"I've had two miscarriages so i'll just wish for a child to ensure I do, and to also avoid the pain of childbirth." We already have a solution to that without a wish granting room and it's called adoption, Kate.
Welp. They could've used some of that money to pay for an IVF also. Maybe they could've tricked the room by having the person who works for a company that does IVF, bring a portable ATM into the home. But would the money turn into ashes if it's moved electronically? 🤷
This would be the dream for people that never leave the house. If the room truly has no limits you could create a universe, become immortal, and be the god of that universe.
Then wish to recreate the entire world/universe inside the room (much like Shane did with the forest and the cloned house). You literally live inside that room for the rest of your days BUT it would be like living in the actual world. You win.
So this room basically has no downside aside from the you can't take anything outside rule? Pretty much perfect as long as you're not dumb enough to wish for a kid
Thats the beauty of the flawed people in this story. People are going to wish for the thing they are missing. They are just the worst people to inherit the room.
"I wish for tomorrow's lottery number." Done, now you're rich and can buy all the material things outside the house. Maybe go and adopt some child in need of love and home. They are so dumb!!!
I mean, I don't see the problem with this thing. This solves a lot of problems - you never need to buy new appliances, or books, or movies, because you can just wish for them. This strikes me as something that can only go wrong if you're the sort of person who immediately starts wishing for morally questionable things like real people or children.
Exactly! The film is very intelligent. It has very important wisdom but its still a movie and not a motivational video or a meme. The wife was an idiot,
@@GizmoMaltese The wife was irrationally attached to the kid. Same reason she wished for the baby in the first place. I find it very difficult to watch films like these and not come away thinking that having slightly more rational characters would prevent these plots from happening. I don't understand the kind of people who would see a room like this and assume it would give them happiness as opposed to convenience. I suppose that's the theme: money can't buy happiness, and trying to *make* it buy happiness will guarantee a disaster, but it's too inconsistent for me to suspend my disbelief.
@@GizmoMaltese If we take your argument to its logical conclusion, we cannot ever complain about irrational actions taken by characters in fiction, regardless of how nonsensical or unprompted they might be. I dont think you would accept that conclusion, but your premise that all people are irrational requires it. If the conclusion is false, the premise is false.
It might be smart or it might be a nightmare where you can never be sure if you’re in the room or not. The concept is similar to Inception or even Star Trek’s holodeck.
The second thing I would wish for in that room (assuming that the first thing was whatever made me realize that the room granted wishes) would be an instruction manual which explained the rules, limitations, and costs for wishes made in that room.
I actually feel bad for that John Doe... he was just a wish granted by the room just like Shane, he couldn't leave the house at all but, when he finally had the chance to do it, he got trapped in another building for life, that psychiatry hospital...
I thought that Jon Doe being a wished child means they are all inside the room, because Jon Doe would turn to dust if he left the house, so he wished for an entire world inside the room...
Shane: *Continuously wishes that his parents never leave the room* Me: "I wish for all of Shane's wishes to be ineffective. I also wish for me and my partner to leave this room safely and enter the real world." Shane: "..... Dang it."
If everything fake dies outside that house, that would mean the child couldn't be their son's, as his seed or the part of the baby that has grown out of it would be dead too, so she wouldn't get pregnant.
@@Brandon-ob9rg If they're still in the room then why did the guy turn to dust? The only way for that to happen would be if he wished himself into dust to trick them, but I doubt someone like that would be willing to sacrifice themselves.
Shane wins. He wished his parents ("parents") could never leave the room, that they were forever his, and that he would be around forever. The room made it their universe and it got creative about it.
@@notanonymous3976 By wishing they could never leave the room, that they were his forever, and that he would be around forever... removing their ability to have any power, like wishing for stuff, would be a part of what the room would need to do to grant that wish.
@@LiminalHorror I think they could just wish that everything went back to be the way it was prior to their first wish. End credits haha. But then there's no movie.
So, no one is mentioning the statement "The only thing more dangerous than a person who cant get what they want is the person who gets whatever they want." That's a horror story in real life.
imagine how creative people could truly get with a home that grants wishes, of course due to budget reasons the movie could not explore those possibilities
keep wishing for the newest nvidia gfx cards, then selling them hand 2 hand (for real outside world money) while in the house. Recording for (court) evidence that everything you sell is working and is real.
@@Oreo-vh7rk Yeah, but the wonderful thing about conception and pregnancy is it gives about a year of prep time. Rushing prep time and well, love turned to hate real quick.
@@darkpaw1522 whether it takes 1 year or 2 to give birth, it doesn't change the fact that the baby is already coming out soon. So he needs to be ready the moment he realises she is pregnant anyway. What's the difference ? Plus he is the one who wanted to try for another. How can he change his stance that quickly ?
@@bp-u-will-always-be-famous In the movie, she became upset at him for not being a father to Shane and calling it a "thing". She was trying to force him into fatherhood.
If you wish for that, you'll just get a note saying, whoever wishes it must die, so then someone else would be taking the stuff outside. You would have to go out and look for a homeless guy that noone will miss. Make him wish for everything you want. Then kill him and you can take it all outside. Alternatively, you could use a person that's dying anyway and get them to do it. However, that might not work if they die of a natural death. Part of it is probably that it's evil magic, so a murder must be involved.
There is one downside of watching 12 minute movies is that you cannot remember the movie after a few days. Watching a 2 hour movie will stay in your memory for long.
In Hollywood Land, nobody secures a door before doing something others passing by shouldn't see or hear. A discussion between a traitor and antagonist? Allow us to have a conversation with the door slightly ajar and don't forget to YELL!
Since we know that if the wish-maker dies then their wishes don't fade after leaving the room. We can assume the following: 1. Wish for a man who wishes for whatever you wish for. 2. Tell the man to wish for what you want 3. Tell the man to die
Pretty sure as soon as i realised what the room did i would have wished for a manual on what the rules of the room are. Is there a price to pay later? Is there a way to expand the wish-gratnting area? Can we build a second house with a room like that? Can we stop our aging? Can the knowledge gained in the room be carried outside? If so could we just wish for a bunch of geniuses with their corresponding labs to solve all of humanity's problems and write the solutions down on non-room notebooks to share with everyone? So much knowledge just one wish away.
I think the point of the movie was that no matter what you wished, the ending outcome would be a fuckup no matter what. It would probably come back and bite you in the butt anyway. It's pretty much a D&D genie wish spell.
@@Shendue And this guy knows damn well that if he got a room where he could wish anything, the thought wouldn't even cross his mind. It's easy to think of a these smart wishes when u aren't in the situation.
I would wish for the revival of sir Einstein sir, Stephen Hawkings , sir Newton and sir scheödinger haha . Give them all the books and workspace and tell them that they have reached heaven 🤓🤧
The baby is clearly Matt's. Since everything created in the room disintegrates when taken outside. If it were Shane's baby, then she would've already pissed dust.
unfortunately, the room does not allow counter arguments to itself. but what i dont understand is why did they even need a child? they could have wished for literal heaven to their minds extend and just live there forever. whats the point of ever going outside, when you have infinite in that room?
@@descendinggod9740 That's impossible to not allow counter arguments if every which can be granted including reality breaking wishes like a full outdoor place inside the room. Also there's no need to go outside. Just wish for a 1 to 1 mirror of the real outside world inside the room and live there as if you're outside because you'd not even recognize the difference.
Would love this as a thought experiment. So the basic rules: your wish is material so no "super powers" or "grant me knowledge". The wish can only create/alter things inside the room. Your wish cannot alter how the room works. Anything created by the room disintegrates when it leaves. The room cannot provide you with knowledge of the future (like lottery numbers). I would wish for something I could copy like a fantastic new novel (I might be able to conjure it on a disc or something and copy-paste to my computer , but even if that wouldn't work, just conjure it on paper then type it up myself). I could do this for all sorts, like plans and schematics and such. If the digital copy-paste method works then even better - I could make all sorts of fun things like graphics, novels, comics, games, applications and more. These can be published/sold/etc for money I could use outside - pay taxes, nights out, etc. I could create new houses within that room like extra dimensional spaces - my family could move in and have private mansions on private islands with everything they could need. It would be everything. Pure contentment. Bliss. Problem is, wouldn't be entertaining for a movie so of course the people in the movie had to be stupid about it. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Sure room give me access to all the rich people accounts, so i can get real money. Or sure make me smart enough to hack any account without being ever caught.
You guys are slow motion. Im wishing for the next 10 powerball draws. I wont stop there ill have a PDF of every lottery number in ever state for the next 20 years. Im gonna be loaded
Me: Walks into the room. Close my eyes and makes a wish. Tommy Wiseau walks in. "I did not hit her, it is not true, its bullshit. I did not her. I DID NOT! oh hi mark."
that room is literally consequence free. They just brought it to themselves. if I were the one in their situation, I would have never ever left the house cause i have everything i need. food, everything! I can just literally live in the room itself, with just loopholing to get real life money so i can get some irl nights out if i really wanted some human company(but hey, who needs that when you got your wifus?) i'll just also renovate the house a bit so i can live a super modern life just never leaving? It's literally something worth but.. enters the "oh we want babies" and the "maybe we can do bla, bla, bla" people. To be honest, the only people who can actually see the room for what it should be used for is the introverts, gamer, people in the comment section, and any decent fangirls and fanguys who just want to use that room for what it should be used for. They literally have something any person in the world would want, the ones who desperately wanted to shift realities or whatever. Yet they WASTED IT AND BROUGHT THE BAD LUCK TO THEMSELVES! Ok, point proven.
@@heedmywarning2792 You could literally understand If God, Heaven, Hell, Aliens, Jesus, Mohammed, Noah. And every answer to mankind has ever existed. I would become the most Enlighted human being but also the saddest person If I find the answers to my questions.
@@asandax6 that could potentially negate your wishes, i.e. if the 'consequences'/cause and effect of making a wish is nullified that would result in manifesting 'nothing'. That's the only way to ensure 0% consequences, e.g. if he asked for money in his pocket, sure the money deteriorating would be nullified, but so would the all the other [passive] effects of making said [any] wish. The money wouldn't weigh anything, the paper wouldn't decompose, or be eligible for use (since a potential consequences could be arrested for money fraud/owning fake/printed money). The wish should nullify itself to guarantee no consequences. 😂
It'd just be a matter of when that self control runs out, not if. I think that with such a room, the more wishes one makes, the more likely it is they lose self control, with a false sense of 'safety' increasing with every wish that turns out well.
Honestly this would be awesome as a person that wouldn’t want anything to do with this world after finding the room. I would wish for an entirely different world fantasy adventure based and wish for the ability to be completely invulnerable to anything and just have a grand time!
while that sounds like a good idea, I would say that that's worse than real life. When you have all the power in the world, everything will become boring. The best representation of this IMO is saitama from onepunch, he's basically a god and no one can even scratch him, but with that power nothing is really a challenge. not having enough stress in your life can make you depressed
I only said I would be invulnerable, you know so I wouldn’t be blown to smitherines from a fireball. And the beauty of the room is that I could adjust anything I wanted to make it more enjoyable including removing said invulnerability whenever I wanted to. There is only a down side in the realization that none of it is truly real of course, but then again the person that it actually created could become real with the sacrifice of another. Also if you chose to create a word where time is different than the real world, you could in essence spend any amount of time in the room and have it not last but a moment in real time, thus losing nothing and gaining real knowledge that could be put to use in the real world, of course I don’t know the rules for how that would affect you as a real person.
@@محمدالميلادي-ط5ر not true. If that were the case then knowledge of the room itself and all things learned inside of it would be gone as soon as they stepped out of the door into the outside world.
@@Deathtollscorner Nope. Incorrect. You wished for the knowledge of the world with that Library. You read and absorbed every piece of knowledge that you could in whatever time you allotted to yourself. The physical pieces of the Library would dust, but the knowledge that you gleaned from it was never wished for. You LEARNED it. That was never wished for. The knowledge is real and can exist outside the walls and confines of the house. The physical knowledge cannot because that was wished for. This is an easy one to get past. Now, if you wished for all the knowledge of the Library without making the Library happen, then yeah, soon as you leave the house that knowledge goes away. You have to remember how these wishes work and play the game.
the room takes on a whole new meaning when its 1 person with the room. as long as you know the rules and play within your limits it brings you unlimited fun. if i was in this movie i would put rules on the door to the room before my death so the next owners can be careful and enjoy without something this horrible happening
Why whenever people in movies are given the ability to wish for stuff they wish for some boring cliche things? They need to take a page out of Starlord’s book and start wishing for some interesting stuff. The only reason this is a horror movie is because these people couldn’t think beyond some paintings, money, and a baby. Bruh, I’d be wishing for characters from magical worlds and shiz. I’d invite my friends over and they’d be shocked to find Aslan and Princess Peach drinking blue milk from Stars Wars while My Little Pony and Girls Und Panzer characters have a Wii Sports tournament in the living room. My house would be POPPING! Also, if HAD to be boring and just go for financial gain , couldn’t I wish for a valid check and then cash it digitally? That’s the thing with all these antiquated cursed houses and stuff, they’re so old that technology gives us loop-holes around their arbitrary rules. Imma be partying on yacht with Animal Crossing characters y’all.
Legit tho. Like there only seems to be consequences when you create "living" beings so everything else is on the table. You can legit bring anything else so you could make a mish mash of a bunch of your favorite places and put it into one room. You can travel the world in one room. A lot of the things they wish for are like things that probably nobody wants
And you would probably end up insane anyway. The idea is that absolute power messes up your mind, and desires magically obtained out of thin air without any effort will probably have a hidden cost. Ultimately, you shouldn't mess with something you don't fully understand, and everything has consequences and costs. These are simple concept that are the base for a lot of great stories. It's basically a sci-fi version of the classic genie's wish that ends up very badly no matter what you wish.
@@Shendue *wishes for a full body dive technology that makes you dream inside a vr world as some sort of god who can make anything in that world* Seems, rather fine?
@@Shendue you could easily do some stuff with it and mess with reality, just like wishing to have your conscience transplanted to a fully developed robot created by your wish just to live forever without needing basic forms of human needs
Imagine how fairly comfortable you could live if you used the room not as a genie but as a magic Alexa that does little miracles. Nothing bad can happen from wishing for a nice comfy bed, the best furniture and appliances, etc. Always wish for indoor use stuff
wish for the winning numbers at the next loterry. Wish for a calendar which shows you in the future major events. Wish for basically anything that can help you make money outside the house, so you basically have a free cheatcode with limited use.
You could wish for plans and schematics for extremely advanced technologies like FTL drives, replicators, teleporters, etc... Then copy the schematics on paper that can leave the room. You could wish for a step by step plan to create a utopia on earth, or world peace, or a panacea. If a person wished for knowledge, it would be a much better use of the room than wishing for material things.
@@robertnett9793 That's why I said to wish for plans and knowledge to accomplish your goals, instead of material objects. If you don't like the plans, don't follow them, or make the wish a different way.
no need for all that. Wish for an undefeatable AI program that can carry that plan from inside the room through the internet to the entire world. What? you gonna read all that bs? let the AI do it instead. Full chaos, undisclose every secret, publicly free share every blueprint of advanced technology, overtake and deactivate all weapons and overthrow all governments. etc etc, you name it
I'll just make that room the most perfect gaming room anyone could ask for and you won't need to go out since you could just wish foods and drinks. Edit: I got a question for those people saying that I would die if I go out because the food will turn into ashes. Who the fck said that I would go out the room? I literally can have anything inside the room so why would I even bother to go out lol?
Spoiler: Imagine if Shane wished a universe within the room for the couple to be trapped in and he sacrificed himself so they would think its the real world. And he would be reincarnated as that baby she has
They can wish for something to check if they are still in the room. But he rapidly aged, which is som,ething that can be done in the real world. Doubt he will be smart enough to think about that since he is a grown teenager only physically
I’m curious about what would happen if she wished for makeup, put it on, and then walked outside. Would her face just suddenly be covered in ashes and makeup free? Would her face turn into ash entirely since the makeup would be slightly absorbed into her skin? Don’t ask me why I randomly thought of the most dumb wish ever but here I am.
I reckon it would just take the make up, I mean it’s not your face you wished for unless it’s like a proper malevolent wish room then it would definitely take your whole face 😂
A room that grants any wish and they barely scratched the surface of it's potential...could've wished for powers of invisibility/supersenses/flying/teleportation, healing, etc. learnt any language, heck even wish for the room to become an imaginary realm like middle earth, but no, instead they wish for the usual crap like money.
@@Austeja608 still they had unlimited food, electronics, supplies, and could have lived a good life, but they were reckless, not wanting to know the price of the room
i would have wished for a amazing driving road and race track , and all the dream cars i could want, after a long day of work i just drive like a mad man
A more in depth explanation(taken from Reddit) “It's a bit confusing but I learned that if the creator is killed then the thing wished for or created lives on. When Shane (the son) raped his mother he impregnated her, which means he created life in his mother's womb.... and he died which means what he created lives on. Because his the product of the room he did not need to wish for the child, by creating something else he was actually fulfilling the ritual of wishing cause his been yearning to live with his mother forever and if you think of it he fulfilled that wish by giving his mother a piece of himself. The lights flickering at the end simply means she is holding a child of a figmented person (a product of the room). Everytime the lights flicker it means a wish was made or being granted so Shane's wish was granted. That's my hypothesis of the end.”
yes but she was already pregnant, since the tests need to be taken after some time. So the light shouldn't flicker after a couple of days but when the pregnancy started
If you can practically wish for another room within the room, why even bother with materialistic things that you need to take out. If you do want to take something out, wish for something that will last a bit longer; based on the speed of aging, you could get away with wishing for precious metals or diamonds. Also, since you can wish something away, once it’s in the room, you may as well run a junk removal business lol.
Take the entire world garbage supply there and wish it to disappear. Solved trash issues! ... except the world might lose a lot of mass and we will never get it back for decomposition or recycling...
You can wish to own a city and then live in it. Then you can start wishing things like car plane... the only problem is the city will be empty and no human beings wish sucks. Also you can bring your loved ones and still have a happy life in there. Until one of them misses up.
Because it’s all fake. The people you create, the experiences you have. They’re all limited by your imagination. The real world is unpredictable and full of surprise.
@@rey_nemaattori but the room includes everything inside it ..otherwise it could just be four walls. So if you are inside, you cease to exist.. I don't even know man
If Kate got pregnant from Shane it would end up in a miscarriage since they are outside the house. If Shane is the father that means she's still inside the house. 🤦🏽♂️
I doubt they are still inside the house since they have most likely met other people and shane has little to know idea about how other humans act. It's likely shane impregnated her since she couldn't have a child before with multiple miscarriage's. It's a dark and twisted tale just like the one before.
@@Wofulrumble4893 Highly doubtful its Shane's, thats just a dark twist to make the audience think. What OP said is true, also having 2 miscarriages by 1 man doesn't mean the third pregnancy cant be his. Also the fact that she took a pregnancy test a month after the incident means they've had sex between that time otherwise she would've taken it a week or two after. Additionally, theres many reasons for successful pregnancies after miscarriages, the trauma from the incident could've kick started her biological imperative to reproduce.
Not once does anyone ask for an instruction manual for the magical, wish granting room. "I want a book that explains, in detail, with terms and instructions that I can understand, what your deal is."
Simple solution. Wish for things that you can reproduce. Step 1: Wish for today’s winning Lotto ticket. Step 2: Write down numbers from ticket. Step 3: Buy Lotto ticket with the numbers you wrote down.
Or similarly, gambling: wish to know the result of every season playoff, or the future of the stock market and which stocks to buy. Boomchakalaka. Money you can use outside.
As a young boy, 18 years ago I kept telling my friends that one day we would have summarized movies and they all laughed. If you could ever grant me a wish please do a recap on Citizen Kane. That movie is way too long for me. I've tried watching it 7 times and I've never gone past 30 minutes.
Me as a black person: *looks at house ,looks At the weird ass walls,looks around the area, go among the neighbors asking for history, hears the owners have died* Me: not a minute in there longer
I would be afraid that the house is evil. lol But in reality, there are no real consequences for making wishes in the room. Just don't wish for a baby. lol
Solution for the money: Wish for an ATM, deposit all the money, then just like that the money is connected to your bank account and therefore can't actually age or technically leave the house.
@@Zen-nu1fb the data packets are generated by the ATM inside the room which will cease to exist as soon as they enter the part of the wiring outside the house i.e 100% data loss
They should have wished for a powerful artifact that allows the granted wishes to exist outside the house. This is how you exploit the mechanism of a wish granting machine by wishing for an artifact that gets rid of the limitations of their wishes.
Honestly, I kinda like it, but the Premise of not being able to take things out of the house being an end game for these people is pretty dumb. Like wish for some furniture, then wish for an AI that makes Vtuber accounts and profit. (EDIT) You can also create an infinite world full of nature and beauty.
I would honestly create a room full of portals It would lead infinitely Forward I could add more portals Those portals would transfer me to another universe I would always have the ability to respawn aslong as I died in those universe and the ability to go back to the Hub I would then create universes have sex,eat food,FLY,idk destroy the universe become god,play minecraft,Create a crypto machine Etc
But then wouldn't technically the videos (data) of said Vtuber Account or even real account (if you say, wished for a real but loyal or docile person recording the videos in a room of the house or even a simulated universe, world or area within) vanish as soon as you tried to upload as they'd leave the house? I'm not sure what would happen if you were record this through an external source like a video camera and if the rules would then still apply. Maybe it works if you basically record with a "real camera" and not one you wished for.
I completely understand wishing for money and booze, but why the hell would you wish for a child, that’s like wishing for trouble, and a massive one at that, assuming that the kid doesn’t grow into a psychopathic rapist/murderer like he did in the movie.
Here's one of the approaches I'd take ;- Step one : wish for all the important knowledge for humanity - knowledge on how to cure all diseases (cancer, aging, injury etc..) - how to build nanotech, teleportation etc... Step two: - make a physical copy of it and store it outside the house Step three : - use the knowledge to end all diseases and suffering make humanity an advanced post scarcity civilisation
You can't take out physical items but you can take out information So simply wish for useful information that you can use in the outside world e.g how to cure all diseases, How to become biologically immortal etc... Once you've got that info, copy it to a medium that wouldn't decay e.g a bunch of hard drives from the outside world Then boom, you can share that info with humanity, use it to become a billionaire etc.. This room is an absolute blessing. These characters were just super short sighted
There weren't even any real consequences for making wishes, and yet they still managed to mess it up
So couples are being warned, kids will mess things up and do age with the speed of light.
@@eduardochavacano 😂😂
The down side is if you can't handle that power then it's all over.
When they wished for the kid they should have told the kid to wish for another kid then kill the first kid boom kid that can go out
I didnt see anybody in the comment who thought of this
Gotta love that John Doe dude. He was nice enough to warn them.
Survivours of traumatic events usually try to go out of their ways to warn people or help them. It's not unusual.
so how did john doe survive outside of the room?
@@michaelupsala420 because his mother killed his father letting him live outside of the room
@@michaelupsala420 Because his "mother" killed his "father" and then she died too. So he was able to leave without consequences
Poor guy just get locked up after leaving the house
"I've had two miscarriages so i'll just wish for a child to ensure I do, and to also avoid the pain of childbirth."
We already have a solution to that without a wish granting room and it's called adoption, Kate.
It's always the dumb ones thats name is Kate honestly
@@xavierlee5360 fr
Welp. They could've used some of that money to pay for an IVF also. Maybe they could've tricked the room by having the person who works for a company that does IVF, bring a portable ATM into the home. But would the money turn into ashes if it's moved electronically? 🤷
@@noniaanimates sent 📤📤
@@deesus1085 disagree. As long as you are ready it won't matter
I wish no one finds out I have a room like that.
I found out
I found out
I found out
I found out
I found out
This would be the dream for people that never leave the house. If the room truly has no limits you could create a universe, become immortal, and be the god of that universe.
Introverts: *UNLIMITED POWER!!!*
And the implication is, how do we know that isn't what happened, and that universe is the one we live in.
@@privatename5788 what?
Then wish to recreate the entire world/universe inside the room (much like Shane did with the forest and the cloned house). You literally live inside that room for the rest of your days BUT it would be like living in the actual world. You win.
@@privatename5788 cus all your wishes would come true
So this room basically has no downside aside from the you can't take anything outside rule?
Pretty much perfect as long as you're not dumb enough to wish for a kid
Thats the beauty of the flawed people in this story. People are going to wish for the thing they are missing. They are just the worst people to inherit the room.
"I wish for tomorrow's lottery number." Done, now you're rich and can buy all the material things outside the house. Maybe go and adopt some child in need of love and home. They are so dumb!!!
@@Palla148 it said you can only wish for materialistic things so I don't think it could change events that were to happen
or a car
@@Palla148 lol, ikr. but movie would be 5 minutes long xD
I mean, I don't see the problem with this thing. This solves a lot of problems - you never need to buy new appliances, or books, or movies, because you can just wish for them. This strikes me as something that can only go wrong if you're the sort of person who immediately starts wishing for morally questionable things like real people or children.
Exactly! The film is very intelligent. It has very important wisdom but its still a movie and not a motivational video or a meme. The wife was an idiot,
But can't you just wish those away? I'm not sure why they didn't just wish they kid away after he turned crazy.
@@GizmoMaltese The wife was irrationally attached to the kid. Same reason she wished for the baby in the first place.
I find it very difficult to watch films like these and not come away thinking that having slightly more rational characters would prevent these plots from happening. I don't understand the kind of people who would see a room like this and assume it would give them happiness as opposed to convenience.
I suppose that's the theme: money can't buy happiness, and trying to *make* it buy happiness will guarantee a disaster, but it's too inconsistent for me to suspend my disbelief.
@@GoblinKnightLeo Rational characters? Have you looked around the world? Human beings are not rational actors.
@@GizmoMaltese If we take your argument to its logical conclusion, we cannot ever complain about irrational actions taken by characters in fiction, regardless of how nonsensical or unprompted they might be.
I dont think you would accept that conclusion, but your premise that all people are irrational requires it. If the conclusion is false, the premise is false.
Wishing for a small world within the room is so smart. These recaps of lesser known movies are the best.
It might be smart or it might be a nightmare where you can never be sure if you’re in the room or not.
The concept is similar to Inception or even Star Trek’s holodeck.
As far as Shane turned into dust, they were not in the magic room in my opinion@@Noplayster13
The second thing I would wish for in that room (assuming that the first thing was whatever made me realize that the room granted wishes) would be an instruction manual which explained the rules, limitations, and costs for wishes made in that room.
Are you kira?
You are too dangerous to be outside of Anime universe.
ah i see, someone who reads instruction manuals as well
I don't think you realize how smart you really are lol
Hacked
"Shane has never experienced the outside" technically he spend 99% of his life outside due to his rapid aging
🤣 technically.
Well aging isn’t really time related it’s just the cells decayed iirc and anyone can become “old” just by making their cells less sufficient
He grow years in seconds with no water or food?
@@f0lkblues And think about the waste-heat generated during the process. Chemistry is a bitch like that.
@@f0lkblues 😂fr, he would've died. Old was a terrible movie but at least the baby in it died within seconds of neglect.
Matt: No, Shane! Don't enter the room
Shane: *It's free real estate*
I just realized, how do we know we're not living in the room right now.
@@Ehatntmtntahe because try wishing for something you see nothing appear boom not in the room
@@Heidijackward I'm so dumb... You're right.
@@Heidijackward "I wish that whenever I make a wish, the lights don't flicker"
BOOM back to square one
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I actually feel bad for that John Doe... he was just a wish granted by the room just like Shane, he couldn't leave the house at all but, when he finally had the chance to do it, he got trapped in another building for life, that psychiatry hospital...
I thought that Jon Doe being a wished child means they are all inside the room, because Jon Doe would turn to dust if he left the house, so he wished for an entire world inside the room...
@@andrijajovanovic1589yes, but if his mother is killed, he can live and that’s what he did.
Room: "I'll grant all your wishes, but you can't bring it outside"
Gamers: "challenge accepted!"
Quad SLI RTX 3090 TI , 360hz MONITOR 1ms ping
Let me get my waifu first
LMAO
Anime and movie watcher has enter the chat 😏
hahaa
Shane: *Continuously wishes that his parents never leave the room*
Me: "I wish for all of Shane's wishes to be ineffective. I also wish for me and my partner to leave this room safely and enter the real world."
Shane: "..... Dang it."
In short: uno reverse card
I wish they wished for a brain
Or they could just wish to cancel everything they've ever wish for in the room.
@Zhale Murphy that's not the case because they cloned themselves while in Shane's room
I wish for the room to be destroyed.
The most unrealistic part of this whole story is how Matt bought a gun and had it mailed straight to his house, ESPECIALLY if they live in New York
Eeeeeeegg Zackly 😆
Yeah just wish for a gun
Yeah ur right
@@jordanstricker9296 but that gun would turn into dust if taken outside, hence ..
@@abhinavs6313 I mean if the gun is meant for Shane though
Very lucky they didn't wish for physical alterations , Imagine if Matt wished for a bigger member, only to walk outside and have it turn to dust. 😂
I’d wish for a smaller one, mine’s already too big 😎
Lmfao
@@joeschlomo2143 but you dont have one to begin with bro
@@joeschlomo2143 I'd wish to not have one
there bugging id wish for nutrition rich food that taste like junk food!! just imagine beets kale and spinach that tastes like bacon;)
If everything fake dies outside that house, that would mean the child couldn't be their son's, as his seed or the part of the baby that has grown out of it would be dead too, so she wouldn't get pregnant.
They might still be in the room the entire time
Yeah. So this is the two possibilities
@@Brandon-ob9rg
If they're still in the room then why did the guy turn to dust?
The only way for that to happen would be if he wished himself into dust to trick them, but I doubt someone like that would be willing to sacrifice themselves.
@@Nobody-ed9bv oh shit... Good point.
@@Nobody-ed9bv or wish for a clone of them to turn into dust
Shane wins. He wished his parents ("parents") could never leave the room, that they were forever his, and that he would be around forever. The room made it their universe and it got creative about it.
why dont they just test the theory by wishing for stuff
@@notanonymous3976 By wishing they could never leave the room, that they were his forever, and that he would be around forever... removing their ability to have any power, like wishing for stuff, would be a part of what the room would need to do to grant that wish.
@@LiminalHorror right
It grants material wishes from what I could gather from the story.
So Wishing someone to never leave or have no wishes seems to contradict that.
@@LiminalHorror I think they could just wish that everything went back to be the way it was prior to their first wish. End credits haha.
But then there's no movie.
So, no one is mentioning the statement "The only thing more dangerous than a person who cant get what they want is the person who gets whatever they want."
That's a horror story in real life.
Indeed it is.
Epstein. Harvey. Clinton. Etc
Indeed
@Lori Voss It's obviously if u yourself say the word that u find annoying 🧐
That's ridiculous. If you get what you want, then by definition you can't be unhappy/unsatisfied because it's what you want.
imagine how creative people could truly get with a home that grants wishes, of course due to budget reasons the movie could not explore those possibilities
Not to mention, most Hollywood writers aren't that creative.
@@Jay_76 hahaha very true!
This movie is really interesting, it has a lot of plot and lessons
I hope they make a sequel that actually goes into more detail on the room itself.
Yes
All of it could've been avoided if the dumbass wife didn't wish for a kid.
@@y.e.a.h5634 they couldn't have children that's why she wished for one. And they would be no movie if she hadn't.
This channel is so much better than watching a movie
true, they call it speed run a movie
Bruh.. If it wasn’t for the recap, I would stop and yell at the idiot couple that brought the house before doing research
@@Vraii25 yes true tho
I’ve watched about 20 movies in two hours
@@dazzaMusic yep
Room: Grant a wish but cannot bring it outside
Introvert: I see this as a win
LOL!
Wish for a kid tell the kid to wish for a baby;-; kill the creator ez
Kill the kid :)
@@kenmausisa3742
problem solved
keep wishing for the newest nvidia gfx cards, then selling them hand 2 hand (for real outside world money) while in the house. Recording for (court) evidence that everything you sell is working and is real.
The mother protects Shane just like I protect my cat. I get terrified at the thought of it going outside and protect her from leaving the house.
someone needs to show me to this room ASAP
That’s kinda sus
shush you would just wish for red to be voted out.
BOII every video I go to, I see Imposter.... S U S
You again
I see you in almost every video I watch
Are you a hacker now
@@austinboston4247 😂😂😂👍
All this could've been avoided if Kate actually consulted her husband first before trying to force him into fatherhood.
He wanted a child, thats why he bought a crib early on in the movie. The bad thing is she's using strange magic to get it
@@Oreo-vh7rk Yeah, but the wonderful thing about conception and pregnancy is it gives about a year of prep time. Rushing prep time and well, love turned to hate real quick.
@@darkpaw1522 he didnt care for shane anyway so its not fatherhood if kate was the only one taking care of shane
@@darkpaw1522 whether it takes 1 year or 2 to give birth, it doesn't change the fact that the baby is already coming out soon. So he needs to be ready the moment he realises she is pregnant anyway. What's the difference ?
Plus he is the one who wanted to try for another. How can he change his stance that quickly ?
@@bp-u-will-always-be-famous In the movie, she became upset at him for not being a father to Shane and calling it a "thing". She was trying to force him into fatherhood.
Why not wish to be able to take the things outside?
Bro you are making sense, stop it.
If you wish for that, you'll just get a note saying, whoever wishes it must die, so then someone else would be taking the stuff outside.
You would have to go out and look for a homeless guy that noone will miss. Make him wish for everything you want. Then kill him and you can take it all outside.
Alternatively, you could use a person that's dying anyway and get them to do it. However, that might not work if they die of a natural death. Part of it is probably that it's evil magic, so a murder must be involved.
That’s like telling a genie you wish for more than 3 wishes, not allowed. There are rules to this shit lol
If I got it right, the room can only grant material things, this power would be imaterial
Homie bro sugar plum that's not a fuckung material possesion
1:45, just like that he suddenly realizes the room can grant wishes, as if it's the most normal thing in the world. 😀
"I did not hit her. It's not true. That's bullshit. I did not hit her. I did nottttt. Oh hi Mark."
That's what I thought at first lmao
the room and disaster artist 😂
Love this part of the movie.
Wrong room, lol
i was genuinely scared when the first 10 sec is over
This was a great 12-minute movie. This is how I'm watching all my movies from now on! I still have time to do other stuff.
Same here. One movie a day
Lol, yep
There is one downside of watching 12 minute movies is that you cannot remember the movie after a few days. Watching a 2 hour movie will stay in your memory for long.
It’s the best!
Me too😂 I can see three movies a day and not feeling bad for all the Time wasted…
So this couple can lock shane up in their house but not lock the doors in their bedroom? 🤡
BAHAHHAHAHAHAHHAhaHHAH
In Hollywood Land, nobody secures a door before doing something others passing by shouldn't see or hear. A discussion between a traitor and antagonist? Allow us to have a conversation with the door slightly ajar and don't forget to YELL!
Locked or not Shane wanted to blast his mom's cheeks
@@DareToBeDeviant that's not loud enough!
Army?
Since we know that if the wish-maker dies then their wishes don't fade after leaving the room. We can assume the following:
1. Wish for a man who wishes for whatever you wish for.
2. Tell the man to wish for what you want
3. Tell the man to die
So you saying wish for a parrot who wish for whatever you wish for and you wish for him to die at the same time he wish for you to die...
@@bilgebaykus6569 holy shit,that could explain the bird in the starting of the movie
@@Aarush04 mind blown 🤯
@@Aarush04 elaborate ?
So basically, you can get whatever you want, but you have to kill a man to get it.
You could just create the perfect world within that one room, where your entire family is alive and well, and you have anything you could imagine.
tbf,one of them will definitely fucked it up
Is that any different than the matrix?
I'd use it as a play world and give myself super human abilities. It would be the best VR imaginable.
@@p3nt4l1ty3 wish for only ur wishes to come true ✌🏽
Rule: You cannot wish for living things.
I feel like i watched every movie ever been bcz of this dude 😁
Not all some movie explains it self
exactly right
Pretty sure as soon as i realised what the room did i would have wished for a manual on what the rules of the room are. Is there a price to pay later? Is there a way to expand the wish-gratnting area? Can we build a second house with a room like that? Can we stop our aging? Can the knowledge gained in the room be carried outside? If so could we just wish for a bunch of geniuses with their corresponding labs to solve all of humanity's problems and write the solutions down on non-room notebooks to share with everyone? So much knowledge just one wish away.
I think the point of the movie was that no matter what you wished, the ending outcome would be a fuckup no matter what.
It would probably come back and bite you in the butt anyway. It's pretty much a D&D genie wish spell.
@@Shendue And this guy knows damn well that if he got a room where he could wish anything, the thought wouldn't even cross his mind. It's easy to think of a these smart wishes when u aren't in the situation.
i think the knowledge would have an scp-055 type effect where the people would forget to write the info down at all
I would wish for the revival of sir Einstein sir, Stephen Hawkings , sir Newton and sir scheödinger haha . Give them all the books and workspace and tell them that they have reached heaven 🤓🤧
I would wish that the rules are no longer there then wish for good stuff
Honestly as long as you don't take the stuff outside or wish for people. That's a sweet deal
How is that different than a video game? or a movie?
The baby is clearly Matt's. Since everything created in the room disintegrates when taken outside. If it were Shane's baby, then she would've already pissed dust.
creations stay if their creator dies. shane would've been it's "creator" and he died.
Also, there's always the thought that Kate might still be in The Room... It's honestly impossible to tell
@@kyledavis23 they cant still be in the room though right? if they were they would still be able to wish for stuff.
@@somethingbanter Very good point!
@@somethingbanter no, WISHES stay if the creator dies. Not creations. That rape wasn't a wish, and that baby definitely wouldn't be one.
Alternate ending:
"I wish my son didn't turn to dust!"
Room:"shit dawg you got me! '
Although I know it’s a joke, Shane would still die of old age if he left the house.
unfortunately, the room does not allow counter arguments to itself. but what i dont understand is why did they even need a child? they could have wished for literal heaven to their minds extend and just live there forever. whats the point of ever going outside, when you have infinite in that room?
@@descendinggod9740
At the beginning, because of past miscarriages.
At the middle, because of the plot.
At the end, because of trauma.
the big brain ending
@@descendinggod9740 That's impossible to not allow counter arguments if every which can be granted including reality breaking wishes like a full outdoor place inside the room. Also there's no need to go outside. Just wish for a 1 to 1 mirror of the real outside world inside the room and live there as if you're outside because you'd not even recognize the difference.
Couldn’t he just wish for a clone of her instead of kidnapping her
STOP
bro
@Milan Kaurin He said Clone...meaning 100% exact same thing. When 100000 iPhones are produced, aren't they clones of each other?
@Milan Kaurin all of which are made in China
FBI OPEN UP
Would love this as a thought experiment. So the basic rules: your wish is material so no "super powers" or "grant me knowledge". The wish can only create/alter things inside the room. Your wish cannot alter how the room works. Anything created by the room disintegrates when it leaves. The room cannot provide you with knowledge of the future (like lottery numbers).
I would wish for something I could copy like a fantastic new novel (I might be able to conjure it on a disc or something and copy-paste to my computer , but even if that wouldn't work, just conjure it on paper then type it up myself). I could do this for all sorts, like plans and schematics and such. If the digital copy-paste method works then even better - I could make all sorts of fun things like graphics, novels, comics, games, applications and more. These can be published/sold/etc for money I could use outside - pay taxes, nights out, etc. I could create new houses within that room like extra dimensional spaces - my family could move in and have private mansions on private islands with everything they could need.
It would be everything. Pure contentment. Bliss. Problem is, wouldn't be entertaining for a movie so of course the people in the movie had to be stupid about it. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
your logic implies humans are perfect which they arent, your kids would do you in pal, they would mess all up
@@Azuria969 My logic doesn't imply any such thing. I have no kids. Was your reply meant for somebody else? It doesn't make sense.
I mean you could wish for like 5,000 lbs of gold. Take it out and since gold won't "age" into dust, sell it for money and become super rich as well
Shane had the opportunity to wish for a pretty girl, who would have been similar to him, but no...
Making a trap for his mother was the best solution
the only woman he ever saw was his mom
Well technically she wasn't her mom.
Clearly she didnt wish for a smart child.
Then don't traumatize your kids by fucking in their presence. Not to mention mat explained him in detail how they aren't his parents.
This is just ckassic Freud it is often used in cinema
Room: "you can have anything as long as you don't bring any outside"
* OK MATE, NOW GIVE ME SUPER CRYPTO FARM MACHINE *
exactly the same thought haha
Sure room give me access to all the rich people accounts, so i can get real money. Or sure make me smart enough to hack any account without being ever caught.
You guys are slow motion. Im wishing for the next 10 powerball draws. I wont stop there ill have a PDF of every lottery number in ever state for the next 20 years. Im gonna be loaded
@@mewtwo6662 kinda obvious if you win them all 😂
FBI open up!
Me: Walks into the room. Close my eyes and makes a wish.
Tommy Wiseau walks in.
"I did not hit her, it is not true, its bullshit. I did not her. I DID NOT! oh hi mark."
Lmao dude this needs more likes
Movie name plz
@@blulemon7481 movie of this name plz
The movie is called "The Room" also. Lol.
What's new with you?
that room is literally consequence free. They just brought it to themselves. if I were the one in their situation, I would have never ever left the house cause i have everything i need. food, everything! I can just literally live in the room itself, with just loopholing to get real life money so i can get some irl nights out if i really wanted some human company(but hey, who needs that when you got your wifus?) i'll just also renovate the house a bit so i can live a super modern life just never leaving? It's literally something worth but..
enters the "oh we want babies" and the "maybe we can do bla, bla, bla" people.
To be honest, the only people who can actually see the room for what it should be used for is the introverts, gamer, people in the comment section, and any decent fangirls and fanguys who just want to use that room for what it should be used for. They literally have something any person in the world would want, the ones who desperately wanted to shift realities or whatever. Yet they WASTED IT AND BROUGHT THE BAD LUCK TO THEMSELVES!
Ok, point proven.
Note to self:
If u ever find a room in ur house that can only unlock with a resident evil 2 key.... just let it lone🤔
Literally, took one look at that key and said nope
Yeah, looks like something straight out of Hellraiser.
It's like i am not a movie main character nor im not getting paid Millions by Hollywood to cast in this shit, i am out.
Imagine having this room in the middle of a pandemic.
I wish for a rtx 3080
Room:even i cant do such thing
I wish for unlimited clones of my crush
Like I would wish for gaming accecories and PC's and play with my siblings
@@soundwave5191 😅
@@soundwave5191 and what would you do with all those clones?
I never understand why people like Matt get so angry at literally everything. Bro, you have a genie for a room! EMBRACE IT!
Isnt that the point? He embraced it and took it for granted?
@@CallsignYukiMizuki you can’t embrace something while taking it for granted. it’s counterintuitive
@@CallsignYukiMizuki think of it as embracing something like it can leave you anytime, when you truly value something you won't take it for granted
But his wife did make a baby without consulting him first, he has every right to be angry right there.
@@GardenfRedRoses777 but he was angry before that
Really nice story recap, tks a lot !
"the wish-granting roomba"
That joke is way too funny for a movie like this
Never use a unknown magic to create an living being.
Facts
Noted
I wish,,,,,,, God were in this room.
The most basic rule everyone loves to break.
@@heedmywarning2792 You could literally understand If God, Heaven, Hell, Aliens, Jesus, Mohammed, Noah. And every answer to mankind has ever existed. I would become the most Enlighted human being but also the saddest person If I find the answers to my questions.
Ah the sound of flickering lights, gotta be the most terrifying sound ever
LMAO I was thinking the same thing!
Imma need you to start putting links to watch the ENTIRE movie. These are TOO GOOD!! 🔥
my first wish would be for a book explaining the origins of the room and it rule and consequences
1 000 000 I.Q.
Exactly
Well... 2nd wish, after I realized it could grant wishes
Or wish that there are no unintended consequences to your wishes and you can wish for whatever you want without any problems.
@@asandax6 that could potentially negate your wishes, i.e. if the 'consequences'/cause and effect of making a wish is nullified that would result in manifesting 'nothing'.
That's the only way to ensure 0% consequences, e.g. if he asked for money in his pocket, sure the money deteriorating would be nullified, but so would the all the other [passive] effects of making said [any] wish.
The money wouldn't weigh anything, the paper wouldn't decompose, or be eligible for use (since a potential consequences could be arrested for money fraud/owning fake/printed money). The wish should nullify itself to guarantee no consequences. 😂
a person with great self-control and wisdom could achieve so much with this room.
I genuinely doubt that any human has the self control necessary to handle an infinite wishing machine.
It'd just be a matter of when that self control runs out, not if. I think that with such a room, the more wishes one makes, the more likely it is they lose self control, with a false sense of 'safety' increasing with every wish that turns out well.
Imagine if the baby is shane's and it has the ability to wish for anything without being in the room
Ohhh- this is a good plot twist since Shane came from the powers of the room-
There's already a Twilight Zone episode like that. Or I think it was in the Twilight Zone movie.
that baby would’ve turned to dust already
I’d wish for an Almanac of all the future events and milestones for the next year so I can make bets and win big in the real world
Honestly this would be awesome as a person that wouldn’t want anything to do with this world after finding the room. I would wish for an entirely different world fantasy adventure based and wish for the ability to be completely invulnerable to anything and just have a grand time!
Sounds like a great wish to me
while that sounds like a good idea, I would say that that's worse than real life. When you have all the power in the world, everything will become boring. The best representation of this IMO is saitama from onepunch, he's basically a god and no one can even scratch him, but with that power nothing is really a challenge. not having enough stress in your life can make you depressed
I only said I would be invulnerable, you know so I wouldn’t be blown to smitherines from a fireball. And the beauty of the room is that I could adjust anything I wanted to make it more enjoyable including removing said invulnerability whenever I wanted to. There is only a down side in the realization that none of it is truly real of course, but then again the person that it actually created could become real with the sacrifice of another. Also if you chose to create a word where time is different than the real world, you could in essence spend any amount of time in the room and have it not last but a moment in real time, thus losing nothing and gaining real knowledge that could be put to use in the real world, of course I don’t know the rules for how that would affect you as a real person.
I have a theory
What if Narnia closet origin story is this
Narnia where you go into a closet and see a new world while time passes differently
Omg wish to be in genshin impact
If I were Mat, I’d just wished for an iron man suit
“Parry this you casual”
don't forget to add Filthy before the Casual
Hahahah this comment is gold
@@xxandyxx569 oh how could I forget
What about the omnitrix
@@thefnfrobloxGDlover well anything would do
Heck why not the infinity suit from Ultron in the What if.... story lines
The scp foundation would like to know the location of this room as well.
😂😂😂😂fosho
Don't worry already contact Dr.Brigth and Clef with the 05 council
With that room, the rat's nest won't be a problem anymore
Secure, Contain and Protect, hehe.
I see you are a man of culture
Dude I really love your videos. I love movies but I don't have time to watch then. But your 10 to 30 min resumes help me a LOT
Ok, who here would wish for the Library of Alexandria to be perfectly replicated and with the books in text you could read?
The knowledge you have would be gone like a zahimer
@@محمدالميلادي-ط5ر not true. If that were the case then knowledge of the room itself and all things learned inside of it would be gone as soon as they stepped out of the door into the outside world.
@@Deathtollscorner Nope. Incorrect. You wished for the knowledge of the world with that Library. You read and absorbed every piece of knowledge that you could in whatever time you allotted to yourself. The physical pieces of the Library would dust, but the knowledge that you gleaned from it was never wished for. You LEARNED it. That was never wished for. The knowledge is real and can exist outside the walls and confines of the house. The physical knowledge cannot because that was wished for.
This is an easy one to get past.
Now, if you wished for all the knowledge of the Library without making the Library happen, then yeah, soon as you leave the house that knowledge goes away.
You have to remember how these wishes work and play the game.
@@BigDaddyJinx Unless you got real paper/pen and write everything before leaving the room.
@@slenderbc0751 or you know, take a photo like a normal human being instead of spending hours writing each book by hand on a paper
They could have wished for a valid 1 million dollar cheque, and used their phones to auto deposit them.
I know right for real
What sorcery is this?!?!
Ur to smart to be kept alive
@@kontrarien5721 technology :D
wouldnt it be suspicious?, i mean someone with suddenly 1 million dollars? dont a lot of thieves get caught this way?
“ the only thing more dangerous then a person who can’t get what they want is a person who can get whatever they want “ powerful message 💯🙌🏾
Basically Squid Game
man i likes these videos, i literally watched an entire movie in 13 min. Talk about efficiency!
the room takes on a whole new meaning when its 1 person with the room. as long as you know the rules and play within your limits it brings you unlimited fun. if i was in this movie i would put rules on the door to the room before my death so the next owners can be careful and enjoy without something this horrible happening
aww ... You are too kind sir .
Why whenever people in movies are given the ability to wish for stuff they wish for some boring cliche things? They need to take a page out of Starlord’s book and start wishing for some interesting stuff.
The only reason this is a horror movie is because these people couldn’t think beyond some paintings, money, and a baby. Bruh, I’d be wishing for characters from magical worlds and shiz. I’d invite my friends over and they’d be shocked to find Aslan and Princess Peach drinking blue milk from Stars Wars while My Little Pony and Girls Und Panzer characters have a Wii Sports tournament in the living room. My house would be POPPING!
Also, if HAD to be boring and just go for financial gain , couldn’t I wish for a valid check and then cash it digitally? That’s the thing with all these antiquated cursed houses and stuff, they’re so old that technology gives us loop-holes around their arbitrary rules.
Imma be partying on yacht with Animal Crossing characters y’all.
Legit tho. Like there only seems to be consequences when you create "living" beings so everything else is on the table. You can legit bring anything else so you could make a mish mash of a bunch of your favorite places and put it into one room. You can travel the world in one room. A lot of the things they wish for are like things that probably nobody wants
And you would probably end up insane anyway.
The idea is that absolute power messes up your mind, and desires magically obtained out of thin air without any effort will probably have a hidden cost.
Ultimately, you shouldn't mess with something you don't fully understand, and everything has consequences and costs. These are simple concept that are the base for a lot of great stories.
It's basically a sci-fi version of the classic genie's wish that ends up very badly no matter what you wish.
@@Shendue *wishes for a full body dive technology that makes you dream inside a vr world as some sort of god who can make anything in that world*
Seems, rather fine?
@@Shendue you could easily do some stuff with it and mess with reality, just like wishing to have your conscience transplanted to a fully developed robot created by your wish just to live forever without needing basic forms of human needs
Hm you could create a city in this room, or lifing lego
Imagine how fairly comfortable you could live if you used the room not as a genie but as a magic Alexa that does little miracles.
Nothing bad can happen from wishing for a nice comfy bed, the best furniture and appliances, etc. Always wish for indoor use stuff
wish for the winning numbers at the next loterry. Wish for a calendar which shows you in the future major events. Wish for basically anything that can help you make money outside the house, so you basically have a free cheatcode with limited use.
Don't say that or a guy name Shendue is going to say you'll turn insane anyway for using the room 🤣
@@alexwindy3 wish for a crystal ball.
@@alexwindy3 You cannot wish for things that do not yet exist.
shane: tries to keep me in the room
me: 'i wish shane never existed and that the room didn't either'
shane: aw crap you've foiled my cunning plan
You could wish for plans and schematics for extremely advanced technologies like FTL drives, replicators, teleporters, etc... Then copy the schematics on paper that can leave the room. You could wish for a step by step plan to create a utopia on earth, or world peace, or a panacea. If a person wished for knowledge, it would be a much better use of the room than wishing for material things.
Imagine wishing for world peace and all you get is one infinity gauntlet...
@@robertnett9793 That's why I said to wish for plans and knowledge to accomplish your goals, instead of material objects. If you don't like the plans, don't follow them, or make the wish a different way.
@William Howe Yeah, such as plans and schematics.
no need for all that. Wish for an undefeatable AI program that can carry that plan from inside the room through the internet to the entire world. What? you gonna read all that bs? let the AI do it instead.
Full chaos, undisclose every secret, publicly free share every blueprint of advanced technology, overtake and deactivate all weapons and overthrow all governments. etc etc, you name it
"i wish for a 3d printer that can print anything from any matter"
immediately wishing for art pieces is the most artistic thing I've ever seen 😭 I am an artist and I would do the same thing as well.
This is one way of saying you’re as stupid as he was
But money...
I'll just make that room the most perfect gaming room anyone could ask for and you won't need to go out since you could just wish foods and drinks.
Edit: I got a question for those people saying that I would die if I go out because the food will turn into ashes.
Who the fck said that I would go out the room? I literally can have anything inside the room so why would I even bother to go out lol?
The food n drink that you ate will turn u to ash if u go out the room, resulting death lmao
Amen
@@Secretxxx67 no
@@Secretxxx67 that's not how it works and also in the movie they ordered and ate food and they went outside you sound stupid
@@Secretxxx67 hey at least we died from eating and drinking while playing video games...
If I had a room like this. I would never have an issue I couldn’t solve again in my life.
It would be awesome if they created a series where they explore "every" kind of "what if.." scenario
Yes!!!
isnt that the fantasy island series?
@@Ryuzaki712 I didn't know that serie. Do you recommend it?
marvel: on your left
“Kill Kate and save Shane or kill Shane and save Kate” That was a bit of tounge twister. If you repeat multiple times...Kill Kane and shave Sate
Spoiler:
Imagine if Shane wished a universe within the room for the couple to be trapped in and he sacrificed himself so they would think its the real world. And he would be reincarnated as that baby she has
They can wish for something to check if they are still in the room. But he rapidly aged, which is som,ething that can be done in the real world. Doubt he will be smart enough to think about that since he is a grown teenager only physically
Spoiler plot twist:
it was just Matt's dream
I am beyond confused
@@danepher idk why would he force himself on his mom🤔 he was very young when he shape shifted🤔
@@nilanjasa007 He saw the parents doing it and though that that way his mom will love him. You do see it in the film
I’m curious about what would happen if she wished for makeup, put it on, and then walked outside. Would her face just suddenly be covered in ashes and makeup free? Would her face turn into ash entirely since the makeup would be slightly absorbed into her skin? Don’t ask me why I randomly thought of the most dumb wish ever but here I am.
That is kinda nice question, not a dumb one.
I reckon it would just take the make up, I mean it’s not your face you wished for unless it’s like a proper malevolent wish room then it would definitely take your whole face 😂
Maybe it would take the makeup and like graze the skin where the makeup was? Like a superficial wound, nothing major.
What would happen if you wore makeup and never took it off. It would eventually just turn into dust and blow away or get absorbed into your skin.
A room that grants any wish and they barely scratched the surface of it's potential...could've wished for powers of invisibility/supersenses/flying/teleportation, healing, etc. learnt any language, heck even wish for the room to become an imaginary realm like middle earth, but no, instead they wish for the usual crap like money.
Outside house wishes becomes ineffective and turns into dust
They made the characters generic, which is why I don’t like movies like this
@@Austeja608 still they had unlimited food, electronics, supplies, and could have lived a good life, but they were reckless, not wanting to know the price of the room
@@sword4005 wouldnt the food turn into dust therefore killing them if they left the house
i would have wished for a amazing driving road and race track , and all the dream cars i could want, after a long day of work i just drive like a mad man
A more in depth explanation(taken from Reddit)
“It's a bit confusing but I learned that if the creator is killed then the thing wished for or created lives on. When Shane (the son) raped his mother he impregnated her, which means he created life in his mother's womb.... and he died which means what he created lives on. Because his the product of the room he did not need to wish for the child, by creating something else he was actually fulfilling the ritual of wishing cause his been yearning to live with his mother forever and if you think of it he fulfilled that wish by giving his mother a piece of himself.
The lights flickering at the end simply means she is holding a child of a figmented person (a product of the room). Everytime the lights flicker it means a wish was made or being granted so Shane's wish was granted.
That's my hypothesis of the end.”
yes but she was already pregnant, since the tests need to be taken after some time.
So the light shouldn't flicker after a couple of days but when the pregnancy started
Good one.
If you can practically wish for another room within the room, why even bother with materialistic things that you need to take out. If you do want to take something out, wish for something that will last a bit longer; based on the speed of aging, you could get away with wishing for precious metals or diamonds.
Also, since you can wish something away, once it’s in the room, you may as well run a junk removal business lol.
Take the entire world garbage supply there and wish it to disappear. Solved trash issues!
... except the world might lose a lot of mass and we will never get it back for decomposition or recycling...
You can wish to own a city and then live in it. Then you can start wishing things like car plane... the only problem is the city will be empty and no human beings wish sucks. Also you can bring your loved ones and still have a happy life in there. Until one of them misses up.
Because it’s all fake. The people you create, the experiences you have. They’re all limited by your imagination. The real world is unpredictable and full of surprise.
This room is something the SCP Foundation should handle
If they were in the room at the end they could just wish for the room to go back to its normal size
True!
Also, I was thinking, what would happen if they wished for the room to never exist. What would happen to the people inside? 🤔
@@GardenfRedRoses777 The room wouldn't exist to trap them inside in the first place.
@@rey_nemaattori but the room includes everything inside it ..otherwise it could just be four walls. So if you are inside, you cease to exist..
I don't even know man
@@GardenfRedRoses777 no its just like alexa. U can set it so it only recognizes one voice.
couldn't matt have just wished Shane away....I know that would kill the action/movie but come on....
I don’t think you can counter things the room has already created
@@rulinghand2166 but thats literally what they wanted to do with the baby.
Should be added to movie sins lmao
They wanted in the beginning but he couldn't bring himself to do it... because morals. But why he didn't that when Shane became murderous psycho...
@@ImperativeGames oops.
If Kate got pregnant from Shane it would end up in a miscarriage since they are outside the house. If Shane is the father that means she's still inside the house. 🤦🏽♂️
I doubt they are still inside the house since they have most likely met other people and shane has little to know idea about how other humans act. It's likely shane impregnated her since she couldn't have a child before with multiple miscarriage's. It's a dark and twisted tale just like the one before.
Lol I literally was saying the same thing. Thank you
@@Wofulrumble4893 Highly doubtful its Shane's, thats just a dark twist to make the audience think. What OP said is true, also having 2 miscarriages by 1 man doesn't mean the third pregnancy cant be his. Also the fact that she took a pregnancy test a month after the incident means they've had sex between that time otherwise she would've taken it a week or two after. Additionally, theres many reasons for successful pregnancies after miscarriages, the trauma from the incident could've kick started her biological imperative to reproduce.
@@ProphetofXebec That is true since it was only a miscarriage. Unable to get pregnant would've been another story though...
@@Wofulrumble4893 but ashes can’t make a baby. So no. Only Matt’s real sperm can.
This Story Recap ROCKS!!! Thank you Story Recapped.
Not once does anyone ask for an instruction manual for the magical, wish granting room. "I want a book that explains, in detail, with terms and instructions that I can understand, what your deal is."
"A room that grants any wish"
Give me world's best computer *NOW!*
I'd wish for GPUs and mine Crypto
Simple solution. Wish for things that you can reproduce.
Step 1: Wish for today’s winning Lotto ticket.
Step 2: Write down numbers from ticket.
Step 3: Buy Lotto ticket with the numbers you wrote down.
Or just wisha duplicate world inside the room where you can be like god
@@aaronfajardo48 What happens if the house catches on fire or is damaged from the outside?
@@aaronfajardo48 it would be empty then because as seen creations can wish things too
Or similarly, gambling: wish to know the result of every season playoff, or the future of the stock market and which stocks to buy. Boomchakalaka. Money you can use outside.
Big brained.
0:49 is that the triforce on the door lmao
As a young boy, 18 years ago I kept telling my friends that one day we would have summarized movies and they all laughed.
If you could ever grant me a wish please do a recap on Citizen Kane. That movie is way too long for me. I've tried watching it 7 times and I've never gone past 30 minutes.
Room: You can't leave with your wishes...
Me: i wish for a nice gaming room with all the things...
best wish un the world lol
The scariest part of this movie is the painful lack of critical thinking this couple (especially Matt) has.
That’s vast majority of people in general. They would fail in most cases due to self sabotage
I think that most people would fail this test. Probably every one of us would eventually wish for something that’d ruin us.
Definitely didn't expect the Oedipus complex twist
Me as a black person: *looks at house ,looks At the weird ass walls,looks around the area, go among the neighbors asking for history, hears the owners have died*
Me: not a minute in there longer
I would be afraid that the house is evil. lol But in reality, there are no real consequences for making wishes in the room. Just don't wish for a baby. lol
Black people instinctively know when to get away. White people instinctively know how to take away.
Funny thing is they're supposed to disclose that someone died in a house when selling it
@@UrMom-fz4ht
WTH is this racism crap ?
@@Palestine4Ever169 Ur Mom
Solution for the money: Wish for an ATM, deposit all the money, then just like that the money is connected to your bank account and therefore can't actually age or technically leave the house.
Network wouldn't work since all signals leaving the room will cease to exist or become extremely weak and dissipate into noise.
someone else mentioned diamonds as they take billions of years to decay or a slightly better option to an atm is an all powerful crypto miner
@@kartaaham what if i connect the room with a real ntwork from outside? i can just install my own network and use it inside the house lol
@@Zen-nu1fb but the signal would be initiated from the machine, not your network
@@Zen-nu1fb the data packets are generated by the ATM inside the room which will cease to exist as soon as they enter the part of the wiring outside the house i.e 100% data loss
As much as I want to condemn the wife for wishing for a child, I would've wished for a girlfriend...so, fair enough.
a gf that doesn't get pregnant...
I can see how that could end badly.
@@kalmdwn7711 . . .
Dream of every streamer out there
They should have wished for a powerful artifact that allows the granted wishes to exist outside the house. This is how you exploit the mechanism of a wish granting machine by wishing for an artifact that gets rid of the limitations of their wishes.
Honestly, I kinda like it, but the Premise of not being able to take things out of the house being an end game for these people is pretty dumb. Like wish for some furniture, then wish for an AI that makes Vtuber accounts and profit.
(EDIT) You can also create an infinite world full of nature and beauty.
I would honestly create a room full of portals
It would lead infinitely Forward I could add more portals
Those portals would transfer me to another universe
I would always have the ability to respawn aslong as I died in those universe and the ability to go back to the Hub
I would then create universes have sex,eat food,FLY,idk destroy the universe become god,play minecraft,Create a crypto machine
Etc
But then wouldn't technically the videos (data) of said Vtuber Account or even real account (if you say, wished for a real but loyal or docile person recording the videos in a room of the house or even a simulated universe, world or area within) vanish as soon as you tried to upload as they'd leave the house?
I'm not sure what would happen if you were record this through an external source like a video camera and if the rules would then still apply. Maybe it works if you basically record with a "real camera" and not one you wished for.
I completely understand wishing for money and booze, but why the hell would you wish for a child, that’s like wishing for trouble, and a massive one at that, assuming that the kid doesn’t grow into a psychopathic rapist/murderer like he did in the movie.
Here's one of the approaches I'd take ;-
Step one : wish for all the important knowledge for humanity
- knowledge on how to cure all diseases (cancer, aging, injury etc..)
- how to build nanotech, teleportation etc...
Step two:
- make a physical copy of it and store it outside the house
Step three :
- use the knowledge to end all diseases and suffering make humanity an advanced post scarcity civilisation
You can't take out physical items but you can take out information
So simply wish for useful information that you can use in the outside world e.g how to cure all diseases, How to become biologically immortal etc...
Once you've got that info, copy it to a medium that wouldn't decay e.g a bunch of hard drives from the outside world
Then boom, you can share that info with humanity, use it to become a billionaire etc..
This room is an absolute blessing. These characters were just super short sighted