It's 2019 and I did not watch any of the talent shows back then but from me watching the show's season here on youtube in 2019 , Elliot should have won for sure , I can not believe he didn't ?
Tbh I thought this was a cruel way to have Elliott leave the show, this is right before the finale and they just show his name when they say who got the least amount of votes. Normally Ryan would send one person to the finale and then announce the next person in the finale which would lead to the third person leaving
sboudreaux27 but Taylor picked the group he thought was safe when the thing you should do is not pick either group like David Archuleta & Melinda Doolittle did. And Taylor just cheered for joy when he won & that just screamed arrogance. Chris should’ve won and him & Katharine should’ve been the top 2
Actually in the first 4 seasons before that he would just announce the eliminated person without addressing either of the other two first. He didn’t start announcing the top 2 one at a time until season 6,
i wish Elliott and one of the two would have won =( But, given that night, considering overall Taylor had three strong performances, and Kat had SOTR, he was a goner
I still think Chris & Katharine should’ve been the top 2 with Chris winning but after Chris left I was hoping that Elliott would be in the finale with Katherine with her winning. Taylor shouldn’t have won
@@Snide01 taylor shined for his stage presence and energy. People liked his connection with the audience and his personality, but in terms of voice it was elliot or Katherine.
First season I watched, I actually got on board with Kellie early and stuck with her. Loved Chris. But Elliott was clearly robbed. Kat was often shrill, and Taylor was a fucking clown. But the best rarely wins Idol.
Never forgot that night when the best singer Elliott Yamin was eliminated ! it broke my heart !
LOVE! LOVE! LOVED! HIS VOICE!!! His record 'Wait For You' is one of my favorites.
Love those three but Yamin is my fave 😍😘
most shocking decision i have witnessed on a tv talent show!!! even now i still feel the same,this guy was robbed!
Elliot you are talented man .
You got a wonderful gift from God .
I was crying back then watching this... I was rooting for him.... ❤️ ❤️ ❤️ ❤️
“This is not I’m sorry, this is congratulations.” Well said by Ryan, and I very much agree!
The saddest elimination of AI for me
From what I heard the best was Elliott, no question.
in my opinion yamin and daughtry should have been the final 2.
Bless Paula Abdul , she was crying when Elliott was eliminated , she is just such a *softy* and I adore her .
ELLIOTT'S MOM!!! :'(
Eilliott was the one I enjoyed the most
It's 2019 and I did not watch any of the talent shows back then but from me watching the show's season here on youtube in 2019 , Elliot should have won for sure , I can not believe he didn't ?
Hicks winning was the day I stopped following the show.
Even more surprising, he was never in the bottom 3.
Tbh I thought this was a cruel way to have Elliott leave the show, this is right before the finale and they just show his name when they say who got the least amount of votes. Normally Ryan would send one person to the finale and then announce the next person in the finale which would lead to the third person leaving
sboudreaux27 but Taylor picked the group he thought was safe when the thing you should do is not pick either group like David Archuleta & Melinda Doolittle did. And Taylor just cheered for joy when he won & that just screamed arrogance. Chris should’ve won and him & Katharine should’ve been the top 2
Actually in the first 4 seasons before that he would just announce the eliminated person without addressing either of the other two first. He didn’t start announcing the top 2 one at a time until season 6,
I don’t care who wins! Elliot yam in is the Real Winner! From a JAZZ EXPERT!,
Thank u for finding his elimanation
no problem
Taylor is great but shouldn't have won, should have gone here
i wish Elliott and one of the two would have won =( But, given that night, considering overall Taylor had three strong performances, and Kat had SOTR, he was a goner
oh, and i didnt like Kat in general, but WTF at the judges' comments? i loved her third song tbh
I still think Chris & Katharine should’ve been the top 2 with Chris winning but after Chris left I was hoping that Elliott would be in the finale with Katherine with her winning. Taylor shouldn’t have won
Taylor was different and just out shined the rest no matter what you think about him as an artist
@@Snide01 taylor shined for his stage presence and energy. People liked his connection with the audience and his personality, but in terms of voice it was elliot or Katherine.
Elliott and Chris should've been top 2
Gay. Soul patrol!!
@@samsmith8415 ?
@@ClassicallyChristion Taylor hicks rightfully won.
@@ClassicallyChristion he's such a stud
@@samsmith8415 Oh ok lol. I don't mind Taylor he's cool but Elliot and Daughtry are two of my all time favorites
5:15 Ouch!!! 🐝🐝🐝🐝🐝🐝🐝
If you can, could post the season 4 top 16 eliminations?
He got eliminated but I only know of him. The other two I haven't heard of them.
Taylor kind of reminds me of Chandler Bing 🤭
Elliott was in a hurry singing his songs, if he slowed down a bit, he would have sounded like a professional.
5:15
*RYDER: OHHHHHHH!!!*
crazy percentage!
It was made up
I'm trying to find a Christmas song that Elliott has. Anyone aware of the song? Please help?
너무 정확하게 불러서,오히려 3등이 된 사람..
Thank you for reliving my trauma….
First season I watched, I actually got on board with Kellie early and stuck with her. Loved Chris. But Elliott was clearly robbed. Kat was often shrill, and Taylor was a fucking clown. But the best rarely wins Idol.
What songs did Taylor Hicks do?
Dancing in the dark, you're so beautiful, & try a little tenderness
I still dont understand why kat got this far! Top 2 should have been elliott and chris.
hattiehedgehog She’s one of the best singers of that season.
I agree
Song title?
He is a way better vocal talent than Katherine and Taylor
GOANIMATE IDOL SEASON 4 - TOP 3 (06/11/08)
Even if Elliot goes to Final, she can never beat Taylor and Kat...
Only Kat or Daughtry can fight Taylor
will never forget how the three best singers of the season (daughtry, elliott, and katharine) were all eliminated in a row (4th, 3rd, 2nd).
Katharine not that good come on now