They brought up three beautiful children and were a credit to Catherine who came from a very stable background. William appreciated this has been very fortunate to have such in-laws.
The Middletons represent what is good about family values. Love, encouragement, setting an example of working hard and creating your own success, support, friendship and passing on those values to children and grandchildren. They did a great job parenting and Catherine is a real asset to the Royal family. William has a good head on his shoulders and chose well knowing you don’t just marry the person, you marry the family. best wishes to all!
She is a real gem and wonderful grand mother and mother in law...you couldn't have a more gracefully woman and teacher, she taught her daughters and son well. Great mom💖
Trop d éloge pour rien sa fille n a pas bon cœur elle a malmené la femme d Henry on a comprit qu elle eloignait les copines d Henry pour préparer le terrain pour pippa
Carole has brought up 3 beautiful accomplished children and runs a successful business. She has class and elegance and is a huge support for her children and her Grandchildren. She gave William a haven to relax in and experience a normal family life too. Her husband is lovely too!
Sadly they are divorced. The msm does not publish this. Also James M. strikes me as unsavoury and immature. He is also bankrupt. Pippa had a restraining order placed on her by the Percy family. She was a stalker. I know nothing about Kate and so cannot comment.
@@gemmag.2988 Oh my goodness, bankruptcy, stalking behavior? Interesting to read, shocked, but, not surprised. However magazine companies here in America, don't really print narratives regarding Kate's family very often, other than to print 'positive' things about them. So I'm a bit 'taken back' by the information, however I don't like to knock people when they're down, so I wish you and Kate's family well. Happy Christmas
@@kimoakes1503 "The msm does not publish this" - this is the usual "proof and source" of such people. That the media do not write anything like that, because it is not true and for the dissemination of such information may threaten legal proceedings, it does not even occur to them.
@@hedaheda1609 it’s technically either Catherine, the Princess of Wales or just the Princess of Wales. Using her name without the “the” implies she’s divorced from William since “N, princess/duchess/countess of X” is the style for a divorce ex of a peer
That’s why Kate knows how to communicate and be a normal human. Because her mum and dad cared about them and worked hard. Carol is down to earth . God bless you all. 🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰love from Australia
@Elena Escócia Doria is a well-respected black woman who loves her daughter, and so there's no need to be hateful. Happy holidays to you. Remember, these are people whom you and I will never meet. Meghan or Kate...lol
Carole is a prime example of what it means to work hard, have dreams, be gracious & humble. She did a fine job raising the future Queen consort!! The Middleton family gives much comfort to William. He chose an exceptional woman, wife & mother of his children! I wish the Wales good health and a long & happy marriage! 🥰
Our Middleton family, are a beautiful family. They have raised three lovely children, and gone through issues, supporting their family. God bless you all.
No wonder Carol’s children all grew up knowing how to create a solid, happy family. A family of beautiful women too. Well done Carol, from humble beginnings to great success, yet you are a hard working, fabulous wife, mother and grandmother. All kudos to you.
Smart woman! She knows how to make things happen. This is why she enrolled her daughter in the same college as Prince William…and then when he changed his mind and went to St. Andrews, mom re-enrolled Catherine.
That's an admirable woman. She is smart and elegant and raised all her kids to be smart and elegant. Don't even try to imply otherwise. We need more Middletons in this world, less drama, more humble and truly classy.
Ce carol don't vous faites d éloges elle a poussé Kate à draguer William Carol poussait sa fille d être près de William juqu à la faire défiler nue qu'elle mama 'c est pas par amour que William l à épousé William souffre d avoir Kate comme épouse
What a beautiful woman! The whole family is great! Such beautiful people who love each other.William has found a beautiful queen for himself and for Great Britain.The whole world adores his family.Our beloved Princess Diana can be proud of such a son, daughter-in-law and grandchildren.
I think they have a wonderful life and a wonderful family. She had a perfect combination of family, home life and making her own money. She did a fabulous job raising her children and they in turn are doing the same.
Nothing wrong with being working class most of the population are,and are honest and honourable people,Catherine is elegant and displays a strong work ethic,ideal qualities for future Queen,May she get well soon and continue to flourish,She is remarkable in that she has her feet are firmly on the ground
To the royal family and not anyone outside of it … an older lady I worked with, her sister had dealings with them and expressed how William and Kate were lovely but Kate’s parents are absolute rotten stuck up snobs with terrible entitled energy
Don’t know much about the Middleton but princess Catherine was raised right from what I see. The Duchess of nutflix should have kept her as a friend and learned something! Shine on princess Catherine!
Carol is beautiful and very classy she is every bit a Royal member she is the mother of Princess Catherine and Michael Middleton pure class this family. I love the ❤Middletons and they are all gorgeous and Princess Catherine can stand tall coming from The Middletons like I said hard working and pure class
Very Beautiful and Blessful lady and family.very Blessful couple princess Kate mum Dad. Mrs William got very Beautiful and Blessful smile from her Beautiful and Blessful mum. nice one thanks for sharing Beautiful memories merry Christmas you all.😊🌲🍯🥄
Let's be real, both kate and meghan are social climbers. The difference is kate and her family know their places and work with the palace & they play their part - don't cause any trouble and shut the eff up and if any family members get too much beat them down or cut them off (the uncle, her sister's stunt, etc), birth heirs and look pretty. In return, the palace pump out positive stories, give them perks etc. I highly doubt some party favors can get highschool grad peasants into a stately home -they probably received some help to match the socioeconomic status of the inlaws of the future king of 🇬🇧. However, Meghan and her family failed it. I remember meghan was portrayed in a rather positive light in the beginning. They painted her to be a career girl with high education (Northwestern is indeed a very good uni in the US) who is outspoken about socio political issues - that was her mojo. Then Meghan did not only play accordingly w the institution, but she foolishly challenged it. Work for a big corporation, you will see the rise and fall of many kates and meghans alikes. Don't get me wrong, I've grown to like Kate a lot. Many of her items she used and worn, I've purchased. Hunting down designer goods and high streets goods and what not. She is a PR success case. I liked meghan until the oprah show. Then lost respect
@@anohacharlesschlosser9305 Oh my, Willem Alexander was quite handsome. The fact that he liked to have a little fun in his youth(Prince Pils 😂🍺) - so what? Frederik of Denmark behaved even more madly - and look now! And no one will tell me that William lived like a saint until he married Catherine.
@@hilaryjoseph9706 Germs...Yes... ...Chubby Brown says It and I have been to see him at the Sunderland Empire Theatre and he was Tres-Bon as the French say Boys and Germs...
Thank You for this report on Mother Middleton. William should be grateful to this family that Welcomed him into their Household. William KNOWS his in- laws. He knows his wife’s family background for generations Mother and Father. No Shenanigans, murky details verifiable reports. Unlike some others, smoke and Mirrors.
What a good mother to have brought up Kate as she did. Carole grew up in a council flat but she knew instinctively that good morals and grace have nothing to do with income, they're available to all.
PRINCESS OF WALES WAS BROUGHT UP AS ANY OTHER ORDINARY FAMILY. A WONDERFUL MUMMY. IT'S SEEMS SHE WAS DIVINELY PREPARED TO BE WILLIAM'S WIFE. I PRAY AND HOPE FOR THIER HAPPINESS . ' HAPPY KATHERINE '
Why do you think it is necessary to be an aristocrat to act and behave tactfully, politely and responsibly? That in non-aristocratic circles it is some exceptional rarity? Omg, society is really sick with classism.
It's humility & the fear of the Lord that raised them to this height today. May you all continue to serve the Lord, & be an encouragement to The Prince & Princess of Wales . l can't wait to see the 4th Royal baby. His protection & love will surrounds all of them as they seek God in their daily prayers. No evil will come upon them as they are ALL children of the promise. Take very good care of eachother. Happy Holidays always.
Mrs. Carole Middleton, Mother of Catherine Princess of Wales and Grandmother of Prince George, Princess Charlotte and Prince Louis. She has a thriving Business and the Middleton Fsmily has enjoyed a Upper Middle Class lifestyle. She's a beautiful Woman like daughter Princess Catherine, and along with her family, are always well dressed. ❤️ 💙🇬🇧
Does Carole Goldsmith Middleton celebrate Hanukah, being jewish. Her business went bankrupt by the way. Hoping the goldsmith-middleton family is not supported by british taxpayers money.
Brilliant mama middleton , who worked so well to marry her 2 daughters with wealthy men ! Kate very prepared from her chidhood to follow the future king of UK william ! Pippa to find also one wealthy man ! Success ! And these 2 women never work , just in search of men. Their parents have one simple job , a joke shop . But william had helped them to buy an important home , better then their former humble little one , and had helped them for their joke shop !
The truth is that carol goldsmith middleton is what is called in Hollywood a stage mother. Pushing her children to be social climbers. The middleton family knew that william was going to St Andrews and that is the reason they enlisted kate at same university That is the truth and nothing bitter about this
How do you feel about the Middleton family?
Class act and beautiful people!!!
Wonderful people….grace and kindness comes naturally….
Very Classy and Common for sure, not like MM.
They brought up three beautiful children and were a credit to Catherine who came from a very stable background. William appreciated this has been very fortunate to have such in-laws.
The Middletons represent what is good about family values. Love, encouragement, setting an example of working hard and creating your own success, support, friendship and passing on those values to children and grandchildren. They did a great job parenting and Catherine is a real asset to the Royal family. William has a good head on his shoulders and chose well knowing you don’t just marry the person, you marry the family. best wishes to all!
Love this, A positive societal Role Model….. is exactly what we need to hear and know about at this time…..♥️
She is a real gem and wonderful grand mother and mother in law...you couldn't have a more gracefully woman and teacher, she taught her daughters and son
well. Great mom💖
Trop d éloge pour rien sa fille n a pas bon cœur elle a malmené la femme d Henry on a comprit qu elle eloignait les copines d Henry pour préparer le terrain pour pippa
Carole has brought up 3 beautiful accomplished children and runs a successful business. She has class and elegance and is a huge support for her children and her Grandchildren. She gave William a haven to relax in and experience a normal family life too. Her husband is lovely too!
Sadly they are divorced. The msm does not publish this. Also James M. strikes me as unsavoury and immature. He is also bankrupt. Pippa had a restraining order placed on her by the Percy family. She was a stalker. I know nothing about Kate and so cannot comment.
@@gemmag.2988 Oh my goodness, bankruptcy, stalking behavior? Interesting to read, shocked, but, not surprised. However magazine companies here in America, don't really print narratives regarding Kate's family very often, other than to print 'positive' things about them. So I'm a bit 'taken back' by the information, however I don't like to knock people when they're down, so I wish you and Kate's family well. Happy Christmas
@@gemmag.2988 Where’s the proof???
@@gemmag.2988 And what proof do you have?
@@kimoakes1503 "The msm does not publish this" - this is the usual "proof and source" of such people. That the media do not write anything like that, because it is not true and for the dissemination of such information may threaten legal proceedings, it does not even occur to them.
This is why Princess Catherine is unpretentious and graceful. She is wonderfully comfortable when in public. Well Done Mum
it's not Princess Catherine
@@andypham1636 untwist your panties Fluffy😂
@@keithbraham6438 what
@@andypham1636 She is Catherine, Princess of Wales. But not a Princess by virtue of birth.
@@hedaheda1609 it’s technically either Catherine, the Princess of Wales or just the Princess of Wales. Using her name without the “the” implies she’s divorced from William since “N, princess/duchess/countess of X” is the style for a divorce ex of a peer
That’s why Kate knows how to communicate and be a normal human. Because her mum and dad cared about them and worked hard. Carol is down to earth . God bless you all. 🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰love from Australia
Just like Doria, Meghan's mom. Hard working and raised Meghan well!! Great video
@@theresaisaBIGBOSS What from jail? Dorito didn’t raise Megaliar her dad did.
@Elena Escócia Doria is a well-respected black woman who loves her daughter, and so there's no need to be hateful. Happy holidays to you. Remember, these are people whom you and I will never meet. Meghan or Kate...lol
@@LSG-108 Yes, that's her name. Meghan!
@@theresaisaBIGBOSS that's you brought the meghan who is constantly attacking kate.
So nice to see a positive role model who works for a living! Great parents 😊.
Carole is a prime example of what it means to work hard, have dreams, be gracious & humble. She did a fine job raising the future Queen consort!! The Middleton family gives much comfort to William. He chose an exceptional woman, wife & mother of his children! I wish the Wales good health and a long & happy marriage! 🥰
She raised polite respectful kind friendly smart children, just like herself and her husband...
She done very well down to earth mother
Pure class, congratulations Carole Middleton 💐💐💐
Our Middleton family, are a beautiful family. They have raised three lovely children, and gone through issues, supporting their family. God bless you all.
A story of "positive people" vs "negative people". There's a lesson in there.
Who cares if she's kate mother boaring
No wonder Carol’s children all grew up knowing how to create a solid, happy family. A family of beautiful women too. Well done Carol, from humble beginnings to great success, yet you are a hard working, fabulous wife, mother and grandmother. All kudos to you.
Wonderful role model. It shows in her kids too.
Fantastic woman I admire her so much.
Her hard work beneffited her whole family. Look where she started and where she ended up.
Such a lovely family, and thank the Lord Catherine joined the Royal family.
Smart woman! She knows how to make things happen. This is why she enrolled her daughter in the same college as Prince William…and then when he changed his mind and went to St. Andrews, mom re-enrolled Catherine.
That's an admirable woman. She is smart and elegant and raised all her kids to be smart and elegant. Don't even try to imply otherwise. We need more Middletons in this world, less drama, more humble and truly classy.
Ce carol don't vous faites d éloges elle a poussé Kate à draguer William Carol poussait sa fille d être près de William juqu à la faire défiler nue qu'elle mama 'c est pas par amour que William l à épousé William souffre d avoir Kate comme épouse
Great role model for her daughter. Success in her beautiful daughter.
their booth is very ugly look woman!
What a beautiful woman! The whole family is great! Such beautiful people who love each other.William has found a beautiful queen for himself and for Great Britain.The whole world adores his family.Our beloved Princess Diana can be proud of such a son, daughter-in-law and grandchildren.
I knew I liked the Middleton family for a reason...😍 Yay for Carol Middleton! Peace from Colorado, 🇺🇸...
Carole Middleton is my generation, and I have the same backgrund, but I had the chance to study. I really admire Carole, both brain and beauty.
A loving Mother, wife, grand mother.She talk with sense🌲🤩🌲
Carole is to be admired above all because she is a brilliant business person, beautiful lady and exudes class, which is something money can’t buy.
Total RESPECT, to the lady!
I think they have a wonderful life and a wonderful family. She had a perfect combination of family, home life and making her own money. She did a fabulous job raising her children and they in turn are doing the same.
Nothing wrong with being working class most of the population are,and are honest and honourable people,Catherine is elegant and displays a strong work ethic,ideal qualities for future Queen,May she get well soon and continue to flourish,She is remarkable in that she has her feet are firmly on the ground
Doesn`t matter where they grew up or how they earn a living - they have behaved with the utmost decorum and respect toward the Royal Family.
To the royal family and not anyone outside of it … an older lady I worked with, her sister had dealings with them and expressed how William and Kate were lovely but Kate’s parents are absolute rotten stuck up snobs with terrible entitled energy
This couple is great, they are inspiring.
Eine starke Familie. Die alles selbst erarbeitet hat.👍👍👍💚💛🧡❤
The Royal Family is lucky that Prince William has nice In-Laws!
Blessings ❤️ to Kate and her family 🙏
Outstanding parent for raising a child who end up to be the Princess of Wales
La mama di Princess of Wales e una grande signiora ,una mama che ha cresciuto tre figli meravigliosi ,una donna esemplare 🤗🌹❤🤗
I like them!
What a beautiful story
And her daughter can play the PIANO COMPETYENTLY! Absolutely Class.
A very respectful woman. She knows what hard work is and she knows how to appreciate and respect values.
❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉 FROM BALKAN !!!!!!!
If Michael and Carol Middleton will write a book on good parenthood, It certainly will be a worldwide success. ❤️👏👏👏
She is lovely
Beautiful family 👍
Don’t know much about the Middleton but princess Catherine was raised right from what I see. The Duchess of nutflix should have kept her as a friend and learned something! Shine on princess Catherine!
The Middletons may not be royal, but they are classy. educated, and kind. They are exemplary parents.
I know classy...just like Meghan's mom. Both classy moms.
@@theresaisaBIGBOSS 🙄
Carol is beautiful and very classy she is every bit a Royal member she is the mother of Princess Catherine and Michael Middleton pure class this family. I love the ❤Middletons and they are all gorgeous and Princess Catherine can stand tall coming from The Middletons like I said hard working and pure class
She's a Brit. She gets on with it. You are loved by so many! 💖 Happy Christmas to all! 💖
dignity, classy and grace. Role models for everyone who starts humble but want to become wealthy and successful
Catherine has a different shaped face to her mum, more like her dad, but she is still very much like her lovely mum too
I admire her. Great Lady
Carole is lovely and very classy. ❤️❤️
Very Beautiful and Blessful lady and family.very Blessful couple princess Kate mum Dad. Mrs William got very Beautiful and Blessful smile from her Beautiful and Blessful mum. nice one thanks for sharing Beautiful memories merry Christmas you all.😊🌲🍯🥄
Such a beautiful family.....🌷🍀🩷🇨🇵
I like the bit where she suddenly had three children 🙂
Carol is attractive and relateable. She is my age...I like her sense of style.
We Americans love your daughter Love New York
Let's be real, both kate and meghan are social climbers.
The difference is kate and her family know their places and work with the palace & they play their part - don't cause any trouble and shut the eff up and if any family members get too much beat them down or cut them off (the uncle, her sister's stunt, etc), birth heirs and look pretty. In return, the palace pump out positive stories, give them perks etc. I highly doubt some party favors can get highschool grad peasants into a stately home -they probably received some help to match the socioeconomic status of the inlaws of the future king of 🇬🇧.
However, Meghan and her family failed it. I remember meghan was portrayed in a rather positive light in the beginning. They painted her to be a career girl with high education (Northwestern is indeed a very good uni in the US) who is outspoken about socio political issues - that was her mojo. Then Meghan did not only play accordingly w the institution, but she foolishly challenged it.
Work for a big corporation, you will see the rise and fall of many kates and meghans alikes.
Don't get me wrong, I've grown to like Kate a lot. Many of her items she used and worn, I've purchased. Hunting down designer goods and high streets goods and what not. She is a PR success case. I liked meghan until the oprah show. Then lost respect
@@anohacharlesschlosser9305 Oh my, Willem Alexander was quite handsome. The fact that he liked to have a little fun in his youth(Prince Pils 😂🍺) - so what? Frederik of Denmark behaved even more madly - and look now! And no one will tell me that William lived like a saint until he married Catherine.
Bellissima identica alla sua Kate!
Tres-Bon as the French say Boys and Germs...
Germs?
@@hilaryjoseph9706 Germs...Yes...
...Chubby Brown says It and I have been to see him at the Sunderland Empire Theatre and he was Tres-Bon as the French say Boys and Germs...
@@IanEckert1977 I think that means "good soap"?
Soap?...
...Do you mean Eastenders and Coronation Street?...
Very wise to have Serena Scott Thomas play as her in the 2011 movie.
Thank You for this report on Mother Middleton.
William should be grateful to this family that Welcomed him into their Household. William KNOWS his in- laws. He knows his wife’s family background for generations Mother and Father. No Shenanigans, murky details verifiable reports. Unlike some others, smoke and
Mirrors.
Used her daughter to get into the royal family. Having said that I respect her hard work and improving her and her family's curcumstances.
What a good mother to have brought up Kate as she did. Carole grew up in a council flat but she knew instinctively that good morals and grace have nothing to do with income, they're available to all.
She's a classy lady.
Oh wow this explains some things 😮 😬
Super interesting!❤
💕💕💕💕💕
PRINCESS OF WALES WAS BROUGHT UP AS ANY OTHER ORDINARY FAMILY.
A WONDERFUL MUMMY.
IT'S SEEMS SHE WAS DIVINELY PREPARED TO BE WILLIAM'S WIFE.
I PRAY AND HOPE FOR THIER HAPPINESS .
' HAPPY KATHERINE '
A lovely family
Little Charlotte looks like her grandmother Carole ❤️
Carole has the best title...mother/grandmother
Is Carol related to Jemima Goldsmith?
Even if they are not aristocratic they defently don't bring shame on Catherine or total family. On the contrary, they look & act really classy. 👏
Why do you think it is necessary to be an aristocrat to act and behave tactfully, politely and responsibly? That in non-aristocratic circles it is some exceptional rarity? Omg, society is really sick with classism.
According to Catherines' mother surname ( Goldsmith ), Catherine is JEW from her mothers' side ?😮
Exactly - both carol's parents are jewish too
Love them.
To bad Harry couldn't find someone from a family like the Middletons.
He had such an opportunity, even twice, but he was unable to realize it in life.
It's humility & the fear of the Lord that raised them to this height today. May you all continue to serve the Lord, & be an encouragement to The Prince & Princess of Wales . l can't wait to see the 4th Royal baby. His protection & love will surrounds all of them as they seek God in their daily prayers. No evil will come upon them as they are ALL children of the promise. Take very good care of eachother. Happy Holidays always.
Carol…don’t stop working….you would drive your lovely husband nuts….😊
They have different shape of eyes, I mean Catherine and her mother. Catherine inherited fathers' eyes.
Unless you know her personally I doubt that you could answer that question correctly
Mrs. Carole Middleton, Mother of Catherine Princess of Wales and Grandmother of Prince George, Princess Charlotte and Prince Louis. She has a thriving Business and the Middleton Fsmily has enjoyed a Upper Middle Class lifestyle. She's a beautiful Woman like daughter Princess Catherine, and along with her family, are always well dressed. ❤️ 💙🇬🇧
It's a family with class.
HER NAME IS PRINCESS CATHERINE 🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧
She worked hard at business and family. Beautiful family. !!!
(she needs to cut her hair, its dragging her down) IMO
Short haircuts are out of fashion.
NOT KEROL . BUT CAROL .
Does Carole Goldsmith Middleton celebrate Hanukah, being jewish. Her business went bankrupt by the way. Hoping the goldsmith-middleton family is not supported by british taxpayers money.
I wish they would stop calling her a "mom", that is an american term NOT British
Brilliant mama middleton , who worked so well to marry her 2 daughters with wealthy men !
Kate very prepared from her chidhood to follow the future king of UK william !
Pippa to find also one wealthy man ! Success !
And these 2 women never work , just in search of men.
Their parents have one simple job , a joke shop .
But william had helped them to buy an important home , better then their former humble
little one , and had helped them for their joke shop !
How bitter.
Kamamoko what have u achieved in ur life
@@meenarajeshrajesh5697 meenkaka , that’s not your affair , live your mad life ...
So what. Nothing wrong with any of it. In fact, it's all a good thing.
The truth is that carol goldsmith middleton is what is called in Hollywood a stage mother. Pushing her children to be social climbers. The middleton family knew that william was going to St Andrews and that is the reason they enlisted kate at same university
That is the truth and nothing bitter about this
Looks like princess of Wales Cambridge
stalker
Just learned she's half Jewish
And? What would the problem be?
According to jewish tradition, if your mother is jewish, you are jewish.
She is very charmy💖💖💖
her name is NOT Kate Middleton. She is Princess Catherine of Wales.
👍👍👍