basgue language. I see ruin inscription letters of T, O, H and some not recognized. I think you should take a look at it. It's a bronze artifact shaped like a life size hand.
Native Hindi and English speaker, now studying runes, and more generally PIE because I know a bunch of other PIE languages (Russian, Spanish, Dutch) at very basic level, so this is a very good first candidate for a family tree to learn. More later!
A cool note on "Mysterion" from that NT translation. As a Catholic Priest we use the word "Mystery" to refer to our Sacraments. You can interchange those words. Why, and related to your "Runes are an alphabet and not spells", because they have both a visible and an invisible dimension (we believe). But that is true for writing. the visible dimensions are of course the seen script and the invisible is the meaning. thanks for this playlist. looking forward to the rest (Found your channel via the Battlenof Maldon discussion)
More book recommendations? There goes this week's grocery money again! To paraphrase Erasmus: When I have a little money, I support Dr. Crawford on Patreon and I buy books; and if I have any left, I buy food and clothes. But I do thank you for another wonderful video and for sharing your knowledge.
It is hard to listen to the education and read the pop-up info at the same time but I guess most people will watch it a second time anyway so they don't miss things.
BUT DUDE. How interesting is the genetics and the “continuation” more or less for us non-phd certified noobies. Of old Norse in the Icelandic language. I’m stoked that I’ve found your quality videos. Alright I’ll shut up now. And enjoy this
Runo- is also attested in Gaulish in the personal name "Comrunos" meaning "confider". Xavier Delamarre, in his Dictionnaire de la langue gauloise, claims runo- to be a common root word to Celtic and Germanic languages meaning "secret".
Absolute scholar thank you for your time in making this. You sir, have had an effect on this world that I am sure you have no IDEA about. Would you mind if I use this video on my channel please?
Thank you for making these videos. I have been craving a real explanation non "Hollywood, and Magic" talk about the languages and culture around Rune and Scandanavia.
Rune, Runar (male) and Runa (female) are also used as given names in Norway, obviously related to the runes. Great video, I will follow the series with interest :-)
Slavic languages have words for "sheepskin with fleece" sounding very similar to "rune" (e.g. "runo" in Polish or "руно" in Russian). As sheepskin was used to make parchments, letters on such a writing material could symbolically represent sheep hair. The very same word was also used for "small plants in the forest" (like the Polish "runo lésne") whose stems and shoots could remind of letters too. Perhaps these words as well as "rune" go back to some mysterious Indo-European one...
Hi Jackson, Great, thank you very much! Although I only check in from time to time (that will change 😄), I appreciate your channel very much. Good work! Greetings from Germany, Markus
0:42 omg!!! I just … the only thing that would have made this intro (shout out to that little text box at the top there) would have been if you denounced higher academics and said you have simply studied much of your life and we can be the judge and do the research ourselves (as all should) . Then at the end or your next video just deftly dropped in your crazy long list of systemic proof. Basically. What I am saying is this is cool. You are cool. And I agree, people want to know but are afraid to try or that whole ego fueled fear of being “blamed” for taking any stance, claim or shared idea.
Brooooooo. WHAT A BANGER PHD. Ur a Legend dude. I subscribed. I Think its fascinating that you’re so knowledge about this subject. And I agree, that there is a lot of interest, but also that there is little quality content.
Brilliant as always. You have my thanks for sharing your knowledge with us in such an objective way. I've watched many of your videos and continue to learn so much about these ancient languages. BTW the setting for this video is breath-taking!
Hi. Really enjoy your videos! Just a thought, I thought you might like the artist Adrian von Ziegler’s music. My favorite album (if I was forced to choose) is For The Pack. Have a good summer!
Great video. I like your Videos and espacially your "dialect" of speaking norse words. According to magic i have following argument: in Germany in many old Houses that are build with heavy oak beams you often find beams in the attic that have the shape of the rune Othala. This rune means - according to my humble knowledge - house/protection. Maybe ancient people put "magic" into these runes because they believed in their power. So they "loaded" them magically by giving them this prominent meaning. Just an idea and my two cent. Nevertheless, i am talking of vegvisir times and you take us on a yourney like 1400 years back into history.
One other word I ought to have mentioned in the section about words related to "rune" is Finnish "runo," apparently derived directly from the Proto-Germanic word, except that in Finnish it means "poem" (note that each of the individual constituent poems/stories of the Kalevala is called a "runo"). Finnish isn't related to the Germanic languages, but it has borrowed words from them at every stage of their development, including Proto-Germanic. Anyway, this meaning adds one more wrinkle to the surprisingly complex picture of what this word might have originally meant.
As a Swede it's funny when I see a Finnish text, with tons of Swedish words but with an i or an o at the end. Sometimes with an extra vowel stuck in there.
Rún means secret in Irish.
Also as I'm watching this video, I just keep thinking of Ron saying to Hermione "Ancient Runes? Just how many classes are you taking?"
I'm Danish. I named my son Rune, because I've learned, that it meant secret (not a lot of men in my life until I met my husband). I've always thought the secret came from the fact, that only few could actually read what the runes meant. They were meant for the few - and therefore had a sense of mystery about them.
Amazing video, as always!
You mentioned Rune being related to something like the swedish Ränna, meaning to drive. Ränna also means furrow or cut or groove. I find the idea funny that they might simply have called these furrows from cutting them into stone.
Perhaps the meaning of “poem” came from a sharing of Germanic poetry
Runes are just as associated with magic, as the Roman alphabet it is ~ meaning, under almost every doorsill in the Roman Empire you would find a small rolled-up piece of lead or copper foil with a spell to ward the home against evil. Indeed, sometimes those same rolled-up pieces of foil have been found with curses, tugged into a crevice near the home of someone a Roman sought to cause misfortune.
That it, it's the WORDS that are magical ~ NOT the individual characters of the alphabet.
I'm fascinated by the idea of writing being an almost magical secret to the masses in a world where most people were illiterate. The idea of writing being a metaphorical whisper is also intriguing.
Fascinating video, my Old English course at uni only touched this subject only very briefly so I am grateful for you covering it completely free of charge! A huge shoutout to the Patreon supporters who enable Dr. Crawford to share his knowledge publicly!
Doc I know you're not a Heathen yourself but your work helps those of us trying to be historically accurate in our faith practice as closely as we can and I can't thank you enough. I feel it in my gut that you are good people and I wish you the very best in life.
I'm glad you cover these concepts in depth, and make your knowledge available to the public.
The whispers/secrets correlation makes sense given that the Old/Proto Norse societies would have been semi-literate. So you would only know what was said if you had been taught to read.
What a generous offering. Thanks Doc!
Hi,
I've been learning Old Norse and everything you've talked about for over 4 years now. Is there any other way than patreon to support you?
You're a star made of gold and we need more people like you! Thanks for all you're doing to spread the knowledge!
@Marion L. Click on the 'Thanks' or the heart icon with a $ symbol. Usually it lets me set the amount to donate. This one had a fixed $1 donation, which I've never seen before. Maybe just check another video of his.
Thank you Mr Crawford🙏
That's Doctor Mr. Crawford haha
@@Iwoodlikethat hey, just dont call him GURU and he wont mind
@@Iwoodlikethat I should have assumed that with his amazing resumé! Apologies Dr Crawford!
Thank you. This is interesting.
As a Norwegian we learn about the runic alphabet in school. I was taught about them, and now my teens have been taught as well.
I can't say I know them, because I can't write the Futhark just based on memory, but in most generations of Norwegians alive today, there will be someone who have used runes as a secret code language :) Myself included!
Thanks to very generous patreon supporters & Prof. Crawford for making free course available to Internauts.
So interesting to hear actually professional discussion about runes as an actual language. Thank you so much for sharing your knowledge and thoughts.
Actually, alphabet; system of writing, not a language.
I remember when I was on a pagan bulletin board on the web back in the Nineties, people were outraged when I claimed that the main purpose of runes is writing, and that everything else (i.e. the magic stuff) is gravy. They thought I meant the use of runes in magic was bunk, whereas I meant it was a rare and secondary use, like modern pagans writing their magic spells in the Latin alphabet. I was surprised at how many people got angry at what I considered an entirely reasonable statement.
As a swedish history teacher I very mutch like this! This notion that the runes are some sort of a Taro deck is very irriting… thanks doc!
If I was to guess about the meaning of rune it would be memory. One reason is that it's more or less the modern Swedish meaning of the word - in memorial. The more logical one is that it's what you always do when you write something down. Unless the writing is destroyed it will remain readable long after you are dead and gone.
In Latvian language we have a word "runa", which means "speech" and "to speak" - "runāt". These words sound very similar to the Old Norse "rúnar" and have a similar meaning - they are related to speech, talking.
I appreciate your presentation. Thank you .
I look at the evolution of writing from the “mystical” perspective of, what is a word?
It begins as a spark of inspiration, presumably due to some stimulus.
It manifests as a thought, which births another….
The thought is expressed in a word, which also begets offspring.
Who knows all the echoing whispers? Writing was the way to remove the corrupted loyalty relying on messenger memories…as long as literacy segregated the classes.
Great work! As a swede learning this it is a huge help. When I hear "ek erilaz" it says "I the jarl". To me it fits, the strong and learned man wrote what few can read.
I have no idea how you can film outdoors in the snow and have audio quality like your indoors. Impressive
I feel like there’s some kind of shielding mechanism around his microphone 🚫🌬️🎙️
Thanks Doc for offering this college level lecture on UA-cam! I really appreciate it and look forward to the next! :)
As someone with no academic background - indeed, I'm not even a college graduate - these videos have been invaluable to my personal studies and deep interest in this and related subjects. The Patreon is a pittance for the knowledge gained.
I appreciate the time you take to make these available to everyone. You've helped me understand more about Norse Mythology then I ever thought possible. Please don't stop posting 💜
Until your intro in this video I had no idea that Runes were associated with magic in the public mind, or rather any more so than magic is associated with Classical Latin or Koine. There are ample extant magical incantations and curse tablets in these languages of course, but I don’t have the impression that anyone sees these two Mediterranean languages as anything to do with mysticism. Very interesting.
I’m watching every moment of this series no doubt
Can't wait for the following videos about this topic! Just one short note about Frisian. It was spoken along the north sea coast of Belgium, the netherlands and Germany. Or as it is often called, between the Zwin (Bruges) and the Weser(Bremen).
As a Swede-Finn born in Canada; your channel & your books I’ve purchased have been great! Thanks so much!
I found your idea absolutely poetic and beautiful that letters are "language without sounds" like whispering in council! Good job👍
Thank you for sharing your knowledge with us! Even for someone who believes magic, I believe it's important to have a well rounded education.
Thanks!
And now, what we've all been waiting for... it drops, and it's fire! 🔥
When odin hangs himself to obtain the runes, and given the context of the rest of havamal, i cant help but feel that Odin hanged himself to obtain the advise (and or magic) he gives in the other sections
Thanks so much for this. I am so pleased that you are producing a sensible overview of the runes based on the most up to date evidence and research with no speculation about magic. Nice hat too!
I am sincere in my question here: Is that "speculation about magic" really so wide-spread or deeply ingrained? I mean, among at least semi-intelligent people? As much as I enjoyed this video, I felt that the protestations almost seemed to validate the (utterly absurd) "magic" connection. If I served my guests a big pot of stew, I wouldn't say, "Nope, no witch's brew here! Uh-uh, didn't use a bit of eye of newt or toe of frog!" I sort of found the emphasis on it a bit off-putting.
@@pricklypear7516 As a linguist, you are almost always forced to do long preludes and put down some common understandings when you communicate to the broader public.
What can be frequently encountered are some unhelpful derailments via esoteric/nationalist/hyperspritualists who think that a chart on Pinterest has educated them definitely than those """dirty biased""" (sic) academics
I appreciate this series, Jackson.The same politics apply in other disciplines like literature, and some topics are "off topic" for "true" academics (whomever they are, really). As an academic locked out of rune studies since that's not my field, I truly appreciate the time and attention you are taking professionally to provide content. While I do read runes daily for divination on social media, I try to be clear that this usage of them is modern and not necessarily historical since no evidence suggests they were used for anything more than an alphabet. I also think that divination tools, as they stand, can be made of anything since they are intended to bring the user meaning. So, if a stack of bananas is meaningul to a user, that can be a divination tool. But just because it's a tool for one person doesn't mean it's a tool for another. In any case, I love the series, and I am eager to learn more about each rune :).
Nice intro to runes. Looking forward to the next part.
To me, the possibility that the word "rune" came from or is associated with council is plausible. Look at the etymology of our word "thing", which originally meant meeting, assembly, council. Over the years the meaning changed, so it now means an item. Language makes for a fascinating study.
I just started my journey in Norse pagan and I have been told by many to check you out so here I am and Im positive that I'll enjoy your teachings
Thank you for the free course. Educating the public makes you a professor with or without an institutional affiliation.
You're so awesome Dr. Crawford! This is everything I hoped education can and should be, accessible and affordable or free to the public. Thank you (and other academics that I follow in this space) for sharing your knowledge to counteract all the mystical rune bunk out there. I will definitely be following this course!
Hmmm! It's hard to resist imagining a connection between the word rune and the modern Irish words:
Rún = secret, beloved person (noun)
Rúnda = secret (adjective)
Rúnaí = secretary
But I believe the only alphabets ever used to write in Irish were Ogham and the Roman (or Latin).
Thank you, Mr. Crawford!
Thanks
Thank you, Dr. Crawford. As an old Physical Anthropology major, I appreciate this course.
Thank you so much sir and best of days good sir
Thank u so much 🙌🙌🙏
Fascinating stuff mr. Jackson, runes are fascinating, you were able to sum up very well to the point that I as a complete novice to languages was able to understand clearly, great work and keep it up!!
Love it! Love the subject, the hat, all of it. Fantastic video! Looking forward to more. So happy to be a Patreon supporter
Thank you, very kind of you.
Being of the more "magical" mind when I was first introduced to the Elder Futhark 30 years ago, I have since come to realize that words didn't just happen, we pick the sounds we put together to represent the thing we talk about, or the idea we are trying to transmit. Written language is much younger than spoken, and spoken took a long time to formalize everywhere, so the original "magic" is in the sounds a language makes, then later in the shapes they pick to represent those sounds. The letters represent these sounds, thus hold "magic". Even the names of each letter hold a vibration.
I also find it interesting how in the Phoenician letters that all later European writing systems come from, has the first letter representing a bovine creature as well. In their case, it represented a glottal stop that most European languages don't typically have. 'Aleph, where the apostrophe represents the glottal stop. Turn the A upside down and you can clearly see the animal head with horns rising up. When the Greeks borrowed the writing system, since they didn't have a glottal stop in their language, they used the first letter to represent the first vowel that comes after the initial glottal stop in the word 'Aleph, in other words "A". But it's interesting to me that even though an F sounds nothing like an A, the symbol of the cow needing to be first in the row was so important that the first letter was changed from a letter representing an A sound, to one that represented the first sound of the word that DID mean cow in their language, F for Feoh.
Dr. Crawford does it again!
Perfect setting to teach something like this
I'm an Asian just spontaneously want to understand runes so now I'm here watching a man teaching in the snow. Tks
Really appreciate you sharing your wisdom 🤟
Thank you for this. My grandfather stowed away on a ship from Denmark, one of the last.
Outstanding content!
Love the hat sir! From Varusteleka I assume.
Thank you. I am forever your student sir.
I like the eagle that you have in the shoulder profesor
Thank you for providing this information and knowledge openly. May you r blessed in your dail living.
Im a DR crawford fan now ! Its like my 6th video in a row
So I was thinking, because of what you said about the text saying "xx wrote him a runa" and thought about the fact that most runestones, at least around where I live, is what we today also,refers to as a "runa" which I believe in English is called an obituary. Amazing that the word survived untouched until this day when everything else has changed so much that I can't even understand most of my own language from, say the 1400s. I am Swedish by the way. I know Norwegians have always been known for protecting their language more, whereas we often traditionally just adopt words from other languages and let them replace the old ones.
Thanks so much for sharing your counsel on The Mystery of the Runes!
Thanks, I need all the free education I can get. I wasn't exactly paying attention at school, so am making up for it with your help.
Fantastic resource, thank you for sharing your knowledge.
Thank you for your time and your generosity
Fascinating and really clearly explained. Thank you so much for sharing your knowledge and passion for ancient languages with us. :)
Excellent. Much needed.
Thank you for sharing your knowledge - I'm looking forward to getting through all of your videos. I've been studying runes since 2015, when I was first introduced to them.
I know this is off current topic, but I came across something interesting. Have you seen the hand of Irulegi? A brass shaped hand found in Northern Spain from what they believe came from Basgue language.
I see ruin inscription letters of T, O, H and some not recognized. I think you should take a look at it. It's a bronze artifact shaped like a life size hand.
Thanks Dr. Crawford. Looking forward to this course.
Native Hindi and English speaker, now studying runes, and more generally PIE because I know a bunch of other PIE languages (Russian, Spanish, Dutch) at very basic level, so this is a very good first candidate for a family tree to learn. More later!
A cool note on "Mysterion" from that NT translation. As a Catholic Priest we use the word "Mystery" to refer to our Sacraments. You can interchange those words. Why, and related to your "Runes are an alphabet and not spells", because they have both a visible and an invisible dimension (we believe). But that is true for writing. the visible dimensions are of course the seen script and the invisible is the meaning.
thanks for this playlist. looking forward to the rest (Found your channel via the Battlenof Maldon discussion)
More book recommendations? There goes this week's grocery money again! To paraphrase Erasmus:
When I have a little money, I support Dr. Crawford on Patreon and I buy books; and if I have any left, I buy food and clothes.
But I do thank you for another wonderful video and for sharing your knowledge.
Thank you for so much. Brasil
It is hard to listen to the education and read the pop-up info at the same time but I guess most people will watch it a second time anyway so they don't miss things.
Thank you for this wonderful video. First things first, JC. Watching in Texas.
Thank you ❤
BUT DUDE. How interesting is the genetics and the “continuation” more or less for us non-phd certified noobies. Of old Norse in the Icelandic language.
I’m stoked that I’ve found your quality videos. Alright I’ll shut up now. And enjoy this
Runo- is also attested in Gaulish in the personal name "Comrunos" meaning "confider". Xavier Delamarre, in his Dictionnaire de la langue gauloise, claims runo- to be a common root word to Celtic and Germanic languages meaning "secret".
Thanks for this series. Although the hackett publishing link was dead for me, I picked up all the works i could find listed under your name on amazon.
Thank you for the work you have and will put into this course. More please.
Absolute scholar thank you for your time in making this. You sir, have had an effect on this world that I am sure you have no IDEA about. Would you mind if I use this video on my channel please?
Thank you for making these videos. I have been craving a real explanation non "Hollywood, and Magic" talk about the languages and culture around Rune and Scandanavia.
Rune, Runar (male) and Runa (female) are also used as given names in Norway, obviously related to the runes. Great video, I will follow the series with interest :-)
Thank you so much!
Hey, I was at UGA at about the same time you would have been! I took a class in Linguistics, but I think that would have been before you were here.
Slavic languages have words for "sheepskin with fleece" sounding very similar to "rune" (e.g. "runo" in Polish or "руно" in Russian). As sheepskin was used to make parchments, letters on such a writing material could symbolically represent sheep hair.
The very same word was also used for "small plants in the forest" (like the Polish "runo lésne") whose stems and shoots could remind of letters too. Perhaps these words as well as "rune" go back to some mysterious Indo-European one...
Looking forward to this course!!
Great info! ❤
Nice hat 🤠🤠
OMG thank you so much for sharing this knowledge, really THANK YOU! 👏🏻🖤
Hi Jackson,
Great, thank you very much!
Although I only check in from time to time (that will change 😄), I appreciate your channel very much. Good work!
Greetings from Germany,
Markus
0:42 omg!!! I just … the only thing that would have made this intro (shout out to that little text box at the top there) would have been if you denounced higher academics and said you have simply studied much of your life and we can be the judge and do the research ourselves (as all should) . Then at the end or your next video just deftly dropped in your crazy long list of systemic proof.
Basically.
What I am saying is this is cool.
You are cool. And I agree, people want to know but are afraid to try or that whole ego fueled fear of being “blamed” for taking any stance, claim or shared idea.
Brooooooo. WHAT A BANGER PHD. Ur a Legend dude. I subscribed. I Think its fascinating that you’re so knowledge about this subject.
And I agree, that there is a lot of interest, but also that there is little quality content.
Brilliant as always. You have my thanks for sharing your knowledge with us in such an objective way. I've watched many of your videos and continue to learn so much about these ancient languages. BTW the setting for this video is breath-taking!
Thank you so much for sharing your knowledge!
LOVE The Hat!!!
Hi. Really enjoy your videos! Just a thought, I thought you might like the artist Adrian von Ziegler’s music. My favorite album (if I was forced to choose) is For The Pack.
Have a good summer!
Ty for this video, super informative.
Nice hat!
Great video. I like your Videos and espacially your "dialect" of speaking norse words. According to magic i have following argument: in Germany in many old Houses that are build with heavy oak beams you often find beams in the attic that have the shape of the rune Othala. This rune means - according to my humble knowledge - house/protection. Maybe ancient people put "magic" into these runes because they believed in their power. So they "loaded" them magically by giving them this prominent meaning. Just an idea and my two cent. Nevertheless, i am talking of vegvisir times and you take us on a yourney like 1400 years back into history.