What Is The Best Extra Combat Spell?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 12 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 64

  • @Dalenthas
    @Dalenthas 3 роки тому +4

    Looks like you missed Port Razer, which also goes infinite with Rionya if you can get through with a 4/4.

  • @jacobjensen7704
    @jacobjensen7704 3 роки тому +3

    When I was making my aggressive blue EDH decks because I wanted to play coastal piracy effects, I started adding in extra turn spells into those decks. Why? Because extra turns means extra combats! :D
    As the people as my LGS said, "Why do you play Boros in every color??"

  • @fniggl3
    @fniggl3 3 роки тому

    Fury of the Horde is a great fit in Greven voltron. With Greven's ability to dig abysmally deep with his combat-sacrifice trigger, finding a Fury of the top usually means that the player you are attacking dies or, if that player is now dead, you take out another one friend.

  • @hungryguitarstudent
    @hungryguitarstudent 2 роки тому

    Nice breakdown! As a new edh player, I appreciate that you explain your reasoning very well. Thanks :)

    • @CommanderReplay
      @CommanderReplay  2 роки тому

      Glad you liked it! What kind of guitar are you into btw?

  • @riverketcherside1256
    @riverketcherside1256 3 роки тому +2

    Breath of Fury + locust god + any costal piracy effect is a hell of a combo

  • @brian5510
    @brian5510 3 роки тому

    Love your content, everything pertaining to BOROS
    I only play botos, so am a big fan of yours!
    Can’t wait to see your aurelia/combo video!!
    Keep it up bro!!

    • @CommanderReplay
      @CommanderReplay  3 роки тому +1

      Thanks man! It is out currently, you can find it here! enjoy :) ua-cam.com/video/wG5ItVjry8U/v-deo.html

  • @TheJustinist
    @TheJustinist 3 роки тому

    6:02 - Don't forget my Locust God deck

  • @newtpondskipper
    @newtpondskipper 3 роки тому +2

    Love a few of these with Feather.

    • @TheeKMS
      @TheeKMS 3 роки тому

      Especially Seize the Day because it targets so Feather gets it back to your hand. Even better if Feather Voltron is the deck idea

  • @faultier1158
    @faultier1158 3 роки тому

    Wyleth has a decent synergy with "exile cards from your hand to cast this spell for free" cards, like Fury of the Horde. You just draw a billion cards each time you attack. But he's the type of commander who just gets shot the moment he hits the board, often by random stuff. You can try to protect him, but that makes you slower, and you *need* the card draw to even hit your land drops. My Akiri deck feels way more resilient.

  • @salsathe4th
    @salsathe4th 3 роки тому +1

    Best deck with moraug is Klauth. Attack with creatures and make 20 mana main phase two cast genesis wave for 17 hitting 6 lands and a moraug for 6 extra combat steps....maybe more with fetch lands. I play Moraug in all my red decks. Card is insanely undervalue right now for a mythic.

  • @Thespqr1997
    @Thespqr1997 3 роки тому +2

    savage beating has a infinite combo: the other part is an equipment named spellbinder

  • @jonathanhearn9359
    @jonathanhearn9359 3 роки тому +1

    Pj, you missed Port Razer lol love your channel

  • @alsaker13
    @alsaker13 3 роки тому +1

    I am so happy I pack pulled an invocation aggregated assault

  • @ClassicMagicMan
    @ClassicMagicMan 3 роки тому

    Temporal Mages: "Allow me to reintroduce myself."

  • @facelessgames94
    @facelessgames94 3 роки тому +1

    Considering white is seen splashrd in some of these extra combat spell, why have we not yet seen a white extra combat spell? Or a white fight spell? Kinda seems like a very white thing to do

  • @houdini8894
    @houdini8894 3 роки тому +1

    Seize the day is absurd in Xenagos.

  • @chrismarlow9585
    @chrismarlow9585 3 роки тому

    White enchantment, 3WWW: at the beginning of your first post combat main phase, if you gained life this turn, untap all creatures that attacked this turn and there is an additional combat...
    Sounds white enough to me. Could make it X+ life needed or tweak other things to make it 5 mana if they want to aggressively cost it.

    • @jacobjensen7704
      @jacobjensen7704 3 роки тому

      Yuck, please don't tie it to life gain haha. I'm sick of every white card needing to be life gain haha.

    • @chrismarlow9585
      @chrismarlow9585 3 роки тому

      @@jacobjensen7704 Haha very true, but it needs one white theme to make it white and lifegain + enchantment based was just what I picked. Could easily be tied to an equipment like said in the video or something else.

  • @chimneyimp1486
    @chimneyimp1486 3 роки тому

    throat wolf looks like a fun card to me. probably gonna buy it soon if my playgroup accepts playtest cards.
    throat wolf was a super old hoax card which was rumored since 1994. that's why its wording is so bad.
    the gatherer says: "Throat Wolf’s last ability reads like it’s pointless. Only Throat Wolf can attack, but it can’t attack, so nothing can attack. Rather than assume the text is pointless, this ability should be played as though it read “After each opponent’s first combat phase on each turn, you have a combat phase. Only Throat Wolf can attack during that combat phase.” "
    personally i really like response / resurgence. not because i think it is better than the other cards but more because i picked up a few of them and actually play them 😁

  • @dangerfield6855
    @dangerfield6855 3 роки тому +2

    Lightning runner, combat celebrant, pirate guy, those guys in Brudiclad are my favorite. Doesnt need to go infinite but getting the extra damage + triggers for Brud.
    Edit did i miss or did you forget the pirate guy?

    • @CommanderReplay
      @CommanderReplay  3 роки тому +1

      Yeah I can see that being pretty good there. Somehow I missed the pirate guy, I wonder if he has different wording that I didnt catch in the gatherer search.

  • @mn6334
    @mn6334 3 роки тому

    I have Lightning Runner in my Brudiclad deck because I feel like Combat Celebrant is a little too easy in that deck. Runner takes some setup to actually go infinite.

  • @edhtakes3604
    @edhtakes3604 3 роки тому

    The only flaw I can find with Aurelia is that she’s too good that people on the up and up will try to prevent me from attacking with her. Best extra combat spell

    • @CommanderReplay
      @CommanderReplay  3 роки тому +1

      Lol yeah that does happen. I find myself running more and more protection spells because of that these days. If she sticks, shes gonna do things.

  • @d9_1056
    @d9_1056 3 роки тому

    My favorite kind of extra combat is extra turns. Ugins nexus does the job just fine.

  • @AviarkXIII
    @AviarkXIII 3 роки тому

    Port Razer? Another one thats really good in Riona, and can get you multiple combats in a single turn if you play it right.

    • @riverketcherside1256
      @riverketcherside1256 3 роки тому

      Port Razer is my combo in Rionya. She absolutely destroys the opposition. Especially if you can get 3+ copies

    • @CommanderReplay
      @CommanderReplay  3 роки тому +2

      Somehow I missed port razor. It must have different wording that didn’t get picked up by my gatherer search. I’d give a B tier tho. Solid, but it’s not waves of aggression.

  • @yamael14
    @yamael14 3 роки тому

    Interesting video. I play Aurelia but I'm not really into extra combats besides that, I'm more of a 'doublestriker'. Like I said, Aurelia + Gisela + True conviction is one of the coolest wincons I play.

    • @CommanderReplay
      @CommanderReplay  3 роки тому +1

      Yeah that is a super sweet win con...ive done it a few times. If Aurelia is in your command zone, you dont always need additional extra combats in the deck she covers it for you. In non Aurelia decks I generally like to have at least 2, but 3 if im being real aggressive.

  • @mrcllmanni85
    @mrcllmanni85 3 роки тому

    really nice video!!! Could you make a tier list for boros deck or commander?

    • @CommanderReplay
      @CommanderReplay  3 роки тому +4

      Very soon. Ive got 8 decks left to play... I want to play them all first.

    • @tee918
      @tee918 3 роки тому

      @@CommanderReplay can't wait

  • @Dalenthas
    @Dalenthas 3 роки тому

    Rewriting the Comp Rules to make Triple Strike work: fairly easy.
    Rewriting MTGO and Arena to make Triple Strike work: probably a huge headache that breaks lots of things.

    • @CommanderReplay
      @CommanderReplay  3 роки тому

      Lol yeah those are probably good points. Although it just seems like you add another damage step. I maintain that it really doesnt seem that hard.

    • @Dalenthas
      @Dalenthas 3 роки тому

      @@CommanderReplay spoken like someone who's never had to modify ancient software. Arena is probably relatively easy to update, but MTGO? It's possible there's nobody left at the company that knows how the combat damage step was programmed to begin with 😅.

    • @jacobjensen7704
      @jacobjensen7704 3 роки тому

      Still probably easier than Mutate :P

  • @mcpeidorreiro
    @mcpeidorreiro 3 роки тому

    Savage beating goes infinite with spellbinder

  • @Kryptnyt
    @Kryptnyt 3 роки тому

    Time Stretch is pretty good!

  • @trevorwilliams5144
    @trevorwilliams5144 3 роки тому

    Savage Beating is at it's best in Xenagos.

  • @yamael14
    @yamael14 3 роки тому

    When you say 'Seize the day' can be good in certain decks, what voltron deck would that be?

    • @mn6334
      @mn6334 3 роки тому +1

      I have one in my "Untap Krenko as much a possible" deck. It's mostly full of Treachery/Act of Treason type cards but Seize can also be nice, particularly assuming I can give the tokens haste.

    • @CommanderReplay
      @CommanderReplay  3 роки тому +1

      I mean anything where the plan is 1 big creature: Aurelia, Bruenor, Syr Gwyn, basically any of the boros voltron commanders, I would guess Neheb, and probably numerous others.

    • @newtpondskipper
      @newtpondskipper 3 роки тому +2

      @@CommanderReplay Feather. The answer is always Feather.

  • @alexhouse4234
    @alexhouse4234 3 роки тому

    Bear Umbra works well with aggravated assault because gruul

    • @CommanderReplay
      @CommanderReplay  3 роки тому

      Yes it does. I didnt mention that one, also Nature's...something or other from Kamigawa also combos with those as well.

    • @politikh
      @politikh 3 роки тому +1

      @@CommanderReplay Nature's Will. ❤ Auto-include in my token/go wide Hapatra

  • @alexhouse4234
    @alexhouse4234 3 роки тому

    Savage beating!!

    • @CommanderReplay
      @CommanderReplay  3 роки тому

      Is very good, and apparently now very expensive!

    • @mn6334
      @mn6334 3 роки тому

      @@CommanderReplay I apparently didn't realize Aggravated Assault had gotten as expensive as it is. I'm pretty sure I picked one up for like $6 a couple years ago and I was thinking it was still around $10-$20 at most...

  • @TheJustinist
    @TheJustinist 3 роки тому +1

    "fun little video": 40mins long. Sounds about right :P

    • @CommanderReplay
      @CommanderReplay  3 роки тому +2

      I was trying so hard to keep it to 20. The filming session was 90 minutes long. Getting to 40 wasnt awful.

  • @bigblue2075
    @bigblue2075 3 роки тому

    You don't need extra combats if you just one hit everyone :P

    • @CommanderReplay
      @CommanderReplay  3 роки тому +1

      Sure you do, then you can one hit multiple someones in a turn.

  • @jasoncoe944
    @jasoncoe944 3 роки тому

    WOTC IF UR WATCHING PLZ PRINT MONO WHITE EXTRA COMBAT SPELLS

  • @celeste9958
    @celeste9958 7 місяців тому

    Karlach?

    • @CommanderReplay
      @CommanderReplay  7 місяців тому

      This video is older than Karlach. Karlach is great though, definitely a top pick for me.

  • @celeste9958
    @celeste9958 7 місяців тому

    😁

  • @d9_1056
    @d9_1056 3 роки тому

    I like your content, but your level of edh is completely different than what my playgroup plays. You aren't quite cedh, but highly optimized. So this list doesn't really pertain to me lol. Combo's/tutor targets/sword of ff etc. I do appreciate you listing all of them though.

    • @CommanderReplay
      @CommanderReplay  3 роки тому +1

      The irony here is that Ive mostly been getting crushed by people faster than me lately. Although I havent really been playing my stronger decks. But yes your setting really dictates everything. A few people have mentioned that Savage Beating Combos with Spellbinder which is cool but in like 80% of EDH thats just gonna be too slow and fragile to really make work. Setting is everything.