My interpretation that no one asked for. ✨ She’s in a psych ward with postpartum psychosis. Not married to the doctor at all. The room that was previously occupied by children that she hated is her body. The wallpaper she wants to rip off is her skin. She feels trapped in her own body. Rips her skin off to free her self/hallucinations, hence why the doctor passes out. 💅🏻
Yes, I thought she was mistaken about her location, probably in an asylum. However, it is weird that there are so few people. I wonder how long she was really in there.
@uhnisiuh this is EXACTLY what I was thinking! Very interesting to see someone else thought that too. Most other theories are interesting but don’t explain why John faints at the end..
Look, everyone interprets things differently but the Asian thing completely came out of nowhere. I think the fact that you briefly mentioned it with absolutely ZERO supporting evidence to back it up proves it’s a moot point. Don’t know why it’s in the video.
Maybe the color yellow refers to the skin color of Asians. The protagonist's hatred against the color yellow is mentioned several times throughout the parable : "The color is repellent, almost revolting, smouldering unclean yellow," "It is the strangest yellow, that wallpaper! It makes me think of yellow things I ever saw, not beautiful ones like buttercups, but old, foul bad yellow things."
@@summerlight2000 I agree that her passionate dislike for the COLOR is mentioned; the problem is that color being associated with Asian culture is something we as the readers can only infer because of history, not because of the book. There's nothing even remotely close in the TEXT to support that the protagonist was referring to Asians. It's just a blind assumption.
yes, they should have really elaborated on the point or cut it. it most definitely was not a conscious decision to have the yellow represent fear of Asian immigration but could be a subconscious choice that reflects the historical context in which Gilman wrote. of course it could also just be completely unrelated and the colour yellow could have been chosen for a different meaning or just chosen at random.
i would like everyone to know that while i was watching this video and the creepy music was playing that my closet door started opening on its own help me
@A1 The story has nothing to do with racism but still white man( not all but most southern american republican/conservatives) have xenophobic,islamophobic and misogynistic views.
Gilman was not fond of people of colour. Yes she was a feminist but only for white women like her. She was afraid of the "problems" people of colour might cause in society, even writing a book about it called "A Suggestion on the N**** Problem"(1908). The colour yellow is loaded with meaning. During the 19th century, yellow was often the colour that referred to any person of colour or any immigrant. Gilman might have picked the colour yellow to represent these people. How I see it she might have used the yellow wallpaper as a metaphor of wanting to protect women like her from these people of colour and therefore the woman tears the wallpaper away, trying to free the white women she later discribes as being a part of.
My friend recommended this short story to me, and I find it really interesting, but the main character reminds me a lot of my mom and her weird actions
I know, I feel like this is a bit of a stretch given that race and ethnicity isn't brought up even slightly. Although, there is a fear of the unknown and perhaps in a destorted way this could be interpreted as the mass fear of the unknown.
I agree, I strongly believe the narrator has post partum depression, and perhaps she suffers with other undiagnosed things, but PPD explains a lot of her behaviour and she definitely has it.
I agree that this analysis was quite bizarre and I dont really see how it links or has anything to do with the story; that was the only analysis I didn't agree with.
Thank you so much for this. I've been rereading the story; struggling to understand the meaning behind it. This analysis was presented super well and I feel so much more confident in my understanding of the story!
This was so useful, I was pretty lost by the meaning when initially reading. One issue, the wallpaper being about xenophobia made absolutely no sense though lol. Not mentioned or inferred at all anywhere in the text, felt like you could've just cut that part out.
apparently Gilman had a very racist view towards Asian people i think its a stretch but given her politics it isnt absurd to think she chose yellow as this abhorrent colour to reflect her racist views. Personally theres not much evidence for it though and it sounded ridiculous without context
Thanks you helped me with my assignment. Besides the Asian part, I summarized and analyzed the story correctly. I had to come for confirmation because in a way this story was driving me crazy how she kept complaining and was so focused on the wallpaper 🤣
This story makes me feel weird because I used or i still get obsessed with certain things I can't hesitate for example a pattern or a texture there was a pillow i hated it's form and especially texture it gives me goosebumps but I used always to stare and touch it a lot even though it makes me uncomfortable
I did wonder though, while I agree with the assessment that the treatment chosen didnt help, was it the actual treatment, or was it the advancement of the condition due to lack of correct treatment, making it worse? Also in the same sense, was it her obsession with the wallpaper the factor in her hallucinations or was it from sleep deprivation from the condition? Isnt it very possible she would have hallucinations regardless if she obsessed about anything?
I like your questioning, especially because the woman wrote. Even though the treatment wasn't helping, she was still able to write about her reality in privacy. So I guess you could say that the isolation wasn't being administered to the effect that her husband had hoped anyways, because she was still able to exercise thought. It's very likely that her condition got worse due to no treatment rather than improper treatment.
i can't imagine this being a plausible interpretation. if you were isolated in a house with nothing to do, with your family treating you essentially like a child, i am absolutely certain you'd go crazy too.
I think that it was both her lack of proper treatment as well as the treatment they did prescribe to her that amplified her condition. Without proper treatment it wasn’t going to get better, and with total isolation it was probably going to get worse. As for the wallpaper thing, I don’t think it’s what made her hallucinate it more was just the main outlet for her hallucinations. It’s very possible she could’ve hallucinated about something else, the wallpaper just so happens to have extreme thematic significance which is why it was chosen by the author.
Extremely helpful, wonderfully done, masterfully made, perfectly concise, amazingly straight to the point... I mean what can i say! THANK YOU SO MUCH 😍❤️👏🏻👍🏻👌🏻
I know this is late but you could probs write about the superego ego and id and about her basic desires of freedom and how she is rejecting her desire of motherhood
This story It makes me feel weird because I used or i still get obsessed with certain things I can't hesitate for example a pattern or a texture there was a pillow i hated it's form and especially patters it gives goosebumps but I used always to stare and touch it a lot even though it makes me uncomfortable
i was following along thinking this was very well made untill a reference to xenofobia was made? i read it twice before watching this and the reference of xenofobia towards asians is such a wild assumption that has 0 support in the text and just feels like something you added for some personal reason? Mentioning xenofobia as a result of the character disliking a specific colour is just out of this world in my personal opinion. That comment really has nothing to do in a summary unless its your personal ideology you try to push.
It's interesting that some parts that, I would say, have very obvious interpretations, are said as 'maybe it represents' and 'perhaps the author' but the totally out of nowhere conclusion about anti-Asian xenophobia is stated as a fact. Which for me is not supported by anything in the text or context
Symbolizes contemporary Xenophobia...fears of Asian immigration? No! lol I do not like this analysis at all ! I disagree with almost everything she is saying.
I'd argue you can have that take, especially if you understand the cultural significance of East Asian Americans in America throughout the 1850's and up. There are multiple symbolisms in this book, which means it can be taken up to multiple interpretations. Considering how this book was published in 1890, it wouldn't be far fetched to have a xenophobic outlook on the yellow wallpaper itself. The Chinese Exclusion Act was passed almost a decade earlier, as well as the Scott Act being passed two years before the release of the story. Since East Asian hate was on the rise due to Americans being paranoid over them "taking their jobs", it wouldn't be surprising to have this take on The Yellow Wallpaper. The whole "East Asians are yellow" thing was expanded on and basically popularized by Johann Friedrich Blumenbach, who, if you know anything about what the man was spewing, grouped all East Asians and some Central Asians under the label "Mongolian Race", and implicating the name "Mongols", which striked troubling and threatening connotations for Europeans (and Americans as I'm sure they had some knowledge of European history through whatever means they had) with their memories of Attila the Hun, Genghis Khan, and Timur. The yellow label came associated with discrimination, exclusion, and violence. Again, symbols are always up to interpretation. It's an interesting interpretation, yes, but not completely far fetched to think that it could signify xenophobia. Plus I don't think that it's that hard to assume that the narrator is a white woman, considering I highly doubt that a successful white man in that day and age wouldn't have a distaste for marrying a different race.
okay, I might just be blowing smoke, but oddly colored wallpaper in the late 18th century can be related to the fact that wallpapers in that day had violent chemicals, which mightve exacerbated her friggin delirium?
the husband going into the room with all that wallpaper off couldve been caused by a massive amount of toxins in the room, i mean she talks constanty about fungus and how the walls reacted to the moist conditions, she couldve been living in a friggin cesspool and being confined to the room only destroyed her senses
God, we’re not even far from all this nonsensical and backwards thinking and prescription for good health. My father passed recently and I believe his COVID confinement and manual restraints after he removed his feeding tubes 3x are what hastened his death over the cancer and COVID he battled. Family was not allowed in to see him and he rapidly deteriorated in his final days. Hospitals are still getting it wrong. Fresh air, family and friends, options, and respecting the patient’s wishes are what preserves or maintains health - not the opposite!!!
Ayo? I agree with many of the points you cover, but where did you pull the Asian immigration thing out of??? Not once in this story does it even almost talk about Asian culture or immigration, and Gilman’s real life has very little to do with that either. You lost me for a second there, I would love to see an explanation for that lol.
I read and analyzed The Yellow Wallpaper while in high school, again in college and later on my own. NEVER has anything about Asians or any race been included in any analysis I’ve heard. I TOTALLY disagree with this part of your analysis. Highly disappointing!
My interpretation that no one asked for. ✨ She’s in a psych ward with postpartum psychosis. Not married to the doctor at all. The room that was previously occupied by children that she hated is her body. The wallpaper she wants to rip off is her skin. She feels trapped in her own body. Rips her skin off to free her self/hallucinations, hence why the doctor passes out. 💅🏻
Your version makes so much more sense.....but I thought she comited su1cid3..and thats why he passes out...What do you think?
Yes, I thought she was mistaken about her location, probably in an asylum. However, it is weird that there are so few people. I wonder how long she was really in there.
@uhnisiuh this is EXACTLY what I was thinking! Very interesting to see someone else thought that too. Most other theories are interesting but don’t explain why John faints at the end..
This has to be my favorite interpretation yet 👌🏼
very smart but near the start she asks john to remove the yellow wallpaper and he said no so there definitly is yellow wallpaper
Look, everyone interprets things differently but the Asian thing completely came out of nowhere. I think the fact that you briefly mentioned it with absolutely ZERO supporting evidence to back it up proves it’s a moot point. Don’t know why it’s in the video.
that part killed me
its like something a middle schooler would say when called on in class after skipping the reading
Maybe the color yellow refers to the skin color of Asians. The protagonist's hatred against the color yellow is mentioned several times throughout the parable : "The color is repellent, almost revolting, smouldering unclean yellow," "It is the strangest yellow, that wallpaper! It makes me think of yellow things I ever saw, not beautiful ones like buttercups, but old, foul bad yellow things."
@@summerlight2000 I agree that her passionate dislike for the COLOR is mentioned; the problem is that color being associated with Asian culture is something we as the readers can only infer because of history, not because of the book. There's nothing even remotely close in the TEXT to support that the protagonist was referring to Asians. It's just a blind assumption.
@@gldflcn agreed. I thought that claim was weirdly placed
yes, they should have really elaborated on the point or cut it. it most definitely was not a conscious decision to have the yellow represent fear of Asian immigration but could be a subconscious choice that reflects the historical context in which Gilman wrote. of course it could also just be completely unrelated and the colour yellow could have been chosen for a different meaning or just chosen at random.
" What kind of mental health can we expect from such kind of cultural traditions " in the end was awesome.
This is very professionally and masterfully done!!
This is excellent. You made it very clear and concise, but provided depth and detail with insightful analysis, too. Thank you.
i would like everyone to know that while i was watching this video and the creepy music was playing that my closet door started opening on its own help me
Oh, you're dead....
Good luck.
Sit up and close it
@@ifora7780 bRUH that’s how you get yourself KIlled! 😭
yo its been a year are u good
Lol I finally understand wtf is going on
what he said
Same
Right! As I was reading this, I was like, "what the heck is going on?" Lol!
FR LMAO
This video was incredibly helpful. Thank-you so much!!! Doing an essay on this for my Lit class and this really helped me gather my thoughts!!!
@A1 The story has nothing to do with racism but still white man( not all but most southern american republican/conservatives) have xenophobic,islamophobic and misogynistic views.
A1 Exactly that was so Out of pocket and unnecessary
I don't understand the xenophobia part however, this is greatly done!!
I was confused as well. Maybe yellow wallpaper, yellowman.
Gilman was not fond of people of colour. Yes she was a feminist but only for white women like her. She was afraid of the "problems" people of colour might cause in society, even writing a book about it called "A Suggestion on the N**** Problem"(1908). The colour yellow is loaded with meaning. During the 19th century, yellow was often the colour that referred to any person of colour or any immigrant. Gilman might have picked the colour yellow to represent these people. How I see it she might have used the yellow wallpaper as a metaphor of wanting to protect women like her from these people of colour and therefore the woman tears the wallpaper away, trying to free the white women she later discribes as being a part of.
This is wonderful! I have read this short story before for a separate class ,but now I’m about to take a quiz for my American literature class
My friend recommended this short story to me, and I find it really interesting, but the main character reminds me a lot of my mom and her weird actions
Last part got me like Asian immigration? Where that shi come from?????
I know, I feel like this is a bit of a stretch given that race and ethnicity isn't brought up even slightly. Although, there is a fear of the unknown and perhaps in a destorted way this could be interpreted as the mass fear of the unknown.
I’m surprised post- partum depression isn’t specifically mentioned.
I agree, I strongly believe the narrator has post partum depression, and perhaps she suffers with other undiagnosed things, but PPD explains a lot of her behaviour and she definitely has it.
I don't get what the wallpaper has to do with xenophobia of Asians; does anyone agree with that part of this analysis?
Yeah
I agree that this analysis was quite bizarre and I dont really see how it links or has anything to do with the story; that was the only analysis I didn't agree with.
@@vanyapetrova3493 her comment about xenophobia says more about her than it does the story.
A green and yellowish color together can cause anyone a kind of deterioration in condition and John tells us he is a doctor 😂😂.
Locking his wife in
Thank you so much for this. I've been rereading the story; struggling to understand the meaning behind it. This analysis was presented super well and I feel so much more confident in my understanding of the story!
This was so useful, I was pretty lost by the meaning when initially reading. One issue, the wallpaper being about xenophobia made absolutely no sense though lol. Not mentioned or inferred at all anywhere in the text, felt like you could've just cut that part out.
exactly dude like what even was that?
apparently Gilman had a very racist view towards Asian people i think its a stretch but given her politics it isnt absurd to think she chose yellow as this abhorrent colour to reflect her racist views. Personally theres not much evidence for it though and it sounded ridiculous without context
Thank you so much for this explanation I was able to answer the questions with ease
This story is explained in the best possible way
Thanks you helped me with my assignment. Besides the Asian part, I summarized and analyzed the story correctly. I had to come for confirmation because in a way this story was driving me crazy how she kept complaining and was so focused on the wallpaper 🤣
thanks, this was very helpful.
The had a marked influence on my adolescence. Amazing short story.
I read this short story about a month ago and I loved it.
this is so well done! thank you.
Explanation was done very well.. everything was clear.. thanks a lot for your efforts 👌
this video helped me understand the story much better and is very well constructed. thank you!!
Just one word "Outstanding"
great analysis and summary, thank you!
I don't know about the Asian part.
This story makes me feel weird because I used or i still get obsessed with certain things I can't hesitate for example a pattern or a texture there was a pillow i hated it's form and especially texture it gives me goosebumps but I used always to stare and touch it a lot even though it makes me uncomfortable
Wow the way of of teaching is soo graceoois ,i understand the whole story in 1 shot thanks nam🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰
I did wonder though, while I agree with the assessment that the treatment chosen didnt help, was it the actual treatment, or was it the advancement of the condition due to lack of correct treatment, making it worse? Also in the same sense, was it her obsession with the wallpaper the factor in her hallucinations or was it from sleep deprivation from the condition? Isnt it very possible she would have hallucinations regardless if she obsessed about anything?
I like your questioning, especially because the woman wrote. Even though the treatment wasn't helping, she was still able to write about her reality in privacy. So I guess you could say that the isolation wasn't being administered to the effect that her husband had hoped anyways, because she was still able to exercise thought. It's very likely that her condition got worse due to no treatment rather than improper treatment.
i can't imagine this being a plausible interpretation. if you were isolated in a house with nothing to do, with your family treating you essentially like a child, i am absolutely certain you'd go crazy too.
I think that it was both her lack of proper treatment as well as the treatment they did prescribe to her that amplified her condition. Without proper treatment it wasn’t going to get better, and with total isolation it was probably going to get worse. As for the wallpaper thing, I don’t think it’s what made her hallucinate it more was just the main outlet for her hallucinations. It’s very possible she could’ve hallucinated about something else, the wallpaper just so happens to have extreme thematic significance which is why it was chosen by the author.
Extremely helpful, wonderfully done, masterfully made, perfectly concise, amazingly straight to the point... I mean what can i say! THANK YOU SO MUCH 😍❤️👏🏻👍🏻👌🏻
this story will be in my exam paper .the question will be analyze this story with the theorie of Freud (psychoanalysis ) any help please ?
I know this is late but you could probs write about the superego ego and id and about her basic desires of freedom and how she is rejecting her desire of motherhood
a reliable and helpful video! thank you
5:52 Help?
thanks, it really helps me passed my class quiz
Asian stuff came out of nowhere. Really unsupported in the source material.
This was indeed helpful
Thank u
Wow very interesting & very well explained thanks so much.
This story It makes me feel weird because I used or i still get obsessed with certain things I can't hesitate for example a pattern or a texture there was a pillow i hated it's form and especially patters it gives goosebumps but I used always to stare and touch it a lot even though it makes me uncomfortable
Amazing! Perfectly explained. Thanks(:
i was following along thinking this was very well made untill a reference to xenofobia was made? i read it twice before watching this and the reference of xenofobia towards asians is such a wild assumption that has 0 support in the text and just feels like something you added for some personal reason? Mentioning xenofobia as a result of the character disliking a specific colour is just out of this world in my personal opinion. That comment really has nothing to do in a summary unless its your personal ideology you try to push.
i know right 😂literally came out of nowhere and has nothing to back it
Thank you for your great analysis
Excellent explained
Brilliant work 👍👍👍👍
Lewy body dementia symptoms, usually seen in the elderly folk.
It's interesting that some parts that, I would say, have very obvious interpretations, are said as 'maybe it represents' and 'perhaps the author' but the totally out of nowhere conclusion about anti-Asian xenophobia is stated as a fact. Which for me is not supported by anything in the text or context
Very well put out !
2:50 5:05 6:45 8:44
Symbolizes contemporary Xenophobia...fears of Asian immigration? No! lol I do not like this analysis at all ! I disagree with almost everything she is saying.
I'd argue you can have that take, especially if you understand the cultural significance of East Asian Americans in America throughout the 1850's and up. There are multiple symbolisms in this book, which means it can be taken up to multiple interpretations. Considering how this book was published in 1890, it wouldn't be far fetched to have a xenophobic outlook on the yellow wallpaper itself. The Chinese Exclusion Act was passed almost a decade earlier, as well as the Scott Act being passed two years before the release of the story. Since East Asian hate was on the rise due to Americans being paranoid over them "taking their jobs", it wouldn't be surprising to have this take on The Yellow Wallpaper. The whole "East Asians are yellow" thing was expanded on and basically popularized by Johann Friedrich Blumenbach, who, if you know anything about what the man was spewing, grouped all East Asians and some Central Asians under the label "Mongolian Race", and implicating the name "Mongols", which striked troubling and threatening connotations for Europeans (and Americans as I'm sure they had some knowledge of European history through whatever means they had) with their memories of Attila the Hun, Genghis Khan, and Timur. The yellow label came associated with discrimination, exclusion, and violence. Again, symbols are always up to interpretation. It's an interesting interpretation, yes, but not completely far fetched to think that it could signify xenophobia. Plus I don't think that it's that hard to assume that the narrator is a white woman, considering I highly doubt that a successful white man in that day and age wouldn't have a distaste for marrying a different race.
@@cowabunga2497 okay melvin we know.
still zero textual evidence for that mouth-breathing take though
Very excellent very helpful to us
okay, I might just be blowing smoke, but oddly colored wallpaper in the late 18th century can be related to the fact that wallpapers in that day had violent chemicals, which mightve exacerbated her friggin delirium?
the husband going into the room with all that wallpaper off couldve been caused by a massive amount of toxins in the room, i mean she talks constanty about fungus and how the walls reacted to the moist conditions, she couldve been living in a friggin cesspool and being confined to the room only destroyed her senses
very good well put together video! I aspire to be like you someday 🎃🎃
Helped me with my homework 🤣🥰
What an amazing explanation 👌👏
Really very helpful all things like theme symbol etc are mentioned in this video... But it also should be in urdu n Hindi
i will make this video in hindi go and subscribe to my channel windowsolver
That was amazing thank you .
Impressive! Thanks! God bless you!
Wow. This is excellent❤️
This was great
This is good content
Kane pixel is a genius
Really informative
Thank u☺☺☺☺☺☺
Where the hell did you get the anti-asian xenophobia?
God, we’re not even far from all this nonsensical and backwards thinking and prescription for good health. My father passed recently and I believe his COVID confinement and manual restraints after he removed his feeding tubes 3x are what hastened his death over the cancer and COVID he battled. Family was not allowed in to see him and he rapidly deteriorated in his final days. Hospitals are still getting it wrong. Fresh air, family and friends, options, and respecting the patient’s wishes are what preserves or maintains health - not the opposite!!!
Ayo? I agree with many of the points you cover, but where did you pull the Asian immigration thing out of??? Not once in this story does it even almost talk about Asian culture or immigration, and Gilman’s real life has very little to do with that either. You lost me for a second there, I would love to see an explanation for that lol.
I can’t believe this predicted the backroom meme.
I read and analyzed The Yellow Wallpaper while in high school, again in college and later on my own. NEVER has anything about Asians or any race been included in any analysis I’ve heard. I TOTALLY disagree with this part of your analysis. Highly disappointing!
Hi, did the narrator die or not? I am confused
the xenophobia part sounds very strange and odd to me. I don't get it.
THANK U
I like this analysis but I agree the Asian thing came out of nowhere. At least give more depth on why you think that. It would go along way.
Precise 👍
thx
better than sparknotes
BEST EDUCATIONAL VIDEO I'VE EVER SEEN
That was amazing
Who else had to watch this after CGP Grey's narration?
Central irony .. can anyone tell?
Doctors treatment made her crazy instead of helping.
منو إب أتكامل؟
this music tho
I'm a guy, and even I want to read this book now.
Check it out, it's not very long, and very good!
Yo u look very familiar with John Cena
woman and moonlight 😭😭
Tell John to un-faint himself, open his eyes and look at what he did!
Bros in the backrooms 😆🤣😆
xenophobia 😭😭
Very creepy
backrooms
Backrooms
im sorry what asian immigration?????
Where did asian people come from 😭😭😭
I just use google EPIC
me af
ASIAN IMMIGRATION?
i think the narrator has schizophrenia
You had me until "19th century expressive patriarchy"
Shame, shame.
Stop falling for the feminist lies and acknowledge women history.
The story was written by a feminist.