2023 NFL QUARTERBACK TIERS
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 тра 2024
- There will be arguments. ***FYI, the order of the QB's in each tier is done alphabetically, it's not done by who I think is the best or worst. That was a tier is for, QB's who are relatively just as good as each other.***
MERCHANDISE LINK: teespring.com/stores/barry-mc...
PLEASE BUY MY MERCH!
Joking aside, please check out my merchandise. There's some good stuff in here, especially when it comes to raising awareness for Marijuana Overdoses. Save lives by buying some merch. Others already have. What are you waiting for?
MERCHANDISE LINK: teespring.com/stores/barry-mccockiner-products
Thank you Barry , your awareness campaign has saved me from my marijuana addiction, I’ve now tried Fentanyl as I’ve heard it’s a much safer drug that you cannot overdose on !!!!
Barry your wrong we have seen a case like Geno Smith before and his name is Rich Gannon
Sounds good
Jokes aside *makes joke
Look Barry, I'm worried you're close to a serious cannabis related death....who the fuck is Davante Williams???
I'll never consider Mahomes to be the best QB in the league until he sends inspirational text messages to his teammates.
But for real as a Patriots fan, there’s a small part of me that feels like opening day. I’m going to see Brady run out wearing his uniform that would be funny
@@Thugg12nope, never gonna happen again, now you will be seeing him run out with the raiders cuz he’s a part owner
he needs to send an inspirational text to chris jones
He's not 40 either. Did you Tom was in his 40s and played football? Super unknown fact that no announcer ever told us.
No he just delivers Super Bowl rings to his teammates
Barry single handedly keeps our mind on what truly matters: Football and Jimmy Gs beauty. Remember kids, if you overdose on marijuana you will never again get to see Jimmy’s beautiful face
*Jimmy GQ
He looked so hot with his sunglasses on. Literally printed it out and it is now covering my wife’s boyfriend kid’s drawing on the fridge.
That's a fate worse than death
hurts should’ve sent his defense a motivational text, that’s how you get them to do well
Tom Brady would’ve motivated his defense more
Tom brady willed his defense to success. Truly the most quarterback of all time
That’s why Hurts will never win a Super Bowl
The NFL watered down the middle of the field and left the sidelines drier. This benefited wide receivers. And left no traction for the defense in the middle of the field to give Mahomes the advantage. This is in Arizona, where the field should have been dried. This is the most important game of the year. Why was a field in such s***** condition?
Hurts had better stats than Mahomes on a sloppy field though.. so what advantage are you talking about?
Mahomes clearly was on one good leg still made the plays when needed..
What about 0 sacks for the Eagles
Major credit to Chiefs Oline to show up
This man ripped an absolute ass blast during the Russ segment
12:22
Bro hell no 😂😂
😂😂😂
😭😭😭
Good thing I'm not driving because I am in tears right now 😂😂😂
Barry is such a hero. Even after shitting his pants at 12:22 and completely ruining his Jimmy G pajamas, he powered through and continued with the video until it was over. Thank you Barry. Youre my inspiration!
He does what other non elite QBs can’t do-he comes back after shitting all over himself
*talks about every other quarterback being inconsistent
*puts Jalen Hurts in the elite category after one good season
He's a massive homer. Hurts had the best oline, top 3 set of weapons, and a great defense. Almost any quarterback would look good in that situation.
@connordemo8043 I'm not even saying Hurts is bad or anything. If he wants to put him as elite that's fine. But he can't talk about other Quarterbacks inconsistencies as their biggest weakness when their careers so far have been way more consistent than Hurts'.
@@ryancline54where has Hurts been inconsistent? He has gotten better every season, played at an elite level last year, and was the best player on the field on the biggest stage. If he regresses next year then we can say he is inconsistent but if Hurts is anything it’s consistent.
7:07 "He doesn't throw touchdown passes" Says this during a clip of Daniel Jones throwing a touchdown. I love you Barry.
Barry released this the day Hurricane Idalia made landfall. A true American hero, giving us something to cherish in this trying time.
A real hero would have offered an egg.
Hearing Barry go from “Colts were stupid drafting AR, and AR owes all the millions of dollars he’ll make to Josh Allen” to “wow this actually looked decent in college compared to what I thought and even though he’s a risk I’m glad the Colts took it” just made my whole day. Barry is almost as much of an inspiration as Tom Brady himself
Barry, from a lifelong vikings fan i think you summed up Kirk perfect. Opposite feeling of playing Brady is a perfect description
>Puts up 30+ points half of the time
>Led the largest comeback in the history of the game
>Still loses because of his choking defense
>"WTF WHY IS COUSINS DOING THIS TO US!?"
@@thekillers1stfanhe does not send inspirational texts to his defense so therefore it’s his fault
Yes he did a great job summing up the enigma of Kirk. This year he'll break his curse 🙏
@@thekillers1stfan he got shafted by Mac Jones I'm gonna go ahead and blame Kirk 😭
Hurts should have had 2 fumbles for TD's in the Superbowl. Let's be real.
Ykb
thank you
Wasnt Miles Sanders at fault for fumbling that screen pass?
what a class act to release this video before the season starts.
Goff may go down as the most underrated quarterback in nfl history, he was elite last season and is on pace in breaking Aaron Rodgers record for the most passing attempts without an interception.. 2nd fastest quarterback to reach 25k yards, already a 3x pro bowler at age 28.. like cmon he’s super underrated
Elite quarterbacks don’t lose super bowls 3-13. The biggest stage and you don’t even show up. You can’t even get in the end zone? Come one man, that’s the opposite of elite.
@@Cabooseforprez2012 explain Peyton manning? You’re not going into depth , I bet you didn’t know goff didn’t have kupp, higbee or a run game that game, let’s not ignore the fact that’s an all time patriots defense that held Dak and Big Ben to 0 TDs the following year , hell mahomes scored 0 points in the first half of that afc championship game against that same defense only difference was Andy Reid made adjustments
@@Elusivve You mean where the Broncos lost by 40 something? I don't think it takes a genius to see that even if the offense played better, they're losing the game. Gofff needed to just be average to win and he couldn't. I appreciate the excuse list though.
Jared Goff is a bad quarterback and always will be no matter how his career ends.
@@MrGoodeats 🥱 you’re definitely butthurt
Daniel Jones could go out there and have 40 TDs and 3 INTs and Barry would still put him in scrubs😢
giants made a steep upgrade in weaponry from last year. he’ll likely change his tune on DJ
We all know Daniel Jones will never have that kind of season. 18 TDs to 15 interceptions incoming
That’ll never happen so i guess we’ll never know how true this is
@@tobieainano it’s not and you know that
@@tobieainahe’s definitely not throwing 15 ints lmao
12:22 props to barry for not editing that absolute rip out of the video
im happy someone noticed it too and i wasn't tweaking
Barry it’s 5 am 😞
Well you're awake aren't you 😂
Not here!
8 30 am fr me
It's 8:35 am for me.
@@silvershadow8405 same u wrote this less than a minute ago and we have same time
I feel like you need another tier between Above Average and Elite with Herbert, Jackson, and Tua (maybe Lawrence and Murray) because seeing Lamar Jackson in the same tier as Derek Carr and Kirk Cousins feels like witnessing a crime.
Rodger's connection with Davante Williams was insane
Having Carr and Hebert in the same tier is criminal
I’d put both higher - Carr’s dealing with the worst franchise in the past 5 years (which is REALLY saying something). Their management CANNOT draft, they trade away their great players, and are the most distractingly bad personalities. And that’s not even considering Gruden thinking it’s still the early 2000s, or what Ruggs did, etc. I cannot wait to see him in a different situation.
Youre right, Carr is better.
@@ImFlooryou’re either joking or you’re delusional 😂
They’re more similar physically than you realize although Herbert is better physically. They’re both very talented quarterbacks with consistently bad teams/coaching. Considering Herbert hasn’t shown that more than Carr in terms of winning, it’s fair to put them in the same tier for now.
@@purpl3spartan if you had to pick Carr or Herbert who are you picking
We really need a Barry Fart Counter. I feel like that's something everyone needs
This is at least the second video to have one, I wish I could remember what video the other was
@@WhatAG23 "2021 draft Hit miss or mid" was the other one. Barry let rip just before assessing Kwity Paye and now whenever I see Paye mentioned I can only think of that.
Lamar gonna go crazy if he can stay on the field. Can’t wait. Offensive line also needs to be clicking on pass pro.
Being early to a Barry video is like coming downstairs on Christmas morning
I can’t believe hurts is having this much success despite only having 30-40 all pro/hof caliber players on the roster.
At this stage, Kyler Murray is definitely no longer above average. I look at each of those guys in the average (and average but sexy) tiers and choose each and every one of them over Kyler.
Barry thank you from keeping me from dying of boredom last year with your great vids.
If Herbert was drafted by Miami, he’d be the second coming of Marino and put up insane stats, but no rings
the second coming of Marino in 2023 would need to throw 6k yards a year, that's how far ahead of everyone else Marino was in his time
:( please stop
Still blows my mind that Rodgers was playing with a fractured thumb ON HIS THROWING HAND for most of last season and the entire media basically brushed it off as nothing major.
Some of the most surface level analysis I’ve seen on this app. 10/10 exactly what I came for.
lamar should be higher, but i understand why he’s placed where he is. He really needs to win some playoff games before he’s considered elite
"The Best no. 2 receiver Odell Beckham Jr" That was slick Mr McCockiner, well played.
Claims Joe Burrow’s lack of clutch cop out is his o-line, then immediately blames Jalens lack of clutch on the defense. This guy may actually be an idiot
2 different situations and context though
@@KlvnDxxminiquenot really, joe burrows line as actually bad and the eagles defense is one of the best in the league 😂 Barry is the very definition of a hypocrite and a hater, if it isn’t his team winning he finds excuses and flaws In others to twist the blame that’s called picking a scapegoat.
@@Youremadarentya you’re paying too much attention to the narrative and not what actually happened in those games (AFC Championship & eagles vs chiefs Super Bowl). The bengals defense never allowed 35+ points in the playoffs in the Burrow era, they average around 19 ppg, and Burrow had two go ahead drives in the afc championship to take the lead and choked both times while Hurts was clutch the entire SB outside of the fumble and with the game on the line his defense let Mahomes do whatever he wanted
burrow averages 22 ppg in playoffs with all those weapons... those are pathetic numbers. burrow also threw 4td in 3 playoff games... jalen threw 4 td in just the superbowl...
Also... burrow has 0 td in 4th qtr of playoff games... 0. How can you be called clutch and yet have 0 4th qtr td in 7 playoff games... thats the definition of anti clutch.
Want to know why Cousins seems so 'unlucky'? Check out his defenses over the years since becoming a starter.
'22- 30th
'21- 27th
'20- 28th
'19- 9th
'18- 6th
'17- 24th
'16- 24th
'15- 23rd
Also, having a new OC every year since '17 will certainly have an impact as well. 😳
Thank you! I've been saying for years that Minnesota's offense isn't their problem for years.
Unlucky is not what i would describe last season though, 11 1 score wins.
@joshberkins1834 yeah he was just able to barely outplay his terrible defense in those 11 games. Not luck
New Barry video, I can have a great day now
Jalen Hurts really went from “Will he stay in the league” to “top 5 QB” in one season. I dont know that his skills changed, but the results put him there.
His skills definitely changed. Obviously his arm strength stayed the same but his pocket presence is a lot better and his accuracy is much much better and that stuff is often skill over athleticism
Well it’s easy to be good when you have one of the best olines in the league and top receivers.
His skills absolutely changed he improved his game every season
@@oldbean7150this. the eagles have the best roster in football
What tops it all off, the Eagles nearly traded for Russell Wilson, but Seattle went with the Denver trade.
“Physical traits matter a lot when it comes to being a good nfl quarterback”
*Drew Brees has entered the chat*
I can't believe Barry found time to make this video even though he's saving people from the hurricane in florida. What a hero!
We need a midseason reassessment on this video.
Fr, lot of this stuff didn’t age well
I keep hearing about how Hurts was second in MVP votes..weird to begin with, but okay cool. I've heard it so many times I decided to look it up. ONE 😮
DUDE GOT ONE VOTE😂
Turns out he got the same number of votes as Josh Allen but since there can't be a tie some points value is used as the tiebreaker. Mahomes got 48 votes🎉🎉
I think all us NFL fans agree that Dak Prescott is #32 in the league
And We All Can Agree That is Zach Wilson Is #69 in The League
@@malone4735Nice.
@@malone4735 Only the middle-aged women disagree
@@diamondfinder8933😂😂😂
Corny ass cope 😭
Great video as always Barry
congrats on 200k Mr McCock 🎉🎉🎉
As a Bengals fan, as much as I want to disagree with you on Burrow, I actually understand what you're saying. Until he wins a SB, he shouldnt be held in a clutch regard quite like Mahomes. Though, I believe he will sooner than later do so.
Falcons fan here. I think Burrow is the best qb in the league.(jealous, YES)
Matthew Stafford’s first name being John was the kind of analysis I didn’t expect to hear. Deshaun Watson being called “Deshaun Weinstein” was precisely the content I’m here for. Thank you for your service
Vídeo Suggestion
Using heavy stereotypes what country each fan base is ?
Devante Williams was definitely A-Rod's best receiver from Greenbay.
Great content again but nothing beats that last video on how every team can win the super bowl that was peak 😂
Are weekly reviews coming back ?
Congrats on 200k been here for the long haul
BCB will be great so long as he can stay healthy and not risk his body so much during plays.
the way he described kirk cousins is so funny yet accurate
3:58 that Pickett pic had me 💀💀💀😂😂
You released this at. 5:00 am my time, I just woke up lol.
People just looked at the box score for Richardson, but his pocket presence was indeed very good.
Honestly this year I can see Goff Overtaking Prescott. They are in the same draft class, should be an interesting year.
What happened to the head coach fight tournament video?
As a chargers fan, this is my make or break Herbert year (not like we should keep him or not lol), is a leap gonna be made where he will be in the elite tier instead of very good, or will he just be a really good quarterback like Philip before him
It's always felt like Herbert was forced to play small ball because he just doesn't have any speed around him. He's always seemed to have one of the slowest WRs cores in league.
He has Guyton but he gets hurt a lot
my house is halfway under the water from the florida hurricane but ykw watching this barry video is more important
Barry please reupload the coach fight club video 🙏
Geno was legit one of the best QB's in the league last year especially 20 yards + downfield. I agree he needs to do it again but man watch some of his throws last year it was insane
5 am upload, we vibing
Josh Allen does turn the ball over a bit much in the regular season, but in the playoffs he’s thrown the same amount of picks per game as Mahomes and holds the NFL record for most postseason yards per game with 346. The issue with that team is that the defense and run game completely disappears in the playoffs for some reason.
Thats true but he was awful vs Bengals at home.. that had 2starters in their secondary out
He was awful when he couldnt afford to be
The fact bills defense got bullied at home by a team we know has a suspect Oline, let alone missing 3 starters was the huge shock! Im a Buffalo blizzard nonetheless
@@aceassn716 he really wasn’t that bad against the Bengals. He had 290 yards and a touchdown. I mean that isn’t his best performance, but considering it was in a blizzard with a torn UCL with an O-line that couldn’t give him more than 1 second to throw to receivers who couldn’t get open, it’s far from a bad game. The problem was that Buffalo’s defense was nonexistent forcing only 2 punts and 0 turnovers all game. And Josh Allen was Buffalo’s leading rusher with 26 yards 😂. In my opinion the coaching job was the biggest offender. There was constant miscommunication, everyone seemed to be in terrible positions to make any type of play, and there were no adjustments all game. Allen was doing everything he possibly could. He would have to, and did a few times, make an absolutely crazy play just to give the offense a 10 yard gain.
@@sprawlz6466I swear at this point you're his alt account. 😂🤣 dudes ucl wasn't torn. It was bruised in week 9. He was on the injury report for 2 weeks. Until week 12, then never listed again. After he failed in the postseason, like normal, he went on to immediately play in a golf tournament. Golf is ridiculously strenuous on the ucl, as in, you can't play with an even slightly sore ucl injury.
Why did Allen alone have 4 turnovers against the dolphins? The 28th ranked defense in the NFL? Is that on the coach?
@@CalebJohnston A partially torn UCL is definitely not a bruise. I don’t think you’ve ever played golf. And you’re lying, Allen did not have 4 turnovers against Miami lol. He’s never turned the ball over in a close postseason game he lost. You’re such an idiot and aren’t worth losing brain cells over so I’m not having this conversation with you. Have a nice day
@@CalebJohnston They have had a top ranked defense in the regular season, which averages like 30+ points in the postseason. Far from Allen’s best playoff performance, where the defense again let him down. I was at the bengals game, and I could tell that there was just a gaping hole 5-8 yards off the line. That is coaching and the defense not doing its job
i think that brady was the anti system qb, i think he was good and bill is bad bc look at his record and stats before and after brady
Barry, do a best NFL/NBA coaches ever list
"Jamarcus Russell levels of terrible" 😡😡😡...IM HOLDING THIS RECEIPT BARRY! That being said congrats on 200k my man!
I'll be absolutely amazed if Geno Smith comes anywhere close to what he did last season
laughed 1 second in, great video barry
Thanks bro
Thanks for the video Barry really makes me appreciate life again after my wife left me and my son overdosed on the devils lettuce
Happy 200k
These are my favorite videos, but I have to watch on my phone because my wife's boyfriend gets the big TV.
That Herbert ranking is criminal.
Barry’s been pumping out videos the same way my wife’s boyfriend pumps her! God, I love the troops
Coming back to this when DJ lights up the league
Love the video, but why so critical of Bryce Young? He’s looked solid so far in the preseason, which I know doesn’t mean a ton but still
the fart at 12:22 killed me. thanks a lot barry
Barry doing his best Collinsworth impression in this video with the "this is a guy" references
“The best number 2 receiver, Odell Beckham Jr.”😂
He might not even be a top 10 wr2
I think it’s a pun about his poop fetish.
Would like a video on how the Bills cant draft since 2018. All of their top picks from 2019 on are busts or mediocre. They just traded Basham for a 7th rounder lol. Beane and McDermott riding the coattails of a random stab in the dark pick with Josh Allen (his draft grade wasnt good) and it being a success.
The Bryce Young hate is in my mind unwarranted this kid is going to be good with a ceiling of great, mark it down
Crazy how people are saying Bryce is injury prone because he’s undersized but yet he’s only been injured once in college and he only missed 1.5 games
this is the pros man come on
@@sleepful1917 So? How many contact injuries have Russ and Kyler had? Not a lot
Explain the trey lance situation in nba terms pls
200k 🔥📈
Its like Robert Downey Jr. is talking to me about qbs, i love it
OSU has never produced a great NFL QB because they’ve been “coddled”. One of the best O lines and incredible weapons every year produces a QB that hasn’t faced any adversity. Essentially the game is easy for them, but the NFL, even facing the worst team, isn’t easy.
They face the same adversity as any qb on a top five team in college, there are a lot of QBs who haven’t faced a lot of adversity and still pan out in the nfl. And there has only been like three osu QBs drafted in the first round in over 25 years.
Most OSU QBs are late rounds picks anyway. And a lot of them were running more than passing.
“Every year we’re waiting for Herbert to become an elite quarterback”.
Nah bro, I think just you are.
Imagine if Aj brown missed 9 games, Devonta missed 6, Mailata missed the whole season, Reddick missed the whole season, Slay missed the whole season, CGJ missed most the season and Hurts had to play on broken ribs. The eagles would still have been healthier than the chargers. and they won 10 games on a schedule that actually played NFL teams instead of the AFC and NFC south
Football and Barry are back
The problem with Rodgers and Cousins is they rolled 15 and 10 out of 99 in the Clutch stat, respectively.
I like how Barry nicknamed Anthony Richardson after the fat guy from the Longest Yard (2005)
herbert with a healthy wr core is a top 3-5 player in the league and if allen, williams, and johnston stays healthy, its a big year ahead
Yeah people don’t think about how he was throwing to no names for more than half of last season and still put up great stats and made insane plays every game.
A true US American hero. Thank you Captain McCockiner!
Love your channel Barry but I think you’re gonna come to regret putting Danny in the “scrubs” category. Watch his stats dramatically increase this year without having the worst (by far) WR corps in the league and Daboll opening up the playbook as a result of that. There’s a reason why the coach of the year and a great GM who both came from the same franchise signed and believe in him.
Yeah, because he had one good game against a terrible Vikings defense in the playoffs and then he crapped his pants against an actually good team the next week. He is thoroughly average, and it's laughable that some people believe that he's good. He and the Giants are going to regress super hard from their flukey season last year.
@@thecrazynodak that wasn’t his only good game plus as Barry always says, the NFL is a TEAM sport. To use the Philly loss is a terrible argument as their team as a whole is and was much further ahead than the Giants. U really think Daboll and Schoen being the guys that they r would sign Danny to that contract because of “one good game”? They had the worst WR corps in the league and couldn’t call the deep crossers that Daboll ran in Buffalo; Danny when he had a half decent offensive coach (Shurmur still sucked as a whole) threw 24 TDs in 12 games his rookie season which was on pace for the rookie record. Let’s see how this plays out but I think you’re gonna be pretty surprised.
That Daniel Jones roast was incredible
Contesting the Mac Jones ranking, I think most of his issues were from Matt Patricia at play caller. My rationale is:
1. A lot of passes ended up being short screens
2. When Mac was hurt and Bailey Zappe came in, the playbook Zappe was given had mostly plays that Mac Jones ran the year before when the playcalling was more suited for him. Zappe, a below average backup, adjusted to it and won games as a result
And yes I know you have the system qb agenda, but I think Mac much more fits into the system qb category. You're right about him having a below average arm, and his vision is sometimes suspect, but under the right system, like what he had in his rookie year, he'll do a lot better
I don't think he's a scrub, but he does fall into that average/system qb tier. He still has time to develop into a solid starter imo, but you're right about this year being telling for the kind of player he's gonna be
Edit: Alright nevermind he was fucking horrible
I was hoping Mahomes would have a category called “rigged Super Bowl”
I would put stafford in elite as he holds a ton of league records. Not just that: in SB56 if you put any other qb in a rams jersey, they wouldn't have made back to back 10 yard tds.
He is the comeback king. That deserves more than "above average".
Edit: for reference Rodgers holds 8 NFL records, Stafford has 18.
Hard worker hunter renfrow just caught me off guard and was too funny
12:07 love the little misdirection here u scared me for a sec