If you read the description, probably you would be able to guess why murshidabadi was picked for this song. They dropped this one on world music day conveying the message that music has no boundaries. From that perspective it makes sense that arnob picked a song from the other side of the border and a singer as well, and together it has been merged into a yet another masterpiece from CSB that conveys the message of harmony in diversity through co-existence.
im from rajshahi ( bangladesh ) . from my home i can see murshidabad ( indian district )..... opposite of padma river . even arijit singh home is there in murshidabad near bangladesh border ...there should not be border in indian subcontinent .... we are all same ....
Hammad and Haris - Guys, there is a lot to say for the work you are doing. Hard to really express in words but suffice to say that your reaction, analysis, commentary, whatever you want to call it, is the best around and it’s not even close. Sure, people enjoy the music but I’ve seen your growth from the earlier videos and I can only commend how you have taken the time to educate yourselves and learn more about these artists, genre, origins, etc. this makes your discussions so meaningful and thoughtful and, honestly, for most of us, educational in some ways. I also want to say, and this is for the music you do outside of coke studio, you guys do an amazing job. We all know and love coke studio (all countries, versions) but I have learned about some really good bangla music thanks to your coverage/discussions. Kind of crazy but it shows the impact and reach you guys have and are creating. Thank you for doing this. I am a big fan. Keep up the great work!
Lalon has perfected our Bengali language through his songs. He was born in a Hindu family. When he went on a pilgrimage on the orders of the zamindar of the area, he contracted smallpox. The people declared him dead and floated him in the river Ganga. And he came floating from India to Kushtia district of Bangladesh. When a Muslim woman saw him there, she took care of him and healed him After recovering, Lalon went to his house and told about his past. His neighbors accuse him of giving place to Muslims in their homes and taking food from Muslims, saying that "Lalon's caste is gone . Angered and saddened, Lalon left his family, religion and society and returned to Kushtia district of Bangladesh. When we listen to the songs, our souls still get excited.
This is more of a fiction than fact. Lalon was born in Bengal and supposedly East Bengal in Jhenaidah, Bangladesh. There are many fiction about Lalon and Sunil Gangopadhyay popularized this one. No one actually knows for sure what happenned. You watched it in a movie and took it for real.
it's fiction .. about his religion, none knows ..It is not known whether he was born in a Hindu or a Muslim family. Lalon had no formal education. One account relates that Lalon, during a pilgrimage to the temple of Jagannath with others of his native village, he contracted smallpox and was abandoned by his companions on the banks of the Kaliganga River, from where Malam Shah and his wife Matijan, members of the weaver community in a Muslim-populated village, Cheuriya, took him to their home to convalesce. They gave Lalon land to live where he founded a musical group and remained to compose and perform his songs, inspired by Siraj Sain, a musician of that village. Lalon lost sight in one of his eyes.Researchers note that Lalon was a close friend of Kangal Harinath, one of the contemporary social reformers and a disciple of Lalon. Lalon lived within the zamindari of the Tagores in Kushtia and had visited the Tagore family. It is said that zamindar Jyotirindranath Tagore sketched the only portrait of Lalon in 1889 in his houseboat on the river Padma. Lalon died at Chheuriya on 17 October 1890 at the age of 118. The news of his death was first published in the newspaper Gram Barta Prokashika, run by Kangal Harinath. Lalon was buried at the middle of his dwelling place known as his Akhra.
To his last breath of life, Fakir Lalon Shah (1774-1890) preached humanity over religion. He composed and sang thousands of songs on the concepts of humanity, the inner meaning of life, and finding the true God. Lalon thought that God keeps Himself hidden as the soul inside the human body. He was a true philosopher and left hundreds of thousands of baauls and followers.
Eagerly waiting for your talk. I assume Arnob had follwed u after "Bhober Pagol" behind the scene. And became sure after watching comment of him in your vedio. You are doing fantastic. Such a pleasure to see you talking about Bangla music as you are in love with Bangla music. Thank you both. Very eager to watch rejected vedios from youtube. Come quickly to FB.
Kabir Das? And I didn't know anything about this Saint? I'm gonna study him. Thanks, Coke Studio Bangla and specifically Arnob for introducing this Saint to Us. How beautiful is that?
Oh, by the way, I just found out that Arnob and Murshidabadi have a history of collaboration (checkout Yogi, from Murshidabadi Project). Somewhere Arnob commented that he always wanted to do a Kabir Das project. This is his project today.
Everyone ask Lalon (17th Century poet and philosopher of Bangla region); which caste or religion do you belong to? He ask them back - "how does a caste look? I was born without a caste". Kabir Das (14th Century poet of Uttar Pradesh) the other poet wrote water in different pot is still nothing but water. Key message is universal humanity without any form of man made discrimination.
Your reviews are the best. I have seen very few reaction videos go so deep into the discussion - lyrics, music, and all the nuances. Brilliant work guys!
Today is World Music Day. Music has the ability to transcend all differences and fascinate everyone in the same way. The explanations of that unity can be found in the writings of two mystic saints who lived hundreds of years and thousands of kilometers apart.
Fakir Lalon Shah is the main founder of Secular society in Bengal. Baul songs written by Lalan Fakir is famous among whole Bengal. Rabindranath Tagore was inspire by Lalan Fakir. His Jamindari area Lalan lived. You have to study this great philosopher again and again. Lalan don’t believe cast / jat/religious system. He had written a lot of songs in this topics.
You know what I love about you guys? I have been listening to these songs for 30+ years, so the "fusion" feels jarring on first listen. For example, it's hard to stomach the urban serenity of saxophone with a Lalon song that is so iconoclastic. You guys give me the perspective of someone who's listening to it for the first time. That kind of normalizes things for me and just amps up the enjoyment. Thank you!
Everyone asks, "What religion does Lalon belong to in this world?" Lalon answers, "What does religion look like?" I've never laid eyes upon it. Some use Malas (Hindu rosaries), others Tasbis (Muslim rosaries), and so people say they belong to a different religion. But do you bear the sign of your religion when you come (to this world) or when you leave (this world)? - Lalon
@@GUULLIVER "ওরে রাধার প্রেমে মাতোয়ারা চাঁদ গৌড় আমার রাধার প্রেমে মাতোয়ারা" Here clearly talking about love for Radha. Offcourse It's a Romantic song.
@@hisham2854 মাঝখান থেকে দুইটা লাইন তুলে নিয়ে এভাবে আক্ষরিক অর্থ করলে ভুল হবে। এটা দ্বিজভূষনের লেখা গৌড়ীয় বৈষ্ণবধর্মের দর্শনে উজ্জীবিত একটা কীর্তন ঘরাণার গান। সোজা কথায় ধর্মীয় গান। এর মধ্যে ঐ ধর্মের ধর্মতত্ত্ব, দর্শন আর মীথ সংক্রান্ত অনেক নিজস্ব টার্মিনোলজি ব্যবহার করা হয়েছে যা আপাত দৃষ্টিতে কোনো কোনো ক্ষেত্রে খুব সহজ মনে হলেও আসলে ভিন্ন, ব্যাপক ও গভীরতর অর্থ বহন করে। এটা কোনো সহজ-সরল টিপিকাল "romantic" গান না। ঠিক যেমন লালনের "মিলন হবে কতদিনে..." কোনো romantic গান না। এসব সবই আসলে আধ্যাত্নিক গান যা কিছুটা "সান্ধ্য" ভাষায় লেখা। এগুলি বুঝতে হলে আপনাকে আরও অনেক জ্ঞানার্জন করতে হবে এবং পরিণত হতে হবে মনে হয়।
@@GUULLIVER হ্যা অবশ্যই এটা টিপিক্যাল রোমান্টিক গান না, এটার সাথে একমত। কিন্তু একটা গান এক একজন শ্রোতা একেকভাবে অনুধাবন করতেই পারে। কোনটা আসলে বুঝানো হয়েছে আর কোনটা আসলে বুঝানো হইনি সেই তর্কে যাওয়াটা আপদমস্তক বোকামি। আপনি আপনার মন্তব্য জানালেন আপনি যেভাবে মর্মার্ত বুঝলেন, আমি জানালাম যেভাবে আমি রূপক অর্থে বুঝলাম। এখন আপনি যদি বলেন আমার বুঝার ভুল আছে আমার আরো ম্যাচিউর হতে হবে এই ধরণের হাস্যাকর শব্দ ব্যবহার না করা ই ভালো। কারণ শিল্প স্বাধীন আর তার নিজস্ব স্বকীয়তা আছে। একজন সতন্ত্র শ্রোতা হিসেবে শিল্পের মর্মার্থ আমার নিজের মতো করে বুঝতে পারাটায় স্বার্থকতা।
@@hisham2854 আমিও তো গোড়াতে নিজের মতামতটাই দিয়েছিলাম। আপনি তখনই স্বতন্ত্র শ্রোতা হিসাবে আমার স্বাধীণতাটা স্বীকার করে নিয়ে এসব কথা বলতে পারতেন। তা না করে কোটেশন, আর্গুমেন্ট এসবে গেলেন। সেজন্যই এত কথার অবতারনা। নচেৎ তখনই কথা শেষ হয়ে যেত। আর হ্যাঁ, এগুলি আসলে _ঠিক বিশুদ্ধ "শিল্প" না। এইসব গান আসলে গানের বেশে সঙ্ঘবদ্ধ ধর্মীয় ভাবাদর্শ, ভাবার্থ, আবেগ-অনুভূতি প্রচারের বাহন। "শিল্প" থেকে এগুলি একটু ভিন্ন জিনিস।_ তাই এগুলিকে তাদের নিজস্ব আদি অর্থে বোঝার প্রয়োজন আছে, প্রয়োজন আছে একটা কমন আন্ডারস্ট্যান্ডিং-এর। এক্ষেত্রে অন্য "শিল্পের" তুলনায়, আমার মতে, ব্যক্তি শ্রোতার স্বাধীণতা একটু কম। এই ধরণের "শিল্প", যা আসলে শিল্পের বেশে কোনো বিশেষ সঙ্ঘবদ্ধ ধর্ম বা দর্শন প্রচারের বাহন - সেসবকে সেইসব মূল ধর্মাবলম্বী বা দর্শনাবলম্বীদের ব্যাখ্যা অনুযায়ী তাদের ধর্ম বা দর্শনের আলোকে বোঝার চেষ্টা করাটাই উত্তম এবং যুক্তিসিদ্ধ কারন তারা এইসব গান একটা "মেসেজ" দেয়ার জন্য রচনা করেছেন - আপনাকে বা আমাকে নিছক আনন্দ বা বিনোদন দান করার জন্য লেখেননি বা যে কোনো শ্রোতার _শিল্পের মর্মার্থ বোঝার স্বাধীণতার নামে অর্থবিকৃতি-চর্চার স্বাধীণতা তোষণ_ করার জন্যও লেখেননি। এই গানগুলি নিছক "শিল্প" নয়, তার থেকেও অনেকখানি সিরিয়াস বিষয়। একদম সংক্ষেপে বললে এগুলি আসলে আগে ধর্ম / দর্শন, তারপর শিল্প / গান বা অন্যকিছু। ধর্ম / দর্শনের প্রাণ ও শরীরটাকে শিল্পের বাহ্যিক গৌণ পোশাক পরিয়ে পরিবেশন করা হয়েছে মাত্র। সঙ্ঘবদ্ধ ধর্ম বা দর্শন প্রচারের এই টেকনিকটা শুধু বৈষ্ণবরা না, বাউল থেকে শুরু করে আরও অনেক ঘরাণার সাধক ও সম্প্রদায়ই হাজার বছর ধরে সেই চর্যাপদের যুগ থেকেই আমাদের দেশে চর্চা করে আসছেন। বিষয়টা যেহেতু মূলত এবং প্রধাণত _"ধর্ম বা দর্শন",_ "শিল্প" না (যা এখানে পোশাক মাত্র), তাই সেই _"ধর্ম বা দর্শন"_ এর প্রাণবস্তু তথা মেসেজটা বোঝার চেষ্টা করাটাই আমি শ্রোতাদের প্রধাণ কর্তব্য মনে করি। নিদেনপক্ষে "শিল্প বোঝার স্বাধীণতার" নামে তার অর্থবিকৃতি করা বা সেই ব্যক্তিগত ভুল অর্থ প্রচার করা সবচেয়ে বড় অকর্তব্য মনে করি। আমার মনে হয় এধরণের গানগুলির মহান স্রষ্টাদের এবং তাদের সম্প্রদায়দের এটুকু অন্তত শ্রদ্ধা ও সম্মান আমাদের কাছে প্রাপ্য হয়, তাই না??? আপনার ধর্মের বা সম্প্রদায়ের কোনো গভীর ও গুরুত্বপূর্ণ আধ্যাত্নিক বাণীকে অন্য সম্প্রদায়ের বা যেকোনো সম্প্রদায়েরই কেউ যদি তার গভীর বা আসল অর্থ ছেটে ফেলে অর্থবিকৃতি ঘটাতে চায় _শিল্পের মর্মার্থ নিজের মত করে বোঝার স্বাধীণতার নামে_ - তখন আপনার বা আপনার সমমনাদের কেমন লাগবে? আমার তো ভাল লাগবে না!!! যাইহোক, নিজের মতামত দিলাম মাত্র। "শিল্প বোঝা" সংক্রান্ত আপনার মতামতটা সম্পর্কেও আমার প্রচুর শ্রদ্ধা আছে। ইন ফ্যাক্ট, শিল্প বোঝার ব্যাপারে আপনার এই যুক্তিটা আমিও বহু জায়গায় ব্যবহার করি। তবে এটা একটু ভিন্ন কন্টেক্সট মনে হয়েছে আমার কাছে তাই একটু ভিন্নমত প্রকাশ করলাম। বাদানুবাদের কোনো আগ্রহ নাই। তাই এখানেই শেষ করছি। ধন্যবাদ।
I used to watch US sitcoms while taking my lunch in Bangladesh. Now I am in US for my Masters and Coke Studio Bangla has started its journey just before I arrived in US. Now a days I am having my lunch watching and rewatching your reviews (more of your adda/friendly chat). I have to rewatch your videos when u guys don't drop a new video that day. Kudos to you and your taste of music. Take love from Bangladesh. 🇧🇩 Please react on Shunno Band's Bedona (Original version: ua-cam.com/video/H5FWPsGJkmw/v-deo.html ) or Behula (ua-cam.com/video/a3-HFoJJPzk/v-deo.html). I hope you'll keep my request.
Coke studio usually does a good job with English lyrics, but this one seemed a bit off. I would do something like this-- Some wear rosaries around their necks, some wear tasbih-- That makes you divide them up in castes*? Who wears the sign of a caste when we come or go? Everyone wonders What caste does Lalon belong to? Lalon says, "I am yet to see with my own eyes how caste looks like." All the people in the world flaunt their castes anywhere Lalon says, "I sold out of my caste-pride in the bazaar of life**. * Here Lalon uses the word "jaat", in the context of the region this goes beyond religious id, jaat defines your position in a stratified society. I would translate this as "caste". ** Lalon repeatedly uses the term Shadhbajar -- a market of Sadhna. It's a Baul term. This is an allegory for life-- you sell your work, your thoughts, your youth, and you buy the riches of life and meet other people (and search for yourself, or the elevated state of yourself, "Moner Manush".)
Something came to my mind which I think need to be share as you guys are talking about poetry, You mentioned ‘This type of poetry rare this days’ but I would say if you look around the poetry specifically these people ‘Lalon Shai, Baul shah Abdul Karim, Hason Raja, Kazi Nazrul, Naz khialvi, Ameer minai or Robi Thakur and some more you could see they wrote something which is at least couple off hundred years ahead off their time. Some of the song you feel like it’s written yesterday if imagine the current environmental and geopolitical scenario. Now a days who have got that kinda guts to write a song like this. Now nobody can think about them lyrics. They did because they were saint and pure by their heart. They are truthful inside them. Some song are hundreds years old but which relates 50 years ago, today even it will relate 50 years later. BTW You guys are doing great job, at least have the knowledge to discuss about the topics you’re talking about. Keep going. Thank you, Stay safe
After hearing the song once I was waiting to hear it again with you guys. When you were still in daylight here in Bangladesh is midnight.hahahaha Lalon Shah's poetry is Incredible. Your reaction is something nice to watch. Thanks a lot. Keep going the good work. Love from Bangladesh ❤️❤️
@@LetsTalkAboutIt-Reactions 🥰 Thanks for the reaction on my comment. It's also been a pleasure 😁... You have already reacted a song of Joler Gaan. If you could react some other song of them, it would be great. Take care Love from Bangladesh ❤️❤️
If one looks at the great saints and sadus of the past, their poetry is about Acceptance of poor, needy and variation to religion, That's from the tip of Iran right through to Sri Lanka and Bangladesh. Unfortunately these messages only exist n songs, but rarely exemplified by the people
Guys, a sincere request. If you dont understand Bengali, please do use the captions. Once you understand the lyrics and what they mean, it would take you to another level altogether.
It's the only song from coke studio i am not very fond of 🫣 cause the female part required a heavy delivery from someone like Anusheh or Shumi, not someone with such soft voice 😶 the emotion was lost for me. Murshidabadi kept the song alive.
Lalon could not identify any difference in anatomy or pathology between a Hindu and a Muslim ! Finding his own religion Lalon invented his own religion/philosophy. There are people who follow his philosophy.
Shob loke koy Lalon ki jaat ei shongshare -How many people are nurtured in the world .. Lalon bole jaat er ki rup? -What are the varieties of Lalon? Dekhlam na ei nojore -I did not see the two eyes. How many people are nurtured in the world .. Keu mala keu toshbir goley -Someone in the garland, someone in the tasbih, Tai te re jaat bhinno bole -So that breed speaks differently Bhobe asha kingba jawar kaale asha kingba .. -Going or coming Caste Symbol Roy Car Ray Bhobe asha kingba jawar kaale Jaatir chinnho roy ki re -How many people are nurtured in the world .. Shunnot dile hoy musholman -If circumcised is a Muslim, Nari jaater ki hoy bidhan -But what is the provision of women, Ami bamun chini poiter proman I know Dwarf by his father Bamni chinbo ki kore ? -What do I know about Bamani(female dwarf)? Shob loke koy Lalan ki jaat ei shongsare How many people are nurtured in the world .. Jogot jure jaater kotha -Conquering the world, Loke golpo kore jotha totha -People are proud of it Lalon shey jater fata ghuchiyeche sadh bazaarey. -Lalon wins the race for victory in Sadh Bazar ' Shob loke koy Lalan ki jaat ei shongsare -How many people are nurtured in the world ..
If you read the description, probably you would be able to guess why murshidabadi was picked for this song. They dropped this one on world music day conveying the message that music has no boundaries. From that perspective it makes sense that arnob picked a song from the other side of the border and a singer as well, and together it has been merged into a yet another masterpiece from CSB that conveys the message of harmony in diversity through co-existence.
Yes you got it right
im from rajshahi ( bangladesh ) . from my home i can see murshidabad ( indian district )..... opposite of padma river . even arijit singh home is there in murshidabad near bangladesh border ...there should not be border in indian subcontinent .... we are all same ....
absolutely right brother
And that is the whole meaning of the entire La,on geeti or the songs that they are singing in bangla
Hammad and Haris - Guys, there is a lot to say for the work you are doing. Hard to really express in words but suffice to say that your reaction, analysis, commentary, whatever you want to call it, is the best around and it’s not even close. Sure, people enjoy the music but I’ve seen your growth from the earlier videos and I can only commend how you have taken the time to educate yourselves and learn more about these artists, genre, origins, etc. this makes your discussions so meaningful and thoughtful and, honestly, for most of us, educational in some ways.
I also want to say, and this is for the music you do outside of coke studio, you guys do an amazing job. We all know and love coke studio (all countries, versions) but I have learned about some really good bangla music thanks to your coverage/discussions. Kind of crazy but it shows the impact and reach you guys have and are creating.
Thank you for doing this. I am a big fan. Keep up the great work!
Thank you so much Ehsan 🙏🏼 We are humbled by your kind words. We can’t thank enough to our viewers for helping us navigate through Bangladeshi music.
Exactly ❤️👌🏻
Lalon has perfected our Bengali language through his songs. He was born in a Hindu family.
When he went on a pilgrimage on the orders of the zamindar of the area, he contracted smallpox. The people declared him dead and floated him in the river Ganga.
And he came floating from India to Kushtia district of Bangladesh.
When a Muslim woman saw him there, she took care of him and healed him After recovering, Lalon went to his house and told about his past. His neighbors accuse him of giving place to Muslims in their homes and taking food from Muslims, saying that "Lalon's caste is gone .
Angered and saddened, Lalon left his family, religion and society and returned to Kushtia district of Bangladesh.
When we listen to the songs, our souls still get excited.
This is more of a fiction than fact. Lalon was born in Bengal and supposedly East Bengal in Jhenaidah, Bangladesh.
There are many fiction about Lalon and Sunil Gangopadhyay popularized this one.
No one actually knows for sure what happenned. You watched it in a movie and took it for real.
it's fiction .. about his religion, none knows ..It is not known whether he was born in a Hindu or a Muslim family. Lalon had no formal education.
One account relates that Lalon, during a pilgrimage to the temple of Jagannath with others of his native village, he contracted smallpox and was abandoned by his companions on the banks of the Kaliganga River, from where Malam Shah and his wife Matijan, members of the weaver community in a Muslim-populated village, Cheuriya, took him to their home to convalesce. They gave Lalon land to live where he founded a musical group and remained to compose and perform his songs, inspired by Siraj Sain, a musician of that village. Lalon lost sight in one of his eyes.Researchers note that Lalon was a close friend of Kangal Harinath, one of the contemporary social reformers and a disciple of Lalon.
Lalon lived within the zamindari of the Tagores in Kushtia and had visited the Tagore family. It is said that zamindar Jyotirindranath Tagore sketched the only portrait of Lalon in 1889 in his houseboat on the river Padma. Lalon died at Chheuriya on 17 October 1890 at the age of 118. The news of his death was first published in the newspaper Gram Barta Prokashika, run by Kangal Harinath. Lalon was buried at the middle of his dwelling place known as his Akhra.
Thanks for your explaining, I did not know that actually.
To his last breath of life, Fakir Lalon Shah (1774-1890) preached humanity over religion. He composed and sang thousands of songs on the concepts of humanity, the inner meaning of life, and finding the true God. Lalon thought that God keeps Himself hidden as the soul inside the human body. He was a true philosopher and left hundreds of thousands of baauls and followers.
Eagerly waiting for your talk. I assume Arnob had follwed u after "Bhober Pagol" behind the scene. And became sure after watching comment of him in your vedio. You are doing fantastic. Such a pleasure to see you talking about Bangla music as you are in love with Bangla music. Thank you both. Very eager to watch rejected vedios from youtube. Come quickly to FB.
You guys got the main point of the song. How beautifully you guys reacted to this song. Loved it 🙌
Kabir Das? And I didn't know anything about this Saint? I'm gonna study him. Thanks, Coke Studio Bangla and specifically Arnob for introducing this Saint to Us. How beautiful is that?
Oh, by the way, I just found out that Arnob and Murshidabadi have a history of collaboration (checkout Yogi, from Murshidabadi Project). Somewhere Arnob commented that he always wanted to do a Kabir Das project. This is his project today.
This channel has become one of my favourite channels. I have watched almost every video twice. Re watching this too.
This means a lot! ❤️
@@LetsTalkAboutIt-Reactions You guys are awesome ❣️
Exactly, that's weird 😄😳
You both really are doing great job. Quality reactions. Love from 🇧🇩
Love your reaction since you both truly catch the real message here. I wait for what you would say after the song.
You brothers are just gradually taking space inside our Heart
Everyone ask Lalon (17th Century poet and philosopher of Bangla region); which caste or religion do you belong to? He ask them back - "how does a caste look? I was born without a caste". Kabir Das (14th Century poet of Uttar Pradesh) the other poet wrote water in different pot is still nothing but water. Key message is universal humanity without any form of man made discrimination.
Your reviews are the best. I have seen very few reaction videos go so deep into the discussion - lyrics, music, and all the nuances. Brilliant work guys!
I wish I could do a review like this! Thank you so much for your very enlightening review. Loved it so much 💕
Lovely words ❤️ how pleasing! And yes, keep uncovering all those layers of Brilliance ❤️❤️that's how we could connect , I hope 🙏
Today is World Music Day. Music has the ability to transcend all differences and fascinate everyone in the same way. The explanations of that unity can be found in the writings of two mystic saints who lived hundreds of years and thousands of kilometers apart.
Another gem review. You are getting into my blood now and there is no antibiotic to that :)
Song start with a great voice. Loved it❤ from Pakistan
I was waiting for your words after the song release ❤️❤️❤️
I think , this is the best reaction and review video I've ever seen.
Thanks
Murshidabadi actual name is soumyadeep sikdar...he is finest artist in west bengal
love you brother... how good you are.! could u understand bengali.. wish next few mounth it will happened
The way you guys review..amazing 💫💫
Thank you for the recognition of our strive for harmony. It’s not easy or perfect, but we are trying.
Love from Bangladesh, nice reactions 👌👍💚❤💚
Beautiful song
You guys are amazing on analysing song.
Perfect reaction, totally did justice to this awesome song! Take love !
Fakir Lalon Shah is the main founder of Secular society in Bengal. Baul songs written by Lalan Fakir is famous among whole Bengal. Rabindranath Tagore was inspire by Lalan Fakir. His Jamindari area Lalan lived.
You have to study this great philosopher again and again.
Lalan don’t believe cast / jat/religious system. He had written a lot of songs in this topics.
Another masterpiece of Fakir Lalon Shah "Emon Manav Janam Aar Ki Hobe" can be enjoyed, message for true hiuminity.
You can also listen to "Indubala go" by Boga Taleb (Ripon) and Murshidabadi. I believe you will love that
Masterpiece👍👍
You know what I love about you guys? I have been listening to these songs for 30+ years, so the "fusion" feels jarring on first listen. For example, it's hard to stomach the urban serenity of saxophone with a Lalon song that is so iconoclastic. You guys give me the perspective of someone who's listening to it for the first time. That kind of normalizes things for me and just amps up the enjoyment. Thank you!
Oh, you just spoke my heart!
love you from bangladesh
I love coke studio bangla
Bangladesh ❤❤❤
How could i partipate here
গুড। song
Everyone asks, "What religion does Lalon belong to in this world?"
Lalon answers, "What does religion look like?"
I've never laid eyes upon it.
Some use Malas (Hindu rosaries),
others Tasbis (Muslim rosaries), and so people say
they belong to a different religion.
But do you bear the sign of your religion
when you come (to this world) or when you leave (this world)?
- Lalon
Thanks guys good reaction
Wow..You got it!
I'd like to recommend one Song. Which is Anusheh Anadil 'Hrid Majare Rakhbo'
This is very Sad, Romantic Folk song.
It's not a spiritual song, not romantic.
@@GUULLIVER "ওরে রাধার প্রেমে মাতোয়ারা চাঁদ গৌড়
আমার রাধার প্রেমে মাতোয়ারা"
Here clearly talking about love for Radha. Offcourse It's a Romantic song.
@@hisham2854 মাঝখান থেকে দুইটা লাইন তুলে নিয়ে এভাবে আক্ষরিক অর্থ করলে ভুল হবে। এটা দ্বিজভূষনের লেখা গৌড়ীয় বৈষ্ণবধর্মের দর্শনে উজ্জীবিত একটা কীর্তন ঘরাণার গান। সোজা কথায় ধর্মীয় গান। এর মধ্যে ঐ ধর্মের ধর্মতত্ত্ব, দর্শন আর মীথ সংক্রান্ত অনেক নিজস্ব টার্মিনোলজি ব্যবহার করা হয়েছে যা আপাত দৃষ্টিতে কোনো কোনো ক্ষেত্রে খুব সহজ মনে হলেও আসলে ভিন্ন, ব্যাপক ও গভীরতর অর্থ বহন করে। এটা কোনো সহজ-সরল টিপিকাল "romantic" গান না। ঠিক যেমন লালনের "মিলন হবে কতদিনে..." কোনো romantic গান না। এসব সবই আসলে আধ্যাত্নিক গান যা কিছুটা "সান্ধ্য" ভাষায় লেখা। এগুলি বুঝতে হলে আপনাকে আরও অনেক জ্ঞানার্জন করতে হবে এবং পরিণত হতে হবে মনে হয়।
@@GUULLIVER হ্যা অবশ্যই এটা টিপিক্যাল রোমান্টিক গান না, এটার সাথে একমত।
কিন্তু একটা গান এক একজন শ্রোতা একেকভাবে অনুধাবন করতেই পারে। কোনটা আসলে বুঝানো হয়েছে আর কোনটা আসলে বুঝানো হইনি সেই তর্কে যাওয়াটা আপদমস্তক বোকামি।
আপনি আপনার মন্তব্য জানালেন আপনি যেভাবে মর্মার্ত বুঝলেন, আমি জানালাম যেভাবে আমি রূপক অর্থে বুঝলাম। এখন আপনি যদি বলেন আমার বুঝার ভুল আছে আমার আরো ম্যাচিউর হতে হবে এই ধরণের হাস্যাকর শব্দ ব্যবহার না করা ই ভালো। কারণ শিল্প স্বাধীন আর তার নিজস্ব স্বকীয়তা আছে। একজন সতন্ত্র শ্রোতা হিসেবে শিল্পের মর্মার্থ আমার নিজের মতো করে বুঝতে পারাটায় স্বার্থকতা।
@@hisham2854 আমিও তো গোড়াতে নিজের মতামতটাই দিয়েছিলাম। আপনি তখনই স্বতন্ত্র শ্রোতা হিসাবে আমার স্বাধীণতাটা স্বীকার করে নিয়ে এসব কথা বলতে পারতেন। তা না করে কোটেশন, আর্গুমেন্ট এসবে গেলেন। সেজন্যই এত কথার অবতারনা। নচেৎ তখনই কথা শেষ হয়ে যেত। আর হ্যাঁ, এগুলি আসলে _ঠিক বিশুদ্ধ "শিল্প" না। এইসব গান আসলে গানের বেশে সঙ্ঘবদ্ধ ধর্মীয় ভাবাদর্শ, ভাবার্থ, আবেগ-অনুভূতি প্রচারের বাহন। "শিল্প" থেকে এগুলি একটু ভিন্ন জিনিস।_ তাই এগুলিকে তাদের নিজস্ব আদি অর্থে বোঝার প্রয়োজন আছে, প্রয়োজন আছে একটা কমন আন্ডারস্ট্যান্ডিং-এর। এক্ষেত্রে অন্য "শিল্পের" তুলনায়, আমার মতে, ব্যক্তি শ্রোতার স্বাধীণতা একটু কম। এই ধরণের "শিল্প", যা আসলে শিল্পের বেশে কোনো বিশেষ সঙ্ঘবদ্ধ ধর্ম বা দর্শন প্রচারের বাহন - সেসবকে সেইসব মূল ধর্মাবলম্বী বা দর্শনাবলম্বীদের ব্যাখ্যা অনুযায়ী তাদের ধর্ম বা দর্শনের আলোকে বোঝার চেষ্টা করাটাই উত্তম এবং যুক্তিসিদ্ধ কারন তারা এইসব গান একটা "মেসেজ" দেয়ার জন্য রচনা করেছেন - আপনাকে বা আমাকে নিছক আনন্দ বা বিনোদন দান করার জন্য লেখেননি বা যে কোনো শ্রোতার _শিল্পের মর্মার্থ বোঝার স্বাধীণতার নামে অর্থবিকৃতি-চর্চার স্বাধীণতা তোষণ_ করার জন্যও লেখেননি। এই গানগুলি নিছক "শিল্প" নয়, তার থেকেও অনেকখানি সিরিয়াস বিষয়। একদম সংক্ষেপে বললে এগুলি আসলে আগে ধর্ম / দর্শন, তারপর শিল্প / গান বা অন্যকিছু। ধর্ম / দর্শনের প্রাণ ও শরীরটাকে শিল্পের বাহ্যিক গৌণ পোশাক পরিয়ে পরিবেশন করা হয়েছে মাত্র। সঙ্ঘবদ্ধ ধর্ম বা দর্শন প্রচারের এই টেকনিকটা শুধু বৈষ্ণবরা না, বাউল থেকে শুরু করে আরও অনেক ঘরাণার সাধক ও সম্প্রদায়ই হাজার বছর ধরে সেই চর্যাপদের যুগ থেকেই আমাদের দেশে চর্চা করে আসছেন। বিষয়টা যেহেতু মূলত এবং প্রধাণত _"ধর্ম বা দর্শন",_ "শিল্প" না (যা এখানে পোশাক মাত্র), তাই সেই _"ধর্ম বা দর্শন"_ এর প্রাণবস্তু তথা মেসেজটা বোঝার চেষ্টা করাটাই আমি শ্রোতাদের প্রধাণ কর্তব্য মনে করি। নিদেনপক্ষে "শিল্প বোঝার স্বাধীণতার" নামে তার অর্থবিকৃতি করা বা সেই ব্যক্তিগত ভুল অর্থ প্রচার করা সবচেয়ে বড় অকর্তব্য মনে করি। আমার মনে হয় এধরণের গানগুলির মহান স্রষ্টাদের এবং তাদের সম্প্রদায়দের এটুকু অন্তত শ্রদ্ধা ও সম্মান আমাদের কাছে প্রাপ্য হয়, তাই না??? আপনার ধর্মের বা সম্প্রদায়ের কোনো গভীর ও গুরুত্বপূর্ণ আধ্যাত্নিক বাণীকে অন্য সম্প্রদায়ের বা যেকোনো সম্প্রদায়েরই কেউ যদি তার গভীর বা আসল অর্থ ছেটে ফেলে অর্থবিকৃতি ঘটাতে চায় _শিল্পের মর্মার্থ নিজের মত করে বোঝার স্বাধীণতার নামে_ - তখন আপনার বা আপনার সমমনাদের কেমন লাগবে? আমার তো ভাল লাগবে না!!! যাইহোক, নিজের মতামত দিলাম মাত্র। "শিল্প বোঝা" সংক্রান্ত আপনার মতামতটা সম্পর্কেও আমার প্রচুর শ্রদ্ধা আছে। ইন ফ্যাক্ট, শিল্প বোঝার ব্যাপারে আপনার এই যুক্তিটা আমিও বহু জায়গায় ব্যবহার করি। তবে এটা একটু ভিন্ন কন্টেক্সট মনে হয়েছে আমার কাছে তাই একটু ভিন্নমত প্রকাশ করলাম। বাদানুবাদের কোনো আগ্রহ নাই। তাই এখানেই শেষ করছি। ধন্যবাদ।
I used to watch US sitcoms while taking my lunch in Bangladesh. Now I am in US for my Masters and Coke Studio Bangla has started its journey just before I arrived in US. Now a days I am having my lunch watching and rewatching your reviews (more of your adda/friendly chat). I have to rewatch your videos when u guys don't drop a new video that day. Kudos to you and your taste of music. Take love from Bangladesh. 🇧🇩
Please react on Shunno Band's Bedona (Original version: ua-cam.com/video/H5FWPsGJkmw/v-deo.html ) or Behula (ua-cam.com/video/a3-HFoJJPzk/v-deo.html). I hope you'll keep my request.
Thanks a bunch Raqibul for your kind words! And thanks for sharing your suggestions too. We are elated by the fact that we have such amazing viewers!
good reaction and review.
Flute king Jalal Bhai ❤️
beauty
ua-cam.com/video/UOYAUSsMW80/v-deo.html
"Yogi" by Murshidabadi and Arnob.
I think you would definitely love it❤️❤️
Fluid ❤️ jalal bhai
Waiting for your analysis 🏵🏵
vober pagol is also from fakir lalon shah
sunlight!!!
Coke studio usually does a good job with English lyrics, but this one seemed a bit off. I would do something like this--
Some wear rosaries around their necks, some wear tasbih--
That makes you divide them up in castes*?
Who wears the sign of a caste
when we come or go?
Everyone wonders
What caste does Lalon belong to?
Lalon says, "I am yet to see with my own eyes
how caste looks like."
All the people in the world
flaunt their castes anywhere
Lalon says, "I sold out of my caste-pride
in the bazaar of life**.
* Here Lalon uses the word "jaat", in the context of the region this goes beyond religious id, jaat defines your position in a stratified society. I would translate this as "caste".
** Lalon repeatedly uses the term Shadhbajar -- a market of Sadhna. It's a Baul term. This is an allegory for life-- you sell your work, your thoughts, your youth, and you buy the riches of life and meet other people (and search for yourself, or the elevated state of yourself, "Moner Manush".)
Awesome song ❤️❤️
Please React 'Komolay Nitto Kore ' From Gaan Bangla wind of change
Plz plz plz🙏🙏🙏🙏
💞Joy guru lalon🙏
"Tu Jhoom" from coke studio!?
You guys are missing out the best thing!
Also "chap tikal" is amazing!!
😍😍😍😍
Lovely
Let's put Humanity first .
Where is your Chiltey roud reaction? Can't find it
It was deleted due to copyright issues
@@LetsTalkAboutIt-Reactions ohh damn, that was my most favt one throughout the two seasons. However, keep going.
Can you react to "Neshar bojha" by popeye?
Something came to my mind which I think need to be share as you guys are talking about poetry,
You mentioned ‘This type of poetry rare this days’ but I would say if you look around the poetry specifically these people ‘Lalon Shai, Baul shah Abdul Karim, Hason Raja, Kazi Nazrul, Naz khialvi, Ameer minai or Robi Thakur and some more you could see they wrote something which is at least couple off hundred years ahead off their time. Some of the song you feel like it’s written yesterday if imagine the current environmental and geopolitical scenario. Now a days who have got that kinda guts to write a song like this. Now nobody can think about them lyrics. They did because they were saint and pure by their heart. They are truthful inside them.
Some song are hundreds years old but which relates 50 years ago, today even it will relate 50 years later.
BTW You guys are doing great job, at least have the knowledge to discuss about the topics you’re talking about. Keep going.
Thank you, Stay safe
You are absolutely right! Some movies, tv shows, art and poetry are always way ahead of their time. Thank you for sharing your thoughts with us.
After hearing the song once I was waiting to hear it again with you guys. When you were still in daylight here in Bangladesh is midnight.hahahaha
Lalon Shah's poetry is Incredible. Your reaction is something nice to watch. Thanks a lot.
Keep going the good work.
Love from Bangladesh ❤️❤️
We were also waiting for you to watch it, we knew you’d let us know :)
@@LetsTalkAboutIt-Reactions 🥰
Thanks for the reaction on my comment. It's also been a pleasure 😁...
You have already reacted a song of Joler Gaan. If you could react some other song of them, it would be great.
Take care
Love from Bangladesh ❤️❤️
🇧🇩❤️✌️🙏🏾
The message of universal humanism of Lalon/Kabir is perhaps more relevant now than ever before -- and, if anything, more so for this subcontinent!
Listen to "Yogi" by Murshidabadi and arnob.....
The song is at different level....
😘🙏👍
Please react on minerva full tribute
If one looks at the great saints and sadus of the past, their poetry is about Acceptance of poor, needy and variation to religion, That's from the tip of Iran right through to Sri Lanka and Bangladesh. Unfortunately these messages only exist n songs, but rarely exemplified by the people
❤️❤️❤️❤️♨️♨️♨️❤️❤️💯💯💯💯❤️♨️♨️
Pls react to indubala go sung by Ananya Chakraborty, it has a similar vibe
why subtitle is off?
We had subs on when we watched it, its just not there on our channel!
I enjoy your conversation after song. If subtitle will be on like other reaction it will be easier to understand your thoughts.
I like the game of thrones reference..
Guys, you need to watch Khoka (feat Ferdous Wahid) by Pritom!! It has 15.6 million views!
❤️
Hy ...Why u don't check Arnobs single track???😋
You will see it very soon! 🙂
Guys, a sincere request. If you dont understand Bengali, please do use the captions. Once you understand the lyrics and what they mean, it would take you to another level altogether.
We always keep captions on. We just dont show them in the video snippet that we upload!
It's the only song from coke studio i am not very fond of 🫣 cause the female part required a heavy delivery from someone like Anusheh or Shumi, not someone with such soft voice 😶 the emotion was lost for me. Murshidabadi kept the song alive.
Lalon could not identify any difference in anatomy or pathology between a Hindu and a Muslim !
Finding his own religion Lalon invented his own religion/philosophy. There are people who follow his philosophy.
🌹🌹
Shob loke koy
Lalon ki jaat ei shongshare
-How many people are nurtured in the world ..
Lalon bole jaat er ki rup?
-What are the varieties of Lalon?
Dekhlam na ei nojore
-I did not see the two eyes.
How many people are nurtured in the world ..
Keu mala keu toshbir goley
-Someone in the garland, someone in the tasbih,
Tai te re jaat bhinno bole
-So that breed speaks differently
Bhobe asha kingba jawar kaale
asha kingba ..
-Going or coming
Caste Symbol Roy Car Ray
Bhobe asha kingba jawar kaale
Jaatir chinnho roy ki re
-How many people are nurtured in the world ..
Shunnot dile hoy musholman
-If circumcised is a Muslim,
Nari jaater ki hoy bidhan
-But what is the provision of women,
Ami bamun chini poiter proman
I know Dwarf by his father
Bamni chinbo ki kore ?
-What do I know about Bamani(female dwarf)?
Shob loke koy
Lalan ki jaat ei shongsare
How many people are nurtured in the world ..
Jogot jure jaater kotha
-Conquering the world,
Loke golpo kore jotha totha
-People are proud of it
Lalon shey jater fata ghuchiyeche sadh bazaarey.
-Lalon wins the race for victory in Sadh Bazar '
Shob loke koy
Lalan ki jaat ei shongsare
-How many people are nurtured in the world ..
Please react to "morey jak" by Pritom
We have done it few days ago 🙂 Here is the link for you:
ua-cam.com/video/flcA35GmVbU/v-deo.html
Please react Om by meghdol
Very Very Nice Songs
from bangladesh.
covered by me 'shob loke bole" lalon song
ua-cam.com/video/tedIgriBodA/v-deo.html
Murshidabadi's part is not matched with Shaiji tone. Apart from that right!
Ahsalamu Ahalikum both of vhiejaan. I love your reaction but I'm not subscribe coke studio because #BoycottCocaCola for that