When you talk about describing a glorious kingdom in the OT by likening to a tree I immediately thought of the Jesse Tree (named after the father of David). Our family has a tradition of putting up the Tree of Jesse at beginning of December with the nativity scene at the foot. My Mrs is European, it's an ancient medieval tradition from her side of the family. The ornaments are Saint icons printed on star and ball decorations with their names printed in gold on the other side. The first 3 icon decorations we put on the tree is always Saint Nicholas of Myra, Patriarch Abraham and Jesse. From December 1 to December 24 every day our kids choose an icon decoration each to put on the tree but before they place it on the tree, they have to tell the rest of the family a short story about the person represented on the icon decoration. The icon decorations include Joseph, Moses, King David, Job, Isaac to John the Baptist, the Holy Apostles, Zechariah, Mary Magdalene, Elizabeth, you can go to town on all the biblical characters and we do. Isaiah, says: "A shoot will come up from the stump of Jesse; from his roots a Branch will bear fruit."
Yeah, to be honest, I was a little disappointed when I saw what reading it was, foolishly thinking I knew everything about it (only to realize over the next seven minutes I didn't).
Its gonna get ugly before it looks beautiful. We say this when picking grapes in the fields LOL some grapes are just plain hideous looking but when you cut the ones that don't taste good and you fix it up right then it looks like the greatest healthiest grape that you ever picked.
When you begin the journey of a pilgrim journeying towards enlightenment, the moments of purity are few - as you meditate you perhaps experience bliss for one hundredth of a second. This is the mustard seed. Finally after many many years you reach a point where bliss is always there, however preoccupied you may occasionally be with events in the gross world. And when nothing there distracts you bliss overwhelms your awareness That’s the fully grown tree
The parable of the mustard seed explains the hierarchy of the Catholic church but has been misinterpreted for centuries. A mustard is an annual herb not a perennial plant so when it grows to become a tree (perennial plant) it becomes something it is not supposed to be. When the birds of the air come to roost in its branches those birds represent the enemy infiltrating it. He refers to the leaven and leaven is always sin. Read what is says closely.. Luke Chapter 13 verses 18-21, English Standard Version He said therefore, “What is the kingdom of God like? And to what shall I compare it? It is like a grain of mustard seed that a man took and sowed in his garden, and it grew and became a tree, and the birds of the air made nests in its branches.” And again he said, “To what shall I compare the kingdom of God? It is like leaven that a woman took and hid in three measures of flour, until it was all leavened. .....Birds of the air in the parable of the seed are the enemy therefore these birds of the air are also the enemy in this parable. Leaven throughout the bible has always represented sin. This is the church that grew to become a tree and the enemy infiltrated it aka the Vatican. The word is consistent so you cant say the birds are not the enemy and you cannot say leaven is not sin otherwise the bible would be contradicting itself.
I was writing of attribute that were my shield to help preserve oneself and their values... The Bible says, "if you have a faith to the size of a mustard seed and tell a mountain to move, it will..." Attitude of the mustard... 😉
Mustard seeds don’t seem to be that small either. Could that also be symbolic? A seed you may not value or notice could produce much in the kingdom of God.
Well, if you look at speciation within the kinds, mustard seeds in Jesus' time could have been the smallest at that time...its been 2000 years since then. now we have all kinds of seeds even smaller than mustard seed...answersingenesis.org/bible-questions/are-mustard-seeds-the-smallest-or-was-jesus-wrong/
2 points to consider 1. Jesus also said if you have faith like a mustard seed. 2. Birds of the air nesting. If the ancient Jews considered the birds to be the gentiles. Paul in romans said the gentiles are now grafted in. So then who are the nesting birds in the Kingdom of Heaven?
I think you may be taking analogy too far, or maybe too literally, which strikes me more as a modern trait than the more poetic characteristics of Sacred Scripture. Is it really that hard to see how being grafted into the vine could mean the same thing as building nests on the tree?
Because... bottom line is if you create a distinction between grafting and nesting, just because of their differing imageries, there is nothing in any theology I've heard of (Catholic, Protestant, Jewish, Muslim, etc.) that could answer your question about who are the nesting birds.
@@JJoseph Parables are puzzles to be figured out, but not ones that are impossible to figure out. Jesus changed his imagery from one parable to the next. Look at sowing of seeds. In one parable, the sower is God. In another, it's an apostle (the one sent to preach but who doesn't know how the seeds grow, so obviously not a reference to God). Same parable Teacher; differing imageries.
The fact is that a mustard tree doesn't grow as big as to nest birds, another point is to not in Genesis, and they shall bring forward fruits of their own kind. Now a mustard tree will not over grow to nest birds. Check out how weak a mustard tree is.. I have seen them and they don't nest birds. Then also read the parable right before and make note of what are the Birds of the air. Both the parables were back to back in the same location and time. Jesus was saying not to over grow God's law but bring forth fruit that are not according to its own kind and over grow like a mustard tree that shouldn't have and then the birds of the air the evil ones that picked up the grains in the previous parable will nest on the tree that over grew.
@@hectormadrid171 He will, when it comes up as a Mass reading. I don't know when that will be. You might want to check his videos to see if any reading from Revelation are there now - can't recall any... well, let me take a look.
@@hectormadrid171 Here's an old video you might like (only say 'old' because Dr. Pitre looks so young on the thumbnail): ua-cam.com/video/OjXEIvWNZGc/v-deo.html But it looks like the series here on UA-cam started with Gospel readings, in which Dr. Pitre would make ties between them and the Old Testament. I do seem to remember now that the second reading was an additional thing Catholic Productions started about a year ago. And a lot of it is meant to entice us to subscribe to the Catholic Productions website, which has a cost (though presumably would be worth it).
You are mistaken he compared it to a weed because it must be cut down .you are living in the kingdom of heaven if you could only hear and see! Seek ye the kingdom of GOD
You are a blessing to this generation, thank you.
WOW! That was great. I will hear that parable with new ears. Thank you
Have always had questions on WHY the mustard seed, and love the very intriguing take on that parable. 👍👍 thank you!
Great🙏
When you talk about describing a glorious kingdom in the OT by likening to a tree I immediately thought of the Jesse Tree (named after the father of David). Our family has a tradition of putting up the Tree of Jesse at beginning of December with the nativity scene at the foot. My Mrs is European, it's an ancient medieval tradition from her side of the family. The ornaments are Saint icons printed on star and ball decorations with their names printed in gold on the other side. The first 3 icon decorations we put on the tree is always Saint Nicholas of Myra, Patriarch Abraham and Jesse.
From December 1 to December 24 every day our kids choose an icon decoration each to put on the tree but before they place it on the tree, they have to tell the rest of the family a short story about the person represented on the icon decoration. The icon decorations include Joseph, Moses, King David, Job, Isaac to John the Baptist, the Holy Apostles, Zechariah, Mary Magdalene, Elizabeth, you can go to town on all the biblical characters and we do. Isaiah, says: "A shoot will come up from the stump of Jesse; from his roots a Branch will bear fruit."
That sounds like a wonderful tradition. Thanks for sharing.
I loved it...interesting!
I would love my friend who is a seventh day adventist to watch these programs. But unfortunately they despise anything that's not theirs
Excellent as usual 👍
Yeah, to be honest, I was a little disappointed when I saw what reading it was, foolishly thinking I knew everything about it (only to realize over the next seven minutes I didn't).
Great job as usual Dr. Pitre. I learn something every time from you. God bless you.
Amen, thank you.
Simple but powerful. Right to the point. God bless you man of God
Little to great tree. Thank you Brant Pitre.
Thank you so much for this. God bless you more! 🙏🏻😇
Woman seed is Jesus
Amen
Seed are people of GOD
And became A great foundation of His Kingdom
What work has been done on how the same parables are being used differently in different gospels?
Brilliant as per usual
Its gonna get ugly before it looks beautiful. We say this when picking grapes in the fields LOL some grapes are just plain hideous looking but when you cut the ones that don't taste good and you fix it up right then it looks like the greatest healthiest grape that you ever picked.
When you begin the journey of a pilgrim journeying towards enlightenment, the moments of purity are few - as you meditate you perhaps experience bliss for one hundredth of a second. This is the mustard seed. Finally after many many years you reach a point where bliss is always there, however preoccupied you may occasionally be with events in the gross world. And when nothing there distracts you bliss overwhelms your awareness
That’s the fully grown tree
The parable of the mustard seed explains the hierarchy of the Catholic church but has been misinterpreted for centuries. A mustard is an annual herb not a perennial plant so when it grows to become a tree (perennial plant) it becomes something it is not supposed to be. When the birds of the air come to roost in its branches those birds represent the enemy infiltrating it. He refers to the leaven and leaven is always sin. Read what is says closely.. Luke Chapter 13 verses 18-21, English Standard Version He said therefore, “What is the kingdom of God like? And to what shall I compare it? It is like a grain of mustard seed that a man took and sowed in his garden, and it grew and became a tree, and the birds of the air made nests in its branches.” And again he said, “To what shall I compare the kingdom of God? It is like leaven that a woman took and hid in three measures of flour, until it was all leavened. .....Birds of the air in the parable of the seed are the enemy therefore these birds of the air are also the enemy in this parable. Leaven throughout the bible has always represented sin. This is the church that grew to become a tree and the enemy infiltrated it aka the Vatican. The word is consistent so you cant say the birds are not the enemy and you cannot say leaven is not sin otherwise the bible would be contradicting itself.
I was writing of attribute that were my shield to help preserve oneself and their values...
The Bible says, "if you have a faith to the size of a mustard seed and tell a mountain to move, it will..."
Attitude of the mustard... 😉
Mustard seeds don’t seem to be that small either. Could that also be symbolic? A seed you may not value or notice could produce much in the kingdom of God.
Well, if you look at speciation within the kinds, mustard seeds in Jesus' time could have been the smallest at that time...its been 2000 years since then. now we have all kinds of seeds even smaller than mustard seed...answersingenesis.org/bible-questions/are-mustard-seeds-the-smallest-or-was-jesus-wrong/
2 points to consider
1. Jesus also said if you have faith like a mustard seed.
2. Birds of the air nesting. If the ancient Jews considered the birds to be the gentiles. Paul in romans said the gentiles are now grafted in. So then who are the nesting birds in the Kingdom of Heaven?
I think you may be taking analogy too far, or maybe too literally, which strikes me more as a modern trait than the more poetic characteristics of Sacred Scripture. Is it really that hard to see how being grafted into the vine could mean the same thing as building nests on the tree?
Because... bottom line is if you create a distinction between grafting and nesting, just because of their differing imageries, there is nothing in any theology I've heard of (Catholic, Protestant, Jewish, Muslim, etc.) that could answer your question about who are the nesting birds.
@@paulmiller3469 Yes it's too hard for me to imagine nesting birds as grafted vines. That's why I brought it up.
@@JJoseph Parables are puzzles to be figured out, but not ones that are impossible to figure out. Jesus changed his imagery from one parable to the next. Look at sowing of seeds. In one parable, the sower is God. In another, it's an apostle (the one sent to preach but who doesn't know how the seeds grow, so obviously not a reference to God). Same parable Teacher; differing imageries.
The fact is that a mustard tree doesn't grow as big as to nest birds, another point is to not in Genesis, and they shall bring forward fruits of their own kind. Now a mustard tree will not over grow to nest birds. Check out how weak a mustard tree is.. I have seen them and they don't nest birds. Then also read the parable right before and make note of what are the Birds of the air. Both the parables were back to back in the same location and time. Jesus was saying not to over grow God's law but bring forth fruit that are not according to its own kind and over grow like a mustard tree that shouldn't have and then the birds of the air the evil ones that picked up the grains in the previous parable will nest on the tree that over grew.
Can ya explain the book of revelation
Dr. Pitre can, but he's following the Lectionary schedule.
@@paulmiller3469 Dr.Pitre is amazing I learn so much with him I didnt knw that...hope one day he can do videos on it
@@hectormadrid171 He will, when it comes up as a Mass reading. I don't know when that will be. You might want to check his videos to see if any reading from Revelation are there now - can't recall any... well, let me take a look.
@@paulmiller3469 surely will be looking forward to it
@@hectormadrid171 Here's an old video you might like (only say 'old' because Dr. Pitre looks so young on the thumbnail):
ua-cam.com/video/OjXEIvWNZGc/v-deo.html
But it looks like the series here on UA-cam started with Gospel readings, in which Dr. Pitre would make ties between them and the Old Testament. I do seem to remember now that the second reading was an additional thing Catholic Productions started about a year ago. And a lot of it is meant to entice us to subscribe to the Catholic Productions website, which has a cost (though presumably would be worth it).
Here’s a song for all you mustard seed fans out there! ua-cam.com/video/ss-1K---sug/v-deo.html
Why not be precise 🙂
You are mistaken he compared it to a weed because it must be cut down .you are living in the kingdom of heaven if you could only hear and see! Seek ye the kingdom of GOD