What Tank Combat Sounds Like

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 17 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 927

  • @Spookston
    @Spookston  3 роки тому +306

    GHPC Patreon: www.patreon.com/GunnerHEATPC/membership
    GHPC Website: gunnerheatpc.com/
    GHPC Discord: discord.gg/eH5vf65

    • @sarttee
      @sarttee 3 роки тому +6

      they should have a tank running over snails for a cinematic.

    • @commentator4515
      @commentator4515 3 роки тому +1

      Learned something new about tanks today. BTW: are there any plans for some more everything-wrong-with videos?

    • @TheArklyte
      @TheArklyte 3 роки тому +1

      Just get 3 people to control a tank in your BF clone and you'll hear panic:)
      Driver - obviously drives and can control hull mounted GPMG and AGL;
      Gunner - controls turret and thus main gun with all ammo options, coaxial HMG and GPMG;
      Commander - controls countermeasures and remote weapon stations(AGL, HMG, GPMG, ATGM/MANPAD).
      Can you imagine level of screaming?;)

    • @TheArklyte
      @TheArklyte 3 роки тому +2

      @@sarttee nah, that smells like what Gaijin does when making fun of WoT... before introducing more arcade BS without arcade fun.

    • @chee.rah.monurB
      @chee.rah.monurB 3 роки тому

      Another video from the millitary furry,yay!

  • @NTAD
    @NTAD 3 роки тому +4096

    I still cannot get over the loader's muffled "UP". Such a simple detail that brings so much immersion.

    • @F-18Super
      @F-18Super 3 роки тому +237

      Oddly enough in Call of duty ghost of all games, the loader also yells “UP” when a shell is loaded.

    • @CircuitCatWT
      @CircuitCatWT 3 роки тому +11

      Exactly

    • @NTAD
      @NTAD 3 роки тому +93

      @@F-18Super It's no wonder I don't remember that since I never finished the game lol. I played maybe the first mission and got bored. It's been just sitting on my shelf ever since.

    • @twentylush
      @twentylush 3 роки тому +57

      @@NTAD its worth revisiting for 30min to an hour. Don't have to play that much of it, but you can kinda see how Ghost set up the entire feel/mechanical direction of cod games these days. Wouldn't say its underrated but there are just some things that were weird back in the day that, in retrospect, are about as pioneering as you can get in a yearly release FPS game

    • @vannlo355
      @vannlo355 3 роки тому +14

      3:25 ivan turret goes helicopter mode 🔥😆

  • @Toolazyfornewname
    @Toolazyfornewname 3 роки тому +4434

    I've been a gunner in a Bradley for about 10 years now... this is the most technically accurate game I think I've ever heard. Even down to you getting a bad laze, and then your BC/TC telling you to relaze. I don't mean this is kinda how it goes, or they almost got it right. You wanna know the experience of being in a turret? This is probably the closest you can get in a video game so far.

    • @vladimirtherussian166
      @vladimirtherussian166 3 роки тому +8

      You ever see combat врат ?

    • @loganb7059
      @loganb7059 3 роки тому +12

      I wonder if a military may use this or an advanced version of it as a simulator.

    • @sinisterisrandom8537
      @sinisterisrandom8537 3 роки тому +118

      @@vladimirtherussian166 considering he's been a gunenr in a M3 bradley the possibility is prob yes.

    • @Apocalypse31
      @Apocalypse31 3 роки тому +12

      Steel Beasts? It has a (near) fully clickable turret for the Brad

    • @GunnerHEATPC
      @GunnerHEATPC 3 роки тому +261

      Glad to hear you found it compelling! We take input from armor vets seriously and do our best to convey the experience authentically, as much as a game can anyway.

  • @Alex-xd9gw
    @Alex-xd9gw 3 роки тому +3759

    War thunder: 'our driver has been knocked out."
    Gunner heat Pc: "OH SHIT, THEY GOT DAVID!"

    • @Dan86130
      @Dan86130 3 роки тому +426

      Rest in pieces, David

    • @jp8612
      @jp8612 3 роки тому +186

      Rest in pieces, David

    • @radimziegler7079
      @radimziegler7079 3 роки тому +130

      Rest in pieces, David

    • @a2broslol
      @a2broslol 3 роки тому +99

      Rest in pieces, David

    • @SgtSkelebone
      @SgtSkelebone 3 роки тому +82

      Rest in pieces, David

  • @Jilve69
    @Jilve69 3 роки тому +2595

    People: why can't you be normal?
    Video game tank crews: *screams*

    • @yourallygod8261
      @yourallygod8261 3 роки тому +77

      What do you mean that is normal :D

    • @jackmio
      @jackmio 3 роки тому +5

      this made me laugh lol

    • @yourallygod8261
      @yourallygod8261 3 роки тому +57

      @@Jilve69 well i would assume irl with a loud ass engine/gun firing among having to use hearing protection to not be completely defeaned by all the noise and the sounds that can happen when hit... yes i would assume yelling is a normal outcome of nearly dying. in games its toned down but still happens slightly so either come at me with proof it ain't or GTFO

    • @rocky-zx6kq
      @rocky-zx6kq 3 роки тому +10

      @@Jilve69 How about this, Imagine you're a tank driver and you see 2 tanks aiming at you and what you gonna say? Are you gonna calmly say target spotted and just relax and ignore the fact you will die by a 120mm AP round penetrating on you?

    • @verticalflyingb737
      @verticalflyingb737 3 роки тому +3

      @@rocky-zx6kq Yep, just typical Tuesdays /s

  • @aenaros6845
    @aenaros6845 3 роки тому +1474

    Game: GunnerheatPC
    UA-cam: Oh, this is War thunder.
    When the video is actually War Thunder.
    UA-cam: Oh, World of Tanks.

    • @gorenc97
      @gorenc97 3 роки тому +56

      Mighty Jingles moment.

    • @colbyuetake130
      @colbyuetake130 3 роки тому +4

      I mean you can choose the Game manually if you want but I guess he didnt lmaO

    • @Orinslayer
      @Orinslayer 3 роки тому +6

      Say it with me, Gunner, Heat, PC. Oh, Warthunder!

    • @nehankaranch2149
      @nehankaranch2149 3 роки тому +4

      UA-cam doesn't auto select. It's all manually and spookston did war thunder to get most views

    • @NTAD
      @NTAD 3 роки тому +2

      @@nehankaranch2149 Plus GHPC doesn't show up as an option yet since it hasn't been published

  • @jackofspades3908
    @jackofspades3908 3 роки тому +1706

    As a former soldier in the British Army who served in the KRH (Kings Royal Hussars) as a tankey, theses voice lines in GHPC are authentic enough to give me chills from my time during training excises. Fantastic job they have done with the American crews, hopefully they model the voices for British tank crews. Great Vid Spook keep it up!
    Edit the extra thing they could add for authenticity is ANR (Active noise reduction) For the gunner site, which is played through the crew headsets to reduce hearing damage while operating a CR2. Would be a fantastic touch on top of an already awesome game.

    • @oscarswinnerton3538
      @oscarswinnerton3538 3 роки тому +43

      I would love to try the challengers in ghpc that way I don't have to suffer in war thunder.

    • @guywhodoesstuff3314
      @guywhodoesstuff3314 3 роки тому +31

      Once they get around to modeling NORTHAG they'll do the Brits justice.

    • @IntrusiveThot420
      @IntrusiveThot420 3 роки тому +13

      Heya, if you hop on the GHPC discord the devs will probably listen to your suggestion!

    • @Deathbomb9
      @Deathbomb9 3 роки тому +13

      I agree, was a US tanker and it gave me chills as well. Seriously, this looks like one of our simulators was put in a video game and I love it. And the voices are super close with how it might actually be, but i think they could really get closer if they can get some real recordings. Also, the "Up!" Of the loader is usually heard as background noise in the tank because their mics are a bit out of the way most the time and they are told to really yell it so it's clear that it was announced. Like you can tell the gunner is yelling 8n the background but his mic picks it up at a lower volume but keeps the tone and everything else.

    • @jackofspades3908
      @jackofspades3908 3 роки тому +2

      @@___-cp6or I know I've seem them when I was in, even got an opportunity to go in the REME version of them called Aeries. Only comment on them is they are bloody massive and barely fit in the hangers we use for CR2s.

  • @aPugachevCobra
    @aPugachevCobra 3 роки тому +942

    Small correction: the TC saying “doubtful” is a type of sensing. Look up the acronym DLOST. He’s telling the gunner where his round landed relative to the target. If the round impact isn’t observable, “doubtful” is used.
    “Target” would be an observed hit, and then a subsequent command of “reengage” or “ceasefire” would determine what the gunner does next.
    Great video, love this game so much.

    • @Nick-rg8oz
      @Nick-rg8oz 3 роки тому +1

      Damn nice

    • @MrArgus11111
      @MrArgus11111 3 роки тому +14

      I was about to say that as more or less a layman I took issue with "doubtful" being used in the sense that Spook claims it is used in really meaning what he says it means. I'm also curious... is the callout "ceasefire" when a unit is knocked out always 100% accurate in the game? I would imagine that, sometimes, this won't be accurate. A vehicle could be prematurely ID'd as done for when, seconds or minutes later, it starts moving again, to everyone's horror.

    • @chaos2876
      @chaos2876 2 роки тому +18

      Correction to this, you're referring to the "Lost" part of DLOST. "Doubtful" means the round missed the target to the left or right, "Lost" is used when the commander doesn't observe the impact.

    • @jefferydraper4019
      @jefferydraper4019 Рік тому +3

      The one I hated was short. You just couldnt be sure. Best to put another in. In WW2 my uncle, a tanker, said they would pass old wrecked German tanks with dozens of holes from guys "being sure."

    • @Danspy501st
      @Danspy501st Рік тому +2

      I always thought that when the TC saying "doubtful" that either the shot missed/lost of trace from the TC. Or that the shot hit the target, but the TC is unsure if it did anything. Like disable the tank, or when straight through

  • @Mkxvandal
    @Mkxvandal 3 роки тому +2082

    Listen to their voices literally made me feel panicked. So simple but so immersive.

    • @StudleyDuderight
      @StudleyDuderight 3 роки тому +32

      Yeah and that's why leaders train to stay as calm as possible when communicating to their subordinates.

    • @f00koff42
      @f00koff42 3 роки тому +115

      @@StudleyDuderight no tank commander could be calm if WW3 had broken up in Europe knowing his estimated remaining life time would be under 15 minutes

    • @LostParadise_
      @LostParadise_ 3 роки тому +4

      I can only imagine the experience is a dozen times more panicky playing the actual game with a headset, and actually trying to select, find, and hit targets of varying levels of threat.

    • @pieppy6058
      @pieppy6058 3 роки тому +2

      He’s LOokiNg At uS

    • @pieppy6058
      @pieppy6058 3 роки тому +5

      @@LostParadise_ still want to see a vr tank game where people play every role (except for the loader, nobody wants to play a loader). Atmospheric to the max . From a game design perspective, it probably wouldn’t work as a pvp game and you would have to take some liberties with what the commander can do, but it would be quite fun.

  • @MrRed_2205
    @MrRed_2205 3 роки тому +606

    Playing war thunder, you kinda just point at enemies and feel happy when you get a kill, and annoyed when you get killed. A game like this really makes you realize how terrifying it is to be in real tank combat, when you miss a shot and can die any second while staring at the enemy's tank barrel pointing straight towards you. Incredible work

    • @Aurora-pi6jr
      @Aurora-pi6jr 3 роки тому +43

      Absolutely, GHPC makes warthunder look like elderly people playing with rc model kits

    • @LordOfChaos.x
      @LordOfChaos.x 3 роки тому +6

      thats what i felt being in a M60A3 against a fucking T71M
      couldnt do shit against that mofo unless i got its sides
      even then it wouldnt kill him
      to this day i havent been able to finish that mission
      everytime he landed a shell on me it was a 1 shot and rarely he missed but broke one of my tracks and then 1 shoted, the problem is u have to deal with 1 ATGM camping and several t55A that are stationated a little bit far away
      i dont think anyone has succeded that mission ever

    • @LaVaZ000
      @LaVaZ000 3 роки тому +2

      That's war thunder as well...

    • @fim-43redeye31
      @fim-43redeye31 3 роки тому +2

      You still feel awesome when you get a kill, though.

    • @melc311
      @melc311 2 роки тому +6

      You can also feel that in War thunder sometimes when you're dueling an enemy tank with both of you in the open. Even better when both tanks have to aim for weakspots. The dread of seeing your shell bounce and having to hope the enemy also misses their shot.

  • @Ayattar55
    @Ayattar55 3 роки тому +307

    The voices are just as illegible as they should be. My absolute favourite during the maneouvers is, when someone gets excited/stressed enough to drop radio discipline and starts screaming casually, in long sentences, into the mike. Thing is, you don't scream, you talk laconic, and you use radio voice, punctuating words separately. I'm on Sordin Supreme CC and even they don't manage well with excited screaming.

  • @morselite2241
    @morselite2241 3 роки тому +361

    Hearing an actual "A.D.D.R.A.C." in a game is pretty cool. Really detailed in the sound department, hope the game does well. The acronym stands for Alert, Direction, Description, Range, Assignment, Control.

  • @spinosaurusiii7027
    @spinosaurusiii7027 3 роки тому +316

    The voice acting in GHPC and its implementation are great
    Kinda reminds me of the lines from squads in Company of Heroes,
    which has lots of lines that change depending on the situation
    so if you select a MG42 while it's idle, you'll hear something like
    "Machine gun squad" or "MG42 is ready"
    but then as it keeps fighting the lines get more stressed,
    until all you hear when you select it is "Fourtytwo!"

    • @johnnypetersen3818
      @johnnypetersen3818 3 роки тому +44

      Some of the tanks from the sequel get the same treatment
      They say their full designation while calm, but cut it down to less than a second and mostly yell at YOU if stressed (I.E. combat)
      "Churchill Crocodile reporting in"
      "What, WHAT WHAT?"

    • @alahsiaboi8909
      @alahsiaboi8909 3 роки тому +23

      I heard some simmilar things happen in other rts game (forgot the name) , when you close in the camera to a certain unit you could hear them talking about the mission, OR the act you do, for example if i told them to attack and they succeed they gonna say something like "the CO know what his UpTo" or "damn all hail liuentenant *protag name* " and so on ,but if you lose so much unit they started gossiping you and kinda lose Faith in you "what the hell does lieuntenant thinking?!" "Effing ruskies kicking our a$$ " , sometimes they Made a comment about the mission itself , like when you get the objective to hold certain area from enemy waves with a limited unit you could hear them screaming in eager and couraging each other

    • @dvpant3651
      @dvpant3651 3 роки тому +21

      @@alahsiaboi8909 reminds me of World in Conflict or that's probably the game you are referring to as they also do the same when you zoom in on idle or in combat units.

    • @NixodCreations
      @NixodCreations 3 роки тому +15

      @@alahsiaboi8909 Homeworld did that too; if you zoomed into the ships you could hear the crew talking talking within the ship/squadron on the intercom. Although in those games the voice acting was always very calm and professional.

    • @MetalKitsune
      @MetalKitsune 3 роки тому +5

      @@NixodCreations Which makes sense air and ship combat has alot more that can go wrong if you panic and is also slower than ground combat.

  • @sanguineaurora8765
    @sanguineaurora8765 3 роки тому +391

    We're playing a dedicated tank crew in Post Scriptum and i'm guessing that's as realistic as it gets since it's us who are panicked screaming when a tank is spotted and is looking at us.
    Especially if we are in a long range duel, commander screams "Hit again, AGAIN!", or things like; "NO NO HIT THE TURRET YOU ARE BOUNCING" especially if you come across a Tiger in an Armored car.. i am the driver and i feel my hands shaking in some situations. Trying to avoid the fire, listening to commanders screams "DRIVE DRIVE HE'S LOOKING AT US"
    and when you get a kill shot we're like "HELL YEAAAH"

    • @wilddenbigh
      @wilddenbigh 3 роки тому +57

      I had a moment like this in Squad as a crew of a Bradley, having one guy as Commander, one Gunner then, me as Driver. Listening out for the commanders orders, executing them and acting as a Secondary Spotter, screaming whenever enemy infantry got close to us or a tank/apc was able to sneak up to us. We somehow managed to survive an entire round without losing the Bradley once meanwhile repeatedly killing the enemy armour and light vics from Ambush cause we were able to position and spot well. But the moments where we would be repositioning and caught out by enemy AT was exhilerating, especially jumping out as the Driver to repair the broken track so we can get moving again meanwhile the Gunner is letting lose with the Bushmaster and the Commander hoped out to provide cover.

    • @johnnypetersen3818
      @johnnypetersen3818 3 роки тому +26

      Hell Let Loose
      Be part of the crew in a teeny tiny Panzer 2 Luchs.
      I was the gunner and had to fire by guidance of the commander, as the foliage we used to hide in was tall enough to choke my viewports with muddy greenery.
      It got really tense when we saw bazooka teams move up on us, or if a tank was driving in our vicinity
      We could only deal with the infantry, and run from tanks.
      Best round i ever had, and best crew as a whole i ever had

    • @sanguineaurora8765
      @sanguineaurora8765 3 роки тому +20

      @@wilddenbigh Oh yeah.
      A tank is extremely vulnerable to infantry. I had no idea up until i played PS. Whenever you are within infantry's 100 ish meters, your life expectancy is somewhere in the ballpark of 10-15 seconds, IF you are lucky.

    • @dvpant3651
      @dvpant3651 3 роки тому +2

      ahhh this brings back memories of being TC with my mates in Red Orchestra 2, the panicked screams when an enemy tank looks at us XD

    • @TidusleFlemard
      @TidusleFlemard 3 роки тому +9

      for added realism, get your whole team to use throat mic (they are a kind of mic you wear around your neck, they have usually bad sound quality but are much less influenced by outside sounds that you would have in a tank)

  • @TheoHawk316
    @TheoHawk316 3 роки тому +246

    "The sounds are always weak" Hence why we have sounds mods.

    • @TR33ZY_CRTM
      @TR33ZY_CRTM 3 роки тому +8

      *laughs in Thunder Crew v6.0*

    • @corycottrell1956
      @corycottrell1956 3 роки тому +3

      *cries in console* 😥

    • @TheKaMeLRo
      @TheKaMeLRo 3 роки тому

      Someone just put Armored warfare crew voice and it is so much improved over original warthunder.

    • @randommanchild112
      @randommanchild112 3 роки тому

      At least all the Direct Hit sounds are eargasm

    • @fuhckme8845
      @fuhckme8845 3 роки тому

      @@randommanchild112 yea they great

  • @GearReview23
    @GearReview23 3 роки тому +214

    I'm pretty sure the reason in War Thunder whenever a member is hit the announcer refers to them as "knocked out" "unconscious" or "dazed" is because they're trying to keep it below a certain rating. Technically no one dies in War Thunder. Even when you kill an enemy pilot it only refers to them as "unconscious". So if people actually died it would be a bit higher rating and it they might lose some of their market.

    • @flashtirade
      @flashtirade 3 роки тому +47

      Pretty much. Too many "violent" or "adult" things will push the rating to mature, which isn't so much a restriction on the playerbase (because people lie about their ages on the internet all the time) but on the snail's marketing strategies.

    • @Zorro9129
      @Zorro9129 3 роки тому +42

      @@flashtirade It's pretty stupid though. Even kids playing the game know what's up and will say they "killed" the enemy.

    • @obsidianjane4413
      @obsidianjane4413 3 роки тому +13

      @@Zorro9129 But its a small stupid thing. There's no need for gore or bodies or references thereof, even though some of the aircrew voice tracks are pretty close ("My leg!" " I'm burningggggg...." etc.)

    • @a.p.2356
      @a.p.2356 2 роки тому +24

      *Panzer II takes a KV-2 round to the grill and instantly turns to mist*
      "Enemy crew is taking a nap!"

    • @tramachi7027
      @tramachi7027 2 роки тому

      China is the main reason behind it. Without this kind off censorship/tone down it would receive massive penalties in China or even be banned.

  • @cursedcliff7562
    @cursedcliff7562 3 роки тому +137

    that detail of the voicelines getting more hectic when the enemy is looking at you is so good

  • @xxx4820
    @xxx4820 3 роки тому +57

    The driver saying “he’s looking at us” spooked me quite abit, I’ve heard the other lines before but that one takes the cake

    • @simplemusketeer7421
      @simplemusketeer7421 Рік тому +9

      They plan on adding more, looking through the audio files, and once they get a gore system in, they plan on having the crew saying stuff like "Jesus Christ..." or "fuuuuck me..." when they see a grizzly scene of mangled bodies. Showing humanity.

  • @steweygrrr
    @steweygrrr 3 роки тому +146

    Yeah it bugs me too. Most tank games seem to forget that the inside of a tank, whether in combat or not, is _really fucking loud._ It's a nice touch that it's not just the "short and sweet" that you'd actually hear but that they are yelling to make themselves heard even with the aid of the intercom.

    • @pearlysplayhouse7761
      @pearlysplayhouse7761 2 роки тому +2

      In arma 3 I play a full militarized exile pve mod and with the roaming AI independent turret systems are crucial because enemy rhino tank destroyers will investigate extremely loud cannons, they were driving up the hill to my base with a squad running along side while I was checking out the effect my mortar had on an area, I was watching them move up the hill and decided I should work on adding concrete walls sometime lol

    • @pearlysplayhouse7761
      @pearlysplayhouse7761 2 роки тому +2

      I should add that keeping vehicles off and ears open will vastly improve your survival

    • @eremiticwolf3499
      @eremiticwolf3499 Рік тому +2

      No sh*t. I was in the M1A1 HA in Desert Shield/Storm. When you are moving and that main gun fires over your head you feel it and the whole tank rocks back...

    • @drrocketman7794
      @drrocketman7794 2 місяці тому +1

      Former APC crewman here. Even with intercom, it's FUCKING LOUD and without intercom you can't hear the person next to you unless he's literally screaming in your ear.

  • @bozo5773
    @bozo5773 3 роки тому +59

    The crews voices and their ability to change tone depending on the situation, really makes it feel like they’re alive and there with you. It really changes the standard gaming mentality of “I want to stay alive” to “I have to keep us alive”

  • @thetwangler1805
    @thetwangler1805 3 роки тому +171

    The commands sound good, I served on a m1a2 Abrams for a few years. Some things I seen from the vid the made me question one command "gunner heat tank" that would pretty much never happen unless you're out of sabot. Or I'd see he had to lead with the cross hair which also never happened since the LRF would laze it then keep it's distance and so instead of leading a target moving at something going 20mph you just keep aiming center mass and the ballistic computer would do the rest and if you're bore sighted with your gun correctly you should hit exactly dead on. Other than that great video

    • @AliceDerg
      @AliceDerg 3 роки тому +54

      The tank had HEAT loaded, which is the only reason why gunner, heat, tank was used. Right as he was about to fire, Sabot was queued to be loaded.

    • @thetwangler1805
      @thetwangler1805 3 роки тому +27

      @@AliceDerg I gotcha I missed that thank you, I guess when in doubt dump the round out

    • @OrileyBomb
      @OrileyBomb 3 роки тому +36

      For the leading issue, that is actually modeled in the game. Just as in real life though it has to be toggled. In the clip it probably just wasn’t set but the game 100% does have that feature implemented.

    • @karaya19Kilo
      @karaya19Kilo 3 роки тому +17

      Yeah the doctrine command would be "Fire, Fire Sabot and adjust" also the lead feature was on the original M1 and the A1s, it wasn't until the A2 when we slapped more shit into the FCS that accounted for lead and cant.

    • @AliceDerg
      @AliceDerg 3 роки тому +13

      Also, the TC does call "Fire, fire sabot" to swap rounds if you don't fire before the call is made. I'm not sure if they used fire and adjust in the 80s, though.

  • @napalm5941
    @napalm5941 3 роки тому +245

    I remember seeing a comment of an ex US Abrams loader in a video that showcased this and he said something like: "You better not fucking shoot before I say "up", cuz I dont feel like loosing a hand." 🤣🤣

    • @jungletroll3844
      @jungletroll3844 3 роки тому +13

      lmao i read that as well

    • @napalm5941
      @napalm5941 3 роки тому

      @@jungletroll3844 ayyyy

    • @TR33ZY_CRTM
      @TR33ZY_CRTM 3 роки тому +1

      Ain't nobody got time for the Loader to yell "UP" when an enemy tank is staring you down

    • @IGLArocknroll
      @IGLArocknroll 3 роки тому +37

      @@TR33ZY_CRTM Conclusion: loader needs to be removed. If the loader is not there, then you don't have to wait for him to yell "UP!"

    • @mcrib5794
      @mcrib5794 3 роки тому +16

      @@IGLArocknroll autoloader gang

  • @Jagdpanther226
    @Jagdpanther226 3 роки тому +71

    Being an M1A1 Crewman, this was an amazing effort by the dev team to make it authentic as possible, crew commands are on point.

  • @jaqueslecochon4824
    @jaqueslecochon4824 3 роки тому +66

    2 years since I'm getting teased about GH:PC, I saw him grew that's crazy

  • @jumby_thicc6848
    @jumby_thicc6848 3 роки тому +97

    "UUP". Great day to see another spookston upload.

  • @zomgerln
    @zomgerln 3 роки тому +38

    A moment of silence for the loader's hands at 1:02 as Spookston the cruel fires before he says up.

    • @Danspy501st
      @Danspy501st Рік тому +15

      I think the dev should add an easter egg voice line for the loader going like "Argh! MY F-ING HAND!" if you shoot before he says up

    • @simplemusketeer7421
      @simplemusketeer7421 Рік тому

      @@Danspy501st another one to add to that "HOLY FUCK! FUCK YOU DIPSHIT!"

  • @fegenein862
    @fegenein862 3 роки тому +100

    my favorite line is when you hit an enemy but don't kill it and one of your crew mates goes "AGAIN AGAIN AGAIN AGAIN", that shit always gives me goosebumps

  • @johnclement189
    @johnclement189 3 роки тому +35

    It's worth noting that in reality, if two opposing tanks meet in the battlefield, both are in tremendous amount of stress while firing with one another and GHPC capture this panicked situation inside the tank.

    • @mattjk5299
      @mattjk5299 2 роки тому +4

      I remember reading from a WW2 account is that while there is, for some people, excitement or thrill of combat and people can often be proud of their performance after fact, in the moment nobody wants to be in the thing and the last thing you wanted to see as a tank commander is another enemy tank. Doesn't matter what make or model, the moment you see an enemy tank every second is vital and a mistake will kill you. Hard to imagine.

  • @KomradeMatt
    @KomradeMatt 3 роки тому +14

    When the TC shouts "Again Again Again Again!!" really frantically, they did a great job on the voices.

  • @TheChrush3r
    @TheChrush3r 3 роки тому +81

    its not hard for me to ignore a games sound design for parts that dont matter, but games that excel at using it to show the intensity of a situation of the stress of a person are few but beloved. my notable mentions for that are insurgency sandstorm and escape from tarkov, even though i dont play the latter anymore. one of the death sounds the scavs used to make really stuck in a bad way...

    • @pob_42
      @pob_42 3 роки тому +3

      is it the extended scream and subsequent wailing? it gets us all, man.

    • @ronduptor
      @ronduptor 3 роки тому +1

      If you like sound design, and WW2, give Post Scriptum a go !

    • @pob_42
      @pob_42 3 роки тому +1

      @@ronduptor I love PS, but the community is dwindling and until that armor rework/ any new content at all is released, it'll likely stay that course.

  • @konrad8509
    @konrad8509 3 роки тому +49

    I swear these voicelines were so intense and immersive I actually felt scared, stressed and panicked. Awesome job.

  • @StarGazer0685
    @StarGazer0685 3 роки тому +45

    Would love it if this is what war thunder comms sounded like

  • @ragnarokstravius2074
    @ragnarokstravius2074 3 роки тому +40

    I'm here talking from the Blitz side of WoT.
    We got a new British commander voice, god, is so good.
    The Brit commander saying everything quick and to the point, compared to the older American commander, he's... Dramatic to say the least.
    "That must've hit hard!" = Barely damaged the tracks.
    While the British commander says:
    "Hit!"
    "Target destroyed!"
    Etc.
    It's clearly nowhere near as fast or adaptive as Gunner Heat PC, but it sound so much better.

  • @sambetts7958
    @sambetts7958 3 роки тому +29

    I love the crew lines in ghpc! It’s so much better than “the radio operator gunner is unconscious “

  • @pingwenhung8327
    @pingwenhung8327 3 роки тому +40

    If WarThunder were to update their crew sound
    it would literally be "LOADER RELOAD! FAST! FAST! FAST!"
    Yea....Doesn't feel good when your loader gets killed after being replaced by another guy huh.

    • @flying_fox_117
      @flying_fox_117 Рік тому

      They're updated crew sound but... It doesn't sound as cool as GHPC crew

    • @pingwenhung8327
      @pingwenhung8327 Рік тому

      @flying_fox_117 this comment did not age well and the crew sound I only give 1 out of 10

  • @_danielhld
    @_danielhld 3 роки тому +21

    Gunner HEAT PC: Realistic crew voices
    Me at WT: GuP crew voice mod

  • @FightCain
    @FightCain 3 роки тому +30

    Red Orchestra 2 was a fun “tank simulator”
    Hope there will be another tank sim like this one but in WWII

    • @Zorro9129
      @Zorro9129 3 роки тому +4

      Post Scriptum counts, albeit multiplayer. Check out Vade's videos for a tank crew that knows what they're doing. Otherwise, you're more likely to be stuck with a squad without an experienced commander, who really is the most essential person.

    • @dvpant3651
      @dvpant3651 3 роки тому +2

      yeah it's immersive with it visible interior view and if crew men are dead you get to see their lifeless or headless body and the animation when you switch seats man those were the days~

    • @user-njyzcip
      @user-njyzcip 3 роки тому +4

      Ro2 was more like shoot the gunner over and over again until they run out of crew 🤣

    • @strakhovandrri
      @strakhovandrri 3 роки тому +1

      Sound in RO2 is immersive AF everywhere

    • @blackegret666
      @blackegret666 3 роки тому +2

      @@Zorro9129 My first game as a tank commander I had no idea what I was doing and I was "Manhandling" Callouts but luckily My crew and I managed to get I think four Vehicle kills and one Gun kill. In all seriousness I still had no Idea what I was doing besides not getting My crew killed, tank destroyed, and just killing enemies.

  • @luggilu7864
    @luggilu7864 3 роки тому +17

    Been a Patreon since before AI was introduced and i must say, the progress that ActionScripter and the team that came into the project made since then is simply incredible.

    • @ActionScripter
      @ActionScripter 3 роки тому +10

      We appreciate your support!

    • @rayotoxi1509
      @rayotoxi1509 2 роки тому

      I joined the game when the added firing and damage for t55 and m60 not the fire system
      So around a jear of support to

  • @The-Rowller
    @The-Rowller 3 роки тому +14

    You can really hear the fear in the "He's looking at us!"

  • @Cris-xy2gi
    @Cris-xy2gi 3 роки тому +45

    When I heard these voice lines for the first time:
    *Stress: INFINITY*

  • @bencarver8164
    @bencarver8164 3 роки тому +6

    Another good example is the interior tank scenes for Captain Bannon in World in Conflict. They follow a similar formula to GHPC with the crew communicating to eachother, the gunner announcing his engagement with "on the way" the the muffled thud of the cannon being fired

  • @Bilate07
    @Bilate07 3 роки тому +63

    Reject War Thunder, Embrace Gunner HEAT PC

    • @FirstDagger
      @FirstDagger 3 роки тому +13

      Reject War Thunder, embrace Digital Combat Simulator
      Reject War Thunder, embrace IL-2 Great Battles

    • @jungletroll3844
      @jungletroll3844 3 роки тому +4

      @@FirstDagger This

    • @anttitheinternetguy3213
      @anttitheinternetguy3213 3 роки тому +1

      @@FirstDagger i would. But i play on console so war thunder It is 🤷🏼‍♂️

    • @rayotoxi1509
      @rayotoxi1509 2 роки тому

      @@FirstDagger dcs aint have good tank
      Il2 is ww2 only and aint gonna waste 60 euro for main game and 60 euro for tank dlc rather pick steel beast at that point

  • @the_real_frost
    @the_real_frost 3 роки тому +18

    it reminds me of when me and my friends play tank games (ones with multi person tanks aka 3 people to a tank) and when i just spot a enemy RPG tank etc ill be like "ENEMY RPG 110 HURRY UP ITS AIMING RIGHT AT US" or other times where i just see a tank looking at me and im like all studdering because of how panicy it is.

  • @sortius_
    @sortius_ 3 роки тому +5

    I think the reason War Thunder and the like's voices aren't this realistic is that it creates confronting gameplay. Being screamed at by your crew would turn a lot of people off, so they're toned down, more relaxed.
    As much as I do think it's really cool GHPC is going that extra step, I can fully understand why more unrealistic games like War Thunder (yes, even in RB or sim it's not that realistic) haven't opted to go down this route.
    GHPC is shaping up to succeed in its goal, which is great. I'm quite keen to see how it progresses, and see how they'll implement multiplayer.

  • @AevisPrime
    @AevisPrime 3 роки тому +62

    War Thunder could replace the voice lines, ya know. I say have actual tankers record 10-15 lines for each action, and make sure its loud and to the point. That may, your loader won't say the same line the same way all day long. And for tanks that never had built in crew coms, make them scream it, along with some echo. And make it so every crew member has a different voice actor. Maybe add period correct VAs for different era of tanks.

    • @johnblack8872
      @johnblack8872 3 роки тому +22

      It still amazes me WT has the same voice lines like 7 years later

    • @AevisPrime
      @AevisPrime 3 роки тому +10

      @@johnblack8872 I know right? YOU GOT A HOLE IN YOUR LEFT WING

    • @wave6905
      @wave6905 3 роки тому +11

      mate you are talking about the snails that do jack-shit everyday don't get much hope

    • @sharpy3453
      @sharpy3453 3 роки тому +2

      i mean, tank crews still yell when firing. lol

    • @uisce_
      @uisce_ 3 роки тому +2

      As long as they keep the funny ones

  • @Panzerfan93
    @Panzerfan93 3 роки тому +8

    Sound design is incredibly important, and i really liked the detail when i saw the first videos of it in GHPC

  • @createurdecommentairesdepu1232
    @createurdecommentairesdepu1232 3 роки тому +5

    The voices depending on the context remind me a loooot Insurgency Sandstorm, a multi-player tactical FPS, that is awesome by its gameplay, but also by his song effects. As GHPC, your character (your soldier) have a lot of lines depending on what is happening on the battlefield, in front of him, and that is so immersive, at a point that it gave me chills sometimes, it looks like something about a game...
    (I will alaways remember the first time an Allie get killed in front of me by a sniper, and my character just screamed "SNIPEEEER" with an anxious voice, it was really immersive)

  • @cargo_vroom9729
    @cargo_vroom9729 3 роки тому +7

    Gunner Heat PC is a hidden gem that needs more attention for sure.

  • @zapdog_
    @zapdog_ 3 роки тому +9

    _driver gets liquified by an apfsds round_
    "the driver's been wounded"

    • @rayotoxi1509
      @rayotoxi1509 2 роки тому +1

      Hits ammo
      Turns it black and it disapears
      Enemy tank still drives like nothing happend

  • @Marfius_Au_Marfongus
    @Marfius_Au_Marfongus 3 роки тому +36

    Be really cool if they made a plane game as well, they’d do good on it

    • @theguylivinginyourwalls
      @theguylivinginyourwalls 3 роки тому +5

      Imagine how hectic being in a B-17 over Germany would be. 109s and 190s zipping around everywhere, maybe a couple 262s if you're really unlucky, your pilots trying to keep steady, gunners desperate to knock down the attacking planes, and seeing other bombers getting engulfed in flames as they fall.

    • @okonkwojones
      @okonkwojones 2 роки тому +1

      @@theguylivinginyourwalls I’d love something like that.
      Also I’d a b-17 multicrew multiplayer version, akin to how the new IL:2 works. Big hurdle on that would be flight time to target, idk how a server could handle something like time compression between…(is it 11 in a B-17 crew) a bunch of different clients .
      It works in il2 because the airbases are all just behind the frontlines so you can get to the target in a reasonable time, and oppsing fighters have to scramble so the action can happen relatively quick.

    • @theguylivinginyourwalls
      @theguylivinginyourwalls 2 роки тому +1

      @@okonkwojones Absolutely. Especially with buddies. Everyone screaming over the radio at once would be hilarious.

  • @eric97909
    @eric97909 3 роки тому +6

    Another thing I like is that they model the crew's skulls, "penetrated driver's skull" at the end of video

  • @kitipasa_1839
    @kitipasa_1839 3 роки тому +5

    Just imagine if war thunder added those crew voices in all the vehicles from all the nations... Excellent job GHPC

  • @snuckel4
    @snuckel4 3 роки тому +5

    Got a feeling that you would made a vid about this game again yesterday!

  • @Neuttah
    @Neuttah 3 роки тому +26

    "He's looking at us!" bit sounds like it wouldn't be out of place in a survival-horror game.
    Time to steal WoT's Mirny theme and fucking run with it?

  • @General_Griffin
    @General_Griffin 3 роки тому +5

    All of the attention to detail that makes the soundscape feel more visceral and immersive *really* pays off from what I've heard so far, it's awesome and reminds me of the sound design for Armored Warfare which was pretty solid in my opinion. I agree that good sound design in games is still often neglected by developers and underrated by consumers, it baffles me. This video has me wishing the sound design team for Elite: Dangerous would work on War Thunder so we can FINALLY get a good audible experience out of it.

  • @smeghead765
    @smeghead765 3 роки тому +5

    I love their commands. The voice actors did a great job.

  • @davidecarucci1073
    @davidecarucci1073 3 роки тому +31

    Played the demo and really like it
    Ill probably buy it when it comes on steam
    Are you gonna do a video about il2's tanks?

  • @2ndsunrise_
    @2ndsunrise_ 3 роки тому +40

    If the TC says “Fire and adjust” it’s telling the gunner to scan and shoot

    • @arc_4543
      @arc_4543 3 роки тому +4

      Fire and adjust means to fire and continue to fire at the same target unless cease fire is given. The gunner would already be scanning before the fire command is given.

  • @thewingedporpoise
    @thewingedporpoise 3 роки тому +4

    ohohoho, another video with the most terrifying and immersive voice lines, glad to see it

  • @bardet123
    @bardet123 3 роки тому +5

    2:42
    Damage assessment 105mm SABOT vs man with Kornet:
    Penetrated missile launcher
    Hit Gunner's head
    Penetrated Gunner's skull
    Gee thanks, wasn't sure if the dart fully penetrated or if Ivan's vodka hardened skull would manage to keep him in the fight xD

    • @fernandomarques5166
      @fernandomarques5166 3 роки тому +2

      Meanwhile in another GHPC video
      Round was stopped by gunners pelvis

    • @rayotoxi1509
      @rayotoxi1509 2 роки тому

      Meanwhile on a GHPC play:
      Hit gunner left eye
      Hit gunner right eye
      Hit commander left eye
      Hit commander right eye
      FUCK YOUR EYES T72

  • @qrfss
    @qrfss 3 роки тому +2

    I coded a game much like this but didn't release it, and I really love the attention to detail here. I only had world of tanks crew voices to work with for hit effects but it got pretty contextual and it was a lot of work but eventually I had crew members in 7 languages yelling at me about reloads, hits, bounces, crew losses and vehicles states; but never with the modulating intensity with how close an enemy is to shooting you; that was an amazing touch and the driver comments go above and beyond. I'm happy to see something akin to my old passion project done even better, albiet with a few less swarms of alien monsters and rts elements.
    oh, what I would give to see the concept of cold war era mechanized warfare directed against an apocalyptic invasion of car sized, city devouring alien flesh monsters ;_; it's oddly specific but every time I see a game like this I imagine how fun it would play to gun down hordes of horrific creatures with a well coordinated mechanized platoon, in a hybrid of tank sim and real time strategy. with that sound design? it would be a horrifying and exhilarating spectacle.

  • @itserikboiii
    @itserikboiii 3 роки тому +4

    The crew voices gives me the shivers. As a 19k myself hearing this makes me think I'm in combat or in a gunnery

  • @candle_eatist
    @candle_eatist 2 роки тому +1

    bro i was chilling scrolling through comments then boom ODST music, man that shit hits deep like an apfsds round

  • @bjw6877
    @bjw6877 3 роки тому +3

    "There's no real sense of urgency in their voices." Have you heard that one version of the repairing radio transmission where the guy has what sounds like a voice crack?

  • @sgtrpcommand3778
    @sgtrpcommand3778 3 роки тому +1

    This was - and still is - the only thing I've subbed to on Patreon. The passion for tank warfare the devs have shown is obvious and I am more than happy to support them adding more content to the game.

  • @danielle_pine9676
    @danielle_pine9676 3 роки тому +3

    Truly an amazing game. I'm subed to their patreon just cuz I want to see what the game will look like when done

  • @bruhmoment3741
    @bruhmoment3741 Рік тому +1

    this game shows exactly how immersive sounds and sound design can be. As shown in the video, the graphics arent really that great, but you can see (or hear) the great things. That is also what alot of older games used, providing amazing storytelling and sfx to ballance out the low quality textures. I really hope this game gets the recognition it deserves.

  • @swedihgame
    @swedihgame 3 роки тому +4

    0:30 yeah the swedish crew sound super weird like " the enemy is firing artillery" but said like if he is asking

  • @Sammers987Man
    @Sammers987Man 3 роки тому

    Been seeing all sorts of clips from this game on some videos but only now do I get a name. Thank you for bringing more attention to it, sounds like its going to blow up :)

  • @OrBerkovich-r4l
    @OrBerkovich-r4l 3 роки тому +3

    Damn those responses in the video really brought back the smell of a shell being fired, and i didn't even get my orders in English

  • @s_ckem6846
    @s_ckem6846 2 роки тому +2

    I’m excited for it to release on steam

  • @FredTheTruck
    @FredTheTruck 9 місяців тому +3

    HE'S LOOKING AT US!!

  • @joeyoung4309
    @joeyoung4309 3 роки тому +1

    I want a VR tank combat game where every position is filled by a individual. Imagine how badass that would be, like 2 tanks vs 2 tanks but every crew slot is filled with a individual person. Even if it was very arcadey and simplified it would be so much fun.

  • @Raitzen97
    @Raitzen97 2 роки тому +4

    WT Crew: Telepathic collective mind that doesn't need any commands
    Regular Crew: S C R E A M I N G

  • @PantsuMann
    @PantsuMann 2 роки тому

    When sound design for voices is so damn good and dynamic it stresses you the hell out. This is really cool. Reminds me when I was playing Arma with friends and crewed tanks. Hectic af and stressfull. And now this is just you, and the game does the rest and even better. Really cool!

  • @chunkblaster
    @chunkblaster 3 роки тому +1

    The fucking gunner heat PC crew voices *are so stressful!* the panicked callouts always get to me, they did almost too good a job lol

  • @thedeutschblitz6900
    @thedeutschblitz6900 3 роки тому +4

    "HES LOOKING RIGHT AT US"
    "AH!"
    *yeets shell*

  • @GrOuNdZeRo7777
    @GrOuNdZeRo7777 2 роки тому

    Having served on a M109A6 the sound of a tracked vehicle is louder than you can imagine, The engine has a whine like a banshee and the tracks have a subtle thud thud thud mechanical sound.
    Then there are the sounds of the FCS and the beeps of the ANCD, The hydraulics too of the turret.
    The sound of the cannon firing inside is rather muted while outside its one of the loudest things you can imagine besides a rocket firing.
    MLRS is so loud it can give you a concussion allegedly.

  • @Rosenrot_raccoon
    @Rosenrot_raccoon 3 роки тому +4

    Your private GHPC voice sound mod for WT is awesome, please ask the developer if you could release it publicly. It could make more WT players fund GHPC.

  • @superbrain3848
    @superbrain3848 3 роки тому +2

    the GHPC team is still looking for voice actors,
    they plan to add more German Vehicles and look for people who can voice the crew for them.

  • @lefishe2788
    @lefishe2788 3 роки тому +8

    hopefully gaijin doesn't change the new sounds they go hard

    • @Jugggernaawwt
      @Jugggernaawwt 3 роки тому

      War thunder sounds right now sound like shit

    • @uisce_
      @uisce_ 3 роки тому +1

      @@Jugggernaawwt The .50s sound pretty good

  • @KoOkiEzRoCkz
    @KoOkiEzRoCkz 3 роки тому +1

    The combined panic of the crew and the muffled sounds of the exterior with the clanks of the interior, really sells the reality you're in a cramped shell with other people who all have to work together in unison to face off other tanks that can blow you to bits.

  • @Katniss218
    @Katniss218 3 роки тому +4

    Damn, this is AWESOME

  • @jimplaysbadly3881
    @jimplaysbadly3881 9 місяців тому

    BDU-era Bradley gunner here; everything from the manual range adjustments to the red/black thermals to the sound design brings me right back. All it's missing is the hand cramps, the Bradley bites, and the smell of fart-soaked rubberized canvas and diesel smoke.

  • @naamadossantossilva4736
    @naamadossantossilva4736 3 роки тому +2

    That gun sound was great.The only time i remember hearing something that came even close to that in War Thunder was when i used the T34.

  • @Ersatz-wolf
    @Ersatz-wolf Рік тому

    I can affirm that this is 100% on point, I am a gunner for my crew on the M1A2 SEPv2 tank nicknamed "ANABOLIC" All commands are usually said in this type of manner, with the use of the CITV the TC can designate a target for the gunner if they spot before. Command said something along the lines of, "Designate, (Target- PC, Tank, Troops)" then following "(Target- PC, Tank, Troops) identified, range (range)" and the game quite literally matches that.

  • @officialbazzargaming
    @officialbazzargaming 3 роки тому +25

    "HE'S LOOKING AT US!!!"
    Fuck man, I didn't need that today-

  • @onlymadethisforcomments2476
    @onlymadethisforcomments2476 3 роки тому

    Wow, I sat through a 4 minute ad and actually respected the creator for it

  • @MonkeFlip2000
    @MonkeFlip2000 3 роки тому +3

    it war thunder you dont need ppl screaming in your tank, because you are already screaming out of rage.

  • @wafflecopter9296
    @wafflecopter9296 3 роки тому +1

    One of the few good voicelines in warthunder can be heard if you call artillery on yourself. They either scream "TARGET MY LOCATION" or "Requesting barrage on me, repeat, requesting barrage on me"

  • @lukarajnis4437
    @lukarajnis4437 3 роки тому +11

    Ghpc is brutal. Just like real life

  • @_MaitreuPanda___
    @_MaitreuPanda___ 2 роки тому +1

    Damn the "he's looking at us !!!" is incredible. Makes me feel the panic and fear felt by the crew member and I'm literally just watching a ytb video

  • @GunnerHEATPC
    @GunnerHEATPC 3 роки тому +5

    ❤️

  • @MierVids
    @MierVids 3 роки тому +1

    1:00 Game so realistic it has a super realistic crew damage system. "Hit drivers heart"

  • @lukam8815
    @lukam8815 3 роки тому +4

    meanwhile serbs in Smoluca (actual transcript from a semi famous video): ARE YOU RECORDING?
    YES!
    ALRIGHT, OK BLOW THEM UP!
    *t54 fires at bosnian position*
    I THINK WE GOT THEM
    YEAH!

  • @Paveway-chan
    @Paveway-chan 2 роки тому +1

    Dismount with Konkurs launcher: **reloads with malicious intent**
    M60 commander, after you derped your first HE into the hillsides 500m behind the target: "AGAIN AGAIN AGAIN AGAIN AGAIN"

  • @chadthunder3186
    @chadthunder3186 3 роки тому +7

    Bruh they sound terrified

    • @Tracker947
      @Tracker947 3 роки тому +3

      In combat they probably have to assert themselves loudly and clearly at just about all times for more effective communication, in addition to combat being a terrifying ordeal.

    • @m1a1abrams3
      @m1a1abrams3 3 роки тому +3

      in training, we once whispered to each other to be funny. but yeh in actual combat, it would be like ghpc

    • @obsidianjane4413
      @obsidianjane4413 3 роки тому

      Its a bit exaggerated. You would not want a TC and/or a TC let his crew be on the edge of hysteria.

  • @FSDRyan
    @FSDRyan 3 роки тому +1

    I consider voice acting to be a key feature in games like music and sound design, sounds like this one has it all.

  • @davidp.s.s8383
    @davidp.s.s8383 3 роки тому +3

    GH:PC crew voice: *Panic Scream

  • @bismarckbonedaddy6899
    @bismarckbonedaddy6899 3 роки тому +1

    So cool! The panic in Their voice, even the driver chiming in, so cool!