Few things which we can learn from this session: 1) first Attempt should be best prepared attempt 2)try to crack within 3 attempts (still we can do better with job cause of age as well as career installation is also important) 3) you are the best interviewer of yourself 4) self assessment is the key to success 5)basic english but grammatically correct english is required Views can be different but we should be continue with what we actually want.
He is not discouraging people to not take UPSC , but is inspring in a vibrant manner that if you have that passion in your heart to crack this exam , then just do it 2-3 attempts .. He is giving a big msg that the number of attempts and greater age limits , reduces the number of bright students in other important area of life . From 9 lakh people other than top 1 lakh , 8 lakh can give much better performance in other areas. As our nation not only needs best bueraucrates , but best teacher , best engineer, best of every job . Although your opinion on marks is not very welcome , as any person with less marks , can also crack this exam , And u should not forget , loopholes in our education system . Else it was hard reality outlined .. Thnq sir
He is saying right things but he is not respecting the people emotion of earning more money believe me if one day God come and said only salary no extra money any duffer will go upsc and will pass through such a hard selection process
Very practicle idea sir u shared with the govt that, who is qualifying Mains and rejected in Interview, let absorb in another services like banking. At the same time sir u bear the courage that u have proposed this to govt. and govt rejected it. Salute sir.
Not every achiever achieve in upsc My brother got AIR 178 in IIT-JEE exam and studied Electrical engineering from IIT Bombay and still he couldn't clear the exam even after 3rd attempt
Eversince I started preparation for Civil Services I lways had great respect for this man. After hearing his narrow analysis he made me think so much. Sir you say there is 1% successful candidates who secured below 50% in their 12 and graduation and after you proudly say you were suppose to propose 50% minimum criteria which indicates you were ready to sacrifice those 1% rights. You need to improve educational system from grassroot level where teachers marking system has no parameters. You can not go and sacrifice even those 1% right to service and to take part in national exam like Civil Services. It is a constitutional right of every graduate to appear in civil services exam. No self analysis and no data based on self determination can violate this right. This exam should be based on social economic cultural political behavioural and so on aspects.... coz it is these factors which determines our past and these factors should not allow our present and future. Therefore, having presided post like chairman of UPSC your narrow analysis makes me feel worry abt its future and future of those students whose educational background was shaped by above factors. Regards.
Actually this person has engineering background that is manifested in his analysis..beauty of life is in human ambition aspiration and endeavour....For him more than two chance is wastage of time. he shud know wasting time is much better than than life lacking risk...civil services is not like engineering and management where merit is everything but social and political justice is also ensured by giving representation to all sections of society.going by his logic power will be concentrated in some hands..he shud know that there is India outside Delhi and Pune and there r millions of institutions which have taken the oath to destroy the future of students..
I totally agree with the hard fact the success rate and getting in to any of the services is really hard.... But does that mean given a chance you should not try at all and try to succeed
Govt job is not just about creating space for self, it's much more about safeguarding for next 30-35 yrs, safety, security, knowing your next day is safe rather than living a complacent life in private jobs...if hes so serious about creating space then he should have gone for severance agreement without any retirement benefits...his whole session was full of sadness, not once he said anything which could have uplifted moral...
Traing at early age means creating perspective in young minds suitable for civil services and learning life long process means absorbing information and analyzing on the basis of own perspective..both r compatible
Sir ..really respect you..thank you for being very realistic and hitting the bulls eye...Otherwise we as aspirants r constantly given a mirage by the people around in coaching industry
This speech for well mature people. ""Revolution doesn't came from balance approach. "" That why IAS kannan gopinath resign Right to freedom of expression of J&k people.
Regarding, all civil servicses rejected candidates go for teaching. Thats not true in all the cases. You may check new faculties background of IIT, NIT, NIPER, Central Universities. Many are Ph.Ds from good universities or abroad, just after Masters-without wasting time. Most of them pursuing teaching and more focused in research.
जर तुम्ही तुमच्या full potential ne preparation keli असेल.... Like u never did before it at this extent ..... Then also u didn't get qualify ...just leave it ... U r not made for it... U r made for somthing bigger .... Now u have to decide have u prepared at ur best This is the message given in this video which I have comprehend In Olympics all players at same level but gold medal wins only one who have prepared at their best If any player couldn't do so he/she appear next time with full preparation at/beyond their limit Moral is that be ur best version If any aspirant qualifies in upsc with low grades earlier ...then he/she have expolred himself / herself during the preparation Every student with with low grades does not qualify exam and every student with high grades also does not qualify exam Here Darwin's theory exactly matches "Survival of the fittest"
Timestamps 02:15 - Are teachers equipped to develop personalities of students? [Lament/Rant on the behavior & preferences of civil aspirants, failure of system, perils of social media] 30:30 - How to form an opinion of our own from information? 35:18 - What are the suggestions to candidate's with few hobbies & less participation in extra-curricular activities 42:54 - Should UPSC disclose answer sheets through RTI? 47:30 - Random Question on Interview
Sir u said a harsh truth 90% civil servants children doesn't appear in civil service sir but harsh truth from my side when u have 500 crore in pocket any duffer will go for upsc
As a citizen of India every child coming from a rich family or a humble family, upper caste or from a lower caste has the right to live & die for the country🇮🇳 Civil Services is a social platform where any brilliant child can raise his or her social position in society which is not possible through a business or a private sector high paying job. It's not a job it's a service🇮🇳
Certain points like dissatisfaction of not getting an IAS or IPS or his view on reading the mother tongue literature is valid. However, certain remarks like only meritorious students in academics has to apply for civil service, achieving the rank at 30 is not good enough are over generalisation. The point is what is the personality, physical condition, mental alertness, experience and knowledge of the person at 30. If a person has invested time from 21 to 30 in gaining knowledge and experience of the world, he is the most ideal candidate to score a rank and don the role of country's top bureaucrat. I do agree with him overall that self assessment is the key.
Well, with the change in current pattern of grading system, the similar sets of students, who earlier scored less than 50% now scores 50-70% easily. That means they those who were earlier non capable are capable of getting through UPSC. He uses the number '3' in most of his examples, like while saying that "none, but there were only 3 students who were....... so and so". Well, this number '3' might be his favorite or its and interesting coincidence in the history of UPSC. He is surely not a person who promotes change with changing environment, which is understandable when he spoke about Social Media. He said, similar sets of students can become WORLD'S BEST teacher if they leave IAS aspiration. but if they aspire for IAS then they will surely end up becoming a teacher who could not achieve his first choice. Well, I can list many people who did wonders with his second choice. Thus, this is not a very acceptable argument. Bechare Baache par kya guzar rahi hogi. Complete talk is a destructive counselling. A cynical pessimism.
though he discouraged initially, he has very good insight on services he conducts, availability and opportunities to aspirants. very good and practical views.
Mr dp agrawal btech from AMU and served various organizations in different countries on basis of his knowledge and skills govt made him head of UPSC great man
He is a fellow from IIT background he doesn't know what exactly the society is, he introduced CSAT, it's made injustice to rural background and vernacular students.... Accommodate diversity is democracy.... Govt done a historical fault that its appointed this mugging up community fellow as dignified chairman position.. present UPSC chairman recommended to remove CSAT Paper...
I don't understand ye motivating video hai ya demotivating m 27 aur meri hath me agai, literally!! now after listening this m bound to re-think that koi job lelu pehle ya isi ki preparation karu!!😕😟
Look at the grief in his talk, his accent, his eyes...! THEY are clearly reflecting. How his attempts to modify the System couldn't be executed. 🙄 Do we feel, How sensitive issues he is talking about !!
every rural place doesnt hve the same education standard...sir...u hve a very strong Negative vibe towrds bckwrd and rural class....u sud know that some rural areas are there wer education is available but theres no standard...so u bttr stop giving lectures whch are unrealistic and untrue
Upsc is only an agency to conduct exam. He should talk about how the examination can be improved and route learners can be eliminated. He is talking like a policy maker, which unfortunately is not his job.
suraj singh what hard reality man? there are vulnerable sections who cannot even dream to write this exam.. and his heart bleeds for people who can but fail
He claims that below 50 percent success ratio is less, which may be true based on survey but its a gross generalisation . He forgets that every individual is different and no standardised exam can fully measure him. This analogy is not just wrong but ridiculous. Please see student as an autonomous individual.
Mje smjh n aa rh k ap kya candidates ko sirf ek attmpt se out kr dena chahte jo bar bar ap muh teda kr k keh rh ho kya kre rule general ka 6attmpt allow h but phr b lo de rh h or ban rh h rok pa rh ho ap.. Ek dalit ne 10saal atmpt kia phr b bna
Also tell that cramming up and clearing JEE is not useful for our nation.. That's why we don't have intelligent think tanks who can solve national issues.
how proud they are of inherited British education system where is ancient Indian education system that amazes the west & rest of world till today ? where is india's idea ??
UPSC given equal plateform for every student they want crack exam and this everyone believe that upcs intergity type exam believe your self then u have do that
HIMANSHU SRIVASTAVA congratulations if d concept has helped u keep your comments 2 yourself. .... by d way I faced him in an interview & know what his prejudices are after taking into note several candidates. ...
if u cant understand this much..plz dont prepare for civil services . he wants to convey that a lot of students who has never scored even 50% marks throughout his life attempts civil services and waste many years for their life bcz their success rate is less thn 1% .
He was one of the most biased chairman of upsc... Look at his historical legacy... He had to face many controversies because of his attitude towards candidates... But apart from that, still we can learn few things from this session.. Its all that matters.
Person in service never say don't attempt this exam after 3 attempt, reduce the age...and they barely leave any govt facility or luxurious life style but after retirement they become buddha and give lecture on life🙄 dont reduce the age/attempt rather reduce your salary,perks and post retirement benefits .... Why there is no commt/commsn on reducing these extra benefits which govt servant get over pvt employee ... HYPOCRISY ki bhi sima hoti h
Few things which we can learn from this session:
1) first Attempt should be best prepared attempt
2)try to crack within 3 attempts (still we can do better with job cause of age as well as career installation is also important)
3) you are the best interviewer of yourself
4) self assessment is the key to success
5)basic english but grammatically correct english is required
Views can be different but we should be continue with what we actually want.
What about you sir what is your results.
Students who get through mains but disqualified in interviews should be given a good gov post....Sir it will be a great initiative if its done
Atleast they should get gov teacher job.
Totally agree with him
@@dhruvpatel7457 teaching s a skill not only knowledge
@@iitneetwale9896 good student can become good teacher
He is not discouraging people to not take UPSC , but is inspring in a vibrant manner that if you have that passion in your heart to crack this exam , then just do it 2-3 attempts ..
He is giving a big msg that the number of attempts and greater age limits , reduces the number of bright students in other important area of life . From 9 lakh people other than top 1 lakh , 8 lakh can give much better performance in other areas.
As our nation not only needs best bueraucrates , but best teacher , best engineer, best of every job .
Although your opinion on marks is not very welcome , as any person with less marks , can also crack this exam , And u should not forget , loopholes in our education system . Else it was hard reality outlined .. Thnq sir
He is saying right things but he is not respecting the people emotion of earning more money believe me if one day God come and said only salary no extra money any duffer will go upsc and will pass through such a hard selection process
Join us for upsc preparation
Jab Tak Todenge Nahi..
Tab Tk Chodebge Nahi..
@@LearnWithMasterforIAS chutiya yaha bhi advertisement
@@truecaller655 bro don't bring emotion in this
Very practicle idea sir u shared with the govt that, who is qualifying Mains and rejected in Interview, let absorb in another services like banking.
At the same time sir u bear the courage that u have proposed this to govt. and govt rejected it.
Salute sir.
you can easily see the integrity and ethics in sir's speech...
Not every achiever achieve in upsc
My brother got AIR 178 in IIT-JEE exam and studied Electrical engineering from IIT Bombay and still he couldn't clear the exam even after 3rd attempt
Eversince I started preparation for Civil Services I lways had great respect for this man. After hearing his narrow analysis he made me think so much. Sir you say there is 1% successful candidates who secured below 50% in their 12 and graduation and after you proudly say you were suppose to propose 50% minimum criteria which indicates you were ready to sacrifice those 1% rights. You need to improve educational system from grassroot level where teachers marking system has no parameters. You can not go and sacrifice even those 1% right to service and to take part in national exam like Civil Services. It is a constitutional right of every graduate to appear in civil services exam. No self analysis and no data based on self determination can violate this right. This exam should be based on social economic cultural political behavioural and so on aspects.... coz it is these factors which determines our past and these factors should not allow our present and future. Therefore, having presided post like chairman of UPSC your narrow analysis makes me feel worry abt its future and future of those students whose educational background was shaped by above factors. Regards.
Actually this person has engineering background that is manifested in his analysis..beauty of life is in human ambition aspiration and endeavour....For him more than two chance is wastage of time. he shud know wasting time is much better than than life lacking risk...civil services is not like engineering and management where merit is everything but social and political justice is also ensured by giving representation to all sections of society.going by his logic power will be concentrated in some hands..he shud know that there is India outside Delhi and Pune and there r millions of institutions which have taken the oath to destroy the future of students..
Great man, just taught simply, how precious is our life.
I totally agree with the hard fact the success rate and getting in to any of the services is really hard.... But does that mean given a chance you should not try at all and try to succeed
"Take you decision your own"....this is the objective of this talk mainly.
ua-cam.com/video/3iJANi_vKcY/v-deo.html
How to write an authentic answer
English Vinglish
this is how UPSC differs from coaching institutions who teaches to take balanced approach always....straight and simple
Thank
Govt job is not just about creating space for self, it's much more about safeguarding for next 30-35 yrs, safety, security, knowing your next day is safe rather than living a complacent life in private jobs...if hes so serious about creating space then he should have gone for severance agreement without any retirement benefits...his whole session was full of sadness, not once he said anything which could have uplifted moral...
This is what i feel
Traing at early age means creating perspective in young minds suitable for civil services and learning life long process means absorbing information and analyzing on the basis of own perspective..both r compatible
He is not a biased person ...All he is saying is truth which is hard to accept...and neither he is demotivating anyone ,
Sir ..really respect you..thank you for being very realistic and hitting the bulls eye...Otherwise we as aspirants r constantly given a mirage by the people around in coaching industry
This speech for well mature people.
""Revolution doesn't came from balance approach. ""
That why IAS kannan gopinath resign Right to freedom of expression of J&k people.
you are great sir.. truly enlightened and realist
VERY IMPRESSIVE SPEECH AND NICE REPLY THANK YOU SO MUCH AGRAWAL SIR...
Regarding, all civil servicses rejected candidates go for teaching. Thats not true in all the cases. You may check new faculties background of IIT, NIT, NIPER, Central Universities. Many are Ph.Ds from good universities or abroad, just after Masters-without wasting time. Most of them pursuing teaching and more focused in research.
Best and inspiring ...lecture sir ...u r 100% right ...sir u are telling the bare truth...which will hurt a lot of guys
जर तुम्ही तुमच्या full potential ne preparation keli असेल.... Like u never did before it at this extent ..... Then also u didn't get qualify ...just leave it ... U r not made for it... U r made for somthing bigger ....
Now u have to decide have u prepared at ur best
This is the message given in this video which I have comprehend
In Olympics all players at same level but gold medal wins only one who have prepared at their best
If any player couldn't do so he/she appear next time with full preparation at/beyond their limit
Moral is that be ur best version
If any aspirant qualifies in upsc with low grades earlier ...then he/she have expolred himself / herself during the preparation
Every student with with low grades does not qualify exam and every student with high grades also does not qualify exam
Here Darwin's theory exactly matches
"Survival of the fittest"
Revolution doesn't come through balance. 🔥👍
Timestamps
02:15 - Are teachers equipped to develop personalities of students?
[Lament/Rant on the behavior & preferences of civil aspirants, failure of system, perils of social media]
30:30 - How to form an opinion of our own from information?
35:18 - What are the suggestions to candidate's with few hobbies & less participation in extra-curricular activities
42:54 - Should UPSC disclose answer sheets through RTI?
47:30 - Random Question on Interview
Thank you
Sir u said a harsh truth 90% civil servants children doesn't appear in civil service sir but harsh truth from my side when u have 500 crore in pocket any duffer will go for upsc
Right
8 hour study minimum,in depth and find the best source
Great Sir..What ever you are telling,it's true..
hard truth, spoken with conviction.
very relevant ...
Very genuine and realistic advice for civil services aspirants...
As a citizen of India every child coming from a rich family or a humble family, upper caste or from a lower caste has the right to live & die for the country🇮🇳
Civil Services is a social platform where any brilliant child can raise his or her social position in society which is not possible through a business or a private sector high paying job. It's not a job it's a service🇮🇳
Nice interview. I fully inspired
His eyes tells the amount of pressure he has beared
SUPER DUPER SPEECH AND GUIDE REALLY THANK YOU SO MUCH SIR SALUTE YOU....
all I can tell from this video is- he is a very realistic person and I like that
respect for Shri D. P. Agarwal sir for this precious information
Certain points like dissatisfaction of not getting an IAS or IPS or his view on reading the mother tongue literature is valid. However, certain remarks like only meritorious students in academics has to apply for civil service, achieving the rank at 30 is not good enough are over generalisation. The point is what is the personality, physical condition, mental alertness, experience and knowledge of the person at 30. If a person has invested time from 21 to 30 in gaining knowledge and experience of the world, he is the most ideal candidate to score a rank and don the role of country's top bureaucrat. I do agree with him overall that self assessment is the key.
The man is very honest and empathatic
BRUTALLY HONEST DIRECT STRAIGHT FORWARD GR8 SIR
Thank you mit team for uploading this video
Well, with the change in current pattern of grading system, the similar sets of students, who earlier scored less than 50% now scores 50-70% easily. That means they those who were earlier non capable are capable of getting through UPSC.
He uses the number '3' in most of his examples, like while saying that "none, but there were only 3 students who were....... so and so". Well, this number '3' might be his favorite or its and interesting coincidence in the history of UPSC.
He is surely not a person who promotes change with changing environment, which is understandable when he spoke about Social Media.
He said, similar sets of students can become WORLD'S BEST teacher if they leave IAS aspiration. but if they aspire for IAS then they will surely end up becoming a teacher who could not achieve his first choice. Well, I can list many people who did wonders with his second choice. Thus, this is not a very acceptable argument.
Bechare Baache par kya guzar rahi hogi. Complete talk is a destructive counselling. A cynical pessimism.
though he discouraged initially, he has very good insight on services he conducts, availability and opportunities to aspirants. very good and practical views.
Mr dp agrawal btech from AMU and served various organizations in different countries on basis of his knowledge and skills govt made him head of UPSC great man
Their criteria is not wrong it picked wrong person
Nice sir...
You are need of our COUNTRY
JAY HIND
""Aap likhenge to aapko 5 gaali aaenge."""Absolutely correct.Best ever interview I have seen
He is a fellow from IIT background he doesn't know what exactly the society is, he introduced CSAT, it's made injustice to rural background and vernacular students.... Accommodate diversity is democracy.... Govt done a historical fault that its appointed this mugging up community fellow as dignified chairman position.. present UPSC chairman recommended to remove CSAT Paper...
TRUE FACTS SIR....BEST SPEECH
Why maximum age limit for a civil services exam isn't 28 yrs as before
Sir...hum logo ko bhi young minister's chahiye... President ka minimum age 35 se 21 saal hona chahiye
vry true, thats why he was upsc chairman....
I don't understand ye motivating video hai ya demotivating
m 27 aur meri hath me agai, literally!!
now after listening this m bound to re-think that koi job lelu pehle ya isi ki preparation karu!!😕😟
This is truth
Very explained sir urban and rular area
its a bitter truth that more than 80% ias r those who were good in their academics. its very tough for average students to crack upsc
Maximum 3 attempts should be allowed for upsc civil services,why it's 32 yrs instead of 28 yrs, which was earlier
Dara diya sir.....but every word u spoke is truth
thanks sir!! very informative....
Is this speech for motivation or demotivation.
Sir it's really truth for life
nice informative class
bitter but true
Look at the grief in his talk, his accent, his eyes...! THEY are clearly reflecting.
How his attempts to modify the System couldn't be executed. 🙄 Do we feel, How sensitive issues he is talking about !!
Good way guide ĺ for student for upsc
This video put me in existansial crisis.
very effective opinion for us
every rural place doesnt hve the same education standard...sir...u hve a very strong Negative vibe towrds bckwrd and rural class....u sud know that some rural areas are there wer education is available but theres no standard...so u bttr stop giving lectures whch are unrealistic and untrue
he seems to be a pessimistic person
and i disagree with him that education cannot make person ready for job
Is not Pessimistic is good critic if you can think of it as he intended.
23:11 Hilarious 😂 But serious ✔️
Thanku
From 38 minute...Jabardast hai
Upsc is only an agency to conduct exam. He should talk about how the examination can be improved and route learners can be eliminated. He is talking like a policy maker, which unfortunately is not his job.
For a civil services aspirant there should be restrictions of just 3 attempts .not more than this... otherwise it it's allowing rattafication
Very straight forward .
Nice sir
Why people are complaining. He is being honest. The truth is always ugly.
Very hard reality.
suraj singh what hard reality man? there are vulnerable sections who cannot even dream to write this exam..
and his heart bleeds for people who can but fail
19:20 value of clarity
I thought he was in MIT. then camera zoomed out. 😂😂😂😂
He claims that below 50 percent success ratio is less, which may be true based on survey but its a gross generalisation . He forgets that every individual is different and no standardised exam can fully measure him. This analogy is not just wrong but ridiculous. Please see student as an autonomous individual.
thanx for the video
Thank you Sir.
Trust me guys UPSC people are highly outdated. There mindset is still pre 80 or 90 era..Orthodoxy is too much and innovative ideas are discouraged..
Let the aspirant decide wether he wants to do or not a less serious candidate wouldnt have be appeared in second attempt
He has realistic attitude
he is true at evry thing he say,still i'll try
Very experienced person
Mje smjh n aa rh k ap kya candidates ko sirf ek attmpt se out kr dena chahte jo bar bar ap muh teda kr k keh rh ho kya kre rule general ka 6attmpt allow h but phr b lo de rh h or ban rh h rok pa rh ho ap.. Ek dalit ne 10saal atmpt kia phr b bna
Real practical man
Very nice sir, nice interview
Also tell that cramming up and clearing JEE is not useful for our nation.. That's why we don't have intelligent think tanks who can solve national issues.
yes bitter truth.
kiran sangwan hii
Impressive lecture sir
how proud they are of inherited British education system where is ancient Indian education system that amazes the west & rest of world till today ? where is india's idea ??
Where in the World it's present now
Bitter pill , but completely true.
19:45 heart bleds, enormous loss to nation
great!
i salute you sir
UPSC given equal plateform for every student they want crack exam and this everyone believe that upcs intergity type exam believe your self then u have do that
Very biased person.... first says that he himself never crossed 50% in his life then says 50% mandatory.... thankfully gone....
HIMANSHU SRIVASTAVA congratulations if d concept has helped u keep your comments 2 yourself. .... by d way I faced him in an interview & know what his prejudices are after taking into note several candidates. ...
Sam Sam agree with u ..his viewpoints are very biased !!
if u cant understand this much..plz dont prepare for civil services . he wants to convey that a lot of students who has never scored even 50% marks throughout his life attempts civil services and waste many years for their life bcz their success rate is less thn 1% .
that time 50% means...present day more than 80%
He was one of the most biased chairman of upsc... Look at his historical legacy... He had to face many controversies because of his attitude towards candidates... But apart from that, still we can learn few things from this session.. Its all that matters.
लय भारी अग्रवाल भावा
Which is best coaching centre for upsc
thanks
Person in service never say don't attempt this exam after 3 attempt, reduce the age...and they barely leave any govt facility or luxurious life style but after retirement they become buddha and give lecture on life🙄 dont reduce the age/attempt rather reduce your salary,perks and post retirement benefits .... Why there is no commt/commsn on reducing these extra benefits which govt servant get over pvt employee ... HYPOCRISY ki bhi sima hoti h