Bhagat Singh: The philosophy of an Atheist freedom fighter

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 3 лип 2024
  • This lecture is a special one as we discuss Bhagat Singh's ideas in Hindi.
    Resources
    1) www.marxists.org/archive/bhag...
    2) scroll.in/article/715660/on-b...
    3) www.marxists.org/archive/bhag...
    ----------------------
    ➡️ Telegram Community- t.me/desiphilosopher
    --------------------------
    📷 Instagram:
    / identity.not.available
    --------------------------
    📽️Other UA-cam Channel- / @faraz74811
    ------------------------
    📕Buy these books: www.amazon.in/shop/desiphilos...
    --------------------
    📑Philosophy Masterclass Course- forms.gle/ikA86taFbokPka1S7
    -----------------------------
    0:00 - Introduction
    1:07 - Part-I (social observation)
    7:28 - Bhagat Singh's essay on Atheism
    9:48 - Part-II (Why I am an atheist)
    16:44 - Ending notes & Important Announcements
    -----------------------------
    #history #philosophy #atheism

КОМЕНТАРІ • 892

  • @Raimohan321
    @Raimohan321 3 місяці тому +215

    We all born atheist....until someone tells us lies......

    • @Evolvinggamer371
      @Evolvinggamer371 3 місяці тому +2

      😂😂😂😂

    • @beast369dfh
      @beast369dfh 3 місяці тому +5

      🗿

    • @ProbablyPeculiar
      @ProbablyPeculiar 3 місяці тому +15

      Nah we all are born irreligious not atheist

    • @buzztube1738
      @buzztube1738 3 місяці тому +11

      ​@@Evolvinggamer371what's funny about that mr. Tanatani?

    • @curiash
      @curiash 3 місяці тому +2

      @@ProbablyPeculiar atheist and irreligios have similiarity

  • @DeepakPatel-hg9dg
    @DeepakPatel-hg9dg 3 місяці тому +143

    Athiesm is future of this world

  • @debrajmishra9978
    @debrajmishra9978 3 місяці тому +111

    Religion is the outcome of human weekness or the limitation of human knowledge
    _ Bhagat Singh ✍️

    • @abcop123
      @abcop123 3 місяці тому +2

      bro the soicial conditions that time were different from now. somethings that were usefull then are not useful now.

    • @greaterbharat4175
      @greaterbharat4175 3 місяці тому +7

      Science without religion and religion without science is lame
      Albert Einstein

    • @any__where360
      @any__where360 3 місяці тому

      He never said that..🤣🤣🤣​@@greaterbharat4175

    • @vikrantsingh8147
      @vikrantsingh8147 3 місяці тому

      Bhagat singh>>>>>>>>>>​@@greaterbharat4175

    • @VishalYadav00003
      @VishalYadav00003 2 місяці тому +1

      ​@abcop123 same goes for scriptures written 1500 to 3000 years ago, so don't follow them blindly, follow them logically

  • @S.K_Moharana-3
    @S.K_Moharana-3 3 місяці тому +48

    I am an atheist because of political, social, historical, philosophical and scientific reasons.

  • @RAHULSHARMA-zw1rg
    @RAHULSHARMA-zw1rg 3 місяці тому +44

    मैं नास्तिक क्यों हूं पढ़ने के बाद मैं पूरा हिल गया था भगत सिंह के संदर्भ में मेरा पूरा विचार बदल गया था

  • @all-mighty_paradocs
    @all-mighty_paradocs 3 місяці тому +12

    My atheism stems from several factors:
    1. Rationality superseding blind faith.
    2. Religion's contribution to social hierarchy.
    3. Lack of evidence for supernatural entities.
    4. Ethical and moral development independent of fear.
    5. The inherent meaninglessness of life without personal attribution.
    6. Valuing evidence over majority opinion.
    7. Recognizing imperfections in the universe, challenging the notion of an all-powerful deity.
    8. Acceptance of scientific theories like the Big Bang and evolution.
    9. Acknowledgment of religion's indirect contribution to violence and injustice.
    10. Preference for questioning over blind acceptance.
    Despite acknowledging my imperfections, I take responsibility for my actions rather than attributing them to a divine plan. I strive for self-improvement, guided by science and rationality, remaining open to new ideas and perspectives.

  • @elegantlyradha
    @elegantlyradha 3 місяці тому +35

    Love Bhagat singh as nepali🤍

  • @ourturrethasbeendestroyed4015
    @ourturrethasbeendestroyed4015 3 місяці тому +52

    Born in a Muslim family.. now openly an atheist.. My dad is an imam in a mosque .. A learned Muslim but he is still not able to refute me and my ideologies.. Thats come from the knowledge.. The knowledge of Philosophy.. Philosophy is all in itself..

    • @akhtar0335
      @akhtar0335 3 місяці тому +2

      Go ahead and provide counter argument against Islam or (in general ) against God .

    • @InvinciblePepe
      @InvinciblePepe 3 місяці тому +14

      ​@@akhtar0335the burden of proof lies on the person claiming that a God exists.

    • @kira_bl8qy
      @kira_bl8qy 3 місяці тому +8

      Same im also Muslim family member my father was a panjikana namaji he read Quran every freetime .
      And main nastik hu . 😅😂

    • @akhtar0335
      @akhtar0335 3 місяці тому

      @@InvinciblePepe Bro , don't rush. Reconsider what he mentioned, n what I asked.
      Look bro , actual infinity can't be the case , so logically universe is necessarily contingent,n this entails necessary existence of personal God.

    • @akhtar0335
      @akhtar0335 3 місяці тому

      @@kira_bl8qy nastiq - deviation from rationality and reality.

  • @rajjadhav6964
    @rajjadhav6964 3 місяці тому +49

    Duniya main itne saare dharm ka hona hi bhagwan ke na hone ka saboot hai main isi soch se khud ko atheist (nastik) manta hu

    • @lalitpagare3590
      @lalitpagare3590 3 місяці тому +1

      to ek kaam karo itna bada statement dene se pehle un sare dharm grantho ko pad lo jo har dharm kehna chahta hai use samajh ke fir decide karne becoz in my pov an atheist is a person jisne sabkuch pad ke samajh ke dekha hai or fir kha hai nahi god jesi koi chize nahi hoti hai athiest ka sabse bada reasone bhagwan ko na manne ka hota hai ki wo unkin logical thinking me nahi ghus pata....

    • @rajjadhav6964
      @rajjadhav6964 3 місяці тому +6

      @@lalitpagare3590 itna ander Jane ki jaroorat hi kya hai jab ki tumhe basics pata hai ki itne saare dharam hai hi kyu aur kise pata ki usi ka dharm sahi hai aur baki sare galat sab ko apna hi dharam accha lagta hai itni enargy waste hi kyu karni jab tumhe pehle se hi pata hai ki end main kuch nahi milne wala rehna to atheist hi hai ? Tumhe kya lagta hai ????

    • @raunakmishra9645
      @raunakmishra9645 3 місяці тому

      Ha bhaiya mai bhi atheist hi hu kyuki agr koi bhgwan jaisa entity hoga bhi to wo waisa bilkul nhi hoga जैसा alag अलग insaan apne apne hisab se bhgwan bna rkhe h

    • @rajjadhav6964
      @rajjadhav6964 3 місяці тому

      @@raunakmishra9645 💯 correct

    • @yana2813
      @yana2813 3 місяці тому +1

      ​@@lalitpagare3590 why so serious? Even studying it deep won't make a point.... If you see, these things suppose to help humanity evolve comprehensively ryt "the concept of Gods existence" but why waste time reading about it for hours unless you're not into it... when we could juss simply live it in our own terms... It's about peace, you find it within that's the thing matters besides your family, parents bhai behn and that explains. No labels will help eventually. Fear is like a lil death that leads to false beliefs and illusions to get in...

  • @zenishshahi4140
    @zenishshahi4140 3 місяці тому +13

    I am an Atheist because I am born Atheists ⚛️

  • @sahilhere7270
    @sahilhere7270 3 місяці тому +4

    Video Bohot Bohot Bohot accha laga, and also love your line "hum sab ek healthy argument karenge and ek dushre se sikhenge" 🌻

  • @vishalchaudhary6105
    @vishalchaudhary6105 3 місяці тому +196

    I think mai atheist hu kyoki mujhe nhi lgta ki itni cruel duniya kisi divine power god k dwara banai gai ho

    • @movin543
      @movin543 3 місяці тому +22

      cruelty was not made by god it is the result of our selfish needs ,

    • @abcop123
      @abcop123 3 місяці тому +5

      Hosakta hai sir. yeh world mai koi safe nhi hai even god has to face problems.example;-when god took his avtar as lord Krishna or Lord Ram they both had to face hardships.why dont we embrace hardship.jab kuch bura samay hota hai tab hum log kisi ko kosne lagte hai. .Pain and suffering hai thi aur rahegi.

    • @ThegodButchers
      @ThegodButchers 3 місяці тому +22

      Nice joke 👍 ​@@movin543

    • @movin543
      @movin543 3 місяці тому +4

      this isnt a joke ,do you have anything to disprove my point ?
      @@ThegodButchers

    • @ThegodButchers
      @ThegodButchers 3 місяці тому +9

      ​@@movin543 yes
      Because , wild animals are still cruel
      And practice cruelty just for survival

  • @demonslayerkimetsunoyaiba9139
    @demonslayerkimetsunoyaiba9139 3 місяці тому +16

    Okay ! So I'm atheist not because it's cool to be atheist I'm atheist because of science!!! . Science gives a better description of the world than religion. I just love how science explains everything with proof and evidence rather than written in any holy book .
    Always question the things u doubted will lead you to become better -
    Me

    • @abcop123
      @abcop123 3 місяці тому

      man now days i don't know much but during olden days debates were source of knowledge.Adi Shankaracharya and Mandana Misra their debate lasted for 42 days. now a days i dont know. debates always question beliefs.about sci gives a better description of worl, i agree upon that ok it might give a bettr description.but have you read scriptures which give info about creation of universe from different religions.

    • @Skeptic-Atheist
      @Skeptic-Atheist 3 місяці тому

      ​@@abcop123 yes we have grown up from that period, we now know much more than Shankaracharya could even dream of.

    • @anonymouspersonbehind5354
      @anonymouspersonbehind5354 Місяць тому

      ​@@abcop123there is no proof apart from what u say that shankaraachaary did
      At that time india was filled with budhist school of thought and at that time budhism was purely as in the way budha preached so it was a an athiestic religion and decline existence of atma or any super power
      Shankaraachaary revived hindusim and chance of usage of violence to do so is high
      There are mentions of shankaraachaary coming up with attackers and if he lose debate he would.....

    • @abcop123
      @abcop123 Місяць тому

      @@anonymouspersonbehind5354 secondly nothing remains same.hindus practise puranic rather than vedic. religions change during the course of time.

    • @anonymouspersonbehind5354
      @anonymouspersonbehind5354 Місяць тому

      @@abcop123 yeah a false thing which is imoral needs to change with time for survival in this morally better world

  • @Drt0mm
    @Drt0mm 3 місяці тому +22

    I am atheist and there is no reason needed to explain why I am atheist

    • @Drken712
      @Drken712 Місяць тому

      Koi bhi athiest hi hoga agar usko bhagwan jaisa kuchh usko sikhaya nhi jaaye to
      Main dharmik hu manne waala dharm nhi janne waala dharm

    • @ghost27611
      @ghost27611 11 днів тому

      ​@@Drken712 tum dharm ko jante to mante nahi

    • @Drken712
      @Drken712 11 днів тому

      @@ghost27611 main sahi sahi bolu to dharm ki baat kar rha hai
      Self knowledge to identify ego and observe it's extent and to kill it
      Usme god , bhagwan ye sab kaha se aa gaye ??

    • @ghost27611
      @ghost27611 11 днів тому

      @@Drken712 to dharm me kya super hero aate hai

    • @Drken712
      @Drken712 11 днів тому

      @@ghost27611 arre kuchh nahi hota hai bhai thoda reality ke saath jeena shuru kardom
      Dharm bas ek personal growth hai truth tak pahuchne ka means ego , goodness , bad sab ko sirf observe karke discard karne ke
      Wo sab to pakhand hai ke upar Bhagwan hain ya avtar hai Falana dhimkana koi nhi hai upar Jo ho tum aur aur tum pareshan ho

  • @shahzebyaseenkhan4835
    @shahzebyaseenkhan4835 3 місяці тому +14

    I don’t need a creator who doesn’t has a creator

    • @SaQib-HuSSain-
      @SaQib-HuSSain- 3 місяці тому

      If it has a creator than he's not the Creator , simply this cycle goes on , There is only one creator , Allah-there is no God except Him, the Ever-Living, the Sustainer of [all] existence. Neither drowsiness overtakes Him nor sleep. To Him belongs whatever is in the heavens and whatever is on the earth. Who is it that can intercede with Him except by His permission? He knows what is [presently] before them and what will be after them, and they encompass not a thing of His knowledge except for what He wills. His Kursi extends over the heavens and the earth, and their preservation tires Him not. And He is the Most High, the Most Great.[2]

    • @nilabjadey6211
      @nilabjadey6211 2 місяці тому +2

      @@SaQib-HuSSain-if u can accept there is no creator of god, why is it hard for u to accept there is no creator for universe.

    • @alya-jn3zl
      @alya-jn3zl 2 місяці тому

      ​@@SaQib-HuSSain-same logic can be said for the universe dude. religion people MAKE A CLAIM that god exists and he's created. there's no reason to make an assumption on ur own

  • @ArshadAli-zy6lg
    @ArshadAli-zy6lg 3 місяці тому +21

    Mai nastik hu Q ke maine Apne holy book Quran sharif ko Open mind hokr khud se padha with tarjuma aur usme mujhe bht sari galtiya mili.
    Phir mujhe ye smjh Aa gya ke ye koi God ke dwara bheja hwa book nahi hai

    • @godofgamerzindian
      @godofgamerzindian 3 місяці тому

      Quran is *not* holy book.

    • @NMalik26
      @NMalik26 3 місяці тому

      Ok Konsi gaaltiyan lagi.... ?

    • @mordret_wizard
      @mordret_wizard 3 місяці тому

      Giaan hain aap nobita wale

    • @ArshadAli-zy6lg
      @ArshadAli-zy6lg 2 місяці тому +1

      ​@@NMalik26 Scientific and Moral

    • @kafka1343
      @kafka1343 2 місяці тому

      ​@@ArshadAli-zy6lglol understanding things with emotions can't make it objective facts
      You neither know the surrounding when quran was revealed neither knows the science properly
      So the lack of knowledge made you think this

  • @RitikArya11
    @RitikArya11 3 місяці тому +32

    main atheist hoon. Kyunki main curious tha. Or mujhe sirf sach ko follow karna tha. Main ek humanist hoon or dil se chahta hoon ki sab equal ho jaye sab khushi se rahe. Koi na lade. Koi kuch bura na kare kabhi bhi kisi ka.

    • @Innerlightexplorer
      @Innerlightexplorer 3 місяці тому +3

      Tum kuch jagah shi ho but jaise tum bhagwan ko nhi man rhe usi tarah is baat ko bhi mano ki equality hone se bhi equality nhi ho skti. Jaise class mein teacher sab ko equally treat krke padhata hai but jab result ata hai tab kitni equality hoti hai. So we need to accept the fact that equality is not possible in this modern world. Log jitna position ke piche, money ke piche bhagenge jo ki obviously natural hai utna he equality kam hoti rhegi. Yeh sirf mera POV hai. I m not debating with you🙏

    • @RitikArya11
      @RitikArya11 3 місяці тому +1

      @@Innerlightexplorer kafi hadd tak sahi kaha.
      Equality sabko ekdum se di to nahi ja sakti. Par equal opportunities di ja sakti hai bass.
      Wo bas dil ki ichchha thi k sab equal ho jaye. Zameeni hakikat me ye mushkil hi hai..

    • @unusual_ashu
      @unusual_ashu 3 місяці тому

      Bhaiyo sanatani bano sanatan ka matlab hi hota hai manavta 😊🚩

    • @Innerlightexplorer
      @Innerlightexplorer 3 місяці тому

      @@unusual_ashu Hum Sanatani Hai aur sanatan dharm ko नकारा nhi ja skta. Jab tak sanatani bnne ki zarurat hai, tab tak hum sanatani ban he nhi skte kyunki uski na toh koi shuruaat hai aur na he ant. Ban toh hum woh skte hai jo hum nhi hai. Jo hai woh hum ban he nhi skte. Thnx for sharing your thoughts ❤❤🙏🙏

    • @nilabjadey6211
      @nilabjadey6211 2 місяці тому

      Equality is an idea of a weak man , the world cannot flourish without true natural hierarchy.

  • @alchemisticcreator2222
    @alchemisticcreator2222 3 місяці тому +1

    Greatly explained ❤

  • @meme_otaku_9955
    @meme_otaku_9955 3 місяці тому +14

    Religion is a business. I don't want to be part of this 😅😅

    • @abcop123
      @abcop123 3 місяці тому

      ? arguement kya hai sirji

    • @AmbrishIsCool
      @AmbrishIsCool 3 місяці тому

      ​@@abcop123go to temples, mecca madinas, churches and find out.

    • @meme_otaku_9955
      @meme_otaku_9955 3 місяці тому

      @@abcop123 it's my opinion

    • @abcop123
      @abcop123 3 місяці тому

      @@meme_otaku_9955 opinion mai kya hi bolu aapko ab🤣

    • @meme_otaku_9955
      @meme_otaku_9955 Місяць тому

      @@abcop123 my argument is that religion is business of hope . Delulu if any problem occurs we have to worship.for that we have to spend prist or pujari. If he completes your wish. Then you have to complete Navas .for that required money. If you want an early darshan of him you have to buy a VIP ticket to see him. Different Poojas have different packages.

  • @kaustubhanandchandola4049
    @kaustubhanandchandola4049 3 місяці тому +1

    This video is really nice and best and thank you so much 🌹🌹💐💐

  • @knowourindiafact
    @knowourindiafact 3 місяці тому +1

    nice video brother. keep it up

  • @scienceisdope
    @scienceisdope Місяць тому

    Excellent content dude

  • @Aditya_malhotra4511
    @Aditya_malhotra4511 2 місяці тому

    Ur content of quality is soo gooddd bhaiya. ........you will definitely grow but don't stop....

  • @UnknownVillain-pe7vv
    @UnknownVillain-pe7vv 3 місяці тому +20

    I think im atheist , reason is all of the existing religions can't give proper and logical answers to questions but i belive in power (entity) that created this universe, by very basics of physics universe created by big bang but there can be something before , that superpower maybe its beyond scope . Great work sir ❤

  • @Question-Research-wj5wr
    @Question-Research-wj5wr 3 місяці тому +1

    WHAT A CONTENT....❤

  • @rauhan_sheikh
    @rauhan_sheikh 3 місяці тому +12

    I am an atheist.
    I became an atheist because when I was growing up, in school I started to really getting interested in maths and science and the more I studied the less reasons I found for God, because growing up in a muslim family, all the reasons and stories I heard were either unreasonable or unscientific and it took a little while to completely detach myself with the idea of god, I had issues with the idea of hell even though I became an atheist, but slowly as I kept studying and growing I found myself at a phase where I no longer believed in any god, spirituality or anything supernatural.

    • @yana2813
      @yana2813 3 місяці тому

      Do you plan to join the community? It'd be great to hear rational thoughts from you...

    • @rauhan_sheikh
      @rauhan_sheikh 3 місяці тому

      @@yana2813 which community?

    • @rauhan_sheikh
      @rauhan_sheikh 3 місяці тому

      @@Riskyik-ff what about it?

    • @veer4176
      @veer4176 3 місяці тому

      Same situation happened with me but there is still something else except science I also got interested in history ,politics ,religion books and I started to read this books after that I become athiest

    • @rauhan_sheikh
      @rauhan_sheikh 3 місяці тому +1

      @@veer4176 yeah! Same the foundations were mathematics and science but I have read everything that I could get my hands on, history, literature, theology, politics, philosophy etc

  • @vijayKushvaha-ps8rk
    @vijayKushvaha-ps8rk 3 місяці тому +24

    I am an agnostic

    • @satyasankalpapanigrahi9416
      @satyasankalpapanigrahi9416 3 місяці тому +4

      I'm too but I'm a gnostic atheist ( liberal/weak atheist 😅😊.)

    • @PHANTOM-cm1og
      @PHANTOM-cm1og 2 місяці тому +2

      Theist or atheist ?

    • @Drken712
      @Drken712 Місяць тому +1

      ​@@PHANTOM-cm1ogthere's no extreme

  • @Computer_Yatra
    @Computer_Yatra 3 місяці тому +8

    5:13 Bhagat Singh age was 23 and with his comrades Shivaram Rajguru and Sukhdev Thapar was age of 22 when they got martyr on 23 March 1931 in the evening 7 'O' Clock🙏.

  • @unknown_5107
    @unknown_5107 2 місяці тому +6

    The fear of death & what would happen after death are only two reasons why people believe in such superficial things, they're lazy & scared because believing is easier and safer than independently searching truth or not believing something for fake satisfaction.
    this is responsible for conventional believes in superficial things we say it religion. But there is also one more reason that's ego, people's want to justify their bad actions with the help of religion Like sacrificing animals for a ridiculous reason. The husband is God or superior to the woman, and the wife can drink the holy water of his feet, there is nothing wrong in this according to religion. Killing a non-believer can also be justified to a great extent by religion by declaring that innocent person unrighteous according to their religion. He can justify every violence done by him by saying that I did it to protect the religion and the interesting thing is that even our beloved religious society will not blame him.
    I am not a traditionalist religious person, just because I am not afraid of death, I know very well that one day I will die, so there is no question of being afraid, anyway, I am not going to become immortal by being afraid. And as far as heaven and hell are concerned, there is no single proof available with any religious person who can prove all this, so there is no point in being afraid of all this.

  • @thinleynamgyal4457
    @thinleynamgyal4457 3 місяці тому

    Love the way you explain🫡. Please make a full explanation video on ‘Why I am an Atheist’.

  • @SiddharthJain-yq8my
    @SiddharthJain-yq8my 3 місяці тому

    Great work

  • @alya-jn3zl
    @alya-jn3zl 2 місяці тому +1

    beautiful lecture

  • @hargunpreetsingh4134
    @hargunpreetsingh4134 3 місяці тому

    bhai please bna dena poora lecture boht pyaar aya sabh sun k plz bna dena ❤️🙏

  • @noorimran2179
    @noorimran2179 3 місяці тому +1

    Well done ❤

  • @MdSonu-cb9qx
    @MdSonu-cb9qx 2 місяці тому

    Great Bhai

  • @Question-Research-wj5wr
    @Question-Research-wj5wr 3 місяці тому +1

    More of such contents ❤

  • @footBlastshorts
    @footBlastshorts 2 місяці тому +2

    Please make a video on atheism of veer savarkar

  • @hargunpreetsingh4134
    @hargunpreetsingh4134 3 місяці тому

    boht badia ❤❤❤

  • @shortvideos0084
    @shortvideos0084 3 місяці тому

    Very good informative video

  • @AshutoshSingh-kq3mo
    @AshutoshSingh-kq3mo 3 місяці тому +1

    Thankyou sir 🙏

  • @arghadeb9180
    @arghadeb9180 3 місяці тому +10

    Dada I'm an atheist. I was raised in a hindu non conservative family then later on I turned to islam due to some influences on my close one n became more religious n kinda respected God n everything related to it. Down the line when I saw this society then realized there is not sign of any celestial being paving path for human. No one no religious organisation is taking responsibility of those wrong things that are done by religious people in the name of religion.. then I thought it was humans fault but religious books are holy n religious customs are good n give equality to everyone.. then I started reading books from islam Hinduism n even bible .. i found the roots of all evil. It's with in religion n the idea of a celestial dictatorship..if I can praise the matter in the name of god if in a accident a 2 years kid got saved n if it's a miracle then what about at the same time same day hundreds of kids getting birth with blood cancer with fatal physical issues n who can kids die from hunger n lack of water on this earth if god is watching.. whom to blame ?? When it comes to good give credit to god n when it comes to bad then?? Its only our fault ?? What kind of logic is this..

    • @AgrazMilind
      @AgrazMilind 3 місяці тому +1

      You were like me. ❤ God exists but not religion

    • @arghadeb9180
      @arghadeb9180 3 місяці тому

      @@AgrazMilind look religion is one of the biggest cause of evil.. n when it comes to god.. by default we hv to be agnostic cause none can prove the existence anyways.. but that is not the matter .. I think you can solve this complex matter of existence of god with one question..
      Will I change myself and my actions if there was a god ??
      In my case .. no.. so I dont care care or need to know if there is a god or not.. cause nothing I will change .. simple ..

    • @AmbrishIsCool
      @AmbrishIsCool 3 місяці тому

      ​@@AgrazMilindAbey religion ek tool hai god k bare me jaanne ka. Kya yaar ... Tere logic se agar god exist krta hai to religion bhi automatically karega q ki vahi to ho raha hai religion exist to kar rha hai but ye logic hi flawed hai. God q hi exist karega? Koi proof hai? Chal Maan bhi liya ki vo exist karte hai to tu duniya ki condition dekh nahi Raha kya? Aisi duniya kisi saatvi fail bhi nahi bana skta. 😂

    • @arghadeb9180
      @arghadeb9180 3 місяці тому +1

      @@AgrazMilind look brother.. ask yourself one simple question.
      will u change yourself and your actions if god exists ???
      it doesnt matters if there is a god or not cause none can prove. only thing matters is your action and your choice..
      for me i will never change myself if there is a god or if there is no god. its as simple as that

    • @akhtar0335
      @akhtar0335 3 місяці тому

      @@arghadeb9180 Every atheist I debated , committed the same emotional fallacy I,e they Anthropomorphise God .
      If you're truly sincere, then bring your case( rational I,e devoid of fallacies) against God.I am here.

  • @user-pq3yf1fc2w
    @user-pq3yf1fc2w 3 місяці тому +35

    I'm proud Atheist

    • @lalitpagare3590
      @lalitpagare3590 3 місяці тому +1

      to ek kaam karo itna bada statement dene se pehle un sare dharm grantho ko pad lo jo har dharm kehna chahta hai use samajh ke fir decide karne becoz in my pov an atheist is a person jisne sabkuch pad ke samajh ke dekha hai or fir kha hai nahi god jesi koi chize nahi hoti hai athiest ka sabse bada reasone bhagwan ko na manne ka hota hai ki wo unkin logical thinking me nahi ghus pata....

    • @GIGADEV690
      @GIGADEV690 3 місяці тому +3

      ​@@lalitpagare3590Tune Saare religion ki kitabe padhe hae nahi na? Similarly Atheist ko bhe koi jarurat nahi hae.

    • @Dr.Devil-88
      @Dr.Devil-88 3 місяці тому

      Kisne kaha 😂

    • @Dr.Devil-88
      @Dr.Devil-88 3 місяці тому

      ​@@lalitpagare3590kisne kaha

    • @AtheistIndian2024
      @AtheistIndian2024 3 місяці тому

      ​@@lalitpagare3590very wrong argument, No one can read all religion since there has been lakhs of them and millions of God and each of them contracting eachother even in my legal religion, no one can easily understand Hinduism since there is a counter argument available
      But As an atheist I don't like a dictatorial figure who control my things and he or she want me to bow down to him that's not possible I am not going to blindly follow this dictator, Since has proven alot of things which were happen to be gods action so many more will be disproved in upcoming time

  • @JACK_OF
    @JACK_OF 3 місяці тому +2

    As a atheist it is my duty to take good qualities form religion text and tell to everyone don't do any bad thing for a religion

  • @vanshrajkhare
    @vanshrajkhare 3 місяці тому +5

    Well, I knew about Bhagat Singh since childhood but when I turned 18, I tried to know more about him. I came to know a lot about him then I came to know about one of his habits. He used to read a lot of books, then first of all I read his books which he wrote. From there I understood things a little. Then I read the books written by him, read the books of his comrades, then I started to understand things. I started moving towards atheism. I read Geeta, read Hindu texts, then I saw a lot of flaws in them. I myself am a Hindu from SC. yes, I saw the differences in those books, I saw that God himself is talking about a particular caste, how can this be, if there was a God then for him we all would be equal, otherwise I believe today that these were very clever kings and emperors of that time who made themselves worshipable, when I read Bhagat Singh, I felt that how can the thoughts of a person be so great in just 22-23 years, then I understood because he had read very great people, I used to read, I should do something like this but times are different I cannot become a revolutionary nor can I become 1000th part of him but I can do one thing. To become great I can read great people. I have adopted this habit of him and today I am 21 years old, but I have read more than 70 books, if not many, and as far as I have heard from people about myself, my thoughts are many years ahead of people of my age and because of this today I get more respect in the society than others. And I would like to say that if you want to become great then I should start reading great people. Adopt their habit.

    • @yana2813
      @yana2813 3 місяці тому

      Whom do you read? 70 r manys

    • @vanshrajkhare
      @vanshrajkhare 3 місяці тому +1

      First of all i have not read 70 different writers, I have read all the writings of a few writers only and in my personal library there are many books of new hindi writters, and because i am a finance guy so there is dozens of book on finance, if you want then ican suggest you some books of my fav writters

    • @yana2813
      @yana2813 3 місяці тому +1

      @@vanshrajkhare yea, please go on...

    • @vanshrajkhare
      @vanshrajkhare 3 місяці тому

      @@yana2813 I will tell you the names of some of my favourite books, read - yash ki dharohar by shiv verma , smritiya by shiv verma , bhagat the eternal rebel by malwinder jit singh waraich, why i am atheist, bismil atmkatha , withoutfear by kuldip nayar , why they killed gandhi by ashok kumar pandey

    • @vanshrajkhare
      @vanshrajkhare 3 місяці тому +2

      I will tell you the names of some of my favourite books - why i am atheist and jail diary of bhagat singh by bhagat singh , smritya and yash ki dharohar by shiv verma , bhagat singh the eternal rebel by malvinder singh waraich, without fear by kuldip nayar , bismil atmkatha , aunghad by nilotpal mrinal and read books of friedrich wilhelm nietche , Dharamvir bharti and mulk raj anand

  • @SandeepKumar-yo5oi
    @SandeepKumar-yo5oi 3 місяці тому +4

    Bhai make a video on B R Ambedkar

  • @ketankedare1430
    @ketankedare1430 3 місяці тому +1

    yess brother ...we want full explanation easy ...please make it.........and video is really best.....and yes I am Atheist😊

  • @LoveJEEMaths
    @LoveJEEMaths 3 місяці тому +2

    I am an Atheist not just because I don't Believe in God but also because I think!! This Modern Era Needs to have a flexible mindset that religious person don't have (they have rigid mindset)...and the evidence that nature provides us can't be seen by a Rigid eyes they totally got brainwashed into their religions..Atheism gives us Rational Eyes, Logical Mindset, Fighting Attitude, Morality and makes people Self Dependent..I believe in having some courage to stand on my own feet, rather than believing in a God I have never seen!!

  • @heymourya3364
    @heymourya3364 3 місяці тому +2

    Please make a long video on the essay.

  • @Faisu_Roy
    @Faisu_Roy 3 місяці тому +4

    Accidentally came to your vedio but awesome explanation from Pakistan and also Atheist bahagat Singh wasn't only your hero but also our hero which most of Pakistan people didn't even know and reason of being atheist is as being Ex Muslim kay khuda hy dikh ta nhe khuda hy insaaf nhe karta khuda hy paar usnay yea universe aik insan kay lia banaye khuda nay adam aur Hawa ko babaya aur un ke bachon ke apsa mein shadi karaye jis ko hum incest kehtaya hain khuda hay usnay kafir ko khud banaya aur us kise kafir kay ghr mein khud paida kia aur phir bhe Kafir dozakh mein aur khuda hy us nay yea duniya is lia banye ke us ki ibadat yani us ko puja ja sakay to khuda aur kuch nhe bs khud ko superior apni wah wahi mein khush hy ajj kaye logn ke sath zulm ho raha hy log zinda maray ja rahay hain par us ko kahan farq parta hy q ke wo khud hi tou Zindagi deta aur marta hay na aeisay jhoutay aur makar khuda ko mein nhe manta kehnay ko bhut kuch hay par yahan kia he likh ja sakta hy bus akhir mein yea hi proud to be an Atheist

    • @shubham-shubham
      @shubham-shubham 3 місяці тому

      Full stop comma bhi laga diya karo
      Kya likhe samjh nhi aaya

  • @AteetYadav-ep2pk
    @AteetYadav-ep2pk 2 місяці тому

    Brother' ♥️

  • @sahilparihar6694
    @sahilparihar6694 3 місяці тому +1

    We want more on Atheism 🙌🏽

  • @AdityaSharma-vu8xy
    @AdityaSharma-vu8xy 3 місяці тому

    Sir is there any video of yours which referred vedic philosophy or morals from ancient Hindu tales .
    Pls recommend it to me

  • @Durga-my8zq
    @Durga-my8zq Місяць тому +1

    Atheists is not only to ignore the god but
    As AN ATHEIST IT IS TO IMPORTANT TO TERATE EVERY HUMAN WITH HUMANITY
    and it is real aim of atheists school of thought

  • @Quotesiam
    @Quotesiam 3 місяці тому +1

    Lo Rakh Lo 🏆 Bhai ❤.

  • @Mr.manthan88
    @Mr.manthan88 3 місяці тому +2

    Make video on Dr. Ambedkar philosophy and thoughts too😊

  • @xxzwq
    @xxzwq 3 місяці тому

    Please tell me how can i research like you? and how will I know that yes this article is from the right source and not just yapping. Steps to research like you. pls #AskDesiPhilosopher

  • @anuragbohara9314
    @anuragbohara9314 9 днів тому

    My decision to become an atheist was well thought. In childhood, I was very lazy in performing religious rituals & atheistic tendencies was clear to my parents, but when I grew up and studied deeply the thoughts of Babasaheb Ambedkar and Mahatma Buddha, that's why I became an atheist.

  • @kushalgajpal165
    @kushalgajpal165 3 місяці тому

    Ye book mne padhi h, bhot acchi book h or aaj thoda revision hogya❤

  • @VIVEKMISHRA-ys5hm
    @VIVEKMISHRA-ys5hm 2 місяці тому

    Bro got new subscriber

  • @malkiatmangat1729
    @malkiatmangat1729 3 місяці тому +2

    I am living in Philadelphia last 25 years, I am proud to be atheist and always fan of bhagat singh

  • @hemantjangir5002
    @hemantjangir5002 3 місяці тому +8

    M atheist es liye hu kyoki jab m Chhota tha to har bar mandir me bhagwan se drone mangata tha . Per vo abhi Tak nahi mila 😂.

    • @Ram-he4yq
      @Ram-he4yq 3 місяці тому

      Seriously, you should learn read about the stuffs like history, science, psychology, etc… to be a real A-theist
      And go watch Realist Azad to understand why not your religion…

    • @F16D794
      @F16D794 3 місяці тому +1

      Damn same here i watch Pakistani mulhid he is also a atheist ⚛️ ​@@Ram-he4yq

  • @heymourya3364
    @heymourya3364 3 місяці тому +1

  • @vinayakkaushik383
    @vinayakkaushik383 3 місяці тому +33

    मै खुद को नास्तिक मानता हु, जब मै समाज के सामने खुद का परिचय देता हु, क्युकी उनके ईश्वर की अवधारणा बिल्कुल अतर्किक और फूहड़ मुल्यो से ज्यादा कुछ भी और नही लगता मुझे. लेकिन मुझे सभी धर्मो का अध्यन करना, पसंद है, मुझे कृष्ण, जिजस्, , मोहमद , बुद्ध महावीर सभी अच्छे लगते है, लेकिन मै अपने आप को किसी धर्म के साथ जोड़ना नही चाहता क्युकी वो दूषित है. और इसे समाप्त करके मै लोगो को इक नये तरीके से तार्किक और मानवीय समाज की स्थापना करना चाहता हु.

    • @rajivlochan862
      @rajivlochan862 3 місяці тому

      Bhai aap toh brahman hona?

    • @vinayakkaushik383
      @vinayakkaushik383 3 місяці тому +7

      @@rajivlochan862 हाँ लेकिन इसमे मेरी मर्ज़ी नही थी. और मै खुद को किसी जाती या समुदाय के साथ relate नहीं कर पाता हु, मुझे कोई फर्क ही नही पड़ता.

    • @itzaryan365
      @itzaryan365 3 місяці тому +5

      ​@@vinayakkaushik383bhai tmlog jese log hona chahiye apne desh mein, proud of uh..🖤

    • @lalitpagare3590
      @lalitpagare3590 3 місяці тому +3

      to ek kaam karo itna bada statement dene se pehle un sare dharm grantho ko pad lo jo har dharm kehna chahta hai use samajh ke fir decide karne becoz in my pov an atheist is a person jisne sabkuch pad ke samajh ke dekha hai or fir kha hai nahi god jesi koi chize nahi hoti hai athiest ka sabse bada reasone bhagwan ko na manne ka hota hai ki wo unkin logical thinking me nahi ghus pata....

    • @rajjadhav6964
      @rajjadhav6964 3 місяці тому +2

      @@lalitpagare3590 bhai har jagah same comment kar raha hai tu pakka bhagwan main manane wala hai tu rehne de bhai tumse na ho payega😅😂😂

  • @INSAANOFFICIAL
    @INSAANOFFICIAL 3 місяці тому

    I'm an atheist and Bhagat Singh is my biggest inspiration because of his views on society, vision for India and views on religion. I don't belief in god because I don't find any reason behind my existence and the existence of this universe, I did'nt find any reason in any religious text. We are far smaller than an atom when compared to the Universe and are here by accident. People telling me who I am and defining me according to their views force me to question myself about who I really am and why do I need to give myself so much importance. Plus the views on Bhagat Sing on religion shaped me to become atheist.
    Jai Hind! 🫡

  • @asimkhan9742
    @asimkhan9742 3 місяці тому +2

    Religion is all about beliefs. Belief by definition can contradicts reality or the truth. So once we say we believe something we accepts ourself that we can be wrong. So religion isn't about truth and we can never know the truth.

  • @ashutoshshukla9053
    @ashutoshshukla9053 2 місяці тому +2

    I am an atheist ⚛️ because jhaa prr jasiee loog wasie unke workship kee taarike aur wasie god.... china mei buddha ki eyes alag india mei alag.... Jesus white aur eyes blue... because western mei blue eyes common hai... yhaaa coloured gods... these are just ego of humans.... to workship their image...this universe age 13 billion years... age of humanity 300 thousand yesrs... if god looks like humans so why he took soo much time to made us..even if god is energy... their is more dark energy than energy ..god is just an emotional need for mental stability...

  • @aryanaryanthakur9982
    @aryanaryanthakur9982 3 місяці тому +1

    Full video in detail on this esaay
    Why am i atheist

  • @sudeepheni6016
    @sudeepheni6016 Місяць тому +1

    We all born Atheist then we got brainwashed ..proud to be an Atheist ⚛️⚛️

  • @napoleanhill_123
    @napoleanhill_123 3 місяці тому

    Can You Please Make Lecture On Law of Attraction????

  • @deepanshu9459
    @deepanshu9459 3 місяці тому +1

    I'm an atheist
    The biggest example that resonates with me is Gautam budh ( the biggest example of how atheists can change the world without the need of a religion or a creator/god )
    Although I know Gautam used the word god a lot ,but it's a metaphorical term to represent the best version of the self
    Exited to have a genuine convo ❤

  • @RitikArya11
    @RitikArya11 3 місяці тому +3

    bhagat singh sabse zyada logical/realistic freedom fighter the🎉

  • @pramodsharma75158
    @pramodsharma75158 3 місяці тому

    Ak line hai iss book se jo ki mujhe bhut pasand hai..
    " Today's progress is the domination of men over nature.There is no conscious thing behind it..."

  • @Anshyadav-vk4nb
    @Anshyadav-vk4nb Місяць тому +1

    Why should we blindly believe in something that we don't know?

  • @tanishtandon2633
    @tanishtandon2633 3 місяці тому

    Sir can you make a video on Netaji's philosophy also?

  • @Drt0mm
    @Drt0mm 3 місяці тому

    🙏

  • @sandeepkumarsahu466
    @sandeepkumarsahu466 3 місяці тому

    Respected and honorary sir ,I actually beleive in your thoughts and your reckoning power as well the skills . I strongly disagree with the fact that the Atheists have the useless thinking process . Actually Our society has a lot of pre conceived notions about the belief in the almighty and the supernatural or cosmopolitan power. The netizens of our highly heterogeneous society has the most significant and disruptive or derogatory attributes about the atheism or Theism. I even actual strongly agree with your convictions to a great extent as a person is said to be an Atheist or Theist according to his /her imagination, rationality or logic . The obscurity and scrutiny of ideas varies and are quite difficult to be interpreted. Sir ,in my opinion I feel that Belief in one's religion or ideological principle depends upon the cognitive intuitions of one's mind . Atheists point of view is highly abided by the sense of truth and factual evidences as the ones you mentioned in the video . One can achieve the eternal joy as per the rules , regulations and regimentation of the life's philosophy. The person might not believe in God but he indirectly, inevitably works on the pathway of Karma conjured up the consciousness of conscience of Evil or Virtue as well as fostering the impact of Good Or Bad karmas over one's life to persuade oneself in the path of optimism, virtuous Ness and scandalous free mindset . The people who are the mere believers of one religion without logic and are having the despotic or obstructive/obtrusive feelings are the theocrats. Theocracy makes oneself vulnerable to the excessive allegiance to one religion or sect causing the serious and devastating consequences of the factionalism or partisanship. So , Atheists and Theists are the two sides of a coin that are referred to as the pros and cons of one's mind , body and soul-s amalgamation in the form of balanced confluence realising the universal law of acceptance of the distinctive schools of thoughts. All people have the variations in their faiths but in a nutshell,all are linked with another in one or some other way with versatility of visions.

  • @grewknowledge8750
    @grewknowledge8750 3 місяці тому +1

    Please make one for Savarkar please

  • @meghakd
    @meghakd 2 місяці тому

    Haan please bana do ek dedicated video essay par 17:43

  • @DyNaMiT-369
    @DyNaMiT-369 3 місяці тому +2

    I am atheist cause i just want to all the things on me that god will sort out for me cause it make me better that is the real divine power wants although atheist as i think means a person who dont follow religion rather than believing on a divine entity so the first interpretation should be you believe in any religion or not then the second question should be asked.

  • @kaushalsahu4035
    @kaushalsahu4035 2 місяці тому

    Radha Vallabh Shri Hari vansh 🙏

  • @aslamnijami6731
    @aslamnijami6731 2 місяці тому

    GOD EXISTS ONLY A KIND HEART ❤❤

  • @rudrakshtomar8029
    @rudrakshtomar8029 3 місяці тому

    👏👏👏👏

  • @kolwane6425
    @kolwane6425 Місяць тому

    I feel I am an atheist. Reason prima facie - I have never get any evidences of god's existence. As a rational human I should be - I don't know whether god exist or not . But I choose that god doesn't exist theory as my life doesn't depend on the existence of god but if I except God's existence then I will limit my thoughts, feelings, rationality capabilities, as I will think some one is there who knows better than every one , who knows me well, who do good for me etc. So as I reject it I feel my sufferings problems are result of my or other persons deeds, my works are good or bad depends on universal acceptance of all beings in the world and if I try I can change my fortune I don't have to wait for any divine's mercy. This thought makes me stronger.

  • @akshatgulati5782
    @akshatgulati5782 2 місяці тому

    ❤❤

  • @xen5917
    @xen5917 3 місяці тому

    will you make next Video on Babasaheb Ambedkar's ideology please?

  • @itsgamechangerz9491
    @itsgamechangerz9491 Місяць тому +1

    I am atheist because of fights between religions

  • @ultimate22004
    @ultimate22004 3 місяці тому

    Bhaiya ek vdo adwait vedant /non duality par ban do plz❤

  • @Pendifuditeri
    @Pendifuditeri 3 місяці тому

    Well

  • @ReelsVsShorts
    @ReelsVsShorts 2 місяці тому

    My very first thought when I started becoming an Atheist, many years ago....
    If u are raised from childhood with ANY TYPE OF religion knowledge and it's environment then you believe in that....
    But from childhood only if u r taught there is nothing like Divine Power or God like stuff....
    "Keep Questioning ...don't follow any thing blindly just because it is carrying on from last many years and followed by our elders"

  • @ravi10sharma
    @ravi10sharma 2 місяці тому +1

    *Absence of evidence is not the evidence of absence.*

  • @KoushikMondalVlogs
    @KoushikMondalVlogs 3 місяці тому +1

    Your video quality increases a lot but make controversial topics video more to grow fast ⏩😂

  • @shahidmansoor5855
    @shahidmansoor5855 3 місяці тому +1

    The complex orign of the universe its systematic evolution under the physical laws and origion of life from matter and this life became conscious like human how these happnend without super great mind (Matter,life and conscious ) thats why i m thiest and strongly condem atheistic philosophy
    Atheist have nothing accept Questioning but we have reality in the form of universe

    • @sameerbhalerao431
      @sameerbhalerao431 3 місяці тому

      Tum woh vimoh ka channel dekho he has explained it nicely the origin of life from matter.and I have one question for you can you explain me why life was wiped out from the earth when dinosaur extinction happend as it was also designed by superior being.

    • @shahidmansoor5855
      @shahidmansoor5855 3 місяці тому

      Abhi tk science is hwale se khamosh hai k matter se life kese bni just theories hai kafi sari abhi tk koi specific theory or mechanism explain nh kiya jse orign of the universe se phle kiya tha ye science k liye byan krna bht mushkil hai is trh matter se life or pir us life me consciousness kese i ye b byan krna bht mushkil hai wo alg bt hai k extinction hwa lkn mre buntadi 3sawal hai matter/energy or space time kaha se i origion of the universe k liye pir itna systematic evolution kese hwa universe ka billions of year ka or wo laws kese bne ju universe ko evolve kar warhi thi pir zameen pr non living matter se life kese bni or pir is life me consciousness kese aya ye 3 sawal hai agr ap kahoge nature ne kiya tu nature tu exist hi nh krti thi origion of the universe k time khod 4 fundamental forces bad me bne or by chance itna sb kch systematic nh hosakta agr insan soche tu

  • @kaushikghosh5469
    @kaushikghosh5469 3 місяці тому +1

    Nice sir

  • @KICK839
    @KICK839 Місяць тому

    He is right

  • @lohituchil8907
    @lohituchil8907 3 місяці тому +1

    I would describe myself as 'Unaffiliated' with any sect or religion. I don't believe in god. But i do find myself drawing various insights from Nagarjuna, Advaita, Confucius etc I find it hard to refute them.

  • @relaxingtube5043
    @relaxingtube5043 3 місяці тому +1

    I'm atheist bcz major argument of ppl is that who created universe but any scientific person would ask how can u consider universe as a creation bcz the universe originated from singularity and before that there wasn't any time so that singularity could have Existed forever before big bang so the scope of existence of god remains very narrow
    And simply there is no evidence for god
    It is just human tendency to blame the unknown on god and we have originated this concept to give meaning to our lives bcz human being dont want to accept that their life ends when they die
    And that's why they take the help of god and afterlife

  • @Ayush-uo9vi
    @Ayush-uo9vi 3 місяці тому

    Bro aap apna QR ya Kuchh bhi upi jaisa dedo jisse hm aapko thoda thoda help kar saken

  • @joyprakashmajumder2847
    @joyprakashmajumder2847 3 місяці тому

    Great ideology ❤

  • @napoleanhill_123
    @napoleanhill_123 3 місяці тому +1

    Some People Say Universe Is Very Complicated Thing And It Couldn't Create by its own Therefore Gods Create It. So My Question Is If God Exists He is More Complicated Than universe So, Who Created God? And if God came from no where and its possible that no one created god. And god get created by its own. So that mean the universe can also be get created by its own. Please Correct Me If i am Saying Something Out of Logic

  • @KoushikMondalVlogs
    @KoushikMondalVlogs 3 місяці тому +1

    Next video on Swami Vivekananda's and netaji subhas chandra Bose