Avengers: Endgame - Every Mystery The Russos Have Answered
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 лип 2024
- Why did it have to be Tony Stark? #Avengers #MCU
For more awesome content, check out: whatculture.com/
Follow us on Facebook at: / whatculture
Catch us on Twitter: / whatculture - Розваги
I actually really liked Thor grappling with depression and having it negatively affect him both physically and mentally, because of 1 key scene. When he travels to the past and calls Mjolnir, it comes to him, signifying that his failure and consequential depression does not render him 'unworthy.' It's a quick, but quite resonant moment about self-worth when grappling with feelings of inadequacy.
That's actually really spot on. Well said :)
But they failed to answer the biggest question of all: why is Gamora?
She's a Splinter. There is a reality where in 2014 by the Terran Calendar Thanos and his entire army vanished from the cosmos. What that reality looks like is anyone's guess. Gamora is a traveler from that reality. It was the only way to restore Gamora that wouldn't also open up the ability to just bring Natasha back and negate her sacrifice.
@@MrJackfaire you didn't get it....."i'll do you one better : WHY SO GAMORA ?" from the previous movie
@@MrJackfaire thats what and who. Not why.
@@MrJackfaire but it begs they question, why couldn't they just grab Nat from another dimension? maybe they can grab her from the same reality where thanos disappeared, that one's already messed up, what difference would one more person make? i know, unknown consequences (plus, comic book movie, don't press the science too hard) but in reality somebody who cared about her would at least try, damn the consequences!
To be completely honest, it wasn't the same Gamora that fell in love with Star Lord. Nebula did open her mind to defying Thanos, but the relationship between Quinn and Gamora will probably be shown more in Guardians 3.
If the mouse pressing the button releasing AntMan from the quantum realm was the key to winning that also means they couldn’t win without AntMan. I kinda feel AntMan doesn’t fully get the respect he deserves
Yeah he really doesn't get the respect he deserves in general
Not dissing antman but it wasn't because of him exactly, it's more because of his knowledge of the quantum realm
It was a rat not a mouse, you want to work for WhatCulture, you're lack of knowledge is perfect for them.
EVILSPEAK !!! Oh how could I have missed such a critical fact? Thank you so much for fact checking me on the type of rodent it was 😑
@@blueeyedtech1234 And it's Ant-Man not AntMan (or AnyMan, correct your mistake).
I would love to see a Marvel short of Cap meeting the Red Skull.
Well, they haven't done a Marvel one-shot in a while.
That is NOT a mouse, that was a RAT.
You're damn right. How dare they diminish RAT-man
I was going to say the same thing, rats and mice are very different from the other. I don't know how you can confuse a mouse for a rat?
Rats are much smarter than mice.
@@Golux5 new fan theory.. the rat knew what he was doing the whole time
He said “mouse” so much I was almost convinced it was a mouse by the end of the video 😉
That Bucky thing bugs me when people say he was "healed"...
Shuri only removed his brainwashing and subconscious suggestion state, he's still a traumatized man out of time with the memories of mass murder and the killing of innocents. You don't just "fix" trauma.
I can attest to that first hand. I died when having my lung removed during a series of seizures, and I have nightmares about it pretty regularly years later. Also, I get anxious and sick just thinking about times when I was an asshole as a teenager and it makes me cringe and keeps me up at night, I couldn't even imagine how much worse it must be remembering murder and death and beingcontrolled to do awful things.
Bucky is not okay, and I'm sure one day he will be worthy of the shield, but not yet.
I love y’all 3000. Hope you are having a good day❤️❤️❤️
I kinda wish the mouse pressing the button was a nod to "hitchhikers guide to the galaxy"
Umm, one simple answer. Disney owns Marvel, they have to be consistent with "it all started with a mouse".
You wouldn't happen to know the name of the mouse is Mickey?
In infinity war the red skull says that 70 years ago he sought the stones himself so obviously his conscious is still there
There was a post-credit scene... It was released separately and it was called Far From Home
Domihork underrated comment
Noobmaster69 was really Loki trying to annoy Thor.
They don’t call him the god of mischief for nothing.
Noobmaster69 was really Deadpool, all will be revealed once we get the next DP movie... ;)
I like the theory that it was actually Tony lol
He stays up at night, and that would be daytime in New Asgard and I'm sure he keeps tabs of his friends and probably just trolls Korg because he wants to talk to Thor!
Haha Also Thor told Noobmaster69 to go cry to his father, and that's exactly what Tony did.
I just want to know why they changed how the Infinity Stones works so much and why they seemingly forgot Hulk's regeneration
Ikr? When I watched the movie the first time I didn't realized that Hawkeye shouldn't be capable of holding the soul stone until I rewatched it a couple of months ago
the damage caused by the stones was irreparable that is why hulk didn't regenerate
Van Bowel he was healing by the end of the movie....
@@nomadscheap-n-nerdy9901 at no point are we shown the hulk's arm healing, it's only in an arm sling
mocha 907 injuries from the infinity stone can not be regenerated or at least they take time to heal.
They didn't say there was only 1 reality where the rat allowed Scott to escape the quantum realm. It was a thing that *had* to happen, and didn't happen a large percentage of the time, but there were probably many realities where Scott escaped and the heist either didn't work, or Scott escaped but Tony was already dead by then, or the rat helped Scott escape, but never got the time heist idea, etc.
dennydorko Correct. You are using logic at a level that Josh clearly is incapable of. Not trying to be mean but this video has a follow up to his disastrous “plot holes” video in which he actually goes back and tries to watch the film while not high on crystal meth, and yet he *still* can’t put two and two together. 🙄
The mythological Thor was an overweight alcoholic....made sense to me.
that isnt the problem. the fact that him being an alcoholic overwrited thousands of years of battle training is what doesnt make sense to me.
@@soraceant how does that work, how does battle training prevent you from being an alcoholic? thor is still essentially human (Asgardian, I know, but they seem pretty similar to humans) and subject to at least some human afflictions, such as depression and ptsd. IT MAKES TOTAL SENSE that a man in his position would have these reactions. what makes no sense to me is why people have a problem understanding that. virtually none of us would end up ok after losing father, mother, brother, sister, home planet, Jane, his pride, his dignity, and the future of the planet all in a short period of time. no battle training would change that.
Jude Ceant He will be back to his muscular self the next time we see him.
He has fallen on hard times..Overweight alcoholic gamer
John Smith If we see him. She-Thor is coming.
For number 6 they could have just said “a single time stone can’t fix something that was done by all six stones at once”
Like how you can’t bring back Natasha from Vormir, some things done by the stones are just permanent.
Right, even when thanos reversed time to fix the mind stone, he had to reverse the explosion that destroyed it in the first place and repaired vision. Assuming Strange tried to use the time stone to fix Tony’s body, by the same logic he’d have to reverse the snap to do so. Assuming it’s even possible to do that and go against the combined stones power like you said, there’s no way to stop Iron mans sacrifice without reversing how it happened, which would mean bringing back Thanos too
@@vexxama So have him Snap Tony back with a 5 second delayed self-heal so he lives too.
@@ilovejettrooper5922 Shhhh, they don't want to hear logic.
@@ilovejettrooper5922
And if Strange rolls it back to just before Tony's snap, how does he get that glove off him and onto someone stronger, before Thanos stomps them all?
@@PaulSchober No, no, no. Not *undoing* Tony's Snap; simply using a Snap of his own to heal Tony and setting a heal on himself for afterwards.
My guess about Dr strange and rewinding Tony's death is that you can't undo the power of all six infinity stones, so Tony's death took place and it scarred his body forever, withstanding even the power of the Time Stone and Soul Stone. The only thing capable of bringing him back would be another snap, and no-one around was in a fit state to even attempt one.
Sadly no, because they never go over that anywhere. One thing that irritates me with time travel plots is that they'll write up time travel as a thing, and then be like, "you can't change the past", completely undercutting the time travel they put in.
They actually did a beautiful job with it in About Time. It's not that he can't change the past. He can't go back past his birth because he quantum leaps into his prior self. And he can't go back before the birth of his child, not because it isn't possible, but because he wouldn't have THAT child anymore, because of butterfly effect (that one sperm that makes it through can be changed by the instant.)
Why five years?
- Pod of whales in Hudson, clean water; a critically clever way to show everyone the bright side.
The real question is what happened to Tobey Maguire, Andrew Garfield and Tom Hardy during the snap?
Their agents got dusted.
Tom... Holland?
zax2004 no tom should have stayed snapped.
@@nomadscheap-n-nerdy9901 what?
Nomads cheap-n-nerdy! He was literally the best actor but ok
I think the only reason the hammer let Captain America wield it was because Thor's life was genuinely in danger and he was going to be killed if not for the hammer allowing cap to pick it up
Chr1stph3r James I like that observation.
Bucky "Pretty much cured." He's rested. He had a nice break, in the country. He's still got code-words, and a killer assassin in his head. He's compromised. (Of course, so is America, but we don't want to advertise that.) It would be like giving Banner the shield, back when he couldn't control the Hulk, and was still going on rampages whenever he got Angry.
“Pretty much cured.” I take it you are quoting from the video, with sarcasm, so agreed.
Its mot resolved my questions tbf but ty enjoyed anyway x
I think everyone knows iron man died because his contract was up. He chose not to resign. So they gave him a fond farewell.
Red Skull still has some semblance of a conscious. He once stated on Vormir, "I once held an Infinity Stone in my hand."
BlackSuave44 that would better explain his somber tone and the way he says things. It suggests someone who had misguided ideals that lead to great power, learning of their own folly and understanding that their unfortunate fate was their own doing.
I thought Cap would have felt Bucky deserved more of a chance to rest after decades of being a tool of others. Sam is still an idealistic believer
I still think there should be a 6 part Disney + series about Captain America returning the stones to their timelines. It would good to see Cap on Asgard or returning the Time stone to the Ancient One & have a discussion on Cap going back to past.
well if doctor strange reversed time and saved tony to before he had the stones, that means he never snapped and that would’ve meant that they didn’t win since Thanos was never actually gone.
The mouse one is ludicrous. What actions taken before that happened had any bearing on it happening; until it happens, you don't know you're on that track.
Mat pat did the math. It was essentially guaranteed that the rat would hit the button in a 5 year time period. So basically every future had the rat pressing the button, it was just how the other characters reacted
The Russo brothers can’t say anything about Age of Ultron because they had nothing to do with that movie
Number 6 is actually not that confusing. In every instance where Dr. Strange used the Time Stone to save Tony, something else happens to make them then lose. Maybe in those instances somewhere down the line yet another Thanos shows up, or something worse comes. It is the same concept as everything else; the butterfly effect.
Also consider that even the Snap couldn't bring Nat back, the same is probably true of Tony.
I've always liked the idea that cap goes to live a normal life but weighs in from time to time with organisations like shield to give tips like how to prevent hydra taking over or how to prevent certain wars. I guess the way I see it is he would advise young cap who would carry on the captain america legacy
Adam Jasper No. He is in an alternate timeline. The film makes clear that you can’t change the past, you’d just create an alternate future. Going back to the past to marry and have children is already changing the past. So Cap would have no possibility of living his life without changing the past. He is in alternate timeline, so he can do whatever he thinks is best. As confirmed by the filmmakers.
Bucky should have got the shield. He's an actual super soldier.
AnCap Dawg He is still seen as a criminal and terrorist by much of the world. He is not ready for it. Sam Wilson earned the shield. I am sure Steve will give up some of his blood to use for a super soldier serum for Sam.
@@captcrais101 And Bucky didn't? Dude gave up his life during World War 2, and most of the world isn't going to know that the Winter Soldier and Bucky are the same person. Its also not that hard to explain mind control. Not sayin' Sam didn't earn it, dude did, but having him pass over his BEST FRIEND and greatest ally in favor of a guy he's only known a couple of years was an insult to Bucky.
@@palladiamorsdeus - He also killed Howard Stark, who, oh, btw, MADE THE SHIELD.
Oh, yeah. He's still some semblance of a lunatic..or possibly one.
Iron Man didn't need to die.
He had the Infinity Gauntlet. The snap was necessary to end or return half the life in the universe but Thanos demonstrated in Infinity War that the Gauntlet, with only 4 stones, was powerful enough to crush a moon and hurl the debris onto his destroyed home planet.
Surely, a fully loaded Infinity Gauntlet could annihilate Thanos' entire forces with less effort.
Anthony Cristo : This statement continues to be foolish on the same two levels and the folly is pointed out dozens of times on this forum, but of course stupid is as stupid does, so a fool would never bother to read the thread before responding.
1-> The Gauntlet was sending gamma radiation thru his body from the moment he touched it. So Iron man was *dead* from the moment he put the Gauntlet on.
2-> IronMan has to destroy Thanos from all time lines....body mind and soul, in space time and all of reality. He needs to snap.
Go ahead and fail to understand the answer and repeat that question then. That’s what one would expect from a fool.
Calling someone you do not know a "fool" (or any other belittling name) because they disagree with your point of view, is the sign of someone with a weak argument.
When you graduate magna cum laude with a degree in writing from a prestigious university in screenwriting and can understand story arc, then come respond to this thread.
Still a great movie. Just had a few loopholes (as do all movies) where the suspension of disbelief has to be maintained.
Perhaps Dr. Strange would have learned the verity I pointed out if he had experienced 16,000,406.
Lemme help you out chief. Mule-o-near.
Me-YOLE-near. My Grandma (who just passed away last week, rest her soul) was full Norwiegian, she used to tell us stories from Norse mythology, and this is how she'd always say it.
@@feanor411
Maybe I'm just being pedantic... but wouldn't it be more like...
mYOLE-near... with only 2 syllables and not 3?
The "mYOLE" portion of the word runs together as one syllable with the "near" as the 2nd?
Anyway that's how I was taught to pronounce it by my Norwegian grandmother as a kid... but she died 30 years ago now so my memory may be off.
@@whitetallon8784 actually you are right, it is two syllables. that is how my grandma said it too.
@@whitetallon8784 you are spot on, 2 syllables with the M and Y sounds blending together. with the only caveat being it's less of the hard O sound. It's more like the U sound of mule.
It's hard to explain with the way the language works, but the inflection is on that part of the word and it inflects more downward like the natural English U sound. Instead of upward like the hard O.
I'm just glad they didn't break their own time travel rules, that whole "cap was always here" thing really messed with me.
The Mouse was truly Inevitable
It was a rat.
It was luck. Pure luck. 14 million other times that didn't happen.
The fact that people didn't think on their own that the pim particle was reverse engineered by thanos and his crew bothers me. Why do so many people lack imagination when watching or reading a fictional story?.... Are you actually paying attention? There are freaking wizards and aliens!!! Anything can happen lol
I knew Iron Man was the one to die from the first movie and the way Dr. Strange was talking to him, plus of the three people with contacts up-I figured it had to be Iron Man
Russos "His past conscious may or may not exist any more."
They must of forgot their own movie. Red Skull's memories are still inside him about who Captain America is and who he use to be, he mentioned during Infinity War...
Red Skull "A life time ago, I too sought the stones. I even held one in my hand, but it cast me out. Banished me here, guiding others to a treasure I cannot possess."
Scorpwanna Good post, but I think the issue is more persona than conscious. After all the Red Skull also knew who Natasha’s daddy was, and knew of Thanos....so that’s not just the Red Skull from WWII now is it? He is really a condemned spirit consigned to hell.
At this point, you only get powdered milk from this cow, WhatCulture. Enough.
If you poke enough, everything is going to seem flimsy to a point. Its entertainment, not a biopic, people need to chill.
And thanks to people like you cinema is SHIT these days.
All Hail RATvenger! the greatest hero in the MCU!
For the question of why couldn't they bring Ironman back: It seems like the time stone puts the energy back into whatever was destroyed. Vision and the mind stone being a good example. But since Ironman was destroyed while releasing enough energy to completely destroy Thanos and his army, then they would have to undo that final snap to bring him back.
Every other use of the time stone didn't undo something that another stone did. Vision and the mind stone being reversed was undoing something that Wanda did.
Flight Recorder Why do people have trouble with the simple logic of this.
1) remove time stone from dead iron mans gauntlet.
2) put in Eye of Agamotto
3) dial back time.
4) result time stone leaves Eye and goes back to dead Iron Man’s gauntlet. *Experiment Over*
⬆️ I guess Josh and his fans would just keep doing this over and over and never figure out that their logic is flawed, and you can’t bring iron man back to life in this way. ??
I always thought that the “snapped” weren’t actually dead or alive but in the soul stone or something
My 2 disappointments in this movie are.....I really wanted to see thanos retrieve the space stone because the planet it was on was a big part of GOTG. I really wanted to see hulk "hulk out" in the final fight.
This is epic
real question is why did bucky go fight thanos , a damn space titan god,and his hordes of aliens with a damn M4 lol
@The Mad Atheist cap was using his strength vs the space titan god and he fought well.bucky was shooting with the m4 instead of using the superhuman superstrength shit he is on
bucky has superhuman strength and speed thanks to the serum, is a trained fighter and has a vibranium arm. the real question is what was mantis doing there??
@Joe Kinchicken you do know that iron man does that too rihgt?
Cause that's what he had in Infinity War. He was snapped than came back at the same time.
@Joe Kinchicken i mean it´s still exiting technology to have new tech, also not every character has to be this op dude, some of them can be more grounded, and we´ve seen how bucky can fight if he is in winter soldier terminator mode, so he is not really lame he is just more grounded which is always a nice touch also he is a super soldier got experimented on by zola
Consider this for Tony's death. The thing that caused his death was the snap itself. The snap which the Time Stone was a part of. Rewinding Tony to the moment before the snap would undo the snap AND force the Time Stone to alter its own timeline, which would cause a paradox. BUT! Technically it would also undo the snap, therefore returning Thanos and his army back to existence. It's sort of like in Doctor Who when something is a fixed point in time and altering it shatters reality.
I think I might have an explanation for 6. Thanos' army was already there in existence 5 years later.
To the "Why Tony?" question, I'd like to think that he may have thought that there was a "Monkey's Paw" thing with the snap, where it will take everything literally and it could go wrong if you aren't specific enough, and to Tony, he probably thought he was the only one available to account for all the details for his snap.
Ex: if he tossed it to Cap. Marvel, she may have said, "dust all the aliens", and the only ones left would be earthlings..... in the entire universe.
or
"Dust all of Thanos' army and family." which would include Nebula and Gamora as well.
Captain Marvel was knocked out by Thanos at the time, and with one stone. IronMan absorbed the stones into his armor. It’s nano tech. It’s lethal radiation meant that at this point he was dead. Trying to find a better strategy for Iron Man than snapping is a fools errand and every fool who tries - ends up like Josh, just revealing that they don’t understand how the stones work, how the gauntlet works, how alternate timeline work, or how movies work for that matter.
I guess the Sorcerers want to avoid messing with time unless the whole world is on the line, Mordo warned Strange about it. That's why Strange restored the Sanctum and its occupants in his movie but didn't resurrect the Ancient One or Tony and even then Mordo was still pissed off that he risked using the Time Stone. Thanos doesn't have any concern for altering the space-time continuum to get the rest of the stones and getting his sunrise moment.
2. That WAS the same Red Skull as he quotes in Infinity War "I once sought out the stones a lifetime ago" ...so yeah you're wrong.
pash91 Anything that involves time travel - Josh is mentally overmatched. That much is clear.
First, I think it was a rat, not a mouse. Second, Tony had to sacrifice himself because RDJ wanted to hang up the role. Third, no one cares how Bruce & Hulk worked out their differences. Fourth, the shield isn't a powerful weapon, it's a SYMBOL -- it's only a weapon in Cap's hands because he has super-strength and super-agility. Anyway, I like this channel, but this video is just dopey.
I agree with RDJ thing. If they ever wanted to bring Tony back, they’d have to renew his contract.
I think people do care about how Hulk and Banner made peace with each other.
Also caps shield is made of virbraniam and is very powerful
@@Deathpool_04 Personally, while I'm a little curious about the process he used to merge the two, it'd no doubt be some ridiculous pseudo scientific bullshit (Vita Rays, anyone?) After the events of Infinity War it should be very clear why he would want to, and his line "We have a lot to work out, pal" sets up his transformation perfectly. That's really all the information you need for the transformation to make sense, the rest is just unnecessary details.
Jerrod Tibor Sure but we don’t know how. They “worked things out” but the mind of the hulk is basically gone. How exactly did Hulk just accept that? People do think that banner basically “killed” the hulk.
@@Deathpool_04 I don't think the Hulk's mind is gone, but he has probably grown up some due to the transformation. Prf Hulk has a somewhat different personality than just Bruce had, more lighthearted, more of a people person, less brooding and introverted. That's Hulk's contribution to the mix. Bruce may have helped Hulk realize he wouldn't be angry all the time, and he wouldn't have to go away once Banner had cooled off.
I don't get why people think Thanos figuring out Pym Particles is "hand wavey." the entire plot of ant-man was because Cross figured out how to make them based just on rumors, Thanos had an actual sample of them. Even if he couldn't figure them out, he had access to Nebulas memories so would know he could just invade earth and get some there
There was no possibility that Thanos wouldn't figure it out. His intelligence is near peerless.
I thought Tony had to survive Infinity War to solve the time travel problem not do the snap. Who else could have done that?
Tony couldn't have done it without Hank Pym first creating the tunnel that takes you into the quantum realm. He didn't really solve it by himself.
It wasn't just the mouse everything had to line up perfectly for that one to happen I'm shore there are time lines where the mouse pushed the button but tony didn't get rescued 114 million different outcomes
I thought captain America was not worthy to pick up thor's hammer because he knew that Bucky Burns kill Tony's parents and didn't tell him the truth then when the true was told he was worthy.
It really concerns me that he doesn’t know the difference between a mouse and a rat...
hurdy gurdy 😂😂😂
Dr Strange dying over and over again in the futures he visited isnt really that different than dying to Dormamu over and over again in the Dr Strange movie. Apparently he was hardened to that investigative method during the "who knows how many times" he died in his stand-alone adventure.
This video is an absolute masterpiece,
didn't expect such a gem so late in the Endgame newscycle
For the Time Stone, I find the explanation rather simple.
1. Thanos was still alive when he used the stone on his own wound, it was also a wound inflicted by an axe, not infinite cosmic energies.
2. When Thanos undid Vision's Death with it, it was a death inflicted by Wanda, not the full gauntlet. Also, Vision is, at the end of the day, a robot. Artificial life.
3. If Tony had died any other way, the stone could have reversed it, but because Tony died because he used the full power of the Gauntlet, the damage was simply too much for even the Time Stone to undo. Even if juiced up by the Power Stone.
Those are my reasonings on why the Stone wasn't used to bring Tony back. Personally, I think it's more of that last one, since the Time Stone has proven capable of reversing human death. However, those ones were caused by Dormammu's attack, not by using an Infinity Gauntlet.
Alice 1) Correct, and he could use the power stone also to heal his wound. The Thor wound is not caused by the Infinity Gauntlet, what Josh misses - among *many* other things, is that Thanos wound from the Infinity Gauntlet to his arm and left side - is permanent. It *did not heal.* Josh and his frankly not too perceptive followers just missed it.
2) The key point with Vision is a delicate bit of logic, that too many still miss, and given their inability to even grasp why Peter’s friends are still in school, this one may be too hard for some of them, but anyway.....
-> Thanos uses the time stone on Vision. Vision has the mind stone. Remember this. Again...Vision has the mind stone, not the time stone.
-> When Vision is turned back in time, the *mind stone* goes back to Vision because he had in the immediate past.
-> Now, if you use the Eye of Agamoto to turn Tony Stark back in time -> the *time stone* goes back to Tony Stark - because he had it when he snapped, which is what killed him in the first place.
*Once the time stone is not in the Eye,but is in Tony’s Gauntlet again, then you don’t have it, and you *can’t use it*, because you have *turned the time stone back in time along with Iron Man.*
He would just be laying their dead. *Granted.* One can keep taking the time stone off of his dead body and trying again...over and over, if you’re feeling especially retarded about it. 😂
"Mule" "near" say it like that and you'll be fine.
Didn't like how they nerfed the power of Thanos's lieutenants ..
Black Widow is NOT a superhuman in anyway, she's not stronger than an ordinary female athlete, yet she fended of Proxima Midnight without much problem, and the fact that Captain America captures her spear when it's tossed, a spear that put so much weight on the Hulk that he couldn't move....
Hand to hand combat, Proxima Midnight should even put Captain America in his place due to her strength combined with her master of Hand to hand combat..
Booky Barnes
You know what is really sad about Tony's sacrifice? It was totally unnecessary. He had the stones. All he had to do was fly to Nebraska and wait for Captain Marvel to clean up the battle.
Tony could hardly stand at that point. Chances are his suit was as messed up as it was the previous time he got smacked around by Thanos. No guarantee he could have made an escape with the stones. Thanos would have directed everything he had against him. He had to snap. Even if Strange rolled back time, how could they get Tony's gauntlet off an onto someone else before Thanos kicks their asses? He was standing right there.
2:42 seems to be a separate closed timeline. Ran in conjunction to "normal" plot time as a secret side identity is one my guesses. Or it was a whole separate mini pocket verse paradox letting him cheat a little and live both timelines at the end. Woulda loved to see Widow come back with her happy ending too everyone else except MAYBE Quill seemed to get one. But if its "meant" to be she'll still find her way to his crew and side only With retired Thor and Nebula there now too
There's another reason why Tony Stark was the only one who could have performed the snap beyond the fact that he was the closest. The glove that Thanos was wearing in the end was made from Stark nano-tech, which means that since every attempt to get the glove off of Thanos in both movies had failed that logically Stark could remove the stones via manipulating the nano-tech on Thanos' hand via the same nano-tech in the Iron Man suit that Stark was wearing. If you watch closely when Stark grabs the glove he's obviously not trying to remove the glove so much as buy enough time to snatch the stones.
Why iroman? Cuz hes retiring. Thats the simple asnwer.
Not retiring, his contract ranoit
Dude was making a shit ton of money from the movies. They wanted to remove him without upsetting anyone.
In film simple answer: Because only Iron Man's armour could steal/transfer and hold the stones. Everyone else would have to first get the gauntlet of Thanos while Stark just had to get his fist close enough to the gauntlet (it also being Stark Tech) to initiate the transfer. Simple.
The MCU began with Tony, so it's only logical his death would close out the first chapter.
Because at the rate RDJ's paycheck kept increasing per movie, they'd barely break even at the box office.
No way, in number 10, Cap knew it was Tony father's killer is Buck (in Winter Soldier Dr. Zola shows him and Natasha, the same video Zimo uses to split heroes in Civil War) and it wasn't revealed to Tony what happened, The Age of Ultron is exactly between these two films, so Cap, for hiding it from his friend, this event probably doesn't allow him to be completely worthy of wielding the Mjölnir at that time in the Age of Ultron, but changing at Endgame with Cap already redeemed of your mistake with your friend Tony.
Logan Gomes da Silva : Funny people can remember that Bucky killed Tony’s father, but seem to forget about when they ask the question why Cap doesn’t give the shield to Bucky. Maybe they forget the scene where Cap threw the shield down in the 1st place - when Iron Man reminded him that *his father* made the shield.
No end credits?
TING.... TING...
They should go into world breaker hulk next. They could make it seem like banner never merged with hulk, but just left him in a dorment state. This forced dormancy will cause the anger to build to new height.
No... The opportunity for the World Breaker is passed.
Here's a mystery - are there only 14.000.605 possible futures? Surely the amount of potential futures must be near endless? So why didn't Dr. Strange keep going until he found one where all the heroes survived?
I think the Sorcerer Supreme said there were infinite timelines, maybe she didn't mean it in a literal sense? It's not likely that the possible outcomes would be literally limitless. Actions create consequences, so every possible future relies on a set of actions in order to come into being.
It would be cool if it was some guy just messing around in the van then he turned it on, i mean come on look whats in that van
I have 2 theories for why Doctor Strange couldn’t save Tony.
1. The time stone wouldn’t be able to undo his injuries. The snap has a really terrible affect on the user and it doesn’t appear to be undo able. Thanos was able to heal his chest wound but he still had the injuries from both snaps.
2. Healing tony would also undo the snap. Since his injuries came directly from the stones, healing him without affecting the stones seems impossible.
Your theories are wrong. The time stone easily can reverse death. the only death it couldnt reverse is the death of someone related to the soul stone. If you remember from the first movie, thanos using the gauntlet didnt injure his arm, only the gauntlet itself. The idea that the gauntlet hurts the user when they use all stones only came to be a thing in endgame. The second time he uses it in endgame its to destroy it so he cant heal himself afterwards. Healing tony would not undo the snap. They only need to use the reality stone not the whole gauntlet to heal tony or just the time stone so they can easily get him to a hospital. Its just bad writing.
Jude Ceant I was saying that it couldn’t undo damage caused by the stones, not just death itself. If you look back at the end of Infinity War, Thanos is injured. When he is watching the sunset, you can see his arm is burned. His chest wound was healed but his arm wasn’t. Why wouldn’t he heal that as well? They also didn’t undo Hulk’s arm when they had all of the stones. If the damage to Tony came from the snap, it could mean undoing it could undo what the stones have done.
@@irondolphin9387 ok i went back and rewatched and i see that his arm was injured but why is it his arm is only injured when he does the snap but not when he was using all the stones to fight thors axe? Also i just don't agree that just because the damage came from the stones means that it couldnt be healed and even more important is that the characters in the movie dont know the answer to that so they should have at least tried.
"if I yell you what happens, it won't happen"
Hence there are at least 2 futures were the rodent hits the button. But there's probably thousands. At least 2 confirmed via dialogue
Sadly people just can't enjoy movies without obsessing with certain details. Good for the Russo bros
yeah, a lot of the supposed plot holes were things that didn't really need to be explained. people just love to critique movies.
I'm an OG geek. Nit picking's kinda a prerequisite!...🙃
That said, sometimes you just gotta go where the ride takes you. I have a love-hate relationship w/CinemaSins as a result. Their commentary's on-point & hilarious. They obviously love movies as much as I do, because they obviously do repeat viewings of films to catch all the plot-holes, gaffs, & continuity flubs. But sometimes they make me feel guilty about liking a movie they skewer unmercifully. I just choose to ignore screw-ups if I enjoy the overall story & move on. If said movie, conversely, happens to suck badly or has one too many gaffs that are so bad they take me all the Hell way out, nup, sorry. I can forgive a lot, but when things get too blatent to emotionally reinvest myself in it, the movie sucks.
@Fididum Niwit what do you mean, their use of time travel made no sense? it's not as if we know what 'really happens' with time travel. And a plot hole isn't just some question you have that isn't answered, it's a piece that doesn't make sense. I had no trouble following the story. You really think it was 'horrible?' That's hard to justify.
@@scotcarr3390 Well said. I consider the MCU movies to be the ultimate popcorn movies, meant to entertain above all else. The basic premises are ludicrous. If you can believe a man injected with Windex & dosed with Vita Rays can grow 6'' and get super buff, then you can accept that Nat isn't coming back. And personally I'm a big fan of nit-picking! I'm just tired of people saying 'plot hole!' over things that aren't actually plot holes, just things not shown that they wonder about.
@@feanor411 I... was a little long-winded in my input. But, yeah, pretty much what you said...🙃
I may have missed it, but I'm curious as to what happened to Mijlnior? Cap took it back with him to the Past but I didn't see it when he showed up as an old man. Anybody got an answer on that one?
He gave it back to Thor I'd guess.
The part i didnt really understand was that The Avengers only have 1 try to get back to their own timeline, yet Thanos (the one that know about the plot) comes all of a sudden with a entire ship and Nebula. So what exactly did they use to follow them to the timeline?
Only Hank Pym on earth can isolate Pym particles. Thanos has more advanced technology and can isolate all the Pym particles that he wants. The particles are only named after Hank Pym because he discovered them on earth....not because no one in the entire Universe can figure out how to use them. Again EndGame is an intelligent film, which makes certain reasoning skills necessary to understand the film. Josh is an unintelligent film reviewer, so this is the wrong film for him. He is better off with something like John Wick... plot is - you kill my dog, and the rest is just fake dance/fight scenes. So there are no “plot holes”, where plot hole is defined as - things too hard for Josh to understand.
I don't have a problem with Strange and the time stone not being able to bring Tony back. I see it as the only one of the 14 M futures Strange visited had them winning with A)the mouse activating Scott's machine and B) Tony being the only one able to steal the stones out of Thanos' glove like that, since he designed both their gloves. Perhaps even if he could use the time stone to position himself near to Tony before the snap (as Thanos did resurrecting Vision), all the possible futures had Thanos retaking them before anyone else powerful enough to survive could get the glove on and take Tony's place. Maybe all the "rewind to save Tony" futures he saw had Thanos retake the glove and win.
In this you said it’s like all the people that were dusted were sleeping and woke up from a long nap when brought back but doesn’t that mean thanos and his followers aren’t really dead they are just in the same state the people that got snapped were in and doesn’t that mean it be possible to snap thanos back if someone gathered the stones again kinda wish they would of just physically kill thanos like Thor did in the opening
Spider man pretty much explained the dusted had no concept of the time they were out of commission, that’s not a mystery.
some of these supposed plot holes...sheesh...it's like they didn't even see the movie!
Bookie... 🤭🤣😂
Why Tony Stark had to die, and time stone couldn't fix: The energy killing him was the power of ALL the stones, which would not be undone by the power of ONE stone. Let's say the mind stone messed up his mind, the reality stone messed up him existing at all, the space stone scrambled his atoms, the powerstone made his cells turn purple and be destroyed, the time stone aged him, and the soul stone meant he could no longer inhabit his body. Then you use the time stone to de-age him, he would still be in irreparable shape.
Qc SoDa :Correct. The film’s in Universe logic is simple and elegant and reinforces ‘consequences’. The reason there is so much mentally-challenged carping about it is because super hero based films - indeed films in general - almost never have real consequences for heroes or protagonists. *Why Him?* equal -> How dare you actually have the hero die fighting for his cause without creating the usual bullshiite loophole and give him a way out. That’s what this is really all about. Iron Man had to snap to save the Universe, and it killed him. There’s no way out, after all the bullshiiting is over and done.
There are sounds of swords scraping against one another after the credits roll...Answer that!
That was the sound of Tony Stark making the Iron Man Mark I armour from the first Iron Man movie. It was meant as a way of bringing his story full circle.
You guys are crediting a lot to the Russo's that was the decisions of the screenplay writer's Markus and Mcfeely. The Russo's are incredible directors, but they didn't write the movie.
They often contradict what M&M say in interviews.
Two observations about the dusted returning. You already answered the conscienceless aspect but I want to know where they returned. If they were in their home, no problem. If they were on an airplane then it's a long way down without a parachute. Also how did everybody, newly returned dusted or not, get together and organize for the finale battle. That seemed vey fast.
Hulk willed everyone to return "safely". Meaning that people snapped away in planes and on cruise ships or in space were blimped back safe on land. And anyone else who was snapped away from safety were just put back where they were dusted.
#6, also because Robert Downey Jr's contract was up and he wasn't going to renew. Btw, He could still comeback, as an A.I. like he did in the comics.
Stupid to expect Falcon to wield that shield, he has no superpower to launch it with any purpose.
I'm more curious on how the sudden death if half the universe affected any Ghost Riders out there.
Even if only 1% were innocent enough to cause a Spirit of Vengeance to awaken, that's still 1% of half the universe. That's still a lot of people.
If Thanos snapped the host, the spirit likely would have just jumped to a new host. Unless, in the MCU, the Spirits themselves are not as resilient and powerful as depicted in the comics.
I also just want more Ghost Rider, tbh...
What I'm mad at is how they never explained that the bald chick whose the sister to the green chick, forgot her name, but the bald chicks past self was killed so how could she still exist in the present, like wtf they slipped that shit
Josh Bautista : You are too lazy to even keep track of the characters name. Your middle name should be *WTF* because you will likely go through your whole life confused.
Besides I heard Thor's appearance was a direct homage to a certain legendary movie character played by Jeff Bridges. Much like The Dude gave on life after his 60s radical heyday, and became a lazy slob Thor did the exact same thing after his defeat at the hands of Thanos. What do you expect from the guys behind "Community", but a cleverly placed reference to another movie.
good head cannon for #5
Falcon was not genetically engineered like Captain America so he can't be him.
Canonically, Falcon is Captain America for a period of time.
@@sarahkrzywicki1886 he's not trying to here that.
What about the earpieces? How did all the folks coming back from being snapped, like Falcon, all have the right earpieces to communicate with Captain America and have the correct frequency?
Mule+Near=Mewmew
Meowmeow
Just HOW did Scott Lang's van get off Hank Pym's building and into storage?
John K Now that’s a good question, considering they must have used Pym Particles to shrink the van to get it up there in the first place. I guess maybe Ghost or Bill Foster new of their mission, as they were after more quantum energy, and after the snap they located the van and put it in storage.
Paul Burton Casey was alive, and would have had the police track her daddy down to that location. After which they might have assumed that he like all the rest was snapped.
There not being a post credit scene makes sense in hindsight. They're focusing more on the shows right now and there's no way to coherently sum them all up in such a short amount of time.
Think of pronouncing Mjolnir like this
Me-yol-near
But say it fast, like Me-yol is one syllable
I like to think of it kinda sounding like "meow near" lol
More like Meal-Near but "Meal" has an "O" in it. So..Mea-ol-NEAR
professor hulk should be the new tech guy
also red skull is still red skull he talked about how he himself got ahold of one of the infinity stones when og ghamorah died
Chris Proves little. He also knows Natasha’s father’s name. The point is he is now a spirit or demon or ghost, essentially existing in a version of hell, he is not really a living man.