Christina made herself as the female counterpart of James brown here. That tribute she did for James brown is still one of the greatest performances in Grammy history
Christina’s version of this sound has set the bar extremely high. You either pull off a good James Brown style or Christina style. There’s no way around it.
Christina's original live performance version wins. The song really fits her powerful voice. Despite the fact that Celine can sing every single note perfectly and well executed, her version was very similar to Xtina's.
Yes, and Celine doesn't use autotune to prerecorded tracks either like Christina is very well known to do. Just because she's standing up there on the stage with a microphone doesn't mean she's singing live. She was at an Award ceremony and it was televised. I happen to know for a fact that during these shows artists like Christina, Britney Spears, and other pop stars use prerecorded tracks and autotune to make their vocals sound better. Celine on the other hand has never used them during any live performance. So I beg to differ. The performance of Celine's was recorded by a fan in the audience while Christina's by the network. Celine Dion is and always will be the greatest vocalist in the world. I have heard both singers live in concert and trust me Christina needs the extra help while Celine belts it out as perfect as it gets.
@@Meriale46 Oh bull.. you can easily tell when xtina is lip synching because the veins wouldn't be sticking out of her neck. Xtina's performance here was totally live. Celine has been known to use them too LOL.
@@Meriale46 Christina is not known to use lipsync , she always sings live even when her voice has problems , she only uses them for "critical times" which most singers don't understand these days . Stop being a bitch lmaoo, praise these women christina did way better here, and your so called celine took inspiration from her because she does not feel entitled like you do :) maybe character check ?
@@Meriale46 lol youre a joke! They dont lip sync at the grammys during that time! Xtina's performance was 100% live and stop spreading lies because she is not known for lip syncing at all! Maybe mariah and Britney but Xtina NEVER lipsyncs! Stupid delusional idiot!
@@gorkaistina6235 Nope... Christina did her own version for Grammy's, listen to the original performed by James Brown, and that twist Christina made was love by Celine and she decided to sing her version, inspired by Christina's twist of the song. Céline loves Christina, listen to her in the interviews... 🙌🏾
@@gorkaistina6235 lol it's not debatable since Celine has said it herself. Those riffs are not James Brown's it's Xtinas and Celine maintained the exact same. It's not bad it's just the truth.
100% Christina deeper voice more rugged for the song. Celine's voice is to soft for the song to be done right. The people saying Celine are fans of hers and refuse to admit the truth. You are clueless if you think celine out sang her on this song sorry people
I am a fan of celine dion and yes christina's voice is better for this title .. on the other hand the sound quality of celine dion the band is less strong than christina's video, it distorts the power of celine a little; the 2 videos are not with equal sound .. here celine is 40 years old I think, chrisitna 30 years old celine can sing like christina, listen to this, broken voice while remaining powerful, it looks like aguliera, celine has several voices ua-cam.com/video/AsVFAe-dMFI/v-deo.html
Well i think the truth is that celine won for us bcuz its our preference not like something we have to admit. You're the one that cant admit that theres the fact that there are people that love celine's version more than christina's bcuz that's what they prefer.
celine little sang rougher broken voice .. she also little sang by forcing on her full voice ... in the early 90s. celine loved to sing with violence and a break in her voice ... example al by myself in 1996 at all debut she was singing a super broken eb5 a bit like aguillera
Christina Aguilera is such a legend and such a queen,her voice is unique and her stage presence is incredible she literally put her soul and her heart in this performance!!!
Celine Dion she is the most defensive of the big three. amidst the onslaught of young female singers. until now Celine she is the most still Active, Still Shining Bright, and the most respected. The last album is Courage. released in November 2019. And the four video clips have graced the music world throughout 2020. Satisfying the thirst of fans who miss him around the world. Even the courage tour is scheduled for 2022 around the world. She is a legend with Mariah and whitney. the three of them cannot be replaced by any female singer in this world. Celine's total album sales. until now also Far above the two of them.. the thrones of the three of them were already above the level of other female singers. The world calls them by a big name, As THE VOCAL TRINITY * But Mariah, she is no longer active. she rarely appears about her latest project. and doesn't have a new album anymore to greet her fans. Caution's, last album in 2018 . *While Whitney she has long died. Her work will be remembered forever. May her soul rest in peace there.
celine little sang rougher broken voice .. she also little sang by forcing on her full voice ... in the early 90s. celine loved to sing with violence and a break in her voice ... example al by myself in 1996 at all debut she was singing a super broken eb5 a bit like aguillera
Celine has a GREAT voice, and outsang Xtina in some songs but definitely NOT this one. Christina owned it, felt it, MADE US feel it. No shade to Celine but this belongs to Xtina
You must me kidding with me🤬 Celine has even more power just talking the worlds out. Christina isn’t in the trinity and will Never be😎 Celine dions voice voice like a rocket trough the roof👍🏻
Celine is such a Legend and incredible artist who is so respectful and good to other artist,but Christina Aguilera rendition of man's world is the best,and standard version,even Celine herself is doing xtina version,and many artist had done xtina version,and Celine herself has said Christina is the best vocalist of this generation,lastly Celine is outstanding I love how she annihilated Mariah and Arethra in divas live 1998...
celine little sang rougher broken voice .. she also little sang by forcing on her full voice ... in the early 90s. celine loved to sing with violence and a break in her voice ... example al by myself in 1996 at all debut she was singing a super broken eb5 a bit like aguillera
Celine is one of the best singers in my book, but Xtina has that soul sounding voice that not many singers can perform. Not taking away Celine being amazing because I love her 😍, it’s just Christina is one and only.
Celine is brilliant but comparing her version to Christina’s is just ridiculous. Christina destroyed it, owned it, slayed it!!! That’s one of the best performances of all time. Nobody can compare to Christina.
celine can sing like christina, listen to this, broken voice while remaining powerful, it looks like aguliera, celine has several voices ua-cam.com/video/AsVFAe-dMFI/v-deo.html
@@ntuzunkaurintah very true, if you don’t have a any vocal training in the slightest, Christinas style of singing would hurt the average persons voice. Which why she’s considered the voice of her gen. Haha. She’s amazing and so is Celine.
I will say Christina she gives everything, while Celine is a great singer for sure, but Celine is a vocal machine for me, however, Christina is a true Artist
To all the commentators here saying that CELINE SANG IT BETTER, first of all don’t shoot me coz im a die hard celine fan as well but this version was CHRISTINAS and made it her own. She sang it for James Brown tribute (She was asked to do it) and to see that Celine sang it the same way as Christinas she copied it but Not as good as how Christina did, it’s not because Christina is a better singer (because they’re both GREAT SINGERS) IT IS BECAUSE CELINE singing this version didnt fit her voice the way Christina did. If Celine sang it her own version probably it was a diff story. ✌🏻✌🏻✌🏻
celine's D5 is super clear, piercing with lots of chest, the E5 aguillera is super nice, I love the high-pitched sound with a broken voice! celine can do that too even on F5 in 2020 in tribute to arteha franklin at the end her voice becomes tense and resembles that of aguilera :: at 52 years old
celine can sing like christina, listen to this, broken voice while remaining powerful, it looks like aguliera, celine has several voices ua-cam.com/video/AsVFAe-dMFI/v-deo.html
In my opinion Céline is the greatest female singer on the planet, no doubt about it... But I must say Christina voice suit this song better. Céline voice is almost to "perfect" and well managed.. Céline definitely hit the notes perfect and in a more healthy way, but the rough style Christina possess is better for this song!
For the people saying Christina screams, certainly dont know soul and gospel. Christina, J Hud, Jennifer Holliday, Aretha, James Brown are ICONIC Definitions of Soul. Celine is a legend but nothing compared to Christina when it comes to Soul.
celine can sing like christina, listen to this, broken voice while remaining powerful, it looks like aguliera, celine has several voices ua-cam.com/video/AsVFAe-dMFI/v-deo.html
Excuse me. Celine was invited to sing for even the burial of the Queen of soul herself with nothing but black people as her audience. So dont preach about celine havin no soul or christina has more soul. Soul is not about growlin and screaming hahahah you're a joke. Comparin this trinity member to screamtina who can barely reach high notes. 3:50 sounds like there's a rat on stage eeeekkkkk
jak30341 this is soul music and james brown song resonance isn’t needed here 😂😂😂 celine has technique but lacks soul. Christina was completely screaming but you could feel what she was singing
Resonance is when the sound leaves the mouth. In any kind of way, whether it is strained, clear, full, rich, loud, quiet and all that. I know that you are talking about an open sound, but resonance is everything what comes from your mouth. Speaking as well is resonance.
@@BlackDavid900 exactly. Music is not only about technique and all that bs, it's also (MAJORLY) about the emotion you put into it. You can have the best technique in the world but if you don't put soul and emotion in your performance, it means nothing 😂
As a Celine's fan, I agreed that Xtina sang better than Celine for this song. I'm not offended by all the comments thay said Xtina is better... But both can sing very well tho..
This belongs to Christina. She owned it. Celine has the technique and ease, but i prefer Aguilera's version. All the growls, rasp and screamy approach just fit the song.
Cristina esta en su ambito musical natural Soul (R&B), interpretando magistralmente la pieza, lamentablemente Celine sale de su estilo Pop (balada), donde indudablemente es extraordinaria, y no tiene el feeling necesario para la pieza musical interpretada
Christina sang it powerful & rock. Celine sang it soft and seductive. If you love powerful voices & something rock, Christina is the best choice. But if you love soft & seductive way, Celine's version is the best. Both are beautiful. But I love Celine's version 'coz she's my most idolized singer ever!
celine can sing like christina, listen to this, broken voice while remaining powerful, it looks like aguliera, celine has several voices ua-cam.com/video/AsVFAe-dMFI/v-deo.html
Was this a real comparison? Christina Aguilera continues to blow the competition out the water. Her rich, soulful, and clear vocals are unmatched. Now get ready to buy that Spanish album on the way.
Christina chose to use this song to showcase her vocal abilities, which simply cannot compare to Celine's. Celine chose to do with this song what she does best, which is to sing it beautifully. While I definitely appreciate Christina's version, it is a bit labored, while Celine seems to fly through the song effortlessly. And Celine beats Christina in some high notes as well.
celine's D5 is super clear, piercing with lots of chest, the E5 aguillera is super nice, I love the high-pitched sound with a broken voice! celine can do that too even on F5 in 2020 in tribute to arteha franklin at the end her voice becomes tense and resembles that of aguilera :: at 52 years old
Love both ,but Celine was superior 🔥🔥....everything calm,controlled and full of technique,without wanting to prove anything. Of course Christina also is an incredible vocalist ,but she sometimes gets lost while trying to prove something/show-off....that's when she oversings notes and etc.
I really love Celine Dion but when it comes to soul/James Brown I think Christina Aguilera has the best voice and power for this song. I know… all the self titled “voice coach” on UA-cam maybe have another opinion while sitting home behind the screen in a couch with fries on the side…
@@elenadanailova3870 Celine Dion sing this song after sing 12 song, and ask Christina to sing this sing after 12 song, u will see the different. Oh yeah celine more older than christina, soo only stupid people's said that's Christina version is more better
Christina made herself as the female counterpart of James brown here.
That tribute she did for James brown is still one of the greatest performances in Grammy history
Christina gave us the best performance of her lifetime that day. That soul, that power… she pulled that mic 2 feet away but you still hear everything.
Christina’s version of this sound has set the bar extremely high. You either pull off a good James Brown style or Christina style. There’s no way around it.
Are U for real!? Goodness me.........
@@Jespher1 Yes Christina Aguilera....version is better....you can feel that soul.....
Christina's original live performance version wins. The song really fits her powerful voice. Despite the fact that Celine can sing every single note perfectly and well executed, her version was very similar to Xtina's.
That's why Christina is such an amazing performer!
Yes, and Celine doesn't use autotune to prerecorded tracks either like Christina is very well known to do. Just because she's standing up there on the stage with a microphone doesn't mean she's singing live. She was at an Award ceremony and it was televised. I happen to know for a fact that during these shows artists like Christina, Britney Spears, and other pop stars use prerecorded tracks and autotune to make their vocals sound better. Celine on the other hand has never used them during any live performance. So I beg to differ. The performance of Celine's was recorded by a fan in the audience while Christina's by the network. Celine Dion is and always will be the greatest vocalist in the world. I have heard both singers live in concert and trust me Christina needs the extra help while Celine belts it out as perfect as it gets.
@@Meriale46 Oh bull.. you can easily tell when xtina is lip synching because the veins wouldn't be sticking out of her neck. Xtina's performance here was totally live. Celine has been known to use them too LOL.
@@Meriale46 Christina is not known to use lipsync , she always sings live even when her voice has problems , she only uses them for "critical times" which most singers don't understand these days . Stop being a bitch lmaoo, praise these women christina did way better here, and your so called celine took inspiration from her because she does not feel entitled like you do :) maybe character check ?
@@Meriale46 lol youre a joke! They dont lip sync at the grammys during that time! Xtina's performance was 100% live and stop spreading lies because she is not known for lip syncing at all! Maybe mariah and Britney but Xtina NEVER lipsyncs! Stupid delusional idiot!
Celine once said in an interview that her version was actually inspired by Christina's. Listen to 2:25 and 2:43 for comparison: same riff.
Lol they both actuely are inspired of orginal version .
@@gorkaistina6235 Nope... Christina did her own version for Grammy's, listen to the original performed by James Brown, and that twist Christina made was love by Celine and she decided to sing her version, inspired by Christina's twist of the song. Céline loves Christina, listen to her in the interviews... 🙌🏾
Omg ❤️❤️❤️
But Celine is using Christina's arrangement.
@@gorkaistina6235 lol it's not debatable since Celine has said it herself. Those riffs are not James Brown's it's Xtinas and Celine maintained the exact same. It's not bad it's just the truth.
100% Christina deeper voice more rugged for the song. Celine's voice is to soft for the song to be done right. The people saying Celine are fans of hers and refuse to admit the truth. You are clueless if you think celine out sang her on this song sorry people
Troy Darby 100 miles away you can notice that Christina killed this isn’t that obvious I’m not a super fan but I can hear
I am a fan of celine dion and yes christina's voice is better for this title .. on the other hand the sound quality of celine dion the band is less strong than christina's video, it distorts the power of celine a little; the 2 videos are not with equal sound .. here celine is 40 years old I think, chrisitna 30 years old celine can sing like christina, listen to this, broken voice while remaining powerful, it looks like aguliera, celine has several voices ua-cam.com/video/AsVFAe-dMFI/v-deo.html
Well i think the truth is that celine won for us bcuz its our preference not like something we have to admit. You're the one that cant admit that theres the fact that there are people that love celine's version more than christina's bcuz that's what they prefer.
Deeper voice. ? Goodness you have t seen a lot of Celine s ateeeeeeel going strong careeee
celine little sang rougher broken voice .. she also little sang by forcing on her full voice ... in the early 90s. celine loved to sing with violence and a break in her voice ... example al by myself in 1996 at all debut she was singing a super broken eb5 a bit like aguillera
Christina Aguilera is such a legend and such a queen,her voice is unique and her stage presence is incredible she literally put her soul and her heart in this performance!!!
Celine Dion she is the most defensive of the big three. amidst the onslaught of young female singers. until now Celine she is the most still Active, Still Shining Bright, and the most respected. The last album is Courage. released in November 2019. And the four video clips have graced the music world throughout 2020. Satisfying the thirst of fans who miss him around the world. Even the courage tour is scheduled for 2022 around the world.
She is a legend with Mariah and whitney. the three of them cannot be replaced by any female singer in this world.
Celine's total album sales.
until now also Far above the two of them.. the thrones of the three of them were already above the level of other female singers.
The world calls them by a big name, As THE VOCAL TRINITY
* But Mariah, she is no longer active. she rarely appears about her latest project. and doesn't have a new album anymore to greet her fans. Caution's, last album in 2018 .
*While Whitney she has long died. Her work will be remembered forever. May her soul rest in peace there.
Biased asf
2 of the greatest vocalists of all time but Christina has the slight edge.
I'm a Celine fan, but cmon, Christina's version will always be iconic.
Christina sang like Etta James and James Brown, it’s more fitting. This isn’t about vocal technique it’s about the rasp and rugged sound!
🤣🤣🤣🤣
christina uses a technique to scratch her voice..
celine little sang rougher broken voice .. she also little sang by forcing on her full voice ... in the early 90s. celine loved to sing with violence and a break in her voice ... example al by myself in 1996 at all debut she was singing a super broken eb5 a bit like aguillera
Christina all the way, full of emotions....
Please listen to the version of Angelina "cute" Jordan. She just smash these two version.
Growling your way through a song isn't emotional. It's just butchering the song
Dion is a LEGEND but christina is so special.
Aguilera is a LEGEND!
Christina. She OWNED this performance.
Of course Christina Aguilera is a LEGEND ❤❤
Please listen to the version of Angelina Jordan.
No shes a trash
So stupid
Celine has a GREAT voice, and outsang Xtina in some songs but definitely NOT this one. Christina owned it, felt it, MADE US feel it. No shade to Celine but this belongs to Xtina
I agree. The voice of Christina is for this type of song.
Why do you like to replace CHRIST by x????
You must me kidding with me🤬
Celine has even more power just talking the worlds out. Christina isn’t in the trinity and will
Never be😎 Celine dions voice voice like a rocket trough the roof👍🏻
And with so much power anyway.
@@Jespher1 stop being toxic 🥲
Celine is such a Legend and incredible artist who is so respectful and good to other artist,but Christina Aguilera rendition of man's world is the best,and standard version,even Celine herself is doing xtina version,and many artist had done xtina version,and Celine herself has said Christina is the best vocalist of this generation,lastly Celine is outstanding I love how she annihilated Mariah and Arethra in divas live 1998...
celine little sang rougher broken voice .. she also little sang by forcing on her full voice ... in the early 90s. celine loved to sing with violence and a break in her voice ... example al by myself in 1996 at all debut she was singing a super broken eb5 a bit like aguillera
Christina all the way!
Celine is one of the best singers in my book, but Xtina has that soul sounding voice that not many singers can perform. Not taking away Celine being amazing because I love her 😍, it’s just Christina is one and only.
Xtinas stage presence is out this world! They both are amazing but, we all know X slayed that night up! 👏👑💋❌
Each have their style and talent and that is what makes both of them queens in their own right❤
They both win. I can't pick between two of my favorite singers!
Xtina baby
Celine is brilliant but comparing her version to Christina’s is just ridiculous. Christina destroyed it, owned it, slayed it!!! That’s one of the best performances of all time. Nobody can compare to Christina.
christina's voice is better for this title .. super celine's high notes, she is clear and superb, piercing the magnificent A5
Christina la Reyna!!! 👑
Christina got way more soul and emotion
EXACTLY her stage presence was incredible!!!
Hahahah eh? Gosh.
Christina all the way
Celine doesn't have VIBRATO at that song...it is light and all emotions that Its mans world has lost it all
celine can sing like christina, listen to this, broken voice while remaining powerful, it looks like aguliera, celine has several voices ua-cam.com/video/AsVFAe-dMFI/v-deo.html
La de christina fue elegido como uno de los mejores 3 performance de la historia de los grammys fue un tributo con la familia de James Brown presente
Christina so iconic😮
I'm a Celine fan yet Christina owned this.
No competition....Christina kilt it!!
My throat was sore after just watching Christina
Yes untrained people will have sore throat,but xtina is a gifted artist who was singing like that since she was 6 years old till now
@@ntuzunkaurintah very true, if you don’t have a any vocal training in the slightest, Christinas style of singing would hurt the average persons voice. Which why she’s considered the voice of her gen. Haha. She’s amazing and so is Celine.
Celine Dion OMG !!!
Xtina is the winner....Celine too soft
Celine was inspired by Christina to sing this, so idk why y’all a bunch of Christina haters lol
Two amazing singers.
Xtina
I will say Christina she gives everything, while Celine is a great singer for sure, but Celine is a vocal machine for me, however, Christina is a true Artist
To all the commentators here saying that CELINE SANG IT BETTER, first of all don’t shoot me coz im a die hard celine fan as well but this version was CHRISTINAS and made it her own. She sang it for James Brown tribute (She was asked to do it) and to see that Celine sang it the same way as Christinas she copied it but Not as good as how Christina did, it’s not because Christina is a better singer (because they’re both GREAT SINGERS) IT IS BECAUSE CELINE singing this version didnt fit her voice the way Christina did. If Celine sang it her own version probably it was a diff story. ✌🏻✌🏻✌🏻
I LOVE them Both. But I prefer Christina Aguilera Version because it has a Soulful version and Powerful Version. And Growl.. More Emotion..
celine's D5 is super clear, piercing with lots of chest, the E5 aguillera is super nice, I love the high-pitched sound with a broken voice! celine can do that too even on F5 in 2020 in tribute to arteha franklin at the end her voice becomes tense and resembles that of aguilera :: at 52 years old
celine can sing like christina, listen to this, broken voice while remaining powerful, it looks like aguliera, celine has several voices ua-cam.com/video/AsVFAe-dMFI/v-deo.html
In my opinion Céline is the greatest female singer on the planet, no doubt about it... But I must say Christina voice suit this song better. Céline voice is almost to "perfect" and well managed.. Céline definitely hit the notes perfect and in a more healthy way, but the rough style Christina possess is better for this song!
Whitney Houston is the best voice and Christina Aguilera!!!
For the people saying Christina screams, certainly dont know soul and gospel. Christina, J Hud, Jennifer Holliday, Aretha, James Brown are ICONIC Definitions of Soul. Celine is a legend but nothing compared to Christina when it comes to Soul.
celine can sing like christina, listen to this, broken voice while remaining powerful, it looks like aguliera, celine has several voices ua-cam.com/video/AsVFAe-dMFI/v-deo.html
Céline Dion all The Way!!!....
Excuse me. Celine was invited to sing for even the burial of the Queen of soul herself with nothing but black people as her audience. So dont preach about celine havin no soul or christina has more soul. Soul is not about growlin and screaming hahahah you're a joke. Comparin this trinity member to screamtina who can barely reach high notes. 3:50 sounds like there's a rat on stage eeeekkkkk
Celine voice very strong, clear, powerfull, balance, control, and be easy for her this song.. not just load
Christina looks up to Celine, don’t get it twisted. But I love Christina. She doesn’t have the resonance that Celine has. Lol
jak30341 this is soul music and james brown song resonance isn’t needed here 😂😂😂 celine has technique but lacks soul. Christina was completely screaming but you could feel what she was singing
Resonance is when the sound leaves the mouth. In any kind of way, whether it is strained, clear, full, rich, loud, quiet and all that. I know that you are talking about an open sound, but resonance is everything what comes from your mouth. Speaking as well is resonance.
Who tf cares lol its not operah Music, you all are so annoying with all your stuff about technique while we're talking about pop singers 😂😂😂😂
@@BlackDavid900 exactly. Music is not only about technique and all that bs, it's also (MAJORLY) about the emotion you put into it. You can have the best technique in the world but if you don't put soul and emotion in your performance, it means nothing 😂
CELINE!
*Celine Dion* always the best
No Contest, Christina !
As a Celine's fan, I agreed that Xtina sang better than Celine for this song. I'm not offended by all the comments thay said Xtina is better... But both can sing very well tho..
Xtina😘😍
This belongs to Christina. She owned it. Celine has the technique and ease, but i prefer Aguilera's version. All the growls, rasp and screamy approach just fit the song.
Xtina sounds strain so I'd go with Celine's. However, both sounding better than any other covers so.....
They're both very good and I love them also.. but in this case, Celine has more relax way of singing.. 😊
i for one prefer celine's version. truly a master class in singing. she took her time, she didn't oversing, and her upper belts were exquisite.
Celine dion ofcourse
Celine Dion very detail
Love both (singer) divas, but I go for Christina's version of this song💖💕
Céline Dion is the best vocaliste, but Christiana is better on this performance 😍
I am a Celine fan all the way but this one is Christina's one
Celine is the best .
both nailed it
Christina Aguilera. Please, there’s no comparison.
Celine Dion of course! She has every musical note controlled and a better vocal technique.
Queen Celine of course😍😍😍😍😍
👑 Xtina 👑
Celine 4ever 😍
Celine sings better and that was even after singing like 12 songs ?? Celine wins
Xtina for ever !
Cristina esta en su ambito musical natural Soul (R&B), interpretando magistralmente la pieza, lamentablemente Celine sale de su estilo Pop (balada), donde indudablemente es extraordinaria, y no tiene el feeling necesario para la pieza musical interpretada
Christina
Sorry xtina I’m exhausted listening you to sing this song. I love celine, she is effortless to sing it ❤
No one gives a fuck girl yuor irelevant jajja like yuo Mather jajjaj xtina all the way
Christina sang it powerful & rock. Celine sang it soft and seductive. If you love powerful voices & something rock, Christina is the best choice. But if you love soft & seductive way, Celine's version is the best. Both are beautiful. But I love Celine's version 'coz she's my most idolized singer ever!
celine can sing like christina, listen to this, broken voice while remaining powerful, it looks like aguliera, celine has several voices ua-cam.com/video/AsVFAe-dMFI/v-deo.html
Celine ofcourse
Was this a real comparison? Christina Aguilera continues to blow the competition out the water. Her rich, soulful, and clear vocals are unmatched. Now get ready to buy that Spanish album on the way.
Christina chose to use this song to showcase her vocal abilities, which simply cannot compare to Celine's. Celine chose to do with this song what she does best, which is to sing it beautifully. While I definitely appreciate Christina's version, it is a bit labored, while Celine seems to fly through the song effortlessly. And Celine beats Christina in some high notes as well.
OMG BOTH
celine's D5 is super clear, piercing with lots of chest, the E5 aguillera is super nice, I love the high-pitched sound with a broken voice! celine can do that too even on F5 in 2020 in tribute to arteha franklin at the end her voice becomes tense and resembles that of aguilera :: at 52 years old
g#5!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! no f5!!! more high
@@fauna7499 for 'It's A Man's World ?????
CELINE 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻❤️❤️❤️❤️
Celine is the most incredible singer of all time..her voice it's legendary. With that song ..or some other..she's the only number one.
It's not even close, Christina without a doubt. It was a All Time Great Performance !!!!
CELINE DION
Christina has the power. Celine‘s voice is to thin for this song
Celine sang this night after night on tour. Christina couldn't have done this more than a couple of times without losing her voice.
mfimh0901 she actually sang this on the liberation tour every date 😴
5:31 RUN NOWWW 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Queen Céline ❤❤❤
Love both ,but Celine was superior 🔥🔥....everything calm,controlled and full of technique,without wanting to prove anything. Of course Christina also is an incredible vocalist ,but she sometimes gets lost while trying to prove something/show-off....that's when she oversings notes and etc.
After hearing Christina Aguilera’s version, for me everyone sounds so dry.
EXACTLY
Céline 🎉🎉
I really love Celine Dion but when it comes to soul/James Brown I think Christina Aguilera has the best voice and power for this song.
I know… all the self titled “voice coach” on UA-cam maybe have another opinion while sitting home behind the screen in a couch with fries on the side…
For me Celine 🔥🔥🔥
Indudablemente Cristina la mejor..
Celine 😍😍😍
Christina the best singer!
3:48 LMAO, she sounds like "Help, there's roaches inside my pants"
Screaming is the way James Brown did it. It's a tribute. Christina perfectly well knows when to scream
@@elenadanailova3870 Celine Dion sing this song after sing 12 song, and ask Christina to sing this sing after 12 song, u will see the different. Oh yeah celine more older than christina, soo only stupid people's said that's Christina version is more better
@Nasir Germain how about your english? Is your english more better than the others, are u english men or just immigrants in Western country
@@elenadanailova3870 it's a high note, not a scream
Both are amazing artisit.
*CD* the best of the best versi clear voice beautiful version nO0o other? 😷
love celine too but tone of aguilera for this song is perfect
They’re both equally amazing, but this song? Christina by far.
Celine😍
No